Electric power conversion optimized for efficient harmonic elimination

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6510063
  • Patent Number
    6,510,063
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, October 3, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, January 21, 2003
    21 years ago
Abstract
Power conversion units using pulse width modulation for elimination of harmonics of specific orders are connected in parallel with an ac power system so that the power conversion units supply voltages of mutually different waveforms to the ac power system.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The present invention generally relates to methods and apparatuses for electric power conversion and, more particularly, to a method and an apparatus for electric power conversion operating between a dc power system and an ac power system optimized for efficient harmonic elimination.




2. Description of the Related Art





FIG. 20

shows a construction of a related-art electric power conversion apparatus shown in


Generalized Techniques of Harmonic Elimination and Voltage Control in Thyristor Inverters: Part I—Harmonic Elimination, IEEE Transactions On Industry Applications,


Vol. IA-9, No.


3


, May/June 1973. Referring to

FIG. 20

, the electric power conversion apparatus comprises a dc power system, a three-phase (u phase, v phase, w phase) ac power system


2


, a power conversion unit


3


for dc to ac power conversion based on pulse width modulation for elimination of harmonics of specific orders and a codulating circuit


4


for controlling an output voltage of the power conversion unit


3


. The power conversion unit


3


utilizes switching elements such as gate turn-off thyristors.





FIGS. 21A

,


21


B and


21


C are graphs showing waveforms V


ou


, V


ov


and V


ow


of the u-phase voltage, v-phase voltage and w-phase voltage, respectively, output from the power conversion unit


3


. V


su


, V


sv


and V


s


each represents a sinusoidal waveform of the fundamental of the output voltage for each phase. The waveforms V


su


, V


sv


and V


sw


are mathematically represented as








V




su




=k·E




dc


·sin θ  (1)










V




sv




=k·E




dc


·sin(θ−120°)  (2)










V




sv




=k·E




dc


·sin(θ+120°)  (3)






where k indicates an instruction (control setting) for an amplitude of voltage of a fundamental, θ indicates an instruction (control setting) for a phase of a voltage of a fundamental and E


dc


indicates a dc voltage level.





FIG. 22

is a numeral chart referred to in order to determine variables α


1


, α


2


, α


3


, α


4


and α


5


that define the sinusoidal waveforms V


su


, V


sv


and V


sw


. Instructions k input to the modulating circuit


4


are plotted horizontally in the chart. Each of the variables α


1





5


varies in a range of 0 to 90 degrees and is plotted vertically in the chart. For each given instruction k, a set of variables α


1


, α


2


, α


3


, α


4


and α


5


are determined.





FIG. 23

is a graph showing an amplitude of a third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by the electric power conversion apparatus.




A description will now be given of the operation according to the related art. Responsive to an input of a fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k and a fundamental voltage phase instruction θ, the modulating circuit


4


outputs an operation signal r for ensuring that the fundamental components of the voltages for the respective phases output from the power conversion unit


3


have respective waveforms V


su


, V


sv


and V


sw


. In other words, the modulating circuit outputs the operation signal r that causes the power conversion unit


3


to output the waveforms V


ou


, V


ov


and V


ow


.




In response to the operation signal r from the modulating circuit


4


, the power conversion unit


3


effects power conversion between the dc power system


1


and the ac power system


2


, by driving the switching elements so that the u-phase output voltage, the v-phase output voltage and the w-phase output voltage have the waveforms V


ou


, V


ov


and V


ow


, respectively.




As shown in

FIGS. 21A

,


21


B and


21


C, the voltage waveforms V


ou


, V


ov


and V


ow


are determined by the variables α


1





5


. The variable α


1





5


are uniquely determined by the fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k. More specifically, the variables α


1





5


are determined by the modulating circuit


4


by referring to a numeral table of FIG.


22


.




Each of the voltage waveforms V


ou


, V


ov


and V


ow


comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The fundamental components of the voltage waveforms V


ou


, V


ov


and V


ow


have the waveforms V


su


, V


sv


and V


sw


. The amplitude of fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics is zero.




With this operation, it is ensured that the fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics are eliminated from the voltage output from the power conversion unit


3


. The power conversion unit


3


outputs fundamental components having a predetermined amplitude. When the output voltages are in a three-phase balanced state, the line-to-line voltage cancels harmonics that are multiples of three so that these harmonics are not included in the output voltages.




As described above, the related-art power conversion apparatus is constructed such that harmonics that are multiples of three are cancelled by the line-to-line voltage and eliminated from the output voltages, when the output voltages of the power conversion unit


3


are in a three-phase balanced state. When imbalance of the output voltages of the power conversion unit


3


occurs, harmonics that are multiples of three are included in the output voltages.




More specifically, when imbalance of the output voltages of the power conversion unit


3


occurs (for example, when the output voltages of the respective phases have mutually different fundamental components so that the fundamental components have different phases), the magnitude of harmonics of multiples of three, included in the output voltage, differ from phase to phase. Consequently, harmonics of multiples of three cannot be canceled by the line-to-line voltage and are included in the output voltages.




In order to eliminate harmonics such as third harmonics or ninth harmonics, it is conceivable to use a plurality of power conversion units that employ the pulse width modulation method for eliminating harmonics of specific orders.




However, when a plurality of power conversion units are connected in parallel such that the phases of the fundamental components thereof are displaced from each other by an appropriate magnitude, using multiple reactors for connection, a cross current having a fundamental frequency may flow between the plurality of power conversion units. When a plurality of power conversion units are connected in series such that the phases of the fundamental components thereof are displaced from each other, the upper limit of the voltage of the fundamental that can be output is reduced.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




Accordingly, an object of the present invention is to provide an electric power conversion apparatus in which the aforementioned problems are eliminated.




