Efficient high-productivity cascade impactors

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6453758
  • Patent Number
    6,453,758
  • Date Filed
    Friday, May 5, 2000
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 24, 2002
    23 years ago
Abstract
A compact cascade impactor is formed to classify particles carried in a flow through the impactor. The impactor has collection chambers that are arranged to conserve space and yet provide a large flow passageway. The collection chamber may be tear drop shaped and being nested together. The impactor includes nozzles that are used across a desired flow range without changing the nozzles.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to a particle impactor used for classifying particles according to size for analysis of the particles carried in a gas flow. Sharp particle cutoff is obtained, with compactly arranged impactor/collection cups and flow channels for conserving space, and providing accurate information about the particles.




Various types of impactors have been utilized in the prior art, including devices that use cascading elements for obtaining a classification of particles. Generally a cascade impactor has a plurality of collection stages arranged in series, with each stage having a nozzle or orifice plate with nozzle openings smaller in size than those of the previous stage, and also having an impaction surface for the collection of the particles that are too large to be carried farther in the fluid stream. At the smaller nozzle openings, the velocity of the fluid carrier is higher, and the particles have a higher velocity moving through the nozzle. The higher the flow velocity through the nozzle, the smaller the particles that are collected on the impaction plate. In other words, particles larger than the cut size of an impactor will impinge upon the impaction surface and the rest of the particles will pass with the fluid or airstream to the next stage. The particles that are collected at each stage can be analyzed by weight, or by quantitative chemical analysis. When the particles are to be chemically analyzed, it is desirable to collect the particles in a container or cup so the particles easily can be transported to a lab for analysis.




Another problem that arises with impactors is loss of particles due to the collection of some particles on surfaces other than the particle impactor surface, the collection on surfaces other than the impactor surface results in losses and these are called interstage particle loss. Minimizing such interstage particle loss is a desirable feature of the present invention




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to a compact, high productivity cascade impactor that is easily used, manually or with a robot system and which provides for a broad flow range with quite precise particle cutoff sizes at the various stages. The physical construction makes the impactors of the present invention easily automated, and the usual final filters can be eliminated from the system and a microporous plate filter provided to avoid errors that may arise by contaminants on conventional filters.




The interstage passageways and the nozzles are designed so that they have low particle losses. The impactors thus are acceptable to regulators, such as the Food and Drug Administration and the British and European equivalents.




The impactor preferably has cups that are supported on a tray or frame. The cup tray and all the cups can be removed as a separate unit for quantitative recovery of material from the cups. The cup shape is chosen to reduce the space occupied by the impactor while not compromising the aerodynamic performance of the impactor.




A preferred form of the invention conserves space by utilizing teardrop shaped interstage passageways and collection cups. Other forms include stacked impactors, in order to provide for unique and compact units. The impactors are preferably constructed of inert materials, and are physically robust, and since they are metal and can be grounded they are unaffected by static.




The present invention is made with one set of fixed nozzles to achieve the desired range of particle size cut points, from about 0.5 μm to 10 μm at seven different cut points. At any flow rate, five or more of these are within the range desired for assessing the safety and efficacy of the drug formulation. The impactor is designed to accept a wide range of flows, for example between 30 liters per minute and 100 liters per minute, which is the typical flow range for testing inhalables as described in the United States Pharmacopoeial (USP) or corresponding British, European or Japanese Pharmacopoeials.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a side view of an impactor made according to the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a top plan view thereof with parts broken away;





FIG. 3

is a top plan view thereof with the top cover removed;





FIG. 3A

is a bottom plan view of the impactor with a seal plate removed and showing passageways in a cover through openings in the base and with other parts removed;





FIG. 4

is a sectional view taken as on line


4





4


in

FIG. 3

;





FIG. 5

is a sectional view taken as on line


5





5


in

FIG. 3

;





FIG. 6

is a sectional view taken as on line


6





6


in

FIG. 3

;





FIG. 7

is an enlarged sectional view taken on line


7





7


in

FIG. 3

;





FIG. 8

is an exploded perspective view of a pre-separator that can be used with the present impactor;





FIG. 9

is an enlarged sectional view of the pre-separator shown in

FIG. 8

;





FIG. 10

is a fragmentary side view of a latch in position about to close;





FIG. 11

is an enlarged rear view of a typical cover hinge;





FIG. 12

is a sectional view taken on line


12





12


in

FIG. 11

;





FIG. 13

is a perspective sectional view of a modified form of the invention;





FIG. 14

is a side sectional view of the device of the impactor shown in

FIG. 13

;





FIG. 15

is a plan view of one section of the impactor in

FIG. 14

taken along lines


15





15


in

FIG. 14

;





FIG. 16

is a vertical sectional view of a further modified form of the present invention;





FIG. 17

is a sectional view taken along line


17





17


in

FIG. 16

; and





FIG. 18

is a sectional view taken along line


18





18


in

FIG. 16

; and





FIG. 19

is a side sectional view of a further modified form of the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE ILLUSTRATIVE EMBODIMENTS




A first form of the invention illustrated in

FIGS. 1 through 9

comprises an impactor assembly


10


, which has a housing assembly


12


, with an aerosol inlet


14


of standard size described in USP


24


, Section


601


. The inlet can be a standard USP type inlet tube. A pre-separator


16


is illustrated on the inlet in

FIG. 1

, and it is used to separate out large particles with a standard type impactor arrangement. The pre-separator is also shown in detail in

FIGS. 8 and 9

.




The aerosol that is passed through the impactor


10


is an aerosol generated by a hand-held inhaler


17


or other device that may be a liquid or dry powder drug inhaler, such as those used to control asthma and similar problems. The amount of flow from each charge is small, so the internal volume of the impactor


10


must be kept low. For testing dry powder inhalers, accepted methods call for the total volume of sampled air to be between 2 liters and 4 liters. Therefore, the internal volume of the impactor must be low to achieve proper particle sizing. The internal volume or dead volume is preferably 1 to 2.5 liters. Small dead volume is important for achieving steady state flow during a typical breath volume of 2 to 4 liters. Steady state flow is achieved in about 0.2 seconds. The entire test is completed in 2 to 4 seconds. The flow rate through the impactor will be generated in a selected manner, for example by providing a vacuum pump such as that shown at


20


on an exhaust or flow outlet opening


22


from the impactor housing


12


.




