The present disclosure relates broadly, but not exclusively, to devices and methods for measuring respiratory air flow.
Asthma is a very common condition that affects approximately 300 million people globally, with an estimated prevalence of 10-15% in children in Singapore. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that there are about 65 million people with moderate to severe Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). Most patients with respiratory diseases such as asthma and COPD need regular controller and/or reliever medications in the form of inhalers. Despite the presence of guideline-based standard treatment protocols and regular follow-ups as part of integrated asthma care programs, a substantial proportion of children continue to have suboptimal asthma control whilst on therapy. Poor asthma control is associated with significant interval asthma symptoms that adversely affect the quality of life in these children. Children with poorly controlled asthma are at risk of developing acute asthma exacerbations that may require frequent unscheduled physician/emergency visits and/or hospital admissions. In addition, acute asthma exacerbations may even be life threatening. Poor asthma control can lead to an accelerated decline in lung function and development of fixed airflow obstruction in the longer term. The healthcare and economic burden of poorly controlled asthma can be substantial for individuals and countries.
While there are many factors that may contribute to poor asthma control, suboptimal adherence to treatment is a common cause. An example of an asthma treatment includes regular asthma controller therapy, which in most patients includes inhaled steroids from a Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI) with a valved holding chamber (VHC), also known as a spacer, for use once or twice a day. Studies have shown that poor medication adherence and incorrect inhaler technique are common (ranging from 40-70%) in children with asthma. As asthma is a long-term chronic disease that has no cure currently, the objective of asthma treatment is to control it. It is found that children with asthma that is under control have higher medication adherence compared to those whose asthma is not under control.
The assessment of treatment adherence is part of a clinical encounter with asthma patients (adults and children) and forms a key piece of information based on which important treatment decisions are made by the clinicians. Clinicians may decide to step up, maintain or step down the treatment based on the clinical assessment of asthma control, as recommended by the clinical practice guidelines. The treatment decision to step up, maintain or step down the treatment is heavily influenced by the assessment of asthma control and the reported treatment adherence. Therefore, an incorrect assessment of treatment adherence may result in unwarranted step up of treatment by the physician and this can result in significant side effects, unnecessary medication burden and increased cost of care. On the other hand, it has been noted that self-reported adherence often overestimates true medication adherence and an inappropriate step down of treatment may lead to persistent poor asthma control and increased risk of asthma exacerbations.
The use of a MDI with a VHC (or spacer) is the most commonly used form of asthma controller therapy in the paediatric age group. Such a therapy is also recommended for a substantial proportion of adults with asthma or COPD. There are a number of VHCs available having variations in the size, shape and the materials used for making them.
However, errors in inhaler technique while executing the steps described above using the MDI with the VHC are common. These errors may include: the patient breathing in and out too fast (i.e. a panting type of breathing); the patient having a variable breathing pattern and/or the inspiratory flow rate is either too low or exceeds the recommended inspiratory flow rate (15-30 L/min); the patient has the MDI connected to the VHC with the mouth piece of the VHC in his/her mouth, but the patient breathes in and out through the nose (which means that he/she does not get any medication); the patient has the MDI connected to the VHC; with the mouth piece of the VHC in his/her mouth and the patient breathes in through the nose and then breathes out through the mouthpiece (meaning the patient will not get any medication).
The assessment of treatment adherence, e.g. asthma controller therapy by inhaling steroid using MDI with VHC, in routine clinical practice is typically based on patient's self-reporting, pharmacy records of prescriptions and inhaler check including checking the dose counter available on some inhalers. These tools have many limitations and treatment adherence is often over estimated. For example, the mere documentation of collection of medicines from pharmacy or dose counter/inhaler check does not confirm true medication adherence, i.e. whether the patient has been taking the medication correctly, as recommended by the physician. Hence, tools to assess adherence with asthma medications objectively are necessary.
