Electrical wire insulation

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6753478
  • Patent Number
    6,753,478
  • Date Filed
    Friday, September 13, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, June 22, 2004
    20 years ago
Abstract
An electrical wire or cable having insulation comprisinga first layer of a polyolefin-based formulation, of which at least 20%, preferably at least 40%, more preferably at least 60% or very preferably at least 80% of the weight of the polymeric portion of the formulation consists of a carbonyl-containing polymer (homopolymer or copolymer or terpolymer), the at least one constituent monomer of the polymer being a carboxylic acid ester, preferably an acrylate or acetate, especially an alkyl acrylate (preferably methyl acrylate, ethyl acrylate, propyl acrylate or butyl acrylate), the monomer itself being at least 5%, preferably at least 9%, more preferably at least 15% by weight of the said co- or terpolymer when used, and the remainder or the majority of the remainder of the said co- or terpolymer preferably being derived from olefinic monomer, preferably ethylene;a second layer of another material formulation in contact with the first layer, containing at least 10%, more preferably at least 50%, very preferably at least 90%, especially 100%, by weight of the second layer, of non-PVDF-based fluoropolymer, preferably based on ETFE or ECTFE;wherein the first and second layers are cross-linked while in contact with each other, preferably by radiation, more preferably ionising radiation, sufficient to create a significant bond between the two layers, or to increase the peel bond strength between the layers to at least 3N, preferably increasing the bond strength by at least 50%, more preferably by at least 100%, especially by at least 500% or 1000%, compared to that between the layers prior to being cross-linked.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to insulation for electrical wire or cable.




Wire and cable with chemically-resistant dual-wall insulation comprising a polyolefin inner layer and a fluoropolymer outer layer have been commercially available for over 30 years. Such insulation suffers, from a number of performance shortcomings, including a tendency to wrinkling, crack propagation, and peeling of the outer insulation layer.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




It has now been surprisingly discovered, according to the present invention, that improved insulation can be provided by a first layer comprising a selected carbonyl-containing polymer and an adjacent second layer comprising a selected fluoropolymer. These layers can be bonded together by cross-linking to provide insulation having improved performance characteristics in one or more areas such as resistance to abrasion, peeling (especially if one of layers is damaged), blistering (especially if beat is applied), delamination, creasing and wrinkling (especially when the insulation is subject to mechanical stress or exposure to solvents).




Throughout this specification, including the claims, the terms “a”, “an” and “the” before an item mean that there can be a single such item or two or more such items, unless the context makes this impossible (for example, in the first aspect of the invention, the first polymeric componene can comprise a single carbonyl-containing polymer as defined or two or more such polymers; and the second polymeric component can contain a single fluoropolymer or a mixture of two or more fluropolymers); and the term “consisting essentially of” certain ingredients means that those ingredients are necessarily present and that other ingredients may be present providing that they do not have an adverse effect on the desired properties of the insulation.




In a first aspect, this invention provides an electrical wire or cable having insulation comprising:




(I) a first layer which is composed of a first polymeric composition consisting of a first polymeric component and optionally a first non-polymeric component, the first polymeric component comprising at least 20%, preferably at least 40%, more preferably at least 60% or at least 80%, by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, (or, in some embodiments, based on the weight of the whole composition) of a carbonyl-containing polymer (which may be a homopolymer or copolymer, including terpolymer, and which preferably has a non-aromatic backbone), the carbonyl-containing polymer comprising repeating units derived from a monomer which (i) can be copolymerized with an olefinic monomer and (ii) contains a carboxylic acid ester group, preferably an acrylate or acetate, especially an alkyl acrylate (preferably methyl acrylate, ethyl acrylate, propyl acrylate or butyl acrylate), the units derived from said monomer constituting at least 5%, preferably at least 9%, more preferably at least 15%, for example 15 to 28%, by weight of the carbonyl-containing polymer, and any other repeating units of the carbonyl-containing polymer preferably being derived from an olefinic monomer, preferably ethylene;




(II) a second layer which is in direct contact with the first layer at an interface, and which is composed of a second polymeric composition consisting of a second polymeric component and optionally a second non-polymeric component, the second polymeric component comprising at least 10%, preferably at least 50%, particularly at least 90%, for example substantially 100%, by weight based on the weight of the second composition, of a fluoropolymer, and being free of polymers containing more than 50% by weight, based on the weight of the polymer, of repeating units derived from vinylidene fluoride.