Another and more specific object of the present invention is to provide an electric power conversion apparatus capable of suppressing harmonics including third harmonics and ninth harmonics included in the output voltage even when phase-to-phase imbalance of the output voltages of a plurality of power conversion units, and without inducing a cross current having the frequency of a fundamental between the plurality of power conversion units.




The aforementioned objects can be achieved by a power conversion apparatus using a power conversion unit to effect power conversion between a dc power system and an ac power system, comprising: a plurality of power conversion units using a pulse width modulation method adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders and connected to the ac power system, wherein the plurality of power conversion units supply voltages of mutually different waveforms to the ac power system.




The plurality of power conversion units may be connected in parallel with the ac power system via reactors.




Two power conversion units may be connected in parallel.




Three power conversion units may be connected in parallel.




The aforementioned objects can also be achieved by a method of converting electric power between a dc power system and an ac power system, comprising the steps of: supplying instructions to a plurality of power conversion units each using a pulse width modulation method adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders and connected to the ac power system; supplying from the plurality of power conversion units voltages of mutually different waveforms to the ac power system.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




Other objects and further features of the present invention will be apparent from the following detailed description when read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:





FIG. 1

is a schematic diagram showing an electric power conversion apparatus according to a first embodiment of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a flowchart showing processes performed by the electric power conversion apparatus according to the first embodiment;





FIGS. 3A through 3C

are graphs showing waveforms of voltages output by a power conversion unit


14


;





FIG. 4

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


11


, α


12


, α


13


, α


14


and α


15


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


;





FIGS. 5A through 5C

are graphs showing waveforms of voltages output by a power conversion unit


15


;





FIG. 6

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


21


, α


32


, α


23


, α


24


and α


25


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


;





FIG. 7

is a graph showing an amplitude of a third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by the electric power conversion unit


14


;





FIG. 8

is a graph showing an amplitude of a third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by the electric power conversion unit


15


;





FIG. 9

is a graph showing an amplitude of a third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by a dual-system power conversion apparatus according to the first embodiment;





FIG. 10

shows a construction of a power conversion apparatus according to a second embodiment;





FIGS. 11A through 11C

are graphs showing waveforms of voltages output by a power conversion unit


25


;





FIG. 12

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


11


, α


12


, α


13


, α


14


and α


15


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


;





FIGS. 13A through 13C

are graphs showing waveforms of voltages output by a power conversion unit


26


;





FIG. 14

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


21


, α


22


, α


23


, α


24


and α


25


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


;





FIGS. 15A through 15C

are graphs showing waveforms of voltages output by a power conversion unit


27


;





FIG. 16

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


31


, α


32


, α


33


, α


34


and α


35


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


;





FIG. 17

is a graph showing an amplitude of a third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by a triple-system power conversion apparatus according to the second embodiment;





FIG. 18

is a graph showing an amplitude of a ninth harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by a dual-system power conversion apparatus of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 19

is a graph showing an amplitude of a ninth harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by a triple-system power conversion apparatus of

FIG. 10

;





FIG. 20

shows a construction of an electric power conversion apparatus according to the related art;





FIGS. 21A through 21C

are graphs showing waveforms of voltages output by a power conversion unit according to the related art;





FIG. 22

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


1


, α


2


, α


3


, α


4


and α


5


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


su


, V


sv


and V


sw


;





FIG. 23

is a graph showing an amplitude of a third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for one phase produced by a power conversion apparatus according to the related art;





FIG. 24

shows a detailed structure of a modulator for the power conversion apparatus of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 25

is a block diagram and electrical schematic illustrating conversion of a control signal; and





FIG. 26

shows a detailed structure of a modulator for the power conversion apparatus of FIG.


1


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS





FIG. 1

is a schematic diagram showing an electric power conversion apparatus according to a first embodiment of the present invention.




Generally, a total of (n


1


+n


2


+n


3


+ . . . +nq) power conversion units adapted to output voltage waveforms Px (x=1, 2, . . . q) not including m


1


, m


2


, . . . mr harmonic components are used to construct the power conversion apparatus. In the example of

FIG. 1

, r=4, m


1


=5, m


2


=7, m


3


=11, m


4


=13, q=2, n


1


=1 and n


2


=1. The voltage waveform Px comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The power conversion apparatus uses three-phase, three-level, five-pulse inverters respectively adapted to cancel fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics included in the output voltage comprising the five pulses. In the case of

FIG. 1

, the power conversion apparatus is formed as a dual-system power conversion apparatus.




Referring to

FIG. 1

, the power conversion apparatus comprises a dc power system in which a P


1


-O


1


voltage and a O


1


-N


1


voltage are equal to E


dc


, a dc power system


12


in which a P


2


-O


2


voltage and a O


2


-N


2


voltage are equal to E


dc


, a three-phase (u-phase, v-phase, w-phase) ac power system


13


, power conversion units


14


and


15


for dc to ac power conversion based on the pulse width modulation adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders, using switching elements such as GTOs. The power conversion apparatus further comprises modulating circuits


16


and


17


receiving a u-phase fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k


u


, a v-phase fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k


v


, and a w-phase fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k


w


and outputting operation signals r


1


and r


2


, which controls the output voltage of the power conversion units


14


and


15


, in response to a u-phase fundamental voltage phase instruction θ


u


, a v-phase fundamental voltage phase instruction θ


v


and a w-phase fundamental voltage phase instruction θ


w


, and reactors


18


and


19


connecting in parallel the power conversion units


14


and


15


, respectively, to the ac power system


13


.




