Filter matrix

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 5877099
  • Patent Number
    5,877,099
  • Date Filed
    Monday, January 27, 1997
    27 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 2, 1999
    25 years ago
Abstract
A web, formed from dielectric fibers and non-dielectric fibers, which has been subjected to corona discharge to improve the particulate filtration properties of the web is provided. The dielectric and non-dielectric fibers may be intermingled within the web such that the distribution of the dielectric and non-dielectric fibers within the web is generally uniform. In one embodiment, the dielectric fibers may be formed from a thermoplastic polymer, and particularly polyolefin and the non-dielectric fibers may be formed from cellulose, and particularly wood pulp.
Description

FIELD OF INVENTION
This invention relates to filtration media, and particularly to a fibrous filtration media formed from a nonwoven web of cellulose pulp fibers and polyolefin fibers.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Various particulate filtering media may be formed from diverse materials, such as glass fibers, asbestos fibers, synthetic polymer fibers, e.g., polyolefins, polyamides, polyesters and the like, and natural fibers, such as wood pulp and the like. Desirably, a particulate filter medium should possess a high particulate filtration efficiency, but should also possess a high filtered fluid (e.g., gas or liquid) permeability. However, these performance attributes tend to be inversely related. For example, in some instances, increasing the particulate filtration efficiency of a filter media may tend to increase the pressure differential at the filter media between the filtered fluid and the unfiltered fluid.
As is known in the filtration art, filtration efficiency is improved by improving the ability of the filter media to mechanically entrap contaminates. In some instances, the filter media's ability to mechanically entrap contaminates, such as air born particulates, is improved by increasing the loft or thickness of the filter media without increasing the density of the filter media.
However, increasing the filter media's thickness has several disadvantages. In some instances, existing filter receiving structures may not be large enough to receive such thickened filters. In other instances, and particularly in those instances when the filter media is formed from a conform of wood pulp and polymer fibers, such increased thickness is generally achieved by incorporating increased quantities of the conformed materials. Increasing the quantities of these materials not only results in increased material costs and shipping costs but also reduces the filter material's fluid throughput by increasing the pressure differential across the filter media.
Therefore, there exists a need for a filter media, and particularly for filter media formed from a conform of wood pulp and polymer fibers, and methods of making the same which provides improved filtration efficiencies over conventional filter media formed from similar materials and which avoids the problems associated with conventional methods of improving the filtration efficiencies of filter media.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In response to the above problems encountered by those skilled in the art, the present invention provides a web, formed from dielectric fibers and non-dielectric fibers, which has been subjected to corona discharge. The dielectric and non-dielectric fibers may be intermingled within the web such that the distribution of the dielectric and non-dielectric fibers within the web is generally uniform. In one embodiment, the dielectric fibers may be formed from a thermoplastic polymer, and particularly polyolefin and the non-dielectric fibers may be formed from cellulose, and particularly wood pulp.
The percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web may range from about 1% to 99% weight of the web and particularly from about 5% to 95% weight of the web, and particularly from about 10% to 90% weight of the web, and more particularly from about 20% to 80% weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 30% to 70% weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 40% to 60% weight of the web. Generally, the percent weight of non-dielectric fibers present in the web may range from about 1% to 99% weight of the web, and particularly from about 5% to 95% weight of the web, and particularly from about 10% to 90% weight of the web, and more particularly from about 20% to 80% weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 30% to 70% weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 40% to 60% weight of the web.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
As used herein, the term "dielectric" means, according to McGraw-Hill Encyclopedia of Science & Technolocy, 7th Edition, Copyright 1992, a material, such as a polymer, which is an electrical insulator or in which an electric field can be sustained with a minimum dissipation of power. A solid material is a dielectric if its valence band is full and is separated from the conduction band by at least 3 eV.
As used herein, the term "nonwoven web" refers to a web that has a structure of individual fibers or filaments which are interlaid, but not in an identifiable repeating manner.