Preferably, the layers (I) and (II), while in contact with each other, have been subjected to conditions which cause cross-linking of polymers at the interface between them, preferably by subjecting the layers to radiation, particularly ionising radiation. The cross-linking is preferably such that at least one of the following conditions is fulfilled




(i) the peel bond strength between the layers, measured by ASTM 81876-95, is at least 3N, preferably more than 5N, e.g. more than 10N




(ii) when a sample of the electrical wire or cable is subjected to steps (a), (b) and (c), there is no delamination of the two layers, step (a) being to slit the insulation axially over a length of 50 mm down to the conductor, step (b) being to wrap the wire around a mandrel whose diameter is twice the diameter of the insulated wire, with the slit on the outside of the wrapped wire, thus exposing the conductor, and step (c) being to unwrap the wire from the mandrel until the wire is straight, and




(iii) the peel bond strength after the crosslinking, measured by ASTM B1876-95, is at least 50% greater, preferably at least 100% greater especially at least 500% or 1000% greater, than the peel bond strength before the crosslinking, measured by ASTM B1876-95.




Throughout this specification, including the claims, the terms “a”, “an” and “the” before an item mean that there can be a single such item or two or more such items, unless the context makes this impossible (for example, in the first aspect of the invention, the first polymeric component can comprise a single carbonyl-containing polymer as defined or two or more such polymers; and the second polymeric component can contain a single fluoropolymer or a mixture of two or more fluoropolymers); and the term “consisting essentially of” certain ingredients means that those ingredients are necessarily present and that other ingredients may be present providing that they do not have an adverse effect on the desired properties of the insulation.




A second aspect of the invention provides a method of making an insulated wire or cable, the method comprising the steps of




(A) providing an electrical conductor surrounded by




(i) a first layer which is composed of a first polymeric composition as defined in the first aspect of the invention; and




(ii) a second layer which is composed of a second polymeric composition as defined in the first aspect of the invention;




the first and second layers being in direct contact with each other at an interface; and




(B) exposing the layers while in contact with each other to ionising radiation which causes cross-linking of polymers at the interface.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING




The FIGURE in the accompanying drawings is a diagrammatic cross-section, not to scale, of an insulated wire according to the invention, showing a metallic conductor


1


, an inner insulating layer


2


, and an outer insulating layer


3


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




When the first polymeric component does not consist solely of the carbonyl-containing polymer, any other polymer present in the first polymeric component is preferably a polyolefin, particularly high-density polyethylene.




The fluoropolymer in the second polymeric composition is preferably selected from copolymers of tetrafluoroethylene and ethylene and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of tetrafluoroethylene and vinylidene fluoride and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of chlorotrifluoroethylene and ethylene and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of hexafluoropropylene and ethylene and optionally third comonomer, and copolymers of hexafluoropropylene and vinylidene fluoride and optionally a third comonomer.




Each of the layers (I) and (II) optionally contains polyolefin-based layer (I), in addition to the polymeric component of the composition, a non-polymeric component comprising additives such as anti-oxidants, pigments, fillers, flame retardants, etc. to enhance mechanical, thermal, electrical etc. properties of the polymeric composition.




In the method of the invention, step (A) can make use of any process which causes intimate contact between the layers (I) and (II). Examples include coating one of the polymeric compositions onto a pre-formed layer of the other, and dual or multi-walled extrusion to form insulation layers respectively containing one or other of the polymeric compositions. Preferably, the layer (I) composed of the first composition (which comprises the carbonyl-containing polymer) is an inner layer and the fluoropolymer-based layer (II) is an outer layer on the wire. The layers made from the two different compositions can be coextruded, tandem extruded, multipass extruded, or coated by other means. Known wire insulation processes such as tube draw-down extrusion may be used, to form one or more of the layers, but pressure extrusion as known per se is preferred for optimum adhesion of the second and any subsequent insulation layers to be applied to a pre-formed underlying layer.




