Fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheets with surface coverings

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • RE44893
  • Patent Number
    RE44,893
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, March 22, 2012
    12 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 13, 2014
    10 years ago
  • US Classifications
    Field of Search
    • US
    • 156 062400
    • 156 062800
    • 264 138000
    • 264 255000
    • 264 299000
    • 264 308000
    • 428 292100
    • 428 319000
    • 428 411100
  • International Classifications
    • B32B27/36
    • B32B27/38
Abstract
A composite sheet material in one embodiment includes a porous core layer. The porous core layer includes a thermoplastic polymer, about 20 weight percent to about 80 weight percent of reinforcing fibers based on a total weight of the porous core layer, and an effective amount of a flame retardant agent.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

This invention relates generally to porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic polymer composite sheets, and more particularly to porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic polymer composite sheets having flame retardants, smoke suppressants, and/or synergistic compounds along with surface coverings providing for at least one of reduced flame spread, reduced smoke density, reduced heat release, and reduced gas emissions.


Porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic composite sheets have been described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,978,489 and 4,670,331 and are used in numerous and varied applications in the product manufacturing industry because of the ease molding the fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheets into articles. For example, known techniques such as thermo-stamping, compression molding, and thermoforming have been used to successfully form articles from fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheets.


Because of the varied applications, fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheets are subjected to various performance tests. For example flame spread, smoke density, and gaseous emissions characteristics of the fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheets are important when the formed articles are used in environments that might be subjected to a flame event, such as a fire. Because of safety concerns, there is a need to improve the flame, smoke and toxicity performance of fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet products.


BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

In one aspect, a composite sheet material is provided that includes a porous core layer. The porous core layer includes a thermoplastic polymer, about 20 weight percent to about 80 weight percent of reinforcing fibers based on a total weight of the porous core layer, and an effective amount of a flame retardant agent.


In another aspect, a method of manufacturing a porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet is provided. The method includes providing a porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet having at least one porous core layer including a thermoplastic material, from about 20 weight percent to about 80 weight percent of reinforcing fibers, and an effective amount of a flame retardant agent. The method also includes laminating at least one skin to a surface of the porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet. Each skin includes at least one of a thermoplastic film, an elastomeric film, a metal foil, a thermosetting coating, an inorganic coating, a fiber based scrim, a non-woven fabric, and a woven fabric, the skin having a limiting oxygen index greater than about 22, as measured per ISO 4589, to enhance at least one of the flame, smoke, heat release and gaseous emissions characteristics of the porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS


FIG. 1 is cross sectional illustration of an exemplary fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention.



FIG. 2 is cross sectional illustration of an exemplary fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet in accordance with another embodiment of the present invention.



FIG. 3 is cross sectional illustration of an exemplary fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet in accordance with another embodiment of the present invention.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

Multi-layered porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic composite sheets having characteristics of reduced flame spread, reduced smoke density, reduced heat release, and reduced gas emissions are described below in detail. In an exemplary embodiment, the multi-layered porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheets include one or more porous core layers that are formed from one or more thermoplastic materials, about 20 weight percent to about 80 weight percent of fibers dispersed in the thermoplastic material, and an effective amount of a halogen fire retardant agent. At least one surface of the core layer is covered by a skin laminated to the core layer under heat and/or pressure with or without the use of an adhesive or a tie layer. The skin materials are chosen, at least in part, to impart the desired reduction in flame spread, heat release, smoke density, and gaseous emissions of the composite sheet when exposed to a fire event. Also, handling, moldability and end use performance can be improved by laminating two or more porous core layers together having different thermoplastic materials and/or different fibers. Further, skins can be laminated between core layers to affect performance characteristics. Additionally, moldability and formability can be improved by laminating at least one skin to a surface of the core layer where the skin is at least one of a fiber-based scrim, a non-woven fabric and a woven fabric.


Referring to the drawings, FIG. 1 is a cross sectional illustration of an exemplary fiber reinforced thermoplastic composite sheet 10 that includes one porous core layer 12 and skins 14 and 16 laminated to outer surfaces 18 and 20 of core layer 12. In one embodiment, composite sheet 10 has a thickness of about 0.5 millimeters (mm) to about 50 mm and in another embodiment, a thickness of about 0.5 mm to about 25 mm. Also, skins 14 and 16 each have a thickness in one embodiment of about 25 micrometers to about 5 mm, and in another embodiment from about 25 micrometers to about 2.5 mm.


Core layer 12 is formed from a web made up of open cell structures formed by random crossing over of reinforcing fibers held together, at least in part, by one or more thermoplastic resins, where the void content of porous core layer 12 ranges in general between about 5% and about 95% and in particular between about 30% and about 80% of the total volume of core layer 12. In an another embodiment, porous core layer 12 is made up of open cell structures formed by random crossing over of reinforcing fibers held together, at least in part, by one or more thermoplastic resins, where about 40% to about 100% of the cell structure are open and allow the flow of air and gases through. Core layer 12 has a density in one embodiment of about 0.2 gm/cc to about 1.8 gm/cc and in another embodiment about 0.3 gm/cc to about 1.0 gm/cc. Core layer 12 is formed using known manufacturing process, for example, a wet laid process, an air laid process, a dry blend process, a carding and needle process, and other known process that are employed for making non-woven products. Combinations of such manufacturing processes are also useful. Core layer 12 includes about 20% to about 80% by weight fibers having a high tensile modulus of elasticity and an average length of between about 7 and about 200 mm, and about 20% to about 80% by weight of a wholly or substantially unconsolidated fibrous or particulate thermoplastic materials, where the weight percentages are based on the total weight of core layer 12 In another embodiment, core layer includes about 35% to about 55% by weight fibers. The web is heated above the glass transition temperature of the thermoplastic resins on core layer 12 to substantially soften the plastic materials and is passed through one or more consolidation devices, for example nip rollers, calendaring rolls, double belt laminators, indexing presses, multiple daylight presses, autoclaves, and other such devices used for lamination and consolidation of sheets and fabrics so that the plastic material can flow and wet out the fibers. The gap between the consolidating elements in the consolidation devices are set to a dimension less than that of the unconsolidated web and greater than that of the web if it were to be fully consolidated, thus allowing the web to expand and remain substantially permeable after passing through the rollers. In one embodiment, the gap is set to a dimension about 5% to about 10% greater than that of the web if it were to be fully consolidated. A fully consolidated web means a web that is fully compressed and substantially void free. A fully consolidated web would have less than 5% void content and have negligible open cell structure.


A high tensile modulus of elasticity means a tensile modulus of elasticity substantially higher than that of a consolidated sheet which could be formed from the web structure. Fibers falling into this category include metal, metalized inorganic, metalized synthetic, glass, graphite, carbon and ceramic fibers and fibers such as the aramid fibers sold under the trade names Kevlar and Nomex, and generally includes any fiber having a tensile modulus higher than about 10,000 Mega Pascals at room temperature and pressure.


