The present invention relates to toxicity screening assays and, more specifically, to the use spatially organized cardiac organoids engineered from human induced pluripotent stem cells to evaluate potential toxicity.
Recent progress in stem cell-based organoid technology offers unique opportunities to in vitro recapitulate biological processes of organogenesis into spatially organized tissue structures that resemble the architecture and functions of specific tissues. Integration of organoid technology and microfabrication has provided promising ways to guide self-organization and spatial pattern formation of developing biological tissues. Microfluidic systems could precisely control the localization of morphogen source and gradient to guide the spatial human pluripotent stem cells (hPSC) differentiation and organization into in vitro synthetic embryonic tissues, such as in germ layer patterning, as well as amniotic and epiblast layer separation. Surface micropatterning techniques were also able to provide geometric confinement for modeling gastrulation process, where PSCs were patterned and differentiated to form concentric rings indicative of specific germ layers. These examples illustrate the critical need for spatiotemporal engineering of cell microenvironments to guide the structure and function of stem cell organoids to specific biological tissues.
Despite extensive efforts in controlling stem cell lineage specification via biophysical inputs, there are few studies focusing on how 2D patterned cell colonies could give rise to organoids with defined structure-function relationships. Understanding these relationships require comprehensive analysis of multiple variables simultaneously, which increases the data dimensionality for analysis and visualization. As methods to detect cardiac functions evolve and become more sophisticated, large-scale multidimensional data requires more advanced analytics to effectively comprehend the functional outcomes. Currently, data dimensionality reduction techniques, which are the basis of bioinformatics analysis, are still underexplored for analyzing tissue level structural and functional properties. The combination of tissue engineering, organoid technology and advanced data mining techniques would potentially provide the versatility and capability to discover trends and relationships to guide new engineering designs with a spectrum of biological structures and functions.
hPSC-derived organoids exhibit characteristics of specific tissue lineages at their early developmental stages, thus providing great potential as in vitro assays of developmental drug toxicity. In vivo animal models and in vitro mouse embryonic stem cell tests (mEST) are widely implemented by pharmaceutical companies as biological assays for embryotoxicity screening. To overcome species barriers that impose limitations in traditional drug screening, hPSC technology has been proposed to replace the mEST for better predictions of human-specific developmental toxicity. However, most 2D stem cell-based assays lack the capability of morphological scoring of 3D tissue morphogenesis. This undermines the predictability of drug-induced teratogenicity, which potentially leads to structural malformations manifested in late prenatal fetus development. Moreover, traditional organoid technology exhibits relatively random positioning of tissue regions of specific cell types, and these regions are not reliably spatial-organized relative to one another. Heterogeneity in organoid formation also makes it difficult for embryotoxicity drug testing purposes with high consistency and reproducibility.
The majority of in vitro cardiac tissue models focus on accurate recapitulation of physiologically relevant tissue structures of adult human heart, which are generally achieved by populating pre-fabricated 3D biomaterial scaffolds with pre-differentiated hiPSC-derived cardiomyocytes (hiPSC-CMs). These adult-mimicking model systems are designed to enhance the maturity of hiPSC-CMs for the purpose of drug screening and disease modeling, but not designed for studying dynamic cellular self-organization occurring along with the cardiac differentiation process. In contrast, stem cell-derived organoids are designed to resemble the early developing organs through self-organization of differentiating cells into spatial-distinct tissue-specific structures. However, cardiac organoids are still largely generated by aggregating pre-differentiated hiPSC-CMs with other stromal cells, instead of originating from directed stem cell differentiation.
According there is a need in the art for approaches that create and use cardiac organoids that reflect the biological process of tissue self-assembly and morphogenesis during early heart formation for screening of drug candidates for potential drug-induced developmental toxicity.
