The present invention relates to detection of microwave radiation in the 2.4 GHz unlicensed band using medium sensing in wireless local area networks (WLANs).
The industrial, scientific and medical (ISM) band at 2.4 GHz is reserved for many different types of apparatus, e.g., microwave ovens, medical diathermy and ultrasonic equipment, which radiate electromagnetic interference. This band can also be used for unlicensed communications provided certain regulatory requirements are met. Due to the attractiveness of unlicensed operation, many wireless networking devices have been developed and standardized to operate in this band, including IEEE 802.11b, HomeRF, Bluetooth, and some proprietary cordless telephones.
Many of these technologies are complementary and are likely to be deployed in the same environment. The IEEE 802.11b standard is the fastest and most popular WLAN technology as of today. As the price of using this technology becomes cheaper and cheaper, more and more IEEE 802.11b devices will be adopted and deployed in many different environments including offices, homes, and public places. Therefore, interference is not only likely to occur but its frequency of occurrence is likely to grow and become more important.
There is a considerable likelihood that devices designed to utilize the same frequency band as the ISM band will experience strong in-band interference from residential and commercial microwave ovens. This is especially true for Bluetooth and IEEE 802.11 protocols, which have been developed specifically to utilize a portion of the ISM spectrum. Therefore, reliable microwave radiation detection is needed by devices communicating via these protocols.
The system and method of the present invention reliably detects the operation of residential and commercial microwave ovens. Collecting information about the activity of other radio devices, such as residential and commercial microwave ovens, is going to become a necessary part of the functionality of any device operating in the ISM band. The characterization of interference from other radio devices requires a dedicated measurement set up. Collecting information about the activity of other radio devices is accomplished in the system and method of the present invention through medium sensing in IEEE 802.11 WLANs. The Task Group k (TGk) of IEEE 802.11 working group currently specifies several useful types of medium sensing measurement requests and reports, see, e.g., Draft Amendment to STANDARD FOR Information Technology—Telecommunications and Information exchange Between Systems—LAN/MAN Specific Requirements—Part 11:Wireless Medium Access Control (MAC) and physical layer (PHY) specifications, Amendment 7: Radio Resource Measurement, IEEE P802.11k/D1.0, July 2004 and Z. Zhong, S. Mangold and A. Soomro, Proposed Text for Medium Sensing Measurement Requests and Report, IEEE Working Document 802.11-03/340r1, May 2003, the entire contents of both of which are hereby incorporated by reference as if fully set forth herein. Using these medium sensing measurement requests and reports, information about ongoing activities of other radio devices is collected without receiving probe responses or beacons from other devices. For example, Received Power Indicator (RPI) is a quantized measure of the received power level as seen at an antenna connector and by using the information collected for RPI and clear channel assessment (CCA), RPI busy time histograms, RPI idle time histograms, and CCA time histograms are created from which it can be determined if there are non-802.11 devices, for example, microwave ovens, operating on the channel and what is their medium access pattern.
In a preferred embodiment, RPI histograms are created by a sensing device detecting and counting durations of times when the medium is busy and times when the medium is idle. The medium is identified as busy if the received power level is larger than a certain pre-determined RPI value. Otherwise, the medium is identified as idle. The busy and idle periods are used to build an interference pattern.
In an alternative embodiment, CCA busy and idle time histograms with preamble detection are created by interpreting the medium as busy only if there is an ongoing transmission from an 802.11 device. Such a transmission is identified by a recognizable preamble at the beginning of each transmission.
Thus, in the present invention, collecting information about the activity of other radio devices is done using medium sensing in IEEE 802.11 WLANs to create medium sensing time histogram reports. A sensing device builds one or more RPI busy histograms that represent an interference pattern based on busy and idle periods when the received power level is larger than a certain pre-determined value.
Fundamental to constructing these histograms is the characteristic of a microwave oven working with a single magnetron: it radiates microwaves depending on the oscillation of its magnetron, once every time t1. Typically, t1=16.67 ms in the United States of America and t1=20 ms in Europe, where 1 ms=1 millisecond, with a constant period. That is, residential microwave ovens having a single magnetron produce microwave radiation every other half-cycle of the frequency of the alternating current powering the oven. A microwave oven is referred to as trans-type microwave oven if the magnetron works with a conventional voltage transformer. Residential trans-type microwave ovens, i.e., microwave ovens that are used in domestic situations, typically operate with a single magnetron. The histograms developed using the current invention exhibit a half-cycle pulsed pattern in the presence of such microwave oven radiation.
