Patent Grant
8747618
This application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/510,378 filed Jul. 21, 2011, which is incorporated by reference herein.
The present application is related to U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/020,462 filed Feb. 3, 2011, now U.S. Pat. No. 8,163,136 granted Apr. 24, 2012, which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/423,977 filed Dec. 16, 2010, the entirety of each of which is incorporated by reference herein.
The present invention is directed to an apparatus used in the formation of paper. More specifically the present invention is directed to an apparatus, system, and method for lowering the consistency or degree of density of fiber suspension on the forming table, and improving the quality and physical properties of the paper formed thereon.
In general, it is well known in the papermaking industry that proper drainage of liquid from the paper stock on a forming fabric is an important step to ensure a quality product. This is done through the use of drainage blades or foils usually located at the wet end of the machine, e.g. a Fourdrinier paper machine. (Note the term drainage blade, as used herein, is meant to include blades or foils that cause drainage or stock activity or both.) A wide variety of different designs for these blades are available today. Typically, these blades provide for a bearing or support surface for the wire or forming fabric with a trailing portion for dewatering, which angles away from the wire. This creates a gap between the blade surface and the fabric, which causes a vacuum between the blade and the fabric. This not only drains water out of the fabric, but also can result in pulling the fabric down due to suction. However, when the vacuum collapses, the fabric returns to its original position, which can result in a pulse across the stock, which may be desirable for stock distribution. The activity (caused by the wire deflection) and the amount of water drained from the sheet are directly related to vacuum generated by the blade. Drainage and activity by such blades can be augmented by placing the blade or blades on a vacuum chamber. The direct relationship between drainage and activity is not desirable because while activity is always desirable, too much drainage early in the sheet formation process may have adverse effects on retention of fibers and filler. Rapid drainage may also cause sheet sealing, making subsequent water removal more difficult. Existing technology forces the paper maker to compromise desired activity in order to slow early drainage.
Drainage can be accomplished by way of a liquid to liquid transfer such as that taught in U.S. Pat. No. 3,823,062 to Ward, which is incorporated herein by reference. This reference teaches the removal of liquid through sudden pressure shocks to the stock. The reference states that controlled liquid to liquid drainage of water from the suspension is less violent than conventional drainage.
A similar type of drainage is taught in U.S. Pat. No. 5,242,547 to Corbellini. This patent teaches preventing the formation of a meniscus (air/water interface) on the surface of the forming fabric opposite the sheet to be drained. This reference achieves this by flooding the vacuum box structure containing the blade(s) and adjusting the draw off of the liquid by a control mechanism. This is referred to as “Submerged Drainage.” Improved dewatering is said to occur through the use of sub-atmospheric pressure in the suction box.
In addition to drainage, blades are constructed to purposely create activity in the suspension in order to provide for desirable distribution of the stock. Such a blade is taught, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 4,789,433 to Fuchs. This reference teaches the use of a wave shaped blade (preferably having a rough dewatering surface) to create micro-turbulence in the fiber suspension.
Other types of blades wish to avoid turbulence, but yet affect drainage, such as that described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 4,687,549 to Kallmes. This reference teaches filling the gap between the blade and the web, and states that the absence of air prevents expansion and ‘cavitation’ of the water in the gap and substantially eliminates any pressure pulses. A number of such blades and other arrangements can be found in the following prior art: U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,951,823; 5,393,382; 5,089,090; 4,838,996; 5,011,577; 4,123,322; 3,874,998; 4,909,906; 3,598,694; 4,459,176; 4,544,449; 4,425,189; 5,437,769; 3,922,190; 5,389,207; 3,870,597; 5,387,320; 3,738,911; 5,169,500 and 5,830,322, which are incorporated herein by reference.
