The present disclosure generally relates to methods and arrangements of components that prevent high-pressure shutdown during loads that can exceed the design load, or designed saturated condenser temperature or condenser coil condition of a field deployable, mobile, Environmental Control Unit (ECU).
In military applications where transport bulk and weight are at a costly premium, simply enlarging ECU's for greater capacity is unacceptable. Heretofore, attempts have been made to reduce the size and weight of ECU's and produce a lighter, smaller, more efficient unit. The effort has primarily been focused on known techniques such as hot gas by-pass and fixed capacity compressors, in a smaller frame or enclosure.
ECU's for military use differ from non military air conditioning systems. An ECU for military service is designed for withstanding induced vibration from ship, air, and ground transportation, particularly when stacked with other units. Additionally, lifting provisions must be provided for helicopter sling transport; and, the units must withstand dropping, 40 Mph winds with 4 inches per hour rain, must be able to operate on both 60 and 50 hertz alternating current with limited compressor starts and must be capable of being operated on un-prepared or rough terrain. In military service, the operational extremes can vary from severe cold, snow and freezing rain to above 145° F. combined ground solar and ambient load. Military service units must also withstand tropical, desert, and high altitude conditions. Each ECU intended for military field service is developed for a specific capacity and application; however, once fielded, will be required to operate when attached to any tent or hard wall structure. It has been difficult to match ECU capacity to the load due to the various field tent and hard wall shelter variations. These structures vary in insulation factor, fenestration, and the type of air distribution system employed. Thermal loads and evaporator air flow can vary to an extent that the known evaporator de-rating techniques, such as hot gas by-pass and compressor suction cooling are inefficient. In many cases, it has been found such techniques cannot provide the range of control necessary to prevent component degradation or provide consistent ECU operation.
In such military applications, the ECU can be a split design, with the evaporator inside the area to be cooled with the condenser and compressor section outside; or, all components can be contained within a single enclosure. ECU's for military applications are generally powered by portable generators, but may be connected to a local power grid when such is available. Examples of the range of refrigerants used are HCFC-22, HFC-134a and R410,A R407C. Current ECU's have compressors with fixed capacity output. Load capacities of an ECU generally range from about 9,000 BTU to about 100,000 BTU. The most commonly used ECU's have a capacity of about 60,000 BTU.
In an attempt to retain design airflow, ECU condensers and evaporators are provided with screens and filters to protect them from debris. Particulate matter encountered in military field usage can vary from blown organic plant matter, such as grasses or trees, to foot and vehicle generated sand and dust, to climatic sand and dust storms. Restriction of condenser airflow from sand and dust is a frequent field occurrence. The dust that is removed from condensers and evaporators has the consistency of talc and passes easily through the screens and filters, clogging coils and reducing airflow.
Currently, there is no method of preventing sand and dust from causing coil airflow restriction in a unit, in a manner that will meet space volume and electrical power draw requirements. For operation in high ambient solar temperatures, some manufacturers have included a sun shield or fly to reduce the solar load on the ECU, in an attempt to reduce compressor high side system pressures. Also, coils are being cleaned more frequently; however, with so many ECU's in the field, this takes time and cannot always be done in a timely manner.
Another ECU problem is the cost of providing diesel fuel for power generation in the field. Fuel cost can easily exceed $30.00 per gallon on site. Current ECU technology uses hot gas bypass, to de-rate or reduce the efficiency of the evaporator during low load conditions. The by-pass of gas can be before or after the evaporator. This fluid by-pass is not used for cooling but uses compressor energy to pump it. Such non-cooling load on the compressor is disadvantageous because it results in costly increased diesel fuel consumption.
These aforesaid refrigerant management techniques have added to the complexity of the ECU in view of the requirement for the additional piping, valves and fittings. They have also resulted in increased system leaks, inoperable units and increased maintenance. Furthermore, the gas by-pass approach does not adequately regulate the system when the condenser is restricted, or during ECU operation under high ambient conditions when the load exceeds the design load. This results in frequent nuisance shut downs, due to overpressure conditions at the compressor discharge.