Also fundamental to constructing these histograms is the characteristics of commercial microwave ovens are, for example, used in large kitchens of restaurants and typically operate with two magnetrons. Commercial microwave ovens radiate microwaves twice every time t1.
The interference from the commercial type of microwave oven has been more difficult to characterize than the interference from the residential microwave ovens, see, e.g., S. Kamerman and N. Erkoçevic, Microwave Oven Interference On Wireless Lans Operating in the 2.4 GHz Band, Revue HF, pp. 17-26, 2000. However, switching-type microwave ovens can be distinguished from trans-type microwave ovens because they operate with higher frequency switching circuits for the magnetron oscillation, see, e.g., J. Del Prado, and S. Choi, Empirical Study on Co-existence of IEEE 802.11b WLAN with Alien Devices in the 2.4 GHz Band, Philips Research USA—Tech Report TR-2001-044, December 2001. This results in repeated short microwave radiation periods of time t2 during the busy phase t1. Typically, t2=20 μs (1 μs=1 microsecond).
The system and method of the present invention can be used in all devices that sense the medium to build RPI busy time histograms and RPI idle time histograms.
In the following description, by way of explanation and not limitation, specific details are set forth such as the particular architecture, interfaces, techniques, etc., in order to provide a thorough understanding of the present invention. However, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the present invention may be practiced in other embodiments that depart from these specific details.
The present invention provides a system and method for an IEEE 802.11 device to detect microwave oven radiation using an RPI busy time histogram and an RPI idle time histogram. A first alternative embodiment also uses CCA busy and idle time histograms to improve the accuracy of such detection. A second alternative embodiment looks elsewhere in the spectrum for radiation from a microwave source to further support the accuracy of such detection. Finally, a third alternative embodiment employs time correlation of interference patterns for further support.
Microwave ovens create a characteristic interference pattern by radiating microwaves in regular periodic intervals, see, e.g., P. E. Gawthrop, F. H. Sanders, K. B. Nebbia and J. J. Sell, Radio Spectrum Measurements of Individual Microwave Ovens—Volume 1, NTIA Report 94-303-1, March 1994, the entire contents of which is hereby incorporated by reference as if fully set forth herein.
In a preferred embodiment, a device detects microwave ovens with a single magnetron and with two magnetrons using medium sensing measurement requests and reports to report usage patterns. The patterns are reported as time histograms, i.e., sets of values that represent the probability of occurrence (“densities”) of some busy and/or idle durations. Instead of providing histograms over different power levels, the time histograms provide information about busy and idle durations with a precision as defined in the request. For example, if a medium sensing time histogram with a slot precision is collected, information about the medium activities of other 802.11 devices can be derived from the collected information. The time histograms are simple to create without much effort, and clearly provide details about activities of other radio systems on a channel. This measurement allows improved radio resource measurement in 802.11 Wireless LAN.
As a main benefit of the Medium Sensing Time Histogram, information about ongoing activities of other radio devices can be collected without receiving probe responses or beacons from other devices during a measurement period. Once the information is collected, radio resource management is facilitated by addressing the following questions:
The format of a Measurement Request field 100 corresponding to a Medium Sensing Time Histogram Request is shown in
The Channel Number 101 indicates the channel number for which the measurement request applies.
The Channel Band 102 indicates the frequency band, taken from Table 1, in which the Channel Number applies.
The Measurement Duration 103 is set equal to the duration of the requested measurement, expressed in Timer Units (TUs).
The Medium Sensing Measurement Subtype 104 indicates the subtype of Medium Sensing Measurements to make. The available subtypes of Medium Sensing Measurement are defined in Table 2.
The Bin Offset 106 indicates the position of the first bin, expressed in microseconds.
The Bin Interval 107 indicates the time interval during which Medium Sensing Events are counted to be in this bin, expressed in slot times. Medium Sensing Events are defined in Table 3.
The Number of Bins 108 indicates the total number of time intervals that are covered by the time histogram.
The format of the Measurement Report field of a Medium Sensing Time Histogram Report is shown in
The Channel Number 110 indicates the channel number to which the Medium Sensing Time Histogram Report applies.
The Channel Band 111 indicates the measured frequency band, taken from Table 2, in which the Channel Number applies.
The Measurement Duration 112 is set equal to the duration over which the Media Sensing Time Histogram Report was measured, expressed in TUs.
