Elastomeric connector assembly

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6685487
  • Patent Number
    6,685,487
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, June 12, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, February 3, 2004
    20 years ago
Abstract
An elastomeric connector assembly for electrically coupling electronic components comprises a first contact member extending from a surface of a first electronic component in a generally vertical plane for providing electrical connection to the first electronic component and a second contact member extending from a surface of a second electronic component in a generally vertical plane for providing electrical connection to the second electronic component. An elastomeric connector is disposed between the first contact member and the second contact member in a generally horizontal plane. The elastomeric connector couples the first contact member and the second contact member for providing an electrical connection between the first and second electronic components.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates generally to elastomeric connector assemblies used for electrically connecting components such as printed circuit boards (PCBs), liquid crystal displays (LCDs), and the like, in an electronic device, and more particularly, to an elastomeric connector assembly having an elastomeric connector mounted in a generally horizontal plane between two or more contact members extending from the electronic components in a substantially vertical plane.




Traditional elastomeric connector assemblies consist of an elastomeric connector mounted in a vertical orientation between contacts horizontally disposed on the surface of the electronic components being interconnected. These contacts are then forced together, compressing the elastomeric connector to provide electrical connection of the components.

FIGS. 1 through 3

illustrate the basic construction of a traditional elastomeric connector assembly


100


. The elastomeric connector assembly


100


consists of an elastomeric connector


102


compressed between electronic components, in this case, a printed circuit board (PCB)


104


and a liquid crystal display (LCD)


106


. The elastomeric connector


102


is fabricated of a resilient, elastomeric material having layered connector elements


108


extending therethrough for electrically coupling contacts


110


formed on the surfaces of electronic components


104


and


106


. In this manner, electrical connection of the electronic components


104


and


106


is achieved.




Compression of the elastomeric connector


102


is required to ensure a low contact resistivity between the layered connector elements


108


of the elastomeric connector


102


and the contacts


110


. As shown in

FIG. 2

, the electronic components


104


and


106


exert a force (F


1


) on the elastomeric connector


102


in a vertical plane (i.e., in a plane normal to the surfaces of the components), compressing the elastomeric material. In turn, the elastomeric connector


102


applies an opposite force (F


2


) against the electronic components


104


and


106


, promoting separation and/or bending of the components in the vertical plane (i.e., in a plane normal to the surfaces of the electronic components


104


and


106


). However, if the force (F


2


) exerted on the contacts


110


is reduced, the elastomeric material relaxes, increasing contact resistivity so that a reliable electrical connection may no longer be available. This reduction in force (F


2


) can be caused by stretch, i.e., relaxation over time of plastic materials used in the supporting structure


112


applying the force (F


1


), or by shifting of the electronic components


104


and


106


and supporting structure


112


due to mechanical shock.




Compression of the elastomeric connector


102


also requires the use of additional supporting structure, e.g., a metal support frame


114


, for clamping the electronic components


104


and


106


together. Use of the additional supporting structure increases manufacturing costs. This supporting structure increases the height or thickness (H) of the assembly, and thus increases the minimum thickness of the electronic device in which the elastomeric connector assembly


100


is used. As electronic consumer devices become smaller, increased thicknesses of assemblies within devices is not desirable.




Moreover, electronic devices are usually assembled vertically for convenience of manufacturing, generating a level of error requiring the use of greater tolerances in the vertical plane. Consequently, shifts in the vertical alignment of electronic components are common. As shown in

FIG. 3

, such problems are exacerbated by the use of traditional elastomeric connector assemblies


100


. Compression of the elastomeric connector


102


applies a force (F


2


) on supporting structure


112


for the electronic components


104


and


106


that acts in a direction parallel to the tolerance stack up (represented by maximum vertical tolerance T


V


). As a result, stringent vertical tolerances are required for maintaining adequate contact between the elastomeric connector


102


and contacts


110


, thereby increasing the cost of manufacturing the electronic device in which the elastomeric connector assembly


100


is used.




