Dual band antenna feed using an embedded waveguide structure

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6700548
  • Patent Number
    6,700,548
  • Date Filed
    Friday, September 27, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 2, 2004
    20 years ago
Abstract
A dual band antenna feed is made with an embedded waveguide structure to enable combining of Ka and Ku band signals without the need for an additional cavity-type filter. The antenna feed includes a Ka and Ku band interface section (22) with two Ka band vertical polarization waveguide sections (31) and (32), and a single Ku band waveguide section (34) which carries both vertical and horizontal polarization Ku band signals. The opposing walls (36-37) of the Ku band waveguide (34) carrying the vertical polarization Ku band signals are transitioned to step down from an input section (40) to successively smaller dimensioned sections (41-44), and then to step back up in successively larger dimensioned sections (45-47) to an output section (48). The two Ka band sections (31-32) are fed into openings in Ku band section.(46), on opposite sides of the opening for the Ku band transition section (45). The output section (48) then provides a combined Ka band vertical and Ku band horizontal and vertical signals. With the Ka-band waveguides (31-32) having ports (56-57) facing the antenna port for radiation on opposite sides of the Ku-band section (45) port, sufficient isolation will be provided between the Ka and Ku band signals without requiring an additional filter. A dielectric insert (FIG. 8A) may be included to improve performance characteristics of the antenna feed.
Description




BACKGROUND




1. Technical Field




The present invention relates to dual band antenna feeds for combining two or more different frequency antenna feeds to connect to a single antenna.




2. Related Art




The dual band antenna feeds are usually designed by connecting two waveguide ports carrying signals over two separate frequency bands to a common waveguide structure which connects to an antenna operating over both bands. As illustrated in block diagram form in

FIG. 1

, a conventional antenna feed receives a first high frequency band of signals at input


2


. The second lower frequency band is received at input


4


. A filter


6


, which may be a low pass, band pass, or band stop filter removes higher frequency components from the low frequency input


4


to prevent interference with signals from the high frequency input


2


. Cavity-type filters are used as filter


6


to connect the waveguide ports to the common waveguide and avoid interference between the two frequency bands. Since a filter is a frequency sensitive device, its cost is high due to the tight tolerance and tuning requirements. A common junction


8


combines the signals from ports


2


and


4


to provide an output for an antenna


10


.




SUMMARY




The present invention provides a dual band antenna feed using an embedded waveguide structure made without requiring an added cavity-type filter. The dual band antenna feed of the present invention is made amenable to die-casting.




The dual band antenna feed in accordance with the present invention, referring to

FIG. 2

, includes a Ka and Ku band interface section


22


. The interface section


22


has signals fed from a orthogonal mode transducer (OMT) and power combiner section


20


. The output of the Ka and Ku band interface section


22


is provided to an antenna section


24


.




The Ka and Ku band interface section


22


, referring to

FIGS. 3A-3D

, includes two Ka band vertical polarization waveguide sections


31


and


32


, and a single Ku band waveguide section


34


which carries both vertical and horizontal polarization Ku band signals. The opposing walls


36


-


37


of the Ku band waveguide


34


carrying the vertical polarization Ku band signals are transitioned to step down from an input section


40


to successively smaller dimensioned sections


41


-


44


, and then to step back up in successively larger dimensioned sections


45


-


47


to an output section


48


. The two Ka band sections


31


-


32


are fed into openings in the combined Ka/Ku band section


46


, on opposite sides of the opening for the Ku band transition section


45


. A slightly larger Ka/Ku band section


47


then transitions from section


46


to the output section


48


. The output section


48


provides a combined Ka band vertical and Ku band horizontal and vertical signals. The output section


48


connects to the separate antenna section (


24


). With the Ka-band waveguides


31


-


32


having ports


56


-


57


facing the antenna port for radiation on opposite sides of the Ku-band section


45


port, sufficient isolation will be provided between the Ka and Ku band signals without requiring an additional filter.




The OMT and power combiner section


20


can have components as shown in

FIGS. 4A-4D

. The OMT


90


is a conventional device with separate Ku band vertical and horizontal polarization inputs


12


and


14


which combines the inputs to produce a single output carrying both the vertical and horizontal polarization Ku band signals. The power combiner has a first input (


16


) for receiving the Ka band vertical polarization signal, and functions to split the input into two separate signals provided in two separate Ka band vertical polarization waveguides


81


-


82


.