The impactor


10


of the first form of the invention is made to be compact so that it is easily used, portable and does not take up much space, and can be operated in a normal manner. The impactor


10


of the first form of the invention has a lid or cover


24


that is sufficiently thick to include flow passageways on the underside. The lid or cover


24


has the inlet


14


at one and thereof. The lid or cover


24


is hinged along one edge to a base frame


25


that has a number of egg shaped or teardrop shaped openings that receive and support impactor particle collection chambers or cups as will be shown.




As shown in

FIGS. 3

,


4


,


5


and


6


a seal plate


30


is positioned just below the cover of lid


24


and as will be explained, has seals on both sides to seal passageways on the underside of the cover and, on the opposite or bottom side of the seal plate


30


, to seal around lips of each of the impaction chambers or cups to define sealed passageways for forming the flow path. The collection chambers or cups will be individually numbered in this description, but the first cup at the inlet is shown at


34


, and is larger than the rest. Inlet opening


14


in cover


24


opens through an inlet opening


34


that sealingly opens through the seal plate


30


and cover or lid


24


into a chamber or passageway


34


A defined by a first impaction stage cup


34


. Cup


34


fits through an opening in a cup retainer tray or frame


36


. The tray or frame


36


is supported on the top of the base frame


25


. The cup


34


has a peripheral flange


34


B that rests on the tray


36


. The cup also fits in an opening


34


E in the base frame


25


.




The impaction cups are tear drop shaped as shown. The large end


34


E of the first stage cup forms the impactor surface and underlies the inlet opening


32


. The flange


34


B of the cup


34


is sealed with a seal


34


D on the seal plate and extends transversely of the impactor to a vertical passageway


38


that opens through the seal plate


30


to interface or crossover passage


40


formed on the underside of the cover


24


.





FIG. 3A

is a bottom view of the base frame


25


, with the cups and seal plate removed, so the interstage passages on the underside of the cover


24


can be seen. The openings in the cups on the base frame


25


are designated with the cup member followed by the letter “E”. The seals on the periphery of the cups follow the shape of the cup openings in base frame


25


shown in

FIG. 3A

, and as shown in dotted lines in FIG.


3


.




The crossover or interstage passageway


40


leads to a nozzle passageway or opening in seal plate


30


(

FIGS. 3 and 6

) having a nozzle


44


that has openings


44


A of desired size, and desired number as will be shown in Table I, so that particles passing through the nozzle


44


will be accelerated and will discharge into a second stage impactor surface of a cup


46


that underlies the nozzle


44


. The interstage passageway


40


in the cover


24


is sealed with a seal


40


A (FIG.


3


). The nozzle thus is downwardly directed toward an underlying impaction surface. The tear drop shaped cup


46


has a wide end under the nozzle and a narrow opposite end. The cup


46


forms an impactor chamber that defines a passageway


46


A that extends laterally across the seal plate


30


. The flange


46


B of the cup


46


is sealed with seal


46


D, that encircles the cup. The cup is positioned in opening


46


E of the base frame


25


. The small end of the cup


46


aligns with a vertical passageway or port


50


that extends through the seal plate and opens into a crossover or interstage passage


54


in the cover


24


. The opening


46


E in the base frame


25


shown in

FIG. 3

shows the shape of the cup


46


and passageway


46


A.




The crossover or interstage passageway


54


is also tear drop shaped as can be seen in

FIGS. 3 and 3A

, and the large end


54


B of passageway


54


overlies an opening in seal plate


30


which holds a nozzle


56


that has openings


56


A therein. The interstage passageway


54


is sealed with a seal


54


A. The openings


56


A are smaller and greater in number than the opening


44


A in nozzle


44


. The nozzle


56


overlies a third stage impactor surface of a cup


58


. The third stage impactor cup


58


is also tear drop shaped and forms a passageway


58


A (see

FIGS. 3

,


3


A and


5


) that extends laterally back in direction toward the hinge side of the base frame


25


and opens to a vertical passageway


60


through the seal plate


30


that connects to a crossover or interstage passageway


62


in the cover


24


. The seal plate


30


has a seal


58


D that seals on flange


58


B of cup


58


.




The crossover passage


62


also is tear drop shaped, and the large end of the crossover passage


62


opens downwardly through an opening in seal plate


30


which holds a nozzle


64


which has a selected number of openings


64


A. The interstage or crossover passageway


62


is sealed with a seal


62


A.




Nozzle


64


opens to a underlying cup


66


that again is tear drop shaped and provides a fourth stage impactor surface at its larger end. The cup


66


has a flange


66


B sealed with a seal


66


D and forms a passageway


66


A that extends laterally back across the base frame


25


to a vertical port or passageway


68


through seal plate


30


that connects to a crossover or interstage passageway


70


in the cover


24


. Passageway


70


has a larger end that opens through an opening in the seal plate


30


supporting a nozzle


72


with openings


72


A. The interstage passageway


70


is sealed with a bounding seal


70


A.




A cup


74


providing a fifth stage impactor and has an impactor surface at its large end that underlies the nozzle


72


and forms a passageway


74


A that extends laterally back across the base frame


25


to a vertical port or opening


76


through the seal plate


30


. The cup


74


has a peripheral flange


74


B that is sealed with a peripheral seal


74


D. The opening


76


connects to a crossover or interstage passageway


78


in the underside of cover


24


. The opening


74


E in the base frame


25


shown in

FIG. 3A

is for cup


74


and shows the shape of the cups


74


, looking from the bottom up. Cups


66


and


74


are also shown in

FIG. 5

, where the cover and seal plate are broken away.




The crossover passageway


78


is tear drop shaped and opens to a nozzle supporting opening in the seal plate


30


having a nozzle


80


therein, with openings


80


A that provides for a flow downwardly into an underlying sixth stage impactor cup


82


in an opening


82


E in base


25


. The nozzle


80


is retained in place with a rim


80


D. The interstage passageway


78


is sealed with a seal


78


A on seal plate


30


. The cup


82


forms an impaction chamber and passageway


82


A. The cup


82


is tear drop shaped and has an impaction surface at its large end. The cup


82


has a flange


82


B supported on the cup tray, and a peripheral seal


82


D on the seal plate seals around the cup. The cup


82


extends over to an opening or passageway


84


that leads through the seal plate


30


to a crossover interstage passageway


86


in the underside of cover


24


that forms a passageway section for carrying flow.




