Door latching device

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6823701
  • Patent Number
    6,823,701
  • Date Filed
    Friday, August 29, 2003
    21 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 30, 2004
    20 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Examiners
    • Gail; Lloyd A.
    Agents
    • Schwab; Charles L.
    • Nexsen Pruet, LLC
Abstract
A door latching device is disclosed that is mountable to conventional doors, including cargo container doors and garage doors, for preventing opening thereof. A conventional keyed lock, such as a padlock or puck-shaped protected shackle lock, couples with the latching device to lock the latching device in a latched position with a door. The latching device includes a rigid housing having an attachment bolt affixed thereto for securing the latching device to the door, a slidable locking pin having an opening for receiving a locking pin ingress/egress. In a locked position, the locking pin protrudes from the housing, and the lock is coupled with the locking pin to prevent movement of the same. In an unlocked position, the lock is uncoupled from the locking pin to permit sliding of the locking pin. The housing provides limited access to the lock once the lock is coupled with the locking pin.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates generally to latching devices, and more particularly to a latching mechanism for preventing opening of conventional doors.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Securing cargo container doors, such as tractor trailer container doors and storage container doors, and preventing unauthorized opening of container doors are important to protecting the contents of the container. The use of locks alone to prevent unauthorized opening of container doors is inadequate because of the physical vulnerabilities of the locks. Locks are commonly broken or destroyed by means such as applying a hammer to the lock body or by applying a lock cutter to a locking bar or shackle of the lock. Once the lock is broken, access to the contents of the container is inevitable. A number of devices have been proposed in the past to prevent destruction of the locks or minimize access to the lock body.




U.S. Pat. No. 3,976,318 describes a protector for a lock mounted on a door hinged to a doorframe. The protector includes a lock cover and a plate that prevents access to the lock. The lock cover member includes an opening for access to a keyhole of the lock and is bolted to the door and over the lock. The plate includes a slot and is attached to a doorjamb such that when the door is closed, the lock cover fits snugly in the slot thereby preventing access to one side of the lock cover.




U.S. Pat. No. 5,168,258 describes a padlock protecting device to secure a conventional latch assembly found on a cargo door of a truck. The latch assembly includes a locking lever, lever retaining mechanism attached to the cargo door, and lock coupled to the lever retaining mechanism. The protecting device includes a pivoting cover mounted to the cargo door for enclosing the lock and lever retaining mechanism, a detector switch that engages the cover when the cover is closed and detects displacement of the cover, and an alarm connected to the detector switch that emits an alarm signal during unauthorized displacement of the cover.




U.S. Pat. No. 6,058,745 describes a padlock cover assembly for use with shackle type padlocks. The padlock cover assembly includes a padlock mounting bracket that is attached to one door and a cover secured to another door and advanceable to cover a padlock secured to the mounting bracket. The mounting bracket includes two tabs, and the cover has a latch finger that is positioned inside the cover and a tab. When the cover is placed over the padlock and the padlock is locked, the latch finger catches the apex of the shackle and one of the tabs and the tab of the cover catches the second tab of the mounting bracket. An access hole is provided at the bottom of the cover to access a keyhole of the padlock.




U.S. Pat. No. 6,233,984 describes a semitrailer cargo door locking system for use with an upper hasp and a lower hasp to secure a door handle. The system includes a shackleless lock that receives the upper and lower hasps when the hasps are aligned. A locking bolt within the shackleless lock engages the aligned hasps by a key-activated tumbler to lock the hasps in the aligned position.




U.S. Pat. No. 6,367,292 describes a padlock protector for use with disk type padlocks having circular shackles to lock two moveable objects of a cargo container in a fixed relationship. The padlock protector includes a housing that is mounted to one of the objects, a moveable bar mounted on the interior of the housing to engage a sleeve mounted on the other object, a lower collar for enclosing the bar and having a padlock retainer at one end with a shackle receiving opening, and an upper collar for enclosing the bar having a keyhole protector. A predetermined hole is formed in the length of the bar. The keyhole protector provides access to a key to a keyhole slot of the padlock when the padlock is shackled through the hole of the bar.