Consequently, it is desirable to provide an elastomeric connector assembly that does not require the elastomeric connector to be compressed in the vertical plane of the components it interconnects (i.e., in a plane normal to the surfaces of the electronic components) to achieve good electrical connection.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention is directed to an elastomeric connector assembly suitable for electrically coupling components such as printed circuit boards (PCBs), liquid crystal displays (LCDs), and the like, in an electronic device. The elastomeric connector assembly comprises an elastomeric connector mounted in a generally horizontal plane (i.e., a plane generally parallel to the surface of one or both of the electronic components) between two or more contact members extending from the electronic components in a substantially vertical plane (i.e., a plane generally normal to the surfaces of the electrical components).




According to a specific embodiment, the present invention provides an elastomeric connector assembly including a first contact member extending from a surface of a first electronic component for providing electrical connection to the first electronic component and a second contact member extending from a surface of a second electronic component for providing electrical connection to the second electronic component. An elastomeric connector is disposed between the first contact member and the second contact member in a generally horizontal plane (i.e., a plane generally parallel to the surface of one or both of the first and second electronic components). The elastomeric connector couples the first contact member and the second contact member for providing an electrical connection between the first and second electronic components.




According to a second specific embodiment, the present invention provides an electronic device employing an elastomeric connector assembly. The electronic device includes a first electronic component and a second electronic component electrically interconnected by the elastomeric connector assembly. The elastomeric connector assembly includes a first contact member extending from a surface of the first electronic component for providing electrical connection to the first electronic component and a second contact member extending from a surface of the second electronic component for providing electrical connection to the second electronic component. An elastomeric connector is disposed between the first contact member and the second contact member a generally horizontal plane (i.e., a plane generally parallel to the surface of one or both of the first and second electronic components) for electrically coupling the first contact member and the second contact member.











It is to be understood that both the foregoing general description and the following detailed description are exemplary and explanatory only and are not necessarily restrictive of the invention claimed. The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of the specification, illustrate embodiments of the invention and together with the general description, serve to explain the principles of the invention.




BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is an isometric view illustrating an elastomeric connector assembly in accordance with the prior art;





FIG. 2

is a cross-sectional side elevation view of the elastomeric connector assembly shown in

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 3

is a cross-sectional side elevation view of the elastomeric connector assembly shown in

FIG. 1

, wherein the elastomeric connector assembly is assembled into an electronic device;





FIG. 4

is an isometric view illustrating an elastomeric connector assembly in accordance with an exemplary embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 5

is a cross-sectional side elevation view of the elastomeric connector assembly shown in

FIG. 4

;





FIG. 6

is a cross-sectional side elevation view of the elastomeric connector assembly shown in

FIG. 4

, wherein the elastomeric connector assembly is assembled into an electronic device; and





FIG. 7

is a cross-sectional side elevation view of a liquid crystal display (LCD) assembly employing an elastomeric connector assembly in accordance with the present invention, wherein at least one contact member of the elastomeric assembly comprises a flexible circuit.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF SPECIFIC EMBODIMENTS




Reference will now be made in detail to the presently preferred embodiments of the invention, examples of which are illustrated in the accompanying drawings.





FIGS. 4 and 5

illustrate an exemplary elastomeric connector assembly


200


in accordance with a specific embodiment of the present invention. The elastomeric connector assembly


200


is suitable for electrically interconnecting two electronic components


202


and


204


having surfaces


206


and


208


held in a generally parallel, spaced apart relationship. As shown in

FIGS. 4 and 5

, the elastomeric connector assembly


200


includes a first contact member


210


coupled to the first electronic component


202


and a second contact member


212


coupled to the second electronic component


204


. In the embodiment illustrated, contact members


210


and


212


comprise rigid, generally L-shaped members including a base portion


214


attached to the surface


206


or


208


of the electronic component


202


or


204


and a contact support portion


216


extending from the surface


206


or


208


in a generally vertical plane (i.e., a plane generally normal or perpendicular to one or both of the surfaces


206


and


208


). However, it is contemplated that the contact members


210


and


212


may have other cross-sectional shapes (e.g., square, triangular, etc.) or may include bracing for providing the contact members


210


and


212


with additional structural rigidity.




