The present invention relates to fabrication of electrochemical devices, and in particular, processes for electrochemical device electrode deposition with low temperature anneal.
All solid state Thin Film Batteries (TFB) are known to exhibit several advantages over conventional battery technology such as superior form factors, cycle life, power capability and safety. However, there is a need for cost effective and high-volume manufacturing (HVM) compatible fabrication technologies to enable broad market applicability of TFBs.
Most of the past and current state-of-the-art approaches, as they pertain to TFB and TFB fabrication technologies, have been conservative, wherein the efforts have been limited to scaling the basic technologies of the original Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) device development that started in the early 1990s. A summary of ORNL TFB development can be found in N. J. Dudney, Materials Science and Engineering B 116, (2005) 245-249.
As shown in
Next, in
Finally, in
There may be an additional “barrier” layer deposition step, prior to the CCC 102, if the CCC does not function as the barrier and if the substrate and patterning/architecture call for such a barrier layer. Also, the protective coating need not be a vacuum deposition step.
In typical processes, annealing of the cathode layer 106 will be required in order to improve the crystallinity of the layer if, for example, the TFB performance specification calls for “plateau of operating voltage”, high power capability and extended cycle life.
While some improvements have been made to the original ORNL approaches, there are many problems with the prior art fabrication processes for TFBs that prevent them from being compatible with cost effective and high-volume manufacturing (HVM), and thereby preclude broad market applicability of TFBs. For example, an issue with the state-of-the-art thin film cathode and cathode deposition process includes a need for a high temperature anneal to achieve a desirable crystalline phase, which adds to process complexity, low throughput and limitations on the choice of substrate materials.
Accordingly, a need remains in the art for fabrication processes and technologies for TFBs that are compatible with cost effective and high-volume manufacturing (HVM), and thereby enable broad market applicability of TFBs.
The present invention relates to methods and apparatuses that overcome a key problem of current state-of-the-art fabrication technologies for thin film batteries (TFBs) that precludes broader market applications. The invention relates to the application of a low cost, high throughput PVD deposition process followed by anneal for cathode layers in thin film batteries. The deposition process is a high chamber pressure and high substrate temperature PVD deposition process—potentially up to 100 mTorr or more and up to 450° C. or higher for LiCoO2 deposition—which permits annealing at significantly lower temperatures than low and medium range pressure and temperature deposition processes. The lower temperature anneal of less than 450° C.—low compared with the published standards ranging from 650° C. to 700° C.—provides a significant increase in throughput due to the shorter heat up and cool down times, as well as cost savings associated with lower power consumption of the furnace. (Note that the increase in throughput at the furnace more than compensates for the longer deposition time for the high pressure process and furthermore that deposition time can be reduced for the high pressure process by adjusting the argon to oxygen gas ratio and the power.) Furthermore, the lower temperature anneal leads to lower temperature induced thermal damage, such as stress induced fractures of the annealed layers and even to peeling of the layers, thus avoiding the thermal damage which can lead to yield losses and therefore, higher cost per produced cell. Yet furthermore, the lower temperature anneal may allow for elimination of an ex-situ anneal—a single integrated tool may be used for deposition and anneal. Furthermore, it is anticipated that it may be possible to eliminate the anneal altogether, according to some embodiments of the present invention. Herein, the PVD deposition process may include sputter deposition or thermal deposition, the latter including one or more of electron beam evaporation, laser ablation, inductive heating, etc.
According to some embodiments of the present invention, a method of manufacturing an electrochemical device may comprise: depositing a LiCoO2 layer over a substrate using a sputter deposition process in a deposition chamber, wherein the chamber deposition pressure is greater than about 10 mTorr, and the substrate temperature is between about room temperature (22° C.) and about 450° C. or higher and the target comprises LiCoO2; and annealing the LiCoO2 layer for crystallizing the cathode layer, wherein the annealing temperature is about 450° C. or less and wherein the annealed LiCoO2 layer is characterized by an A1g mode peak at about 593 cm−1 with a peak FWHM (full width at half maximum) of less than or equal to about 12 cm−1 using Raman spectroscopy. Furthermore, the chamber deposition pressure may be greater than or equal to about 15 mTorr, about 30 mTorr, or even up to about 100 mTorr, the substrate temperature may be up to about 450° C. or higher, or between about 22° C. and about 300° C. and the anneal temperature may be about 450° C. or less, about 400° C. or less, or in some cases may be eliminated altogether. The argon to oxygen gas ratio in the deposition chamber and application of a bias voltage to the target and/or substrate may also be varied to improve throughput for the low temperature anneal process of the present invention. Further variations of process parameters may be used to provide the desired outcome of a high temperature phase cathode layer with a lower temperature anneal, as described herein. LiCoO2 cathode layers without cracks after annealing, even with high temperature (650° C.) anneal, have been demonstrated for the high chamber pressure and high substrate temperature PVD processes according to some embodiments of the present invention.