The crossover or interstage passageway


86


is sealed with a seal


86


A on seal plate


30


. The passageway


86


leads to an opening in seal plate


30


that has a further nozzle


88


that has openings


88


A that open to an underlying cup


90


forming a seventh impaction stage. The cup


90


is tear drop shaped and forms a passageway


90


A that extends laterally to a vertical opening


92


through seal plate


30


that leads to crossover or interstage passageway


94


in the cover


24


. The cup


90


has a flange


90


B that is sealed with a seal


90


D on the seal plate. The flange


90


B is shaped like opening


90


E, and rests on the cup tray


36


, as to all of the cups.




The passageway


94


opens to a final stage micro orifice filter nozzle


96


supported in an opening in the seal plate


30


. The passageway


94


is sealed with a seal


94


A on the seal plate that has openings


96


A and which discharges the fluid into an underlying cup


98


that is tear drop shaped and opens to the fluid flow outlet passage


22


from the impactor.




In

FIG. 7

a detailed enlarged showing of a typical way of mounting a nozzle in the seal plate is illustrated. In this instance, the nozzle


80


is illustrated, and

FIG. 7

is taken along line


7





7


in FIG.


3


.




The seal plate


30


, as shown, and as was explained has “O” ring type seals thereon. The seal


78


A is illustrated on the top side of the seal plate, against the surface of the cover


24


, and a seal


82


D is shown against the flange


82


B of the cup


82


. The seal receiving grooves that are formed in the seal plate


30


are shown at


32


G and


32


H, respectively, and are shaped so that they will permit the seals


78


A and


82


D, which are suitable durometer rubber, to spread slightly as the cover


24


is loaded against the seals and then the seal plate is loaded against the flange


82


B, which in turn is supported by the cup tray


36


. The cup tray


36


is supported on the base


25


.




Each of the nozzle holders is formed with a sealing rim typically shown at


80


D in FIG.


7


and is positively seated in an opening


31


in the seal plate


30


against a shoulder


31


B, so that the distances from the nozzle to the cup such as that shown at


83


are precisely maintained. The nozzles are made so the rim and side walls are machined from a single block of material. The actual nozzle plate having the nozzle opening will be machined on the nozzles with larger openings. When small openings are needed, the nozzles are two pieces assembled together. The bottom wall or plate can be made by other processes to get the small holes needed. Then it can be brazed or otherwise sealingly secured to the lower end of the nozzle holder.




Also, the nozzle sealing along the surface


31


insures that there will be no flow leakage, and with the seals carried by the seal plate, which will expand into the grooves when compressed, positively sealing of each of the passageways, and on the cups along the cup flanges is maintained.




The cover


24


is hinged to the base with a hinge. As shown, a pin that is spring loaded is provided to permit some desired resilient movement perpendicular to the seal plate to provide compression of the seals on the seal plate


30


. As shown in

FIGS. 2

,


4


,


10


,


11


and


12


, the hinging between the cover


24


and the base


25


may be made so that as compression of the seals on the seal plate


30


occurs, the surfaces that engage the seal plate, namely the lips on the cups and the under surface of the cover, remain parallel.




As shown, the base frame


25


has a plurality of upright hinge posts


100


, that are spaced along the hinging edge of the base frame and cover, and the cover has sets of flanges


101


, that fit on the opposite sides of the posts


100


. The flanges


101


carry a pivot pin


101


A that passes through a slot


100


B in each of the upright posts


100


. The pivot pin


101


B can move up and down in the slot


100


B, shown in

FIGS. 11 and 12

, and the pin is urged downwardly with a spring loaded, threaded plunger


102


that is threaded into a bore in the respective hinge posts. The spring loaded plunger is a purchased unit that has an internal spring and a centering point


102


A at the lower end thereof that rides in a groove


101


C in the pin


101


A. This will keep the pin centered and held in the hinge post


100


. It can be seen then that if the pin


101


B is moved so that the flanges


101


on the cover tend to move upwardly, the pin


101


B will have to compress the spring. When the cover is lifted, however, then the spring will be made so that it will urge the pin downwardly toward the lower end of the slot


100


B.




When the cover is closed, and the seals on the seal plate engage the respective surfaces, the design is made so that there will be a load on the spring loaded plunger


102


tending to resist movement of the cover away from the base frame


25


.




In order to have an adequate compression load on the seals, a cam type latch assembly


104


is utilized, and is shown in

FIGS. 2

,


4


and


10


primarily. The latch assembly


104


is supported on ears


104


A that are on the cover member, through first pivot arms


104


B. The hinge members or ears


104


A have pins


104


C that permit the arms


104


B to pivot upwardly and downwardly as shown in dotted lines in

FIG. 4

, where the solid line position shows the cam latch assembly


104


in locked position, and the dotted line position shows it released.




The arms


104


B in turn are pivoted to a latch handle assembly


105


, at each of the arms, with a pin


105


A positioned so that it will permit pivotal movement of the handle


105


. The handle assembly


105


comprises a pair of end arm members


105


B,


105


B as shown in

FIG. 2

that are to the outside of the outer ones of the hinges


104


A and first pivot arms


104


B. The handle arms


105


B are connected with a handle rail


105


C that comprises a hand grip, and the handle arms


105


B are also joined with a latch bar


105


D that is carried so that it will pivot with the arms


105


as they pivot on the pins


105


A. There are four of the pins


105


A, one at each of the first pivot arms


104


B, and the latch bar


105


D, extends along the impactor front edge. As shown in

FIGS. 4 and 10

, the latch bar has a rounded nose portion


105


E.




The base flange


25


carries a plurality of latch hooks


106


, which as shown in

FIGS. 5 and 10

have recesses facing downwardly, and the recesses in the hooks


106


are spaced from a line that passes through the axis of pin


105


A and the axis of pin


104


C when the latch bar is in its latched position in the hooks


106


, as shown in FIG.


4


. This forms an over center latch, and it can be seen that the hooks


106


have a surface receive the nose portion


105


E and extend parallel to the latch bar


105


B.




As shown in

FIG. 4

, when the latch is in position, the load line of the nose portion


105


E is over center so that the unit is held tightly closed, and will not be released accidentally. The amount of compression of the seals can be regulated by the distance between the pivot of the pins


105


A and the center of the nose


105


E on the latch bar.




The handle


105


C can be moved for release in direction as indicated by the arrow


106


D. There is a double pivot about the pins


105


A and the pins


104


C so that the latch handle can be moved all the way up to a released position as shown in dotted lines in FIG.


