Typically, in highly sensitive sensing environments, such as an aircraft, redundant sensing devices, such as pressure sensors, wheatstone bridge sensors, or other sensors where output is a function of an input voltage, are provided for sensing the same signal. This is due mainly to certain inabilities to determine the effectiveness of the voltage regulator that is associated with each of the individual sensors. Failures of these sensors may occur due to simple supply voltage irregularities or (low voltage) from malfunction of their associated voltage regulators, such as regulator drift.
Therefore, there exists a need to improve the reliability of sensors, thereby reducing the need for a plurality of redundant sensors and associated complex voting algorithms.
An embodiment of the present invention is a circuit that detects the following failure modes:
Low input voltage supply that does not allow the regulators to function properly
Regulator output drift (high or low)
Regulator failure (open or short circuit)
Wheatstone bridge open or short
Detection of these failure modes allows an end user to reduce the overall system complexity that would otherwise be required.
The preferred and alternative embodiments of the present invention are described in detail below with reference to the following drawings.
The supply voltage is received directly by the first voltage regulator 26 and passes through a first resistor 44 before it is received by the second regulator 28. The comparators 30 and 32 are essentially amplifiers configured as comparators. The first comparator 30 subtracts the output of the second regulator 28 from the output of the first regulator 26. The result of the comparator 30 is high if the difference between the two output regulator signals is below a threshold amount and is low if the difference is above the threshold amount. If the output of the comparator is high, the output of the comparator is the regulated voltage signal from the first regulator 26.
The second comparator 32 subtracts the output of the first regulator 26 from the output of the second regulator 28. Similar to comparator 30, the second comparator 32 outputs a high signal if the difference between the two signals is within a threshold amount and outputs a low signal if the difference between the two signals is greater than the threshold amount.
The outputs of the first and second comparators 30 and 32 are fed into the AND logic gate 36. The AND logic gate 36 supplies a voltage to the sensor 40 if the outputs of both comparators 30 and 32 are high (“on”) i.e., the regulators 26 and 28 have the same or nearly the same output. If either or both of the voltage outputs of the first and second comparators 30 and 32 are low (“off”), then no voltage is supplied to the sensor 40.
When the outputs of both comparators 30 and 32 are high, the AND logic gate 36 outputs the voltage that supplies power to the gate 36. In one embodiment, the power to the gate 36 is supplied by the output of the first regulator 26.
The circuit 20 can detect when a low input voltage is supplied; one that does not allow the regulators 26 and 28 to function properly. The circuit 20 can also determine if there is drift in either one of the regulators 26 or 28 or failure of the regulators, such as an open or short circuit.
The threshold network 110 allows for slight deviation of a couple of tenth of one percent to exist between the outputs of the regulators 104 and 106 without causing any slight deviation to flag a failure. This is done so that the tolerance on the regulators 104 and 106 does not have to be extremely high.
First and second comparators 114 and 116 compare the outputs of the threshold network 110. The comparators 114 and 116 produce high signals if the two regulator voltages that they receive match within a threshold voltage limit. If the compared regulator voltages differ by more than the threshold voltage limit, the comparators 114 and 116 produce a low signal. The outputs of the comparators 114 and 116 are entered into an AND logic gate 120. The AND logic gate 120 sends a regulated voltage signal to a sensor 124 if both comparators 114 and 116 produced high signals.
While the preferred embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, as noted above, many changes can be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. Accordingly, the scope of the invention is not limited by the disclosure of the preferred embodiment. Instead, the invention should be determined entirely by reference to the claims that follow.