The present description is directed to the field of electrodes for use in energy storage systems, such as batteries, fuel cells, and the like. More particularly, the description relates to electrodes formed using unique methods of binding active materials and current collectors together, the compositions used therefor, and methods for forming such electrodes.
The relatively high conductivity, low cost, abundance, low atomic mass, electrochemical stability and other favourable properties of carbonaceous materials (e.g., graphite, activated carbons, carbon blacks, graphene, carbon nanotubes, etc.) make them the material of choice for electrodes used as the active material directly, or as composites with or coatings on other active materials, in most electrochemical devices including batteries, supercapacitors and fuel cells. For example, silicon, a metalloid, is increasingly either composited with or coated with carbonaceous materials in order to improve electrode stability and conductivity. For all of these cases electrodes are usually comprised of a micron-sized powder which is cast dry or wet with other components onto a current collector foil (e.g., copper, aluminium) to create a thicker functional electrode film. Electrons flow between the current collector and the carbon and are transferred between hundreds to thousands of such packed particles throughout the film thickness. The flow of these electrons is often impeded by low contact area between particles and by the polymeric binders that are typically used to hold the particulate structure together. In some cases, these factors contribute to a significant resistance to electron flow, in particular, when electrodes are made in commercially relevant thicknesses (i.e., >10-100 μm thick). These thicker films are required to reduce the ratio of active material to inactive material in the electrochemical device. For example, in a lithium (Li) ion battery, any increase in electrode thickness leads to an improvement in energy density; however, such increased thickness typically comes at the expense of too high a resistance to operate the device at reasonable charge/discharge rates and thus, in practice, thicknesses are limited.
Li-ion batteries were invented in the 1970's and were commercialized in 1990's. Their relatively large energy density allowed them to be made light enough to usher the present era of portable electronics that includes cellphones, laptops and digital cameras. Despite the large success of these devices, under the worldwide environmental push for electrification of transportation the automotive sector has recently become the largest application for Li-ion batteries (Eftekhari A. et al.). However, mass adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) hinges on the ability of batteries to recharge in a timeframe comparable to the refuelling of internal combustion engine vehicles. By way of example, the U.S. Department of Energy has defined the Extreme Fast Charging (XFC) standards to require EVs to be able to reach 80% full charge in under 15 minutes (Liu, Y. et al.; Ahmed, S. et al.).
Such fast-charging is, however, hindered by the slow electrochemistry of Li-ion batteries, in particular at the anode where lithium plating and electrode delamination tend to occur under the large currents required under XFC conditions (Liu, Q. et al.; Prezas, P. D. et al.). These phenomena are caused by the local potential dropping below 0 V vs. Li/Li+ and joule heating, respectively. Both causes are the result of high electrode ionic and electronic impedance. One of the main causes of ionic impedance of anodes is related to charge transport through the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) that is formed (Rangom, Y. et al., 2021).
As is known in the art, the so-called formation cycle is important in creating a stable SEI on a graphite anode, and such process is typically carried out at C/10, in other words, one full charge over 10 hours of charging time, at the manufacturing facility. This therefore means that every battery must be hooked up to a charger for over 10 h after packaging, which adds significant costs to the manufacturing process. Currently, the cost of the SEI formation step is estimated at around 6% of total battery production costs. It has recently been shown that SEI formation at high rates can better facilitate fast charging but only in thin films due to the limited conductivity of thicker graphite anodes.
Readily available fast-charging batteries that are able to satisfy XFC requirements utilize lithium titanium oxide (LTO). LTO chemistry exhibits fast lithium storage kinetics at a relatively high voltage between 1.5 and 1.6 V vs. Li/Li+ that prevents SEI formation. However, the reduced cell voltage also reduces energy density by at least 33% compared to a graphite anode. Furthermore, LTO's specific capacity of 175 mAh/g is less than half that of graphite making such anode material less than ideal for EV applications. A more rational approach to fast charging involves heating batteries before charging. In this regard, it has been demonstrated that elevating temperatures from 25 to 45° C. increases electrolyte conductivity by a factor of 1.4 and intercalation kinetics by 5.6 (Yang, et al.). However, high temperatures can degrade electrolytes and accelerate aging (Hou, et al.). Furthermore, EV batteries can exceed half a ton in weight which requires a significant amount of time to achieve the desired heating, especially in cold climates. Therefore, an alternative method for achieving fast charging is necessary.
