Plastic and reconstructive surgery regularly uses free flaps, for example in breast reconstruction. In free flap tissue surgery, a free flap (e.g., tissue and/or muscle and its associated artery and vein) is removed from one part of the body or donor site and is reattached to another part of the body or recipient site. The artery and vein of the transferred tissue and/or muscle are then anastomosed to a native artery and vein in order to achieve blood circulation in the transferred free flap (e.g., tissue and/or muscle).
The anastomosis of the free flap tissue to the native tissue is typically done using microvascular techniques, including under microscopic visualization. In previous years, several surgical instruments and techniques have been developed to aid in anastomosis. One known system for creating an anastomosis is an anastomosis coupler, described in U.S. Pat. No. 7,192,400, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference. This anastomotic coupler is a surgical instrument that allows a surgeon to more easily and effectively join together two blood vessel ends. The coupler involves the use of two fastener portions, in the shape of rings, upon which are secured respective sections of the vessel to be attached. Each fastener portion is also provided with a series of pins, and corresponding holes for receiving those pins, in order to close and connect the portions, and in turn the vessel, together (See
Microvascular anastomosis is the surgical coaptation of veins and arteries. Microvascular anastomosis of veins is readily accomplished using a microanastomotic coupling device, such as the GEM FLOW COUPLER®, which reduces complication rates, improves patency rates, substantially reduces the time necessary to complete the coaptation compared to manual suturing techniques. However, microanastomosis of arteries is most often accomplished with standard manual suturing techniques because the thick, muscular wall of the arteries precludes use of the current microanastomotic couplers. The thick wall of the artery prevents the tissue of the arterial wall from being stretched over the rings of a coupler. Each microanastomotic coupler ring has a plurality of pins or posts, which are used to secure an everted portion of a vessel segment to the ring. Even after securing one portion of an everted arterial segment to a pin or post (or even a few pins or posts) of a microanastomotic coupler ring, efforts to secure remaining portions of the everted arterial segment to the coupler ring are often complicated by the first portion coming off the previously-secured pin(s) or post(s). Due to the lack of a reliable device or technique to avoid this problem, manual suturing is predominantly used for surgical coaptation of arteries.
However, microscopic manual suturing of arteries can be quite challenging, primarily due to the small size of the vessels and the minimal working space. Since most vessels are only 1 to 3 mm in diameter, the procedure requires the use of a surgical microscope. The sutures are about 70 μm thick and can be difficult to handle and as a result, medical practitioners (e.g., surgeons and surgical residents) must undergo extensive additional training prior to operating on a patient in need of tissue transfer. Moreover, surgeons attempt to limit the recipient site morbidity resulting in small incisions and small areas within which to work. For instance, in microsurgical postmastectomy breast reconstruction, the surgeon may typically work in a surgical field of approximately 3 cm or less. These size constraints may make it difficult for surgeons to maneuver their surgical instruments. Arterial microanastomoses performed by manual suturing take approximately 23.5 minutes in the operating room, versus coaptation times as low as 5 minutes or less that would be possible if a surgeon were using a coupling device.
The present disclosure provides improved vessel sizing and vessel eversion systems, devices and methods to improve the coaptation of veins and arteries in arterial microvascular anastomosis procedures.
In a first embodiment, an everter device includes a handle and at least one eversion tip. The handle has a first end and a second and each of the at least one eversion tip is coupled to a respective end of the handle. Additionally, the at least one eversion tip has a respective distal end, a respective proximal end, and a respective eversion surface.
In another example embodiment, the at least one eversion tip is rotatably coupled to the handle.
In another example embodiment, the at least one eversion tip is removably coupled to the handle.
In another example embodiment, the eversion surface includes a piloting region starting at the distal end of the eversion tip, a concave region, a transition region, and a nearly linear region ending at the proximal end of the eversion tip. The concave region connects the piloting region to the transition region, the transition region connects the concave region to the nearly linear region, and the eversion surface transitions from a concave surface to a convex surface in the transition region. Additionally, the eversion tip has a diameter. The diameter of the eversion tip in the concave region increases exponentially as the eversion surface approaches the transition region. The diameter of the eversion tip in the transition region continuously increases through the transition region towards the nearly linear region. The rate of change of the diameter of the eversion tip in the transition region continuously decreases through the transition region towards the nearly linear region, and the diameter of the eversion tip in the nearly linear region continues to increase until reaching the proximal end of the eversion tip.