The Ka and Ku band interface section


22


can be manufactured from a single block of stock metal. The stock metal block is first cut into two halves, and the Ka band waveguides are machined into the halves. The two halves are then each cut in half to form a total of four quarter sections. The Ku band waveguide is then machined into the quarter sections, and the quarter sections are reassembled to form the completed interface section


22


. The quarter sections can be used to form molds which are then used for die casting to enable rapid manufacturing of multiple interface sections


22


.




In one embodiment, the antenna feed can include a dielectric insert as shown in

FIGS. 8A-8C

. The dielectric insert includes Ka band inserts


110


and


111


which insert into Ka band sections


31


and


32


to improve matching between the Ka band sections


31


and


32


and combined Ka/Ku band section


46


. A notch


114


is further included to improve the match between the Ku band section


45


and combined Ka/Ku band section


46


. The insert has a rectangular portion


106


which transitions into a tapered conical section


108


which extends into the antenna portion


24


of the antenna feed.











DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




Further details of the present invention are explained with the help of the attached drawings in which:





FIGS. 1

show a block diagram of components of a conventional dual-band antenna feed;





FIG. 2

shows a perspective view of exterior and interior portions of an antenna feed assembly in accordance with the present invention;





FIGS. 3A-3D

show cutaway and end views of a Ku and Ka band interface


22


section of the antenna feed of

FIG. 2

;





FIGS. 4A-4D

show cutaway and end views of the OMT and power combiner section


20


of the antenna feed of

FIG. 2

;





FIGS. 5A-5B

show a cutaway and a front view of the antenna section


24


of the antenna feed of

FIG. 2

; and





FIGS. 6A-6B

show a cutaway and a front view of an alternative conical antenna usable as the antenna portion


24


of the antenna feed of

FIG. 2

; and





FIGS. 7A-7E

, illustrate cuts made in stock metal to enable manufacturing of an embodiment of the antenna feed of the present invention.





FIGS. 8A-8C

illustrate a dielectric insert which can be provided as part of the antenna feed of the present invention for improved performance.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION





FIG. 2

shows an antenna feed in accordance with the present invention. The antenna feed has four ports: Ku-band vertical polarization


12


, Ku-band horizontal polarization


14


, Ka-band vertical polarization


16


, and the antenna port


18


. The ports


12


and


14


are indicated as being Ku-band, while the port


16


is indicated as being Ka band for purposes of illustration. Other bands may be used in accordance with the present invention.




The antenna feed of

FIG. 2

can be considered as three separate sections


20


,


22


and


24


. A first section


20


is a combined orthogonal mode transducer (OMT) and power combiner, which is shown in more detail in

FIGS. 4A-4D

. The OMT portion combines signals from the horizontal and vertical polarization Ku band inputs


12


and


14


. The power combiner portion splits the Ka vertical band signal received at port


16


into two separate waveguides. The combined OMT and power combiner


20


is described in more detail with reference to

FIGS. 4A-4D

to follow.




The second section


22


is a Ku and Ka band interface, which is shown in more detail in

FIGS. 3A-3D

. The Ku and Ka band interface


22


is configured to direct the Ku and Ka band signals from the combined OMT and power combiner section


20


to form a single combined signal for launching at an antenna connection port. The Ku and Ka band interface section


22


is described in more detail with reference to

FIGS. 3A-3D

to follow.




The third section


24


is the antenna for connecting to the Ku and Ka band interface section


22


. The antenna section


24


shown in

FIG. 2

is described in more detail with reference to

FIGS. 5A-5B

. An alternative conical shaped antenna may be used in place of antenna


24


, and is described with reference to

FIGS. 6A-6B

to follow.





FIGS. 3A-3D

show cutaway and end views of a Ku and Ka band interface


22


section of the antenna feed of FIG.


2


. The Ku and Ka band interface section


22


includes two rectangular Ka band waveguides


31


-


32


. The two Ka band waveguides


31


-


32


are fed from two similar waveguides in the combined OMT and power combiner


20


, as described in more detail to follow with regard to

FIGS. 4A-4D

.