4


. When the latch is to be closed, it is moved down to a position shown in

FIG. 10

, where the pivot arms


104


B are pivoted downwardly about the pin


104


C, but the handle arms


105


B are still “cocked” in a ready position so that the latch bar


105


D is beneath the hooks


106


, but not engaging them. Then, by moving the handle in direction as indicated by the arrow


106


E in

FIG. 10

, it can be seen that the latch bar


105


D will tilt upwardly, and come under the hook members


106


into the seat that the nose


105


E rests in, and as it does so, it will tend to clamp the cover and the base frame


25


together. It will then go over center as shown in

FIG. 4

in order to latch in place.




As can be seen, there are four of the hooks


106


and four of the hinges


104


A. The latch provides a positive lock. The cover hinge can be a pin hinge that does not move vertically and comprises hinge pins on the cover and bores for the hinge pins on the base frame. The pins on the cover can be fixed to ears and slip into the bores for pivoting when the cover moves laterally so that upon reverse direction movement the pins can be removed from the base for washing. Also, instead of the latch hooks being on the base frame


25


, the hooks can be on the cover, and the pivoting arms and latch bar mounted on the base frame.




As shown in

FIG. 1

, the base frame


25


has support feet


25


F, and at the hinge end, a bracket


108


is provided that can be fixed to the hinge bosses


100


, and the bracket


108


has an upright leg


108


A that is rigidly attached to the lower portion of the leg, and when the unit is turned up on edge, the bracket


108


A will support the impactor assembly


10


with the hinge edge downwardly, and letting it stand in an upright position with the handle extended upwardly.




As can be seen in FIG.


6


and other figures, the bottom surface of the base frame


25


is supported off the supporting surface with the feet legs


25


F. The bottoms of the cups clear the supporting surface. This means that when the cover is opened, after the test has been run, tray


36


can be lifted out of the bottom frame, manually or with a fixture. When the tray is lifted all of the cups can be removed as a unit. The cups may be placed either in a separate container and sealed, or moved to another location for direct analysis.




The ability to lift all of the cups at once makes automation easier, because they can be installed in racks and moved as a unit. The cup tray has locating flanges


37


that act as feet when the tray is removed. The locator flanges


37


lap over the edges of the base to keep the tray


36


in place.




The cups also have outwardly tapered side walls so they can be nested and stacked for storage.




The flow paths are shown essentially in

FIG. 3

, with arrows


99


. The flow path is from the inlet to the outlet. The path is divided into segments, forming impaction stages, by the nozzles.




The nozzles and the orifice sizes are selected to provide at least 5 cut points at all desired flow ranges that are between 0.4 μm and 6.0 μm. In addition, one stage should provide particles between 5 μm and 10 μm. A pressure drop across the impactor of less than 100 inches of water at the maximum flow rate is desired.




The designs for meeting Pharmacopoeial standards of the present invention have fixed nozzles and flow rates between 30 liters per minute and 100 liters per minute. The cut point of particles at the first stage (at the inlet) with a flow rate of 100 liters per minute (a maximum) will provide particles of about 6.0 μm. The cut point of the last stage at a minimum design flow rate of 30 liters per minute would be 0.50 microns.




The nozzles need to be spaced appropriately, and if they are too close to each other or to the wall of the impactor body, they will tend not to collect particles well. The cluster diameter of the nozzle openings and each of the nozzles is no more than two inches at any stage, which influences the overall design.




The flow range of 30 liters per minute (minimum) to 100 liters per minute is a selected range that is in keeping with hand-held inhalers and other equipment with which this device is to be used.




The impactors of the present invention obtain the desired range of cut points without having interchangeable nozzle plates. While the cut points will shift with flow rates, with 7 stages as shown, followed by a micro orifice filter, the desired range of cut points can be obtained from 5 or more of the nozzle plates.




The micro orifice filter is a nozzle that has a large number of small holes, and takes the place of, a conventional or absolute final filter typically used in impactor designs. The reason for designing the impactor with a micro orifice filter is that it is much easier to recover drug material from a micro orifice filter than from a conventional glass fiber or metallic final filter in manual and automated operations. The micro orifice filter is like an impactor stage with thousands of nozzles, each less than about a hundred microns in diameter.




The micro orifice filter is made to efficiently capture particles of about 0.1 μm to 0.2 μm, depending on the flow rate. The smallest particles captured by the micro orifice filter will be approximately ⅓ the size of the smallest particles impacted in the seventh stage of the impactor. Table I that follows shows impactor cut point characteristics obtained with the listed nozzle openings size, for three selected inlet flows in liters per minute. Table I, the “Stage Number” is the orifice plate shown in

FIG. 2

, for example, at each of the respective numbers.




The micro orifice filter is mounted the same as the nozzles on the seal plate


30


and can be removed for cleaning, as can the nozzles. Any particles in cup


98


will also be used in analysis.




The tables that follow are for illustrative purposes.












TABLE I











Impactor Cut-Point Characteristics















Inlet





Nozzle





Cut






Flow




Stage




Diameter




Number of




Point






(LPM)




Number




(mm)




Nozzles




(μm)


















100




1-32




5.49




12




6.00







2-44




3.06




24




3.49







3-56




1.96




32




2.03







4-64




1.18




52




1.18







5-72




0.597




152




0.689







6-80




0.317




400




0.401







7-80




0.205




648




0.233







Micro-





3100







Orifice







Filter






60




1-32




5.49




12




7.77







2-44




3.06




24




4.53







3-56




1.96




32




2.65







4-64




1.18




52




1.55







5-72




0.597




152




0.916







6-80




0.317




400




0.546







7-88




0.205




648




0.333







Micro-





3100







Orifice







Filter






30




1-32




5.49




12




11.0







2-44




3.06




24




6.45







3-56




1.96




32




3.78







4-64




1.18




52




2.23







5-72




0.597




152




1.33







6-80




0.317




400




0.808







7-88




0.205




648




0.506







Micro-





3100







Orifice







Filter














Table II shows the Reynolds numbers and cumulative pressure drop for the respective nozzles at different diameters at the different stages shown in Table I.