U.S. Pat. No. 6,463,769 describes a padlock lock box for protecting the padlock from bolt cutters. The lock box includes a housing that is securable to a door and has an aperture in the back for receiving a fixed hasp plate that is secured to a second door or to a doorframe. The hasp plate has an opening for receiving a shackle of the padlock. The lock box has an open bottom to receive the padlock, and the front of the lock box includes an aperture for key access to the padlock.




U.S. Pat. No. 6,494,064 describes an enclosed lock device for use with a padlock having a shackle. The lock device includes a latch box, a strike box, and a slide assembly. The latch box has a guide bar with a channel for passing the top of the shackle therethrough, a pivoting link having a hole for receiving the shackle, and a travel limiter above the guide bar. The slide assembly includes a slidable latch located between the guide bar and the travel limiter and the padlock that is attached to the latch. The strike box includes a strike plate with a slot for receiving the latch. The bottom of the latch box has an opening for a key to access the padlock.




Trailer cargo doors commonly include rotatable stanchions that are permanently held to the exterior of the cargo doors by brackets. The stanchions are rotated to a locking position and typically secured by a lock, such as a padlock or shackle lock described in the locking system of U.S. Pat. No. 6,233,984. However, none of the aforementioned lock protecting devices may be coupled directly with stanchions found on conventional trailer cargo doors to secure the stanchions in a locked position, or prohibit movement of the stanchions, and prevent unauthorized opening of the doors. Additionally, none of the aforementioned lock protecting devices may be coupled directly with the stanchions and simultaneously protect the lock device.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




An object of this invention is to provide a lock protecting device that secures a door in a locked position.




A more particular object of this invention is to provide a lock protecting device that may be coupled with conventional cargo container stanchions to secure the stanchions in a locked position.




Another object of this invention is to provide a lockable door latching system that secures a door to a door frame or an immoveable object adjacent to the door and prevents unauthorized tampering of the lock.




Yet another object of this invention is to provide a door latching device for use with a lock that protects the lock from unauthorized tampering.




These and other objects of the invention are accomplished by providing a latching device for securing a door in a closed position. The latching device includes a rigid housing having an attachment bolt affixed thereto for securing the latching device to a door, a slidable locking pin having an opening for receiving a locking bar or shackle of a lock, and a guide coupled with the locking pin. The rigid housing includes an opening for receiving the lock, an opening providing limited access to a keyhole of the lock (which may or may not be combined with the lock), and a locking pin ingress/egress. In a latched position, the locking pin protrudes from the housing, and the lock is coupled with the locking pin to prevent movement of the same. In an unlatched position, the lock is uncoupled from the locking pin to permit displacement of the locking pin. The housing provides limited access to the lock once the lock is coupled with the locking pin. In applications of securing cargo container doors having stanchions, the latching device is mounted substantially adjacent to a desired stanchion that includes an aperture for receiving the locking pin. In alternative applications for securing a door that operatively couples with an immoveable object, such as a doorframe or fixed door, the latching device is mounted substantially adjacent to the object that includes an aperture for receiving the locking pin. The locking pin and the aperture are preferably aligned when the door is in the closed position to permit insertion of the locking pin into the aperture.




These and other objects of the invention are also accomplished by providing a door latching system having a lockable latch, a means for receiving the latch to secure a door in a closed position against an immovable object, and a lock engageable with the latch and having a key receiving portion, such as a keyhole. The lockable latch includes a rigid housing providing restricted access to the lock when the lock is positioned therein, a slidable locking pin coupled with the housing, and a means for affixing the lockable latch to the door, such as an attachment bolt and nut. The housing has a first opening for receiving the lock, a second opening for accessing the key receiving portion of the lock, and a locking pin ingress/egress. The locking pin has an aperture for receiving a locking bar or shackle of the lock. Depending on the type of door desired to be secured, an aperture is preferably formed in the immoveable object to receive the locking pin when the door is in the closed position.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a partially exploded view of a latching device in accordance with the present invention.





FIG. 2

is a sectional view of the latching device mounted to a container door, shown in broken line.





FIG. 3

is a partial sectional view of a lock coupled with the latching device shown in

FIG. 2

illustrating a latched and unlocked position.





FIG. 4

is a partial sectional view of a lock coupled with the latching device shown in

FIG. 2

illustrating a locked position.