Particulate plastic materials include short plastics fibers which can be included to enhance the cohesion of the web structure during manufacture. Bonding is effected by utilizing the thermal characteristics of the plastic materials within the web structure. The web structure is heated sufficiently to cause the thermoplastic component to fuse at its surfaces to adjacent particles and fibers.


In one embodiment, individual reinforcing fibers should not on he average be shorter than about 7 millimeters, because shorter fibers do not generally provide adequate reinforcement in the ultimate molded article. Also, fibers should not on average be longer than about 200 millimeters since such fibers are difficult to handle in the manufacturing process.


In one embodiment, glass fibers are used, and in order to confer structural strength the fibers have an average diameter between about 7 and about 22 microns. Fibers of diameter less than about 7 microns can easily become airborne and can cause environmental health and safety issues. Fibers of diameter greater than about 22 microns are difficult to handle in manufacturing processes and do not efficiently reinforce the plastics matrix after molding.


In one embodiment, the thermoplastics material is, at least in part, in a particulate form. Suitable thermoplastics include, but are not limited to, polyethylene, polypropylene, polystyrene, acrylonitrylstyrene, butadiene, polyethyleneterephthalate, polybutyleneterephthalate, polybutyleneterachlorate, and polyvinyl chloride, both plasticised and unplasticised, and blends of these materials with each other or other polymeric materials. Other suitable thermoplastics include, but are not limited to, polyarylene ethers, polycarbonates, polyestercarbonates, thermoplastic polyesters, polyetherimides, acrylonitrile-butylacrylate-styrene polymers, amorphous nylon, polyarylene ether ketone, polyphenylene sulfide, polyaryl sulfone, polyether sulfone, liquid crystalline polymers, poly(1,4 phenylene) compounds commercially known as PARMAX®, high heat polycarbonate such as Bayer's APEC® PC, high temperature nylon, and silicones, as well as alloys and blends of these materials with each other or other polymeric materials. Preferably, the thermoplastic material has a limited oxygen index (LOI) greater than about 22, as measured in accordance with ISO 4589-2, second edition, Mar. 15, 1996, test method. It is anticipated that any thermoplastics resin can be used which is not chemically attacked by water and which can be sufficiently softened by heat to permit fusing and/or molding without being chemically or thermally decomposed.


In one embodiment, the plastic particles need not be excessively fine, but particles coarser than about 1.5 millimeters are unsatisfactory in that they do not flow sufficiently during the molding process to produce a homogenous structure. The use of larger particles can result in a reduction in the flexural modulus of the material when consolidated. In one embodiment, the plastics particles are not more than about 1 millimeter in size.


Core layer 12 further includes an effective amount of at least one flame retardant agent containing at least one of N, P, As, Sb, Bi, S, Se, Te, Po, F, Cl, Br, I, and At. In one exemplary embodiment, the flame retardant agent is a halogen flame retardant agent. In another embodiment, the flame retardant agent is a halogenated thermoplastic polymer, for example, tetra-bromo bisphenol-A. The amount of the flame retardant in core layer 12 can range in one embodiment from about 2 weight percent to about 13 weight percent, in another embodiment from about 2 weight percent to about 5 weight percent, and in another embodiment, from about 5 weight percent to about 13 weight percent.


Core layer 12 can also include one or more smoke suppressant compositions in the amount of about 0.2 weight percent to about 10 weight percent. Suitable smoke suppressant compositions include, but are not limited to, stannates, zinc borates, zinc molybdate, magnesium silicates, calcium zinc molybdate, calcium silicates, calcium hydroxides, and mixtures thereof.


Core layer 12 can also include a synergist material to increase the efficacy of the halogen flame retardants. Suitable synergist materials include, but are not limited to, sodium trichlorobenzene sulfonate potassium, diphenyl sulfone-3-sulfonate, and mixtures thereof.


Referring to FIG. 1, skins 14 and 16 are formed from materials that can withstand processing temperatures of between about 200° C. and about 425° C. Skins 14 and 16 can be thermoplastic films, elastomeric films, metal foils, thermosetting coating, inorganic coatings, fiber reinforced scrims, and woven or non-woven fabric materials. Any suitable thermoplastic material, including blends of thermoplastic materials, having a LOI greater than about 22, as measured in accordance with ISO 4589-2, second edition, Mar. 15, 1996, test method, can be used for forming the thermoplastic films, for example, poly(ether imide), poly(ether ketone), poly(ether-ether ketone), poly(phenylene sulfide), poly(ether sulfone), poly(amide-imide), poly(aryl sulfone) and combinations thereof. Suitable fibers for forming the scrims include, but are not limited to, glass fibers, aramid fibers, carbon fibers, inorganic fibers, metal fibers, metalized synthetic fibers, metalized inorganic fibers, and combinations thereof. Preferably, the fibers used in forming the scrims have a LOI greater than about 22, as measured in accordance with ISO 4589-2, second edition, Mar. 15, 1996, test method.


In one embodiment, the inorganic coating includes a layer of at least one of gypsum paste, a calcium carbonate paste, a mortar and a concrete. The fiber-based scrim includes a light-weight non-woven covering material manufactured via wet laid, air laid, spunbond, and spunlace processes. The fiber based scrim includes, for example, glass, carbon, polyacrylonitrile, aramid, poly(p-phenylene-benzobisoxazole), poly (ether-imide), poly(phenylene sulfide), etc. The non-woven fabric includes a thermoplastic material, a thermal setting binder, inorganic fibers, metal fibers, metallized inorganic fibers and metallized synthetic fibers.


Skins 14 and 16 are laminated to core layer 12 by any suitable lamination process using heat and/or pressure with or without the use of an adhesive or a tie layer, for example using nip rollers or a lamination machine. Skins 14 and 16 are laminated to core 12 after it has been formed, and in one embodiment, skins 14 and 16 are laminated to core layer 12 before it has been cut into sheets of predetermined size. In another embodiment, skins 14 and 16 are laminated to core layer 12 after it has been cut into sheets. In one embodiment, the temperature of the lamination process is greater than the glass transition temperature of the thermoplastic resins of the skins and core layer, for example, greater than about 100° C. In another embodiment, skins 14 and 16 are bonded to core layer 12 at room temperature using thermal setting adhesives and pressure.



FIG. 2 is a cross sectional illustration of another exemplary fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet 30 that includes core layers 32 and 34, and skins 36, 38 and 40 laminated to core layers 32 and 34. Particularly, core layer 32 includes a first surface 42 and a second surface 44, and core layer 34 includes a first surface 46 and a second surface 48. Core layers 32 and 34 are arranged so that second surface 44 of core layer 32 is adjacent to first surface 46 of core layer 34. Skin 36 is positioned over first surface 42 of core layer 32, skin 38 is positioned over second surface 48 of core layer 34, and skin 40 is positioned between second surface 44 of core layer 32 and first surface 46 of core layer 34. Core layers 32 and 34, and skins 36, 38, and 40 are laminated together to form fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet 30.