TABLE II











Impactor Cut-Point Characteristics



















Cumulative







Inlet Flow




Stage





Δ (inches







(LPM)




Number




Nozzle Re




of water)




















100




1-32




2070




0.11








2-44




1860




0.41








3-56




2180




1.41








4-64




2220




4.24








5-72




1510




9.43








6-80




1080




18.9








7-88




1030




40.3








Micro-





88.8








Orifice








Filter







60




1-32




1240




0.04








2-44




1120




0.15








3-56




1310




0.51








4-64




1330




1.52








5-72




905




3.38








6-80




647




6.75








7-88




618




14.2








Micro-





30.5








Orifice








Filter







30




1-32




622




0.01








2-44




559




0.04








3-56




654




0.13








4-64




666




0.38








5-72




453




0.84








6-80




323




1.68








7-88




309




3.52








Micro-





7.47








Orifice








Filter















It can be seen that the particle size cut points for each of the different stages, when having 7 stages, provides 5 stages which are within the range of 0.5 μm to 5.0 μm and one stage between 5.0 μm and 10.0 μm, with some variations in the ranges when single size, nozzles are used across the full range. The nozzles do not have to be changed to obtain the beneficial results.




With the inlet flow of 30 liters per minute, the cut points are essentially within the ranges desired are shown in stages 3-7, that is impactors


56


,


64


,


72


,


80


and


88


. When the inlet flow is in the nominal range of 60 liters per minute, where actual flow range may be between 50 liters per minute and 70 liters per minute, where many DPI devices will be tested, there are 5 stage cuts between 0.5 μm and 5.0 μm and one stage between 5.0 μm and 10.0 μm (stages 1-6, namely nozzles


32


,


44


,


56


,


64


and


72


). At the high flow of 100 liters per minute, stages 1-6 provide cut points between 0.4 μm and 6.0 μm. While the desired cut point is 0.5 μm, it is important to have one cut below 0.5 μm at the lowest stage, because of the fine particles that some drug companies are developing. 6 microns in stage 1 at 100 liters per minute as shown in Table I is between the 5-10 micron range for one cut point.




The pre-separator


16


is shown in

FIG. 8

in exploded view and in

FIG. 9

in section. The pre-separator


16


includes a base particle collection plate


110


, that has a tube forming an outlet opening


112


leading into the inlet opening


14


of the impactor assembly


10


. An impinger plate


114


is mounted above the collection plate


110


in use. The impinger plate includes an annular nozzle


116


, with a plurality of openings


118


around the periphery of the impinger plate


114


. The openings


118


have tapered inlet ends


118


A, and are made so that there are approximately ten openings


118


around the periphery extending through the nozzle


116


. The nozzle surrounds a cylindrical wall


120


that forms an impinger chamber


122


within the bounds of the wall


120


. The impinger chamber


122


is a small reservoir, and includes a quantity of water that is directly below a tube forming an inlet passage


124


in a cover


123


to which the standard inlet throat is connected. When assembled, the interior chamber


125


around the wall


120


is sealed, and air flowing in through the inlet opening


124


will be directed down onto the surface of the water in the impinger chamber


122


, which will cause the heavier particles to separate into the impinger chamber while the flow and smaller particles will pass through the openings


118


of the nozzle


116


toward the surface


110


A of the collection plate


110


. The cover


123


has an interior surface that tapers toward the inlet passage when inverted, and the under surface of plate


114


also tapers toward opening


118


when the inlet is inverted, so material drains toward the tube forming passage


124


.




The impinger chamber


122


is designed so that most particles larger than approximately 20 microns and no smaller than 10 microns will strike the surface of the water when the inlet flow rate is 100 liters per minute. The remaining particles will then pass with the flow through the openings


118


. The flow will accelerate in the openings so that all particles larger than 10 microns will collect on the surface


110


A below the nozzle. The flow now ideally free of particles larger than 10 microns proceed through the opening


112


into the impactor inlet and to the first stage of the impactor


10


.




The pre-separator can be quite small, for example, approximately 4 inches in diameter and 2.6 inches tall excluding the connecting fittings. The openings


118


have a diameter of 0.322 inches.




Approximately 20 ml of water will be in the impinger chamber


122


, and the distance from the inlet to the surface of the water will be controlled so that air will flow around the top of the wall


120


and through the openings


118


.




In

FIGS. 13

,


14


and


15


, a modified stacked cup design impactor embodying the principles of the present invention is illustrated at


130


. The impactor


130


includes several individual stages, one of which is shown in greater detail in FIG.


15


. The impactor


130


has an inlet shown schematically at


132


that leads to a first impactor housing


134


. The impactor housings are made essentially identical, except that the direction of flow is reversed in the vertically adjacent impactor sections.




The first stage


134


receives the flow from the inlet


132


through a nozzle


133


. The first stage housing


134


has a tear drop shaped chamber


134


A. The large end comprises an impaction surface


134


E, the flow then goes to the narrow end and through a cross or interstage passageway


134


B and then through a nozzle passage


134


C that has a nozzle plate


134


D therein. The nozzle plate


134


D is for the second stage impactor and has large openings. The flow will then pass into a second stage impactor housing


136


, which forms a chamber


136


A that is also tear drop shaped, as can be seen. The chamber


136


A receives the flow and has an impactor surface


136


E. As indicated by the arrows, the flow goes through a cross or interstage passageway


136


B and then into a nozzle passageway


136


C and through a third stage nozzle plate


136


D that has smaller openings in it, than the second stage nozzle plate


134


D as shown in Table I, for example. A different selected size of opening can be selected for different cut points.




The third stage housing


138


includes a third stage chamber


138


A through which the flow will pass. The housing


138


has an impaction surface


138


E on which particle above the cut point will impinge. The flow enters an interstage passage


138


B, and goes into a nozzle passage


138


C and through a fourth stage nozzle plate


138


D which again has smaller orifices or openings than the third stage nozzle plate


136


D.




The flow then passes into a fourth stage housing


140


, having a tear drop shaped chamber


140


A. It is the fourth stage housing


140


that is shown in FIG.


15


. This again is typical of the housings that are shown. The particles above the cut point will impinge on fourth stage impactor surface


140


E. The flow passes through an interstage passage


140


B, and into a nozzle passageway


140


C and through a fifth stage nozzle plate


140


D. The opening size in nozzle plate


140


D is selected to obtain the desired cut point.




The flow through the nozzle plate


140


D enters a fifth stage housing


142


, which has a tear drop shaped chamber


142


A, and an impactor surface


142


E that will serve as a collection plate for particles passing through the nozzle plate


140


D that are above the cut off at this stage. The flow goes through an interstage passage


142


B and into a nozzle passage


142


C. The flow will pass through a further small opening sixth stage nozzle plate


142


D. The flow then goes into a sixth stage housing


144


, and the sixth stage housing


144


has an impaction surface


144


E, in the chamber


144


A. The flow then goes through an interstage passage


144


B, and through a nozzle passage


144


C and then through a seventh stage nozzle


144


D into a chamber


146


A of a seventh stage housing


146


.