In another example embodiment, the eversion surface is a curved surface between the distal end and the proximal end of the eversion tip. The curved surface slopes outward toward a shoulder of the eversion tip and then slopes back inward after the shoulder as the curved surface approaches the proximal end.
In another example embodiment, the eversion surface is configured to expand radially outward at the shoulder in response to a compressive force applied on the curved surface. The compressive force is applied toward the proximal end.
In another example embodiment, the eversion tip is made from an elastic material, which is piercable, deformable, or that is adapted to axially recede to accommodate posts or pins of a coupler ring of an anastomosis clamp system.
In another example embodiment, the elastic material is configured to deform or axially recede when the everter device is advanced into contact with posts or pins of a coupler ring.
In another example embodiment, the elastic material is a thermoplastic elastomer.
In another example embodiment, the thermoplastic elastomer is a silicone elastomer.
In another example embodiment, the silicone elastomer is NUSIL 4840 silicone.
In another example embodiment, the eversion tip has a Shore A hardness between 10 and 50.
In another example embodiment, the eversion tip has a Shore A hardness between 30 and 45.
In another example embodiment, the handle includes a plurality of gripping members.
In another example embodiment, the handle includes at least one retention barb configured and arranged to retain the at least one eversion tip on the handle.
In another example embodiment, the retention barb includes a shelf, a trunk and a cap. The trunk is adjacent to the shelf and extends from the shelf to the cap. Additionally, the cap forms a respective end of the handle.
In a second embodiment, a method includes providing a coupler ring on a vessel segment where the coupler ring has a plurality of pins projecting therefrom, such that the securement pins are directed toward a free end of the vessel segment. The method also includes advancing a rotatable eversion tip of an everter device toward the coupler ring and the free end of the vessel segment until a distal end of the eversion tip is received in the free end of the vessel segment and advanced past the coupler ring. Additionally, the method includes continuing to advance the rotatable eversion tip of the everter device toward the coupler ring until the free end of the vessel segment is everted over the coupler ring, applying sufficient force to the everter device to cause the pins of the coupler ring to pierce through the everted free end of the vessel segment, and removing the everter device from the vessel segment.
In a third embodiment, a sizing device includes a handle and at least one sizing guide. The handle has a first end and a second end. Each of the at least one sizing guide is coupled to a respective end of the handle. Additionally, the at least one sizing guide has a plurality of sizing apertures and associated sizing indicators.
In another example embodiment, the at least one sizing guide is removably coupled to the handle.
In another example embodiment, the handle includes a plurality of gripping members.
In another example embodiment, the handle includes at least one retention member configured and arranged to retain the at least one sizing guide on the handle.
In another example embodiment, the retention member is a retention barb.
In another example embodiment, the plurality of sizing apertures have diameters between 0.1 mm and 10.0 mm.
In a fourth embodiment, an eversion kit includes an everter device and a sizing device. The everter device includes a first handle having a first end and a second end, and at least one eversion tip. Each of the at least one eversion tip is coupled to a respective end of the handle. The at least one eversion tip has a respective distal end, a respective proximal end and a respective eversion surface. The sizing device includes a second handle having a first end portion and a second end portion, and at least one sizing guide. The at least one sizing guide is coupled to a respective end portion of the handle. Additionally, the at least one sizing guide has a plurality of sizing apertures and associated sizing indicators.
In another example embodiment, the at least one eversion tip of the everter device is rotatably coupled to the handle.
In another example embodiment, the at least one eversion tip of the everter device is removably coupled to the handle.
