This invention relates to method and apparatus for detection of airborne particulates, and particularly detection of biological particulates.
Technologies and apparatus for detection of airborne biological particulates, such as bacterial cells, bacterial spores and viruses are currently in great demand, especially with the emergence of antibiotic resistant bacterial species, such as methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), and also the threat of bioterrorism.
Detection of airborne biological particulates is more often than not dependent on a requirement for collection of particulates into a liquid phase. This is chiefly to ensure retention of structural integrity and/or activity which is often required for obtaining an accurate result. Detection systems currently available however, are effectively mobile laboratories, requiring huge quantities of liquid and reagents, and a high power input. There is therefore a requirement for improved systems that are smaller, require less reagents and less power, and can operate more flexibly.
The present invention generally aims to provide an instrument capable of detecting biological particulates without the need to collect the particulates from airborne suspension into a bulk liquid.
As commonly understood and also as used herein, a particulate is a solid or liquid substance relating to, or existing in the form of a single particle or plurality of particles. An aerosol is a gaseous suspension, or cloud, of particulates. A liquid droplet may in some circumstances be considered a particulate however, in general a liquid droplet is a droplet.
Detection of particulates in the atmosphere is an important area of scientific research, especially particulates of less than 10 μm in diameter which are acknowledged as a major health risk, causing damage by travelling deep into the lungs, or even entering the bloodstream. Biological particulates, such as bacterial cells, bacterial spores, fungi spores, viruses, and fragments thereof, are particularly problematic since they comprise diameters of between about 0.5 μm to 5 μm.
Elimination and removal of airborne particulates from the atmosphere is conventionally achieved by electrostatic precipitation. However, the collection efficiency of electrostatic precipitators, especially for particulates of less than 10 μm in diameter, has traditionally been difficult. The collection efficiency has however been dramatically improved by incorporating electrostatic agglomeration prior to precipitation (J. F. Hughes et al, Proceedings of the 3rd ICESP 1987, 337-342). Electrostatically charged liquid droplets have been shown to increase the agglomeration, and thereby precipitation, of dust particles over the use of non-charged liquid droplets. Agglomeration is facilitated by increased contact between liquid droplets and particles as a result of electrostatic attraction forces (L. F. Gaunt et al, J. Electrostatics 2003, 58, 159-169). Inductively charged water drops have also been used to agglomerate and precipitate smoke particles from the air (W. Balachandran et al, J. Electrostatics 2001, 51-52, 193-199). Charging of particles and aerosols can be achieved by numerous methods, such as photovoltaic excitation, static electrification, radioactive ionisation, flame charging, diffusion charging and field charging. Diffusion charging and field charging involve bombardment with unipolar ions. This can be achieved by using corona discharge whereby air molecules are ionised in the region of a highly charged electrode.
As used herein, agglomeration is a process whereby particulates and liquid droplets aggregate or merge. Agglomeration can occur naturally by close proximity of particulates and liquid droplets, such as with mixing of particulates and liquid droplets, however the efficiency of agglomeration can be improved by manipulation of characteristics such as, but not restricted to, pressure, temperature, and electrostatic charge. Agglomeration is used in many industries, such as fertilizer production, nuclear fuel, ceramics, lightweight aggregate production, catalysts, pesticides and pharmaceutical products.
The submicron particle collection efficiency of an electrostatic precipitator has also been improved by using a low frequency alternating current (AC) electric field, encouraging electrostatic agglomeration of bipolar-charged particles and water droplets. Water droplets give a large agglomeration coefficient due to a large dielectric constant (Y. Koizumi et al J. Electrostatics 2000, 48, 93-101). For effective electrostatic agglomeration of submicron particles, the size and charge of the liquid droplets should be large compared to the submicron particles.
An AC unipolar charger is an instrument comprising discharge electrodes for ionisation of molecules, and grids to which an AC electric field can be applied (J. E. J. Dalley et al Aerosol Science 2005). Such a charger is suitable for improving the efficiency of agglomeration of particulates and liquid droplets. The discharge electrodes maximise charge, whilst the AC field, in addition to facilitating agglomeration, minimises losses to the walls of the charger. An example of an AC unipolar charger includes the boxer charger (S. Masuda et al Proceedings of the IEEE/IAS Annual Meeting, Toronto, Canada 1978, 16-22).