FIG. 5

is a perspective view of the latching device mounted to a container door of a tractor trailer in accordance with the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




The present invention is a latching device for securing a door in a closed position. Additionally, the present invention is a door latching system for securing a door in the closed position using a conventional lock. The latching device is ideally suited to directly couple with and secure cargo stanchions, such as found on storage container and tractor trailer doors, in a position that prevents opening of the cargo container door. Additionally, the latching device may be used to secure a door in a closed position relative to a corresponding immoveable object, such as a doorframe or fixed door. For example, the latching device may be affixed to a conventional rolling door, such as used in a garage, mini-storage, and/or tractor trailer, where the rolling door is latched and locked relative to a door frame such that the rolling door is secured in a closed position. Keyed locks are preferably used with the latching device.




As used herein, the term “locking bar” is defined to mean a rod, bar, shaft, and/or shackle found on conventional locks including but not limited to padlocks and protected-shackle type locks. While a protected-shackle type lock, or shackleless type lock (e.g., puck-shape type lock), is shown and described for use with the locking device, the latching device is not intended to be limited to coupling with shackleless type locks and may be used with conventional shackle locks having key access, including but not limited to padlocks. Further, while the latching device is described with respect to securing a door in the closed position, the latching device may be used to secure the door in any desired position depending on the relationship of the door with respect to the corresponding immoveable object, such as a doorframe. Depending on a mounting location of the latching device and a location of a locking pin receiving aperture, described in greater detail hereinafter, the door is secured in varying degrees of open or closed positions. For example, depending on the mounting location of the latching device at varying heights of a conventional rolling garage door and the location of the receiving aperture at varying heights of a corresponding doorframe, the garage door is lifted to allow a partial opening into the garage and secured in such position by latching and locking the latching device.





FIG. 1

is a partially exploded view of a latching device, shown generally at


10


, in accordance with the present invention. The latching device


10


includes a rigid housing


12


, an attachment bolt


24


affixed to the housing


12


, a slidable locking pin


26


operatively engageable with a locking bar


28


(

FIGS. 3 and 4

) of a lock


16


, and a pin guide


30


coupled with the locking pin


26


. In one embodiment of the present invention, a shackleless lock


16


is used, and as best shown in

FIG. 1

, the housing


12


restricts access to the lock


16


by surrounding a perimeter of the lock


16


to minimize tampering of the lock


16


. In an alternative embodiment using a shackled lock, the slidable locking pin is operatively engageable with a shackle of such lock.




The rigid housing


12


has a bottom or back wall


32


and a side wall or side wall structure


34


connected to the back wall


32


and extending outward therefrom to form a front opening chamber for containing the puck shaped lock


16


. The side wall structure


34


is preferably connected to the back wall


32


at a perimeter of the back wall


32


. The side wall structure


34


forms a top opening, shown generally at


14


, for receiving the lock


16


therethrough. The housing


12


includes a first opening, shown generally at


18


, for accessing a key receiving portion


20


of the lock


16


. The housing


12


has a second or locking pin ingress/egress opening


22


. The first opening


18


is positioned on the housing


12


depending on the location of the key receiving portion


20


on the lock


16


and is preferably sized corresponding to the key receiving portion


20


of the lock


16


to restrict access to the lock


16


. In this embodiment, the key receiving portion


20


of the lock


16


is located at the side of the lock


16


, and extends through the first opening


18


(FIG.


3


), which is positioned at the side of the housing


12


, when the lock


16


is unlocked. The locking pin opening


22


is formed through the side wall structure


34


of the housing


12


opposite the part thereof in which the first opening


18


is formed and below a partition wall or tab guide


44


which is rigidly secured to the side wall structure


34


in spaced parallel relation to the back wall


32


. The partition wall


44


divides the chamber of the housing


12


into an outer compartment in which the lock


16


is disposed and an inner compartment in which the locking pin opening


22


is formed. A pin guide


30


in the form of a cylindrical bushing with a cylindrical opening is secured to the side wall structure


34


in axial alignment with the locking pin opening


22


, which is also cylindrical.





FIG. 2

is a sectional view of the latching device


10


mounted to a container door


36


, shown in broken line, having a stanchion


50


.

