A discussion of basic principles of Fourier-domain holography is first presented, followed by a discussion of digital holography.
Fourier-Domain Holography
The optical configuration for Fourier-domain digital holographic imaging is shown schematically in
An example of a Fourier-domain hologram is shown in
The 1-D Fourier transform of the section denoted by the dashed line in
which is determined by the numerical aperture (f/#) of the imaging optics. A 2-D Fourier transform is shown in
Digital Holography
Digital holograms (containing N×N=800×800 pixels) are encoded on a CCD chip with 4096 gray levels (12 bits). The pixel size is Δx′=Δy′=6.8 μm and the area of the CCD chip is L×L=5.44×5.44 mm2. The FFT reconstruction of the digital hologram produces an image with N×N pixels with a pixel size Δξ (Δξ=Δη) given by
where Δvx′(Δvx′=Δvy′=1/L) is the sampling spatial frequency.
To record interference fringes in the digital hologram, the fringe spacing should range from twice the pixel size (minimum) to the CCD chip size (in-line holography). The spatial frequency corresponding to the maximum fringe spacing is Δvx′=1/L, and the spatial frequency for the minimum fringe spacing is 1/(2Δx′)=NΔvx′/2, which is the spatial frequency limit. Four times the pixel size (4Δx′) is the best fringe spacing, at which the sideband is located at half of the spatial frequency limit. When the fringe spacing is 4Δx′, the maximum field of view for the holographic image is achieved with NΔξ/2=λf/(2Δx′). The fringe spacing for
The transverse resolution in FD-DHOCI (Fourier Domain-Digital Holographic Optical Coherence Imaging) depends on the area of the CCD chip. If the object beam at the Fourier plane covers the full span of the CCD, the transverse resolution at the Rayleigh criterion is
Rs=1.22λf/L=1.22Δξ. (3)
The longitudinal resolution depends on the coherence length of the short-coherence source and is
where Δλ is wavelength bandwidth of the source intensity coherence envelope. The 12-bit CCD camera has Δx′=6.8 μm, N=800, λ=840 nm, and f=4.8 cm, and the bandwidth of the source is 17 nm. The transverse and the longitudinal resolution for this system are 9 μm and 18 μm, respectively.
In FD-DHOCI, the CCD camera is placed at the Fourier plane conjugate to the target plane in the object. The depth of focus is
where λ is the wavelength and NA is the numerical aperture. The depth of focus for the system with the transverse resolution of 9 μm is 131 μm. The volumetric targets (tumor spheroids) are typically thicker than the depth of focus. The spheroids range in size from 300 μm to 1 mm. To minimize out-of-focus in the numerical reconstruction, the object plane is placed about ⅓ of the way into the tumor from the incident face. In this way, the tumor images remain in focus, except for the back face of the tumor, where multiple scattering and the “showerglass effect” already limit the imaging resolution.
The acquisition of dynamic speckle is a broad-ranging process shared by many light scattering techniques. In this disclosure we teach how to extract spectrogram fingerprints based on this speckle, with depth-gated selectivity that separates behavior from different parts of the tissue sample. The spectrogram fingerprints capture the different effects that differing drugs and environmental perturbations have on the tissue and the subcellular motion in the cells of the tissue.
By building a spectrogram library of the fingerprints of known drugs with known drug action and cellular toxicity, the library can be used to compare against the spectrogram fingerprints of unknown drug candidates. In this way similar mechanisms of action, and level of toxicity, can be discovered between known and unknown compounds. For classification in mechanism of action, the spectrogram of an unknown compound can be converted to spectrogram features that are compared against features of spectrums of known drugs. The unknown drugs can then be paired up with groups of drugs that share common spectrogram features.
For assessment of drug toxicity, the spectrogram markers for cell health can be established based on response to environmental perturbations. As cell spectrograms deviate from normal response to these stimuli, the degree of cellular health may be measured.
The signature differences between the shell and the core of the tumor spheroids can be measured. The core is either hypoxic, hypoglycemic (starved) or necrotic (or combinations) and hence depleted in ATP, while the shell contains cells in close contact with oxygen and nutrients and enriched in ATP. This tissue precondition affects the spectrogram fingerprints of drugs, and can control whether cells undergo necrosis or apoptosis. This separation of shell and core is unique to optical coherence imaging with its coherence-gated depth selectivity. However, drug toxicity and mechanism of action in healthy tissue can be ascertained without the need for the coherence gate, and can be applied to other imaging approaches that capture speckle from living tissue.
Speckle fluctuation spectroscopy of intra-cellular motion in living tissue using coherence-domain digital holography can be performed. A reference library of “fingerprints” of one or more known compounds can be created, and the “fingerprints” of new compounds can be compared to the reference library. The library might include the “fingerprint” of only one compound, or a plurality of compounds. The reference library may be used to screen compounds for those potentially possessing similar beneficial results. Such beneficial results might include mechanisms of action similar to current anti-mitotic drugs. Additionally, the same or a different reference library might be used to screen for toxicity.
Motility contrast imaging (MCI) is a depth-resolved holographic technique to extract cellular and subcellular motion inside tissue. The holographic basis of the measurement technique makes it highly susceptible to mechanical motion. The motility contrast application, in particular, can include increased mechanical stability because the signal is based on time-varying changes caused by cellular motion, which should not be confused with mechanical motion of the system. Apparatus are disclosed for motility contrast imaging that provide increased mechanical stability. It is based on common-path configurations, in which the signal and reference beams traverse the same optical elements to the detector. The two beams share mechanical motions in common, and hence these motions do not contribute to the signal.
