The present disclosure relates generally to methods for reducing friction and wear of contacting surfaces in manufacturing processes and machine operation. More particularly, this disclosure relates to methods for reducing friction, wear and workpiece adhesion in machining cutters.
Reducing friction and wear of contacting surfaces has been increasingly important as industries strive to improve the energy efficiency of manufacturing processes and machine operation. This is particularly true for the case of cutting tools; high friction and wear in cutting tools can lead to high cutting forces and frequent cutting tool replacement. Use of lubricants between machining cutter and workpiece, and deposition of low-friction coatings on cutters are conventional approaches to friction and wear reduction.
More recently, the creation of surface textures has attracted wide attention because of the possibility of adhesion reduction and lubrication enhancement. Noticeable tribological improvements are evident when properly designed dimples are machined onto contacting surfaces. Theories explaining the effects of surface texturing attribute the tribological benefits to the lubricant pockets created by the dimples. These pockets help to retain lubricant between the contacting parts and reduce side leakage, thereby decreasing friction. Additionally, the textured recesses serve as receptacles for wear particles, preventing further surface damage via plowing. Several works have been conducted to study surface texturing of cutting tools.
There is a need for improved methods for extending the life of tools employed in cutting of metal or metal alloy workpieces. In particular, there is a need for improved methods for reducing workpiece adhesion to cutting tool surfaces and enhancing lubrication during machining of metallic workpieces.
This disclosure is directed to surface texturing for extending the life of cutting tools employed in machining of metal or metal alloy workpieces, such as titanium workpieces. This can be accomplished by micro-texturing selected surfaces on the cutting tool, e.g., by laser machining. Properly designed micro-scale surface textures on cutting tools can have a positive impact on workpiece adhesion reduction and lubrication enhancement. Different surfaces of a cutting tool, for example, a rake face, a flank or relief surface or a margin, can be textured in accordance with the teachings herein.
Lubricants are formulated to maintain a lubricious film under high hydrodynamic loads. Getting lubricants to the actual cutting edge can be difficult, as in the bottom of a hole being drilled. Micro-texture recesses may form a reservoir to help deliver lubricant to the point of contact between the cutting edge and the workpiece. If implemented into a manufacturing process, friction and wear improvements resulting from textured surface technology should result in enhanced energy efficiency and an extended product life, ultimately helping save both fuel and raw materials.
In the embodiments disclosed below, engineered micro-textures are applied to strategic surfaces and areas on cutting tools to enhance tool performance. The textures may take many forms, from an array of dimples to rows of channel-type recesses. The dimple or recess feature sizes can vary from several to 500 microns. The shape, dimensions and orientation of the machined recesses can be selected to provide one or more of the following benefits: improved cutter wear, reduced friction, enhanced lubrication, and/or reduced workpiece adhesion.
Such micro-texturing can be accomplished by laser machining (or other texture machining methods) various shapes/patterns. One example is an array of rectangular texture features with a triangular distribution pattern laser machined onto selected surfaces of a cutting tool. [As used herein, the term “rectangular” means shaped like a rectangle and includes such shapes having rounded corners.] The recesses may have other shapes, such as elliptical. In particular cases, two or more rows of channel-type recesses can be formed on the surface to be treated. The recesses in each row may have constant spacing. In addition, the recesses in one row are offset relative to and partially overlap the recesses in the adjacent row or rows. The recesses may be 5 to 200 microns wide, 10 to 500 microns long and 1 to 10 microns deep, with the longer sides of the recesses being transverse to the direction of relative motion between the workpiece and cutter. In cases where micro-scale recesses are formed on a rake face or flank surface in an area adjacent a cutting edge, the patterns were chosen so that all chip flow should pass over the micro-machined recesses that make up the texture.
In view of the foregoing, one aspect of the subject matter disclosed in detail hereinafter is a cutting tool comprising first and second surfaces that intersect at an edge, wherein the first surface has a textured region comprising a multiplicity of recesses each having a length greater than its width. The recesses are distributed in a pattern comprising a first row of recesses arranged lengthwise along a first line with spaces between neighboring recesses of the first row, and a second row of recesses arranged lengthwise along a second line with spaces between neighboring recesses of the second row, the recesses of the second row being offset from the recesses of the first row. Recesses of the first row have end portions that overlap with the end portions of the recesses in the second row. The pattern set by the first and second rows of recess repeats as needed.
Another aspect is a method for treating a cutting tool to improve its durability by laser machining (or other texture machining methods) a multiplicity of recesses on either or both of first and second surfaces that meet at an edge. The recesses are shaped and arrayed as described in the previous paragraph.
A further aspect is a cutting tool comprising a rake face and a flank surface which intersect at a cutting edge, wherein the flank surface has a textured region near the cutting edge, the textured region comprising a multiplicity of machined recesses distributed in a pattern.