FIG. 2

illustrates in a simple manner the desired mounting location of the latching device


10


with respect to the stanchion


50


which is not shown in proportional size relation to the latching device


10


. For example, in an application of the present invention, the latching device more closely approximates a diameter of the stanchion, and a height of the latching device may be greater or lesser than the diameter of the stanchion. As best shown in

FIG. 2

, the attachment bolt


24


is affixed to the back plate


32


of the housing


12


for attachment to the door


36


such that the back plate


32


is positioned substantially adjacent the door


36


. In one embodiment, the attachment bolt


24


is inserted through an opening, shown generally at


68


, formed in the door


36


and a nut


38


is threaded onto the attachment bolt


24


to affix the housing


12


to the door


36


. Conventional specialized adhesives or sealants may be used on the bolt


24


and nut


38


to prevent movement of the same. Alternatively, the housing


12


may be affixed to the door


36


using a variety of known techniques including, by way of example and not limitation, welding the back plate


32


to the door


36


. Furthermore, the location of the housing is not critical to the present invention as long as the housing is attached to either the door or the immoveable object that is operatively coupled with the door and the locking pin receiving aperture is conversely located on either the immoveable object or the door, respectively.




The pin guide


30


is mounted to the interior of the housing


12


and adjacent to the locking pin ingress/egress


22


to guide the locking pin


26


into and out of the ingress/egress


22


. The locking pin


26


has a cylindrical pin portion


40


and a tab


42


connected to the cylindrical pin portion


40


such that the tab


42


extends radially away from the cylindrical pin portion


40


. The tab


42


has an opening


56


for receiving the locking bar


28


of the lock


16


therethrough. When the latching device


10


is unlocked, the locking pin


26


is displaceable with respect to the pin guide


30


in a sliding motion. In this embodiment, the locking pin receiving aperture


52


is formed in the stanchion


50


. In a latched position, the locking pin


26


extends out through the pin guide


30


and the ingress/egress


22


and into the locking pin receiving aperture


52


.




As best shown in

FIG. 1

, a tab guide


44


is positioned in the interior of the housing


12


and includes a channel


46


that receives the tab


42


of the locking pin


26


when the locking pin


26


is inserted through the pin guide


30


. The tab guide


44


and the pin guide


30


together assist in guiding the movement of the locking pin


26


inside the housing


12


and through the ingress/egress


22


.




In one embodiment of the present invention, a rigid cap


48


(

FIGS. 2

,


3


and


4


) or shelf is optionally attached to the exterior of the housing


12


to prevent access to the locking pin


26


. In this embodiment, the cap


48


is attached to the side wall


34


of the housing substantially adjacent to the locking pin ingress/egress


22


and away from the back plate


32


of the housing


12


. When the latching device


10


is mounted adjacent to the stanchion


50


on the door


36


, the locking pin


26


is between the door


36


and the cap


48


. The dimension of the cap


48


may vary depending on the size of the stanchion as well as the latching device and preferably provides sufficient coverage to restrict access to the locking pin


26


when the latching device is mounted adjacent to the stanchion


50


. The rigid cap


48


is ideally suited to prevent sawing of the locking pin


26


.




In another embodiment, a tab retainer, not shown, may optionally be included to further prevent displacement of the locking pin


26


. In this embodiment, the tab retainer is pivotally attached to the interior of the housing


12


and adjacent to the tab guide


44


. The tab retainer includes a slot for receiving the tab


42


of the locking pin


26


when the latching device


10


is in the latched position and prevents movement of the locking pin


26


when the locking pin is received through the slot of the tab retainer. To permit movement of the locking pin


26


, the tab retainer is pivoted away from the interior of the housing


12


such that the tab


42


exits the slot of the tab retainer.





FIG. 3

is a partial sectional view of the lock


16


coupled with the latching device


10


that is attached to the door


36


illustrating a latched and unlocked position. In the latched position, the locking pin


26


is retained by the locking pin receiving aperture


52


. After the lock


16


is positioned within the interior of the housing


12


, the locking bar


28


is inserted through the opening


56


of the tab


42


to engage the lock. As previously mentioned hereinabove, the second opening


19


of the housing


12


permits a key


60


to access the key receiving portion


20


of the lock


16


to engage the lock


16


and lock the latching device


10


in a locked position or disengage the lock


16


. Washers may optionally be used to assist in affixing the attachment bolt


24


to the housing


12


. For example, a locking washer


58


is inserted between a head of the attachment bolt


24


and the back plate


32


when the attachment bolt


24


is affixed to the back plate


32


.