A motility contrast imaging apparatus is disclosed for imaging a tissue sample at a detection plane. The imaging apparatus includes an illumination source, a focusing element, a mirror, a collecting element and a detector. The illumination source provides an illumination beam that is split into a collimated reference beam and a collimated signal beam, the collimated signal beam being scattered by the tissue sample at the detection plane. The focusing element focuses the reference beam onto the detection plane, and the mirror reflects the focused reference beam from the detection plane. The collecting element collects the reflected reference beam and the scattered signal beam, and the detector detects the collected reflected reference beam and the collected scattered signal beam. The apparatus can also include a beam expander for expanding the illumination beam before the illumination beam is split into the collimated reference and signal beams. The beam expander can be a cylindrical leans beam expander. The focusing element can be a cylindrical leans. The mirror can be located in a well containing the tissue sample. The collecting element can be a Fourier-transform lens where the detector is located at the Fourier plane; the crossing angle between the reference beam and the signal beam at the detector providing a carrier frequency for digital holography. The detector can be a CCD chip.
A motility contrast imaging apparatus for imaging a tissue sample is disclosed that includes an illumination source, an opaque aperture mask, a mirror, a Fourier transform lens, a prism, a variable compensator and a detector. The illumination source provides a signal beam and a reference beam. The opaque aperture mask has a signal opening where the signal beam is scattered by the tissue sample and passes through the signal opening. The mirror is located substantially adjacent laterally to the tissue sample and the reference beam is reflected by the mirror. The scattered signal beam passes through the Fourier transform lens. The prism is adjacent laterally to the Fourier transform lens, and the reflected reference beam is deflected by the prism to intersect an optical axis of the signal beam at the Fourier plane of the Fourier transform lens. The variable compensator is tuned to compensate for path length differences between the signal beam and the reference beam paths, the signal beam passing through the variable compensator. The detector is located at the Fourier plane, and detects the path-compensated scattered signal beam passing through the Fourier transform lens and the intersecting reference beam deflected by the prism. The apparatus can also include a polarizing beam splitter, the signal beam being deflected by the polarizing beam splitter and then backscattered by the tissue sample and passed through the polarizing beam splitter; the reference beam being deflected by the polarizing beam splitter and then reflected by the mirror and passed through the polarizing beam splitter. The mirror can be attached to the opaque aperture mask advance of the tissue sample to help compensate for the distance traveled by the reference beam relative to the signal beam. The tissue sample can be on a plate tilted relative to the optical axis of the signal beam to prevent specular reflection. The illumination source can generates a Gaussian beam, the signal beam being on the optical axis of the Gaussian beam and the reference beam being a side-lobe of the Gaussian beam. The mirror can be laterally adjacent to the tissue sample and the opaque optical mask can have a reference opening; the mirror and tissue sample being on one side of the opaque optical mask and the detector being on the opposite side of the opaque optical mask; the signal beam being side-scattered by the tissue sample and passing through the signal opening of the opaque optical mask towards the detector, and the mirror being positioned to reflect the reference beam through the reference opening of the opaque optical mask parallel to the signal beam towards the detector. The apparatus can also include a quarter wave plate located next to the opaque optical mask, the tissue sample and mirror being on one side of the quarter wave plate and the detector being on the opposite side of the quarter wave plate. The variable compensator can include a first dielectric plate placed in the signal path and a second dielectric plate placed in the reference path. The variable compensator can be tuned to define a depth gate within the tissue sample.
A motility contrast imaging apparatus for writing Fourier-domain holograms with speckle modulation from a tissue sample is disclosed that includes an illumination source, a focusing lens, a transparent coverslip, a beam splitter, a Fourier transform lens and a detector. The illumination source provides illumination pulses including a leading pulse and a trailing pulse. The focusing lens focuses the illumination pulses in front of the tissue sample. The transparent coverslip covers the tissue sample, the coverslip and tissue sample comprising a target. The beam splitter reflects the illumination pulses, after the illumination pulses pass through the focusing lens, onto the target and passes through the return pulses. The Fourier transform lens processes the return pulses, and the detector is located at the Fourier plane of the Fourier transform lens to receive the processed pulses. The leading pulse is scattered by the tissue sample and the trailing pulse is reflected by the coverslip. The leading pulse is time-coincident with the trailing pulse to define a coherence-gated depth of the target showing interference at the detector. The illumination source can be a fiber-optic interferometer configuration with a variable delay. The speckle on the detector can be modulated by moving the focusing lens. The detector can be a CCD array.
Multiple embodiments are disclosed and claimed herein. There are numerous refinements that are generally applicable to most, if not all, of these embodiments.
For purposes of promoting an understanding of the principles of the inventions, reference will now be made to the embodiments illustrated in the drawings and specific language will be used to describe the same. It will nevertheless be understood that no limitation of the scope of the inventions is thereby intended, such alterations and further modifications in the illustrated devices, and such further applications of the principles of the inventions as illustrated therein being contemplated as would normally occur to one skilled in the art to which the inventions relate.
Multicellular Tumor Spheroids
Multicellular spheroids of normal cells or neoplastic cells (tumor spheroids) are balls of cells that may be easily cultured up to 1 mm in size in vitro. The spheroids can be used to simulate the optical properties of a variety of tissues such as the epidermis and various epithelial tissues and may be used to simulate the histological and metabolic features of small nodular tumors in the early avascular stages of growth. The multicellular tumor spheroids are a model of 3-D aggregates of permanent cell lines for the systematic study of tumor response to therapy.