One approach to addressing the described problems is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 6,047,557; U.S. Pat. No. 6,601,397 B2; International Publication Number WO 2006/014079 A1 and U.S. Pat. Publication 2005/0189888 A1 the disclosures of which are incorporated herein by reference in their entireties. These patents show the components of the compressors and how they work. The solution presented in the above patents is that of using a variable capacity type scroll compressor that is able to load and unload to vary the capacity. Other methods use variable speed compressor drive converters that provide scroll or rotary compressor RPM controls for changing the capacity output of a compressor. Although the techniques described in the aforesaid patents have been used in commercial refrigeration applications and in unitary air conditioners for the commercial market, such systems have not been able to meet the special operational, maintenance, and sustainment cost requirements for a military field deployable ECU.
U.S. Patent Publication 2005/0189888 A1 refers to a variable speed drive of compressors; and, U.S. Pat. No. 6,047,557 refers to a pulse width modulating duty cycle. Each has the ability to be temperature controlled by an operator selectable thermostat input with additional pressure and temperature sensor connection locations.
It has been proposed to employ an inverter driven compressor for an ECU application; however, the inverter or variable frequency drive is complicated to diagnose and creates high levels of Electro Magnetic Interference. EMI is also costly to shield.
In military applications, ECU's are often required to operate in high ambient conditions with blowing sand and dust. In order to meet recently increased demand for military service applications, commercially available and modified commercial air conditioners have been employed in military usage. In desert environments, the modified commercial air conditioners have frequently shut down due to over pressure. Such units employed in desert environments have also experienced high failure rates of compressors, contactors and function controllers. These failures have been attributed to prolonged operation at elevated system pressure and subsequent high compressor motor current draw. The cost and effort required to provide routine maintenance and repair has thus been increased. Furthermore, where non-military contractors are hired to perform maintenance, if their contract cost is exceeded, maintenance and repair work is stopped until contract cost issues are resolved, resulting in periods of inoperation.
Current ECU and fielded commercial air conditioners do not have the ability to reduce capacity during excessive high ambient conditions or when operated with reduced condenser air flow, caused by sand and dust loading. Loss of cooling and additional maintenance is created from high-pressure induced short cycling, i.e., when the compressor overload pressure switch trips on high-pressure. Some designs will automatically reset, and others need to be manually reset. High temperature starting and stopping of the compressor under load also decreases the life of the compressor. Repetitive starting and stopping of compressors can also create power line problems when powered by a mobile generator; and, the loss of cooling can also be life threatening in a field hospital application.
It has thus been desired to provide a lighter, smaller, more efficient ECU that self regulates capacity based on indoor and outside temperatures, indoor air distribution airflows and evaporator and condenser coil heat transfer conditions without shut downs due to overpressure.
However, when compressor high side capacity is exceeded, currently the compressor is simply shut down. This is disadvantageous for the reasons detailed above. Accordingly, it has been deemed desirable to develop a new and improved environmental control unit which would overcome the foregoing difficulties and others while providing better and more advantageous overall results.
The subject matter of the present disclosure integrates a variable capacity compressor with pressure and temperature sensors to modulate system capacity based on component condition, ambient temperatures, and airflows. This variable capacity system control, self regulates, during over capacity and under capacity conditions, to the maximum cooling capacity obtainable using less power than systems currently available in ECU's utilized in military field service.
More specifically, the present disclosure relates to the use of variable capacity compressors and methods to provide voltage control input to the variable capacity compressor controller or inverter. This eliminates the need for hot gas by-pass, which is inefficient during low load conditions, and provides an alternative to compressor suction side quenching and similar refrigerant management schemes that have increased the occurrence of refrigerant leaks.