In step (B) of the method of the invention, the insulation on the wire is exposed to conditions which cause a cross-linking reaction. The cross-linking which may involve chemical reagents such as peroxides, but preferably is effected by radiation, especially radiation from a source of ionising radiation capable of causing the formation of free radicals and thus, cross-links, in the polymers, some of which should preferably be formed in the region of the interface between the two compositions. Penetration of the radiation into the insulation at least as far as the interface is therefore desirable, although not necessarily essential if ion or radical mobility, for example, enables molecular reactions to continue at or near the interface after the radiation process. The radiation source could, for example, be a radio-isotope, or an X-ray source, or possibly a non-ionising radical-generating source, for example a UV source, but is preferably an electron beam, more preferably one providing a beam dose greater than 2 Mrads, preferably at least 5 Mrads, more preferably at least 10 Mrads, very preferably at least 15 Mrads, into the material.




It has been found that, when the cross-linking is effected by ionizing radiation, enhancements to the interfacial bond strength may be obtained by including a cross-linking promoter (“pro-rad”) in the first and/or second polymeric composition. Known pro-rads may be used, preferably methacrylate/acrylate based pro-rads, e.g. trimethylolpropanetrimethacrylate (TMPTM), or pro-rads of the multifunctional allyl type, preferably triallyl cyanurate (TAC), more preferably triallyl isocyanurate (TAIC).




Experimental Results




All results quoted in the tables below were obtained by testing pressed plaques of the two materials prepared by the usual polymer handling techniques, well known per se. The plaques were pressed together to adhere them temporarily face-to-face and the adhering plaques were then irradiated as indicated. Plaques were used to represent the layers I and II for these demonstration experiments, due to the relative ease of measuring bond strength on plaques, rather than on wires. Conditions for these experiments were as follows:




Plaque dimensions: 150 mm by 150 mm by 0.85 mm Pressing temperature: 220° C.




Pressing time: 2 minute preheat, 1 minute at pressure




Pressing pressure: 20-40 Tons between 300 mm by 300 mm metal plates




Cooling conditions: 2 minutes at same pressure with same plates water cooled.




In the Experimental Results shown below, the first composition (comprising the carbonyl-containing polymer) is referred to as the polyolefin-based material and as Material


1


, and the second composition is referred to as the fluoropolymer-based material and as Material


2


; and the following abbreviations are used (in addition to those already given). EEA is ethylene/ethyl acrylate copolymer. EMA is ethylene/methyl acrylate copolymer. HDPE is high-density polyethylene. PVDF is polyvinylidene fluoride. ETFE is ethylene/tetrafluoroethylene copolymer. ECTFE is ethylene/chlorotrifluoroethylene copolymer. MFR is melt flow rate.




















Dose




Mean maximum






Material 1




Material 2




(Mrads)




peel force (N)