In recent times, researchers have tried to develop tools to assess adherence with asthma medications and some examples of such tools include devices that act as dose counters (keeps track of number of left over doses), Smart Track devices (i.e. electronic device that captures data on the number of times the MDIs are actuated) and mobile phone applications. These tools/devices have limitations. In particular, the use of simple dose counters may not assist in the objective assessment of treatment adherence as they only indicate how many times the device was actuated. For example, a person could actuate the device as many times as needed to get the desired number of leftover doses, without inhaling any medication. Therefore, these devices do not give any evidence of the correct use of MDI through the VHC. Further, the patient may actuate the MDI correctly, but may use the inhaler using a direct method (i.e. without the VHC), inhale the medication using the VHC using an incorrect technique or may not inhale the medication at all (i.e. actuate the MDI only to get the desired count on the dose counter). There is also the potential issue of ‘contrivance’, which is the case where the patient may demonstrate the correct inhaler technique using the VHC at clinic reviews, but may voluntarily choose to use an alternate suboptimal technique in the home setting.
A need therefore exists to provide a device and a method for measuring inhalation technique and adherence to medications (in patients on treatment with pressurised metered dose inhaler (pMDI) with spacer) that seeks to address at least some of the above problems and limitations.
An aspect of the present disclosure provides a device for measuring respiratory air flow of a subject. The device comprises a hollow member having a proximal end, a distal end and a flow passage formed between the proximal and distal ends, wherein the proximal end is configured to be received in a mouth of a subject. A flow sensor is disposed in the flow passage and configured to sense characteristics of an air flow in the flow passage. A processor is communicatively coupled to the flow sensor and configured to determine, based on an output from the flow sensor, whether the sensed characteristics of the air flow correspond to predetermined parameters.
Another aspect of the present disclosure provides a method for measuring respiratory air flow of a subject. The method comprises the steps of inserting a proximal end of a hollow channel into a mouth of the subject; sensing, by a flow sensor, characteristics of an air flow in a flow passage formed between the proximal end and a distal end of the hollow member; and determining, by a processor, based on an output from the flow sensor, whether the sensed characteristics of the air flow correspond to predetermined parameters
The accompanying Figures, where like reference numerals refer to identical or functionally similar elements throughout the separate views and which together with the detailed description below are incorporated in and form part of the specification, serve to illustrate various embodiments and to explain various principles and advantages in accordance with a present embodiment, by way of non-limiting example only.
Embodiments of the invention are described hereinafter with reference to the following drawings, in which:
The following detailed description is merely exemplary in nature and is not intended to limit the invention or the application and uses of the invention. Furthermore, there is no intention to be bound by any theory presented in the preceding background of the invention or the following detailed description. Herein, a device and a method for measuring respiratory air flow are presented in accordance with present embodiments having the advantages of having an accurate and objective monitoring of medication adherence (pressurised Metered Dose Inhaler (pMDI) and spacer) and inhaler technique in patients with respiratory diseases.
The device 200 also includes a processor (not shown in
In alternate embodiments, the distal end 206 of the device 200 may be placed at the mouth of the subject 306 and the proximal end 204 may be attached to the opposite tapered end 314 of the VHC 304. In another embodiment, the distal end 206 of the device 200 may be attached directly to the end 310 of the pMDI 302 without using the VHC 304. Furthermore, the distal end 206 of the device 200 may be configured in such a way that it can be attached directly to the mouth piece of asthma drug delivery devices (also known as inhalers) other than pMDI (such as dry powder inhalers, accuhaler, turbohaler, etc.). In other words, the device 200 is versatile and compatible with different devices without any physical modification.
In the example shown in
The subject 306 then releases the medication contained in the pMDI 302. The medication release can be carried out by pressing a compressible member of the pMDI 302 or by activating a release catch in the pMDI 302. This will release the medicine into the VHC 304. The subject 306 then inhales which draws the medication in the VHC 304 through the device 200 into the mouth of the subject 306. After inhaling the medication, the subject 306 may hold his breath and exhale slowly. Alternately, the subject may breathe slowly and deeply in and out through the device 200 3-8 times so as to fully inhale the medication held in the VHC 304. In an alternate embodiment, the pMDI 302 may be directly attached to the device 200 without the VHC 304. The VHC 304 may include a one way valve mechanism that allows flow of the aerosolized medicine in one direction (i.e. towards the subject 306) when the subject 306 inhales. The exhaled air from the subject 306 will pass through the device 200 into end 314 of the VHC 304, and will be released to outside through the exhalation ports in the VHC 304, without entering the hollow chamber of VHC 304.