In another example embodiment, the eversion surface of the at least one eversion tip of the everter device is a curved surface between the distal end and the proximal end of the eversion tip. The curved surface slopes outward toward a shoulder of the eversion tip and then slopes back inward after the shoulder as the curved surfaces approaches the proximal end of the eversion tip.
In another example embodiment, the eversion tip is made from an elastic material, which is piercable, deformable, or that is adapted to axially recede to accommodate posts or pins of a coupler ring of an anastomosis clamp system.
In another example embodiment, the eversion tip has a Shore A hardness between 10 and 50 and preferably a Shore A hardness between 30 and 45.
In another example embodiment, the first handle and the second handle both include a plurality of gripping members.
In another example embodiment, the first handle includes at least one retention barb configured and arranged to retain the at least one eversion tip on the first handle.
In a fifth embodiment, a method includes determining a size of a vessel segment and providing a coupler ring on a vessel segment. The coupler ring has a plurality of pins projecting therefrom, such that the securement pins are directed toward a free end of the vessel segment. The method also includes advancing an eversion tip of an everter device toward the coupler ring and the free end of the vessel segment until a distal end of the eversion tip is received in the free end of the vessel segment and advanced past the coupler ring, continuing to advance the eversion tip of the everter device toward the coupler ring until the free end of the vessel segment is everted over the coupler ring, applying sufficient force to the everter device to cause the pins of the coupler ring to pierce through the everted free end of the vessel segment, and removing the everter device from the vessel segment.
It is accordingly an advantage of the present disclosure to improve coaptation of veins and arteries in arterial microvascular anastomosis procedures
It is another advantage of the present disclosure to improve vessel wall capture and retention on pins of a ring coupler device used for a microvascular anastomosis procedure.
It is another advantage of the present disclosure to improve vessel wall eversion when performing a microvascular anastomosis procedure when using a ring coupler device.
It is a further advantage of the present disclosure to provide reliable vessel sizing device and methods.
It is yet a further advantage of the present disclosure to reduce vessel wall tearing and failure when performing a microvascular anastomosis procedure when using a ring coupler device.
It is still another advantage of the present disclosure to reduce coaptation times when performing arterial microanastomosis procedures.
Additional features and advantages of the disclosed vessel sizing and vessel eversion systems, devices and methods are described in, and will be apparent from, the following Detailed Description and the Figures. The features and advantages described herein are not all-inclusive and, in particular, many additional features and advantages will be apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art in view of the figures and description. Also, any particular embodiment does not have to have all of the advantages listed herein. Moreover, it should be noted that the language used in the specification has been principally selected for readability and instructional purposes, and not to limit the scope of the inventive subject matter.
As discussed above, vascular monitoring system, device and method are provided to reduce vessel wall tearing and failure and improve vessel wall eversion and vessel wall capture and retention on pins of a ring coupler device when performing a microvascular anastomosis procedure. Additionally, the systems, devices and methods disclosed herein are provided to enable reliable vessel sizing as to reduce coaptation times when performing arterial microanastomosis procedures. Arterial microanastomoses performed by manual suturing take approximately 23.5 minutes in the operating room, versus coaptation times as low as 5 minutes or less when successfully using a coupling device. Successful using of a coupling device often requires accurately determining vessel sizes and properly and efficiently everting the vessel wall to ensure vessel wall capture and retention on pins of the ring coupler.
In an effort to promote efficiency in the execution of an arterial microanastomosis procedure, it is found that the challenges presented by the relatively thick wall of an artery (as compared to the wall thickness of a vein) can be mitigated by applying uniform support to a region of an arterial segment just behind, and/or within, a coupler ring of an anastomosis clamp system such as the such as the GEM FLOW COUPLER® of Synovis Micro Companies. Example embodiments of everter devices and sizing devices are described in further detail below.
As illustrated in
Handle 110 may include a first shoulder 112a near the first end a second shoulder 112b near the second end (hereinafter referred to generally as shoulder 112). Eversion tip(s) 120 may be substantially flush with the edge of shoulder(s) 112 such that the eversion tip(s) are in contact with shoulder(s) 112 or are in close proximity with shoulder(s) 112 with a small gap (e.g., a gap of approximately 0.006 inches or 0.15 mm). Even if eversion tip(s) 120 are in contact with shoulder(s) 112, the eversion tip(s) 120 may still be capable of rotating about central axis 105.