Furthermore, the principles and teaching of the present invention may be applicable to the PVD deposition of other materials and to electrode layers in other devices such as electrochromic devices. For example, the present invention may provide low annealing temperatures for electrode materials in electrochemical devices, where examples of electrode materials include lithium cobalt oxides, nickel cobalt aluminum oxides, nickel cobalt manganese oxides, spinel-based oxides, olivine based phosphates, and lithium titanates, and where examples of electrochemical devices include thin film batteries and electrochromic devices. Examples of process conditions may include wherein the chamber deposition pressure is greater than about 10 mTorr, about 15 mTorr, about 30 mTorr, or even up to about 100 mTorr, the substrate temperature is between about room temperature (22° C.) and about 450° C. or higher, or between about 22° C. and about 300° C. and the anneal temperature is about 450° C. or less, about 400° C. or less, or in some cases may be eliminated altogether.
Furthermore, some embodiments of the present invention are tools for fabrication of the cathode layers with high deposition pressure and deposition temperature and low temperature anneal for crystallization.
These and other aspects and features of the present invention will become apparent to those ordinarily skilled in the art upon review of the following description of specific embodiments of the invention in conjunction with the accompanying figures, wherein:
The present invention will now be described in detail with reference to the drawings, which are provided as illustrative examples of the invention so as to enable those skilled in the art to practice the invention. Notably, the figures and examples below are not meant to limit the scope of the present invention to a single embodiment, but other embodiments are possible by way of interchange of some or all of the described or illustrated elements. Moreover, where certain elements of the present invention can be partially or fully implemented using known components, only those portions of such known components that are necessary for an understanding of the present invention will be described, and detailed descriptions of other portions of such known components will be omitted so as not to obscure the invention. In the present specification, an embodiment showing a singular component should not be considered limiting; rather, the invention is intended to encompass other embodiments including a plurality of the same component, and vice-versa, unless explicitly stated otherwise herein. Moreover, applicants do not intend for any term in the specification or claims to be ascribed an uncommon or special meaning unless explicitly set forth as such. Further, the present invention encompasses present and future known equivalents to the known components referred to herein by way of illustration.
Often in electrochemical devices, the active materials (in their final form) need to have good crystallinity, as opposed to having an amorphous or even microcrystalline structure. A typical cathode material in batteries (thin film or bulk) is LiCoO2, which is deposited as an amorphous or microcrystalline layer under typical conditions of physical vapor deposition (PVD). As such, the deposited layers need to be annealed, typically using a furnace, to crystallize the film. The furnace temperature has to ramp up to hundreds of degrees to fully crystallize the film. This furnace anneal process takes several hours to complete as it goes through ramp up, soak, and cool down stages. While the throughput implications can be overcome with multiple furnaces, such an approach can lead to high cost of capital investment. In addition, the furnace anneal appears to deteriorate the interface between the cathode and cathode current collector and the properties (for example, the electrical conductivity) of the cathode current collector, leading to battery cells with higher impedance for poorer power (discharge/charge rate) capability. Furthermore, furnace anneal processes cause cracking of the LiCoO2 cathode film due to a mismatch of the thermal expansion coefficient between the cathode and the substrate, where typical substrate materials are Si/SiN, glass, mica, metal foils, etc. Other radiation based rapid thermal annealing may be used. However, the breadth of wavelengths in typical broad spectrum lamps (a laser would be too expensive) means that the result of lamp annealing is very similar to that for the standard furnace anneal, including the undesirable side effects and throughput issues.