While the illustrated construction uses the reactors


18


and


19


to connect the power conversion units


14


and


15


to the ac power system


13


, a transformer may also be used to connect the power conversion units


14


and


15


to the ac power system


13


. Alternatively, the power conversion units


14


and


15


may be connected in series with the ac power system


13


instead of in parallel.





FIG. 2

is a flowchart showing processes performed by the electric power conversion apparatus according to the first embodiment.





FIGS. 3A

,


3


B and


3


C are graphs showing waveforms V


ou1


, V


ov1


and V


ow1


of the u-phase voltage, v-phase voltage and w-phase voltage, respectively, output from the power conversion unit


14


. V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


each represents a sinusoidal waveform of the fundamental of the output voltage for each phase. The waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


and mathematically represented as








V




ru




=k




u




·E




dc


·sin θ


u


  (4)










V




rv




=k




v




·E




dc


·sin(θ


v


−120°)  (5)










V




rw




=k




w




·E




dc


·sin(θ


w


+120°)  (6)






where k


u


, k


v


and k


w


indicate instructions (control setting) for an amplitude of voltage of a fundamental, θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


each indicates an instruction (control setting) for a phase of a voltage of a fundamental.





FIG. 4

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


11


, α


12


, α


13


, α


14


and α


15


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


ru


and V


rw


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuit


16


are plotted horizontally in the chart. Each of the variables α


11





15


varies in a range of 0 to 90 degrees and is plotted vertically in the chart. For each of the given instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


, a set of variables α


11


, α


12


, α


13


, α


14


and α


15


are determined.





FIGS. 5A

,


5


B and


5


C are graphs showing waveforms V


ou2


, V


ov2


and V


ow2


output from the power conversion unit


15


. V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


each represents a sinusoidal waveform of the fundamental of the output voltage for each phase. The waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


are mathematically represented as the equations (4), (5) and (6) above.





FIG. 6

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


21


, α


32


, α


23


, α


24


and α


25


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


ru


and V


rw


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


(generally represented as k) input to the modulating circuit


17


are plotted horizontally in the chart. Each of the variables α


21





25


varies in a range of 0 to 90 degrees and is plotted vertically in the chart. For each of the given instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


, a set of variables α


21


, α


22


, α


23


, α


24


and


25


are determined.





FIG. 7

is a graph showing an amplitude of third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for a phase produced by the electric power conversion unit


14


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuit


16


are plotted horizontally in the graph. A relative amplitude of third harmonic component included in the voltage waveform for a phase with respect to the amplitude of fundamental is plotted vertically. In determining a ratio of the third harmonic component, it is assumed that the amplitude of fundamental when k


u


, k


v


, k


w


=1 is equal to 1.





FIG. 8

is a graph showing an amplitude of third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for a phase produced by the electric power conversion unit


15


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuit


17


are plotted horizontally in the graph. A relative amplitude of third harmonic component included in the voltage waveform for a phase with respect to the amplitude of fundamental is plotted vertically. In determining a ratio of the third harmonic component, it is assumed that the amplitude of fundamental when k


u


, k


v


, k


w


=1 is equal to 1.





FIG. 9

is a graph showing an amplitude of third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for a phase produced by a dual-system power conversion apparatus according to the first embodiment. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuits


16


and


17


are plotted horizontally in the graph. A relative amplitude of third harmonic component included in the voltage waveform for a phase with respect to the amplitude of fundamental is plotted vertically. In determining a ratio of the third harmonic component, it is assumed that the amplitude of fundamental when k


u


, k


v


, k


w


=1 is equal to 1.




A description will now be given of the operation according to the first embodiment.




When the modulating circuit


16


receives the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


and the fundamental voltage phase instructions, θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


(step ST


1


), the modulating circuit


16


outputs an operation signal r


1


for ensuring that the fundamental components of the voltages for the respective phases output from the power conversion unit


14


have the respective waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. In other words, the modulating circuit


16


outputs the operation signal r


1


that causes the power conversion unit


14


to output the waveforms V


ou1


, V


ov1


and V


ow1


(step ST


2


).




When the modulating circuit


17


receives the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


and the fundamental voltage phase instructions θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


(step ST


1


), the modulating circuit


17


outputs an operation signal r


2


for ensuring that the fundamental components of the voltages for the respective phases output from the power conversion unit


15


have the respective waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. In other words, the modulating circuit


17


outputs the operation signal r


2


that causes the power conversion unit


15


to output the waveforms V


ou2


, V


ov2


and V


ow2


(step ST


3


).




In response to the operation signal r


1


from the modulating circuit


16


, the power conversion unit


14


effects power conversion between the dc power system


11


and the ac power system


13


, by driving the switching elements so that the u-phase output voltage, the v-phase output voltage and the w-phase output voltage have the waveforms V


ou1


, V


ov1


and V


ow1


, respectively (step ST


4


).




In response to the operation signal r


2


from the modulating circuit


17


, the power conversion unit


15


effects power conversion between the dc power system


12


and the ac power system


13


, by driving the switching elements so that the u-phase output voltage, the v-phase output voltage and the w-phase output voltage have the waveforms V


ou2


, V


ov2


and V


ow2


, respectively (step ST


5


).




As shown in

FIGS. 3A

,


3


B and


3


C, the voltage waveforms V


ou1


, V


ov1


and V


ow1


are determined by the variables α


11





15


. The variables α


11





15


are uniquely determined by the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


. More specifically, the variables α


11





15


are determined by the modulating circuit


17


by referring to the numeral table of FIG.


