Deflectable guiding catheter

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6251092
  • Patent Number
    6,251,092
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, December 30, 1997
    28 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, June 26, 2001
    24 years ago
Abstract
A deflectable guiding catheter generally having an elongated shaft with a deflectable distal section, a second lumen, a first lumen in fluid communication with a port in the distal end of the shaft, an elongated tapered deflection line within the second lumen, and reinforcement strands within a wall of the shaft. The first lumen is independent from the second lumen, and is therefore not obstructed by the deflection line. The longitudinal axes of the second lumen and first lumen are axially aligned with respect to one another, and are eccentric to the shaft longitudinal axis. The reinforcement strands and the deflection line extend in at least a portion of the deflectable distal shaft section to a location spaced proximally of the distal end of the deflectable distal shaft section.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The invention relates to the field of intraluminal catheters, and more particularly to a guiding catheter having a deflectable distal end.




Guiding catheters are used in many percutaneous intravascular procedures to guide diagnostic and therapeutic devices or fluids, and the like, to a desired location within the patient. For example, a guiding catheter is typically used in conjunction with balloon catheters used in angioplasty procedures and electrophysiology (EP) devices used for ablation or mapping of cardiac tissue. U.S. Pat. No. 5,509,411, incorporated by reference (Littmann et al.) is an example of an EP catheter.




In the design of guiding catheters, different and often competing considerations relating to catheter flexibility and strength must be balanced. The guiding catheter proximal section must have sufficient flexibility and strength to be advanceable and torqueable, and have sufficient column strength to limit shaft buckling. The distal end of the guiding catheter is typically more flexible than the proximal section, to provide maneuverability and to prevent trauma to the patient's vasculature. However, the distal end must have sufficient strength to prevent kinking during advancement.




While a large delivery lumen is desirable for delivering devices such as EP catheters, the outer diameter of the catheter must be minimized so that the catheter can be readily advanced within the patient. Therefore, when the catheter contains a large delivery lumen, the walls of the catheter are necessarily thin in order to minimize the outer diameter of the guiding catheter. Typically, a tubular or braided metal line reinforcement may be provided within a wall of the catheter. The line reinforcement stiffens the catheter and transmits torque to the catheter distal end as the proximal end of the catheter outside the patient is rotated .




The distal end of the guiding catheter frequently needs to be bent or shaped while within the patient. The bent shape is useful in guiding the catheter distal end into a desired body lumen or chamber. For example, during an EP ablation or mapping procedure, the guiding catheter must be maneuvered through a patient's branched vasculature to advance an EP device into a patient's coronary sinus. Moreover, the shaped or shapeable distal end of the guiding catheter is used to orient the distal tip of the EP device with respect to tissue, such as a patient's endocardium, to facilitate proper delivery of the device's RF or laser energy to the tissue. Consequently, the guiding catheter may be provided with a preformed distal tip which may be guided into the desired location in the patient by rotating the proximal end of the guiding catheter from outside the patient. Additionally, the guiding catheter may be provided with a deflection mechanism to reversibly deflect the distal tip while within the patient.




One difficulty has been providing a deflectable guiding catheter having sufficient column strength and torque transmission in combination with a relatively large lumen for delivering devices such as EP catheters. Moreover, many prior deflectable catheters are typically limited to uniplanar deflection, which requires the catheter shaft to be rotated from its proximal end located outside of the patient in order to place to deflected tip into a desired plane, as, for example, to place the distal tip of the catheter into a desired branched vessel or in contact with a desired tissue wall.




What has been needed is a catheter with a kink resistant, torqueable, and deflectable shaft which nonetheless defines a large unobstructed lumen for receiving a device therein. The present invention satisfies these and other needs.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The invention is directed to a catheter comprising an elongated shaft which has a deflectable distal section and an unobstructed delivery lumen, with kink resistance and torque transmission.




The guiding or delivery catheter of the invention generally has an elongated shaft with a deflectable distal section, a deflection line lumen, and a delivery lumen in fluid communication with a port in the distal end of the shaft. An elongated, preferably tapered, deflection line is disposed within the deflection line lumen. Preferably the wall of the shaft has reinforcing or stiffening strands or fibers which may be braided or wound. The longitudinal axes of the deflection line lumen and delivery lumen are axially aligned with respect to one another, and are eccentric to the central longitudinal axis of the shaft. The phrase “axially aligned” refers to the fact that the two lumens are aligned along a bisecting plane intersecting the central longitudinal axis of the shaft.