Traditionally, high and low speed paper machines produce different grades of paper with a wide range of basis weights. Sheet forming is a hydromechanical process and the motion of the fibers follow the motion of the fluid because the inertial force of an individual fiber is small compared to the viscous drag in the liquid. Formation and drainage elements affect three principle hydrodynamic processes, which are drainage, stock activity and oriented shear. Liquid is a substance that responds according to shear forces acting in or on it. Drainage is the flow through the wire or fabric, and it is characterized by a flow velocity that is usually time dependant. Stock activity, in an idealized sense, is the random fluctuation in flow velocity in the undrained fiber suspension, and generally appears due to a change in momentum in the flow due to deflection of the forming fabric in response to drainage forces or as being caused by blade configuration. The predominant effect of stock activity is to break down networks and to mobilize fibers in suspension. Oriented shear and stock activity are both shear-producing processes that differ only in their degree of orientation on a fairly large scale, i.e. a scale that is large compared to the size of individual fibers.
Oriented shear is shear flow having a distinct and recognizable pattern in the undrained fiber suspension. Cross Direction (“CD”) oriented shear improves both sheet formation and test. The primary mechanism for CD shear (on paper machines that do not shake) is the creation, collapse and subsequent recreation of well defined Machine Direction (“MD”) ridges in the stock of the fabric. The source of these ridges may be the headbox rectifier roll, the head box slice lip (see e.g., International Application PCT WO95/30048 published Nov. 9, 1995) or a formation shower. The ridges collapse and reform at constant intervals, depending upon machine speed and the mass above the forming fabric. This is referred to as CD shear inversion. The number of inversions and therefore the effect of CD shear is maximized if the fiber/water slurry maintains the maximum of its original kinetic energy and is subjected to drainage pulses located (in the MD) directly below the natural inversion points.
In any forming system, all these hydrodynamic processes may occur simultaneously. They are generally not uniformly distributed in either time or space, and they are not wholly independent of one another; they interact. In fact, each of these processes contributes in more than one way to the overall system. Thus, while the above-mentioned prior art may contribute to some aspect of the hydrodynamic processes aforesaid, they do not coordinate all processes in a relatively simple and effective way.
Stock activity in the early part of a Fourdrinier table as mentioned earlier is critical to the production of a good sheet of paper. Generally, stock activity can be defined as turbulence in the fiber-water slurry on the forming fabric. This turbulence takes place in all three dimensions. Stock activity plays a major part in developing good formation by impeding stratification of the sheet as it is formed, by breaking up fiber flocks, and by causing fiber orientation to be random.
Typically, stock activity quality is inversely proportional to water removal from the sheet; that is, activity is typically enhanced if the rate of dewatering is retarded or controlled. As water is removed, activity becomes more difficult because the sheet becomes set, the lack of water, which is the primary media in which the activity takes place, becomes scarcer. Good paper machine operation is thus a balance between activity, drainage and shear effect.
The capacity of each forming machine is determined by the forming elements that compose the table. After a forming board, the elements which follow have to drain the remaining water without destroying the mat already formed. The purpose of these elements is to enhance the work done by the previous forming elements.
As the basis weight is increased, the thickness of the mat is increased. With the actual forming/drainage elements it is not possible to maintain a controlled hydraulic pulse strong enough to produce the hydrodynamic processes necessary to make a well-formed sheet of paper.
An example of conventional means for reintroducing drainage water into the fiber stock in order to promote activity and drainage can be seen in
A table roll 100 in
Step blades 82 as show in
Positive pulse step blade 78, as shown in
In use, a vacuum augmented foil blade box will generate vacuum as the gravity foil does, the water is removed continuously without control, and the predominant drainage process is filtration. Typically, there is no refluidization of the mat that is already formed.
In a vacuum augmented flat blade box, a slight positive pulse is generated over the blade/wire contact surface and the pressure exerted on the fiber mat is due only to the vacuum level maintained in the box.