An elastomeric connector


218


is disposed between the first contact member


210


and the second contact member


212


in a generally horizontal plane (i.e., in a plane generally parallel to one or both of the surfaces


206


and


208


of the first and second electronic components


202


and


204


). The elastomeric connector


218


electrically couples the first contact member


210


and the second contact member


212


for providing an electrical connection between the first and second electronic components


202


and


204


. Preferably, contact members


210


and


212


may be allowed to move or float in the vertical plane relative to one another, and/or relative to elastomeric connector


218


while maintaining adequate electrical connection with the elastomeric connector


218


.




In the exemplary embodiment illustrated in

FIG. 4

, the first and second contact members


210


and


212


each comprise a plurality of generally parallel contact elements


220


formed of a suitable material such as copper, gold, silver, or the like, on the surface of the contact support portion


216


. These contact elements


220


are soldered or bonded to the electronic component


202


or


204


to provide electrical connection to the electronic component


202


or


204


. The elastomeric connector


218


is formed of a resilient material having a plurality of connector elements


222


extending therethrough. In embodiments of the invention, the connector elements


222


comprise layers or paths formed of a suitable conductive material such as copper, gold, silver, aluminum, carbon impregnated silicone, silver impregnated silicone, or the like, laminated within an electrically insulating material such as silicone, vinyl, rubber, or the like. Preferably, the contact elements


220


on each contact member


210


and


212


are positioned to be electrically connected by one or more connector elements


222


completing an electrical circuit between contact elements


220


for electrically coupling the first contact member


210


and the second contact member


212


.




Elastomeric connector


218


may be compressed between the first contact member


210


and the second contact member


212


to provide a low contact resistivity between the connector elements


222


of the elastomeric connector


218


and the contact elements


220


of contact members


210


and


212


. As shown in

FIG. 5

, the electronic components


202


and


204


exert a force (F


1


) on the elastomeric connector


218


in a generally horizontal plane (i.e., in a plane generally parallel to one or both surfaces


206


and


208


of the electronic components


202


and


204


) through the contact members


210


and


212


, compressing the elastomeric material. The elastomeric connector


218


applies an opposite force (F


2


) against the contact members


210


and


212


, providing a positive contact between the connector elements


222


and the contact elements


220


. By mounting and compressing the elastomeric connector


218


in the horizontal plane, it becomes possible to reduce or eliminate forces applied to the elastomeric connector


218


in the vertical plane, or, alternately, to reduce the cross-sectional area over which such forces are applied. In this manner, deflection in the electronic components


202


and


204


is reduced or eliminated, minimizing the possibility of failure of the elastomeric connector assembly


200


due to bending, fatigue, or the like.




Elastomeric connector assemblies


200


in accordance with the present invention may be used to electrically interconnect a variety of electronic components


202


and


204


. For example, in one application, the elastomeric connector assembly


200


may be used in display assemblies employing a liquid crystal display (LCD), an electroflorescent display, a piezoelectric display, or the like. In this application, the first electronic component


202


comprises a printed circuit board (PCB), while the, second electronic component


204


comprises the display. In a second application, the elastomeric connector assembly


200


may be used to interconnect nested printed circuit boards (PCBs). In this application, the first and second electronic components


202


and


204


each comprise printed circuit boards (PCBs). In yet another application, the elastomeric connector assembly


200


may be utilized to couple a chip carrier to a printed circuit board (PCB). In this application, the first electronic component


202


comprises a printed circuit board (PCB) and the second electronic component


204


comprises the chip carrier. Based on the present disclosure, it is contemplated that one of skill in the art may devise other applications employing elastomeric connector assemblies


200


in accordance with the present invention. Accordingly, use of the elastomeric connector assemblies


200


of the present invention in such applications would not depart from the scope and spirit of the present invention.