4


.




Each of the voltage waveforms V


ou1


, V


ov1


and V


ow1


comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The fundamental components of the voltage waveforms V


ou1


, V


ov1


and V


ow1


have the waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. The amplitude of fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics is zero.




As shown in

FIGS. 5A

,


5


B and


5


C, the voltage waveforms V


ou2


, V


ov2


and V


ow2


are determined by the variables α


21





25


. The variables α


21





25


are uniquely determined by the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


. More specifically, the variables α


11





15


are determined by the modulating circuit


17


by referring to the numeral table of FIG.


6


.




Each of the voltage waveforms V


ou2


, V


ov2


and V


ow2


comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The fundamental components of the voltage waveforms V


ou2


, V


ov2


and V


ow2


have the waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. The amplitude of fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics is zero.




With this operation, it is ensured that the fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics are eliminated from the voltage output from the power conversion units


14


and


15


. The power conversion units


14


and


15


output fundamental components having a predetermined amplitude.




The output voltage of the dual-system power conversion apparatus of

FIG. 1

is an average of the output voltage of the power conversion unit


14


and the output voltage of the power conversion unit


15


. The fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics are eliminated from the voltage output from the dual-system power conversion apparatus of FIG.


1


. Thus, the power conversion apparatus of

FIG. 1

outputs a fundamental component having a predetermined amplitude.




Since the fundamental components of the power conversion units


14


and


15


are identical, a cross current having a frequency of a fundamental is prevented from flowing between the power conversion units


14


and


15


.




When the output voltages are in a three-phase balanced state, that is, when the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


of the respective phases are identical, and when the fundamental voltage phase instructions θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


are displaced 120 degrees from each other, the line-to-line voltage cancels harmonics that are multiples of three so that these harmonics are not included in the output voltages.




When a minor imbalance between the output voltages of the respective phases is produced, the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


may not be identical and the fundamental voltage phase instructions θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


are displaced from each other by degrees other than 120 degrees.




As shown in

FIGS. 7 and 8

, in the PWM method in which harmonics of specific orders are eliminated, the amplitude of third harmonic in the output voltage differs depending on the amplitude of fundamental of the output voltage. Accordingly, when a singular power conversion unit employing the PWM method designed to eliminate harmonics of specific orders is used (for example, when only the power conversion unit


14


is used for power conversion or when only the power conversion unit


15


is used for power conversion), third harmonic components may be included by different magnitude in the three phases when the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


are not identical. Consequently, some portion of the third harmonic component included in the output voltage remains in the output voltage without being cancelled by the line-to-line voltage.




In contrast, the output voltage of the dual-system power conversion apparatus of

FIG. 1

, in which both the power conversion units


14


and


15


are used for power conversion) is an average of the output voltage of the power conversion unit


14


and the output voltage of the power conversion unit


15


. Accordingly, the amplitude of third harmonic components included in the output voltages of the respective phases is as shown in FIG.


9


.





FIG. 9

shows that the amplitude of third harmonic components included in the output voltages of the respective phases of the dual-system power conversion apparatus is constant irrespective of the amplitude of fundamental components included in the output voltages. As a result, the third harmonic components included in the output voltages of the respective phases have substantially identical amplitude even when there is a minor imbalance between the output voltages of the respective phases of the dual-system power conversion apparatus. The third harmonic component in the output voltage is cancelled assuming that the phase differences between the fundamental components are only slightly different from 120 degrees.




A more detailed description will now be given of the operation of the modulating circuits


16


and


17


, by taking an example of the u phase.





FIG. 24

shows a detailed construction of the modulating circuit


16


of FIG.


1


. The modulating circuit


16


comprises a numeral table


40


and an operation instruction unit


41


. The numeral table


40


is as shown in FIG.


4


and outputs variables (angles) α


11


, α


12


, α


13


, α


14


, and α


15


, in accordance with the voltage instruction k


u


. The operation instruction unit


41


compares the phase θ


u


of a target alternate output with the angles α


11


, α


12


, α


13


, α


14


, and α


15


, so as to output a u-phase control signal (instruction) r


1(u)


. The PWM waveform is as shown in FIG.


3


. The PWM pattern in the first quarter period (0-90°) is symmetrical with that of the second quarter period. The PWM pattern in the third quarter period is symmetrical with that of the fourth quarter period.




Referring to the operation instruction unit


41


of

FIG. 24

, a determination is first made as to whether the phase angle θ


u


is smaller than 180°. If it is determined that θ


u


is smaller than 180°, a determination is then made as to whether θ


u


is smaller than 90°. If it is determined that θ


u


is smaller than 90° and also smaller than α


11


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating a voltage pattern at 0 level is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than α


11


, but smaller than α


12


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating E


dc


is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than α


12


but smaller than α


13


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating 0 is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than α


13


but smaller than α


14


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating E


dc


is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than α


14


but smaller than α


15


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating 0 is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than α


15


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating E


dc


is output.




If it is determined that θ


u


is such that 90°≦θ


u


<180°, a determination is then made as to whether θ


u


is smaller than 180°−α


15


. If θ


u


is determined to be smaller than 180°−α


15


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating E


dc


is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than 180°−α


15


but smaller than 180°−α


14


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating 0 is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than 180°−α


14


but smaller than 180°−α


13


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating E


dc


is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than 180°−α


12


but smaller than 180°−α


11


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating 0 is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than 180°−α


12


, but smaller than 180°−α


11


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating E


dc


is output. If θ


u


is determined to be equal to or larger than 180°−α


11


, the control signal r


1(u)


indicating 0 is output.