It has been known that forming SEI layers under high current rates significantly increases their conductivity. A thin film study recently published demonstrates that stable SEI layers can be formed under high current rates if the electrode electronic impedance is decreased.
Traditional slurries can support charge and discharge rates well above those required for XFC, however this requires unpractical amounts of carbon conductive additive, such as up to 65% (Kang, et al.).
There is, therefore, a need for an improvement in the known electrodes and/or active materials used for forming electrodes, particularly those for use in Li-ion batteries.
In one aspect, the present description provides novel electrodes, such as electrodes used in lithium (Li) ion batteries, and electroactive materials therefor. In one aspect, the description provides an electrode architecture wherein active materials are bound to current collectors with electrically conductive, covalently bonded interfaces. Such architecture results in increased electronic conductivity as well as improved bonding strength between the active material and the current collector.
The description also provides a method for increasing electronic conductivity as well as bonding strength between the electroactive materials and the current collector of an electrode. The method comprises the formation of functional covalent bonds between heterogeneous materials including carbonaceous, metallic, and metalloid materials. The method and resulting compositions described herein address one or more of the deficiencies known in the art.
The features of certain embodiments will become more apparent in the following detailed description in which reference is made to the appended figures wherein:
Described herein are novel methods and compositions of electrode architecture that bind active material and a current collector together using electrically conductive, covalently bonded interfaces. Also described herein are methods for the production of such material. The compositions described herein have utility in the field of electrodes for use in energy storage systems and related applications including batteries, fuel cells, and the like.
In general, the present description provides a method of covalently bonding active material of an electrode to a heterogeneous current collector either directly or through an intermediate active compound. Covalent bonding can be achieved directly with a metal or metal-plated current collector such as, but not limited to nickel, titanium, vanadium, chromium, tungsten, tantalum, molybdenum, niobium, hafnium, zirconium, boron, silicon, germanium, antimony, tellurium, arsenic, polonium and astatine and their compounds. The chemical bonding between current collectors and any combination of carbons or metalloids particle or coating or composites of these materials can also be achieved through an intermediate active compound of any the aforementioned elements.
The description also provides a method of forming covalent bonds between the carbonaceous or carbon coated, metalloid particles constituent of electrodes. These bonds can be achieved by incorporating the elements and compounds mentioned above in the composition of electrode materials.
In one aspect, the new architecture described herein uses an additive, such as titanium hydride, to produce carbide bonds with carbon-based or carbon-coated materials. Furthermore, the same system alloys with metalloids and metal current collectors when sintered at high temperatures, such as greater than about 400° C., under inert atmosphere. The sintering temperature may be from about 400° C. to about 1000° C., including 400° C., 500° C., 600° C., 700° C., 800° C., 900° C., and 1000° C., any temperatures there-between. Preferably, the sintering step is conducted at a temperature from about 600° C. to about 1000° C. A covalently joined electrode architecture as described herein avoids the need for a polymeric binder as typically used in the art or can transform it into conductive carbonized material.
As discussed further below, another feature realized by the method of the present description relates to the decomposition of the polymers used to form the slurry comprising active electrode components. Specifically, in order to form the electrodes described herein, the desired active particles are dispersed in a polymer and subsequently applied to a current collector. Typically, after drying, such polymers are retained in the active material matrix. However, with the method described herein, the formed electrode is subjected to a heating phase, which results in decomposition of the polymer material in a gaseous phase. Consequently, the electrode is provided with a degree of porosity, which was not realizable with known methods and results in improved ionic pathways throughout the electrodes.
The present description provides a unique method for covalently linking or fusing carbon particles together with carbide-based interconnects. This both mechanically and electrically crosslinks the particle constituents of the electrode, significantly improving conductivity and eliminating the need for polymer binders. In one aspect, this is achieved by mixing a carbide or alloy forming additive, such as TiH2, with a carbon-based active material (and optionally with a sacrificial carbon source, such as a conductive carbon additive) which are cast together using conventional electrode casting methods (e.g., slurry casting). The electrodes are heated to induce a carbothermal reaction which converts the carbon and TiH2 to a covalent composite of carbon and titanium carbide, TiC.
