Distortion compensation circuit

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6385436
  • Patent Number
    6,385,436
  • Date Filed
    Friday, October 29, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 7, 2002
    22 years ago
Abstract
Conventional distortion compensation circuits have addressed the problem that their distortion compensation amount is greatly reduced at levels other than the designed power level. The present invention provides a distortion compensation circuit that comprises: a vector adjuster; a linearizer; a linear signal extraction path for extracting part of an input signal from the input side of the vector adjuster; a nonlinear signal extraction path for extracting part of an output signal from the output side of the amplifier; a level detector for detecting a combined power level of the signals from the linear signal extraction path and the nonlinear signal extraction path; and a control circuit for adjusting a bias of the linearizer in accordance with the detected combined power level, electrically adjusting the linearizer so that the power detected by the level detector is minimized, and adjusting the vector adjuster so that the power detected by the level detector is minimized every time the linearizer is adjusted. As a result, the distortion compensation circuit of the present invention can optimize distortion compensation at all times independently of the average power changes of the input signal, the secular changes of the amplifier and the state changes of the amplifier caused by temperature changes.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention relates to a distortion compensation circuit incorporated in a communication apparatus that is used for satellite communications, ground microwave communications, mobile telecommunications and the like.




2. Description of the Related Art




Conventional linearizers will be described with reference to the drawings.

FIG. 9

is a diagram showing the basic structure of a first conventional linearizer disclosed in, e.g., “The Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers, Shingaku-Giho, MW 96-152, 1997.”




In

FIG. 9

, reference numeral


1


denotes an input terminal;


2


, an output terminal;


31


, a bias terminal;


32


, a resistor;


33


, a diode; and


34


and


35


, capacitors.




This linearizer is an example of an analog predistortion linearizer comprising an analog nonlinear element. This analog predistortion linearizer is a linearizer comprising an analog nonlinear element having amplitude and phase characteristics that are opposite to those of an amplifier with respect to input power changes. While connected in series with an amplifier in the preceding or succeeding stage of the amplifier, the linearizer compensates for the nonlinear characteristics of the amplifier, i.e., the amplitude and phase characteristics of the amplifier with respect to input power changes.




A signal is inputted to the input terminal


1


, and led to the anode terminal of the diode


33


. A bias voltage is applied to the diode


33


from the bias terminal


31


through the resistor


32


. The diode


33


provides the effect of compensating for the amplitude and phase characteristics of the amplifier connected to the preceding or succeeding stage of the linearizer with respect to changes in the power level of the inputted signal. The thus compensated signal is outputted from the output terminal


2


.




Next, a second conventional linearizer will be described with reference to the drawing.

FIG. 11

is a diagram showing the basic structure of the second conventional linearizer disclosed in, e.g., “IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communication, vol. SAC-5, no. 5, pp. 890-895, Apr. 1987.”




Reference numeral


1


denotes an input terminal;


2


, an output terminal;


7


, a directional coupler;


11


, an amplifier;


25


, a local oscillator;


41


, a modulated signal generator;


42


, an orthogonal modulator;


43


, an orthogonal demodulator; and


44


and


45


, reverse-phase adders.




This linearizer is a Cartesian feedback linearizer, which is a type of a feedback linearizer. This feedback linearizer extracts part of an output signal from the amplifier, and the extracted signal is negatively fed back to the input side to thereby compensate for the nonlinear characteristics of the amplifier. Of those linearizers, in a transmitter having an orthogonal modulator, one that is called a Cartesian feedback linearizer is characterized as demodulating an output signal from the amplifier into two orthogonal base band frequency components and subjecting the orthogonal components to negative feedback processes, respectively.




The nonlinear characteristics of the amplifier is compensated for by the following way. Transmitted data is inputted to the input terminal


1


, and a modulated signal is generated per orthogonal component by the modulated signal generator


41


, and the orthogonal modulator


42


modulates the signal into a radio frequency from the base band frequency. The modulated signal is inputted to the amplifier


11


, and part of its output signal is extracted by means of the directional coupler


7


. The extracted signal is demodulated into two orthogonal base band frequency components by the orthogonal demodulator


43


, and the demodulated components are negatively fed back to the input side.