Beyond a critical size (about 100 microns) most spheroids develop a necrotic core surrounded by a shell of viable, proliferating cells, with a thickness varying from 100 to 300 μm. The development of necrosis has been linked to deficiencies in the metabolites related to energy generation and transfer. The limiting factor for necrosis development is oxygen—the oxygen consumption and oxygen transport reflecting the status of the spheroid. Early work studied therapeutic strategies for cancer, and especially the spheroid response to different drugs. The response to drug therapy was quantified by spheroid volume growth delay, increase in the necrotic area, and change in survival capacity. This work focused on hypoxia and its induction by chemical agents
To create tumor spheroids for our studies, two different cell lines were used: rat osteogenic sarcoma UMR-106 cells, and human liver carcinoma Hep G2 cells. These were cultured in a rotating bioreactor (Synthecon, Houston, Tex.) where they were maintained in suspension. The spheroids may be grown up to a mm in diameter. An advantage to using this continuous culture model is that fresh spheroids of varying size are easily prepared on a daily basis. Overall, the tumor spheroids provide a reasonable tissue model that does not require special handling of animal subjects.
Electron microscopy sections of the two types of tumor embedded in Toluidine-blue-stained epoxy resin and sectioned at 1 μm thickness are shown in
The experimentally measured reduced scattering coefficient μ′ of rat osteogenic tumor spheroids is on the order of 8 mm−1 to 15 mm−1 with decreasing extinction with increasing tumor size. A tumor with a diameter of 416 microns was fit best with an anisotropy factor of g=0.9, while a slightly larger tumor with a diameter of 484 microns was fit with a smaller factor of g=0.85. Overall, the rat osteogenic tumor spheroids are relatively translucent tumors with strong forward scattering.
Holographic Optical Coherence Imaging of Tumor Spheroids
The scattering geometry of a tumor spheroid 50 is shown in
The section images and the volume representation in
Subcellular Motility in Tissues
Motion is the over-arching characteristic that distinguishes living from inanimate matter. The cellular machinery that drives motion consists of molecular motors and their molecular tracks known as the cytoskeleton. The cytoskeleton is composed of three types of filaments: microtubules, actin and intermediate filaments. Of these, the best studied and understood are the microtubules and actin. Microtubules form interconnected pathways that span the cytosol that provide molecular highways for organelles carried by molecular motors like kinesin and dynein. The smaller actin filaments form a tight mesh called the cell cortex concentrated mostly near the cell membrane, but with lower densities throughout the cytosol. The actin skeleton lends mechanical stability to the cell membrane and allows its motion, including the crawling of metastatic cancer cells through tissue.
The most active use of the cytoskeletal machinery occurs during mitosis in which the entire cellular structure is reorganized prior to and during division. During mitosis, the microtubules form the mitotic spindle, which is an organized mechanical structure that helps divide the intracellular contents for cell division. Actin plays an important role in cytokinesis at the end of mitosis when the cell membrane pinches off, and the cell physically divides. For these reasons, drugs that inhibit the motors and their tracks are common anti-cancer agents, arresting the cell cycle by arresting motion.
The largest class of anti-cancer therapeutic agents are known as anti-mitotic drugs (AMD), also called cytoskeletal drugs. These drugs affect the cellular cytoskeleton and prevent cells from entering the mitosis phase of the cell cycle. Some of the best known anti-cancer drugs fall in this class, such as Taxol and Colchicine. Although efficacious, these drugs have serious toxic side effects because their action is non-specific as they affect the cytoskeleton of healthy and cancer cell alike. Morbidity and death from the side effects of chemotherapy rival the death rate from the disease itself. Therefore, a modern generation of anti-mitotic agents are being investigated that specifically target actively dividing cells, while leaving interphase cells alone. Some of these drugs act on certain myosin molecular motors that only function during mitosis and are quiescent otherwise. Others act on proteins of the signaling pathways that constitute the mitotic checkpoints of the cell cycle. By turning off selected molecular signals with these drugs, the cell cycle is arrested, and cancer cells do not proliferate.
Motility Contrast Imaging
Motility contrast imaging relies on dynamic light scattering combined with coherence gating. Digital holography fulfills the function of the coherence detection and hence the depth discrimination when using a short-coherence source, while consecutive images acquired at successive times fulfill the function of dynamic speckle recording. The data acquisition process includes setting the optical path of the reference arm (and hence the depth inside the tissue), and recording consecutive holograms on the CCD chip, followed by numerical reconstruction. Data from a fixed depth of about 300 microns inside two tumors are shown in
One goal of the data analysis is to extract the statistical properties of the speckle and to relate them to structure and function. The average autocorrelation graph of a proliferating healthy tumor at depths of 40, 110 and 180 microns is shown in
Tumors under different physiological conditions also show clear differences in the dynamic speckle. Autocorrelation graphs for the three physiological states of healthy/proliferating, metabolically poisoned and cross-linked are shown in
Among the several possible ways to define a motility metric, one particularly robust approach simply calculates the coefficient of variance (known as the CV or as the normalized standard deviation) of a pixel value (after background subtraction) as a property related to the cellular and subcellular motion. The motility metric for individual pixels is plotted in
Armed with the motility metric and the maps of cellular motion, it is possible to image the effects of anti-mitotic drugs (AMD) on the motility images. A time series at a fixed depth is shown in
Time evolution under different doses is shown for Nocodazole in
The above describes various aspects of the physical and biological phenomenon. Additional details relating to previously used apparatus that may be of use in the apparatus and/or methods disclosed herein arc disclosed in International PCT Application Serial No. PCT/US2009/0362124 titled “Method And Apparatus For Motility Contrast Imaging” filed on 5 Mar. 2009 that published on 11 Sep. 2009 as WO 2009/111609 A2. The discussion below is of an aspect of the present invention in which the apparatus potentially provides increased stability over the apparatus described in the just mentioned PCT application.
Digital Holographic Apparatus With Improved Stability
The various configurations below can provide improved stability in a holographic apparatus for motility contrast imaging.