Furthermore, as known in the art, a significant resistance in an electrode is attributed to the contact between the current collector and the carbon particles. Using a carbothermal reaction as discussed herein, it is possible to covalently join these two interfaces with conductive covalent bonds.
In one example, the present inventors found that a graphite-based anode and a carbon-coated lithium iron phosphate cathode with covalent, conductive bonds, as described herein, cycled at 4C at room temperature delivered up to 80% of the capacity that can be achieved at low rates. In contrast, the corresponding traditional slurry-based anode and cathode delivered about 20% and 60% of the capacity achievable at lower rates, respectively, when cycled at the same 4C rate and temperature.
As would be understood by persons skilled in the art, the term “C” value refers to charging rate of a battery and, more particularly, the rate at which the battery can be charged to its nominal or theoretical capacity in 1 hour. Thus, a battery charged at a rate of 0.1C capacity requires 10 hours, and a battery charged at a rate of 2C will charge for 30 minutes. Therefore, to meet the above mentioned XFC standard, a battery is expected to charge at a minimum of 3.2C rate and be able to charge to 80% of the nominal or theoretical capacity during this timeframe (i.e., 15 min or less).
The present description provides certain examples of active materials that may be used to form the electrodes described herein. Such examples are provided to illustrate the features of the invention and are not intended to limit the scope of same. The description contemplates the use of other active materials, such as one or more of:
As noted above, the description comprises the use of additive materials for forming carbide bonds or alloys between electrode active materials and current collectors and/or between particles of active materials. The description contemplates the use of any carbide forming or alloy forming compounds, such as compounds of transition metal and metalloid elements. Such additive materials include, but are not limited to compounds of titanium, vanadium, tungsten, zirconium, molybdenum, niobium, silicon, or germanium, and mixtures thereof. In one aspect, the description provides the use of titanium hydride as an additive for the formation of such carbide bonds. However, the description also contemplates the use of other titanium compounds as would be known to persons skilled in the art.
In one aspect, the present description provides electrodes having a unique architecture, wherein electrode active materials are covalently bonded to current collector materials. Methods of manufacturing such electrodes are also described.
Covalently joined electrode architectures as described herein were prepared by sintering traditional electrode slurry components comprising active materials in combination with a carbide forming additive, as described herein. In one example, the additive comprised titanium hydride (TiH2) nanoparticles (such as available from Nanoshell). The active materials were mixed with the additive, in this instance titanium hydride nanoparticles. Typically, the amount of active material ranges between 80 and 90% by weight and concentration of the additive, such as TiH2 nanoparticles, may range from 5 to 10 wt %.
As known in the art, one or more other conductive carbon additives may be included along with the active materials and carbide or alloy forming additives.
In one aspect, and particularly where carbonaceous active materials are incorporated, the additive particles, e.g., TiH2 nanoparticles, may be subjected to an optional “activation” step before being combined with the active materials. In such optional step, the additive particles are combined with a small quantity of the corresponding active material particles and subjected to a ball milling step. Ideally, the activation, or ball milling step is performed under inert atmosphere (e.g., an argon atmosphere). Generally, the inert atmosphere is one that is absent of oxygen or nitrogen. In one aspect, the weight ratio of the additive material to carbonaceous material for the activation step may preferably be 2 to 1; however, other ratios are possible, such as 1:1, 3:1, 4:1, 5:1 or greater. In one example, the milling parameters utilized were 400 rpm for 3 hours with a ball to powder weight ratio of 20 to 1. In the present example, where carbon-coated materials were used, the activation step was conducted with a further carbon conductive additive, such as Super P™.
Without being held to any theory, it is believed that the aforementioned activation step initiates bond formation or initiation sites between the additive particles and the particles of carbonaceous material. This activation procedure is preferred as it reduces the temperature needed for the subsequent formation of carbide covalent bonding.
The above-mentioned activation step may not be necessary for active materials comprising metalloids.
For anode materials, the aforementioned powders were mixed and added to an aqueous solution of polyacrylic acid (PAA) or polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) or any mixture thereof. Thus, the weight ratio of PAA relative to PVA may vary from 100:0, 90:1, 80:20, 70:30, 60:40, 50:50, 40:60, 30:70, 20:80, 10:90, and 0:100, or any value there-between.