Core layers 32 and 34, similar to core layer 12 described above, includes about 20% to about 80% by weight fibers having a high tensile modulus of elasticity and about 20% to about 80% by weight of thermoplastics material. The thermoplastic material and/or the fibers of core layer 32 can be the same or different from the thermoplastic material and/or the fibers of core layer 34 depending on the desired properties of sheet 30.


Skins 36, 38, and 40, similar to skins 14 and 16 described above, are formed from materials that can withstand processing temperatures of between about 200° C. and about 425° C. Skins 36, 38, and 40 can be thermoplastic films, fiber reinforced scrims, and woven or non-woven fabric materials. Skins 36, 38, and 40 can be formed from the same materials or can be formed from different materials depending on the desired properties of sheet 30.


In an alternate embodiment, sheet 30 does not include skin 40 laminated between core layers 32 and 34. In further alternate embodiments, only one of the outer surfaces of sheet 30 includes a skin and/or a skin laminated between core layers 32 and 34. In a further alternate embodiment, sheet 30 includes a skin or a skin 40 laminated between core layers 32 and 34 that covers at least a part of second surface 44 of core layer 32 and first surface 46 of core layer 34. FIG. 3 is a cross sectional illustration of another exemplary fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet 60 that includes porous core layers 62, 64, and 66, and skins 68, 70, 72, and 74 laminated to core layers 62, 64, and 66. Particularly, core layer 62 includes a first surface 76 and a second surface 78, core layer 64 includes a first surface 80 and a second surface 82, and core layer 66 includes a first surface 84 and a second surface 86. Core layers 62, 64, and 66 are arranged so that second surface 78 of core layer 62 is adjacent to first surface 80 of core layer 64, and second surface 82 of core layer 64 is adjacent to first surface 84 of core layer 66. Skin 68 is positioned over first surface 76 of core layer 62, skin 70 is positioned over second surface 86 of core layer 66, skin 72 is positioned between second surface 78 of core layer 62 and first surface 80 of core layer 64, and skin 74 is positioned between second surface 82 of core layer 64 and first surface 84 of core layer 66. Core layers 62, 64, and 66, and skins 68, 70, 72, and 74 are laminated together to form fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet 60.


Core layers 62, 64, and 66, similar to core layer 12 described above, includes about 20% to about 80% by weight fibers having a high modulus of elasticity and about 20% to about 80% by weight of one or more thermoplastic materials. The thermoplastic material and/or the fibers of each core layer 62, 64, and 66 can be the same or different from the thermoplastic material and/or the fibers of each other core layer depending on the desired properties of sheet 60.


Skins 68, 70, 72, and 74, similar to skins 14 and 16 described above, are formed from materials that can withstand processing temperatures of between about 200° C. and about 425° C. Skins 68, 70, 72, and 74 can be thermoplastic films, fiber reinforced scrims, and woven or non-woven fabric materials. Skins 68, 70, 72, and 74 can be formed from the same materials or can be formed from different materials depending on the desired properties of sheet 60. In an alternate embodiments, sheet 60 includes one or more of skins 68, 70, 72, and 74 but not all four skins. In another embodiment, sheet 60 includes one or more of skins 68, 70, 72, and 74 covering at least a part of the surfaces of core layers 62, 64, and 66.


The porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic composite sheets described above can be used in, but not limited to, building infrastructure, aircraft, train and naval vessel side wall panels, ceiling panels, cargo liners, office partitions, elevator shaft lining, ceiling tiles, recessed housing for light fixtures and other such applications that are currently made with honeycomb sandwich structures, thermoplastic sheets, and FRP. The composite sheets can be molded into various articles using methods known in the art including, for example, pressure forming, thermal forming, thermal stamping, vacuum forming, compression forming, and autoclaving. The combination of high stiffness to weight ratio, ability to be thermoformed with deep draw sections, end of life recyclability, acoustics and desirable low flame spread index, heat release, smoke density and gas emission properties make the porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic composite a more desirable product than the products currently being used.


The invention will be further described by reference to the following examples which are presented for the purpose of illustration only and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. Unless otherwise indicated, all amounts are listed as parts by weight.


Comparative example tests comparing the flame, smoke and gaseous emissions of a control sample designated Sample A and exemplary samples of an embodiment of the invention designated Samples B and C. Sample A is a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from a blend of poly(ether-imide), commercially available from General Electric Company under the ULTEM trademark, and bisphenol A polycarbonate resin containing a bromine based fire retardant additive, commercially available from General Electric Company under the LEXAN trademark, the resins blended in weight ratios of 5 percent and 55 percent. The blended resins were dispersed in a porous fiber-reinforced sheet containing about 40 weight percent glass fibers having a nominal fiber diameter of 16 microns and an average length of 12.7 mm. Sample B is the porous fiber-reinforced sheet of Sample A laminated with 76 micron thick poly(ether-imide) films, commercially available from General Electric Company under the ULTEM trademark, in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention. Sample C is the porous fiber-reinforced sheet of Sample A laminated with 27 g/m2 aramid scrims, commercially available from E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company under the KEVLAR trademark laminated onto the exterior surfaces in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention. Sample D is the porous fiber-reinforced sheet of Sample A laminated with 8 mil thick polypropylene films. Sample D is a comparative sample that contains laminated polypropylene films that have an LOI of 17. The results are presented below in Tables I to II.


Comparative example tests comparing the flame and smoke characteristics of Sample E, a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from a blend of poly(ether-imide) and polycarbonate resins in weight ratio of 25 percent each with 50 weight percent glass fibers of 16 micron in diameter and 12.7 mm in length, Sample F, a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from a blend of poly(ether-imide) and an eco-friendly flame retardant based polycarbonate resin in a weight ratios of 5 and 55 percent combined with 40 weight percent glass fibers of 16 microns diameter and 12.7 mm length, Sample G, a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from a polycarbonate resin with 50 weight percent glass fibers of 16 micron diameter and 12.7 mm length, Sample H, a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from polypropylene with 55 weight percent glass fibers of 16 micron diameter and 12.7 mm length, Sample I, a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from a polyarylene ether resin with 50 weight percent glass fibers, and Sample J, a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from blend of polycarbonate and polybutylene terephthalate combined in a weight ratio of 33 percent and 17 percent each with 50 weight percent glass fibers of 16 micron diameter and 12.7 mm length are presented below in Table IV.


The fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheets for Samples A-J were made using the wet-laid paper making process described in United Kingdom Patent Nos. 1129757 and 1329409. The fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet was further subjected to heat and pressure in a double belt laminator at 325° C. and 2 bar to partially consolidate the sheet and have the resin wet the fibers. Sample B was prepared from the same fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet as Sample A, but with a 75 micrometer thick poly(ether-imide) film covering the surfaces using the double belt laminator under the conditions described above. Sample C was prepared from the same fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet as Sample A, but with a 27 g/m2 aramid scrim covering the surfaces using the double belt laminator under the conditions described above. Sample D was prepared from the same fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet as Sample A, but with a 8 mil thick polypropylene film covering the surfaces using the double belt laminator under the conditions described above.