The seventh stage has a chamber


146


A, with an impactor surface


146


E. The flow will pass through an interstage passage


146


B, through a nozzle passage


146


C and through a micro orifice filter


146


D having openings thereon to achieve the desired filtering. The flow will impinge on an impactor plate in housing


148


which has a chamber


148


A that receives the flow from the filter


146


D. The flow then will pass out through an outlet opening


148


C. The micro orifice filter


148


D has very fine openings in the nozzle plate as mentioned previously. A microporous filter can have in the range of 3100 openings, as shown in Table I.




The stacked design of

FIGS. 13-15

uses the tear shaped chambers, as shown, to insure smooth flow, with little dead volume and thus little chance of having improper cut points.




A further modified form of the invention is shown in

FIGS. 16

,


17


and


18


. An impactor


170


is a cylindrical form and the impactor stages are mounted one above the other, as is common.




The impactor assembly


170


has an inlet tube


172


that connects to a standard inlet as shown, and flow comes through the nozzle


173


into an inlet or first stage housing


174


. Housing


174


has an impactor chamber


174


A, with a impactor wall or plate portion


174


B aligned with the inlet nozzle


173


. The flow in this form of the invention is shown in

FIG. 16

, and large particles will impinge on the surface of impaction plate


174


B in the center portions of the wall. The impaction plate


174


B is surrounded by an annular nozzle ring


174


C that has a plurality of orifices or openings


174


D arranged around the periphery adjacent an exterior wall


174


E. The flow then will pass through the chamber


174


A and through the orifices or openings


174


D into a second stage housing


176


. The plate


174


B and nozzle ring


174


C are part of the top wall of the housing


176


. The housing


176


is a ring


174


E around plate


174


B that has a shoulder


174


F that receives an end of the housing wall


174


E so the two housings nest together.




Housing


176


has a chamber


176


A into which the flow through the openings


174


D passes. Particles above the cut off size impact on the surface of an annular impaction on wall plate wall


176


B. The particles above the cut point will be collected on this annular surface


176


B, and the flow in the chamber


176


A will then go inwardly toward the center of the chamber


176


A and through a center nozzle section


176


C in the center portions of the wall, which has a pattern of openings or orifices


176


D therein. The orifices


176


D are arranged in a square pattern as can be seen in

FIG. 17

, and the pattern is made of a particular size, generally not more than two inches square, at each of the nozzle plates where the openings are in the center of the impactor plate.




The flow through the nozzle openings


176


D will enter into a third impactor stage housing


178


, that has a chamber


178


A, with an impaction surface on an impaction plate


178


B in the center of the chamber, to receive the flow coming through the nozzle openings


176


D.




It should be noted that the walls forming the impaction surfaces are supported by the outer wall of the underlying housing, that is wall


174


B is supported by


176


E, and wall


176


B is supported by wall


178


E of housing


178


. For convenience the impaction surfaces are described as part of the chambers above the walls. Also, the wall


176


E has a lower flange


178


F that nests on a shoulder


178


E of the outer wall


178


E of housing


178


.




The flow from nozzle


176


C then goes outwardly toward the outer periphery of the housing


178


, and enters an annular nozzle


178


C that has a plurality of openings shown schematically at


178


D. The openings in nozzle


178


C are smaller than previous nozzles, so that the flow through the openings


178


D will pass into a fourth impactor stage housing


180


of the impactor.




The fourth stage


180


has a chamber


180


A, and immediately below the annular nozzle


178


C, there is an annular impaction surface


180


B to receive particles at the cut point for this stage. The flow then goes in toward the center, where there is a center nozzle


180


C that has suitable openings, that are of size such that they do not show up in FIG.


16


. The flow through the nozzle


180


C is through openings such as those shown in FIG.


18


. The openings are smaller but still in the square pattern. A shoulder


180


F of a peripheral wall


180


E supports a lower portion of wall


178


E, which nests in place.




The flow through the nozzle


180


C then passes into a fifth impactor stage housing


182


that has a chamber


182


A, and a wall


182


B defining an impaction surface is below nozzle


180


C to collect particles at the cut point passing through nozzle


180


C. The flow in chamber


182


then moves laterally outwardly to an annular nozzle


182


C that again has smaller openings or orifices than the nozzle


180


C.




The annular nozzle


182


C is arranged as shown in

FIG. 17

, except that the nozzle openings are smaller. Flow through nozzle


182


C enter a sixth housing


184


that has a chamber


184


A. The chamber


184


A has a lower wall


184


B with an annular impaction surface below the annular nozzle


182


C. This is an annular wall


184


B that forms an impaction surface. The flow then goes toward the center of the wall


184


B and through a center nozzle


184


C that has small openings that will provide for the desired cut point as the flow enters into a housing


186


. The housing


186


has a chamber


186


A that receives the flow, and which has a wall


186


B having an impaction surface directly below the nozzle


184


C, to receive the particles at the cut point for that stage of the impactor. The flow then again goes laterally outwardly into an annular nozzle


186


C that has openings leading to a micro filter housing


188


defined by a wall


188


E. The flow comes into a chamber


188


A, and through a micro filter plate


188


B that is filled with small openings as shown in Table I, and then the flow will exit out through an exit passageway


190


. The housing walls


182


E,


184


E, and


186


E have shoulders


182


F,


184


F and


186


F to support the housing above it, respectively. The outlet


190


b is supported on a cover


192


.




The impactor


170


provides the range of cut points as shown in Table I, although the sizes may vary. The annular nozzles and center nozzles alternate between stages.




The impactor


170


can also have the pre-separator assembly on the inlet. The impactor assembly


170


can be disassembled by pulling the telescoping or nesting parts of the housings apart.





FIG. 19

is a schematic cross sectional view of a modified impactor


200


of the present invention. Impactor


200


is made up of curved cylindrical tubes which places all of the collection cups on a single plane, but yet is compact and space saving. A standard inlet


202


leads through a nozzle passage


202


A, and through a first stage nozzle


202


B into an impactor chamber comprising a cup


202


C that will collect particles above a selected cut size. The cup


202


C and the other cups in impactor


200


are removably mounted to permit removal after a test. The cup


202


C is larger than and extends annularly around the tube


202


D, which forms the passage


202


A.




A second impactor stage


204


includes a tube


204


D that has a tube section


204


F that removably supports the outer edges of the cup


202


C, and which surrounds tube section


202


D. The cup


202


C can be threaded directly to the end of a tube section


204


F of tube


204


that forms a passageway to the next impactor stage, or otherwise sealingly, releasably connected in place.