In an example, the length (LE) 122 of the everter device 100 may be between 4.0 inches to 7.0 and may preferably be approximately 5.7 inches (144.78 mm). The size, shape and dimensions (e.g., length) of everter device 100 may be adapted to provide sufficient surface area for gripping and handling by a medical practitioner as well as being optimized for use in small surgical fields (e.g., surgical fields of approximately 3 cm or less).
In an example, handle 110 may include gripping members 114. For example, the bottom of handle 110 may include gripping member 114, such as a plurality of ribs or ridges to provide the user, such as a medical practitioner, additional gripping and handling features on handle 110. Additionally, gripping members 114 may comprise a plurality of projections or bumps to provide better gripping and handling characteristics of everter device 100 (similar to gripping members 314b and 314c of
Handle 110 may be formed of a rigid or semi-rigid material, such as thermoplastic, that is adapted to provide support for eversion tips 120 while preventing excessive deformation during use. For example, handle 110 may be made from MAKROLON 2458 polycarbonate. In another example, the exterior of the everter device 100 may be made substantially of or entirely made of pierceable material. For example, both the handle 110 and eversion tips 120 may be formed of a pierceable material and the everter device 100 may further include a supporting rod or other internal structural support member. The supporting rod may be made of a rigid or semi-rigid material that is adapted to support eversion tops 120 while preventing excessive deformation during use.
As illustrated in
Retention barbs 130 may be formed as a single piece with handle 110. In another example, retention barbs 130 may be threadingly connected to handle 110 such that different barb geometries may be interchangeably attached to handle 110.
The cylindrical, conical, and/or frustoconical profiles of the various sections (e.g., shelf 150, trunk 160 and cap 170) of retention barb 130 advantageously retains eversion tips 120 on handle 110 while still allowing eversion tips 120 to rotate. As discussed in more detail below, rotation of eversion tips 120 advantageously reduces the occurrence and/or prevents eversion tip 120 from bending and deforming pins or posts of a ring coupler.
As illustrated in
The dimensions above may be adjusted to increase or decrease stiffness imparted to eversion tip 120. Additionally, the dimensions above may be adjusted to improve the engagement between barb 130 and eversion tip 120 to increase the required pulling force to remove eversion tip 120 or to provide additional friction so there is more resistance to eversion tip 120 rotation. Additionally, dimensions may be adjusted to lessen the engagement between barb 130 and eversion tip 120 such that the pulling force is decreased or to reduce friction and lessen the resistance to eversion tip 120 such that eversion tip 120 rotates more freely. In other examples, shelf width (WS) 152 may be approximately 0.220 inches (5.58 mm) or approximately 0.141 inches (3.58 mm).
Furthermore, eversion tips 120 may deform to assist with vessel eversion as the deformation causes the eversion tip 120 to compress slightly and “balloon” or “mushroom” out thereby pressing against the internal vessel wall and causing the vessel to further evert. The “ballooning” and/or “mushrooming” of eversion tip 120 is a function of eversion tip geometry, eversion tip material selection, retention barb geometry and retention barb material selection. For example, retention barb geometry and more specifically the distance for the tip of retention barb 130 to the distal end 210 of eversion tip 120 may affect the overall stiffness and/or flexibility of eversion tip 120 thereby affecting how much or how little “ballooning” and/or “mushrooming” takes place as the eversion tip 120 is pushed into a vessel and against a ring coupler.
In an example, eversion tip 120 may be made from NUSIL 4840 silicone. In another example, the eversion tip 120 may be transparent or translucent to provide additional visibility to the user, such as a medical practitioner, when using the everter device 100 to evert a vessel wall onto a coupler ring of an anastomosis clamp system.