The present invention comprises the formation and use of optimized cardiac organoids from 2D micropatterned human induced PSCs (hiPSCs). Organoids generated from genome engineered GCaMP6f hiPSCs were used for integrated functional analysis of calcium transient and contraction motion. Using data mining tools, relationships amongst a multitude of organoid metrics of tissue structure and contractile functions were established. The inter-dependency amongst these parameters associated with the geometric sizes was explored, which highlighted that biophysical microenvironment could modulate tissue structure and cardiac function. The model was then evaluated as a reliable indicator of cardiac developmental toxicity by quantifying the drug effects based on cardiac differentiation, contractile behaviors and 3D tissue morphology. More specifically, the present invention comprises a method for screening a target compound for embryotoxicity that includes the step of forming an amount of cardiac organoids, each of which includes a contracting cardiomyocyte surrounded by a plurality of stromal cells distributed therearound, from a quantity of human induced pluripotent stem cells. The human induced pluripotent stem cells are exposed to the target compounds during the step of forming the amount of spatially organized cardiac organoids. Finally, the amount of cardiac differentiation, the contractile behavior, and the three dimensional tissue morphology of the amount of cardiac organoids are considered after exposing the amount of spatially organized cardiac organoids to the target compounds to determine whether the target compound is embryotoxic. The cardiac organoids are spatially organized and can be formed using a micropatterned substrate. The micropatterned substrate may include a plurality of circles, each which has a diameter of about 600 μm. The human induced pluripotent stem cells are exposed to the target compounds during the step of forming the amount of spatially organized cardiac organoids comprises exposing the human induced pluripotent stem cells on a first day of differentiation. The step of forming the amount of cardiac organoids may include the step of differentiating human induced pluripotent stem cells by small molecule modulation of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway. The step of forming the amount of cardiac organoids includes the step of oxygen plasma etching an amount of poly(ethylene glycol) to form the micropatterned substrate. The step of oxygen plasma etching the amount of poly(ethylene glycol) includes using a mask formed from poly(dimethyl siloxane). The step of forming the amount of cardiac organoids includes the step of coating the micropatterned surface were coated with a diluted hESC-qualified matrix. The step of forming the amount of cardiac organoids includes the step of differentiating the human induced pluripotent stem cells with a GSK3 inhibitor.
The results of drug-induced cardiac developmental toxicity evaluation on hiPSC-based cardiac organoids using the present invention was also compared and confirmed using the effects on in vivo cardiac development using whole embryo culture (WEC) of living Danio rerio (zebrafish) embryos. The human cardiac organoid model and approach of the present invention thus provides as a versatile platform to assess cardiac organogenesis and developmental toxicity, which can be adopted for pharmaceutical development and fetal safety assessments.
The present invention will be more fully understood and appreciated by reading the following Detailed Description in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:
Referring to
At early differentiation stages, the positive expression of mesoderm marker BRA (Day 1) as seen in
The gene expression profile between cardiac organoids from three different pattern sizes (200 μm, 600 μm and 1000 μm in diameter) and traditional 2D monolayer differentiation was compared. In general, gene expression showed upregulation of cardiac-specific genes and downregulation of WNT signaling at Day 20 differentiation, though the gene expression profile had closer similarity amongst different organoids than 2D differentiation (
The pattern geometry was found to dictate the structural morphology and contractile physiology of cardiac organoids. Using immunofluorescence staining, the cardiac tissue distribution was measured by calculating the area ratio between the areas of cardiomyocyte differentiation and entire pattern area as seen in
To examine the effects of pattern size on cardiac organoid development, organoids were generated from circular patterns ranging 200-1000 μm in diameter (
From the t-SNE plot (
These parameters for the cardiac organoids of different sizes were then compared in the heat map (
Circle, square, and triangle organoids with the same area as seen in
Cardiac organoids according to the present invention can be used for an in vitro assay for cardiac developmental toxicity. The heart is the first functional organ to form, thus cardiac differentiation is often used as a key evaluation for developmental toxicity. Since 600 μm-diameter circular patterns gave robust organoid production, large 3D morphology, consistent contractile functions and high level of cardiac-specific differentiation, arrays of cardiac organoids from this geometry were used to test the capabilities of this platform to be implemented as a cardiac developmental toxicity assay. Using flow cytometry, we quantified the consistency of cardiac differentiation efficiency of organoids and 2D monolayer differentiation from 5 different batches (n=5) across 10 passages of hiPSCs from two different lines. Both organoids of 600 μm and 2D differentiation produced over 50% cells that were positive for cardiac troponin T as seen in
Nine drugs, as seen in Table 1 below, used in connection with the present invention covered the entire spectrum of the past FDA pregnancy category system that ranked drugs from A (safe) to X (toxic) based on predicted teratogenic risk.