In a vacuum augmented step blade box, as shown in
The vacuum augmented positive pulse step blade low vacuum box, as shown in
Positive pulse blade, as water drains through the fabric, a converging nip produced by the lead angle of the blade and the fabric forces the water back into the sheet. This produces a shear force capable of breaking the fiber mat and penetrating through the stock slurry, re-fluidizing of the slurry is minimum, as it is shown in
A special type of double posi-blade incorporates a positive incoming nip to generate a positive and negative pressure pulse. This blade reintroduces water to the fiber mat with the lead in edge, the water reintroduced is limited to the amount adhere to the bottom of the forming fabric. This type of blade creates pressure pulses rather than consistency reduction. This type of blade simulates a table roll, as it is shown in
U.S. Pat. No. 5,830,322 to Cabrera et al., filed February 1996, titled “Velocity induced drainage method and unit” describes an alternate means of creating activity and drainage. The apparatus described therein decouples activity and drainage and thus presents a means of controlling and optimizing them. It uses a long blade with a controlled, probably non-flat or partially non-flat surface to induce initial activity in the sheet, and limits the flow after the blade through placement of a trail blade to control drainage. The '322 patent discloses that drainage is enhanced if the area between the long blade and forming fabric is flooded and surface tension is maintained between the water above and below the fabric. The invention disclosed therein is shown schematically in
However, with the '322 patent there is only one way to reintroduce a minimum amount of water to the fiber suspension. It occurs in the “counterflow zone,” and exists because the incompressible fluid follows the non-flat top of the long blade and is thus pumped through the forming fabric. The consistency that reaches the lead in edge of the Velocity Induce Unit does not change along the same blade. The stock consistency will be increased when the stock reaches the trial blade, because of drained water in the slot, if the Velocity Induce Unit is designed with multiple long blades and the consistency is constantly increased along the Velocity Induce Unit.
While some of the foregoing references have certain attendant advantages, further improvements and/or alternative forms, are always desirable.
Stock dilution on the forming section of the paper machine is critical to the production of a good sheet of paper. Generally, stock dilution is achieved at the short loop system of the forming section of the machine by increasing the recirculation of the white water.
Stock dilution on the forming table plays a major part in developing good formation, facilitates the realization of the three hydrodynamic processes necessary to make a well-formed sheet of paper; allowing the fiber orientation to be random.
Most of the paper machines have been sped up in order to increase production and have lower consistencies for better paper quality and still have the same machine screen, same piping and same headbox to supply water and stock to the forming table. The forming tables have been reworked in order to take care of the excessive flow.
Let us suppose as an example a paper machine originally designed with a headbox 200 inches wide, at a speed of 800 feet per min with a headbox consistency of 0.65%, making paper of 54 grams per square meter and a retention of 70%; the calculated flow out of the headbox will be about 3927 Gallons per minute. However, over the years the machine has increased the speed 1.75 times and the headbox consistency has been lowered for better quality to 0.38%, the retention has dropped to 65%; the flow out of the headbox is now about 12660 Gallons per minute. The flow has increased 3.22 times and as a result all internal velocities in the entire system have more than tripled, which may have harmful results.
Therefore, when working at low consistencies or when the paper machine is sped up, it is necessary to increase the number of drainage elements, because of the increased flow out of headbox. In some instances it is also necessary to increase the longitude of the table in order to make space for the installation of additional drainage equipment or to install new vacuum assisted drainage equipment.
However, due to the present invention, it is not necessary to increase the longitude of the table or to install new vacuum assisted drainage equipment. Additionally, there is a considerable reduction of energy consumption on the forming table.
Accordingly, an object of the present invention is to provide a machine for maintaining the hydrodynamic processes on the forming table irrespective of what the machine speed.
It is a further object of the present invention to provide a machine usable with a forming board and or a velocity induced drainage machine.
It is a further object of the present invention that the efficiency of the machine not be affected by the velocity of the machine, the basis weight of the paper sheet and or the thickness of the mat.
The present invention describes a machine that recycles the water by itself in order to dilute the fiber suspension on the table to the desired levels after the head box; the dilution rate of the present invention may be anything between 0% to 100%; the work done by the machine in the present invention is not affected by the degree of refining, velocity of the machine, the basis weight of the paper sheet or the thickness of the mat. After the sheet has been formed by the present invention, the drainage and the consolidation of the sheet is done by the equipment in continuation.