The present system maintains ECU operation during out-of-design tolerance operation such as operation with high condenser pressure, low evaporator pressure and excessive compressor inlet temperature. The presently disclosed adaptive control provides a variable voltage output signal to operate commercially available compressor controllers that vary the compressor capacity (such as digital scroll) or the speed of the compressor (such as variable frequency drive or inverter). This adaptive input provides automatic ECU balancing when used in an environmentally severe or military application, matching variable cooling capacity based on maximum heat transfer of the evaporator or condenser and protects the compressor inlet temperature.
This disclosure describes and illustrates a system with the ability to vary the system high and low side pressures and temperatures, coupled with providing thermostat input to a digital or variable speed compressor drive controller. The compressor capacity can be reduced during low load conditions, caused by cool ambient conditions or a restricted evaporator coil. The present system has the ability to lower the compressor capacity to match the load and prevents frost or evaporator freeze up, and reduces energy related costs compared to a system employing hot gas by-pass. By reducing compressor output to match the heat rejection capabilities of the condenser, where condenser airflow has become restricted, compressor cut-off due to high pressure is eliminated. During high evaporator load conditions, when the suction gas temperature exceeds the manufacturer's design limits, the compressor capacity can be changed to lower the suction temperature thereby saving energy. Contrasted with systems which use hot gas by-pass and quench type refrigerant management resulting in additional components, associated tubing and fittings with greater potential leak points, this disclosure presents a system that reduces generator fuel or electric grid cost, is simple to understand and repair while using fewer components.
In one embodiment, the sensors may generate a signal to a controller which operates an actuator for effecting movement of a member in the compressor for varying compressor capacity. In another embodiment, the sensors may generate a signal to a controller which effects compressor speed changes to vary the capacity. In a sensed overload condition, the generated signal effects varying the compressor capacity to the lowest capacity output condition.
Referring now to
In order to provide the compressor 1 with high temperature and pressure protection and system safety, additional components are specified by the compressor manufacture and the military. A high-pressure switch 27 is typically specified, with a manual reset, to shut the compressor off in the event of a restricted filter dryer 9, or insufficient refrigerant cooling of the condenser 2, that can be created by reduced airflow, such as caused by sand or dust restriction, or high ambient conditions. The high-pressure manually resettable switch 27, when tripped, will shut off the compressor, stopping the ECU from cooling until the operator manually resets the switch. This is by design, in order to require human operator maintenance action. The ECU operational manual usually instructs that, before manually resetting of the high-pressure switch 27, the condenser condition should be checked for blockage and cleaned as needed. The usual scenario is that the high-pressure switch 27 is repeatedly reset until maintenance personnel can clean the coil with pressurized air or water. A pressure relief valve 28 located in the compressor discharge line provides release of excessive system pressure and recloses when a safe pressure is established. A sight glass 10 between the filter drier 9 and an expansion device 11 provides a visual observation of the liquid charge and moisture state of the system and aids during servicing.
A low-pressure manually resettable switch 6 is specified to shut the compressor off, in the event of loss of system charge. More commonly, it will trip due to a frosted, frozen evaporator coil, due to airflow loss. Air flow restriction through evaporator 3 can be caused by the conventional air filter (not shown) being clogged with sand and dust. In many cases such air filter cannot capture or retain the dust due to its small size. Over time, the dust will clog the evaporator 3 and restrict the air flow through the evaporator. If the low-pressure switch 6 trips, the compressor will stop, preventing the ECU from cooling until the operator manually resets the switch. This requirement is by design, in order to require human operator maintenance action. The ECU operational manual usually instructs that, before manual resetting of the low-pressure switch 6, the condition of evaporator 3 be checked for blockage and the evaporator be cleaned, as needed. Also, the inlet filter and return ducts are checked for blockage or restriction. If no deficiency is found, gages are attached and the system is checked for low refrigerant charge level. The low-pressure switch 6 may be repeatedly reset until maintenance personnel can repair the ECU. The continual resetting of either the low pressure switch 6 or the high pressure switch 27 results in increased wear of the compressor. This, in turn, increases the power required to operate the compressor and creates excessive loads on the power supply generator. If either pressure switch is left tripped, no cooling is provided to the shelter.