Each eversion tip 120 may include a distal end 210 and an eversion surface 220. Additionally, at the proximal end or base 212, eversion tip 120 includes a barb cavity 230. Eversion tip 120 may come to a tip or point at distal end 210, which may have a blunt end (as illustrated in
The eversion surface 220 may include a piloting region 231 between reference planes “A” and “B”, a concave region 233 between reference planes “B” and “C”, a transition region 235 between reference planes “C” and “D”, and a nearly linear region 237 between reference planes “D” and “E”. The piloting region 231 may have a nearly linear slope as the radius of the eversion surface 220 increases from reference plane “A” to reference plane “B”. As the eversion surface 220 continues beyond the piloting region 231, the radius continues to increase exponentially creating a concave surface in the concave region 233 to reference plane “C”. As illustrated in
As illustrated in
The diameter of the eversion surface 220 then increases at a slower and slower rate and transitions from a concave to a convex surface at shoulder 222. In the illustrated example, the transition region 235 may be approximately 5 mm deep. For example, the transition region may start (e.g., reference plane “C”) at approximately 2.81 mm from the distal end 210 and may end (e.g., reference plane “D”) at approximately 7.81 mm from the distal end 210 (e.g., reference plane “A”). As the eversion surface approaches the proximal end 212 of the eversion tip 120 at reference plane “E”, the diameter is increasing in a linear fashion. In an example, the diameter at the proximal end 212 is 8.0 mm. Additionally, in the illustrated example, the angle (γ) 224 of the nearly linear region 237 may be 89 degrees.
The exponential like curve of the concave region 233 and the abrupt rate of change of the radius after the shoulder 222 advantageously provides a shelf-like surface to accept pins or posts 512 of a coupler ring 510 that pierce through eversion tip 120. For example, as illustrated in
In the examples illustrated in
As illustrated in
In an example, barb cavity 230 may have a cavity depth (DCAV) 238. As illustrated in
As illustrated in
In an example, eversion tip(s) 120 (e.g., eversion tip 120a and eversion tip 120b) may have different sizes and/or contours. For example, eversion tip 120a may have a different size, shape, and/or contour than eversion tip 120b, which advantageously increases the versatility of the everter device 100 by permitting its use with a greater size range of vessels and/or anastomosis couplers. However, distal ends 210 of each eversion tip 120 may have the same profile so that each end of the everter device 100 may be used to pilot arteries and veins typically involved in microvascular anastomosis (e.g., arteries or veins with a diameter ranging from 1 mm to 4 mm). For example, eversion tip 120 may include a narrow distal end 210 to pilot down the bore of vessels, which may have a tendency to collapse in on themselves. The distal end 210 may be sized such that regardless of the overall size of eversion tip 120, the distal end 210 is adapted to be inserted into the smallest vessels (e.g., 0.1 mm or 0.5 mm diameter openings). After piloting through the end of the vessel, the flared contoured shaped of eversion tip 120 may provide support for the vessel wall as the eversion tip 120 is advanced through the vessel towards a ring coupler.
Handle 310 may be formed of a rigid or semi-rigid material, such as thermoplastic, and may be shaped similar to that of handle 110 to provide a similar feel and allow the user to similarly manipulate and move both the everter device 100 and sizing device 300. In an example, handle 310 may be made from MAKROLON 2458 polycarbonate.
As illustrated in
Each sizing guide 320 may include one or more sizing aperture 330 (as Illustrated in
Sizing guides 320 may be formed as a single piece with handle 310. In an alternative example, sizing guides may be press-fit onto handle 310. For example, sizing guides 320 may be interchangeable for differing use cases depending on space restrictions and/or vessel diameters. Instead of two rows (e.g., pairs) of sizing apertures 330, a sizing guide 320 with a single row of sizing apertures 330 may be press-fit onto sizing device 300 to reduce the profile of sizing device 300 when sizing a vessel in a tight or hard to reach area during surgery. Additionally, a sizing guide 320 with larger or smaller variations in sizes may be used (e.g., with vessel diameter increments of 0.10, 0.25, 0.5, 1.0, etc.). In the above alternative example, handle 310 may include barbs, similar to barb(s) 130 of
Sizing guides 320 may be angled upwards from the bottom of handle 310 at an angle (λ) 332. The angled orientation of sizing guides 320 may be adapted to assist with positioning vessels through the apertures 330 of the sizing guide at both ends. For example, by providing sizing guides 320 an angle 332, a medical practitioner may route vessels through apertures 330 on each side of the sizing guide 320 so that each vessel can be positioned on a coupler ring. In an example, angle (λ) 332 is approximately 20 degrees. In another example, the angle (λ) 332 may be approximately 25 degrees to 45 degrees to provide a smoother transition for each vessel routed through an aperture 330 on the sizing guide 320. Additionally, the sizing device 300 may be shaped and arranged such that the sizing guides 320 mimic the shape and structure of a coupler ring and to provide lateral access to position vessels on respective coupler rings.