Similar steps are performed when 180°<θ


u


<360° (see the bottom portion of the operation instruction unit


41


of

FIG. 24

) so that the control signal r


1(u)


indicating a voltage pattern at either 0 level or −E


dc


level is output.





FIG. 25

shows how the u-phase control signals r


1(u)


are converted into associated switching signals. Block


42


is a chart illustrating how the conversion takes place and block


43


indicates the switching elements corresponding to the u phase and subject to control by the control signal r


1(u)


. The control signal r


1(u)


is converted into switching signals for controlling the switching elements GT


1


, GT


2


, GT


3


, and GT


4


constituting the power conversion unit


14


. When the control signal r


1(u)


indicates E


dc


, the switching elements GT


1


and GT


2


are turned on so that a capacitor voltage E


dc


is output via the output terminal. When the control signal r


1(u)


indicates 0, the switching elements GT


2


and GT


3


are turned on so that a 0 voltage is output via the output terminal. When the control signal r


1(u)


indicates −E


dc


, the switching elements GT


3


and GT


4


are turned on so that a capacitor voltage −E


dc


is output via the output terminal.





FIG. 26

shows a detailed construction of the modulating circuit


17


of FIG.


1


. The modulating circuit


17


comprises a numeral table


50


and an operation instruction unit


51


. The procedure for control is the same as that of the modulating circuit


16


shown in FIG.


24


. The numeral table


50


is as shown in FIG.


6


. The other aspects of the operation of the modulating circuit


17


are essentially the same as those of the modulating circuit


16


so that the description thereof is omitted.




The power conversion units


14


and


15


controlled in accordance with different numeral tables as described above are connected to each other via the reactors


18


and


19


. The voltage V


out


at the point of connection between the reactors


18


and


19


is an average voltage of the output voltages of the power conversion units


14


and


15


.




The numerals in the numeral table


40


for controlling the power conversion unit


14


and the numeral table


50


for controlling the power conversion unit


15


are calculated and stored such that, given the same voltage instruction k (generically referring to the instructions k


u


, k


v


, and k


w


), the third harmonics respectively occurring in the power conversion units


14


and


15


are of the same magnitude and 180° phase displaced. When an alternating current with a 180° phase displacement from the other alternating current is at a positive level, the other current is at an opposite negative level with the same absolute value. The magnitude of the third harmonic occurring in the power conversion unit


14


controlled in accordance with the numeral table


40


is as shown in FIG.


7


. When the value designated by the instruction k is in the neighborhood of 1, the magnitude of the third harmonic is higher than −0.1 level. As the value approaches 0.7, the magnitude approaches −0.3 level, resulting in a 0.2 increase in the absolute value. In contrast, the magnitude of the third harmonic occurring in the power conversion unit


15


controlled in accordance with the numeral table


50


is as shown in FIG.


8


. When the value designated by the instruction k is in the neighborhood of 1, the magnitude of the third harmonic is higher than 0.2 level. As the value approaches 0.7, the magnitude approaches 0.6 level. The magnitude of the third harmonic occurring at the point of connection between the reactors results from averaging the two voltages and varies with k as shown in FIG.


9


. The magnitude of the third harmonic substantially remains at 0.1 level irrespective of the value of k. For example, the magnitude of the third harmonic is (−0.05+0.26)/2=0.105 when k=1 and (−0.30+0.56)/2=0.13 when k=0.7. Accordingly, by operating the two power conversion units using different PWM tables, an alternating output containing a third harmonic component at a reduced level is obtained.




As has been described, according to the first embodiment, the power conversion units


14


and


15


employing the PWM method designed to cancel harmonics of specific orders are connected in parallel with the ac power system. The power conversion units


14


and


15


supply phase voltages with mutually different waveforms to the ac power system


13


. Therefore, even when there is a phase-to-phase imbalance between the output voltages of the power conversion units


14


and


15


, a cross current having a frequency of the fundamental is prevented from flowing between the power conversion units


14


and


15


and harmonics including third and ninth harmonics are suppressed in the output voltage.





FIG. 10

shows a construction of a power conversion apparatus according to a second embodiment. Generally, a total of (n


1


+n


2


+n


3


+ . . . +nq) power conversion units adapted to output voltage waveforms Px (x=1, 2, . . . q) not including m


1


, m


2


, . . . mr harmonic components are used to construct the power conversion apparatus. In the example of

FIG. 10

, r=4, m


1


=5, m


2


=7, m


3


=11, m


4


=13, q=3, n


1


=1, n


2


=1 and n


3


=1. The voltage waveform Px comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The power conversion apparatus uses three-phase, three-level, five-pulse inverters respectively adapted to cancel fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics included in the output voltage comprising the five pulses. In the case of

FIG. 10

, the power conversion apparatus is formed as a triple-system power conversion apparatus.




Referring to

FIG. 10

, the power conversion apparatus comprises a dc power system in which a P


1


-O


1


voltage and a O


1


-N


1


voltage are equal to E


dc


, a dc power system


22


in which a P


2


-O


2


voltage and a O


2


-N


2


voltage are equal to E


dc


, a dc power system


23


in which a P


3


-O


3


voltage and a O


3


-N


3


voltage are equal to E


dc


, a three-phase (u-phase, v-phase, w-phase) ac power system


24


, power conversion units


25


,


26


and


27


for dc to ac power conversion based on the pulse width modulation adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders, using switching elements such as GTOs. The power conversion apparatus further comprises modulating circuits


28


,


29


and


30


receiving a u-phase fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k


u


, a v-phase fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k


v


, and a w-phase fundamental voltage amplitude instruction k


w


and outputting operation signals r


1


, r


2


and r


3


, which controls the output voltage of the power conversion units


25


,


26


and


27


, in response to a u-phase fundamental voltage phase instruction θ


u


, a v-phase fundamental voltage phase instruction θ


v


and a w-phase fundamental voltage phase instruction θ


w


, and reactors


31


,


32


ad


33


connecting in parallel the power conversion units


25


,


26


and


27


, respectively, to the ac power system


24


.