Referring now to

FIG. 6

, a hand-held electronic device


230


employing an elastomeric connector assembly


200


in accordance with the present invention is described. The electronic device


230


comprises a small, hand-held consumer device such as a mobile telephone handset, a cellular telephone, a hand-held computer, or the like, employing a liquid crystal display (LCD) assembly


232


for displaying information to a user of the device. In such embodiments, the elastomeric connector assembly


200


may be utilized in the liquid crystal display (LCD) assembly


232


for electrically interconnecting electronic components


202


and


204


comprising a printed circuit board (PCB) and a liquid crystal display (LCD), respectively. However, it is also contemplated that elastomeric connector assemblies


200


in accordance with the present invention may also be used to electrically interconnect other components of the electronic device


230


(e.g., nested printed circuit boards (PCBs), chip carriers, or the like) without departing from the scope and spirit of the present invention.




As shown in

FIG. 6

, the liquid crystal display (LCD) assembly


232


is enclosed in a housing


234


that provides horizontal alignment of the electronic components


202


and


204


for controlling compression of the elastomeric connector


218


. Thus, rather than being sandwiched in a vertical plane by supporting structure as in prior art elastomeric connector assemblies, the elastomeric connector


218


of the present invention is compressed in the horizontal plane between generally vertical contact members


210


and


212


. Consequently, the contact members


210


and


212


may be allowed to move or float in the vertical plane relative to one another, and/or relative to the elastomeric connector


218


, while maintaining adequate electrical connection with the elastomeric connector


218


. Thus, the electronic components


202


and


204


may also be allowed to move relative to one another in the vertical plane, for example, due to manufacturing variations in the housing


234


, or the like. In this manner, the component tolerances in the vertical plane (represented by maximum vertical tolerance T


V


) may be relaxed since stringent vertical tolerances are no longer required to maintain adequate contact between the elastomeric connector


218


and the contact members


210


and


212


. In this manner, components of the electronic device


230


may be manufactured at a lower cost. Additionally, where the electronic device


230


is assembled in the vertical plane, alignment of the electronic components


202


and


204


in the horizontal plane is more easily controlled since horizontal alignment is less dependent on proper component assembly. Thus, alignment of electronic components


202


and


204


may be more readily achieved through efficient design of the housing


234


.




Comparing

FIGS. 3 and 6

, it can be seen that elastomeric connector assemblies


200


in accordance with the present invention also require less supporting structure than do conventional elastomeric connector assemblies


100


. As shown in

FIG. 3

, compression of the elastomeric connector


102


of conventional elastomeric connector assemblies


100


requires the use of supporting structure


112


for clamping electronic components


104


and


106


together. Typically, this supporting structure


112


consists of a metal support frame


114


secured via a plurality of screws or snaps


116


. Because the elastomeric connector assembly


200


of the present invention does not require compression in the vertical plane, metal support frame


114


can be eliminated, reducing the height (H) of the assembly


232


. In this manner, the size and weight of the electronic device


230


can be reduced. Further, because internal supporting structure


112


is eliminated or simplified, the cost of the electronic device


230


may be reduced and the time required for its assembly shortened. Moreover, it becomes possible to employ the elastomeric connector assembly


200


in applications where prior art elastomeric connector assemblies


100


could not be used, for example, because supporting structure


112


could not be provided that furnished adequate compression of the elastomeric connector


102


in the vertical plane.





FIG. 7

depicts an exemplary elastomeric connector assembly


200


in accordance with a second exemplary embodiment of the present invention. In this embodiment, the elastomeric connector


218


is mounted in a horizontal plane between first and second contact members


210


and


212


. The first contact member


210


is comprised of a rigid, L-shaped member bonded or soldered to the first electronic component


202


, which in the embodiment shown, comprises a printed circuit board (PCB). However, the second contact member


212


comprises a flexible circuit or ribbon cable


242


coupled to the second electronic component


204


, a liquid crystal display (LCD). A support


244


is provided adjacent to the first contact member


212


. The support


244


provides shape to the second contact member


212


and supports the contact member


212


in a generally vertical plane so that the elastomeric connector


218


may be compressed between the second contact member


212


and the first contact member


210


. Like the elastomeric connector assemblies


200


of the embodiments illustrated in

FIGS. 4 through 6

, the elastomeric connector assembly


200


shown in

FIG. 7

may be utilized in an electronic device, such as the electronic device


230


shown in

FIG. 6

, for electrically interconnecting components of the device.