As best shown in

FIG. 3

, the extent the side wall


34


extends away from the back plate


32


and the position of the tab guide


44


, and the tab retainer when using the same, within the housing


12


preferably allows the lock


16


to rest against an outer surface of the tab guide


44


such that the side wall


34


extends a distance away from the back plate to sufficiently block access to all sides of the lock


16


with the exception of the key receiving portion


20


.




In one embodiment, the back plate


32


is slightly raised with respect to the door


36


when the latching device


10


is mounted to the door


36


. For example, when the latching device


10


is mounted to the door


36


, the back plate


32


does not fit flush with the door


36


along the entire surface of the back plate


32


but the perimeter of the back plate


32


and/or the side wall


34


fits flush with the door


36


. In this embodiment, a “bite” effect is created that counters any attempt to lift a side of the latching device


10


away from the door


36


. When a side of the latching device


10


is lifted away from the door


36


, an opposing side of the latching device


10


is pressed into the door


36


thereby countering such lift.





FIG. 4

is a partial sectional view of the lock


16


coupled with the latching device


10


shown in

FIG. 3

illustrating the locked position. In the locked position, the locking bar


28


is inserted through the opening


56


of the tab


42


, and the key


60


engages the lock


16


so that the locking pin


26


cannot exit the locking pin receiving aperture


52


. As best shown in

FIGS. 2

,


3


, and


4


, the housing


12


surrounds the perimeter of the lock


16


such that movement of the lock is minimized when the lock


16


is engaged. In the locked position, the lock


16


prevents movement of the locking pin


26


so that the aperture


52


retains the locking pin thereby securing the door


36


in the closed position.





FIG. 5

is a perspective view of the latching device


10


mounted to a container door


62


of a tractor-trailer cargo container


64


in accordance with the present invention. The container door


62


has stanchions


66


that prevent movement of the door


62


using brackets


70


. The stanchion has a foot connected to an end of the stanchion that catches a top or a bottom of the cargo container


64


. The stanchions


66


typically operate by rotating the stanchion along an axis of the same to uncouple the stanchion from the bracket


70


. Once the stanchion is uncoupled from the bracket, the stanchion is withdrawn from the bracket and the door to which the stanchion is attached may be opened.




As best shown in

FIG. 5

, the latching device


10


is mounted substantially adjacent to one of the stanchions


66


for direct coupling of the latching device


10


with the stanchion


66


. The locking pin receiving aperture is preferably formed through the stanchion


66


, and the latching device is mounted substantially adjacent to the locking pin receiving aperture. After the locking pin is inserted into and through the locking pin receiving aperture, rotation of the stanchion


66


is prevented thus preventing opening of the door


62


. Coupling a lock, and locking the same, with the latching device


10


locks the locking pin in this position and thus locks the stanchion


66


in the closed position. Depending on the direction of rotation of the stanchion


66


to open the door


62


, the latching device is most preferably mounted to a side of the stanchion such that rotation of the stanchion


66


to open the door


62


directs the locking pin and the latching device against the door


62


.




As previously mentioned, a rigid cap or shelf may optionally be attached to the exterior of the housing to prevent access to the locking pin


26


. In one embodiment, the cap is attached to the side wall of the housing substantially adjacent to the locking pin ingress/egress and away from the back plate of the housing. When the latching device


10


is mounted adjacent to the stanchion


66


on the door


62


, the locking pin


26


is between the door and the cap. The rigid cap is ideally suited to prevent sawing of the locking pin


26


.




Alternative Embodiment




Although the present invention is shown and described with respect to a shackleless lock, a shackled lock such as a conventional padlock with a shackle may also be used with the latching device. In this embodiment, the latching device remains substantially the same with modifications to the housing and protection of the locking pin. The latching device has a rigid housing, a slidable locking pin operatively engageable with the shackle, a pin guide coupled with the locking pin, and a stopper that prevents displacement of the locking pin. The housing includes a back plate, side walls connected to the back plate and extending outward therefrom, and a front plate opposing the back plate and connected to the side walls. The back plate, side walls, and front plate form a cavity for containing the lock and surrounding the shackle of the lock. The latching device has a first opening that is a bottom opening for coupling a shackled lock with the latching device that also provides access to key receiving portion of the lock. The locking pin ingress/egress is formed through one of the side walls of the housing.