The drugs were individually introduced on Day 1 of differentiation, 24 hours after treatment of GSK3 inhibitor CHIR99021 (
Next, cardiac developmental toxicity of drugs from the other pregnancy categories were tested. Three antibiotic drugs tested on the cardiac organoids showed increased developmental toxicity with the increase of their risk classification in the pregnancy category. Amoxicillin (category B antibiotics) in mammalian cells has been shown to induce DNA lesions as a result of amoxicillin-induced oxidative stress. In the organoids, amoxicillin showed no clear toxic effect on either structure or functions of the cardiac organoids at all three tested concentrations (see
Other category D dugs with various therapeutic applications were tested. Lithium carbonate (category D antidepressant), which inhibits the PKC signaling for its psychiatric medication purpose, appeared to inhibit phosphatidylinositol cycle and Wnt pathway activation, based on mEST assays. Exposure of lithium did not affect the contractile functions of the cardiac organoids but exhibited mild toxicity to the organoid formation measured by area ratio and FWHM (see
Overexposure to retinoids was shown to result in birth defects from retinoic acid deficiency with decreased levels of retinoic acid-producing enzymes. Hence, we also tested isotretinoin (13-cis-retinoic acid, category X retinoid) (see
Finally, the developmental toxicity of these drugs between cardiac organoid model and zebrafish whole embryo culture (zWEC), a well-established toxicity assay with promising potential to screen for teratogenicity, was tested. Transgenic Tg(my17:GFP) with GFP only in cardiomyocytes was used, which allowed scoring of myocardial development and heart tube looping at 48 hours post-fertilization (hpf) (
The present invention thus allows for the generation of cardiac organoids starting with 2D micropatterned hiPSC colonies, allowing for cell self-organization into 3D tissue structures during the differentiation process under geometric confinement. This approach provides the ability to create cardiac organoids that replicate, to a certain extent, the biological process of tissue self-assembly and morphogenesis during early heart formation. As many commonly reported birth defects are heart related, the potential for generating cardiac defects is a primary concern in determining drug developmental toxicity. The cardiac organoid approach of the present invention allows for the evaluation of human-specific drug-induced developmental toxicity based on the disruption of forming correct 3D organoid structures and developing normal cardiac contractile functions. By exposing the cardiac organoids to a range of drugs with different risks, an overall increase of teratogenic severity on cardiac organoid formation was found, corresponding to an increase of test concentrations, and an increase of risk category from A to X. Especially, category D drugs (phenytoin, lithium, doxycycline and tretinoin) showed diverse effects on developmental toxicity. Surprisingly, exposure of lithium only showed mild developmental toxicity of slight reduction in cardiac differentiation and organoid formation, although there has been a long debate of this drugs' developmental toxicity, especially resulting in congenital heart defects.
For highly toxic drugs, doxycycline failed to create 3D organoids due to massive cell apoptosis at high concentrations, whereas exposure of tretinoin created supersized organoids, but abolished all cardiac differentiation. The drug response results of thalidomide were generally consistent with published works of embryotoxicity using both whole embryo and in vitro stem cell models. In testing of the present invention, retinoids impaired the cardiac differentiation but promoted the formation of giant tissues. It is possible that progenitor cells in the retinoid-treated organoids retained a high proliferative capacity to give rise large tissue growth, but inhibited the terminal differentiation of cardiomyocytes. Another possibility is that the cells were directed to the endoderm lineages, as exposure to these compounds was shown to severely disrupt mesoderm formation.
Embryotoxicity assays based on WEC have been invaluable in drug toxicology for decades, because they can study drug effects on whole systematic biological processes. Generally, WEC assays focus on drug toxicity on structural and morphological features, such as limb and appendage malformations, but suffer from species differences that can lead to inaccurate predictions in humans. In contrast, stem cell-based assays, including mEST and newly developed in vitro platforms using human pluripotent stem cells, offer a cheaper and less invasive method to measure drug toxicity on mammalian and human cell differentiation. However, they cannot characterize tissue morphogenesis and organ formation. Meaningful comparisons between these systems are difficult to draw due to significant variations in characterization and measurement readouts from each model. In a comparison of triazole exposure to rat WEC, zebrafish WEC and mEST, the zebrafish tests showed the best correlation, followed by mEST tests, regarding their toxicity levels relative to in vivo studies conducted in industry. Rat WEC had the lowest correlation scores, which was likely caused by differences in drug exposure times calculated for each system, illustrating the challenges in embryotoxicity model comparisons. Other studies on embryotoxicity indicated a comparable result between WEC and mEST models, but poor correlation with in vivo reports. Furthermore, these works suggest that a combination of different testing systems can provide better predictivity of embryotoxic potential. One study integrated mEST and zebrafish WEC to understand biological mechanisms of triclosan on early development, and found that triclosan causes developmental defects via disruption of pluripotent markers. In relation to the apparent heterogeneity of the cardiac organoids, cardiac organoids according to the present invention can serve as complementary tests to current well-established assays to assess teratogenicity in both cell differentiation and tissue morphogenesis, which can provide a comprehensive risk-assessment toolkit to better predict drug toxicity on fetal health.