Paper making chemicals as known to those of ordinary skill in the art can be added to fiber suspension in order to enhance paper strength and machine productivity. All paper chemicals are added before or after the forming table.
One exemplary embodiment of the present invention is an apparatus for lowering consistency or degree of density of fiber contained in a liquid suspension on a forming table of a papermaking machine, the apparatus comprising at least one conduit for adding paper making chemicals into a flow of liquid to form a mixed flow, a forming fabric on which a fiber slurry is conveyed, the forming fabric having an outer surface and an inner surface, and a primary blade having a leading edge support surface that is in sliding contact with the inner surface of the forming fabric, a central plate that comprises at least a portion of self dilution, shear, microactivity or drainage section of the forming table, wherein the central plate is separated from a bottom plate by a predetermined distance to form a channel for recirculation of at least a portion of the liquid. The papermaking machine is configured such that mixed flow including a drained liquid to be re-used in at least a part of the forming process.
Another exemplary embodiment of the present invention is a system for lowering consistency or degree of density of fiber contained in a liquid suspension on a forming table of a papermaking machine, the system comprising an apparatus comprising at least one conduit for adding paper making chemicals into a flow of liquid to form a mixed flow, a forming fabric on which a fiber slurry is conveyed, the forming fabric having an outer surface and an inner surface, a primary blade having a leading edge support surface that is in sliding contact with the inner surface of the forming fabric, a central plate that comprises at least a portion of self dilution, shear, microactivity or drainage section of the forming table, wherein the central plate is separated from a bottom plate by a predetermined distance to form a channel for recirculation of at least a portion of the liquid. The papermaking machine such that mixed flow including a adrained liquid can be re-used in at least a part of the forming process.
Another exemplary embodiment of the present invention is a method for lowering consistency or degree of density of fiber suspension on a forming table of a papermaking machine, the method comprising the steps of providing a forming fabric on which a fiber slurry is conveyed, the forming fabric having an outer surface and an inner surface, providing a primary blade having a leading edge support surface that is in sliding contact with the inner surface of the forming fabric, and providing a central plate that comprises at least a portion of self dilution, shear, microactivity or drainage section of the forming table, wherein the central plate is separated from a bottom plate of the forming table by a predetermined distance to form a channel for recirculation of at least a portion of the liquid.
The various features of novelty which characterize the invention are pointed out in particularity in the following description of preferred embodiments. For a better understanding of the invention, its operating advantages and specific objects attained by its uses, reference is made to the accompanying drawings and descriptive matter in which preferred embodiments of the invention are illustrated.
The following detailed description, given by way of example and not intended to limit the present invention solely thereto, will best be appreciated in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, wherein like reference numerals denote like elements and parts, in which:
All devices already described as a part of the previous art are part of or form the gravity and dynamic drainage zone or sheet formation zone 4 shown in
Shown in
Fan pump 24 and cleaning system 27 and 32 are typically located in the basement underneath the forming section of the paper machine. The stock is delivered from the headbox 1 onto the Fourdrinier wire 11 through a slice 2. The total flow discharged over the forming wire 11 by the slice lip 2 of the head box 1, is controlled by changing the revolutions of the fan pump 24 and by adjusting the valves 23 and 22, when more flow is necessary the an pump 24 increases the revolutions and valve 23 increases the opening, valve 22 is adjusted to fine tune the required flow. In some installations the fan pump 24 has a constant speed motor in order to increase or decrease the flow out of the pump; in this case it is necessary to adjust valves 23 and 22.
The wet sheet 10 is actually formed on the Fourdrinier table that consists essentially of endless forming mesh belt 11 which is supported in zones 4, 5 and 6 by forming, and drainage devices which make up the wet end of the paper machine.
Close to the headbox 1, the forming mesh is supported by the breast roll 3, which is followed by forming, and drainage devices in zones 4, 5. The endless forming mesh moves over several suction boxes in zone 6 before it returns over a suction couch roll 7 and drive roil 9.