As shown in

FIG. 9

, the first conventional linearizer comprises an analog nonlinear element, and usually, its circuit is designed and its bias is set so that the linearizer has the amplitude and phase characteristics opposite to those of the amplifier with respect to input power changes. However, it is, actually, impossible to design amplitude and phase characteristics that are completely opposite to those of the amplifier using analog linear and nonlinear elements. Thus, it is so designed, in reality, that a maximum distortion compensation amount can be obtained when the amplifier outputs a specified average power.





FIG. 10

shows a relationship between the distortion compensation amount and the average output power of the amplifier when the first conventional linearizer is used. This linearizer can implement the maximum distortion compensation amount at a specified average output P


1


, but its distortion compensation amount is reduced at an output P


2


that is deviated from the specified average output P


1


. Thus, when the first conventional linearizer is used, the distortion compensation amount is greatly reduced at power levels other than the designed power level.




Further, as described above, the second conventional linearizer is a Cartesian feedback linearizer, which is a type of a feedback linearizer. As shown in

FIG. 11

, this linearizer compensates for the nonlinear characteristics of the amplifier by extracting part of an output signal from the amplifier, and negatively feeding the extracted signal back to the input side. However, at the reverse-phase adders


44


and


45


, input signals do not coincide with feedback signals from the output side timewise, and thus, when an input signal changes at a high speed timewise, i.e., when the input signal contains a wide band of frequencies, this linearizer cannot keep distortion compensation automatically optimized.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention has been made to overcome the aforementioned problems, and therefore has an object of the invention to provide a distortion compensation circuit capable of always optimizing distortion compensation independently of the average power changes of an input signal, the secular changes of an amplifier and the state changes of the amplifier caused by temperature changes, and capable also of compensating for distortions even when an input signal contains a wide band of frequencies.




A distortion compensation circuit according to the present invention comprises: a vector adjuster for electrically adjusting amplitude and phase characteristics of an input signal; a linearizer, constructed of analog linear and nonlinear elements and having amplitude and phase characteristics opposite to those of an amplifier with respect to changes in input power, which is an output from the vector adjuster, for electrically adjusting the amplitude and phase characteristics with respect to the changes in input power, the amplifier being connected to the succeeding stage of the linearizer; a linear signal extraction path for extracting part of the input signal from the input side of the vector adjuster; a nonlinear signal extraction path for extracting part of an output signal from the output side of the amplifier; a level detector for detecting a combined power level of the signals from the linear signal extraction path and the nonlinear signal extraction path; and a control circuit for adjusting a bias of the linearizer in accordance with the detected combined power level, electrically adjusting the linearizer so that the power detected by the level detector is minimized, and adjusting the vector adjuster so that the power detected by the level detector is minimized every time the linearizer is adjusted.




Further, in the distortion compensation circuit according to the present invention, the linear signal extraction path has a signal path constructed of the vector adjuster, the linearizer and the amplifier, and a delay circuit for making delay characteristics of the nonlinear signal extraction path equivalent to delay characteristics of the linear signal extraction path.




Further, the distortion compensation circuit according to the present invention further comprises: a distortion amplification path for causing an auxiliary amplifier to amplify a combined signal obtained by combining the signal of the linear signal extraction path and the signal of the nonlinear signal extraction path; and an output signal path having a second delay circuit for making delay characteristics of the nonlinear signal extraction path and the distortion amplification path equivalent to delay characteristics thereof to thereby form a feed-forward amplifier for compensating for nonlinear characteristics of the amplifier by combining an output signal from the distortion amplification path and an output signal from the output signal path so as to be anti-phase to each other, wherein the level detector extracts a signal at the input side of the auxiliary amplifier in the distortion amplification path, and detects a power level of the extracted signal.




Further, the distortion compensation circuit according to the present invention further comprises: a distortion amplification path for causing an auxiliary amplifier to amplify a combined signal obtained by combining the signal of the linear signal extraction path and the signal of the nonlinear signal extraction path; and an output signal path having a second delay circuit for making delay characteristics of the nonlinear signal extraction path and the distortion amplification path equivalent to delay characteristics thereof to thereby form a feed-forward amplifier for compensating for nonlinear characteristics of the amplifier by combining an output signal from the distortion amplification path and an output signal from the output signal path so as to be anti-phase to each other, wherein the level detector extracts a signal at the output side of the auxiliary amplifier in the distortion amplification path, and detects a power level of the extracted signal.