The present invention is directed primarily to studying early developmental events and drug effects on embryonic cardiogenesis, instead of mimicking adult-like physiology and drug responses. Future experiments, such as lineage tracking, fate mapping, and single cell genomic sequencing of organoids at different developmental stages, can reveal parallelism between human cardiac development and cardiac organoid formation through comprehensive molecular evidence.
Experimental Procedures
Micropatterning of Tissue Culture Surfaces
Surface micropatterning on tissue culture polystyrene was carried out using the selective etching approach. Patterned wafers were (SU8 master) fabricated using standard SU8 photolithography to fabricate molds with raised features of patterns. Poly(dimethyl siloxane) (PDMS) prepared at a 10:1 wt/wt ratio of elastomer base to curing agent was casted onto SU8 masters and clamped down using clear transparency sheets and glass slides. This process produced thin PDMS stencils with clear-through holes from the raised patterns on the SU8 master molds. Non-fouling poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) solution was prepared by combining 150 mg PEG 1000 (Polysciences, cat. no. 16666), 1.8 mL PEGDA 400 (Polysciences, cat. no. 01871), 14.55 mL isopropyl alcohol, and 0.45 mL MilliQ water. The solution was grafted onto 6-well tissue culture plates and cured under UV light exposure (Dymax UV Illuminator; model no. 2000EC) for 45 seconds. Micropatterns were fabricated by selective oxygen plasma etching (Oxygen plasma treatment system, PlasmaEtch PE50XL) of the PEG using the PDMS stencils. Micropatterned tissue culture plates were sterilized by immersing in 70% ethanol for 1 hour and subsequent washing with sterile phosphate buffered saline (PBS).
Cell Lines
Wild-type (WTC) hiPSC line was obtained from Dr. Conklin's laboratory at the Gladstone Institute of Cardiovascular Research. This hiPSC line was derived from a skin biopsy from a healthy adult Asian male donor in his early thirties. The original fibroblasts were reprogrammed using episomal methods with the factors of LIN28A, MYC (c-MYC), POU5F1 (OCT4) and SOX2. WTC GCaMPf6 hiPSC line was generated in Dr. Conklin's laboratory by targeting to the AAVS1 locus of WTC cells. A strong constitutive promoter (CAG) drives the expression of the GCaMP6f ORF. Yale-WT hiPSCs line was obtained from Dr. Abha Gupta's laboratory at the Yale University Department of Pediatrics and Child Study Center. Briefly hiPSCs were generated from the T-lymphocytes of a 25-year-old healthy South Asian male using the CytoTune-iPS Sendai Reprogramming kit.
Generation of Cardiac Organoids
Micropatterned surfaces were coated with diluted Geltrex hESC-qualified matrix (Life Technologies, cat. no. A1413302) at 37° C. for 1 hour prior to cell seeding. hiPSCs were cultured using standard PSC practices in Essential 8 (E8) medium (Life Technologies, cat. no. A1517001). At passaging confluency, cells were dissociated with Accutase (Life Technologies, cat. no. A1110501) and seeded at a density of 6.0×105 cells per well of the micropatterned 6-well plate (˜0.63×105 cells per cm2) supplemented with 10 μM Y27632 (BioVision, cat. no. 1784-5). Cardiac differentiation was initiated approximately 3 days after seeding (Day 0) when the micropatterns reached confluency, and performed via small molecule modulation of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway (Lian et al., 2012) with GSK3 inhibitor CHIR99021 (Day 0) (Stemgent, cat. no. 04-0004) and WNT pathway inhibitor IWP4 (Day 2) (Stemgent, cat. no. 04-0036). Small molecules were diluted in in RPMI 1640 medium (Life Technologies, cat. no. 11875093) supplemented with B27-minus insulin (RPMI/B27 minus insulin) (Life Technologies, cat. no. A1895601). Cardiac organoids began to contract around Day 9 of differentiation and were maintained in RPMI 1640 medium supplemented with complete B27 supplement (RPMI/B27 Complete) (Life Technologies cat. no. 17504044) until Day 20 for contractile and structural analysis.