The flame characteristics were measured using a radiant heat source and an inclined specimen of the sample material in accordance with ASTM method E-162-02A titled Standard Method for Surface Flammability of Materials Using a Radiant Heat Energy Source. A flame spread index was derived from the rate of progress of the flame front and the rate of heat liberation by the material under test. Key criteria are a flame spread index (FSI) and dripping/burning dripping observations. United States and Canadian requirements for passenger bus applications for interior materials are a FSI of 35 or less with no flaming drips. The Underwriters Laboratory (UL) requires that parts greater than 10 square feet should have an FSI of 200 or less to obtain a listing from UL.


The smoke characteristics were measured by exposing test specimens to flaming and non flaming conditions within a closed chamber according to ASTM method E-662-03 titled Standard Test Method for Specific Optical Density of Smoke Generated by Solid Materials. Light transmissions measurements were made and used to calculate specific optical density of the smoke generated during the test time period. Key criteria are an optical density (Ds) of smoke produced by a sample exposed to a radiant furnace or a radiant furnace plus multiple flames. The optical density is plotted versus time for generally 20 minutes. Maximum optical density and time to reach this maximum are important outputs. United States and Canadian Rail regulations and some United States and Canadian Bus guidelines set a maximum Ds of 100 or less at 1.5 minutes, and a maximum Ds of 200 or less at 4 minutes. Global Air regulations sets the Ds at 4 minutes for many large interior applications at 200 or less.


FAA requirements for toxicity and flame were also measured in accordance FAA tests BSS-7239, developed by Boeing Corporation, and FAR 25.853 (a) Appendix F, Part IV (OSU 65/65) Calorimeter.


A large part in an aircraft passenger cabin interior typically will need to meet the ASTM E162 and ASTM E662 described above as well a maximum Ds of 200 at 4 minutes. A difficult test for plastics has traditionally been the OSU 65/65 heat release test. In this test, the test material is exposed to defined radiant heat source, and calorimeter measurements are recorded. Key criteria are an average maximum heat release during the 5 minute test that should not exceed 65 kW/m2, and an average total heat released during the first 2 minutes of the test that should not exceed 65 kW-min/m2.


In the 60 second vertical burn test, the part is exposed to a small-scale open flame for 60 seconds and the key criteria are a burned length of 150 mm or less, an after flame time of 15 seconds or less, and flame time drippings of 3 seconds or less.













TABLE I





Test Method
Sample A
Sample B
Sample C
Sample D



















ASTM E-162:






Average Flame Spread
10
5.5
6.0
>200


Index Fs






Flaming Drips
None
None
None
Yes


ASTM E-662:






Smoke Density Ds at 1.5
9
2
6
6


minutes






Smoke Density Ds at 4.0
65
25
133
133


minutes






Maximum Smoke Density
315
182
289
289


DsMax






FAR 25.853 (a)



N/A


Appendix F,






Part IV:






2 minutes Total Heat
54 kW/m2
45 kW/m2
48 kW/m2



Release






Maximum Heat Release
54 KW/m2
41 KW/m2
48 KW/m2



60 Second Vertical Burn:






Vertical Burn Time
Pass
Pass
Pass



Burn Length
91.4 mm
61.0 mm
53.3 mm




















TABLE II







BSS-7239:
Sample A
Sample B



Gases
(ppm at 4 minutes)
(ppm at 4 minutes)




















HCN
1
1



CO
200
100



NO + NO3
2
2



SO2
<1
<1



HF
<1
<1



HCL
2
1























TABLE III






Sample
Sample
Sample
Sample
Sample
Sample


Test Method
E
F
G
H
I
J





















ASTM E-162:








Fs
27.5
50
45
245
39
69


Flaming Drips
None
None
None
F.D.*
None
None


ASTM E-662:

N/A






Ds at 1.5 minutes
13

18
21
28
16


Ds at 4.0 minutes
114

100
146
53
79


Max. DsMax
299

388
495
59
294





*F.D. = flaming drips.






The above test results show that the fiber reinforced thermoplastic sheet with poly(ether imide) skins of Sample B and with aramid scrims of Sample C exhibit a reduced flame spread index Fs, a reduced smoke density Ds, reduced heat release, and reduced gaseous emissions over Sample A. As shown in Table 1, Samples B and C exhibit test results that are superior to the test results of Sample A. For example, Samples B and C exhibited a lower flame spread index Fs, 5.5 and 6.0 respectively, than Sample A, which had a Fs of 10. Particularly, Samples B and C exhibited lower test results for the tests run according to ASTM E-162, ASTM E-662, FAR 25.853 (a), and the 60 second vertical burn test. The only anomaly being the 4 minute smoke density D, result of Sample C. Comparative Example D, which included a thermoplastic film having an LOI of only 17, exhibited a flame spread index Fs of greater than 200 and exhibited flaming drips. Further, each of samples E-J exhibit at least one of a flame spread index Fs and a four minute smoke density Ds that are significantly higher than the flame spread index Fs and the four minute smoke density Ds of Samples B and C.


Further comparative example tests comparing the flame, smoke and gaseous emissions of a control sample designated Sample K and exemplary samples of an embodiment of the invention designated Samples L and M. Sample L is similar to Sample A described above. Sample K is similar to Sample G described above and is a porous fiber-reinforced sheet formed from a blend of poly(ether-imide), commercially available from General Electric Company under the ULTEM trademark, and bisphenol A polycarbonate resin free of fire retardant additives, commercially available from General Electric Company under the LEXAN trademark.


Further comparative example tests comparing the flame, smoke and gaseous emissions of a control sample designated Sample K and exemplary samples of an embodiment of the invention designated Samples L and M were made using nominal 16 micron, 12.7 mm long wet chopped glass fibers and a blended mixture of powdered polyetherimide resin, a relatively high flow Bisphenol-A Polycarbonate (BPA-PC) resin with a nominal MFI≧25 g/10 min @300° C./12.kgf, and a random copolymer polycarbonate resin containing Bisphenol-A and Tetra-bromo Bisphenol A (TBBPA) units in the polymer backbone with a nominal 26% Bromine content and MFI≧7 g/10 min @300° C./12.kgf. The powder blending of the polycarbonate resins at different blend ratios allowed for tuning the total bromine content of the resins used in the core web. The core web had an area weight of around 2000±100 grams/m2 and a w/w glass content of around 45%±5%. Sample K was made without the bromine containing resin. The fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheets for Samples K-M were made using the wet-laid paper making process described in United Kingdom Patent Nos. 1129757 and 1329409. The fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheets were further subjected to heat and pressure in a double belt laminator at 325° C. and 2 bar to partially consolidate the sheet and have the resin wet the fibers.