Further, the distortion compensation circuit according to the present invention comprises, in place of the linearizer, a reverse distortion amplifier having amplitude and phase characteristics opposite to those of the amplifier connected to the succeeding stage thereof with respect to input power changes, wherein the control circuit electrically controls the reverse distortion amplifier and the vector adjuster in accordance with the detected combined power level.




Further, the distortion compensation circuit according to the present invention further comprises: a first frequency converter, inserted into the succeeding stage of the linearizer, for converting an output signal from the linearizer from an intermediate frequency to a radio frequency; and a second frequency converter, inserted into the nonlinear signal extraction path, for converting an output signal from the amplifier from a radio frequency to an intermediate frequency.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




In the accompanying drawings:





FIG. 1

is a diagram showing the structure of a distortion compensation circuit according to a first embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a flowchart showing the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 3

is a diagram showing the characteristics of the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 4

is a diagram showing the structure of a distortion compensation circuit according to a second embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 5

is a diagram showing the structure of a distortion compensation circuit according to a third embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 6

is a diagram showing the structure of a distortion compensation circuit according to a fourth embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 7

is a diagram showing the structure of a distortion compensation circuit according to a fifth embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 8

is a diagram showing the structure of a distortion compensation circuit according to a sixth embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 9

is a diagram showing the basic structure of a conventional linearizer;





FIG. 10

is a diagram showing the characteristics of the conventional linearizer; and





FIG. 11

is a diagram showing the basic structure of another conventional linearizer.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




First Embodiment




A distortion compensation circuit according to a first embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings.

FIG. 1

is a diagram showing the structure of the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention. Note that the same reference numerals denote the same or like parts and components in each drawing.




In

FIG. 1

, reference numeral I denotes an input terminal;


2


, an output terminal;


3


, a signal path;


41


a linear signal extrication path;


5


, a nonlinear signal extraction path;


6


, a directional coupler for extracting part of an input signal;


7


, a directional coupler for extracting part of an output signal; and


8


,a directional coupler for combining signals from the linear signal extrication path


4


and the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


.




Further, in

FIG. 1

, reference numeral


9


denotes a vector adjuster;


10


, a linearizer;


11


, an amplifier;


12


, a level detector for detecting a combined power level obtained by the directional coupler


8


; and


13


, a control circuit for electrically controlling the vector adjuster


9


and the linearizer


10


so as to minimize the power level detected by the level detector


12


.




Next, the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment will be described with reference to the drawings.

FIG. 2

is a flowchart showing the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention. Further,

FIG. 3

is a diagram showing the characteristics of the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment of the present invention.




First, a signal is inputted to the input terminal


1


, and the inputted signal is branched into the signal path


3


and the linear signal extraction path


4


by the directional coupler


6


. At the signal path


3


, the signal passes through the vector adjuster


9


, the linearizer


10


and the amplifier


11


in the stated order. The linearizer


10


comprises analog linear and nonlinear elements whose amplitude and phase characteristics are opposite to those of the amplifier


11


with respect to input power changes, and can electrically adjust changes in the amplitude and phase characteristics with respect to input power. The vector adjuster


9


can electrically adjust the amplitude and phase characteristics.




Part of an output signal is inputted to the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


by the directional coupler


7


, and combined with the input signal that has passed through the linear signal extraction path


4


by the directional coupler


8


. The combined power level of the combined signal is detected by the level detector


12


. The control circuit


13


electrically controls the linearizer


10


and the vector adjuster


9


so as to minimize the power level detected by the level detector


12


.




Upon start of automatic control (step


101


in FIG.


2


), the control circuit


13


first initializes the linearizer


10


(step


102


). Next, using the value of the vector adjuster


9


as a parameter, the circuit


13


makes a comparison with the detected power in the level detector


12


, and adjusts the vector adjuster


9


so that the detected power is minimized (steps


103


and


104


). Then, the circuit


13


stores the detected power and the set state of the linearizer


10


(step


105


).