Off-Axis Holography
In
To enable the UL holography configuration to perform depth-gated (coherence-gated) holography in reflection, a compensated path length is created between the target path and the reference path. This coherence-gated configuration is shown in
Because of the importance of angular dependence on scattering, a side-scattering configuration of the UL holography system is shown in
In-Line Holography
Off-axis holography provides many improvements in terms of stability over free-space Mach-Zehnder or Michelson interferometers. However, there are still two separate beams, and even though they pass through the same optical elements, they do not share a common optic axis. Therefore, an in-line configuration may have further advantages for stability because it is a common-path configuration in which the optical beams share a common optic axis and hence will share all phase perturbations in common.
A schematic of an in-line Fourier-transform holographic optical coherence imaging system is shown in
The speckle diameter on the CCD is
where DFT is the diameter of the FT lens, which is twice the maximum radius at the CCD. The excitation beam radius before the focus lens to fill the CCD would be
where a is the radius of the original excitation beam before the focus lens.
If we want fringes within the speckles, there should be at least 3 fringes within a speckle diameter
but this leads to the condition on the detection radius (on the CCD)
which is not feasible.
The phase can be modulated by moving the focus lens. The phase modulation is
Therefore, there are two ways of gating on the coherence. Moving the mirror causes phase modulation (that depends on the square of the detection radius) that can be captured in successive frames and differenced. As an alternative to modulating the phase by moving the lens, the double pulse delay can be adjusted to move the gated depth out of the scattering volume. Or both approaches can be used to find which speckles are coherent with a selected depth, and removing the incoherent background.
Preliminary Discussion of Using Speckle Fluctuation Spectroscopy
Having generally described various apparatus, we now describe a method of obtaining a “fingerprint” of the impact of a change in environment (including, but not limited to, administering a drug) on cells in tissue using speckle fluctuation spectroscopy of intra-cellular motion in living tissue by coherence-domain digital holography. While the more mechanically stable motility contrasting imaging apparatus described herein is preferred, other less stable apparatus might also be used in the methods of the present invention.
To briefly summarize aspects of one method, dynamic speckle from three-dimensional coherence-gated optical sections provides a sensitive label-free measure of cellular activity up to 1 mm deep in living tissue. However, specificity to cellular functionality has not previously been demonstrated. Described below are the results of fluctuation spectroscopy on dynamic speckle captured using coherence-domain digital holography to obtain the spectral response of tissue that is perturbed by environmental factors such as temperature, osmolarity, and anti-mitotic cytoskeletal drugs. Different perturbations induce specific spectrogram response signatures that can show simultaneous enhancement and suppression in different spectral ranges.
Biological speckle has a dual character. On the one hand, it is a parasitic effect that degrades the contrast of biomedical imaging, and many approaches seek speckle reduction. On the other hand, static speckle provides strong statistical information about scattering media and can be used for interferometric imaging of cells. Dynamic speckle, in particular, has considerable information content. For instance, dynamic speckle can be used to monitor blood flow and can assess the health of living tissue using intracellular motion as a fully endogenous imaging contrast agent. Three-dimensional imaging approaches are particularly important for assessing tissue viability, pharmacological toxicity, and cancer progression, and can be provided by coherence-domain techniques and digital holography. Holography captures high-contrast depth-gated speckle statistics because of broad-field illumination.
Coherence-gated digital holography was used to capture intracellular motion in three-dimensional tissue as an imaging contrast agent based on the statistical fluctuations of dynamic speckle. However, there are many functional causes of subcellular motion, and an overall motility metric does not capture specific functions. Thus, fluctuation spectroscopy can be performed on depth-gated dynamic speckle to generate frequency vs. time spectrograms of tissue responding to various environmental and pharmacological perturbations. The spectral responses depend on the specific type of perturbation, and these spectral responses can serve as functional fingerprints for tissue-based screening.
Holograms in short coherence digital holography were recorded and reconstructed from the experimental set-up shown in
Rat osteogenic sarcoma tumor spheroids were used as the target tissue samples. Multicellular tumor spheroids have approximately spherical geometry that facilitates comparison of structure to function. As tumor spheroids are cultured in a rotating bioreactor, they undergo cell apoptosis or necrosis in their center and so consist of an inner necrotic core surrounded by an outer proliferating shell with a 100 to 200 μm thickness. A typical pseudo B-scan image is shown in
To capture dynamic speckle, 200 successive digital holograms were acquired at a fixed depth shown as a dashed line in
The two equivalent approaches to time-series analysis of fluctuating speckle are temporal autocorrelation and power spectra. Autocorrelation of holographic speckle yields a first-order heterodyne function because holography uses a reference wave (the coherence gate) that captures the real and imaginary parts of the fluctuating field as the coherence-gated pixel number id(1)(t). The autocorrelation function is
A(1)(τ)=id(1)(0)id(1)(τ)∝ILO2+2ILORe{I(1)(τ)} (1)
where τ is the time delay among an ensemble of images, and I(1)(τ) is the heterodyne correlation function. Our previous motility metric was defined from the heterodyne correlation function as the normalized standard deviation, or speckle contrast, given by
Autocorrelation functions and power spectra are related through a Fourier transform. Although the autocorrelation function and the power spectrum contain identical information, the interpretation of that information is qualitatively different. In particular, the spectral information directly displays the presence of characteristic frequencies that can be related to biophysical processes, such as fluctuating membranes or organelle transport.