Yet another aspect is a cutting tool comprising a margin and a flute which intersect at a helical edge, wherein the margin has a textured region comprising a multiplicity of machined recesses distributed in a pattern. In particular, the margins of drill bits for drilling titanium workpieces can be micro-textured to reduce adhesion of titanium chips to the drill bit margins, in which case the longer sides of the recesses are parallel to the margin edges.
Other aspects are disclosed and claimed below.
Various embodiments will be hereinafter described with reference to the drawings.
Reference will hereinafter be made to the drawings in which similar elements in different drawings bear the same reference numerals.
Nearly all cutting tools share the concepts shown in the simplified cutter sketch of
Referring now to
The simple model of a cutting edge depicted in
To increase durability, a multiplicity of channel-type recesses 12 can be formed on the rake face 14 by laser machining. Each recess 12 has a length greater than its width. The recesses 12 are distributed in a triangular pattern comprising multiple rows of recesses arranged along respective lines with spaces between neighboring recesses of each row. As seen in
In accordance with various embodiments, the lengths of the recesses 12 may be in a range of 10 to 500 microns and the widths may be in a range of 5 to 200 microns. As shown in
Alternatively or additionally, the flank surface (not shown in
The intersection of two flat plane surfaces yields a straight line. The intersection of a flat plane and a cylinder yields a circle or an ellipse. Through manipulation of the two intersecting surfaces, the cutting tool designer can generate an infinite variety of curved cutting edges.
In many circumstances the cutting edge is designed to be a helix wrapped about the cutter's longitudinal axis. Single-edge router bits are one example, but most such “rotary” cutting tools have multiple helical cutting edges. This class of cutting tool is rotated by the machine tool about the helical axis, and cuts material off the side of the cutter. End milling cutters are an example of side cutting rotary cutting tools with helical cutting edges. A portion of an exemplary end milling cutter is shown in
Referring now to
In accordance with various embodiments, the rake faces 48 and relief lands 50 which meet at the respective helical cutting edges 42 of the end milling cutter shown in
Cutting tools designed to generate holes include drills and reamers. Both have end-cutting cutting edges and typically have helical flutes. However, drills and reamers are designed to cut only when fed along the tools longitudinal axis, not laterally as they are not expected to be side-cutting. Therefore drills and reamers do not have helical cutting edges like the end mill.
In accordance with various embodiments, the rake faces and/or flank surfaces which meet at the primary and secondary cutting edges of the drill bit shown in
Reamers are used to enlarge and improve on drilled holes, generally producing more accurate hole dimensions than possible with a drill alone. Reamers typically have four or more flutes depending on their diameter. They need only cut a small portion of their diameter because they are enlarging an existing hole by typically only about 0.5 mm. Cutting edges are generally 45° chamfers on the outer corners of the cutter, formed at the intersection of the flute surface and a relief surface. Like drills, reamers are not designed for side cutting and have cylindrical margins on their diameter, which margins can be micro-textured as described above.
Many larger cutting tools have replaceable cutting edges in the form of inserts.
Failure of cutting tools is particularly troublesome for materials that require high machining forces, for example, titanium, high-strength steel and other hard and super alloys. Moreover, titanium is notorious for adhesion; cutting chips are often found near the tip of the drill bit. Eventually, the built-up material leads to wearing of the drill bit. Failure occurs when drilling forces reach a sufficiently high level.
In accordance with embodiments which were subjected to testing, micro-scale surface textures were strategically applied on drill bits to reduce adhesion of titanium chips and thereby enhance tool life. Micro-scale surface textures were applied using laser ablation. Laser ablation is a versatile method for surface texturing due to its geometry possibilities and nearly limitless material choice. This technique utilizes high-intensity short and ultra-short laser pulses (nanosecond, picosecond, or femtosecond) to incrementally ablate the substrate material to create the desired feature geometry. Much work has been done to improve the capabilities of laser surface texturing. A suitable laser micro-machining system comprises a picosecond laser with 1064 nm and 532 nm wavelengths and variable repetition rates from 10 to 500 kHz. A positioning system with five degrees of freedom can be used to move the drill bit in relation to the laser beam. One known positioning system has a linear accuracy of 10 nm and a rotational accuracy of 10−4 degrees. Preferably the positioning stage movement is G-code programmable. Position-synchronized output allowed external triggering of the laser beam in coordination with the stage movement. A high-precision fixture was used to rigidly mount the drill bits in an orientation perpendicular to the laser beam direction.