The eversion device 100 and sizing device 300 may be provided in a kit. The kit may be co-pouched, such that each of the eversion device 100 and sizing device 200 are placed in a first pouch, which is then placed in another outer pouch. Each pouch may be made from Poly-Tyvek. In an example, the Poly-Tyvek may be Tyvek® 1073B. Additionally, the kit may be double sterilized using Ethylene Oxide (ETO) sterilization, which advantageously prevents cross-linking within the eversion tip 120.
As illustrated in
Prior to selecting and positioning coupler ring 510 on vessel segment 520, sizing device 300 may be used to determine the size of each vessel segment 520 that is to be surgically coapted together. For example, the vessel segment 520 may be positioned through various sizing apertures 330 of sizing guide 320 until the vessel diameter is determined. If the vessel side walls are pinched, crimped, creased, or pleated when placed in a sizing aperture 330, then the vessel is larger than the selected sizing aperture 330 and can be positioned through the next largest aperture until no more pinching, crimping, creasing and/or pleating is visible. Once the diameter of the vessel segment 520 is determined, an appropriate coupler ring 510 may be selected and positioned about vessel segment 520 as illustrated in
After the coupler ring 510 has been positioned on the vessel segment 520 near the free end 522 of vessel segment 520, as illustrated in
In an effort to simultaneously impale all of the pins or posts 512 of the coupler ring 510 through the free end 522 of the vessel segment 522, the eversion tip 120 is advanced into vessel segment 522 until the eversion surface 220 of eversion tip 120 contacts the free end 522 of vessel segment 520. The eversion device 100 is further advanced toward the coupler ring 510 to cause the vessel segment 520 to evert thereby causing pins or posts 512 of the coupler ring 510 to pierce through the vessel wall tissue of the free end 522 of the vessel segment 520. In an example, the user (e.g., medical practitioner) applies sufficient force to the everter device 100 in the direction of the coupler ring 510 to cause the pins or posts 512 of the coupler ring 510 to pierce through the vessel wall tissue. As discussed above, upon piercing through the vessel wall tissue, the pins or posts 512 may also pierce through eversion tip 120, as illustrated in
When advancing the eversion tip 120 through the vessel and applying force to the everter tool 100, the eversion tip 120 advantageously rotates freely about retention barb 130 to prevent the everter tool 100 from damaging pins or posts 510 of coupler ring 510. For example, if the eversion tip 120 did not rotate, rotation of everter tool 100 by the medical practitioner may cause a pin or post 510 to bend or break and therefore would be unable to be joined with a mating coupler ring.
Specifically, when the everter device 100 is sufficiently advanced toward the free end 522 of vessel segment 520 so as to contact the vessel tissue, the eversion tip 120 is further advanced toward the coupler ring 510, with the contoured eversion surface 220 everting the free end 522 of vessel segment 520, as illustrated in
Typically, arteries are more muscular or more difficult to deform and evert as compared to veins and the above described everter device 100 and anastomotic coupling method are particularly suited for arterial connections. For example, as discussed above, the everter device advantageously maintains the shape of the arterial wall and “balloons” or “mushrooms” to further assist with arterial eversion.