Gene Expression Analysis
Gene expression was quantified using real-time qPCR analysis. On Day 20 of differentiation, cardiac organoids were sacrificed for RT-qPCR analysis. RNA was extracted using the RNeasy Mini Kit (Qiagen cat. no. 74104) and stored in −80° C. until needed. The RNA was then converted to cDNA using the Superscript IV First Strand Synthesis kit (Thermofisher cat. no. 18091050). Genes of interest includes cardiomyocyte-specific genes and stromal cell genes, plus TaqMan array of human factors for cardiogenesis (Thermofisher cat. no. 4414134). PCR plates were prepared and then run using the QuantStudio 3 Real-Time PCR System. All data was normalized to the respective housekeeping genes that were run in parallel with the rest of the gene assays. Value of DCt was calculated by subtracting the average Ct of housekeeping genes from the Ct of the genes of interest. Lower DCt indicates gene upregulation, where high DCt indicates gene downregulation.
Flow Cytometry Analysis
Cardiac organoids were dissociated using 0.25% Trypsin for 10-15 minutes. Cells were collected, centrifuged and washed with PBS. Cells were fixed and permeabilized with a mixture of 4% (vol/vol) paraformaldehyde and 0.2% (vol/vol) TritonX solution for 15 minutes. Cells were incubated with primary antibody cardiac troponin T (Thermofisher cat. no. MA5-12960) in a 1:250 dilution for 1 hour in PBS, and then incubated with AlexaFluor 546 secondary fluorophore for an additional hour. The cell suspension was washed, centrifuged and filtered through 35 μm mesh cell strainer. Flow cytometry was performed on the BDAccuriC6 at Flow Cytometry Core at Syracuse University.
Drug Treatment
Concentrations were chosen after evaluation of blood plasma concentrations reported for each drug from the FDA drug information database (accessdata.FDA.gov). Concentrations were chosen to be at or approximated by blood plasma concentrations, while accounting for drug solubility in water or DMSO, while also supplying a large range in order to detect potential toxicity. Drugs were diluted in the appropriate culture media at three concentrations each increasing by a factor of 10 with respective controls. Control samples were supplemented with water or DMSO (≤0.1%), depending on the solvent used to prepare the concentrated stock. Once initiated, the drugs were supplied continuously throughout the differentiation into cardiac organoids in order to mimic the continuous drug exposure during fetal development. Samples were terminated on Day 20 for motion tracking analysis and for fluorescence/confocal imaging to assess the developmental toxicity of specific drugs based on the organoid morphology and contractile physiology.
Analysis of Contraction Physiology
Organoids were imaged in an onstage microscope incubator (OkoLab Stage Top Incubator, UNO-T-HCO2) at 37° C. and 5% CO2 to maintain standard physiological conditions on a Nikon Ti-E inverted microscope with Andor Zyla 4.2+ digital CMOS camera. Videos of contracting cardiac organoids were recorded at 50 frames per second for ten seconds in brightfield and exported as a series of single frame image files. Contraction physiology was assessed using video-based motion tracking software that computes motion vectors based on block matching of pixel macroblocks from one frame to the next. The motion vectors were assimilated into a contraction motion waveform representative of contractile physiology, providing metrics such as contraction amplitude and frequency. Peak-to-peak interval is the time interval between contraction peak and relaxation peak. Contraction physiology was also assessed by recording the calcium transient using GCaMP6f hiPSC-derived cardiac organoids. Videos were taken under GFP excitation at 40 ms exposure time with 25 frames per second. Calcium flux signals were exported as Z-axis profiles in ImageJ. The fluorescence bleaching decay was corrected and time decay parameters τ0, τ50, τ75 were computed using in-house MATLAB scripts. The pulse duration is the time interval at which the calcium flux is at the half of the maximum flux. The time interval τ0 is defined as the time it takes for the calcium flux to reach peak fluorescence intensity, whereas τ50 and τ75 represent the time it takes for the calcium flux to decay 50% and 75% of the peak fluorescence, respectively. Relationships within the functional data was visualized utilizing R. Normalization to the zero mean, or Znormalization, was utilized to normalize and scale each parameter to have a mean of 0 with a range near 1. This preprocessing step ensures allows us to study the correlation and similarities of our studied variables. t-Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (t-SNE), an unsupervised machine learning algorithm, was used for exploratory data analysis of the impact of pattern sizes on the measured variables of the organoids. This modern dimensionality technique is able to take high-dimensional data and reduce multidimensional relationships between data to a lower dimensional space in such a way that similar relationships are grouped nearer to one another with a higher probability than dissimilar relationships or objects. This is accomplished by first creating a probability distribution of higher dimensional objects such that more similar pairs of higher dimensional objects are given a higher probability with more dissimilar points given a lower probability. A second probability distribution is then generated from this probability distribution for a lower dimensional map in such a way that preserves the maximum amount of similarity between the two probability distributions. t-SNE's ability to capture linear and nonlinear relationships between many variables makes it a powerful and versatile tool for investigating complex patterns while preserving higher dimensional structure of our data. t-SNE plots were generated using suggested parameters for perplexity, in order to condense the relationships between multiple recorded parameters down to a two-dimensional representative plot. Measurements were collected from mean values collected from 166 organoids. The actual t-SNE analysis was performed in R utilizing Jesse Krijthe's 2015 package Rtsne: T-Distrubed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding using a Barnes-Hut Implementation (https://github.com/jkrijthe/Rtsne) to reduce the representation of our parameters to two dimensions. Pattern diameters were displayed by varying size and color of each point, and then individual parameters were investigated by applying a color gradient in the t-SNE plots. A heatmap of the same data was generated to visualize each variables impact with respect to pattern diameter concurrently, while a correlogram gives further insight into the impact between parameters by utilizing Frank Harrell's Hmisc package to generate these figures https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=Hmi sc.