For cathode materials, an organic solution of PAA dispersed in N-methyl-2-pyrrolidine (NMP) may also be used. As would be understood by persons skilled in the art, most cathode materials react with water and, as such, non-aqueous polymers would be preferred.
Dispersions of powders and dissolved polymers were subsequently homogenized using a high-sheer homogenizer for a few minutes. The dispersion was then cast onto a titanium, copper, titanium-coated copper, and aluminum current collector foils using a doctor blade applicator. The electrodes were left to dry in an oven at 75° C. (aqueous) or 150° C. (organic) overnight.
The dried electrodes were then calendared. Such calendaring may be conducted under pressure, such as a pressure of about 77.4 MPa, as a pressing step. The calendared electrodes were then sintered at temperatures greater than 400° C., The sintering may be conducted at a temperature from about 400° C. to about 1000° C., and preferably from about 600° C. to about 1000° C. Ideally, the sintering is conducted under inert atmosphere, such as under argon. Furnace settings were 10° C./min ramp and retained at the final temperature for a minimum of 15 minutes. Further examples of the electrode manufacturing method are provided below. The sintering step may optionally be conducted under pressure.
The covalently joined architecture described herein comprises conductive covalently bonded interfaces 10 between conductive active material particles 12 and the current collector 14, preferably a metal current collector as illustrated in
The top schematic in
In the upper illustration of
In the present study, thermogravimetric analyses (TGA) were conducted on a TA Instrument TGA Q500™ in nitrogen with a heating rate of 10° C./min. The morphology of graphite particles and electrodes was imaged on Zeiss LEO™ field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) under a beam acceleration of 4 kV. Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) was conducted on the same FE-SEM machine under 20 kV beam acceleration. X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns were collected on a Rigaku MiniFlex II™ desktop X-ray diffractometer with copper radiation.
The sintered electrodes were tested in three-electrode Swagelok™ cells as shown in
For carbons, the reaction between TiH2 and carbon particles is obtained after ball milling activation of TiH2 particles and by sintering under argon at temperatures over 400° C. as shown in
In addition, a crush test was conducted on both the compacted non-sintered and sintered graphite-TiH2 powder pellet, as illustrated in
The covalent bond between the active material particles and the current collector is shown indirectly via electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) characterisation. As illustrated in
Thus, as shown by the present results, mitigating electronic impedance at both the current collector particle and particle-to-particle interfaces, as made possible by the present description, allows for improved cycling at fast rates.
The composition of the electrodes featured in
In
Similarly, to pure carbon active material, carbon coated materials can also be incorporated in covalent joined architecture sintered with TiH2 additive. For C-LFP (lithium iron phosphate) cathode material, an increase of about 28% in electrochemical performance at 4C is measured compared to traditional slurry as shown in
Silicon anode material also alloys with titanium from TiH2 particles and copper current collector through sintering under protective atmosphere (
Silicon nanoparticles and TiH2 particles were tested as reference powders. A 2:1 mixture of TiH2 and silicon powder respectively was hot pressed at 1000° C. under 31 MPa of pressure in argon atmosphere. The XRD characterisation of the sintered powder showed a complete reaction as the original peaks for silicon and TiH2 have disappeared.
One objective of the present study was to provide a battery that is able to achieve extreme fast charging (XFC) as defined by the US department of energy, namely, reaching at least 80% state-of-charge in 15 minutes. As discussed above, prior to the present description, a number of hurdles were known to achieving such goal, where such hurdles were mainly associated with the rapid transport of both electrons and ions through the different interfaces of thick high-energy electrodes. The covalently bonded architecture described herein, featuring electrically conductive particle-to-particle and collector-to-particles bonds, has been found to achieve XFC and thereby to reduce battery production times.
The presently described covalently bonded carbon-carbide architecture allows the use of conventional materials such as graphite and carbon coated cathode materials along with known electrolytes to be charged and discharged under higher current densities in order to achieve the XFC charging standard. Previously known techniques required the use of either exotic materials or unconventional electrolytes with a narrower electrochemical stability window (ESW) that can only offer lower energy storage battery compared to traditional materials and electrolytes.
The described chemically bonded electrode architectures offer simultaneous optimization of transport of both ions and electrons in the bulk of electrodes, through electrically conductive bonds and through tuned porosity, as well as low-impedance SEI layers formed under high current densities. These advantages are obtained with the materials discussed above and an additional heat-treatment step in the battery manufacturing workflow.