Example of Effect of Radiation Dose on Bond strength developed






between appropriate polyolefin and fluoropolymer-based materials














EEA copolymer of




ETFE of MFR* = 33




0




0.5






15 wt % EA content






EEA copolymer of




ETFE of MFR* = 33




20




9






15 wt % EA content






EMA copolymer of




ETFE of MFR* = 33




0




0.8






28 wt % MA






content






EMA copolymer of




ETFE of MFR* = 33




20




5






28 wt % MA






content






EEA copolymer of




ETFE of MFR* =




0




0.5






15 wt % EA content




5.5 + 5 wt % TAC






EEA copolymer of




ETFE of MFR* =




20




17.5






15 wt % EA content




5.5 + 5 wt % TAC






EEA copolymer of




ECTFE of MFR** =




0




1.5






15 wt % EA content




11






EEA copolymer of




ECTFE of MFR** =




20




28






15 wt % EA content




11






EEA copolymer of




Terpolymer of tetra-




0




1.8






15 wt % EA content




fluoroethylene, hexa-







fluoropropylene &







vinylidene fluoride of







MFR** = 13






EEA copolymer of




Terpolymer of tetra-




20




36






15 wt % EA content




fluoroethylene, hexa-







fluoropropylene &







vinylidene fluoride of







MFR** = 13






EEA copolymer of




Terpolymer of hexa-




0




2.4






15 wt % EA content




fluoropropylene, tetra-







fluoroethylene &







ethylene of MFR** =







6.7






EEA copolymer of




Terpolymer of hexa-




20




13






15 wt % EA content




fluoropropylene, tetra-







fluoroethylene &







ethylene of MFR** =







6.7











Example of Effect of the addition of Pro-rad in fluoropolymer-based






material on bond strength with appropriate polyolefin-based material






after electron beam crosslinking














EEA copolymer of




ETFE of




20




6.5






15 wt % EA content




MFR* = 5.5






EEA copolymer of




ETFE of




20




17.5






15 wt % EA content




MFR* = 5.5 + 5 wt %







TAC











Effect of percentage Copolymer in a polyolefin polymer blend on bond






strength with appropriate non-PVDF-based fluoropolymer-based






material after electron beam crosslinking














100% HDPE




ETFE of MFR* = 33




20




0






100% EEA




ETFE of MFR* = 33




20




9






copolymer of






15 wt % EA content











The Melt Flow Rate (MFR) used to describe the fluoropolymers in the tables above is quoted in units of grammes/10 minutes and was measured according to ASTM D1238-95 under the following conditions;










*297° C./5 Kg










**265° C./5 Kg.













Examples of Wire Construction




An electrical wire in which the insulation consists of two polymeric layers bonded together according to the present invention was made as follows:




The inner layer of insulation (I) (i.e. nearer to the wire conductor) was a polyolefin-based material, consisting predominantly of (a) an EEA copolymer containing 15 wt % EA and (b) HDPE in a weight ratio of approximately 8:2 copolymer:HDPE, with usual other additives present in smaller proportions including crosslinking promoters, stabilisers, antioxidants, pigments and process aids at a total level of 24 wt %. This layer was pressure extruded onto the metallic conductor.




The outer layer of insulation (II) consisted predominantly of an ETFE copolymer, which in this example contains a crosslinking promoter at 8 wt %. This outer layer was pressure extruded in a separate operation onto the pre-formed inner layer. This coated wire product was then passed through an electron beam, and received a radiation dose of 20 Mrads.




In a second example a wire was made as above, in which the additives of the inner layer were added at a total level of 22.9 wt % and the outer layer was comprised solely of the ETFE copolymer. This coated wire product was then passed through an electron beam, and received a radiation dose of 20 Mrads.




Demonstration of Improved Performance of Wire as in the Example above, Relative to a Wire of Similar Construction in which the Inner and Outer Insulation Layers are not Bonded.




A wire of the above construction and manufacturing process (designated wire A) was compared with another crosslinked but non-bonded polyolefin/ETFE dual-walled wire (designated wire B) of the same dimensions, over a range of tests for wire robustness relevant to harsh handling and end use environments. The following results were obtained.




Example of Resistance to Insulation Separation Improvement




Method: wire size 0.75 mm


2


, wire insulation slit to depth of conductor along wire axis, slit length 50 mm, 4 close-pitched wraps around a 3.60 mm mandrel then unwrapped until straight, temperature 23° C.
















Wire Type




Result of insulation separation test











A




No spontaneous separation/delamination of







core and PJ observed






B




PJ spontaneously wrinkled and separated from core














Example of Scrape Abrasion Resistance Improvement




Method: Equipment=conventional type wire scrape abrader, wire size 0.75 mm


2


(conductor cross sectional area), blade type angled 90°, with 0.225 mm radiused edge contact point, applied load 0.5 Kg, stroke length 10 mm, at 55 cycles/minute, temperature 23° C.
