When the vector adjuster


9


is optimized, the average power level of a signal, whose frequency component is the same as the frequency component of the input signal out of the signals from the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


and the liner signal extrication path


4


, is cancelled. Therefore, only the power level of a distortion component from the amplifier


11


is detected by the level detector


12


.




Next, the control circuit


13


changes the setting of the linearizer


10


(step


102


), and performs steps


103


,


104


and


105


again. In step


105


, the circuit


13


compares the detected power with the stored value from the second round of operation onwards, and keeps changing the setting of the linearizer


10


so as to minimize the detected power.




By repeating the above steps, this distortion compensation circuit can optimize the setting of the linearizer


10


while providing the condition that the level detector


12


can detect only the power level of the distortion component from the amplifier


11


.





FIG. 3

shows a relationship between the distortion compensation amount and the average output power of the amplifier


11


when the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment is used. In this distortion compensation circuit, the set state of the linearizer


10


is kept updated constantly, and thus the maximum distortion compensation amount can be implemented with respect to the average power changes P


1


, P


2


, . . . Pn of a time-varying input signal.




Further, the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment implements such a control as to minimize the combined power of the signals from the linear signal extraction path


4


and the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


. Therefore, the gain of the signal path can be kept constant at all times.




As described above, the distortion compensation circuit according to the first embodiment causes the control circuit


13


to optimize the linearizer


10


and causes the circuit


13


to constantly update the optimized state of the linearizer


10


. Therefore, distortion compensation can be kept optimized at all times independently of the average power changes of the input signal, the secular changes of the amplifier and the state changes of the amplifier


11


caused by temperature changes.




Further, the linearizer


10


of this distortion compensation circuit comprises analog linear and nonlinear elements whose amplitude and phase characteristics are opposite to those of the amplifier


11


with respect to input power changes. Therefore, even for a signal such as a modulated signal whose envelop exhibits a time-varying power distribution, distortions can be compensated for at all times without depending on the power level of its envelop. As a result, by designing the linearizer


10


so that the linearizer


10


can handle a wide band of frequencies, distortions can be compensated for even when an input signal contains a wide band of frequencies.




Second Embodiment




A distortion compensation circuit according to a second embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawing.

FIG. 4

is a diagram showing the structure of the distortion compensation circuit according to the second embodiment of the present invention.




In

FIG. 4

, reference numeral


14


denotes a delay circuit. Note that the other structural aspects are equivalent to those of the first embodiment, and thus repeated descriptions will be omitted.




Next, the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the second embodiment will be described.




In the second embodiment, the delay circuit


14


is connected to the linear signal extraction path


4


. The circuit


14


makes the delay characteristics of the signal path


3


and the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


equivalent to the delay characteristics of the linear signal extraction path


4


.




As a result, differences in delay characteristics with respect to frequencies between the two paths can be reduced. Therefore, by decreasing cancellation errors in both paths caused by their frequency characteristics when a signal contains a wide band of frequencies, the detection level of distortion power can be improved.




Third Embodiment




A distortion compensation circuit according to a third embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawing.

FIG. 5

is a diagram showing the structure of the distortion compensation circuit according to the third embodiment of the present invention.




In

FIG. 5

, reference numeral


15


denotes a distortion amplification path;


16


, an output signal path;


17


and


18


, directional couplers;


19


, an auxiliary amplifier; and


20


, a delay circuit.




The distortion amplification path


15


comprises the directional coupler


18


and the auxiliary amplifier


19


. Further, the output signal path


16


comprises the delay circuit


20


that makes the delay characteristics of the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


and the distortion amplification path


15


equivalent to the delay characteristics of the output signal path


16


.




The level detector


12


extracts a signal before being inputted to the auxiliary amplifier in the distortion amplification path


15


through the directional coupler


18


, and detects the power level of the extracted signal. Note that the other structural aspects are equivalent to those of the first and second embodiments, and thus repeated descriptions will be omitted.




Next, the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the third embodiment will be described.