To study the effect on tool life when the margins of a drill bit are micro-textured, drilling tests were conducted using untreated drill bits, as shown in
The margins of the treated drill bits shown in
The surface texture geometry adopted for purposes of the experiment was an array (i.e., two rows in
Using the laser micro-machining system described above, high-strength steel drill bits (e.g., Dormer A920, 7.9 mm diameter by 40.6 mm flute, 76.2 mm overall length) were textured as depicted in
There should be no chip flow across a drill margin; all drill chips should remain within the drill flutes until they are ejected from the hole. Work material pick-up and adherence to the drill margin is caused by sliding friction between the rotating drill and the hole wall. The relative motion of the hole wall across the drill margin does pass over the texture, but not at 90° to the array of rectangular depressions.
The above-described surface texture geometry was used with two different coverage areas: approximately 10% and 20% of the surface area of the drill bit margins was textured for the two designs (two and three rows of recesses, respectively shown in
Three drill bit groups were tested, non-textured drill bits, and those with 10% and 20% of the drill margin surface textured. Although thrust, torque, and temperature values were not reduced by the introduction of textures on the drill bit, it was found that a sharp increase in peak temperature and torque while drilling were indicative of drill failure. A larger area of workpiece adhesion on the drill bit is directly linked to tool failure. Textured drill bits were found to exhibit less adhesion and improved shedding of adhered chips from hole to hole. Shedding ultimately led to a reduction in chip adhesion and therefore, extended tool life. While 100% of non-textured drill bits failed at or before 60 holes were drilled, both of the texture designs tested (with 10% and 20% of the drill margin surface area textured) only resulted in a 33% failure when drilling 60 holes. There was no discernible difference between the two texture designs in terms of drill life at the tested conditions.
It should be pointed out that the textures were not made in the tip margin region 10 (see
The application of engineered micro-textures to various surfaces of cutting tools takes advantage of the adhesion reduction benefit that the micro-textures provide. Reduction of friction is one such benefit of certain micro-textures as seen in the study of tribology. In cases where a surface near a cutting edge is textured, the designed textures allow the cutting chips to move out along the cutter surface path and over the alternating physical conditions of texture banks and indents. During this movement, the surfaces of the chip can be immediately wetted with oil or cooled by air in the indents following each brief period of solid contact with the texture bank, thereby avoiding adhesion. Therefore, the designed triangular pattern of recess distribution disclosed hereinafter is beneficial because the contact between the chips and the cutter surface is completely interrupted. Micro-textures provide mini-reservoirs to keep coolants and lubricants in the cutting zone to improve cutting efficiency. As a result of adhesion reduction, contact interruption, and alternating wetting or cooling, such a micro-texture applied to the rake face of a cutting tool in an area adjacent to the cutting edge has the benefit of reducing heat at the cutting tool and chip interface and reducing machine tool power requirements. Easier chip escape could slow the wear of cutter surfaces, thereby providing the benefit of longer-lasting cutting tools with reduced power requirements. The foregoing explains the mechanisms by which micro-textures applied to portions of cutting tools that experience sliding contact with either the chip or the workpiece, such as the margins of drills, have been shown to inhibit workpiece material adhesion to the cutting tool, i.e., by reducing the area of contact and interrupting the bond-line between the built-up material and the cutter, and the reason for reduced friction and heat, increased cutting tool life and power savings.
While various embodiments have been described, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the scope of the teachings herein. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt a particular situation to those teachings without departing from the essential scope thereof. Therefore it is intended that scope of the claims set forth hereinafter not be limited to the disclosed embodiments.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3672017 | Nielsen et al. | Jun 1972 | A |
3715788 | Ayer | Feb 1973 | A |
4161972 | Hanaya | Jul 1979 | A |
4984488 | Lunde et al. | Jan 1991 | A |
5160232 | Maier | Nov 1992 | A |
5504981 | Jensen et al. | Apr 1996 | A |
5810520 | Hintze et al. | Sep 1998 | A |
5913644 | DeRoche et al. | Jun 1999 | A |
5984005 | Hart et al. | Nov 1999 | A |
6524036 | Kolker | Feb 2003 | B1 |
6745609 | Garnett et al. | Jun 2004 | B2 |
7682111 | Omi | Mar 2010 | B2 |
20100003089 | Horiike et al. | Jan 2010 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
102189287 | Sep 2011 | CN |
Entry |
---|
Enomoto et al., “Improving anti-adhesive properties of cutting tool surfaces by nano-/micro-textures,” CIRP Annals—Manufacturing Technology, 59 (2010), pp. 597-600. |
Kawasegi et al., “Drilling Aluminum Alloy Using Small-Diameter Drills with Micro/Nanometer-Scale Textures,” Trans. Japanese Society of Mechanical Engineers, Part C, 76 (2010), pp. 446-452. |
Davis et al., “Experimental Friction Study of Micro-Scale Laser-Textured Surfaces,” in: Int'l Workshop on Microfactories, Evanston, IL (2008). |