Water is quantitatively the most important raw material of papermaking. Before the stock is discharged on the forming mesh 11 of the forming table, it is very dilute; its fiber content is probably as low as 0.1%. From this point on, water removal becomes one of the most decisive functions of the machine. The stock out of the headbox 1 contains other solids in addition to fibers, due to which it has approximately 0.5 percent consistency; and the fiber mat 10 out of the couch 7 has between 23 and 25 percent consistency.
However, that in order to reduce viscosity of the water and drain the water properly, it is necessary to heat the fiber slurry in the range of 135 to 140 degree Fahrenheit. During this process, it is normal to have heat losses in the range of 5 to 10 degree Fahrenheit.
Referring now to
The forming table of the paper making machine, which is depicted in
A. The gravity and dynamic drainage zone 4, where the sheet formation occurs. At the beginning of the formation zone 4 the fiber consistency is in the range of 0.1 and 1.0%, and at this point the fibers have high degree of freedom and here is where formation can be improved by enhancing the three hydrodynamic processes needed to form a paper sheet. At exit of gravity and dynamic drainage zone 4 the consistency is in the range of 1.5 to 2.0%, and after this zone, the formation can be improved just minimum.
B. The low and mid vacuum zone 5—In this zone with the use of low vacuum boxes, small amount of vacuum is applied, vacuum is in the range of 2 to 60 inches of water, and consistency at exit of zone 5 is in the range of 6 to 8%.
The water drained by zones 4 and 5 is collected in receptacles 25 under the forming and drainage devices, and the water is directed to a storage tank 18 by channels 26 for reuse in stock dilution in the wet end close loop system, as shown in
C. The high vacuum drainage zone 6, here is where sheet consolidation occurs, water is removed by using high vacuum boxes; vacuum applied is in the range of 2 to 16 inches of mercury. At the end of the wire section the couch 7 removes water with higher vacuum (20 to 22 inches of mercury) assisted by a press roll 8. The water 12 drained in zone 6 is collected in a seal tank 13, the pump 14 sends part of the water for level control 15 in tank 18, the excess water 16 is sent to stock preparation system in conjunction with the overflow water 19 from water storage tank 18.
After the fiber mat is consolidated in the high vacuum drainage zone 6 and press by the suction couch 7 and the lump breaker 8, the sheet 10 leaves the forming table at consistencies between 23 and 27%.
As it was mentioned before, the short loop system at the wet end of the paper machine is the only system that can decrease or increase the consistency at the discharge of the headbox 1.
As an example mass balances are presented, one in
It is important to note that in both mass balances the following operating parameters are exactly the same:
As a result the production 10 out of the forming table is exactly the same in both balances as follows:
The sheet formation is better when consistency out of the headbox is at 0.5% than 0.8%, and performance of the equipment is completely different in both cases. The main difference in these two balances is inside the short loop system as follows:
By decreasing consistency from 0.8% to 0.5%, the hydraulic flow has been increased by 15,913 GPM as an average, and solids are increased by 183 STPD as an average. In order to move the additional flow it is necessary to increase the power of the motors of the fan pump 24 and the screens 27 and 32, and in many instances it is necessary to change the equipment.
Due to excessive flow when working at low consistency of 0.5%, more chemicals are needed; drainage at zones 4 and 5 becomes more difficult. Performance of the headbox is deteriorated if there is too much turbulence due to an excessive flow; cross currents are created that lead to uneven stock delivery to the sheet forming zone. A headbox which is not functioning properly can cause many defects in the finished sheet. The worst of these is poor formation that results when fibers are not dispersed evenly or uniformly.
By working at 0.8% consistency instead of 0.5%, there is a considerable reduction in the flow to the head box; approximately by 15,913 GPM. As a result there is less steam necessary to keep the slurry at its operating temperature, which means a reduction of 807,946 Btu/min for a 5 degree drop in temperature. It will be noted that with respect to companies that use fuel oil for heating purposes, this could mean a reduction of emission of 4640 tons of carbon dioxide per year to the atmosphere, and with respect to companies that use gas for heating purposes, the reduction of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere is approximately 416 tons per year.