The Medium Sensing Measurement Subtype 113 indicates the subtype of Medium Sensing Time Histogram Report, as defined in Table 2.
The RPI Threshold 114 identifies a received power level threshold according to Table 3, as seen at the antenna connector. The RPI Threshold 114 is used to determine if a Medium Sensing Event occurs, while collecting information for the RPI Time Histogram.
The Medium Sensing Time Histogram Report 150 contains the densities in each of the N time intervals as measured in the specified channel over the measurement duration.
The Total Number of Medium Sensing Events 118 indicates how many events have been counted during the measurement. The Medium Sensing Events are defined in Table 4.
To compute the Bin i density, 0≦i<N, a device monitors the contiguous duration of the monitored state and increments count, Bi, corresponding to Bin i. If a Medium Sensing Event occurs during the measurement at time t with
i
0+(i*Δi)<t≦i0+(i*Δi) for any i<N−1,
i
0+(N*Δi)≦t for i=N−1 (1)
then the number of events per Bin i is increased by one. During the Medium Sensing Measurement, a histogram is generated that represents the probability distribution of Medium Sensing Events in time.
A device receiving one or more Medium Sensing Time Histogram Requests responds with a Medium Sensing Time Histogram Report containing the histogram(s) according to the requested Medium Sensing Measurement Subtype(s). To provide information that allows a requester to assess the confidence level of the reported data, the total number of counted Medium Sensing Events is also provided. By analyzing Medium Sensing Time Histograms, it can be estimated if other non-802.11 radio devices operate on the sensed channel and how their medium access is distributed over time. This information is used in the present invention to detect microwave oven operation in the vicinity of the device, for example, by comparing the histograms developed in the foregoing manner with pre-stored archetypical patterns. In one aspect of the invention, if the developed histograms exhibit a pre-determined pattern, e.g., are correlated over time within a predetermined tolerance, it can be assumed with a known confidence level that a microwave oven of a given type corresponding to the pre-stored pattern is operating within radio range of the measuring device.
Referring now to
Referring now to
Referring now to
Time histograms are collected by direct sensing of the medium and requesting and receiving measurement reports, and, preferably, if they show one or more of the following characteristics it is likely that a microwave oven is operating in the vicinity:
By scanning the medium and collecting information about interference patterns, a device can determine that a trans-type microwave oven having two magnetrons is active in the medium and causes interference. Preferably, time histograms are collected and if they show one or more of the following characteristics it is likely that a microwave oven is operating in the vicinity:
Switching-type microwave ovens can be identified with the following method that may be used together with the previously described method, see
Given this information, a switching-type microwave oven can be detected by identifying the interference pattern that is characteristic for the switching type microwave ovens, see
In an alternative embodiment, CCA busy time histograms are collected with preamble detection. During periods when a microwave oven radiates power, the medium will be detected as idle through the CCA process. The value of the CCA busy time histogram at density bin for time 0.5*t1 will remain below a certain threshold and thus will indicate that the interference detected with the RPI busy time histogram is not created by interference from other IEEE 802.11 devices. This additional information can increase the probability of microwave detection.
In yet another alternative embodiment, parallel parts of the spectrum that are not used for IEEE 802.11 communications are scanned to detect characteristic secondary peaks of power that are radiated by microwave ovens. This additional information can increase the probability of microwave detection.
In yet another alternative embodiment, information is collected about the time correlation of interference patterns. This information is for example calculated a priori and stored in the wireless device. A pattern recognition module 406a can later compare the interference measured on the air with the previously stored data. This additional information can increase the probability of microwave detection.
Given the above information about the operation of microwave ovens in their vicinity, devices will be able to dynamically optimize their radio resource management, such as the selection of communication channels, transmission power, and the selection of modulation and coding schemes.
While the preferred embodiments of the present invention have been illustrated and described, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes and modifications may be made, and equivalents may be substituted for elements thereof without departing from the true scope of the present invention. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt to a particular situation, such as format changes of the request and response frames and elements thereof, and the teaching of the present invention can be adapted in ways that are equivalent without departing from its central scope. Therefore it is intended that the present invention not be limited to the particular embodiment disclosed as the best mode contemplated for carrying out the present invention, but that the present invention include all embodiments falling within the scope of the appended claims.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/IB2005/053749 | 11/14/2005 | WO | 00 | 5/15/2007 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60628075 | Nov 2004 | US |