Even though improvements have been made to instruments for collection of submicron particles, a number of limitations remain, especially the requirement for collection of particles into a bulk liquid, which requires huge quantities of liquid and reagents, and a high power input. There is a need for smaller instruments that require less reagents and less power, and can operate more flexibly.
Accordingly, in a first aspect, the present invention provides a method for detection of airborne particulates, comprising
As used herein, an airborne particulate is a particulate in a suspension of air, and includes, but is not limited to, particulates of a chemical or biological nature.
In a preferred embodiment, the particulates have mean diameter of between about 0.1 μm to about 10 μm. The particulates are preferably biological particulates i.e. particulates of a biological nature or origin, for example, viruses, bacterial cells, bacterial spores and particulates of plant origin. The particulates may have mean diameter of between about 0.5 μm to about 5 μm, in particular, about 0.5 μm to about 3 μm.
Electrostatic agglomeration is more effective where the size of the liquid droplet is large compared to the size of the particulate. Accordingly, in one embodiment the mean diameter of the liquid droplet is about an order of magnitude larger than that of the particulate. In a highly preferred embodiment, the liquid droplet has mean diameter between 10 μm and 120 μm.
The air flow may be arranged for by any suitable means, including, but not limited to, wind tunnel technology, cyclone technology, and use of natural air flows resulting from meteorological conditions, especially fluctuations in air pressure.
In one embodiment, the generation of the liquid droplets and their introduction to the air flow is performed at substantially the same time.
It will be understood, however, that the rate of air flow must be optimised to the particular particulate and liquid droplet scenario. The air flow is preferably of a flow rate between about 0.1 lmin−1 to about 100 lmin−1, more preferably of between about 1 lmin−1 to about 50 lmin−1, and most preferably between about 10 lmin−1 to about 25 lmin−1. A sheath air flow may be introduced to prevent turbulence and where applicable contain the air flow in the centre of an oscillating electric field.
The liquid droplets comprise one or more reagents capable of reacting with the particulates to produce emitted light, thus upon agglomeration the particulates and the reagents react to produce the emitted light. As used herein, one or more reagents capable of reacting with the particulates to produce emitted light includes, but is not limited to, reagents capable of producing fluorescence, chemiluminescence, bioluminescence and phosphorescence. The reagents may also include recognition elements, such as antibodies, capable of providing specificity to the method for detection. The emitted light comprises light understood by the skilled person to be capable of being produced in a fluorescent, chemiluminescent, bioluminescent of phosphorescent reaction, and preferably comprises light in the visible part of the electromagnetic spectrum. The light is produced rapidly. One example of bioluminescence is the reaction of the reagents luciferin and luciferase with the biological molecule adenosine triphosphate (ATP), found, for example, in a bacterial cell.
Agglomeration can occur naturally through close proximity of particulates and liquid droplets however, agglomeration can be enhanced by application of an oscillating electric field, preferably an AC electric field. Thus, in a preferred embodiment an oscillating electric field is applied to the air flow.
The efficiency of agglomeration in an oscillating electric field is dependent on mean particulate diameter. Particulates of mean diameter higher than 10 μm are more difficult to control during passage through the oscillating electric field, with deposition of agglomerated particulates at the oscillating field grids becoming a major problem.
The oscillating electric field preferably utilises a field strength of between about 25 kV/m to about 400 kV/m, and more preferably between about 100 kV/m to 250 kV/m, whilst the frequency of the oscillating field is preferably between about 4 Hz to about 1000 Hz, more preferably about 300 Hz to about 500 Hz, and most preferably about 400 Hz. It will be understood that the oscillating electric field must be optimised to the particular particulate and liquid droplet scenario. Highly charged liquid droplets of diameter of about 30 μm oscillate in a 225 kV/m and 400 Hz AC electric field. Liquid droplets of diameter between about 10 μm to about 120 μm can be successfully oscillated within an oscillating electric field by optimisation of the field strength and frequency.