In addition to the above, the excess water 19 sent back to water treatment has less solids (1.8 tons per day less) as can be appreciated from
One aspect of the present invention can be seen in
After drainage zone 56, the consistency of fiber slurry 1C is same as 1A or higher, depending on the amount of water 42 drained by gate 38. The central plate 35 holds the support blade 37, the central plate 35 is in a fixed position in order to maintain the specified distances from the central plate to the forming fabric 11, to the inlet blade 36, to the trail blade 39 and to the bottom plate 63, those distances are designed according to the process needs for specific paper machine, the central plate 35 is fixed by one, two or as many T bars 68 as needed according to the length of the self dilution, shear, microactivity and drainage section. T bars are fixed in position by bolts 65 and spacers 66. The surface 71 of the central plate 35 at drainage section is diverging from the forming fabric 11, and the slope may have anything from 0.1 up to 10 degrees of separation, and pre erred not to exceed 7 degrees.
The length of central plate 35 in
The new invention installed at gravity and dynamic drainage in the sheet formation zone 4 erases the necessity of lowering the fiber slurry consistency at the head box, and as a result will give same benefits as working with traditional system (lower the consistency in whole system).
As an example of benefits obtained with new invention in sheet formation physical properties and productivity when the paper machine is working with low consistency are in mass balance in
A mass balance with the new invention is presented in
A. Self Dilution and Shear Section 54:
This section begins at leading edge of support 37 and ends at end of radial section 69. The length of this section depends on the machine speed, and the amount of water 58 to be introduced to the fiber slurry 1A. Stream flow 58 is composed by streams flows 57 and 62, and stream flow 62 follows the path of channel 74 which allows to have a continuous and uniform flow that later will merge with flow 57 and be delivered into the forming fabric 11 to become flow 1B. The amount of stream flow 62 is controlled by the amount of water 42 purged through gate 38.
High shear effect is developed in this section by controlling differential velocities between flows 1A and flow 58, after these flows merge, high dilution in flow 1A takes place and microactivity is initiated. The radial design of surface 69 evens the flow 58, reducing the fiber mat variability in cross machine direction.
Length of self dilution and shear section depends on machine speed, basis weight and consistency decrease.
B. Microactivity at Low Consistency 55:
Surface 70 of central plate 35 may have different configuration as was described early in this document, and also in FIBER MAT FORMING APPARATUS AND METHOD OF PRESERVING THE HYDRODYNAMIC PROCESSES NEEDED TO FORM A PAPER SHEET by Cabrera, Patent Application Publication No.: US 2009/0301677 A1. There is a gap between the surface 70 of the central plate 35 and the wire 11, this feature allows having water in between them provoking microactivity and shear effect, at this section is where the lowest consistency is obtained.
Length of microactivity at low consistency section will depend on machine speed, basis weight and type of fiber.
C. Drainage 56:
Stream flow 59 in
In case that wire 11 deflects and contacts the central plate, second support blade 37B is added, as it is shown in
In an alternative embodiment as shown in
Chemical Addition
In another embodiment, paper making chemicals as known to those of ordinary skill in the art are added to fiber suspension in order to enhance paper strength and machine productivity. All paper chemicals are added before or after the forming table.
The efficiency of the chemicals is greatly reduced when added before the forming table because of the large dilution and high volume water recirculation at the forming section, in addition to the above, the response time to any change in chemical dosage is not immediate.
When chemicals are added after the forming table, normally is done at the size press in this case the speed of the paper machine is reduced between 13 to 25% or it is necessary to add more dryers in order to evaporate the additional water in the paper web, in both situations there is more use of energy.
Each grade of paper requires a specific combination of furnish ingredients which are selected according to the specifications of the paper being produced.
As it is shown in
The unit may work with or without chemical addition; in case of chemical addition it is preferable to close the gate valve 38 in order to eliminate any chemical lost.