The spectral power density of a 600-μm-diameter tumor is shown in
For tissue responding to stimuli, such as temperature and osmolarity changes or response to drugs, the key property of the spectral power density is its relative change in response to the stimulus. The normalized spectral difference for a time series is given by
where S0(ω, t0) is the starting spectral power density at the beginning time t0 of the experiment, and S(ω, t) is the time development of the spectral power density. The normalized power spectrum as a function of frequency of a 450-μm-diameter tumor responding to a dose of 1 μg/ml of nocodazole, an anti-tubulin cytoskeletal drug, is shown in
The tissue response contained in D(ω, t) can be represented as a spectrogram, showing the relative change in the spectrum as a function of time. Examples of several spectrograms are shown in
Osmolarity has a strong effect on the exchange of water into cells and tissue. Hypotonic conditions lead to strong cellular swelling, or edema, and possibly cell lysis, while hypertonic conditions desiccate the cells and cause them to contract. The change in the relative spectral density was monitored as the osmolarity of the growth medium around the tumors was changed. Isotonic conditions are 310 mOsm. The results of hypotonic conditions (200 mOsm) are shown in
These differences in the tissue response reflect the specific actions of the perturbations on the tissue. Increasing temperature increases metabolic activity and increases membrane fluidity reflected in the preferential enhancement of frequencies around 1 Hz at physiological temperatures relative to room temperature. Conversely, osmotic hypotonicity induces tension on the cell membrane, increasing the effective undulation frequency while reducing damping, reflected in the enhanced fluctuations across the spectral range of
The above preliminary discusses applying speckle fluctuation spectroscopy to dynamic speckle obtained using coherence-gated digital holography on living tumor spheroids. By defining a relative spectral response to perturbations, spectrograms of the tissue were generated responding to temperature changes, osmolarity changes and to the anti-tubulin drug nocodazole. Different spectral ranges increase or decrease, depending on the perturbation, providing insight into the different cellular functions that contribute to different spectral ranges. The striking changes in the responses to various perturbations provide a means to develop spectrogram fingerprints that can be used to identify the effects of drugs on cellular activity. Therefore, the spectrograms define the specificity of motility-contrast imaging to different perturbations and to different functional responses. These signatures and their specificity may open the door to broad compound screening applications. More specific discussion of the method(s) of such compound screening applications follows immediately below.
Drug Screening Using Fluctuation Spectroscopy of Living Tissue
The application of low-coherence digital holography to measure the fluctuation spectra of dynamic speckle arising from cellular and subcellular motions in living tissue is now further discussed. The resulting fluctuation spectrograms act as fingerprints for specific drug action and toxicity. The speckle is sectioned from a fixed depth as deep as 1 mm inside tissue using short-coherence light and coherence gating through digital holography. The cells inside tissue are in their natural environment and far from surfaces allowing them to have a natural response to perturbations. The differential spectrograms capture the response as a function of time as drugs affect the internal functions of the cellular processes. Different perturbations produce time-frequency differential spectrograms that act as specific fingerprints for the mechanism of action. By creating a library of drug response spectrograms for known drugs, the spectrograms from unknown drug candidates can be matched to known drugs through fingerprint similarity analysis. In addition to elucidating mechanisms of action, the state of health of the tissue can be monitored for general toxicity to drug candidates, providing an approach to early toxicity testing in drug discovery.
Motion as a Functional Endogenous Imaging Contrast
Living tissue prominently displays two types of dynamic processes: metabolism and motion. Both of these processes are intimately connected to biological function. Significant effort in molecular imaging has focused on metabolism as the origin of cellular function, including nucleotide and protein metabolism. However, the ultimate measure of cellular function is cellular dynamics: how the internal constituents of cells move. Almost no attention has been paid to cellular motility as a form of functional imaging of tissue. Dynamic light scattering in living tissue has been used for blood flow monitoring, and for trauma assessment, but direct functional imaging of subcellular motion has been developed only recently by the work of Nolte et al. through motility contrast imaging (MCI).
Motility contrast imaging uses short-coherence holography to detect subcellular motion of membranes and organelles inside of cells inside of tissue. The primary data acquired after shining partially coherent light on tissue are fully-developed speckle fields. This is in sharp contrast to OCT (Optical Coherence Tomography) that seeks to eliminate speckle to achieve the highest possible spatial resolution. The speckle-fields of MCI arise from the interference of multiple scatterers with random phases within a coherence volume inside the tissue. The holographic coherence gate localizes the detected motion to within a thin slab inside the tissue with a thickness determined by the coherence length of the laser. Using this approach, permits nanoscale motion to be sensed as deep as 1 mm inside tissue localized to within 30 micron volumes (voxel size corresponding to our spatial resolution) across a field of view of 1 mm. MCI presents us with an unexpected imaging approach based on motility as the contrast agent. The dynamic behavior of the tissue is captured in so-called motility metrics that represent the degree of fluctuations of dynamic speckle, either through speckle decorrelation times or through normalized standard deviations. The motility contrast shows clear differentiation of metabolically active proliferating tissue relative to necrotic tissue in multicellular tumor spheroids. However, considerably more information is present that can be extracted by studying the fluctuating signal and its characteristic fluctuation frequencies.
Useful data results from an analysis of the fluctuation spectra of coherence-gated dynamic speckle. The differential response of the fluctuation spectrum shows specific responses to changes in temperature and osmolarity, as well as differentiated responses to metabolic drugs that separately affect oxydative phosphorylation or anaerobic glycolysis, and to cytoskeletal anti-mitotic drugs separately affecting microtubules or actin filaments. In particular, the spectral response to cytochalasin exhibits simultaneous positive and negative responses in separate spectral bands that explain the weak motility metric response observed previously. This new fluctuation spectroscopy has utility for high-content screening (HCS) and high throughput screening (HTS).
High content screening (HCS) is an imaging approach to cell-based assays for in vitro toxicology screening and the transition of test targets from biochemical to cell-based assays. The measured properties of a target compound include its cellular availability, potency, specificity and toxicity. The power of high-content screening has been derived from molecular labeling of proteomic and genomic pathways combined with the high spatial resolution of microscopy to image organelles and cell morphology changes. Molecular labeling requires the introduction of exogenous agents into the cells, which may be problematic for high molecular weight moieties and for non-membrane-permeable drugs that would then also require tissue fixing and membrane proration for labeling. The measured endpoints for HCS tend to be molecular (gene expression or translation) rather than functional behaviors that include cell size changes, organelle activity, endo and exocytosis, cytoskeletal integrity, membrane stiffness, cytosol elasto-viscous properties, etc., that can be probed by motility contrast imaging in full 3D environments.