The period for agglomeration and detection to occur is dependent on mean particulate diameter, mean liquid droplet diameter, rate of air flow, rate of production of liquid droplets, and where applicable oscillating electric field strength and oscillating electric field frequency. The optimum rate of air flow for particulates of mean diameter 2 μm and liquid droplets of mean diameter 30 μm is about 0.1 ms−1. The period of time for production of the emitted light, once agglomeration is achieved, is thus preferably less than 1 s, more preferably less than 10 ms, and most preferably of the order of μs. It will also be understood that all parameters are dependent on each other, and that the optimum conditions for particular particulate or liquid droplet sizes must be identified and/or determined experimentally.
Agglomeration of the particulates with the liquid droplets comprising reagents capable of reacting with the particulates to produce the emitted light enables detection whilst in the airborne phase or air flow. The benefits of this process include a significant reduction in the quantity of reagents required, and removal of any requirement for a high power collector to capture airborne particulates into a bulk liquid sample. The emitted light is also produced rapidly by the one or more reagents, due in part to the small volume of liquid, in each liquid droplet, within which the particulate must agglomerate.
In a further preferred embodiment the method comprises producing or inducing electrostatic charge within the liquid droplets, particulates, or both liquid droplets and particulates. The electrostatic charge in the liquid droplets is preferably of an opposite net charge to the electrostatic charge in the particulates. Liquid droplets and particulates rapidly become highly charged when exposed to a high concentration of unipolar ions, such as those produced by corona discharge electrodes. An instrument suitable for producing charge in liquid droplets is an AC unipolar charger, such as a boxer charger. Such an instrument combines corona discharge with an AC electric field, enabling control and manipulation of the discharge polarity. Liquid droplets and particulates are preferably proximate prior to producing an electrostatic charge, and thus both particulates and liquid droplets will simultaneously be exposed to a high concentration of unipolar ions. However, since the particulates are in general of smaller diameter than the liquid droplets the particulates will acquire less charge and be less mobile in an AC electric field. The larger liquid droplets will be more mobile, oscillate with larger amplitude and sweep up the smaller particulates. The charge collected on a 1 μm particulate is extremely small at AC unipolar charger parameters optimal for a 30 μm liquid droplet, and the repulsive force between particulates and liquid droplets is likely to be minimal, with the sweeping movement of the liquid droplets being the dominant force in particulate collection.
Agglomeration of particulates and liquid droplets is more efficient with liquid droplets of mean diameter higher than that of the particulates, especially when facilitated by an oscillating electric field, and more especially when the particulates or liquid droplets also possess an electrostatic charge. The method is most efficient with liquid droplets of mean diameter of between about 10 μm to about 120 μm, and especially and preferably with liquid droplets of mean diameter of between about 30 μm to about 70 μm.
The rate of generating liquid droplets is dependent on the flow rate of liquid through the means for generating liquid droplets. The flow rate is preferably between about 20 μlmin−1 to about 250 μlmin−1. Instrumentation suitable for producing liquid droplets of the desired diameter includes the Ultrasonic nozzle (Sonotec Inc), which produces the desired liquid droplet size irrespective of the liquid passed through the nozzle. This simple apparatus has no need for a high voltage supply or a compressed air source.
Charged liquid droplets of mean diameter of about 30 μm effectively sweep up airborne particulates of about 1 μm in diameter, such as viruses, bacterial cells, and bacterial spores, when exposed to an oscillating electric field. The particulates form dipoles as the larger charged liquid droplets approach, and thus agglomeration is further aided by attraction of the oppositely charged pole of the particulate to the charged liquid droplet.
In a second aspect, the present invention provides apparatus for performing the method of the first aspect, comprising
In a preferred embodiment the apparatus further comprises means for enhancing agglomeration of the liquid droplets and the particulates in the air flow. Agglomeration is preferably enhanced by means comprising an oscillating electric field or by means of a turbulent air flow. Means for generating liquid droplets is preferably by means of an ultrasonic nozzle or electrospray.