TABLE IV





Test Method
Sample K
Sample L
Sample M


















Bromine Content in weight %
0
8.1
9.0


ASTM E-162:





Average Flame Spread Index Fs
45
10
6


Flaming Drips
None
None
None


ASTM E-662:





Smoke Density Ds at 1.5 minutes
18
9
4


Smoke Density Ds at 4.0 minutes
100
165
114


Maximum Smoke Density DsMax
388
315
272









The test results of Samples K-M show that the addition of bromine in Samples L and M reduces the flame spread index F, in comparison to control Sample M. Also shown, is that the addition of bromine in Samples Land M reduces the maximum smoke density D, in comparison to control Sample M.


When introducing elements of the methods and articles described and/or illustrated herein, including any and all embodiment(s) thereof, the articles “a”, “an”, “the” and “said” are intended to mean that there are one or more of the elements. The terms “comprising”, “including” and “having” are intended to be inclusive and mean that there may be additional elements other than the listed elements.


While the invention has been described in terms of various specific embodiments, those skilled in the art will recognize that the invention can be practiced with modification within the spirit and scope of the claims.

Claims
  • 1. A composite sheet material comprising a porous core layer, said core layer comprising: a web of open celled structures defined by random crossing over of reinforcing fibers held together by a thermoplastic polymer;said web comprising about 20 weight percent to about 80 weight percent of reinforcing fibers based on a total weight of said porous core layer, andan effective amount of a flame retardant agent, said flame retardant agent comprising at least one of N, P, As, Sb, Bi, S, Se, Te, Po, F, Cl, Br, I, and At.
  • 2. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 1 wherein said flame retardant agent comprises a halogenated thermoplastic polymer.
  • 3. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 2 wherein said halogenated thermoplastic polymer comprises tetrabromo bisphenol-A polycarbonate.
  • 4. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 2 wherein said core layer comprises about 2.0 weight percent to about 13.0 weight percent bromine.
  • 5. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 2 wherein said core layer comprises about 2.0 weight percent to about 5.0 weight percent bromine.
  • 6. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 1 further comprising a smoke suppressant composition, said smoke suppressant composition comprising at least one of stannates, zinc borates, zinc molybdate, magnesium silicates, calcium zinc molybdate, calcium silicates and calcium hydroxides.
  • 7. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 1 further comprising at least one of sodium trichlorobenzene sulfonate potassium and diphenyl sulfone-3-sulfonate.
  • 8. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 1 further comprising at least one skin, each said skin covering at least a portion of a surface of said porous core layer, said skin comprising at least one of a thermoplastic film, an elastomeric film, a metal foil, a thermosetting coating, an inorganic coating, a fiber based scrim, a non-woven fabric, and a woven fabric, said skin having a limiting oxygen index greater than about 22, as measured at a predetermined thickness used to cover at least a portion of a surface of said porous core layer per ISO 4589-2, first edition, 1996.
  • 9. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 8 wherein said thermoplastic film comprises at least one of poly(ether imide), poly(ether ketone), poly(ether-ether ketone), poly(phenylene sulfide), poly(arylene sulfone), poly (ether sulfone), poly(antde-imide)poly(amide-imide), poly(1,4-phenylene), polycarbonate, nylon, and silicone.
  • 10. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 8 wherein said fiber based scrim comprises at least one of glass fibers, aramid fibers, graphite fibers, carbon fibers, inorganic mineral fibers, metal fibers, metalized synthetic fibers, and metalized inorganic fibers.
  • 11. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 10 wherein said fiber based scrim comprises at least one of polyacrylonitrile, p-aramid, m-aramid, poly(p-phenylene2,6,benzobisoxazole), poly(ether-imide) and poly(phenylene sulfide).
  • 12. A composite material in accordance with claim 8 wherein said thermal setting coating comprises at least one of unsaturated polyurethartespolyurethanes, vinyl esters, phenolics and epoxies.
  • 13. A composite material in accordance with claim 8 wherein said inorganic coating comprises minerals containing cations selected from Ca, Mg, Ba, Si, Zn, Ti and Al.
  • 14. A composite material in accordance with claim 13 wherein said inorganic coating comprises at least one of gypsum, calcium carbonate and mortar.
  • 15. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 8 comprising: a first porous core layer having a first surface and a second surface; andat least one skin covering at least a portion of at least one of said first and second surface.
  • 16. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 8 comprising: a first and a second porous core layer, each said core layer comprising a first and a second surface, said second surface of said first core layer positioned adjacent said first surface of said second core layer; andat least one skin covering at least a portion of at least one of said first and second surfaces of said first core layer and said first and second surface of said second core layer.
  • 17. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 16 wherein said first porous core layer comprises at least one of a different thermoplastic material and a different fiber than said second porous core layer.
  • 18. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 8 comprising: a first, a second, and a third porous core layer, each said core layer comprising a first and a second surface, said second surface of said first core layer positioned adjacent said first surface of said second core layer, said second surface of said second core layer positioned adjacent said first surface of said third core layer; andat least one skin covering at least one of said first and second surfaces of said first core layer, said first and second surface of said second core layer, and said first and second surface of said third core layer.
  • 19. A composite sheet material in accordance with claim 18 wherein one of said porous core layers comprises at least one of a different thermoplastic material and a different fiber than at least one of said other layers.
  • 20. A composite sheet material according to claim 1 wherein said thermoplastic polymer comprises at least one of polyethylene, polypropylene, polystyrene, acrylonitryistyrene, butadiene, polyethyleneterephthalate, polybutyleneterephthalate, polybutyleneterachlorate, polyvinyl chloride, polyphenylene ether, polycarbonates, polyestercarbonates, thermoplastic polyesters, polyetherimides, acrylonitrile-butylacrylate-styrene polymers, amorphous nylon, polyarylene ether ketone, polyphenylene sulfide, polyaryl sulfone, polyether sulfone, poly(1,4phenylene) compounds, and silicones.
  • 21. A method of manufacturing a porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet, said method comprising: providing a porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet comprising at least one porous core layer comprising a web of open celled structures defined by random crossing over of reinforcing fibers held together by a thermoplastic material, said web comprising from about 20 weight percent to about 80 weight percent fibers, and an effective amount of a flame retardant agent, said flame retardant agent comprising at least one of N, P, As, Sb, Bi, S, Se, Te, Po, F, Cl, Br, I, and At; andlaminating at least one skin to a surface of the porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet, each skin comprising at least one of a thermoplastic film, an elastomeric film, a metal foil, a thermosetting coating, an inorganic coating, a fiber based scrim, a non-woven fabric, and a woven fabric, the skin having a limiting oxygen index greater than about 22, as measured per ISO 4589-2, first edition, 1996, to enhance at least one of the flame, smoke, heat release and gaseous emissions characteristics of the porous fiber-reinforced thermoplastic sheet.
  • 22. A method in accordance with claim 21 wherein the flame retardant agent comprises a halogenated thermoplastic polymer.
  • 23. A method in accordance with claim 22 wherein the halogenated thermoplastic polymer comprises tetrabromo bisphenol-A polycarbonate.
  • 24. A method in accordance with claim 21 wherein the core layer comprises about 2.0 weight percent to about 13.0 weight percent bromine.
  • 25. A method in accordance with claim 21 wherein the core layer further comprises a smoke suppressant composition, said smoke suppressant composition comprising at least one of stannates, zinc borates, zinc molybdate, magnesium silicates, calcium zinc molybdate, calcium silicates and calcium hydroxides.
  • 26. A method in accordance with claim 21 wherein the core layer further comprises at least one of sodium trichlorobenzene sulfonate potassium and diphenyl sulfone-3-sulfonate.
  • 27. The composite sheet material of claim 1, in which the at least one thermoplastic polymer has a limiting oxygen index greater than about 22, as measured per ISO 4589-2, first edition, 1996.
  • 28. The composite sheet material of claim 1, in which the at least one thermoplastic polymer is a polyetherimide polymer.
  • 29. The composite sheet material of claim 1, in which the at least one thermoplastic polymer is a polycarbonate polymer.
  • 30. The composite sheet material of claim 1, further comprising at least one skin disposed on at least a portion of said porous core layer.
  • 31. The composite sheet material of claim 30, in which said skin comprises glass fibers.
  • 32. A composite sheet material comprising a porous core layer, said porous core layer comprising a web of open celled structures defined by random crossing over of reinforcing fibers held together by a thermoplastic polymer blend, said thermoplastic polymer blend comprising at least two resins at least one of which comprises an effective amount of a flame retardant agent.
  • 33. The composite sheet material of claim 32, in which the thermoplastic polymer blend has a limiting oxygen index greater than about 22, as measured per ISO 4589-2, first edition, 1996.
  • 34. The composite sheet material of claim 32, in which the thermoplastic polymer blend comprises a polyetherimide polymer.
  • 35. The composite sheet material of claim 32, in which the thermoplastic polymer blend comprises a polycarbonate polymer.
  • 36. The composite sheet material of claim 32, further comprising at least one skin disposed on at least a portion of the porous core layer.
  • 37. The composite sheet material of claim 36, in which said skin comprises glass fibers.
  • 38. The composite sheet material of claim 32, further comprising a first skin disposed on at least a portion of a first surface of the porous core layer, and a second skin disposed on at least a portion of a second surface of the porous core layer opposite the first surface of the porous core layer.
  • 39. The composite sheet material of claim 32, in which said web comprises about 20 weight percent to about 80 weight percent of reinforcing fibers based on a total weight of said porous core layer.
  • 40. The composite sheet material of claim 32, in which the thermoplastic polymer blend comprises a halogenated thermoplastic polymer.
  • 41. The composite sheet material of claim 40, in which the halogenated thermoplastic polymer is a polycarbonate polymer comprising bromine.
  • 42. The composite sheet material of claim 32, in which the thermoplastic polymer blend comprises two polymers comprising the same polymer backbone.
  • 43. The composite sheet material of claim 42, in which the two polymers comprising the same polymer backbone are polycarbonate polymers.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a Continuation-In-Part application of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/810,739, filed Mar. 26, 2004 now U.S. Pat. No. 7,244,501, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.