As the medication flows through the flow passage 208 of the device 200 when triggered by the subject's inspiratory effort, the flow sensor 210 detects air flow through the flow passage 208. The flow sensor 210 senses characteristics of the air flow which may include the quantity of the aerosolised medication and/or flow patterns. Other air flow characteristics that may be sensed by the flow sensor 210 include peak expiratory flow rate (PEFR), peak inspiratory flow rate (PIFR), maximum expiratory flow rate (MEFR) and maximum inspiratory flow rate (MIFR). The PIFR, PEFR, MIFR and the MEFR may be measured when the subject 306 exhales though the device 200 after a maximum inhalation, with the pMDI 302 and VHC 304 being disconnected from the device 200.
Measurement of the peak expiratory flow rate (PEFR) can be used in the diagnosis and management of subjects (or patients) with asthma. For example, during asthma diagnosis, day to day variability of PEFR readings may provide additional information along with clinical assessment. In patients with established diagnosis of asthma, a drop in PEFR readings from their predicted or personal best PEFR may help predict asthma exacerbations and/or in the assessment of the severity of asthma exacerbations.
A subject's PIFR information may be useful in deciding if the subject is able to use certain types of inhaler devices (such as the dry powder inhalers) properly. If the subject is unable to generate sufficient peak inspiratory flow rate (PIFR), certain types of inhaler devices will not be suitable for the patient.
The subject's respiratory muscle strength can be determined from the obtained MIFR and MEFR readings. More specifically, the MIFR and MEFR of the subject may be an indicator of the subject's maximum inspiratory/expiratory muscle strength, similar to measurements of Maximal Inspiratory Pressure (MIP) and Maximal Expiratory Pressure (MEP). The assessment of respiratory muscle strength may be useful in the management of children with neuromuscular diseases.
After the flow sensor 210 senses the air flow characteristics, it generates an output to the processor. Based on the output, the processor may determine whether the subject has inhaled the aerosolised medication, e.g. based on an inspiratory flow rate of an air flow containing the medication. The processor may also compare the sensed flow patterns with stored flow patterns, such as a desirable flow pattern or a target, and may also compare the sensed PEFR and PIFR with stored PEFR and PIFR. The processor may also compare the sensed MEFR and MIFR with stored MEFR and MIFR. The stored values of the flow patterns, PEFR, PIFR, MEFR, MIFR, etc. in the example embodiments may be historical data from the same subject, and can be useful in analysing trends and behaviours over time. Alternatively or in addition, the stored values can be preferred values or targets to help to train the subject for improvement or correction of inhalation technique.
By sensing characteristics of the air flow pattern, the device 200 may provide detailed information on the subject's inhaler technique such as inspiratory flow rate, breathing rate, breath holding pause, pause between breathes, average time taken for inhalation etc. This would help clinicians to review the subject's inhaler technique and provide focused, targeted and individualized inhaler technique education, using visual cues. Such feedback using visual cues may significantly improve the subject's inhaler technique so that drug delivery into lungs may be optimised.
The device 200 may include an indicator configured to display an indication whether the sensed characteristics of the air flow correspond to predetermined parameters. The indicator may be in the form of the indicator lights 220 of the housing circuit 212 of
The device 200 may further include a storage module communicatively coupled to the processor and configured to store the output from the flow sensor 210. In a preferred embodiment, the storage module may be in the form of the solid stage drive 216 as shown in
The data from the sensed characteristics of the air flow can be stored in the storage module (e.g. solid stage drive 216) and later downloaded and analysed (e.g. in an outpatient clinic setting) to assess the medication adherence and inhaler technique objectively. This feature allows capturing robust and accurate data on true medication adherence and inhaler technique using the device 200. For example, variabilities in breathing patterns while using the pMDI and the VHC may result in characteristic air flow patterns which can be used to review the inhaler technique. This can provide focused, targeted and individualised inhaler technique education using visual cues at a later stage. For example, the output from the sensor can be processed to derive a graphic representation of the air flow pattern which can be displayed for ease of understanding of the patient as well as the health care providers. Alternatively or in addition, real-time analysis can be done to provide the user with instant feedback about compliance with proper inhaler technique for confirmation or education.