The Ku and Ka band interface section


22


further includes a single Ku band waveguide


34


for carrying both Ku vertical and horizontal polarization signals. The Ku band waveguide


34


includes a square input section


40


. From the square input section


40


, the opposing waveguide walls


36


-


37


carrying the vertical polarization signals are transitioned in steps


41


-


44


down to a minimum size and then back in steps


45


-


47


to a section


48


. Section


48


is the size of the square input section


40


, and forms the output of the Ku band waveguide


34


. The opposing waveguide walls


38


-


39


carrying the horizontal polarization signals remain the same dimension from the input section


40


through transitions


41


-


47


to the output section


48


.




The Ka band waveguides


31


-


32


are routed from initial points


51


and


52


spaced laterally a slight distance from respective opposing vertical waveguide walls


36


-


37


of the initial section


40


of the Ku band waveguide


34


to final points


54


and


55


spaced a slight distance from respective opposing vertical waveguide walls of the transition section


45


. The Ka band waveguides


31


-


32


are then terminated in openings


56


and


57


in the Ka/Ku band section


46


. By terminating the Ka band waveguides


31


-


32


in openings


56


and


57


in the Ka/Ku band section


46


, the Ka band signals are launched and combined with the Ku band signals in section


46


. The combined Ku and Ka band vertical polarization signals are then transitioned using section


47


to the square waveguide output section


48


. The output section


48


of the Ku and Ka band interface provides a connection to the antenna section


24


.




Since the openings


56


and


57


of the Ka-band waveguides


31


and


32


are facing the antenna port for radiation and provided on opposite sides of the Ku-band port of section


45


, there will be sufficient isolation even without a filter. Thus a filter, such as filter


6


of

FIG. 1

, provided between the Ku band input and the common junction at section


46


with the higher frequency Ka band signals is unnecessary.




The two separated Ka-band waveguides


31


-


32


are used instead of a single waveguide launch into section


46


to excite symmetrical modes. The symmetrical modes enable an antenna beam created from a signal at the output section


48


to be aligned with the physical center of the antenna section


24


.




As shown in

FIGS. 3A-3D

, Ku and Ka band interface section


22


includes six tuning stubs


61


-


66


on the initial section


40


, and another six tuning stubs


71


-


76


on the output section. The tuning stubs help optimize the performance of the Ku and Ka band interface section


22


by minimizing reflections or return losses. Although shown with tuning stubs located in the areas illustrated, it is understood that the tuning stubs might be located at other areas without significantly degrading performance. Likewise, the tuning stubs may be eliminated without a significant degradation in performance, depending on desired performance.





FIGS. 4A-4D

show cutaway and end views of the OMT and power combiner section


20


of the antenna feed of FIG.


2


. As indicated above the OMT and power combiner of

FIGS. 4A-4D

includes a single Ka band input


16


and a power combiner


80


(or power splitter) which transitions the single Ka band input


16


into two Ka band waveguide portions


81


-


82


which are routed around an ortho-mode transducer (OMT)


90


to provide Ka band waveguide outputs


84


-


85


for connection to matching waveguide sections


31


-


32


in the Ka and Ku band transition section


22


. Note that labels to similar items, such as Ka band input


16


, are carried over from

FIG. 2

to FIG.


4


. Labels for items carried forward will likewise be similarly labeled in other subsequent drawings.




The OMT


90


is a conventional device and includes the vertical polarization Ku band input


12


and the horizontal polarization Ku band input


14


. The vertical and horizontal polarization signals from inputs


12


and


14


are combined by the OMT


90


into a single square waveguide section


92


which supports both horizontal and vertical polarizations. The square waveguide section


92


mates with the similar square wave guide section


40


of the Ku and Ka band interface section


22


shown in

FIGS. 3A-3D

.





FIGS. 5A-5B

show a cutaway and a front view of the antenna section


24


of the antenna feed of FIG.


2


. As shown the antenna section


24


includes a square waveguide


94


matching the dimensions of the square waveguide output section


48


of the Ku and Ka band interface section


22


. One port


95


of the square waveguide


94


mates with the Ku and Ka band interface section


22


, while a second port


18


forms the antenna output


18


.





FIGS. 6A-6B

show a cutaway and a front view of an alternative conical antenna usable as the antenna portion


24


of the antenna feed of FIG.