Immunofluorescence Staining and Confocal Microscopy
Organoids were characterized based on immunofluorescence staining patterns of cardiac tissue and smooth muscle-like tissue. After video recording, samples were sacrificed and fixed with 4% (vol/vol) paraformaldehyde (PFA) for 10 minutes. After PFA treatment, samples were washed and permeabilized with 0.2% (vol/vol) Triton X-100, blocked with 2% (wt/vol) bovine serum albumin (BSA) and incubated with the appropriate dilution of primary antibodies for 1 hour at room temperature. After incubation, the primary antibody was removed and washed with PBS. Secondary fluorescent antibodies were then incubated in the dark for 2 hours at appropriate dilutions and nuclei were tagged with 300 nM DAPI. All primary and secondary antibodies used are listed in Table 2 below. Confocal microscopy (Zeiss U880) was used to capture z-stacks (8 μm spacing between slices) of the organoids for height measurements and 3D reconstruction.
Morphological and Structural Characterization of Cardiac Organoids
The cardiac organoids were assessed based on three parameters that characterize the overall cardiac tissue distribution and 3D morphology as seen in
Zebrafish Whole Embryo Culture (zWEC) Embryotoxicity Assay
Transgenic Tg(my17:GFP) zebrafish that express GFP exclusively in cardiomyocytes were used to observe myocardium development in vivo. Adult fish were bred to generate a few hundred synchronized embryos, which were divided into individual wells of approximately 50 embryos. The drug stocks were diluted in zebrafish embryo medium. Chemicals at the same concentrations described in Table 1 were administered to chlorinated zebrafish embryos within the first 5 hpf, which is the estimated equivalent to the time point when the chemicals are introduced to the human cardiac organoids. Fresh embryo medium with chemicals is replaced at 24 hpf, when the embryos have developed a prominent linear heart tube, but not yet undergone looping. At 48 hpf, cardiac morphology and looping were scored as the first assessment of cardiac developmental toxicity on in vivo organogenesis. zWEC embryotoxic potentials of each chemical were scored based on the percentage of embryos exhibiting distinct cardiac morphology at 48 hpf. Normal looping (D-looping) refers to looping to the right-hand side of the embryo. Reverse looping (L-looping) is classified as looping towards the left side of the embryo, while no looping (N-looping) refers to a straight linear heart tube that has not successfully undergone cardiac looping events. A subset (˜20%) of embryos, including controls, did not express the GFP transgene, potentially due to silencing, and therefore cannot be classified as D/L/N-looping in this assay. Treatments that produced a rate of GFP absence that was significantly higher than controls are considered to reflect a severe abnormality in myocardial development.
Statistical Analysis
Data was plotted as box plots or mean±s.d. For single comparisons between two individual groups, a two-sided Student's t-test was used, and p≤0.05 was considered significant. For comparisons between more than two groups, one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed and p≤0.05 was considered significant. ANOVA analysis was supplemented with multiple comparison tests to determine significance between groups.
The present application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application No. 63/209,501, filed on Jun. 11, 2021.
This invention was made with government support under Grant No. R01HD101130 awarded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH). The government has certain rights in the invention.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63209501 | Jun 2021 | US |