The chief advantage of HCS (high spatial resolution) is also its chief weakness. To scan many cells across many samples is time-consuming and generates very large datasets that need to be captured and stored digitally, causing data-storage challenges as well as time-consuming data processing. The small field of view furthermore requires high-precision automation of the sample bed and of the optical train. The tolerance on optical performance for image-based acquisition must be tight with autofocus capabilities. In contrast, motility contrast imaging has very broad tolerance to defocus because speckle fields (which contain the statistical information upon which we base image contrast) are immune to even relatively severe defocus. A more serious limitation of microscopy-based HCS is the limited tissue penetration up to only 100 microns using confocal microscopes, as opposed to motility contrast imaging that can penetrate as deep as 1 mm into living tissue using coherence-gated holography, probing cells far from surface gradients that can affect cell phenotypes.
There are challenges associated with using labels when compared with label-free MCI. The chief limitation that restricts high-content screening to small numbers of only 8 to 10 physiological measurements per day per sample is the need for exogenous labels. Labels present many difficulties that adversely affect speed of screening and multiplicity of physiological endpoints. In tissue-based screens, the perfusion of the exogenous label suffers transport limitations, possibly with low diffusion coefficients for large molecular weights. In addition, many labels may be non-membrane permeable, such as large molecular weight molecules, nanostructures or quantum dots. These require the tissue to be fixed and the membranes perforated to introduce them into the cells, seriously altering cell morphology and preventing any longitudinal time-response studies. A much broader adverse effect is the cytotoxicity of many of the fluorophores and chromophores used as labels, again preventing time-course measurements that need to isolate the effect of the target compound uncontaminated by the cellular response to the label. Once the exogenous label is in place, the labels may bleach or may blink, making it difficult to quantify concentrations. Ultimately, it is the difficulty of introducing multiple labels simultaneously that do not interact that seriously limits the multiplexing ability of high-content screening A further limitation to only a dozen physiological measurements per day is because of cross-reactivity or nonspecific binding. In label-free detection, provided by motility contrast imaging, many of these road-blocks are removed.
High-content screening is based on the long-standing industry standard of the two-dimensional cell culture. However, the validity of two-dimensional cultures for cytotoxicity screening is being seriously questioned, with a major move to develop more three-dimensional environments for the cells. Two dimensional cell cultures fail because the cells have the wrong morphology relative to their natural state in a three-dimensional topology that includes extracellular matrix and three-dimensional cell-cell contacts. The intra-cellular and inter-cellular signaling pathways are altered by the altered morphology and local topology. Such cells responding to a drug candidate exhibit an altered response that may not be indicative of the natural physiological state, leading to false leads as well as missed candidates.
What is needed is a tissue-based screen that is three-dimensional. Cells deep within tissue may not be accessible to standard probes, such as confocal microscopy or two-photon microscopy, but they are accessible using MCI. This disclosure describes three-dimensional motility assays using MCI applied to three-dimensional tissues that retain the relevant molecular signaling of in vivo tissue but with the advantages of working in vitro.
To test target compounds, we use multicellular tumor spheroids within which the tumor cells have a full three-dimensional environment, which is becoming recognized as an important factor in intercellular signaling. Multicellular spheroids of normal cells or neoplastic cells (tumor spheroids) are balls of cells that may be easily cultured up to 1 mm in size in vitro. The spheroids can be used to simulate the optical properties of a variety of tissues such as the epidermis and various epithelial tissues, and may be used to simulate the histological and metabolic features of small nodular tumors in the early avascular stages of growth. Three-dimensional aggregates of permanent cell lines offer a reliable model for systematic study of tumor response to therapy. In vitro monitoring of tissue response to drugs is an area of strong interest to pharmaceutical companies. Although the in vitro environment is artificial, the biochemistry, metabolism and cell signaling response of cells grown as 3D constructs closely simulates in vivo tissue. Therefore, in vitro experiments are a validated (and inexpensive) surrogate for in vivo response.
Beyond a critical size (about 100 microns) most spheroids develop a necrotic core surrounded by a shell of viable, proliferating cells, with a thickness varying from 100 to 300 mm. The development of necrosis has been linked to deficiencies in the metabolites related to energy generation and transfer. The limiting factor for necrosis development is oxygen—the oxygen consumption and oxygen transport reflecting the status of the spheroid. Early work on spheroids launched the study of therapeutic strategies for cancer, especially the spheroid response to different drugs. The response to drug therapy was quantified from an analysis of spheroid volume growth delay, increase in the necrotic area, and change in survival capacity, but these are all gross and indirect measures. This work focused on hypoxia and its induction by chemical agents. None of these studies considered cellular and sub-cellular motility as a diagnostic of cellular vitality, despite the obvious utility of this diagnostic, because there was no means of detecting motility nondestructively throughout a volume. Motility contrast imaging provides this capability for the first time, and we obtain motility information up to a millimeter deep in tumor spheroids.
Optical Coherence Imaging and Motility Contrast
Optical coherence imaging uses coherence-gated holography to optically section tissue up to 1 mm deep. It is a full-frame imaging approach, closely related to en face optical coherence tomography, with high-contrast speckle because of the simultaneous illumination of a broad area. The basic system is shown in
In the embodiment of
The biological targets might preferably be multicellular tumor spheroids. These are avascular tumors grown in a circulating bioreactor from proliferating cell lines. They grow to a diameter up to 1 mm. Multicellular tumor spheroids have approximately spherical geometry that facilitates comparison of structure to function. As tumor spheroids are cultured in a rotating bioreactor, they undergo cell apoptosis or necrosis in their center and so consist of an inner necrotic core surrounded by an outer proliferating shell with a 100- to 200-mm thickness. The scattering anisotropy factor for tumors up to 500 microns thick is approximately g=0.9 with a reduced extinction coefficient of m′=10 mm−1 at a wavelength of 840 nm.