US Referenced Citations (296)
Number Name Date Kind
1707008 Havemeyer May 1929 A
2815979 Seymour Dec 1957 A
2976577 Gould Mar 1961 A
3022210 Phillips Feb 1962 A
3179782 Matvay Apr 1965 A
3437550 Paul Apr 1969 A
3484223 Vanderbilt Dec 1969 A
3627603 Greig Dec 1971 A
3639157 Winckler Feb 1972 A
3639424 Gray Feb 1972 A
3684645 Temple Aug 1972 A
3713962 Ackley Jan 1973 A
3716449 Gatward Feb 1973 A
3779592 Goize Dec 1973 A
3809420 Weller May 1974 A
3849241 Butin Nov 1974 A
3850723 Ackley Nov 1974 A
3853808 Sishikawa Dec 1974 A
3857813 Stain Dec 1974 A
3865661 Hata Feb 1975 A
3871952 Robertson Mar 1975 A
3883333 Ackley May 1975 A
4044188 Segal Aug 1977 A
4052241 Walter Oct 1977 A
4098943 Degginger Jul 1978 A
4172293 Vistins Oct 1979 A
4178411 Cogswell Dec 1979 A
4201823 Russell May 1980 A
4208069 Huber Jun 1980 A
4211590 Steward Jul 1980 A
4235952 Holmes Nov 1980 A
4248935 Temple Feb 1981 A
4263082 Temple Apr 1981 A
4277531 Picone Jul 1981 A
4278720 Shannon Jul 1981 A
4285767 Page Aug 1981 A
4335176 Baumann Jun 1982 A
4341877 Das Jul 1982 A
4358501 Temple Nov 1982 A
4366204 Briggs Dec 1982 A
4369234 Baumann Jan 1983 A
4379801 Weaver Apr 1983 A
4379802 Weaver Apr 1983 A
4390384 Turner Jun 1983 A
4412854 Layden Nov 1983 A
4413085 Temple Nov 1983 A
4423000 Teraoka Dec 1983 A
4457547 Sekiyama Jul 1984 A
4464432 Dost Aug 1984 A
4469543 Segal Sep 1984 A
4476183 Holtrop Oct 1984 A
4482180 Huber Nov 1984 A
4495238 Adiletta Jan 1985 A
4508499 Spengler Apr 1985 A
4519766 Spengler May 1985 A
4529641 Holtrop Jul 1985 A
4543288 Radvan Sep 1985 A
4579774 Kuwazuru Apr 1986 A
4586739 Loren May 1986 A
4587278 Dotzauer May 1986 A
4612238 Della Vecchia Sep 1986 A
4615717 Neubauer Oct 1986 A
4616866 Loren Oct 1986 A
4634483 Spengler Jan 1987 A
4635984 Loren Jan 1987 A
4637951 Gill Jan 1987 A
4663369 Kawai May 1987 A
4670331 Radvan Jun 1987 A
4670343 Makino Jun 1987 A
4671550 Molnar Jun 1987 A
4681798 Gill Jul 1987 A
4692375 Neubauer Sep 1987 A
4694031 Morita Sep 1987 A
4704423 Iwanami Nov 1987 A
4713283 Cogswell Dec 1987 A
4714650 Obayashi Dec 1987 A
4717143 Spengler Jan 1988 A
4734321 Radvan Mar 1988 A
4741945 Brant May 1988 A
4749613 Yamada Jun 1988 A
4755575 Domeier Jul 1988 A
4762352 Enomoto Aug 1988 A
4762643 Bohrn Aug 1988 A
4762750 Girgis Aug 1988 A
4767321 Chilva Aug 1988 A
4775725 Depasquale Oct 1988 A
4778722 Yamamura Oct 1988 A
4793802 Chilva Dec 1988 A
4802843 Chilva Feb 1989 A
4804577 Hazelton Feb 1989 A
4828910 Haussling May 1989 A
4840832 Weinle Jun 1989 A
4851167 Marc Jul 1989 A
4882229 Hwo Nov 1989 A
4892780 Cochran Jan 1990 A
4913774 Goguelin Apr 1990 A
4923547 Yamaji May 1990 A
4924224 Suniszek May 1990 A
4925615 Willis May 1990 A
4940629 Weber Jul 1990 A
4943607 Tanisake Jul 1990 A
4944843 Wallace Jul 1990 A
4950532 Das Aug 1990 A
4951986 Hanafusa Aug 1990 A
4952448 Bullock Aug 1990 A
4963603 Felegi Oct 1990 A
4978489 Radvan Dec 1990 A
4983247 Kim Jan 1991 A
5002830 Gillis Mar 1991 A
5009747 Viazmensky Apr 1991 A
5030682 Nomura Jul 1991 A
5043368 Minnick Aug 1991 A
5092952 Minnick Mar 1992 A
5093171 Sheahan Mar 1992 A
5098781 Minnick Mar 1992 A
5115077 Matsuo May 1992 A
5122398 Seiler Jun 1992 A
5137975 Kelusky Aug 1992 A
5147345 Young Sep 1992 A
5151320 Homonoff Sep 1992 A
5165990 Nakano Nov 1992 A
5175198 Minnick Dec 1992 A
5180628 Haardt Jan 1993 A
5186777 Perenon Feb 1993 A
5188778 Jeffs Feb 1993 A
5219913 Tomatsu Jun 1993 A
5231126 Shi et al. Jul 1993 A
5246538 Johnson Sep 1993 A
5262491 Jain Nov 1993 A
5267827 Provan Dec 1993 A
5269574 Bhutani Dec 1993 A
5288555 Exxon Feb 1994 A
5300360 Kocsis Apr 1994 A
5306739 Lucey Apr 1994 A
5316834 Matsuda May 1994 A
5322724 Levens Jun 1994 A
5338059 Inoue Aug 1994 A
5342463 Addeo Aug 1994 A
5344866 Hall Sep 1994 A