Based on the foregoing description, it will be appreciated by those of skill in the art that the elastomeric connector assemblies


200


of the present invention may be mounted within an electronic device


230


in any orientation. Thus, as utilized herein, the terms “horizontal” and “horizontal plane” refers to a plane that is generally parallel to one or both of surfaces


206


and


208


while the terms “vertical” and “vertical plane” refers to a plane that is generally perpendicular or normal to one or both of the surfaces


206


and


208


.




It is believed that the present invention and many of its attendant advantages will be understood by the foregoing description, and it will be apparent that various changes may be made in the form, construction and arrangement of the components thereof without departing from the scope and spirit of the invention or without sacrificing all of its material advantages. The form herein before described being merely an explanatory embodiment thereof, it is the intention of the following claims to encompass and include such changes.



Claims
  • 1. An elastomeric connector assembly, comprising:a first contact member having a first base portion substantially parallel to and disposed on a surface of a first electronic component and having a first contact portion substantially perpendicular to said surface of said first electronic component, said first contact member for providing electrical connection to the first electronic component; a second contact member having a second base portion substantially parallel to and disposed on a surface of a second electronic component and having a second contact portion substantially perpendicular to said surface of said second electronic component, said second contact member for providing electrical connection to the second electronic component; and an elastomeric connector disposed between the first contact portion of said first contact member and the second contact portion of said second contact member in a plane generally parallel to the surface of at least one of the first electronic component and the second electronic component, wherein said elastomeric connector is disposed between said first contact member and said second contact member such that the first base portion and the second base portion are substantially parallel but offset in relation to each other, wherein the elastomeric connector couples the first contact portion of said first contact member and the second contact portion second contact member for providing an electrical connection between the first and second electronic components.
  • 2. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein the elastomeric connector is compressed between the first contact member and the second contact member.
  • 3. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein the first contact member and the second contact member are rigid.
  • 4. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein the first electronic component comprises a printed circuit board (PCB) and the second electronic component comprises one of a liquid crystal display (LCD), an electroflorescent display and a piezoelectric display.
  • 5. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein the first and second electronic components comprise printed circuit boards (PCBs).
  • 6. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein the first electronic component comprises a printed circuit board (PCB) and the second electronic component comprises a chip carrier.
  • 7. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein the elastomeric connector is compressed between the first contact member and the second contact member along the plane generally parallel to the surface of at least one of the first electronic component and the second electronic component.
  • 8. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein the elastomeric connector comprises a resilient material having a plurality of connector elements extending there through for electrically coupling the first contact member and the second contact member.
  • 9. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 8, wherein the first contact member comprises a first contact element electrically coupled to the first electronic component and the second contact member comprises a second contact element electrically coupled to the second electronic component, the first contact element and second contact element being positioned to be electrically connected by a connector element of the elastomeric connector.
  • 10. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 8, wherein the resilient material comprises silicone and the plurality of connector elements comprise one of carbon, silver, and gold.
  • 11. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 1, wherein at least one of the first contact member and the second contact member comprises a flexible circuit.
  • 12. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 11, further comprising a support for supporting the flexible circuit.
  • 13. An electronic device, comprising:a first electronic component; a second electronic component; and an elastomeric connector assembly, including: a first contact member having a first base portion substantially parallel to and disposed on a surface of the first electronic component and having a first contact portion substantially perpendicular to said surface of said first electronic component, said first contact member for providing electrical connection to the first electronic component; a second contact member having a second base portion substantially parallel to and disposed on a surface of the second electronic component and having a second contact portion substantially perpendicular to said surface of said second electronic component, said second contact member for providing electrical connection to the second electronic component; and an elastomeric connector disposed between the first contact portion of said first contact member and the second contact portion of said second contact member in a plane generally parallel to the surface of at least one of the first electronic component and the second electronic component for electrically coupling the first contact member and the second contact member, wherein said elastomeric connector is disposed between said first contact member and said second contact member such that said first base portion and said second base portion are substantially parallel but offset in relation to each other; wherein the elastomeric connector assembly provides electrical connection between the first and second electronic components.