The device 200 may further include an operational-amplifier differential amplifier circuit.
The circuit housing 212 may be integrated with the hollow member 202 such that they form a single unit. In alternative embodiments, the circuit housing 212 may be a separate unit from the hollow member 202 and can be removably attached to the hollow member 202 using conventional attaching means. The flow sensor 210 may function on the principle of “hot element technique”, i.e. using temperature change to alter voltage levels. A Constant Temperature Anemometer (CTA) feedback circuit may be built together with the flow sensor 210 and by using King's Law, a graph showing the relation of temperature to flow velocity may be drawn and displayed.
The device 200 may also include a transmission module communicatively coupled to the processor and configured to transmit the output from the flow sensor to a remote device. The transmission module may be in the form of WiFi components 222 and/or the Bluetooth components 224 shown in
The network device 506 (or transmission module) may then transmit the signal and data from the device 200 to a mobile device 508. The mobile device 508 may include a real-time signal processing module 510 and an online learning system for predictive analysis module 512. The transmitted signal may then be further analyzed by the real-time signal processing module 510 and the online learning system for predictive analysis module 512. For example, the module 512 may be configured to detect patterns based on historical data, apply a look-up table, classification algorithm, machine-learning, etc. to make sense of the received data. The analyzed data may be transmitted to an Al chat bot 514 and a training feedback module 516 for reporting of the analyzed data to the subject 306. The Al chat bot 514 and the training feedback module 516 may be part of a mobile application that is installed in the mobile device 508. In such an implementation, an interactive system can be created where feedback or report can be provided automatically and in natural language. The analyzed data may also be transmitted to a cloud server 518 which a caregiver (or respiratory specialist) 520 has access and thus able to obtain the analyzed data and provide individualised feedback to the subject 306 to correct their inhaler technique. In some embodiments, the caregiver 520 may be able to access the data in real-time.
As shown in
The mobile application may also be linked to the device 200 and compare the subject's PEFR reading and provide feedback, for example by displaying how the actual reading compares to the subject's predicted/personal best PEFR reading. A reading that falls below predetermined parameters may indicate the presence and severity of asthma exacerbations. The mobile application can be designed as a form of game for children or it may be a web based application that is easily accessible to subjects in order to facilitate active patient involvement in adherence and inhaler technique monitoring.
A study was conducted using an initial prototype of the device 200. The clinical study was conducted to test the device 200 in children with asthma in routine clinical context. 294 sets of data were collected on 49 children with asthma who are currently being followed up in specialist asthma clinics at a children hospital. The 49 children were aged between 6 to 18 years old and diagnosed with asthma. The study was conducted on each subject using three baseline measurements of their inhaler technique. Individualized feedback was provided to each subject using visual cues based on their captured flow pattern in order to correct their inhaler technique. This was followed by three measurements after post inhaler technique counselling of their inhaler technique. Hence, each subject has had six measurements giving a total of 294 data sets.
In
In
In
In
In
In
In
In
In
From the graphs in the study, common errors in inhaler technique can be identified using the characteristic flow patterns generated by the device 200. Examples of common errors include improper panting breathing pattern, variable and insufficient inspiratory flow rates; having the VHC mouthpiece in the subject's mouth while the subject inhales and exhales through his/her nose; and having the VHC mouthpiece in the subject's mouth while the subject inhales through his/her nose and exhaling through his/her mouth. The characteristics of the air flow pattern obtained by the device 200 may provide detailed information on the subject's inhaler technique (e.g. inspiratory flow rate, breathing rate, breath holding pause, pause between breathes, average time taken for inhalation etc.). This information can be effectively used to provide individualised feedback to the subject to correct their inhaler technique. Such feedback using visual cues has been shown in the study to improve the subject's inhaler technique.