FIGS. 11A through 11C

are graphs showing waveforms V


pu1


, V


pv1


and V


pw1


of the u-phase voltage, v-phase voltage and w-phase voltage, respectively, output from the power conversion unit


25


. V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


each represents a sinusoidal waveform of the fundamental of the output voltage for each phase. The waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


are mathematically represented as the equations (4), (5) and (6).





FIG. 12

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


11


, α


12





13


, α


14


and α


15


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


ru


and V


rw


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuit


28


are plotted horizontally in the chart. Each of the variables α


11





15


varies in a range of 0 to 90 degrees and is plotted vertically in the chart. For each of the given instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


, a set of variables α


11


, α


12


, α


13


, α


14


and α


15


are determined.





FIGS. 13A through 13C

are graphs showing waveforms V


pu2


, V


pv2


and V


pw2


of the u-phase voltage, v-phase voltage and w-phase voltage, respectively, output from the power conversion unit


26


. V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


each represents a sinusoidal waveform of the fundamental of the output voltage for each phase. The waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


are mathematically represented as the equations (4), (5) and (6).





FIG. 14

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


21


, α


22


, α


23


, α


24


and α


25


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


ru


and V


rw


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


(generally represented as k) input to the modulating circuit


29


are plotted horizontally in the chart. Each of the variables α


21





25


varies in a range of 0 to 90 degrees and is plotted vertically in the chart. For each of the given instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


, a set of variables α


21


, α


22


, α


23


, α


24


and α


25


are determined.





FIGS. 15A through 15C

are graphs showing waveforms V


pu3


, V


pv3


and V


pw3


of the u-phase voltage, v-phase voltage and w-phase voltage, respectively, output from the power conversion unit


27


. V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


each represents a sinusoidal waveform of the fundamental of the output voltage for each phase. The waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


are mathematically represented as the equations (4), (5) and (6).





FIG. 16

shows a numeral table used to determine variables α


31


, α


32


, α


33


, α


34


and α


35


that define sinusoidal waveforms V


ru


, V


ru


and V


rw


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuit


30


are plotted horizontally in the chart. Each of the variables α


31





35


varies in a range of 0 to 90 degrees and is plotted vertically in the chart. For each of the given instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


, a set of variables α


31


, α


32


, α


33


, α


34


and α


35


are determined.





FIG. 17

is a graph showing an amplitude of third harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for a phase produced by a triple-system power conversion apparatus according to the second embodiment. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuits


28


through


30


are plotted horizontally in the graph. A relative amplitude of third harmonic component included in the voltage waveform for a phase with respect to the amplitude of fundamental is plotted vertically. In determining a ratio of the third harmonic component, it is assumed that the amplitude of fundamental when k


u


, k


v


, k


w


−1 is equal to 1.





FIG. 18

is a graph showing an amplitude of ninth harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for a phase produced by a dual-system power conversion apparatus according to the first embodiment. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuits


16


and


17


are plotted horizontally in the graph. A relative amplitude of ninth harmonic component included in the voltage waveform for a phase with respect to the amplitude of fundamental is plotted vertically. In determining a ratio of the third harmonic component, it is assumed that the amplitude of fundamental when k


u


, k


v


, k


w


=1 is equal to 1.





FIG. 19

is a graph showing an amplitude of ninth harmonic included in a waveform of a voltage for a phase produced by a triple-system power conversion apparatus of FIG.


10


. Instructions k


u


, k


v


and k


w


input to the modulating circuits


28


through


30


are plotted horizontally in the graph. A relative amplitude of third harmonic component included in the voltage waveform for a phase with respect to the amplitude of fundamental is plotted vertically. In determining a ratio of the third harmonic component, it is assumed that the amplitude of fundamental when k


u


, k


v


, k


w


=1 is equal to 1.




A description will now be given of the operation according to the second embodiment.




When the modulating circuit


28


receives the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


and the fundamental voltage phase instructions θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


, the modulating circuit


28


outputs an operation signal r


1


for ensuring that the fundamental components of the voltages for the respective phases output from the power conversion unit


25


have the respective waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. In other words, the modulating circuit


28


outputs the operation signal r


1


that causes the power conversion unit


25


to output the waveforms V


pu1


, V


pv1


and V


pw1


.




When the modulating circuit


29


receives the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


and the fundamental voltage phase instructions θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


, the modulating circuit


29


outputs an operation signal r


2


for ensuring that the fundamental components of the voltages for the respective phases output from the power conversion unit


26


have the respective waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. In other words, the modulating circuit


29


outputs the operation signal r


2


that causes the power conversion unit


26


to output the waveforms V


pu2


, V


pv2


and V


pw2


.




When the modulating circuit


30


receives the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


and the fundamental voltage phase instructions θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


, the modulating circuit


30


outputs an operation signal r


3


for ensuring that the fundamental components of the voltages for the respective phases output from the power conversion unit


27


have the respective waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. In other words, the modulating circuit


30


outputs the operation signal r


3


that causes the power conversion unit


27


to output the waveforms V


pu3


, V


pv3


and V


pw3


.