The section


204


F forms a passage


204


A for carrying flow to a nozzle


204


B and into a cup


204


C. The tube


204


D reduces in diameter in a downstream from the junction region


204


H where tube


202


intersects tube


204


D. A tube section


204


G is of smaller diameter and is directed downwardly. The end of tube section


204


G supports nozzle


204


B. The cup


204


C has an impactor surface that receives and collects the particles from the flow at the selected cut point, and is of large enough in diameter to provide a passage around the reduced size section


204


G of tube


204


D.




The edge of cup


204


C is removably connected to the end of a tube


206


D of an impactor stage


206


. The tube section


204


G intersects tube


206


D at a junction


206


H and reduces in size downstream from junction


206


H at tube section


206


G. The tube


206


D forms a curved arched passage


206


A that directs the flow through tube section


206


G and through a nozzle


206


B supported in tube section


206


G and into a cup


206


C. Cup


206


C has an impaction surface for receiving particles at that cut point. The cup


206


C surrounds and is spaced from tube section


206


G and joins larger tube


208


D and is supported on an end of a tube


208


D is part of a fourth impaction stage tube


208


. Tube


208


D surrounds the tube section


206


G, extends upwardly and curves into a “U” shape and carries the flow around the outer part of the tube


206


D through a passageway


208


A. A nozzle


208


B is in a part of passageway


208


A formed by a reduced size tube section


208


G and into a cup


208


C. The cup


208


C forms an impaction surface for receiving the particles of size above the cut point, and is large enough to provide a passage around the tube section


208


G and into a surrounding tube


210


D of a further impactor stage


210


. The cup


208


C is removably sealingly mounted on the end of tube section


208


D. The tube section passes through tube


210


at a junction


210


H.




The tube


210


D has an interior passage


210


A that directs flow in an arched path. The tube


210


reduces in size in a section


210


G that supports a nozzle


210


B through which the flow passes into a cup


210


C that forms an impaction surface and which is of large enough diameter to join a curved tube


212


D of an impaction stage


212


. The tube


210


D intersects tube


212


D at a junction


212


H. The tube


212


D has an internal passage


212


A, that directs flow through a nozzle


212


B in reduced diameter tube section


212


G, and into a cup


212


C, which forms an impaction surface for receiving particles above the cut point. Cup


212


C is removably mounted on an end of a tube section


214


D and surrounds tube section


212


G.




The flow then goes from the cup


212


C into a tube


214


D of an impaction stage


214


. Tube


214


D has an internal passage


214


A and a reduced size section


214


G holding a nozzle


214


B leading to a cup


214


C. Cup


214


C has an impaction surface for collecting particles. The tube


214


D is formed as before. The tube section


212


G passes into the tube


214


D at a junction


214


H. The cup


214


C is supported on an outlet tube


216


that goes to a microporous filter and vacuum pump. The tube section


214


G passes into tube


216


at a junction


214


H. These tubes for the impaction stages


202


-


214


, are supported on a support frame


218


, of suitable design, and form the necessary impaction surface by having nozzles of the appropriate size for carrying the flows. The tubes


204


D-


214


D all taper smoothly from large diameter sections to the small diameter sections. This causes a variation in flow velocity from each cup to the downstream filter.




All forms of the invention provide for compact arrangements, including the stacked units. The form of the invention shown in

FIG. 19

has the common feature of placing the cups all on the single plane so that the cups can easily be put into trays or other supports when they are removed from the respective tubes. The use of the curved, tapered tubes for forming the impaction flow paths permits the cups to not only be in a straight line as shown in

FIG. 19

, but arranged around a central axis if desired.




All forms of the invention can be used with nozzles having openings as shown in Table I with the approximate pressure drops shown in Table II for the various stages. The accuracy is very high, even with hand-held inhalers where the hand-held generation of the aerosol or active ingredient carrying flow can vary substantially. It should also be noted that predose inhalers can be utilized with the present invention, where a measured amount of a dry powdery agent will be picked up in the flow, such as the breath flow, and this type of material can also be analyzed with the present impactors.




The interstage and other losses of particles are 5% or below with the present invention, which meets established requirements. The impactor provides a sharp cut of particles at each stage of the desired particle classification is thus obtained.




Although the present invention has been described with reference to preferred embodiments, workers skilled in the art will recognize that changes may be made in form and detail without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.