As discussed above, each of the pins (e.g., all six pins) may preferably and simultaneously (or nearly simultaneously) pierce through the vessel wall and into the outer wall of the eversion tip 120. In an example, the eversion tip 120 may deform as it comes into contact with the coupler ring 510, thereby further sliding the vessel down the pins or posts 512.
As illustrated in
The above procedure is repeated on another vessel segment (not shown) to be coapted to the first vessel segment 520, so as to secure a free end of that other vessel segment to a mating coupler ring (also not shown). After both vessel segments are attached to coupler rings (e.g., coupler ring 510), the coupler rings may be joined to complete the end-to-end microanastomosis.
As explained above, the everter device 100 may be disposable. Additionally, everter device 100 may be designed for one procedural use (e.g., used to evert one or more arteries or veins during a surgical procedure). For example, everter device 100 may be used several times during a procedure before being disposed of.
Retention Barb Yield Strength Test: During use, the everter device 100 may experience rocking around its center axis (e.g., axis 105 along the length of handle 110 and through center of each retention barb 130). The “worst case scenario” was tested by applying a compressive load perpendicular (e.g., 90 degrees) to the center axis 105 of retention barb 130. In the study, retention barb 130 was analyzed without eversion tip 120 in place in order to isolate and compare retention barb mechanical strengths between various retention barb designs. Three retention barb designs, as illustrated in
Each of the designs in
Retention Barb Rocking Test: When the eversion tip 120 is pulled upwards, a tensile force is created on the retention barb 130. Additionally, the device may be misused by the user while rocking the eversion tip 120 around the center axis in order to secure the vessel on the coupler ring 510. Therefore, testing was performed for a “worst case scenario” of a 45 degree or 90 degree load being applied to the retention barb 130. Furthermore, two materials were tested (ABS and PC).
Each design illustrated in
Retention Barb Geometry/Strength Test 1: The purpose of this study is to evaluate various retention barb features for which one or ones have the greatest tensile strength. For this testing, eight retention barb geometries were evaluated as illustrated in
Each handle 110 was placed in vice grips and the silicone eversion tip 120 was grasped with Mark-10 wedge grips at a location at or above the location of the distal end of the internal retention barb 130. Then, each eversion tip 120 was then pulled upwards away from the handle 110 at a rate of 150 mm/min.
Both of the “F” design (e.g., notched tree) samples that were tested tore instead of cleanly separating. Additionally, the retention barb 130 broke during separation on one design “A” and one design “D” sample. All other samples had a clean retention barb/silicone separation. The average peak force for silicon tip separation for each retention barb design is shown in
Retention Barb Geometry/Strength Test 2: The purpose of this study was to compare the retention strength of the reinforced retention barb 130 to the original retention barb 130. Updated retention barb geometries were evaluated as illustrated in
The same testing parameters as Retention Barb Geometry/Strength Test 1 were used and resulted in the average peak force for silicon tip separation or average retention strength shown in
Eversion Tip Geometry Test: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the functionality of fourteen different silicone eversion tip geometries, as illustrated in
The material of the silicone eversion tip 120 in Solidworks was modeled to mirror the material properties from the data sheet, MED-4840. The fourteen different silicone eversion tip geometries (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L, M, and N) were tested using silicone material properties each under an axial compressive force of 0.5lbf., 1.0lbf., 1.5lbf., 2.0lbf.
A split line was created right below the maximum diameter of the silicone eversion tip to provide a reference plane when applying compressive loads during the FEA analysis. Due to the characteristics of eversion tip 120, all of the direct force from the coupler and artery/vessel will be translated onto the eversion tip 120 between the most distal end 210 and the split line.
For the Silicone eversion tip 120 of this study, the values used from the data sheet are tensile strength (1180 psi) and mass density (0.0405 lb/in3). The remaining material properties were obtained from the article “Overview of materials for Silicone Rubber.” The elastic modulus (3454 psi), Poisson's Ratio (0.47), shear modulus (3315.99 psi), compressive strength (10.7 psi) and yield strength (263 psi) were all added based off of the article, “Overview of materials for Silicone Rubber.” In the article a range of values were given and the chosen value was determined by using a proportion. Based on the tensile strength from the data sheet being 1180 psi and the maximum tensile strength being 94300 psi in the article the remaining values were found based on that proportion. Ex. 1180/94300=(elastic modulus)/276000, so the elastic modulus was set at 3454 psi.