In response to the operation signal r


1


from the modulating circuit


28


, the power conversion unit


25


effects power conversion between the dc power system


21


and the ac power system


24


, by driving the switching elements so that the u-phase output voltage, the v-phase output voltage and the w-phase output voltage have the waveforms V


pu1


, V


pv1


and V


pw1


, respectively.




In response to the operation signal r


2


from the modulating circuit


29


, the power conversion unit


26


effects power conversion between the dc power system


22


and the ac power system


24


, by driving the switching elements so that the u-phase output voltage, the v-phase output voltage and the w-phase output voltage have the waveforms V


pu2


, V


pv2


and V


pw2


, respectively.




In response to the operation signal r


3


from the modulating circuit


30


, the power conversion unit


27


effects power conversion between the dc power system


23


and the ac power system


24


, by driving the switching elements so that the u-phase output voltage, the v-phase output voltage and the w-phase output voltage have the waveforms V


pu3


, V


pv3


and V


pw3


, respectively.




As shown in

FIGS. 11A

,


11


B and


11


C, the voltage waveforms V


pu1


, V


pv1


and V


pw1


are determined by the variables α


11





15


. The variables α


11





15


are uniquely determined by the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


. More specifically, the variables α


11





15


are determined by the modulating circuit


28


by referring to the numeral table of FIG.


12


.




Each of the voltage waveforms V


pu1


, V


pv1


and V


pw1


comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The fundamental components of the voltage waveforms V


pu1


, V


pv1


and V


pw1


have the waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


adn V


rw


. The amplitude of fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics is zero.




As shown in

FIGS. 13A

,


13


B and


13


C, the voltage waveforms V


pu2


, V


pv1


and V


pw1


have the by the variables α


21





25


. The variables α


21





25


are uniquely determined by the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


. More specifically, the variables α


21





25


are determined by the modulating circuit


29


by referring to the numeral table of FIG.


14


.




Each of the voltage waveforms V


pu2


, V


pv2


and V


pw2


comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The fundamental components of the voltage waveforms V


pu2


, V


pv2


and V


pw2


have the waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. The amplitude of fifth seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics is zero.




As shown in

FIGS. 15A

,


15


B and


15


C, the voltage waveforms V


pu3


, V


pv3


and V


pw3


are determined by the variables α


31





35


. The variables α


31





35


are uniquely determined by the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


. More specifically, the variables α


31





35


are determined by the modulating circuit


30


by referring to the numeral table of FIG.


16


.




Each of the voltage waveforms V


pu3


, V


pv3


and V


pw3


comprises five pulses symmetrical about the horizontal axis. The fundamental components of the voltage waveforms V


pu3


, V


pv3


and V


pw3


have the waveforms V


ru


, V


rv


and V


rw


. The amplitude of fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics is zero.




With this operation, it is ensured that the fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics are eliminated from the voltage output from the power conversion units


25


through


27


. The power conversion units


25


through


27


output fundamental components having a predetermined amplitude.




The output voltage of the triple-system power conversion apparatus is an average of the output voltage of the power conversion unit


25


, the output voltage of the power conversion unit


26


and the output voltage of the power conversion unit


27


. The fifth, seventh, eleventh and thirteenth harmonics are eliminated from the voltage output from the triple-system power conversion apparatus. Thus, the power conversion apparatus outputs a fundamental component having a predetermined amplitude.




Since the fundamental components of the power conversion units


25


through


27


are identical, a cross current having a frequency of a fundamental is prevented from flowing between the power conversion units


25


through


27


.




When the output voltages are in a three-phase balanced state, that is, when the fundamental voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


of the respective phases are identical, and when the fundamental voltage phase instructions θ


u


, θ


v


and θ


w


are displaced 120 degrees from each other, the line-to-line voltage cancels harmonics that are multiples of three so that these harmonics are not included in the output voltages.




When a minor imbalance between the output voltages of the respective phases is produced, elimination of third harmonics in the output voltage of the triple-system power conversion apparatus requires that the amplitude of third harmonic included in the output voltage of a phase is constant irrespective of the amplitude of the fundamental of the output voltages.





FIG. 17

shows that, in the triple-system power conversion apparatus, variation in the amplitude of third harmonic in the output voltage in relation to variation in the fundamental component in the output voltage is smaller than the corresponding variation in the power conversion apparatus using a singular power conversion unit employing the PWM method adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders. More specifically, in the triple-system power conversion apparatus, the amplitude of third harmonic in the output voltage occurring when imbalance in the three-phase system is produced is smaller than the corresponding amplitude in the power conversion apparatus using a singular power conversion unit employing the PWM method adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders.




Cancellation of ninth harmonic components will now be discussed. When the three-phase output voltages are balanced, ninth harmonic components are cancelled by the line-to-line voltage and are not included in the output voltage.




Like third harmonics, ninth harmonics show up in the output voltage when the three-phase output voltages are not balanced.




When the dual-system power conversion apparatus according to the first embodiment is used for the purpose of suppressing third harmonics when the three-phase output voltages are not balanced, for example, the amplitude of ninth harmonic for a phase in relation to the amplitude of fundamental for a phase is as shown in FIG.


18


.




In contrast, when the triple-system according to the second embodiment is used, the amplitude of ninth harmonic for a phase in relation to the amplitude of fundamental for a phase is as shown in FIG.


19


.