The typical PVD processes for cathode materials such as LiCoO2 are in the middle or low deposition pressure region close to 5 mTorr and films produced by these conditions need high temperature—at least 650° C.—furnace (or lamp-based) annealing processes to fully crystallize them. In order to use low temperature furnace (or lamp and other electromagnetic wave-based) annealing processes, which avoid the unwanted side effects of a high temperature anneal, the present invention provides LiCoO2 cathode deposition processes with higher chamber deposition pressure, and optionally one or more of higher substrate deposition temperature, higher O2 to Ar gas ratio, applying bias to the pedestal and plasma treatments. Of these process conditions, for some of the embodiments of the present invention the higher deposition pressure and deposition temperature are the critical conditions to be satisfied. Furthermore, it is anticipated that it may be possible to eliminate the anneal altogether, according to some embodiments of the present invention. In general, the present invention overcomes one of the key problems of current state-of-the-art thin film battery (TFB) technologies that preclude them from being compatible with cost-effective and high-volume manufacturing. Herein, deposition pressure is used to refer to chamber pressure during deposition and deposition temperature is used to refer to substrate temperature during deposition. Furthermore, substrate temperature may be measured at the substrate pedestal when there is good thermal conductance between substrate and pedestal, or at the substrate using, for example, a pyrometer.
An example of a typical industry standard PVD deposition process for today which requires a high temperature anneal—650° C.—to provide a LiCoO2 cathode layer with good crystallinity is provided as follows. The process is used to deposit a several micron thick layer of LiCoO2 cathode material at a deposition rate of approximately 1 to 2 μm/hr-kW on a 200 mm diameter silicon substrate with a Ti/Au cathode current collector. An Applied Materials Endura™ 200 PVD chamber was used for a sputter deposition process, with the following process conditions.
A Raman spectrum of the deposited film is shown in FIG. 4—this is an example of a film with the high temperature (HT) crystalline phase. Other PVD chambers, operated under high throughput conditions—typically low or mid-range pressure, ambient substrate deposition temperature, pulsed DC—can also be used to deposit the cathode layer. Note that the gas in the deposition chamber for a sputter deposition process, for example LiCoO2 sputter deposition, will typically be comprised of argon, optionally plus a reactive gas. For non-sputter deposition PVD processes reactive gases and/or carrier gases may be used.
An example of a cathode deposition process according to some embodiments of the present invention which enables a lower temperature anneal—450° C. or maybe less—to provide a cathode layer with good crystallinity—see definition of good crystallinity provided below—is provided as follows. The process used to deposit an approximately several micron thick layer of LiCoO2 cathode material was at a deposition rate of approximately 0.8 μm/hr-kW on a 200 mm diameter silicon substrate with a Ti/Au cathode current collector. An Applied Materials Endura™ 200 PVD chamber was used for the deposition process, with the following process conditions.
Note that the pulsed DC settings were chosen simply for the purpose of demonstrating the process according to some embodiments of the present invention; it is expected that different settings can be used. Furthermore, the process conditions listed above are an example and are not intended to be limiting, as it is expected that a wide range of process conditions may be utilized and achieve the desired result. Also, it is expected that good crystallinity may be achieved with even lower temperature anneals by extending the process regime described above. Other PVD chambers, operated under the conditions of the present invention can also be used to deposit the cathode layer.
Typically, crystalline LiCoO2 can have two phases, a low temperature phase (not desired for battery applications) and a high temperature phase (desired). As deposited LiCoO2 is typically a low temperature phase material. In Raman spectra, the high temperature phase LiCoO2 has an A1g mode in the range of about 590 cm−1 to about 596 cm−1 (at about 593 cm−1 or slightly higher in the examples provided herein) and the low temperature phase LiCoO2 has an A1g mode in the range of about 575 cm−1 to about 584 cm−1. Note that the Raman peak positions may shift due, for example, to film stress and calibration of the measurement tool; furthermore, the peak positions are given herein for pure phase materials, and if both high temperature and low temperature phases are present, the peaks will need to be deconvoluted to properly determine the high and low temperature phase peak positions.
Importantly,
As indicated above, the Ar to O2 flow based ratio plays a role in reducing the thermal budget, although this maybe not be as significant as the deposition pressure and temperature. Specifically, the greater the oxygen content, the greater the reduction in anneal requirement. Furthermore, an interaction has been observed between deposition temperature, chamber pressure and Ar/O2 flow based ratio, where the signal is more prominent at higher chamber pressure and/or higher deposition temperatures. At higher chamber pressure and/or higher deposition temperature, greater oxygen content definitely enhances the thermal budget requirement during low temperature post-deposition annealing. However, higher oxygen content also leads to a greater propensity to form Co3O4, an impurity phase detrimental to capacity and cycle life. Also, it appears that an Ar/O2 range of pure Ar to 90% Ar significantly increases the deposition rate, more than 2 times over the rate for an Ar/O2 ratio of lower than 4. Based on these observations, a process with an Ar/O2 ratio above 80% Ar is recommend in most circumstances for high throughput LiCoO2 deposition processes with lower post-deposition annealing requirement and purer high temperature LiCoO2 phase content.