In order to match cooling capacity to the load, an indoor temperature-sensing thermostat 24 cycles the compressor 1 on and off as required. This is not preferred, and in some cases not allowed when powered by mobile generators. Indoor thermostat 24 is then used as an on-off switch operating contactors 23 provided for compressor control. Contactors 23 may be wired to a soft start device or be used separately to cycle the compressor 1 on and off. Frequent compressor starting causes high compressor motor current draw which overloads the power grid creating line surges and low voltages.
Heretofore, it has been common practice in a typical ECU arrangement to match cooling capacity to the load by using a refrigerant by-pass system. In the
In the
In addition to using a hot gas bypass valve 12, the prior art system of
A high inlet temperature will over-heat the compressor 1 degrading its useful life. Temperature sensor 15 can also be located on the compressor outlet or inside the compressor.
Providing flow through valve 14 and cooling of compressor 1 prevents the compressor 1 from having to be cycled off, in order to not exceed the manufacturer's maximum inlet temperature recommendations. The hot gas bypass 12 and liquid quench valve 14 are shown as common methods of control.
Known ECU's require the ability to de-rate the capacity of condenser 2 and evaporator 3, and cool the compressor 1, in order to prevent compressor 1 from cycling on and off as loads change.
In the above described known system example, any time gas or high pressure liquid is diverted from the basic refrigeration cycle, efficiency is lost. The efficiency loss is the result of electrical power required for compressor operation during any by-pass function. This electrical power required for the compressor may become greater than the actual cooling effect.
An ECU employed for a military application is also more complex in operation than a commercial unit. This is due to the added field environment of sand and dirt loading on the coils. As coils experience reduced airflow, the system reacts to provide premature diversion of gas or high-pressure liquid.
A shelter 306 is shown in
Another shelter 313 may have a hard or soft wall with a first indoor coil 311 and a second indoor coil 312, each containing a ventilation blower with related refrigerant and electrical controls. An outside coil 316 includes a compressor and related refrigerant and electrical controls. The related refrigerant and electrical connections 314 and 315 are routed through shelter wall 313 and attached after placement of indoor coils 311, 312 and outdoor coil 316. Indoor coils 311, 312 can be of a window mount style to provide for fresh air make up flow, mounted to an inside wall, or can be placed on the floor or an elevated stand.
Another shelter 326 may have a hard or soft wall. The supply and return air flow from ECU 327 is connected to the shelter 326 by flexible or rigid duct work 328, 329.
Generator 320 is connected to a power distribution box 318 by power cable 319. The power distribution box 318 supplies power through cable 304 to the compressors and fan motors associated with indoor coil 300 and outdoor coil 303 and power for other uses in shelter 301, through power cable 321.
In addition, power distribution box 318 supplies the compressors and fan motors for indoor coil 305 and outdoor coil 308 through power cable 309. Power for other uses in shelter 306 is supplied through power cable 322.
Power distribution box 318 also supplies power to the compressors and fan motors associated with indoor coils 311, 312 and outdoor coil 316 through power cable 317. Shelter 313 is supplied through power cable 323 for its other uses.
Power distribution box 318 also supplies ECU 327 through power cable 325. Other electrical uses for shelter 326 are supplied through power cable 324.
In
In the
A pressure switch 116 is disposed on the compressor high pressure or discharge line and shuts off the compressor 101 when the maximum allowable design pressure is exceeded. Another pressure switch 106 is disposed in the low pressure or evaporator suction return line 107 and shuts off compressor 101 when the pressure in line 107 is below allowable design suction pressure. A pressure relief valve 108 is set to release excess refrigerant pressure if maximum allowable design pressure is exceeded, e.g. an over pressure condition is sensed. Valve 108 automatically recloses when normal pressure resumes. A service access port 118 is provided in the compressor high pressure discharge line; and, a suction service access port 117 is provided in the suction line 107, both for facilitating diagnostic and refrigerant servicing.