To selectively deflect the shaft distal section, the operator moves the deflection line longitudinally. From an undeflected position aligned with the shaft longitudinal axis, the distal shaft section is deflected away from the shaft longitudinal axis by pulling the line proximally out the proximal end of the shaft. In one embodiment, if the deflection line is stiff enough, the deflection line may be moved longitudinally toward the distal end of the shaft to deflect the shaft distal section in an opposite direction. In one example, the catheter is provided with a steering mechanism on the catheter proximal end, which facilitates the longitudinal movement of the deflection line by the operator.




The catheter of the invention is kink resistant and torqueable. The deflection line, which extends to the distal end of the deflection line lumen, provides column strength and is tapered to provide a smooth transition of stiffness from the catheter proximal shaft section to the deflectable distal shaft section. The distal end of the deflection line lumen extends into at least a portion of the deflectable distal shaft section to a location spaced proximally from the distal end of the deflectable distal shaft section. The deflection line generally extends in about 70% to about 95%, preferably about 85% to about 90%, of the total length of the deflectable distal shaft section. The distal end of the shaft is provided with improved flexibility due to the deflection line terminating proximal to the distal tip of the shaft.




The shaft is reinforced with suitable reinforcing strands or fibers, such as stiffening wire braids, which contribute to the shaft column strength and torque transmission. The reinforcement extends at least into a portion of the deflectable distal shaft section. Generally the reinforcement extends in about 15% to about 50%, preferably about 25% to about 45% of the total length of the deflectable distal shaft section. The reinforcements are preferably made of stainless steel, although other materials with similar stiffness are suitable, such as NITINOL, MP35N, Elginoy, and high strength polymer materials such as polyamide and Kevlar®.




The delivery lumen of the guiding catheter is independent from, or fluidly sealed from, the deflection line lumen, and thus provides an unobstructed passageway for slidably receiving an EP or other therapeutic or diagnostic agent or device. Because the guiding catheter of the invention provides superior control in accessing desired cardiovascular structure, it is particularly useful in supporting and delivering an EP mapping or ablation catheter to various locations in cardiac chambers for diagnosis or therapy. For example, the guiding catheter of the invention may be advanced into the right atrium of the heart from the inferior vena cava to position the operative distal end of an EP catheter within the right atrium above the tricuspid valve. The electrodes on the distal end of the EP catheter can then be put into operative contact with the cardiac tissue of the right atrium by torquing and/or deflecting the tip of the guiding catheter of the invention. Consequently, where a plurality of electrodes are on the EP device distal end, the range of movement and control of the guiding catheter of the invention allows for all the electrodes to be in contact with the cardiac tissue together, so that a more extensive area may be operatively engaged with the device at a given time. In this manner a continuous lesion may be formed from a plurality of individual ablations.




The guiding catheter of the invention has a deflectable distal shaft section and an unobstructed delivery lumen available for delivering therapeutic and diagnostic devices, yet has sufficient strength to transmit torque and resist kinking. By offsetting the central axes of the two lumens from the shaft longitudinal axis and axially aligning the two lumens, while reinforcing the shaft with the deflection line and line braids, the catheter transmits torque and resists kinking. These and other advantages of the invention will become more apparent from the following detailed description of the invention and the accompanying exemplary drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a longitudinal view, partially in longitudinal cross-section, of a guiding catheter embodying features of the invention.





FIG. 2

is a cross section of the catheter shown in

FIG. 1

taken along lines


2





2


.





FIG. 3

is a cross section of the catheter shown in

FIG. 1

taken along lines


3





3


.





FIG. 4

is a cross section of the catheter shown in

FIG. 1

taken along lines


4





4


.





FIG. 5

is a longitudinal view of a catheter of the invention showing the deflection of the distal shaft section, and an EP device located therein.





FIG. 6

is a longitudinal view, partially in section, of a handle for use with the catheter of the invention.





FIG. 7

illustrates a transverse cross section of the handle shown in

FIG. 6

taken along lines


7





7


.





FIG. 8

illustrates a guiding catheter of the invention, and an EP device located therein, positioned in the right atrium of a heart.