The pin guide is mounted to the interior of the housing and adjacent to the locking pin ingress/egress to guide the locking pin into and out of the ingress/egress. The locking pin includes a pin portion connected to a tab extending radially away from the pin portion. The tab includes an opening for receiving the shackle of the lock. In this embodiment, the locking pin also pivots about an axis of the locking pin ingress/egress when the locking pin is received by the locking ingress/egress. The stopper is mounted to the interior of the housing and preferably mounted adjacent to the pin guide. The stopper includes a tab engaging portion that contacts the tab of the locking pin after the locking pin is inserted into the locking pin receiving aperture such that the tab engaging portion prevents displacement of the locking pin out of the receiving aperture.




The tab engaging portion of the stopper includes a slot for receiving the shackle of the lock so that the locking pin may be secured in a locked position against the tab engaging portion of the stopper. In the locked position, the shackle is inserted through both the slot of the stopper and the opening of the tab, and the lock locked. After the lock is unlocked and the shackle withdrawn from the slot of the stopper and the opening of the tab, the locking pin may be displaced by rotating the locking pin so as to pivot the tab of the locking pin clear of the tab engaging portion of the stopper. When the tab of the locking pin is clear of the tab engaging portion of the stopper, the locking pin may be displaced outwardly from the locking pin receiving aperture.




Those of ordinary skill in the art will be aware of other variations that are within the scope of the claimed invention, which is to be measured by the following claims.



Claims
  • 1. A door latching device for a container having a door with a locking stanchion on its outer side, said stanchion being rotatable about its axis between locked and unlocked positions, said latching device comprising:a locking pin receiving aperture in said stanchion in transverse intersecting relation to its axis, a puck shaped shackleless lock having a locking bar and a key-receiving portion, a rigid housing having a back wall adapted for rigid connection to said outer side of said door, a sidewall structure rigidly secured to said back wall and extending outwardly therefrom to define a chamber having a front opening, a partition wall rigidly secured to said sidewall structure in spaced and parallel relation to said back wall dividing said chamber into an outer compartment in which said lock is disposed and an inner compartment, said partition wall having a centrally positioned pin guiding channel, a first opening in said sidewall structure outwardly of said partition wall adapted to receive said key-receiving portion of said puck shaped lock, and a second opening in said sidewall structure opposite the part thereof in which said first opening is formed in, said second opening being disposed in said inner compartment inwardly of said partition wall, and a locking pin axially shiftable between a locking position and an unlocking position having, a cylindrical pin portion disposed in said inner compartment and extending axially through said second opening at a right angle to said axis of said stanchion, and a tab rigidly secured to said cylindrical pin portion and extending radially away from said pin portion through said channel and into said outer compartment, said tab including an opening for receiving said locking bar of said puck shaped shackleless lock when said lock is placed in said outer compartment and said locking pin is in its locking position, said pin portion extending into said pin receiving aperture of said stanchion when said stanchion is in its locked position and said locking pin is in its locking position.
  • 2. The door latching device of claim 1 wherein said pin portion and said second opening are cylindrical.
  • 3. The door latching device of claim 2, having a bushing secured to said side wall structure in said inner compartment in axial alignment with said cylindrical second opening, said cylindrical pin portion extending through said bushing.
  • 4. The door latching device of claim 1 having a shelf secured to and extending from the exterior of said sidewall structure in a manner preventing sawing of said locking pin.
US Referenced Citations (14)
Number Name Date Kind
3976318 Krus Aug 1976 A
4095828 East Jun 1978 A
4688409 Oliver et al. Aug 1987 A
4883294 Goodspeed Nov 1989 A
5168258 Radke Dec 1992 A
5946952 Mintchenko Sep 1999 A
6009731 Emmons et al. Jan 2000 A
6058745 Sanchez May 2000 A
6233984 Blehi, III May 2001 B1
6367292 Bunger Apr 2002 B1
6442982 Larsen et al. Sep 2002 B1
6463769 Garner Oct 2002 B1
6494064 Pena Dec 2002 B1
6668601 Reddick Dec 2003 B1