Furthermore, in some embodiments other process conditions may be varied as well as the chamber pressure in order to enhance the LiCoO2 cathode deposition process. For example, applying a DC bias to the substrate pedestal or forming a DC plasma over the target electrode may be effective in providing some further reduction in the annealing temperature required. Here the addition of energy (thermal, kinetic, plasma, etc.) to the depositing material/film induces better crystallization at the nucleation step and during the subsequent growth of the film.
Other TFB cathodes and anodes that may be suitable for the low cost deposition process as described above may include: layered cathode materials (e.g., nickel cobalt aluminum oxide (NCA) and nickel cobalt manganese oxides (NCM)), spinel-based oxides (e.g. lithium manganese oxide (LMO)), and olivine based phosphates such as lithium iron phosphate (LFP) for the cathode; and lithium titanate for the anode.
Depending on the type of deposition used, one or more of the power sources connected to the substrate can be a DC source, a pulsed DC (pDC) source, an AC source (with frequency below RF, typically below 1 MHz), an RF source, etc. Similarly, one or more of the target power sources can be a DC source, a pDC source, an AC source (with frequency below RF, typically below 1 MHz), an RF source, etc. Furthermore, combinations of more than one of the aforementioned substrate power sources may be connected to the substrate and/or combinations of more than one of the aforementioned target power sources may be connected to the target. The concepts and configurations of the combinatorial power supplies described in U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2009/0288943 to Kwak et al., incorporated by reference in its entirety herein, may be used in the deposition of the thin films according to some embodiments of the present invention.
A first example of a combination of power sources is as follows: pDC power supply connected to the target, DC power supply connected to the substrate for providing a substrate bias. A second example is as follows: pDC power supply connected to the target, DC power supply also connected to the target for generating a DC plasma. Multiple further combinations may be used—for example, see U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2009/0288943 to Kwak et al., incorporated by reference in its entirety herein.
In order to illustrate the movement of a substrate through an in-line fabrication system such as shown in
In further embodiments, in-situ annealing of a cathode layer may be used, where the annealing is completed in the same chamber as the cathode layer deposition.
As described above, furnace anneal processes may cause cracking of the LiCoO2 cathode film due to a mismatch of the thermal expansion coefficient between the cathode and the substrate. However, LiCoO2 (LCO) cathode layers without cracks after annealing, even with high temperature (650° C.) anneal, have been demonstrated for the high pressure and high deposition temperature PVD processes according to some embodiments of the present invention. Screening of samples for cracks was made using optical microscopy with a resolution of approximately one micron and is illustrated in
Although the present invention has been described in detail for a sputter deposition PVD process, the principles and teaching of the present invention are expected to be beneficial for thermal PVD processes where a target material, such as LiCoO2 is subject to one or more of electron beam evaporation, laser ablation, inductive heating, resistive heating, radiative heating from a hot body etc. It is expected that the ranges of deposition pressure and temperature determined for sputter deposition of LiCoO2 will be applicable to thermal deposition processes, with the same result of reduced annealing temperature for crystallization of the LiCoO2 layer to form a LiCoO2 layer with the high temperature crystalline phase of good quality, as specified above. Furthermore, it is expected that these same ranges of deposition pressure and temperature, for the aforementioned PVD processes, will be beneficial for the other TFB anode and cathode materials disclosed herein, again with the result of reducing the annealing temperature for crystallization of the electrode material after deposition, when compared with the annealing temperature required for typical present day lower chamber pressure and lower substrate temperature deposition processes.
Although the present invention has been described for TFB cathode deposition which allows lower temperature annealing, the principles and teaching of the present invention are expected to be beneficial for deposition and annealing of electrodes in electrochromic (EC) devices. For example, the principles of the present invention are expected to improve the “forming” of nickel oxide based counter electrodes in EC devices, reducing the need for post-device-fabrication thermal cycling.
Furthermore, the higher pressure TFB cathode deposition of the present invention, which allows lower temperature furnace or lamp annealing, may be combined with a microwave anneal instead of a furnace or lamp anneal.
Although the present invention has been particularly described with reference to the preferred embodiments thereof, it should be readily apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art that changes and modifications in the form and details may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. It is intended that the appended claims encompass such changes and modifications.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/676,232 filed Jul. 26, 2012, incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61676232 | Jul 2012 | US |