FIG. 9

illustrates a guiding catheter of the invention, and an EP device located therein, in the left atrium of the heart by transseptal insertion.





FIG. 10

illustrates a guiding catheter of the invention, and an EP device located therein, in the left atrium by retrograde insertion.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION





FIG. 1

illustrates an embodiment of a guiding catheter


10


of the invention comprising an elongated shaft


11


having a proximal end


12


and a distal end


13


and a deflectable distal shaft section


14


. A first lumen


16


, located eccentric to the shaft longitudinal axis, extends within the shaft


11


to a port


17


in the shaft distal end


13


. A second lumen


18


, located eccentric to the shaft longitudinal axis and axially aligned with the first lumen


16


, extends to a location proximal to the shaft distal end


13


. An elongated deflection line, or member,


19


is received within the second lumen


18


, and has a tapered distal section


20


with a radially decreasing diameter. Stiffening wire braids


21


, embedded in the shaft


11


, reinforce the shaft to provide sufficient column strength and rigidity for shaft kink resistance and torqueability.




In

FIG. 1

, dashed lines illustrate the location of the axes of the lumens


16


,


18


and the axis of the shaft


11


. As illustrated in

FIGS. 2-4

, showing transverse cross sections of the catheter shown in

FIG. 1

, the first lumen


16


and the second lumen


18


are axially aligned with respect to one another and are eccentric to the shaft longitudinal axis. Thus, the axis


60


of the first lumen


16


and the axis


61


of the second lumen


18


are aligned along a plane intersecting the central axis


62


of the shaft


11


. In one embodiment, the first lumen


16


is lined with a liner


26


having a lubricious surface which facilitates advancement of a device slidably received within the first lumen


16


. The lubricious liner


26


may be made of fluoropolymer.




The length of the guiding catheter


10


may be about 60 cm to about 120 cm in working length, typically about 80 to about 100 cm for use with an EP catheter. The length of the deflectable distal shaft section


14


is about 5 cm to about 15 cm, preferably about 7 to about 10 cm. The wire braids


21


extend from the proximal end


12


of the shaft


11


and within at least a proximal portion


23


of the deflectable distal shaft section


14


, to a location spaced proximally from the shaft


11


distal end


13


. In a presently preferred embodiment, the length of the deflectable distal shaft section


14


having wire braids


21


located therein is about 1.0 cm to about 2.5 cm.




The deflection line total length depends on the length of the catheter. The second lumen


18


, and deflection line


19


therein, extend from the proximal end


12


of the shaft at least into the deflectable distal shaft section


14


to a location spaced proximally of the distal end of the catheter shaft. In a presently preferred embodiment, the length of the deflection line located within the deflectable distal shaft section


14


is about 4 cm to about 12 cm, preferably about 5 cm to about 10 cm, and the length of the deflection line


19


extending beyond the distal end of the wire braids


21


is about 1.5 cm to about 10 cm, preferably about 2.5 cm to about 7 cm.




The distal end of the deflection line


19


is secured to the catheter shaft


11


at the distal end of the second lumen


18


. In the embodiment illustrated in

FIG. 1

, an annular clamp


25


secures the deflection line


19


to the shaft


11


. The deflection line, if formed out of stainless steel wire, has a diameter of about 0.006 inch (0.015 cm) to about 0.015 inch (0.04 cm), preferably about 0.008 inch (0.02 cm) to about 0.012 inch (0.03 cm), which tapers to a smaller diameter at the distal extremity of the line. The length of the tapered distal section


20


is about 6 to about 15 cm, preferably about 8 cm to about 12 cm. The tapered line


19


, in conjunction with other features of the invention, provides sufficient column strength that allows the guiding catheter to be deflected in two directions.




The guiding catheter


10


has an outer diameter (OD) of about 5 French (0.17 cm) to about 15 Fr (0.5 cm), preferably about 6 Fr (0.2 cm) to about 12 Fr (0.4 cm). The diameter of the first lumen will be determined by the device to be delivered, and usually should be about 0.010 inch (0.025 cm) larger than the OD of the device to be delivered. The diameter of the first lumen may range from about 0.035 inch (0.09 cm) to about 0.105 inch (0.26 cm), and preferably about 0.045 inch (0.11 cm) to about 0.105 inch (0.26 cm), and is typically about 0.05 inch (0.13 cm) to about 0.08 inch (0.20 cm) for use with an EP catheter.