2


. The conical antenna of

FIGS. 6A-6B

provides one alternative to simply using the square waveguide of

FIGS. 5A-5B

, although other antennas may be used depending on desired design and performance requirements. The conical antenna of

FIGS. 6A-6B

will typically provided decreased return losses and a lower VSWR than the square waveguide of

FIGS. 5A-5B

. The antenna section of

FIGS. 6A-6B

includes a square waveguide portion making up a first port


98


for mating with the square waveguide output section


48


of the Ku and Ka band interface section


22


. The antenna section then includes a conical shaped transition section for transitioning from the first square port


98


to a second larger round port


18


which forms the antenna output. A part of the exterior


98


of the antenna portion


24


is also machined to form a conical shape feed horn to improve antenna performance.





FIGS. 7A-7E

illustrate cuts to make in stock metal to enable manufacturing of all of sections


20


,


22


and


24


combined as a single unit. For such manufacturing, a solid stock metal block sized to form the entire assembly of sections


20


,


22


and


24


is used. Assuming that a conical antenna portion


24


is used as illustrated in

FIGS. 6A and 6B

, both the inside and outside portion of the conical horn is initially machined using a lathe. Next, the metal block is cut in half longitudinally along line


100


as illustrated in FIG.


7


A. Next a deep double ridge is cut into each half so that when the halves are reassembled the Ka band waveguides


31


,


32


,


81


and


82


are formed. With the halves reassembled, another longitudinal cut


102


is made to cut the stock metal block into quarters as illustrated in FIG.


7


A. The four quarter sections are then machined with the additional Ku band waveguide and combined Ku and Ka band waveguide portions as shown in

FIGS. 7B-7E

. The four quarter sections of

FIGS. 7B-7E

are then reassembled to form the completed unit.




Once machined, the quarter sections of

FIGS. 7B-7E

can be used for form casts so that molds may be made to allow die casting. Die cast sections can be manufactured at a low cost relative to machined sections. Note that although the entire assembly of sections


20


,


22


and


24


are illustrated as being manufactured together, the individual sections may be manufactured in a similar manner by matching quarter sections, and then assembling the quarter sections to form a completed unit.





FIGS. 8A-8C

illustrate a dielectric insert which can be provided as part of the antenna feed of the present invention for improved performance.

FIG. 8A

shows a perspective view of the dielectric insert.

FIG. 8B

shows a side view of the dielectric insert, and

FIG. 8C

shows a back view. The dielectric insert includes Ka band insert portions


110


and


111


which are designed to extend into the Ka band waveguide portions


31


and


32


at respective ends


54


and


55


. The Ka band insert portions


110


and


111


preferably extend a distance ¼ λg of the Ka band waveguide into sections


31


and


32


to improve matching between the Ka band waveguides


31


and


32


and the combined Ka/Ku band waveguide section


46


.




The dielectric insert further includes a rectangular portion


106


with dimensions preferably matching the Ka/Ku band section


46


. The rectangular section


106


then extends through sections


47


and


48


, transitioning into a conical tapered section


108


. The conical tapered section


108


extends into the antenna portion


24


and preferably terminates at a point prior to the antenna opening


18


. The dielectric insert provides improved antenna performance for either the waveguide antenna shown in

FIGS. 5A and 5B

, or the conical antenna shown in

FIGS. 6A and 6B

.




The dielectric insert in one embodiment further includes a notch


114


cut into the rectangular section


106


for the purpose of matching and reducing the backward wave of a Ka band signal. The notch


114


has a height dimension h and a width dimension w. The height dimension h is preferably ¼ λg at Ka band. This notch produces another backward wave


180


degrees out of phase to cancel the original residue backware wave. This minimizes the Ka band backward wave. The width dimension w is adjusted to a desired value to maximize performance of the antenna feed over the desired bandwidth of operation. The tapered conical portion


108


is tapered to minimize reflections of signals launched from the antenna portion


24


.




The dielectric insert can be manufactured from a desired material such as Nylon or Teflon if a low dielectric constant is desired, or from other materials if a higher dielectric constant is desired. For manufacturing the stock material is simply machined into the shape shown in FIG.