5348798 Berghuis Sep 1994 A
5354829 Swisher Oct 1994 A
5376701 Chow Dec 1994 A
5387382 Fottinger Feb 1995 A
5403654 Muto Apr 1995 A
5413661 Spengler May 1995 A
5437919 Welich Aug 1995 A
5464585 Fitzgibbon Nov 1995 A
5470658 Gasca Nov 1995 A
5484653 Kennedy Jan 1996 A
5486256 Romesberg Jan 1996 A
5502088 Hododi Mar 1996 A
5503903 Bainbridge Apr 1996 A
5529742 Strapazzini Jun 1996 A
5536556 Juriga Jul 1996 A
5540986 Kimura Jul 1996 A
5549776 Juriga Aug 1996 A
5565259 Juriga Oct 1996 A
5576080 Sugimoto Nov 1996 A
5582906 Romesberg Dec 1996 A
5591289 Souders Jan 1997 A
5614285 Gardill Mar 1997 A
5627226 Lustiger May 1997 A
5635129 Breezer Jun 1997 A
5639324 Biggs Jun 1997 A
5641554 Koizumi Jun 1997 A
5643989 Van de Grampel Jul 1997 A
5685560 Sugiyama Nov 1997 A
5709925 Spengler Jan 1998 A
5718791 Spengler Feb 1998 A
5775726 Timothy Jul 1998 A
5780519 Imoto Jul 1998 A
5795015 Corpe Aug 1998 A
5800749 Lewit Sep 1998 A
5800846 Hart Sep 1998 A
5804511 Kelman Sep 1998 A
5817408 Orimo Oct 1998 A
5839752 Yamasaki Nov 1998 A
5840812 Schultze Nov 1998 A
5845929 Schlett Dec 1998 A
5853628 Varona Dec 1998 A
5854149 Nagayama Dec 1998 A
5866051 Lin Feb 1999 A
5879608 Lammeck Mar 1999 A
5883021 Beer Mar 1999 A
5885691 Breezer Mar 1999 A
5888435 Mueller Mar 1999 A
5908524 Masui Jun 1999 A
5910458 Beer Jun 1999 A
5914163 Browne Jun 1999 A
5922626 Pelzer Jul 1999 A
5942321 Romesberg Aug 1999 A
5952089 Namura Sep 1999 A
5972444 Patel Oct 1999 A
5976451 Skaja Nov 1999 A
5979931 Totani Nov 1999 A
5981046 Masui Nov 1999 A
5985429 Plummer Nov 1999 A
6007898 Kim Dec 1999 A
6018927 Major Feb 2000 A
6042140 Blazaitis Mar 2000 A
6042141 Welch Mar 2000 A
6042765 Sugahara Mar 2000 A
6062635 Learman May 2000 A
6099055 Hirota Aug 2000 A
6120090 Van Ert Sep 2000 A
6146578 Van Ert Nov 2000 A
6150287 Boyd Nov 2000 A
6203304 Lopez Tonazzi Mar 2001 B1
6214456 Boyd Apr 2001 B1
6238518 Rokman May 2001 B1
6286879 Haque Sep 2001 B1
6287678 Spengler Sep 2001 B1
6293045 Morgan Sep 2001 B1
6322658 Byma Nov 2001 B1
6365533 Horner Apr 2002 B1
6368702 Erickson Apr 2002 B1
6369157 Winckler Apr 2002 B1
6420047 Winckler Jul 2002 B2
6423933 Nicholas Jul 2002 B2
6436854 North Aug 2002 B1
6503372 Rokman Jan 2003 B1
6565712 Lindenfelser May 2003 B2
6572723 Tilton Jun 2003 B1
6596389 Hallett Jul 2003 B1
6610904 Thomas Aug 2003 B1
6631785 Khambete Oct 2003 B2
6639009 Winckler Oct 2003 B2
6649248 Schneider Nov 2003 B1
6652021 Dykman Nov 2003 B1
6696164 Clifford Feb 2004 B2
6702914 North Mar 2004 B2
6762138 Ferreira Jul 2004 B2
6774068 Sung-Ho Aug 2004 B2
6808576 Shimizu Oct 2004 B2
6815053 Inoue Nov 2004 B2
6841028 Tsukada Jan 2005 B2
6994914 Winckler Feb 2006 B2
7047668 Burris May 2006 B2
7060217 Dunton Jun 2006 B2
7157034 Bristow Jan 2007 B2
7236348 Asano Jun 2007 B2
7244501 Raghavendran Jul 2007 B2
7255391 Bristow Aug 2007 B2
7318498 Woodman Jan 2008 B2
7329457 Renard Feb 2008 B2
7378143 Schneider May 2008 B2
7431980 Woodman Oct 2008 B2
7435469 Maupetit Oct 2008 B2
7482048 Boutghrit Jan 2009 B2
7629278 Sabbagh Dec 2009 B2
7682697 Raghavendran Mar 2010 B2
7695815 Agarwal Apr 2010 B2
7759267 Conover Jul 2010 B2
7845265 Park Dec 2010 B1
7922854 Sabbagh Apr 2011 B2
7972685 Raghavendran Jul 2011 B2
8021746 Chen Sep 2011 B2
20010036788 Sandoe Nov 2001 A1
20010037854 Byma Nov 2001 A1
20020009936 North Jan 2002 A1
20020017805 Carroll Feb 2002 A1
20030008592 Block Jan 2003 A1
20030134101 Kikuchi Jul 2003 A1
20030138594 Lobovsky Jul 2003 A1
20030164218 Brahm Sep 2003 A1
20040002274 Tilton Jan 2004 A1
20040081797 Simmons Apr 2004 A1
20040112501 Dittmar Jun 2004 A1
20040216949 Tompson Nov 2004 A1
20040231915 Thompson Nov 2004 A1
20040235377 Byma Nov 2004 A1
20040254299 Lee Dec 2004 A1
20050032452 Helwig Feb 2005 A1
20050095415 Raghavendran May 2005 A1