The method may further include determining whether the sensed quantity is within a predetermined range; determining whether the sensed characteristics of the air flow correspond to predetermined parameters comprises comparing the sensed flow patterns with stored flow patterns; comparing the sensed PEFR and PIFR with stored PEFR and PIFR and comparing the sensed MEFR and MIFR with stored MEFR and MIFR.
The device and method for measuring respiratory flow as described herein may result in capturing data on adherence with medication (pMDI with VHC device) and inhaler technique in patients (children and adults) with respiratory diseases, accurately and objectively. Embodiments of the invention may address the pitfalls of the existing adherence monitoring methods and may be easy to use, convenient, safe and well tolerated in the clinical setting.
The device and method as disclosed may be capable of objectively and accurately capturing data on adherence with inhaler (or Pressurised Metered Dose Inhaler pMDI) and VHC (or spacer) in patients (children and adults) with respiratory diseases. The device and method may also accurately capture data on inhaler technique by analysis of the flow patterns. The objective assessment of inhaler technique can be used to identify errors in inhaler technique and provide an immediate visual feedback to the patient so that they can correct their technique. The air flow patterns generated by the patient will be useful for the clinician in analysing patient's inhaler technique and providing focused, targeted and individualized inhaler technique education, using visual cues. The device may be a modular unit such that it can be used with the any commercially available existing VHC (or spacer).
The device and method as disclosed can also be used to obtain objective data on the patient's medication adherence during clinic (respiratory/asthma/COPD) reviews. The variabilities in breathing patterns when using the pMDI and the VHC can also be assessed using the device of the present invention.
Embodiments of the invention may provide objective monitoring of treatment adherence in patients with respiratory diseases such as asthma. This would enable clinicians to make informed individualized decisions on asthma management aimed at optimizing patient's asthma control. This may also translate to an improved asthma related quality of life; and a reduction in asthma symptoms, asthma exacerbations, asthma related unscheduled physician/hospital visits, hospital admissions, overall morbidity and cost of care.
Embodiments of the present invention may also analyse the air flow patterns generated by the patient when using with the pMDI with the VHC in real-time. This may identify errors in inhaler technique and provide an immediate visual feedback to the patient so that they can correct their technique.
In addition, embodiments of the present invention may also provide a potential for care transformation. The stored data that is sent to the end user (clinician/specialist nurse) remotely using web based or mobile applications may be helpful in tele-monitoring or virtual clinics as part of restructuring care pathways that involve application of telemedicine. For example, web based tools or mobile applications for assessment of asthma control (that includes symptom review, asthma control test, exacerbation history etc.) may be combined with medication adherence data generated with this invention, for remote monitoring of patients with asthma. Accordingly, appropriate treatment recommendations may be made based on such assessments, thus substantially reducing or minimising the need for face to face clinic/hospital visits. Such tools may also allow better use of scarce resources, targeting patients who need clinic visit for asthma review, while avoiding unnecessary ‘routine’ clinic/hospital follow up visits, for those with well controlled asthma. For the patients, this may translate to reduced number of clinic visits and associated time/cost savings and improved empowerment for managing their asthma/respiratory disease.
Embodiments of the present invention may also provide a potential use in clinical research. This may be achieved through objective assessment of treatment adherence. This is crucial in clinical research when assessing the effect of asthma medications, and hence would be a critical step in asthma drug trials that involves use of pMDls.
It will be appreciated by a person skilled in the art that numerous variations and/or modifications may be made to the present invention as shown in the specific embodiments without departing from the scope of the invention as broadly described. The present embodiments are, therefore, to be considered in all respects to be illustrative and not restrictive.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
10201801727U | Mar 2018 | SG | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/SG2019/050121 | 3/4/2019 | WO | 00 |