The description also shows that the enhanced conductivity of electrodes created by the method described herein enables the formation of stable SEI at fast rates. When SEI is formed at 10C, which corresponds to a cycle rate of 6 min, i.e., one hundred times faster than traditional 0.1C (or C/10) current rate, electrodes only display a slightly lower efficiency for a few tens of cycles and then become as stable as cells worked in at the traditional 0.1C rate. The ability to form SEI layers at 1C that is over an order of magnitude higher current density compared to regular practice of 0.1C or lower produces a SEI layer with lower impedance and reduces the overall formation time during battery manufacturing.
Thus, as discussed herein, the architecture described above offers one or more of the following advantages:
1) The covalently bonded architecture described herein reduces potential gradients throughout the bulk of the electrode and increases the electric field between the cathode and anode. This is achieved by reducing the impedance with improved and permanent electronic connectivity between particles and current collector of each electrode. Thus, a constant electric potential is established throughout the bulk of the electrode, whereby a more uniform and higher electric field is established between carbide-bonded electrode and counter electrode.
2) Improved ionic conductivity of the SEI layers, which is enabled by forming such layers under high current densities, such as in the hundreds and thousands of mA/g based on mass of active material.
3) Improved ionic pathways throughout the electrodes, which is achieved by engineering additional porosity in the electrode bulk through evaporation or decomposition of compounds such as polyvinyl alcohol (or others) during a heat-treatment step. This features thereby results in faster transport of ions through the electrodes.
4) Mitigation or prevention of electrode delamination, which is achieved as a result of the electrically conductive chemical bonds that are formed between the active material and the current collector.
5) The ability to form SEI layers under high current rates, which significantly reduces the time to for SEI formation as compared to current methods where SEI layers are formed under typically low current density.
As will be appreciated from the foregoing, the methods and materials described herein have applications in the development of fast charging Li-ion batteries or in alkali-ion batteries. It will also be appreciated that the described materials and methods also have applications in high-loading supercapacitors. As known in the art, high surface area activated carbons or carbon black electrodes are used in commercial supercapacitors which require thick >100 μm electrodes to increase energy density but usually at the expense of power density. We have demonstrated the utility of the presently described materials by fabricating thick electrodes using Ketjenblack™, “KB” (an activated carbon black) that has utility as a supercapacitor electrode. By comparing the same electrodes prepared by casting with TiH2 and heat treatment with those simply bound with conventional binder, we observed a significant boost in high-rate performance for the covalent KB/TiC composite electrode.
It will be appreciated that the above-mentioned examples are provided only to illustrate embodiments and aspects of the methods and materials described herein. Accordingly various other uses of such methods and materials will be apparent to those skilled in the art having read the present description. Such other uses may involve, for example, carbonaceous materials and electrochemical devices that would benefit from the features described herein, such as the lower resistance of carbon-TiC-carbon covalent interfaces over carbon-carbon van der Waals contacts. In addition to electrochemical devices, the methods and materials described herein could be used to covalently join discretely tiled graphene sheets for transparent conductors or used in thin or thick carbon films to create conductive foils (for example, a more conductive version of Graphoil™), etc. for electrical contacting or electromagnetic interference shielding, etc.
Although the above description includes reference to certain specific embodiments, various modifications thereof will be apparent to those skilled in the art. Any examples provided herein are included solely for the purpose of illustration and are not intended to be limiting in any way. Any drawings provided herein are solely for the purpose of illustrating various aspects of the description and are not intended to be drawn to scale or to be limiting in any way. The scope of the claims appended hereto should not be limited by the preferred embodiments set forth in the above description but should be given the broadest interpretation consistent with the present specification as a whole. The disclosures of all prior art recited herein are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.
Yang, X.-G.; Zhang, G.; Ge, S.; Wang, C.-Y., Fast charging of lithium-ion batteries at all temperatures. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2018, 115 (28), 7266-7271.
The present application claims priority to U.S. Patent Application No. 63/248,293, filed Sep. 24, 2021. The entire contents of such prior application are incorporated herein by reference.
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/CA2022/051418 | 9/26/2022 | WO |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 63248293 | Sep 2021 | US |