The prior art system of
Instead, the ECU refrigeration system of
An inverter driven compressor may be employed, but has the disadvantage of being difficult to fault diagnose and costly to shield compared to a digitally controlled compressor. If an inverter driven compressor is employed, the variable voltage hereinafter described is connected to the variable voltage input terminals of the compressor inverter drive.
The following describes an embodiment of the present system in which an electrical control operates a digital compressor drive to create a compressor control signal. The variable output signal is connected to the variable voltage input terminals of the compressor drive.
A sensor 120 is disposed in evaporator discharge line 107 and may be a pressure or temperature source that provides suction side or evaporator discharge signals. A sensor 121 is disposed in the condenser discharge line and may be a pressure or temperature source that provides high-pressure side or condenser discharge signals. Another sensor 122 may be disposed in the compressor discharge line and may be a pressure or a temperature source that provides compressor discharge signals. A thermostat 123 is disposed to provide conditioned air temperature regulation signals for the air in the shelter.
Heretofore, ECU's operated in fielded operational climatic conditions encountered in military applications have not proven satisfactory because of component deficiencies. Also, known air conditioning systems have previously been operated by compressor on-off cycling.
In such a known system, the pressure switch 116 and pressure switch 106 were connected to compressor control 114. Compressor control 114 turned off compressor 101 during an excessively low or high-pressure occurrence. In such prior art systems, no provisions were made to provide variable compressor capacity control based on high side pressures. As discussed earlier, neither hot gas by-pass, liquid quench, nor similar hydraulic control devices are used in an ECU to modulate capacity based on the high-pressure side.
Referring to
The benefit of a single control input is that the digital controller or inverter (depicted as compressor control 114) can be driven with only one connection that is the summation of many sensors. A single variable voltage connection is easier to diagnose. The compressor controller can be made less expensive, as, the pressure and temperature sensors do not have to terminate at the compressor controller. In addition, each sensor input requires software and in this embodiment custom software for operation. Thus the compressor controller 114 becomes application specific, resulting in higher cost and decreased availability as compared to an off-the-shelf readily available compressor controller 114. By using the single thermostat input, the total system capacity can be regulated to the maximum coil capacities during extreme high ambient conditions, such as caused by sand and dust loading of coils or an improperly sized shelter air distribution system.
This voltage control is based upon the fact that a condenser high pressure and a evaporator low pressure will not occur at the same time. Only one sensor at a time will be operational in the circuit, except for the thermostat. In the event that a condenser high pressure and compressor high temperature signal occurred at the same time, the voltage would modulate between the two or be the sum of these two inputs further reducing the regulation of the compressor. If the thermostat is calling for reduced compressor capacity, it is unlikely that any other sensor would be active.
For this example, a positive temperature coefficient (PTC) thermistor 216A employed in discharge side sensor 211 increases in resistance as the compressor discharge temperature rises. The increased resistance lowers the voltage of the control signal, which in turn effects compressor component movement for reducing the compressor output. The resistance of thermistor 211 continues to increase until the compressor discharge temperature begins to lower. As the compressor discharge temperature lowers, the resistance lowers effecting movement of the compressor components for increasing the compressor capacity. The sensor 211 may be placed on the high-pressure outlet of the compressor. This location and function thus provides the same compressor protection as liquid quench valve 14 of the Prior Art system of
A negative temperature coefficient (NTC) thermostat is employed in suction side sensor 212, which has a negative coefficient thermistor 216b built in. As the temperature decreases, the resistance of 216b will increase, thereby lowering the output voltage 215. As the control signal 215 voltage is reduced, the compressor control components will be moved and compressor capacity decreased, reducing cooling system capacity. This type of sensor may be placed at the evaporator discharge location to prevent evaporator freeze up, due to low airflow caused by a coil or filter clogged by sand or dust or from shelter ducting which does not provide adequate airflow.