The third embodiment is an application of the first or second embodiment to a feed-forward amplifier. The third embodiment and the first or second embodiment share in common the linear signal extraction path


4


, the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


, the level detector


12


, the control circuit


13


and part of a control algorithm.




In the distortion compensation circuit according to the third embodiment, distortion compensation is implemented by double systems, i.e., a feed-forward amplifier and the distortion compensation system of the second embodiment. Therefore, the third embodiment can provide a distortion compensation amount larger than that provided when only one of them is used singly.




In the distortion compensation circuit according to the third embodiment, distortion power to be outputted from the amplifier


11


can be reduced by the effect of the linearizer


10


, compared with the case where the feed-forward amplifier is used singly. As a result, the distortion power level to be inputted to the auxiliary amplifier


19


can be reduced, and thus the auxiliary amplifier


19


, which serves to implement the same distortion characteristics as in the case where the feed-forward amplifier is used singly, can be downsized. Therefore, a reduction in the power consumption of the feed-forward amplifier can be implemented.




Further, in the distortion compensation circuit according to the third embodiment, the distortion characteristics of the amplifier


11


can be compensated for by the effect of the linearizer


10


. Thus, the distortion compensation amount required to be provided as the feed-forward system for implementing the specified distortion characteristics can be reduced. Therefore, machining accuracy requirements and frequency characteristic requirements imposed on the feed-forward amplifier can be reduced.




Fourth Embodiment




A distortion compensation circuit according to a fourth embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawing.

FIG. 6

is a diagram showing the structure of the distortion compensation circuit according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention.




In

FIG. 6

, reference numeral


21


denotes a directional coupler. Note that the other structural aspects are equivalent to those of the third embodiment, and thus repeated descriptions will be omitted.




Next, the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the fourth embodiment will be described.




In the distortion compensation circuit according to the fourth embodiment, the level detector


12


extracts a signal after being outputted from the auxiliary amplifier in the distortion amplification path


15


through the directional coupler


21


, and detects the power level of the extracted signal. As a result, the level detector


12


can detect the power level including the output characteristics of the auxiliary amplifier


19


.




Fifth Embodiment




A distortion compensation circuit according to a fifth embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawing.

FIG. 7

is a diagram showing the structure of the distortion compensation circuit according to the fifth embodiment of the present invention.




In

FIG. 7

, reference numeral


22


denotes a reverse distortion amplifier that substitutes for the linearizer and exhibits amplitude and phase characteristics opposite to those of the amplifier


11


with respect to input power changes. Note that the other structural aspects are equivalent to those of the first embodiment, and thus repeated descriptions will be omitted.




Next, the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the fifth embodiment will be described.




The control circuit


13


electrically controls the reverse distortion amplifier


22


and the vector adjuster


9


. By using the reverse distortion amplifier


22


as a driver stage of the amplifier


11


, the distortion compensation circuit can be downsized. Note that this structure can, of course, be applied to other embodiments.




Sixth Embodiment




A distortion compensation circuit according to a sixth embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawing.

FIG. 8

is a diagram showing the structure of the distortion compensation circuit according to the sixth embodiment of the present invention.




In

FIG. 8

, reference numerals


23


and


24


denote frequency converters; and


25


, a local oscillator. Note that the other structural aspects are equivalent to those of the first embodiment, and thus repeated descriptions will be omitted.




Next, the operation of the distortion compensation circuit according to the sixth embodiment will be described.




In the distortion compensation circuit according to the sixth embodiment, an intermediate frequency band signal is inputted to the input terminal


1


, and the frequency converter


23


in the signal path


3


converts the input signal from intermediate frequencies to radio frequencies, and the frequency converter


24


in the nonlinear signal extraction path


5


converts its input signal from radio frequencies band to intermediate frequencies band. Thus, the vector adjuster


9


and the linearizer


10


operate at intermediate frequencies band.




In the distortion compensation circuit according to the sixth embodiment, the power level is detected by the level detector


12


at intermediate frequencies band and the reverse distortion characteristics are generated by the linearizer


10


also at intermediate frequencies. Therefore, a highly accurate control can be implemented. Note that this structure can, of course, be applied to other embodiments.