FIGS. 18 and 19

show that, in a range in which the value of the basic voltage amplitude instructions k


u


, k


v


, k


w


is equal to or larger than 0.73, the amplitude of ninth harmonic included in each phase of the triple-system power conversion apparatus is smaller than the corresponding amplitude of the dual-system power conversion apparatus according to the first embodiment.




Accordingly, by using the triple-system power conversion apparatus, third and ninth harmonics included in the output voltage are suppressed even when there is imbalance in the output voltages of the three-phase system.




Various advantages of the present invention will be summarized below.




According to the invention, a plurality of power conversion units each employing the pulse width modulation method adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders are connected to an ac power system. For each phase of the three-phase system, the plurality of power conversion units output mutually different voltages to the ac power system. Thus, even when the output voltages of the plurality of power conversion units are not balanced in the respective phases, a cross current having a frequency of a fundamental is prevented from flowing between the plurality of power conversion units. Third and ninth harmonics in the output voltage are suppressed.




In further accordance with the invention, a plurality of power conversion units are connected in parallel with an ac power system via reactors. Accordingly, third and ninth harmonic components in the output voltage are suppressed without requiring a complicated construction.




In further accordance with the invention, two power conversion units are connected in parallel so that third harmonic components in the output voltage are suppressed.




In further accordance with the invention, three power conversion units are connected in parallel so that ninth harmonic components in the output voltage are suppressed.




In further accordance with the invention, a power conversion apparatus comprises a plurality of power conversion units each employing the pulse width modulation method adapted for elimination of harmonics of specific orders. The power conversion units are connected to an ac power system so as to supply voltages of mutually different waveforms to the ac power system. Accordingly, even when there is imbalance between the voltages of the respective phases of the plurality of power conversion units, a cross current having a frequency of a fundamental component is prevented from flowing between the plurality of power conversion units. Third and ninth harmonics in the output voltage are thus suppressed.




The present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiments, and variations and modifications may be made without departing from the scope of the present invention.



Claims
  • 1. A power conversion apparatus comprising:two power conversion units, each power conversion unit producing multi-phase power, respective phases of each power conversion unit being connected in parallel via respective reactors and connected to a power system at a point of connection of the reactors, each of the two power conversion units being connected to a respective digitally-operated pulse width modulation apparatus, each digital pulse width modulation apparatus comprising: a pulse pattern storage unit storing numeral tables mapping a voltage instruction to pulse duration; and an operation instruction unit determining a target pulse pattern by referring to said pulse pattern storage unit in accordance with the voltage instruction, and supplying an operation instruction signal corresponding to the target pulse pattern to the power conversion unit, wherein the pulse pattern is calculated such that fifth harmonics, seventh harmonics, eleventh harmonics, and thirteenth harmonics of a voltage at the point of connection of the reactors are substantially zero, and third harmonics present in respective output voltages of-the two power conversion units are substantially identical in magnitude and are phase-displaced by 180° from each other, and the third harmonics present in the voltage at the point of connection of the reactors is smaller in magnitude than the third harmonic in each of the two power conversion units.
  • 2. The power conversion apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the pulse pattern includes information that requires switching five times in a half period of a fundamental wave.
  • 3. A power conversation apparatus comprising:three power conversion units, each power conversion unit producing multi-phase power, respective phases of each power conversion unit being connected in parallel via respective reactors and connected to a power system at a point of connection of the reactors, each of the three power conversion units being connected to a respective digitally-operated pulse width modulation apparatus, each digital pulse width modulation apparatus comprising: a pulse pattern storage unit storing numeral tables mapping a voltage instruction to pulse duration; and an operation instruction unit determining a target pulse pattern by referring to said pulse pattern storage unit in accordance with the voltage instruction, and supplying an operation instruction signal corresponding to the target pulse pattern to the power conversion unit, wherein the pulse pattern is calculated such that fifth harmonics, seventh harmonics, eleventh harmonics, and thirteenth harmonics of a voltage at the point of connection of the reactors are substantially zero, and third harmonics present in respective output voltages of the three power conversion units are substantially identical in magnitude and are phase-displaced by 120° from each other, and the third harmonics present in the voltage at the point of connection of the reactors is smaller in magnitude than the third harmonics occurring in each of the three power conversion units.
  • 4. The power conversion apparatus according to claim 3, wherein the pulse pattern includes information that requires switching five times in a half period of a fundamental wave.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
2000-160872 May 2000 JP
RELATED APPLICATION

This disclosure is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. 09/707,898, filed Nov. 8, 2000 now abandoned.

US Referenced Citations (17)
Number Name Date Kind
3781635 Saver Dec 1973 A
3876923 Humphrey et al. Apr 1975 A
3943429 Heintze Mar 1976 A
3979662 Klein Sep 1976 A
4204264 Lipman May 1980 A
4549258 Honbu et al. Oct 1985 A
4802079 Mizoguchi Jan 1989 A
4849870 Heinrich Jul 1989 A
4975822 Lipman Dec 1990 A
5016158 Matsui et al. May 1991 A
5047909 Hosoda Sep 1991 A
5168437 Gyugyi et al. Dec 1992 A
5198971 Recker et al. Mar 1993 A
5337227 Stacey et al. Aug 1994 A
5434771 Danby et al. Jul 1995 A
5515264 Stacey May 1996 A
5933339 Duba et al. Aug 1999 A
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
Patel et al.; “Generalized Techniques of Harmonic Elimination and Voltage Control in Thyristor Inverters: Part I-Harmonic Elimination”, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 1A-9, No. 3, May/Jun. 1973, pp. 310-317.
Continuation in Parts (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 09/707898 Nov 2000 US
Child 09/969041 US