As best illustrated in

FIGS. 2-4

, the catheter shaft


11


has a two layer construction, with an outer jacket


27


surrounding a core


28


. The outer jacket


27


is preferably a thermoplastic material such as a thermoplastic polyurethane (PU) or PU blend, and the core


28


is preferably a thermoplastic PU or PU blend. While the outer diameter of the shaft


11


is constant, the outer diameter of the core


28


steps down to a smaller diameter at a location distal to the distal end of the second lumen. The outer jacket


27


has a wall thickness of about 0.004 inch (0.01 cm) to about 0.009 inch (0.023 cm), preferably about 0.005 inch (0.013 cm) to about 0.007 inch 0.018cm) in a section of the shaft


11


containing the first lumen


16


and the second lumen


18


, and a nonuniform wall thickness of about 0.006 inch (0.015 cm) to about 0.025 inch (0.064 cm) in a section of the shaft located distally from the distal end of the second lumen


18


. The core


28


defines the shaft lumens, and has a first diameter of about 0.060 inch (0.15 cm) to about 0.062 inch (0.16 cm) in a section of the shaft


11


containing the first lumen


16


and the second lumen


18


, and a second diameter of about 0.014 inch (0.036 cm) to about 0.016 inch (0.04 cm) in a section of the shaft located distally from the distal end of the second lumen


18


.





FIG. 5

illustrates the deflection of the distal shaft section


14


in two opposite directions. In the embodiment illustrated in

FIG. 5

, EP device


32


, having a plurality of electrodes


34


, is within the first lumen


16


. By deflecting the distal shaft section


14


, a diagnostic or therapeutic device in the first lumen


16


can be accurately positioned within the patient.




As illustrated in

FIG. 1

, a handle


30


may be provided on the proximal end


12


of the shaft


11


, with a mechanism for moving the deflection line


19


longitudinally to deflect the distal shaft section


20


. A presently preferred embodiment of a handle


30


, illustrated in

FIG. 6

, generally comprises a sliding member


31


slidably disposed about a connecting member


33


and an inner member


35


, and one or more o-rings


36


disposed about connecting member


33


and inner member


35


. Inner member


35


has a lumen


37


extending therein from a port in the proximal end to a port in the distal end of the inner member.

FIG. 7

illustrates a transverse cross-section of the handle shown in

FIG. 6

, taken along lines


7





7


. Connecting member


33


releasably secures the proximal end


12


of the catheter shaft to handle


30


. The sliding member


31


secures to the proximal portion of the deflection line


19


by a variety of suitable means including screws, hooks, and clamp connectors, such as clamping plates shown in FIG.


6


. The sliding member


31


generally comprises two joined pieces which may be separated to expose the deflection line securing means. When sliding member


31


, and the deflection line secured thereto, are longitudinally displaced, the distal shaft section


14


is deflected in either of two opposite directions depending on whether the sliding member is displaced proximally or distally. O-rings


36


between the sliding member


31


and the inner member


35


and connecting member


33


provide a frictional stop on the displacement of the sliding member, so that sliding member


31


can be smoothly displaced when pulled or pushed by the operator but remains set in any deflected position without the need of a separately actuated lock. In the embodiment shown in

FIG. 6

, the connecting member


33


tapers toward the distal end, and ridges are provided on the distal end for frictional engagement with optional strain relief member


38


. Outer member


39


, disposed about the inner member


35


, provides a comfortable grip for the operator. A radially enlarged finger grip is provided on the sliding member, and may have grooves on an outer surface to improve the operator's grip on the sliding member. The guiding catheter of the invention may be used with other suitable handle configurations. For example, the handle may be provided with a knob which is rotated clockwise to longitudinally move the deflection line


19


in a distal direction toward the distal end of the catheter


10


and counterclockwise to move the deflection line in a proximal direction away from the distal end of the catheter.




The range of movement and control provided by the guiding catheter of the invention provides for superior access to desired cardiac structure.