20050153120 Birrell Jul 2005 A1
20050215698 Raghavendran Sep 2005 A1
20050217932 Woodman Oct 2005 A1
20060099393 Woodman May 2006 A1
20060182947 Jerri Aug 2006 A1
20060240242 Raghavendran Oct 2006 A1
20060244170 Brentup Nov 2006 A1
20070008869 Tsukamoto Jan 2007 A1
20070196637 Good Aug 2007 A1
20070238378 Conover Oct 2007 A1
20070269644 Harper Nov 2007 A1
20070269645 Raghavendran et al. Nov 2007 A1
20070269654 Raghavendran Nov 2007 A1
20080001429 Willis Jan 2008 A1
20080008869 Good Jan 2008 A1
20080032094 Raghavendran Feb 2008 A1
20080070019 Good Mar 2008 A1
20080233342 Birrell Sep 2008 A1
20090011210 Gao Jan 2009 A1
20090053458 Birrell Feb 2009 A1
20090155522 Raghavendran Jun 2009 A1
20100021718 Vos Jan 2010 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (97)
Number Date Country
661949 Aug 1993 AU
842919 May 1970 CA
938391 Dec 1973 CA
1266540 Mar 1990 CA
2054975 Nov 1991 CA
2129453 Aug 1993 CA
1335740 May 1995 CA
1188279 Mar 1965 DE
2231637 Feb 1973 DE
2650096 Oct 1976 DE
2527781 Dec 1976 DE
3125987 Jan 1983 DE
9214896 Dec 1992 DE
69207432 May 1996 DE
19520477 Dec 1996 DE
20102194 May 2001 DE
20106096 Jun 2001 DE
10160442 Aug 2002 DE
20106096 Jun 2006 DE
0001176 Mar 1979 EP
0056703 Jul 1982 EP
011104555 Apr 1984 EP
0148760 Jul 1985 EP
0148763 Jul 1985 EP
0150931 Aug 1985 EP
0177961 Apr 1986 EP
0255316 Feb 1988 EP
0278409 Aug 1988 EP
0312414 Apr 1989 EP
0381857 Aug 1990 EP
0404303 Dec 1990 EP
0410678 Jan 1991 EP
9100021 Jul 1991 EP
0450638 Oct 1991 EP
502141 Sep 1992 EP
0502414 Sep 1992 EP
0625104 Nov 1994 EP
0625544 Nov 1994 EP
0631862 Jan 1995 EP
0635462 Jan 1995 EP
0319589 Feb 1995 EP
0651003 May 1995 EP
0753402 Jul 1995 EP
0671259 Sep 1995 EP
0671259 Sep 1995 EP
0729829 Aug 1996 EP
0758577 Feb 1997 EP
0794215 Sep 1997 EP
0808944 Nov 1997 EP
0808944 Nov 1997 EP
0858481 Aug 1998 EP
0945253 Sep 1999 EP
1031467 Aug 2000 EP
1211138 Jun 2002 EP
1211138 Jun 2002 EP
1373375 Jan 2004 EP
1812637 May 2006 EP
1737650 Jan 2007 EP
1844927 Oct 2007 EP
1857261 Nov 2007 EP
0625104 Nov 1994 FR
1550358 Aug 1979 GB
2077311 Dec 1981 GB
62017048 Jan 1987 JP
62157782 Jun 1987 JP
62195030 Aug 1987 JP
63230542 Sep 1988 JP
1083087 Mar 1989 JP
1083088 Mar 1989 JP
2138349 May 1990 JP
1016660 Jan 1998 JP
11342552 Dec 1999 JP
9207983 May 1992 WO
9315933 Aug 1993 WO
9400418 Jan 1994 WO
9415884 Jul 1994 WO
9427840 Dec 1994 WO
03035435 Jan 1995 WO
9612849 May 1996 WO
9716846 Sep 1997 WO
9831626 Jul 1998 WO
9834778 Aug 1998 WO
9948683 Sep 1999 WO
0208316 Jan 2002 WO
0208316 Jan 2002 WO
02077076 Oct 2002 WO
02081802 Oct 2002 WO
02081802 Oct 2002 WO
03002330 Jan 2003 WO
03086725 Oct 2003 WO
2004004303 Aug 2004 WO
2005070664 Aug 2005 WO
2005097879 Oct 2005 WO
2005100708 Oct 2005 WO
2006008529 Jan 2006 WO
2006052967 May 2006 WO
2006089025 Aug 2006 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (9)
Entry
U.S. Appl. No. 11/437,997, filed May 19, 2006.
U.S. Appl. No. 13/416,617, filed Mar. 9, 2013.
U.S. Appl. No. 11/893,613, filed Oct. 22, 2007.
High Performance SuperLite Sheet, Disclosed Anonymously, IP.com, Aug. 2, 2002, 8 pgs.
Azdel Superlite Sheet—Technical Guide Part 1, Disclosed Anonymously, IP.com, Aug. 5, 2002, 21 pgs.
Azdel Superlite Sheet—Commercial Guide Part 1, Disclosed Anonymously, IP.com, Aug. 5, 2002, 8 pgs.
Azdel Superlite Sheet—Processing Guides, Disclosed Anonymously, IP.com, Aug. 6, 2002, 3 pgs.
Azdel Superlite Sheet—Technical Guide Part 2, Disclosed Anomymously, IP.com, Aug. 5, 2002, 32 pgs.
European Search Report; Aug. 13, 2008; 13 pages.
Continuation in Parts (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 10810739 Mar 2004 US
Child 11441709 US
Reissues (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 11441709 May 2006 US
Child 13427131 US