In a preferred embodiment the apparatus further comprises means for producing an electrostatic charge within liquid droplets, particulates or liquid droplets and particulates. This is preferably by means of a source of unipolar ions, and most preferably by means of an AC unipolar charger, such as a boxer charger. Electrostatic charge could alternatively be induced in the liquid droplets, particulates or liquid droplets and particulates by means of a high voltage ring.
In a preferred embodiment the means for producing an electrostatic charge and means for enhancing agglomeration is the same means, more preferably an AC unipolar charger and most preferably a boxer charger.
The present invention will now be described with reference to the following non-limiting examples and drawings in which
Referring now to
Referring now to
Now having regard to
Having regard to
Having regard to
Detection of agglomerates has been demonstrated in the airborne phase using the combination of boxer charger, chemiluminescent reaction and photon counter. Oxidation of luminol particles by haematin liquid droplets is affected by agglomeration, resulting in light emission. Sucrose was used as a carrier for luminol, providing particles of mean diameter 1 μm. Emitted photons were counted with a photon counter detector (Hamamatsu) located below the boxer charger.
Now having regard to
Having regard to
Electrostatic charging of liquid droplets was identified as a further method of manipulating the agglomeration mechanism. An electrospray instrument was used to produce charged liquid droplets. It incorporated a 50 μm fused silica capillary and a grounded ring electrode. The size distribution of the liquid droplet spray was measured by a Malvern Spraytec instrument. All aqueous solutions tested produced a cloud of liquid droplets from the electrospray upon application of an electric field of 6×105 to 2×106 V/m. Liquid droplet size distributions were similar, and of mean diameter 60 μm. The concentration was 5×105 liquid droplets per minute at a liquid flow rate through the electrospray of 10 μl/min. This was difficult to measure directly due to the high charge which caused deposition within the Aerosol Particle Sizer instrument (TSI 3310), however, an approximation was made based on the size distribution measured with the Spraytec instrument (Malvern Instruments Inc.) and the flow rate of liquid.
Particulates (fluoroscein particles of diameter 3 μm) were directed into the boxer charger whereupon they obtained negative charges and began to move in the alternating electric field. An AC electric field strength of between 150 kV/m and 400 kV/m and a frequency of 100 Hz was investigated. The total flow rate was 12 l/min. A positively charged spray of water droplets (30 μm diameter) was then sprayed into the boxer charger. The water droplets were initially of opposite charge, and moved in the opposite direction, to the airborne particles in the AC electric field. This along with particle-particle attraction enhanced particle collection efficiency. Over time, the negative ions from the boxer charger neutralised the liquid droplets and eventually charged them negatively. The 30 μm liquid droplets continued to oscillate in the AC electric field and because mobility is proportional to diameter moved a greater distance than the particulates during each oscillation. This sweeping action of the liquid droplets was the predominant mechanism of liquid droplet/particle agglomeration.
As the particles and liquid droplets exited the boxer charger they were exposed to a DC electric field deflection zone. Liquid droplets and agglomerates were deflected in the DC electric field and removed from the flow by deposition on one electrode, leaving the smaller particles to pass straight through the system, to be detected, by charge, at a Faraday pail. When the liquid droplet spray was active, the Faraday pail measured a reduction in the number of fluoroscein particles passing straight through the instrument, together with increased deposition of fluoroscein particles at the side electrode.
Having regard to
The experiment was replicated using monodisperse demineralised water droplets of mean diameter 100 μm, produced from a Microdrop spray. A mini-nebuliser was used to produce small salt particles to simulate particulates. The Microdrop spray carries a small charge due to its disruptive method of generation, but does not produce a charge of the magnitude of the electrospray liquid droplets.
Having regard to
The chemiluminescent reaction detailed in Example 2 was also facilitated and monitored by using the apparatus of
Now having regard to
Agglomeration and detection of biological particulates in the airborne phase was illustrated using the apparatus depicted in
Now having regard to
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
0616080.8 | Aug 2006 | GB | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/GB2007/003072 | 8/13/2007 | WO | 00 | 5/4/2009 |