8


A. The dielectric insert is securely attached to the antenna feed by applying an adhesive material to the Ka band inserts


110


and


111


, and to the rectangular portion


106


which contacts the walls of the Ka/Ku band section


46


.




Although the present invention has been described above with particularity, this was merely to teach one of ordinary skill in the art how to make and use the invention. Many additional modifications will fall within the scope of the invention, as that scope is defined by the claims which follow.



Claims
  • 1. An antenna feed comprising:first and second Ka band vertical polarization waveguides; a Ku band horizontal and vertical polarization waveguide, the Ku band waveguide comprising: an input section; an output section; transition sections having opposing waveguide walls for carrying vertical polarization signals from a first dimension at the input section to a smaller dimension than the first dimension at a signal combining transition section, and then back to a larger dimension than the dimension of the signal combining transition section at the output section, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguides are routed into openings in the signal combining transition section.
  • 2. An antenna feed of claim 1, wherein the transition sections further comprise:Ku band step down sections between the input section and the signal combining transition section, each of the Ku band step down sections having opposing waveguide walls for carrying vertical polarization signals with a dimension less than a previous one of the step down sections, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguides are provided laterally spaced from the opposing waveguide walls of the Ku band step down sections for carrying vertical polarization signals.
  • 3. An antenna feed of claim 2, wherein the transition sections further comprise:a Ku band step up section between the Ku band step down sections and the signal combining transition section, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguides are provided laterally spaced from opposing waveguide walls of the Ku band step up section for carrying vertical polarization signals, and wherein the Ku band step up section terminates into an opening in the signal combining transition section between the openings for the first and second Ka band waveguides.
  • 4. The antenna feed of claim 3, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguides are rectangular waveguides, and wherein the input and the output sections of the Ku band waveguide are square waveguide sections.
  • 5. The antenna feed of claim 4, wherein the Ku band waveguide carries Ku band vertical polarization signals between opposing walls having a uniform separation in the transition sections.
  • 6. The antenna feed of claim 1, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguide and the Ku band waveguide are manufactured in a single piece of metal, by a method comprising the steps of:cutting the piece of metal into two halves; machining the first and second Ka band waveguides in the two halves; cutting each of the two halves into two halves to form four quarter sections; machining the Ku band waveguide into the quarter sections; and assembling the quarter sections to form the antenna feed.
  • 7. The antenna feed of claim 1, further comprising a dielectric insert, the dielectric insert comprising:a rectangular body portion having peripheral dimensions substantially matching dimensions of the signal combining transition section, the rectangular body portion being provided in the signal combining transition section; a tapered conical section extending from a first end of the rectangular body portion; and waveguide inserts extending from a second end of the rectangular body portion into the first and second Ka band waveguides, the waveguide inserts having peripheral dimensions substantially matching dimensions of the first and second Ka band waveguides.
  • 8. The antenna feed of claim 7, wherein the dielectric insert further comprises:a notch provided in the rectangular body portion between the waveguide inserts.
  • 9. The antenna feed of claim 8,wherein the waveguide inserts extend ¼ wavelength of the first and second Ka band waveguides from the rectangular body portion, and wherein the notch extends ¼ wavelength of the signal combining transition section into the rectangular body portion.
  • 10. The antenna feed of claim 9, wherein the output section of the antenna feed connects to an antenna, and wherein the tapered conical section of the dielectric insert extends into the antenna.
  • 11. An antenna feed assembly comprising:an OMT and power combiner section comprising: a power combiner having a first terminal forming a Ka band waveguide input section, a second terminal forming a first Ka band waveguide output, and a terminal forming a second Ka band waveguide output; an OMT comprising a Ku band horizontal input, a Ku band vertical input, and a Ku band output for carrying signals provided from both the Ku band horizontal input and the Ku band output; a Ka and Ku band transition section comprising: first and second Ka band vertical polarization waveguides for connecting to the first and second Ka band waveguide outputs of the power combiner; a Ku band horizontal and vertical polarization waveguide, the Ku band waveguide comprising: an input section for connecting to the Ku band output of the OMT; an output section; transition sections having opposing waveguide walls for carrying vertical polarization signals from a first dimension at the input section to a smaller dimension than the first dimension at a signal combining transition section, and then back to a larger dimension than the dimension of the signal combining transition section at the output section, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguides are routed into openings in the signal combining transition section; and an antenna section comprising: an antenna having an input for connecting to the output section of the Ku band waveguide of the Ka and Ku band transition section.