FIG. 8

illustrates a heart


40


, and the anatomy of the heart including the left atrium


41


and left ventricle


42


, and the right atrium


43


and right ventricle


44


separated by the tricuspid valve


45


. The inferior vena cava


46


and superior vena cava


47


deliver deoxygenated blood from the body tissues, into the right atrium, from where it is pumped through the tricuspid valve


45


and ultimately into the lungs for reoxygenation. In

FIG. 8

, the guiding catheter


10


, and EP catheter


32


therein, are shown in the inferior vena cava


46


and the right atrium


43


above the tricuspid valve


45


. The position of the guiding catheter


10


allows a plurality of the electrodes


34


on the EP catheter


32


distal end to be placed in operative contact with the cardiac tissue of the right atrium


43


.

FIG. 9

illustrates the distal end of the guiding catheter


10


, and EP catheter


32


therein, positioned in the left atrium transseptally through the fossa ovalis.




As illustrated in

FIG. 10

, the guiding catheter can also be advanced into the left cardiac chambers retrogradely through the aortic and mitral valves.

FIG. 10

illustrates the operative distal end of the EP catheter positioned in the left atrium, where a distal section of the catheter is shown projecting out of the plane of the figure.




The material used to make the deflectable distal shaft section


14


may be softer or more flexible from the material used in the remainder of the catheter shaft


11


. In one embodiment, a soft atraumatic distal tip


29


, illustrated in

FIG. 5

, is provided on the distal end


13


of the shaft, with a lumen


50


and a distal end port in fluid communication with the first lumen


16


.




While the present invention has been described herein in terms of certain preferred embodiments, modifications and improvements may be made to the invention without departing from the scope thereof.