  • 14. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein the elastomeric connector is compressed between the first contact member and the second contact member.
  • 15. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein the first contact member and the second contact member are rigid.
  • 16. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein the first electronic component comprises a printed circuit board (PCB) and the second electronic component comprises one of a liquid crystal display (LCD), an electroflorescent display and a piezoelectric display.
  • 17. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein the first and second electronic components comprise printed circuit boards (PCB).
  • 18. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein the first electronic component comprises a printed circuit board (PCB) and the second electronic component comprises a chip carrier.
  • 19. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein the elastomeric connector comprises a resilient material having a plurality of connector elements extending there through for electrically coupling the first contact member and the second contact member.
  • 20. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein the elastomeric connector is compressed between the first contact member and the second contact member along the plane generally parallel to the surface of at least one of the first electronic component and the second electronic component.
  • 21. The electronic device as claimed in claim 19, wherein the first contact member comprises a contact element electrically coupled to the first electronic component and the second contact member comprises a second contact element electrically coupled to the second electronic component, the first contact element and second contact element being positioned to be electrically connected by a connector element.
  • 22. The electronic device as claimed in claim 19, wherein the resilient material comprises silicone and the plurality of connector elements comprise one of carbon, silver, and gold.
  • 23. The electronic device as claimed in claim 13, wherein at least one of the first contact member and the second contact member comprises a flexible circuit.
  • 24. The electronic device as claimed in claim 23, further comprising a support for supporting the flexible circuit.
  • 25. An elastomeric connector assembly, comprising:a first contact member having a first portion extending from a surface of a first electronic component in a first plane generally vertical to said surface of said first electronic component, said first contact member for providing electrical connection to the first electronic component; a second contact member having a second portion extending from a surface of a second electronic component in a second plane generally vertical to said surface of said second electronic component, said second contact member for providing electrical connection to the second electronic component; and an elastomeric connector disposed between the first contact member and the second contact member such that the first portion and the second portion are not coplanar, wherein the elastomeric connector couples the first contact member and the second contact member for providing an electrical connection between the first and second electronic components.
  • 26. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein the elastomeric connector is compressed between the first contact member and the second contact member.
  • 27. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein the first contact member and the second contact member are rigid.
  • 28. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein the first electronic component comprises a printed circuit board (PCB) and the second electronic component comprises one of a liquid crystal display (LCD), an electroflorescent display and a piezoelectric display.
  • 29. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein the first and second electronic components comprise printed circuit boards (PCBs).
  • 30. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein the first electronic component comprises a printed circuit board (PCB) and the second electronic component comprises a chip carrier.
  • 31. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein the elastomeric connector is compressed between the first contact member and the second contact member along the generally horizontal plane.
  • 32. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein the elastomeric connector comprises a resilient material having a plurality of connector elements extending there through for electrically coupling the first contact member and the second contact member.
  • 33. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 32, wherein the first contact member comprises a first contact element electrically coupled to the first electronic component and the second contact member comprises a second contact element electrically coupled to the second electronic component, the first contact element and second contact element being positioned to be electrically connected by a connector element of the elastomeric connector.
  • 34. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 32, wherein the resilient material comprises silicone and the plurality of connector elements comprise one of carbon, silver, and gold.
  • 35. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 25, wherein at least one of the first contact member and the second contact member comprises a flexible circuit.
  • 36. The elastomeric connector assembly as claimed in claim 35, further comprising a support for supporting the flexible circuit.
US Referenced Citations (2)
Number Name Date Kind
5613862 Naylor Mar 1997 A
6091475 Ogino et al. Jul 2000 A