In living tissue, the speckle is dynamic, caused by motion of cellular membranes and by intracellular organelles, coupled with the optical channel cross-talk caused by multiple scattering. The membrane and organelle motions are intimately connected to and directed by the cytoskeleton, and hence cytoskeletal drugs have pronounced effects on the dynamic speckle. We previously studied the effects of anti-mitotic drugs on tumor spheroids using optical coherence imaging, and defined motility metrics from the autocorrelation functions of the depth-gated pixel fluctuations. The resulting motility contrast imaging (MCI) is fully endogenous, responding to the dynamic functions of cellular processes. The autocorrelation function is a first-order heterodyne function because the holography uses a reference wave (the coherence gate) that captures the real and imaginary part of the fluctuating field as the coherence-gated pixel number i(1)d(t) to yield the autocorrelation function
A(1)(τ)=id(1)(0)i(1)d(τ)∝ILO2+2ILORe{I(1)(τ)}
where τ is the time delay among an ensemble of images, and I(1)(τ) is the heterodyne correlation function. Two motility metrics can be defined from the heterodyne correlation function. They are the decay time, and the normalized standard deviation, given by
The heterodyne autocorrelation function from a fresh tumor spheroid is shown in
Fluctuation Spectroscopy and Response to Environmental Perturbation
Autocorrelation functions and power spectra are related through a Fourier transform
Although the autocorrelation function and the power spectrum contain identical information, the interpretation of that information is qualitatively different. In particular, the spectral information directly displays the presence of characteristic frequencies that can be related to biophysical processes, such as fluctuating membranes or organelle transport.
This disclosure makes extensions that improve the sensitivity and specificity of MCI while shifting the emphasis of the measurement to functional biomarkers that are monitored in real-time. One extension is the analysis of the dynamic speckle in terms of fluctuation spectral bands and drug-response fluctuation spectrograms that replace the motility metric that our prior work has employed as the source of endogenous imaging contrast. By capturing the differential fluctuation spectrograms of living tissue responding to drugs, much more information is captured. Differential spectrograms become analogous to unique fingerprints that will be much more specific to mechanism of action at a functional level of the effects on intracellular motion.
The spectral density from n distinct processes in the cell is given by
where the magnitude An is determined by the number density of the population of scatterers that contribute to the n-th process, and wa is a characteristic frequency from diffusive or active transport. The scattering wavenumber q=4p/1 in the backscattering geometry, D is the effective diffusion coefficient and v is the transport velocity. Membrane undulations have a diffusive character with small values of D that give wn in the range 0.1-1 Hz, while organelle transport is active transport with velocities in the range of 0.1 to 1 micron/second with wn in the range 20 to 100 Hz. At ultra-low frequencies below 0.1 Hz the motions are likely on the scale of the cell size and would include gross changes in cell shape or movement of the cell, which are motions that could be related to necrosis and apoptosis and the formation of membrane blebs.
The drug-response spectrograms are defined by the differential relative spectral density as
D(ω,t)=[S(ω,t)−S(ω,t0)]/S(ω,t0)
where the spectrum at time t is related to and normalized by the spectrum at time t0 before the application of the perturbation or dose. The normalization is essential, because the spectral power density has general 1/f behavior, and the high frequency amplitudes are much smaller than the low frequency amplitudes. The differential spectrogram is sensitive to shifts in the magnitudes An (dependent on the number of moving constituents) and in the characteristic frequencies wn (the speed of the moving constituents).
The spectral power density of a healthy tumor is shown in
Temperature and Heat Shock
The spectral difference in response to changes in temperature is shown in
The spectral difference in response to changes in temperature is shown in
Osmolarity
Osmolarity has a strong effect on the uptake of water into cells and tissue. Hypotonic conditions lead to strong cellular swelling (edema) and possibly bursting the cell, while hypertonic conditions desiccates the cells and causes them to contract. The change in the relative spectral density was monitored as the osmolarity of the growth medium around tumors was changed. The results of tumors responding to hypo- and hyper-osmolarity at room temperatures of 25° C. are shown in
In
In
The initial transient responses may be understood in terms of cell swelling and shrinking Desiccation of the cytosol under hypertonic conditions shrinks the cell volume, increases the viscosity, and increases the density of intracellular constituents, significantly impeding motion. This is reflected in the initial increase of the low frequencies. However, membrane vesicles may still be active as the cell tries to reestablish stasis. The vesicle activity might be the source of the high-frequency band increase for the hypertonic condition at long times. Conversely, cellular swelling under the hypotonic conditions increases the cell volume, decreases the density of intracellular constituents and reduces the viscosity. This leads to the initial increase in the high frequency motion that then decays. The longer-term low frequency enhancement may be the actual motions of the expanding cell membranes.
Response to pH
The pH of the growth medium is an important factor in tissue stasis. For instance, if the CO2 increases above 5% in the gas over the growth medium this can lead to acidification of the growth medium and decreased viability of the cells and tissues.
Response to Hypoglycemia
A tumor responding to exposure to growth medium that has no glucose is shown in
Response to Anti-Mitotic Drugs
The most active use of the cytoskeletal machinery occurs during mitosis in which the entire cellular structure is reorganized prior to and during division. During mitosis, the microtubules form the mitotic spindle which is an organized mechanical structure that helps divide the intracellular contents for cell division. Actin plays an important role in cytokinesis at the end of mitosis when the cell membrane pinches off, and the cell physically divides. For these reasons, drugs that inhibit the motors and their tracks are common anti-cancer agents, arresting the cell cycle by arresting motion.