Thermostat signal sensor 213 may be of a snap action type. As depicted in
Referring to
Referring to
The first circuit includes series resistor 231, and parallel resistor 232, and drops the output of the control device 239 to a level that is acceptable to the compressor controller 250.
The second circuit, comprising parallel resistors 233, 234, 235, is brought into effect as required by closure of any of the individual system condition switches 242, 243, 244, respectively. These are operative to lower the output signal to the compressor controller to reduce output capacity of the compressor.
The first and second circuits comprise the variable capacity control. In the event a component failure occurs in either of the first or second circuit and an open circuit is created at diode 248, the third circuit 241 (bottle) switch voltage is applied to output 250. The third circuit comprises series resistor 236, and parallel resistors 237, 238. When the switch 241 is in its normal position as shown in
In one embodiment, it has been found operable, for example, to connect output 250 to a Copeland Scroll Digital Compressor Controller part number 543-0024-00. This type of Controller may be employed in the electronic interface between a Copeland Scroll Digital Compressor, such as the ZPD series. However, it will be understood that various types of electronic interfaces may be employed depending on the type of variable capacity compressor, i.e. whether rotary, piston or scroll. This circuit, output 250 connects to the connection points for a variable thermostat voltage. When using the Copeland Scroll Digital Compressor Controller thermostat input, a voltage below 1.4 volts cycles the compressor off. A 1.4 volt to 5 volt variable input controls the compressor capacity from 10% to 100%.
With further reference to
Referring to
Thermostat 239 may be a Johnson Control A350P proportional temperature control that supplies a 10 to 0 volt DC output. Resistor 231 and resistor 232 fixed values may be selected to lower the voltage from 10 to 0 to a 5 to 0 volt potential DC for compatibility with a 5 volt DC compressor electronic interface control. Thermostat 239 increases or decreases the voltage output in relation to sensor 240 and the manually selected temperature set point. When temperature control thermostat 239 calls for maximum cooling, a 5 volt signal is supplied to output 250. When no cooling is required, the voltage drops to 0 volts. A 0 volt output signal 250 to the electronic interface turns off the compressor.
As stated previously it is desirable that an ECU not provide temperature regulation by cycling the compressor on and off. When the switch 241 is in the normal position shown in solid line in
In addition to the circuitry illustrated in
Referring to
In
Referring to
The run routine is initiated and compressor inlet outlet temperature 304, high pressure 307, and evaporator outlet 305 readings are taken. Data derived from testing performed within a controlled ambient-psychrometric chamber is employed to provide the operational control and hysteresis of capacity changes of the ECU vapor cycle. This data provided within a controlled ambient-psychrometric chamber is employed to provide the operations control and hysteresis of capacity changes of the ECU vapor cycle. This data is provided within the memory of microprocessor 312. The microprocessor 312 is operational to increase or decrease the compressor capacity voltage 301 to best match the cooling capacity to component condition and thermostat input 302 set point. The control panel 316 may present the operator with the on/off status and any user preferred information such as ambient and indoor temperature, amperage draw, and the capacity the unit is currently producing to name a few. In addition to the current ECU status information on component degradation such as a clogging evaporator filter or restricted condenser airflow can be provided to the operator for scheduled maintenance. It will be understood that variations of the operation sequences, number of sensors, and level of prognostic and diagnostics may be employed to provide reliable operation and provide notice of need for repair depending upon the application.
The disclosure herein has been described with reference to the preferred embodiments. Obviously, modifications and alterations will occur to others upon reading and understanding the preceding detailed description. It is intended that the disclosure be construed as including all such modifications and alterations insofar as they come within the scope of the appended claims or equivalents thereof.