Wire Type




No. of scrape cycles to abrade through PJ
























A




540






B




129













Claims
  • 1. An electrical wire or cable having insulation comprising(I) a first layer which is composed of a first polymeric composition consisting of a first polymeric component and optionally a first non-polymeric component, the first polymeric component comprising at least 20% by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, of a carbonyl-containing polymer comprising at least 5% by weight, based on the weight of the carbonyl-containing polymer, of repeating units derived from a monomer which can be copolymerized with an olefinic monomer and which contains a carboxylic acid ester group; and (II) a second layer which is in direct contact with the first layer at an interface, and which is composed of a second polymeric composition consisting of a second polymeric component and optionally a second non-polymeric component, the second polymeric component comprising at least 10% by weight, based on the weight of second polymeric composition, of a fluoropolymer, and being free of polymers containing more than 50% by weight, based on the weight of the polymer, of repeating units derived from vinylidene fluoride.
  • 2. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein the first and second layers have been subjected, while in direct contact with each other, to conditions which cause crosslinking of polymers at the interface between them.
  • 3. A wire or cable according to claim 2 wherein the crosslinking of polymers at the interface is such that at least one of the following conditions is fulfilled:(i) the peel bond strength between the layers, measured by ASTM 81876-95, is at least 3N, (ii) when a sample of the electrical wire or cable is subjected to steps (a), (b) and (c), there is no delamination of the two layers, step (a) being to slit the insulation axially over a length of 50 mm down to the conductor, step (b) being to wrap the wire around a mandrel whose diameter is twice the diameter of the insulated wire, with the slit on the outside of the wrapped wire, thus exposing the conductor, and step (c) being to unwrap the wire from the mandrel until the wire is straight, and (iii) the peel bond strength after the crosslinking, measured by ASTM B1876-95, is at least 100% greater than the peel bond strength before the crosslinking, measured by ASTM B1876-95.
  • 4. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein the first polymeric component consists essentially of the carbonyl-containing polymer and a polyolefin.
  • 5. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein the first polymeric component contains at least 60% by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, of the carbonyl-containing polymer, and the second polymeric composition contains at least 50% by weight, based on the weight of the second composition, of the fluoropolymer.
  • 6. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein the first polymeric component contains 80 to 100% by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, of the carbonyl-containing polymer.
  • 7. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein the carbonyl-containing polymer contains 15 to 28% by weight, based on the weight of the carbonyl-containing polymer, of the repeating units containing a carboxylic acid ester group.
  • 8. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein the second polymeric component comprises at least 90% by weight, based on the weight of the second polymeric composition, of the fluoropolymer.
  • 9. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein each fluoropolymer in the second polymeric component is selected from copolymers of tetrafluoroethylene and ethylene and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of tetrafluoroethylene and vinylidene fluoride and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of chlorotrifluoroethylene and ethylene and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of hexafluoropropylene and ethylene and optionally third comonomer, and copolymers of hexafluoropropylene and vinylidene fluoride and optionally a third comonomer.
  • 10. A wire or cable according to claim 1 wherein the first layer is an inner layer and the second layer is an outer layer.
  • 11. An insulated electrical wire comprising(1) a metallic conductor, and (2) insulation which comprises (I) an inner layer which is composed of a first polymeric composition consisting of a first polymeric component and optionally a first non-polymeric component, the first polymeric component consisting essentially of 60 to 100% by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, of a carbonyl-containing polymer, and 0 to 40% by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, of a polyolefin, the carbonyl-containing polymer consisting essentially of (a) 9 to 100% by weight, based on the weight of the carbonyl-containing polymer, of repeating units derived from a monomer which can be copolymerized with an olefin and which contains a carboxylic acid ester group, and (b) 91 to 0% by weight, based on the weight of the carbonyl-containing polymer, of repeating units derived from an olefin; and (II) an outer layer which surrounds and directly contacts the first layer at an interface, and which is composed of a second polymeric composition consisting of a second polymeric component and optionally a second non-polymeric component, the second polymeric component comprising at least 50% by weight, based on the weight of second polymeric composition, of one or more fluoropolymers, and being free of polymers containing more than 50% by weight, based on the weight of the polymer, of repeating units derived from vinylidene fluoride.
  • 12. An insulated wire according to claim 11 wherein the inner and outer layers have been subjected, while in direct contact with each other to ionizing radiation which causes crosslinking of polymers at the interface, and at least one of the layers contains a crosslinking promoter before it is irradiated.