Claims
  • 1. A guiding catheter, comprising,a) an elongated catheter shaft having a proximal end, a distal end, a relatively stiff proximal section, a deflectable distal section with at least a length which is relatively more flexible than the relatively stiff proximal section, a longitudinal axis, and reinforcements embedded in the shaft extending from the proximal section to at least a portion of the deflectable distal section; b) a first lumen eccentric to the longitudinal axis of the shaft; c) a second lumen axially aligned with the first lumen and eccentric to the longitudinal axis; d) an elongated deflection member which has proximal and distal ends, which is disposed in the second lumen, and which has the distal end thereof secured to the shaft; and e) a soft distal tip on the distal end of the shaft, having a lumen extending therein in fluid communication with the first lumen, and having a port in a distal end of the soft distal tip.
  • 2. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the second lumen extends from the shaft proximal end and within at least a portion of the deflectable distal section to a location spaced proximally from the distal end of the catheter shaft.
  • 3. The catheter of claim 2 wherein the deflectable distal section is about 5 to about 15 cm in length.
  • 4. The catheter of claim 3 wherein the second lumen extends in about 4 to about 12 cm of the length of the deflectable distal section.
  • 5. The catheter of claim 3 wherein the deflection member extends in about 4 to about 12 cm of the length of the deflectable distal section.
  • 6. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the first lumen extends from the shaft proximal end to the shaft distal end.
  • 7. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the reinforcements are wire braids.
  • 8. The catheter of claim 7 wherein the wire braids extend from the proximal end of the shaft to within at least a portion of the deflectable distal section.
  • 9. The catheter of claim 8 wherein the wire braids extend to a location spaced proximally from a distal end of the second lumen.
  • 10. The catheter of claim 9 wherein the wire braids extend in about 1 to about 2.5 cm of the length of the deflectable distal section.
  • 11. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the elongated deflection member has a tapered distal section with a radially decreasing diameter.
  • 12. The catheter of claim 11 wherein the length of the deflection member tapered distal section is about 6 to about 15 cm.
  • 13. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the first lumen has a diameter of about 0.09 to about 0.26 cm.
  • 14. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the catheter diameter is about 0.20 to about 0.40 cm.
  • 15. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the longitudinal axis of the catheter shaft is within the first lumen.
  • 16. The catheter of claim 1 wherein the first lumen is unobsructed.
  • 17. A guiding catheter, comprising,a) an elongated catheter shaft having a proximal end, a distal end, a longitudinal axis, a relatively stiff proximal section, a deflectable distal section with at least a length which is relatively more flexible than the relatively stiff proximal section, and reinforcements in at least a portion of the shaft; b) a first lumen eccentric to the longitudinal axis of the shaft; c) a second lumen axially aligned with the first lumen and eccentric to the longitudinal axis; d) an elongated deflection member which has proximal and distal ends, which is disposed in the second lumen, and which has the distal end thereof secured to the shaft; and e) a soft distal tip on the distal end of the shaft, having a lumen extending therein in fluid communication with the first lumen, and having a port in a distal end of the soft distal tip.
  • 18. The guiding catheter of claim 17 wherein the reinforcements in the deflectable distal section comprise wound strands.
  • 19. A guiding catheter, comprising,a) an elongated catheter shaft having a proximal end, a distal end, a relatively stiff proximal section, a deflectable distal section with at least a length which is relatively more flexible than the relatively stiff proximal section, a longitudinal axis, reinforcements in at least a portion of the proximal shaft section, and reinforcements in at least a portion of the deflectable distal shaft section; b) a first lumen eccentric to the longitudinal axis of the shaft; c) a second lumen axially aligned with the first lumen and eccentric to the longitudinal axis; d) an elongated deflection member which has a proximal end, a distal end, and a tapered distal section with a radially decreasing diameter, which is disposed in the second lumen, and which has the distal end thereof secured to the shaft; and e) a port on the distal end of the shaft in fluid communication with the first lumen.
  • 20. A guiding catheter, comprising,a) an elongated catheter shaft having a proximal end, a distal end, a longitudinal axis, a relatively stiff proximal section, a deflectable distal section with at least a length which is relatively more flexible than the relatively stiff proximal section, and reinforcements in at least a portion of the shaft; b) a first lumen eccentric to the longitudinal axis of the shaft; c) a second lumen axially aligned with the first lumen and eccentric to the longitudinal axis; d) an elongated deflection member which has a proximal end, a distal end, and a tapered distal section with a radially decreasing diameter, which is disposed in the second lumen, and which has the distal end thereof secured to the shaft; and e) a port on the distal end of the shaft in fluid communication with the first lumen.
  • 21. A guiding catheter, comprising,a) an elongated catheter shaft having a proximal end, a distal end, a relatively stiff proximal section, a deflectable distal section with at least a length which is relatively more flexible than the relatively stiff proximal section, a longitudinal axis, reinforcements in at least a portion of the proximal shaft section, and reinforcements in at least a portion of the deflectable distal shaft section, the deflectable distal shaft section naturally assuming an undeflected position aligned with a longitudinal axis of a shaft section located proximal to the deflectable distal shaft section; b) a first lumen eccentric to the longitudinal axis of the shaft; c) a second lumen axially aligned with the first lumen and eccentric to the longitudinal axis; d) an elongated deflection member which has a proximal end and a distal end, which is disposed in the second lumen, and which has the distal end thereof secured to the shaft; and e) a soft distal tip on the distal end of the shaft, having a lumen extending therein in fluid communication with the first lumen, and having a port in a distal end of the soft distal tip.
US Referenced Citations (35)
Number Name Date Kind
4586923 Gould et al. May 1986
4748969 Wardle Jun 1988
4898577 Badger et al. Feb 1990
4906230 Maloney et al. Mar 1990
4920980 Jackowski May 1990
4960134 Webster, Jr. Oct 1990
5114414 Bachbinder May 1992
5190050 Nitzsche Mar 1993
5242441 Avitall Sep 1993
5318525 West et al. Jun 1994
5318526 Cohen Jun 1994
5327905 Avitall Jul 1994
5334169 Brown et al. Aug 1994
5354297 Avitall Oct 1994
5368564 Savage Nov 1994
5431168 Webster, Jr. Jul 1995
5462527 Stevens-Wright et al. Oct 1995
5472017 Kovalcheck Dec 1995
5487757 Truckai et al. Jan 1996
5489270 van Erp Feb 1996
5545200 West et al. Aug 1996
5562619 Mirarchi et al. Oct 1996
5571085 Accisano, III Nov 1996
5624397 Snoke et al. Apr 1997
5642736 Avitall Jul 1997
5662606 Cimino et al. Sep 1997
5702373 Samson Dec 1997
5807249 Qin et al. Sep 1998
5820592 Hammerslag Oct 1998
5823955 Kuck et al. Oct 1998
5882333 Schaer et al. Mar 1999
5891114 Chien et al. Apr 1999
5897529 Ponzi Apr 1999
5951539 Nita et al. Sep 1999
5971975 Mills et al. Oct 1999
Foreign Referenced Citations (3)
Number Date Country
0 630 657 Dec 1994 EP
0 815 895 Jan 1998 EP
WO 9505771 Mar 1995 WO