Claims
  • 1. An impactor for classifying particles according to size comprising a housing, a flow passageway through said housing, said flow passageway being divided into a plurality of individual passageway sections, a separate nozzle in each passageway section for carrying a flow between individual passageway sections, a particle collection chamber aligned with each nozzle and having an impaction surface to receive flow from the respective nozzle, each particle collection chamber having an output end joining other passageway sections of said flow passageway, said particle collection chamber having a large area portion immediately below its aligned nozzle, and having side walls tapering to a narrow portion at the output end of said collection chamber.
  • 2. The impactor of claim 1, wherein said collection chamber has a wall formed along a radius at the large end and a wall having a substantially smaller radius at the output end, and the side walls being straight wall sections joining the radiused walls at the opposite ends.
  • 3. The impactor of claim 1, wherein each nozzle comprises a nozzle cup having a rim at an open inlet end, a support plate for the nozzle cups, said support plate having an opening for receiving a rim of the respective nozzle cup, and a support rim formed in the opening for engaging the rim on the respective nozzle cup to support it in a known position.
  • 4. The impactor of claim 3, wherein said opening has a surface that provides a seal around a periphery of the respective nozzle cup.
  • 5. The impactor of claim 3, wherein each nozzle cup overlies a collection chamber and has a nozzle wall positioned at a selected distance from the impaction surface of the collection chamber.
  • 6. The impactor of claim 1, wherein said collection chamber comprises a removable cup, said removable cup having a peripheral flange, and a cup tray for supporting said removable cup, said cup tray being removably mounted in said impactor.
  • 7. The impactor of claim 1, wherein there are a plurality of collection chambers, each of said collection chambers having a wide end for receiving flow from a nozzle, and a narrow end joining other portions of the flow passageway which form flow path sections, said collection chambers being supported substantially on a plane, the narrow ends of the chambers overlapping, with the narrow end of each chamber being adjacent the wide end of an adjacent chamber so that the collection chambers nest together.
  • 8. The impactor of claim 7, wherein said collection chambers are supported in a base portion of the housing, a cover portion of the housing hingedly connected to the base portion along one edge thereof, a portion of each flow path section between individual collection chambers being defined in said cover portion.
  • 9. The impactor of claim 8, wherein the portions of the flow path section defined in the cover extend in a transverse direction to a line extending from the wide ends to the narrow ends of the collection chambers.
  • 10. The impactor of claim 9, and a seal plate between the base portion and the cover portion, said seal plate having sealing members surrounding the collection chambers on one side of the seal plate, and second sealing members surrounding the portions of the flow path sections defined in the cover portion on the other side of the seal plate.
  • 11. The impactor of claim 10 and a latch for securing the base portion and the cover portion together, with the seal plate positioned between the base portion and cover portion, said seals on seal plate compressing as the latch is secured.
  • 12. The impactor of claim 11, wherein the hinge connection between the base portion and the cover portion includes a slot on the base portion, the hinge comprising a hinge pin on the cover portion, a spring loading the hinge pin on the cover portion in a first direction in the slot, and the hinge pin moving in a second direction against the force of said spring when the latch is secured and the seal members are compressed.
  • 13. An impactor comprising a housing, said housing having an inlet and an outlet, and a flow path through the housing, said flow path being divided into at least two flow segments, a nozzle between the flow segments, a collection chamber for receiving flow from the nozzle and collecting particles that are carried in the flow, the improvement comprising a pre-separator at the inlet of the housing, said pre-separator including a chamber having an inlet tube and an outlet tube, and having tapered internal surfaces that taper toward one of the tubes for permitting draining of material on the interior of the pre-separator.
  • 14. The impactor of claim 13, wherein said pre-separator includes a collection tank aligned with the inlet opening such that flow impinges on liquid in said collection tank, and before passing to the outlet.
  • 15. The pre-separator of claim 14 and an annular nozzle plate positioned to receive flow from the tank, said flow passing through said nozzle plate to the outlet.
  • 16. The impactor of claim 13, wherein said pre-separator has an inlet adapted to receive aerosols generated by a hand-held inhaler.
  • 17. An impactor for classifying particles according to size, comprising a support, a flow passage defined relative to said support, said flow passage being divided into a plurality of individual passageway sections, a separate nozzle in each passageway section for carrying the flow between the passageway sections, a particle collection chamber aligned with each nozzle and having an impaction surface to receive flow from the respective nozzle, each chamber having an output portion joining other parts of a downstream flow passage, the particle collection chambers having support walls lying substantially on a common plane, wherein the passageway sections comprise tubes that taper in size between each impaction chamber and a next subsequent impaction chamber in the flow path.
  • 18. The impactor of claim 17, wherein said tubes are formed in a generally U-shaped, and the taper of the tubes extends to a smaller diameter section that carries a nozzle for the next subsequent section, the nozzles facing in a downward direction.
  • 19. An impactor for classifying particles according to size comprising a housing, a flow passageway through said housing, said flow passageway being divided into a plurality of individual passageway sections, a separate nozzle in each passageway section for carrying a flow between individual passageway sections, a particle collection chamber aligned with each nozzle and having an impaction surface to receive flow from the respective nozzle at an inlet end formed with an upright wall portion having a large radius to form the inlet end and carrying flow to a wall portion formed in a smaller radius at an output end, the collection chambers being positioned side-by-side and so the large radius inlet end of one collection chamber overlaps and is adjacent to a small radius outlet end of a next adjacent collection chamber.
  • 20. A cup for use in a particle classification impactor having flow carrying nozzles, the cup having a bottom wall forming an impaction surface, and having a peripheral wall forming an open top chamber, the cups have a wide end for receiving flow from a flow nozzle, and a narrow end and forming a flow path through the cup from the wide end to the narrow end, said cups thereby having generally a tear drop shaped open top.
  • 21. The cup of claim 20, wherein the cup has a generally planar peripheral flange extending outwardly from the peripheral wall.
  • 22. An impactor for classifying particles according to size comprising a housing, a flow passageway through said housing, the flow passageway being divided into a plurality of individual passageways sections, a plurality of particle collection cups, one aligned with each nozzle, the cups forming portions of the flow passageway sections, and each of the cups having a peripheral support flange around the periphery thereof, said housing including a base portion and an openable cover, and a tray positioned between the base portion and the cover, said tray having openings corresponding to the shape of the cups, and the peripheral flange being supported on the tray such that a plurality of the cups can be moved by lifting the tray when the cover is opened.
  • 23. The impactor of claim 22, wherein said cover is hingedly mounted to said base portion, the cups having cup portions extending through the tray, and said base portion having openings for receiving the cup portions extending through the tray, said cover being closeable over the cups and tray for forming the flow passageways.
  • 24. The impactor of claim 23, wherein said cover has recesses extending between cups for forming cover portions of the flow passageway sections, and seal members surrounding the cups for sealing the flow passageway sections.
  • 25. The impactor of claim 23, wherein said cups have peripheral flanges that are supported on said tray around surfaces of the tray forming openings for the cup.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

This application claims priority on provisional application Ser. No. 60/138,742, filed Jun. 11, 1999 for COMPACT, HIGH-PRODUCTIVITY CASCADE IMPACTORS.

US Referenced Citations (23)
Number Name Date Kind
2538116 May Jan 1951 A
3127763 Lippmann Apr 1964 A
3518815 McFarland et al. Jul 1970 A
3693457 Pilat Sep 1972 A
4133202 Marple Jan 1979 A
4255172 Smith Mar 1981 A
4274846 Smith Jun 1981 A
4321822 Marple et al. Mar 1982 A
4391151 Nelson et al. Jul 1983 A
4400982 Bell Aug 1983 A
4452068 Loo Jun 1984 A
4463595 Yeh et al. Aug 1984 A
4523990 Duyckinck Jun 1985 A
4570494 Dunn et al. Feb 1986 A
4640140 Burghoffer et al. Feb 1987 A
4725294 Berger Feb 1988 A
4764186 Langer Aug 1988 A
4827779 Marple et al. May 1989 A
4972957 Liu et al. Nov 1990 A
5201231 Smith Apr 1993 A
5343767 Marple et al. Sep 1994 A
5437198 John Aug 1995 A
5693895 Baxter Dec 1997 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (7)
Number Date Country
2832238 Feb 1979 DE
3110871 Oct 1982 DE
3545120 Jul 1986 DE
1354261 May 1974 GB
2179273 Mar 1987 GB
2 179 273 Mar 1987 GB
560760 Jun 1981 JP
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/138742 Jun 1999 US