  • 13. An insulated wire according to claim 12 wherein the crosslinking of polymers at the interface is such that at least one of the following conditions is fulfilled(i) the peel bond strength between the layers, measured by ASTM 81876-95, is at least 3N, (ii) when a sample of the electrical wire or cable is subjected to steps (a), (b) and (c), there is no delamination of the two layers, step (a) being to slit the insulation axially over a length of 50 mm down to the conductor, step (b) being to wrap the wire around a mandrel whose diameter is twice the diameter of the insulated wire, with the slit on the outside of the wrapped wire, thus exposing the conductor, and step (c) being to unwrap the wire from the mandrel until the wire is straight, and (iii) the peel bond strength after the crosslinking, measured by ASTM B1876-95, is at least 100% greater than the peel bond strength before the crosslinking, measured by ASTM B1876-95.
  • 14. An insulated wire according to claim 12 wherein the first polymeric component contains 80 to 100% by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, of the carbonyl-containing polymer, and the carbonyl-containing polymer contains 15 to 28% by weight, based on the weight of the carbonyl-containing polymer, of the repeating units containing a carboxylic acid ester group.
  • 15. An insulated wire according to claim 12 wherein the repeating units containing a carboxylic acid ester group are derived from vinyl acetate or an alkyl acrylate, and the first composition comprises a mixture of the carbonyl-containing polymer and high-density polyethylene.
  • 16. An insulated wire according to claim 12 wherein the second polymeric component comprises at least 90% by weight, based on the weight of the second polymeric composition, of one or more fluoropolymers.
  • 17. An insulated wire according to claim 12 wherein each fluoropolymer in the second polymeric component is selected from the group consisting of copolymers of tetrafluoroethylene and ethylene and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of tetrafluoroethylene and vinylidene fluoride and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of chlorotrifluoroethylene and ethylene and optionally a third comonomer, copolymers of hexafluoropropylene and ethylene and optionally third comonomer, and copolymers of hexafluoropropylene and vinylidene fluoride and optionally a third comonomer.
  • 18. An insulated wire according to claim 12 wherein the inner layer directly contacts the metallic conductor.
  • 19. A method of making an insulated wire or cable, the method comprising the steps of(A) providing an electrical conductor surrounded by (I) a first layer which is composed of a first polymeric composition consisting of a first polymeric component and optionally a first non-polymeric component, the first polymeric component comprising at least 20% by weight, based on the weight of the first polymeric component, of a carbonyl-containing polymer containing at least 5% by weight, based on the weight of the carbonyl-containing polymer, of repeating units derived from a monomer which can be copolymerized with an olefinic comonomer and which contains a carboxylic acid ester group; and (II) a second layer which is composed of a second polymeric composition consisting of a second polymeric component and optionally a second non-polymeric component, the second polymeric component comprising at least 10% by weight, based on the weight of second polymeric composition, of a fluoropolymer, and being free of polymers containing more than 50% by weight, based on the weight of the polymer, of repeating units derived from vinylidene fluoride; the first and second layers being in direct contact with each other at an interface; and (B) exposing the layers while in contact with each other to ionizing radiation which causes cross-linking of polymers at the interface.
  • 20. A method according to claim 19 wherein step (A) comprises bringing the respective layers into contact with each other at a temperature above the melting or softening point of the polymeric component in at least one of the layers.
  • 21. A method according to claim 19 wherein at least one of the first and second polymeric compositions contains a radiation cross-linking promoter.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
0006333 Mar 2000 GB
PCT Information
Filing Document Filing Date Country Kind
PCT/GB01/01143 WO 00
Publishing Document Publishing Date Country Kind
WO01/69610 9/20/2001 WO A
US Referenced Citations (14)
Number Name Date Kind
3269862 Lanza et al. Aug 1966 A
3632441 Bilow Jan 1972 A
3650827 Brown et al. Mar 1972 A
3864228 Rosetti, Jr. Feb 1975 A
4454249 Suzuki et al. Jun 1984 A
4575533 Horie et al. Mar 1986 A
4606595 Dola Aug 1986 A
4621107 Lagow et al. Nov 1986 A
4693940 Vogdes et al. Sep 1987 A
5589028 Robinson et al. Dec 1996 A
5958532 Krause et al. Sep 1999 A
6074719 Fukushi et al. Jun 2000 A
6096428 Jing et al. Aug 2000 A
6251506 Davis et al. Jun 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (6)
Number Date Country
0 089 266 Sep 1983 EP
0 528 611 Feb 1993 EP
1117118 Oct 1965 GB
WO 8900759 Jan 1989 WO
WO 9727260 Jul 1997 WO
WO 0017889 Mar 2000 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (8)
Entry
British Search Report for British Application No. GB 0006333.9, dated Jul. 26, 2000.
British Search Report for British Application No. GB 9820214.6, dated Feb. 2, 1999.
International Search Report for International Application No. PCT/GB99/03116 dated Jan. 18, 2000.
International Search Report for International Application No. PCT/GB01/01143, filed Jun. 1, 2001.
WPI Abstract Accession No. 92-296862 & JP4206404 (Jul. 28, 1992), abstract only.
WPI Abstract Accession No. 93-002962 & JP4329212 (Nov. 18, 1992), abstract only.
WPI Abstract Accession No. 93-002963 & JP4329213 (Nov. 18, 1992), abstract only.
WPI Abstract Accession No. 94-054027 & JP6009844 (Jan. 18, 1994), abstract only.