Claims
  • 1. A distortion compensation circuit comprising:a vector adjuster for electrically adjusting amplitude and phase characteristics of an input signal; a linearizer, constructed of analog linear and nonlinear elements and having amplitude and phase characteristics opposite to those of an amplifier with respect to changes in input power, which is an output of said vector adjuster, for electrically adjusting the amplitude and phase characteristics with respect to the changes in input power, said amplifier being connected to the succeeding stage of said linearizer; a linear signal extraction path for extracting part of the input signal from the input side of said vector adjuster; a nonlinear signal extraction path for extracting part of an output signal from the output side of said amplifier; a level detector for detecting a combined power level of the signals from said linear signal extraction path and said nonlinear signal extraction path; and a control circuit for adjusting a bias of said linearizer in accordance with the detected combined power level, electrically adjusting said linearizer so that the power detected by said level detector is minimized, and adjusting said vector adjuster so that the power detected by said level detector is minimized every time said linearizer is adjusted.
  • 2. A distortion compensation circuit according to claim 1, whereinsaid linear signal extraction path has a signal path constructed of said vector adjuster, said linearizer and said amplifier, and a delay circuit for making delay characteristics of said nonlinear signal extraction path equivalent to delay characteristics of said linear signal extraction path.
  • 3. A distortion compensation circuit according to claim 2, further comprising:a distortion amplification path for causing an auxiliary amplifier to amplify a combined signal obtained by combining the signal of said linear signal extraction path and the signal of said nonlinear signal extraction path; and an output signal path having a second delay circuit for making delay characteristics of said nonlinear signal extraction path and said distortion amplification path equivalent to delay characteristics thereof to thereby form a feed-forward amplifier for compensating for nonlinear characteristics of said amplifier by combining an output signal from said distortion amplification path and an output signal from said output signal path so as to be anti-phase to each other, wherein said level detector extracts a signal at the input side of said auxiliary amplifier in said distortion amplification path, and detects a power level of the extracted signal.
  • 4. A distortion compensation circuit according to claim 2, further comprising:a distortion amplification path for causing an auxiliary amplifier to amplify a combined signal obtained by combining the signal of said linear signal extraction path and the signal of said nonlinear signal extraction path; and an output signal path having a second delay circuit for making delay characteristics of said nonlinear signal extraction path and said distortion amplification path equivalent to delay characteristics thereof to thereby form a feed-forward amplifier for compensating for nonlinear characteristics of said amplifier by combining an output signal from said distortion amplification path and an output signal from said output signal path so as to be anti-phase to each other, wherein said level detector extracts a signal at the output side of said auxiliary amplifier in said distortion amplification path, and detects a power level of the extracted signal.
  • 5. A distortion compensation circuit according to claim 1, comprising,in place of said linearizer, a reverse distortion amplifier having amplitude and phase characteristics opposite to those of said amplifier connected to the succeeding stage thereof with respect to input power changes, wherein said control circuit electrically controls said reverse distortion amplifier and said vector adjuster in accordance with the detected combined power level.
  • 6. A distortion compensation circuit according to claim 1, further comprising:a first frequency converter, inserted into the succeeding stage of said linearizer, for converting an output signal from said linearizer from an intermediate frequency to a radio frequency; and a second frequency converter, inserted into said nonlinear signal extraction path, for converting an output signal from said amplifier from a radio frequency to an intermediate frequency.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
10-314647 Nov 1998 JP
US Referenced Citations (8)
Number Name Date Kind
5532642 Takai Jul 1996 A
5617061 Fukuchi Apr 1997 A
5691668 Yoshikawa et al. Nov 1997 A
5781069 Baskin Jul 1998 A
5815036 Yoshikawa et al. Sep 1998 A
6037837 Miyaji et al. Mar 2000 A
6133791 Horiguchi et al. Oct 2000 A
6326840 Funada et al. Dec 2001 B1
Non-Patent Literature Citations (2)
Entry
The Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers; Technical Report of Ieice, NW96-152, 1997.
IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, vol. Sac-5, No. 5, pp. 890-895, Jun. 1987.