  • 12. An antenna feed of claim 11, wherein the transition sections further comprise:Ku band step down sections between the input section and the signal combining transition section, each of the Ku band step down sections having opposing waveguide walls for carrying vertical polarization signals with a dimension less than a previous one of the step down sections, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguides are provided laterally spaced from the opposing waveguide walls of the Ku band step down sections for carrying vertical polarization signals.
  • 13. An antenna feed of claim 12, wherein the transition sections further comprise:a Ku band step up section between the Ku band step down sections and the signal combining transition section, wherein the first and second Ka band waveguides are provided laterally spaced from opposing waveguide walls of the Ku band step up section for carrying vertical polarization Ku band signals, and wherein the Ku band step up section terminates into an opening in the signal combining transition section between the openings for the first and second Ka band waveguides.
  • 14. The antenna feed of claim 13, further comprising a dielectric insert, the dielectric insert comprising:a rectangular body portion having peripheral dimensions substantially matching dimensions of the signal combining transition section, the rectangular body portion being provided in the signal combining transition section; a tapered conical section extending from a first end of the rectangular body portion, the tapered conical section provided in the antenna section, but not extending beyond the antenna section; waveguide inserts extending from a second end of the rectangular body portion into the first and second Ka band waveguides, the waveguide inserts having peripheral dimensions substantially matching dimensions of the first and second Ka band waveguides, the waveguide inserts extending ¼ wavelength of the first and second Ka band waveguides from the rectangular body portion, wherein the rectangular body portion includes a notch provided between the waveguide inserts, wherein the notch extends ¼ wavelength of the signal combining transition section into the rectangular body portion.
  • 15. An antenna feed comprising:first and second waveguides for carrying a vertical polarization of a first band of signal frequencies; a third waveguide for carrying both horizontal and vertical polarizations of a second band of signal frequencies having a frequency range lower than at least a portion of the first band of signal frequencies, the third waveguide comprising: an input section; an output section; having first opposing waveguide walls for carrying the vertical portion of the second band of signals, and second opposing walls for carrying a horizontal portion of the second band of signals; and transition sections having opposing waveguide walls for carrying vertical polarization signals of the second band of signals from a first dimension at the input section to a smaller dimension than the first dimension at a signal combining transition section, and then back to a larger dimension than the dimension of the signal combining transition section at the output section, wherein the first and second waveguides are routed into openings in the signal combining transition section.
  • 16. An antenna feed of claim 15, wherein the transition sections further comprise:step down sections between the input section and the signal combining transition section, each of the step down sections having opposing waveguide walls for carrying vertical polarization signals of the second band of signals with a dimension less than a previous one of the step down sections, wherein the first and second waveguides are provided laterally spaced from the opposing waveguide walls of the step down sections.
  • 17. An antenna feed of claim 16, wherein the transition sections further comprise:a step up section between the step down sections and the signal combining transition section, wherein the first and second waveguides are provided laterally spaced from opposing waveguide walls of the step up section for carrying vertical polarization signals of the second band of signals, and wherein the step up section terminates into an opening in the signal combining transition section between the openings for the first and second waveguides.
  • 18. The antenna feed of claim 17, further comprising a dielectric insert, the dielectric insert comprising:a rectangular body portion having peripheral dimensions substantially matching dimensions of the signal combining transition section, the rectangular body portion being provided in the signal combining transition section; a tapered conical section extending from a first end of the rectangular body portion; waveguide inserts extending from a second end of the rectangular body portion into the first and second waveguides, the waveguide inserts having peripheral dimensions substantially matching dimensions of the first and second waveguides, the waveguide inserts extending ¼ wavelength of the first and second waveguides from the rectangular body portion, wherein the rectangular body portion includes a notch provided between the waveguide inserts, wherein the notch extends ¼ wavelength of the signal combining transition section into the rectangular body portion.
US Referenced Citations (5)
Number Name Date Kind
4491810 Saad Jan 1985 A
4912436 Alford et al. Mar 1990 A
5859620 Skinner et al. Jan 1999 A
6046702 Curtis et al. Apr 2000 A
20020175875 Verstraeten Nov 2002 A1