Overall, based on the FEA test results and other contributing factors such as vessel eversion and manufacturability it was determined that the “Large Everter Tip Final (M)” and the “Small Everter Tip Final (N)” were the most effective and realistic eversion tips geometries in this study. Tip geometries “A” through “D” were the first revision, but these eversion tips 120 lacked the ability to evert larger vessels (3 mm+). The eversion tip 120 design was then updated to tip geometries “E” through “H”, which were able to evert some larger vessels because of the broader 8 mm shoulder, but because of the blunt distal tip geometries “E” through “H” were sometimes unable to pilot the vessels. The bulb-shaped cross section (e.g., designs “A”, “B”, “E” and “F”) captured more pins 512 than the crayon-shaped cross section (e.g., designs “C”, “D”, “G” and “H”) from previous evaluations. The designs were then consolidated to make eversion tip 120 geometries “I” and “J”. These designs have different shoulder widths, which are optimized to evert vessels small and large, an identical distal tip curvature so either side is able to pilot the smallest of vessels, and an optimized distance from the end of the barb to the end of the tip for best control and safest eversion of vessels. Though revisions “I” and “J” were able to evert and pilot the vessel, further revisions were made to “I” and “J” for manufacturability purposes, which resulted in eversion tip geometries “M” and “N”. Eversion tip geometries “M” and “N” are able to be manufactured along with being able to evert and pilot the vessel. Furthermore, both eversion tip geometries, “M” and “N”, showed an acceptable amount of distal tip displacement, which can be seen in
Eversion Tip Eversion Test: The eversion tip eversion test evaluated the performance of various eversion tip geometries, as illustrated in
Each of the design geometries was formed from Silicone from a 9:1 mixture of Shore A Polytek TinSil 80-40 Silicon Rubber Part A and Polytek TinSil 80-Series Silicon Rubber Part B. The testing was performed on porcine internal cranial mammary arteries cut into 2.5 cm segments, sorted by outer diameter into three groups: 2.0 mm, 2.5 mm and 3.0 mm. Additionally, the procine arteries were coated with saline to maintain moisture.
A portion of each vessel, approximately 1.75 times the length of the pins or posts 512, was drawn through the back side of each coupler ring 510. Then, eversion tip 120 was axially inserted into the opening of the vessel 520 until resistance was felt. Then, the eversion tip 120 was angled 45 degrees from the central axis of the artery and a complete 360 degree rotation about the artery and coupler ring 510 was completed. The eversion tip 120 was then straightened along the vessel's axis and them removed. The number of fully captured pins or posts, partially captured pins or posts, and non-captured pins or posts were then counted.
Additionally, the Shore A Durometer hardness of each tip design was measured by holding a durometer gauge normal to the surface of the silicone eversion tip, just before the tip began to taper as indicated by the “durometer measurement” arrow in
The testing showed that all tip geometries performed well. Across all sample types, 27 out of the 36 samples (75%) fully captured all six coupler pins 512. There was only once incidence in which fewer than three pins were fully captured. In this incidence, the coupler popped out of the coupler applicator and two pins were still fully captured. There was no significant difference in functionality across the various designs. It was noted by the engineer performing the testing that he felt more “control” using the shorter tip designs (“B” and “D”).
The many features and advantages of the present disclosure are apparent from the written description, and thus, the appended claims are intended to cover all such features and advantages of the disclosure. Further, since numerous modifications and changes will readily occur to those skilled in the art, the present disclosure is not limited to the exact construction and operation as illustrated and described. Therefore, the described embodiments should be taken as illustrative and not restrictive, and the disclosure should not be limited to the details given herein but should be defined by the following claims and their full scope of equivalents, whether foreseeable or unforeseeable now or in the future.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2019/014767 | 1/23/2019 | WO | 00 |