The water and chemicals mixed flow 61 and later 62 merges with new drain flow 57 and it is reintroduced 58 to the fiber suspension 1A, both flows become as flow 1B, fibers are completely saturated with chemicals at microactivity zone 55, not retained chemicals are drained as part of flow 59 in order to be reused again optimizing chemical use.
In relation to a size press it is worth to note that the chemicals added at this stage increases the dry strength of the paper with minimum refining and low fiber quality, the chemicals added at the size press are in solution at approximately 3 to 25% solids, the paper absorbs some of the sizing solution and the balance is removed at the press. The size press solution absorbed by the paper has to be eliminated with additional dryers after the size press.
The benefits of making the chemical injection at the forming table with the new invention are as follows:
1. The efficiency of the chemicals is higher as long as chemicals are not diluted because the volume that the new invention uses is minimum compared with the total volume stored at the silo.
2. The efficiency of chemicals is better because chemicals and fibers are well mixed at the microactivity zone.
3. The chemical are not subject to high shear effect like happen at the fan pump or machine screen, shear action reduces efficiency of chemicals.
4. There is considerable reduction in energy consumption when chemical added at the new invention replaces chemicals at the size press, because it is not necessary to eliminate the excess liquid absorbed by the paper.
5. There is not machine speed reduction due to rewetting of the paper sheet at size press in the dryers.
6. It is possible to control the strength of the paper in cross machine direction.
7. The response to any change in dosage is immediate because the new invention works with minimum volume of water compared to the volume of the silo.
While the invention has been described in connection with what is considered to be the most practical and preferred embodiment, it should be understood that this invention is not limited to the disclosed embodiments, but on the contrary, is intended to cover various modifications and equivalent arrangements included within the spirit and scope of the appended claims.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3573159 | Sepall | Mar 1971 | A |
| 3598694 | Wiebe | Aug 1971 | A |
| 3738911 | Kienzl et al. | Jun 1973 | A |
| 3823062 | Ward et al. | Jul 1974 | A |
| 3870597 | Getman et al. | Mar 1975 | A |
| 3874998 | Johnson | Apr 1975 | A |
| 3922190 | Cowan | Nov 1975 | A |
| 4123322 | Hoult | Oct 1978 | A |
| 4425189 | Mimura | Jan 1984 | A |
| 4459176 | Goodnow | Jul 1984 | A |
| 4544449 | Arav | Oct 1985 | A |
| 4687549 | Kallmes | Aug 1987 | A |
| 4789433 | Fuchs | Dec 1988 | A |
| 4838996 | Kallmes | Jun 1989 | A |
| 4909906 | Bartelmuss et al. | Mar 1990 | A |
| 5011577 | Hansen et al. | Apr 1991 | A |
| 5089090 | Hansen | Feb 1992 | A |
| 5169500 | Mejdell | Dec 1992 | A |
| 5242547 | Corbellini et al. | Sep 1993 | A |
| 5387320 | Jaakkola | Feb 1995 | A |
| 5389207 | Rodriguez et al. | Feb 1995 | A |
| 5393382 | Corbellini et al. | Feb 1995 | A |
| 5437769 | Bando et al. | Aug 1995 | A |
| 5830322 | Cabrera y Lopez Caram et al. | Nov 1998 | A |
| 5922173 | Neun et al. | Jul 1999 | A |
| 5951823 | Cabrera y Lopez Caram et al. | Sep 1999 | A |
| 6126786 | White et al. | Oct 2000 | A |
| 6375799 | Halmschlager et al. | Apr 2002 | B1 |
| 8163136 | Cabrera y Lopez Caram | Apr 2012 | B2 |
| 20090301677 | Cabrera y Lopez Caram | Dec 2009 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| WO 9530048 | Nov 1995 | WO |
| WO 2007088456 | Aug 2007 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| International Search Report and Written Opinion issued by European Patent Office, acting as the International Searching Authority, for corresponding international application PCT/US2012/047566, dated Jan. 28, 2013. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20130042987 A1 | Feb 2013 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 61510378 | Jul 2011 | US |