The largest class of anti-cancer therapeutic agents are known as anti-mitotic drugs (AMD), also called cytoskeletal drugs. These drugs affect the cellular cytoskeleton and prevent cells from entering the mitosis phase of the cell cycle. Common anti-mitotic drugs are colchicine, nocodazole, cytochalasin and taxol. These arrest mitosis through different mechanisms. Colchicine and nocodazole inhibit tubulin polymerization at the leading edge of the microtubules, which causes the degradation of microtubules in the cytosol through the process known as treadmilling that causes the microtubules to depolymerize at the opposite end. Taxol influences the microtubules by using a different mechanism that inhibits microtubule depolymerization and thus stabilizes the microtubules. Many of the microtubule-associated mitotic processes require dynamic instability and treadmilling, which are suppressed by Taxol stabilization of the microtubules. Cytochalasin is an actin drug that inhibits actin polymerization which degrades the cell cortex and prevents cytokinesis.
Cytochalasin D was applied to the tumor spheroids and monitored the relative changes in the fluctuation power spectral density. The results of an experiment that applied cytochalasin D are shown in
The spectrograms of the four anti-mitotic drugs cytochalasin, nocodazole, taxol and colchicine are shown in
Metabolic Drugs
All cells run on ATP as their energy source. ATP can be generated in two ways: oxidative phosphorylation (electron transport in mitochondria) or anaerobic glycolysis. Certain metabolic drugs can shut down one or the other pathway. For instance, electron transport is shut down by KCN, while the anaerobic glycolysis is shut down by Iodoacetate. The spectrograms of these two drugs at 37° C. are shown in
Spectrograms and Specificity
For drug screening applications, among the more important properties of an assay are specificity, sensitivity and dynamic range. Sensitivity defines the limit of detection, dynamic range defines how many orders of magnitude the response can vary between the lowest and the highest response, and specificity defines how specific the response is to the type of stimulus. Motion, collectively, is not highly specific, because there are so many contributions to motion. However, the spectrograms show which frequencies arc affected, how rapidly they are affected, and how much they are affected. Therefore, a specific drug may have a specific signature in how it changes the different aspects of cellular motion.
While the invention has been illustrated and described in detail in the drawings and foregoing description, the same is to be considered as illustrative and not restrictive in character, it being understood that only the preferred embodiments have been shown and described and that all changes and modifications that come within the spirit of the inventions are desired to be protected. It should be understood that while the use of words such as preferable, preferably, preferred or more preferred utilized in the description above indicate that the feature so described may be more desirable, it nonetheless may not be necessary and embodiments lacking the same may be contemplated as within the scope of the invention, the scope being defined by the claims that follow. In reading the claims, it is intended that when words such as “a,” “an,” “at least one,” or “at least one portion” are used there is no intention to limit the claim to only one item unless specifically stated to the contrary in the claim. When the language “at least a portion” and/or “a portion” is used the item can include a portion and/or the entire item unless specifically stated to the contrary.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 61/397,885, filed on Jun. 17, 2010, entitled “Digital Holographic Method Of Measuring Cellular Activity And Of Using Results To Screen Compounds And Measuring Apparatus With Improved Stability” which is incorporated herein by reference.
This invention was made with U.S. Government support from the National Science Foundation grant CBET-0756005. The Government has certain rights in the invention.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2011/040959 | 6/17/2011 | WO | 00 | 12/14/2012 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2011/160068 | 12/22/2011 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6014204 | Prahl | Jan 2000 | A |
6053613 | Wei | Apr 2000 | A |
6144449 | Knuettel | Nov 2000 | A |
6268921 | Seitz | Jul 2001 | B1 |
7327463 | Alphonse | Feb 2008 | B2 |
7364296 | Miller | Apr 2008 | B2 |
7474407 | Gutin | Jan 2009 | B2 |
7551293 | Yelin | Jun 2009 | B2 |
8379218 | Deck | Feb 2013 | B2 |
8508746 | Wax | Aug 2013 | B2 |
20040089800 | Jackman | May 2004 | A1 |
20050121596 | Kam | Jun 2005 | A1 |
20070073156 | Zilberman et al. | Mar 2007 | A1 |
20070236687 | Mikuriya | Oct 2007 | A1 |
20080018966 | Dubois | Jan 2008 | A1 |
20080097183 | Monro | Apr 2008 | A1 |
20090073529 | Imai | Mar 2009 | A1 |
20090221920 | Boppart | Sep 2009 | A1 |
20100065751 | Harra et al. | Mar 2010 | A1 |
20100141829 | Jalali | Jun 2010 | A1 |
20100141954 | Kobayashi | Jun 2010 | A1 |
20110096291 | Buckland | Apr 2011 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2009-053578 | Mar 2009 | JP |
WO2009111609 | Sep 2009 | WO |
WO 2012005952 | Jan 2012 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Lu et al. “Low sidelobe limited deffection opticalcoherence Tomagraphy” (2002). |
Jeong, et al., “Volumetric motility-contast imaging of tissue response to cytoskeletal anti-cancer drugs,” Optics Express, Oct. 2007, entire document, retrieved from the internet: www.physics.purdue.edu/nlo/publication/JoengOE07.pdf/. |
Dailey et al., “Confocal Microscopy of Living Cells,” Handbook of Biological Confocal Microscopy, 3rd Ed. SpringerScience+Business Media, New York, 2006, entire document retrieved from the internet, www.3dcourse.ubc.ca/2011/docs/chapters/PHC19.pdf. |
International Search Report corresponding to international application No. PCT/US2011/040954, date of mailing Oct. 17, 2011, (6 pages). |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20130088568 A1 | Apr 2013 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61397885 | Jun 2010 | US |