As used herein the term "spunbonded fibers" refers to fibers which are formed by extruding molten thermoplastic material as filaments from a plurality of fine, usually circular capillaries of a spinnerette with the diameter of the extruded filaments then being rapidly reduced as by, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 4,340,563 to Appel et al., and U.S. Pat. No. 3,692,618 to Dorschner et al., U.S. Pat. No. 3,802,817 to Matsuki et al., U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,338,992 and 3,341,394 to Kinney, U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,502,763 and 3,909,009 to Levy, and U.S. Pat. No. 3,542,615 to Dobo et al which are all herein incorporated by reference.
As used herein the term "meltblown fibers" means fibers formed by extruding a molten thermoplastic material through a plurality of fine, usually circular, die capillaries as molten threads or filaments into a high velocity, usually heated gas (e.g. air) stream which attenuates the filaments of molten thermoplastic material to reduce their diameter. Thereafter, the meltblown fibers are carried by the high velocity gas stream and are deposited on a collecting surface to form a web of randomly disbursed meltblown fibers. Meltblowing is described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 3,849,241 to Buntin, U.S. Pat. No. 4,307,143 to Meitner et al., and U.S. Pat. No. 4,707,398 to Wisneski et al which are all herein incorporated by reference.
The present invention provides a web, formed from dielectric fibers and non-dielectric fibers, which has been subjected to corona discharge. The dielectric and non-dielectric fibers may be intermingled within the web such that the distribution of the dielectric and non-dielectric fibers within the web is generally uniform. The web formed from intermingled dielectric and non-dielectric fibers may be in the form of a woven web or nonwoven web. Nonwoven webs formed from intermingled dielectric and non-dielectric fibers can be made from a variety of processes including, but not limited to, conforming processes and hydroentangling processes.
It has been found that webs formed from thermoplastic based dielectric fibers and particularly polyolefin based dielectric fibers are well-suited for use in the present invention. Generally, dielectric materials suitable for forming dielectric fibers of the present invention include, but are not limited to, polyesters, polyolefins, nylon and copolymers, polymer blends and bi-component polymers of these materials. Generally, these fibers may be melt extruded fibers such as, for example, meltblown fibers or spunbonded fibers. It has been found that nonwoven webs formed from polyolefin-based fibers and particularly polypropylene-based fibers are particularly well-suited for use in the present invention.
It has also been found that cellulose based non-dielectric fibers and particularly wood pulp based fibers are particularly well-suited for use in the present invention. Generally, non-dielectric materials suitable for forming non-dielectric fibers include, but are not limited to, cellulose, such as wood pulp, glass, wool and protein polymers.
Generally, the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web may range from about 1% to 99% weight of the web and all percent weight ranges of the web therebetween. Desirably, the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web may range about 5% to 95% weight of the web, and particularly from about 10% to 90% weight of the web, and more particularly from about 20% to 807 weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 30% to 70% weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 40% to 60% weight of the web.
Generally, the percent weight of non-dielectric fibers present in the web may range from about 1% to 99% and all ranges of the web therebetween. Desirably, the percent weight of non-dielectric fibers present in the web may range from about 5% to 95% weight of the web, and particularly from about 10% to 90% weight of the web, and more particularly from about 20% to 80% weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 30% to 70% weight of the web, and still more particularly from about 40% to 60% weight of the web.
Methods of subjecting the web to corona discharge, are well known by those skilled in the art. Briefly, corona discharge is achieved by the application of sufficient direct current (DC) voltage to an electric field initiating structure (EFIS) in the proximity of an electric field receiving structure (EFRS). The voltage should be sufficiently high such that ions are generated at the EFIS and flow from the EFIS to the EFRS. Both the EFIS and the EFRS are desirably formed from conductive materials. Suitable conductive materials include conductive metals such as, copper, tungsten, stainless steel and aluminum.
One particular technique of subjecting the web to corona discharge is the technique disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,401,446, which is assigned to the University of Tennessee, and is herein incorporated by reference. This technique involves subjecting the web to a pair of electrical fields wherein the electrical fields have opposite polarities. Each electrical field forms a corona discharge.





EXAMPLES
The following examples demonstrate several embodiments of the present invention. Such examples, however, are not to be construed as limiting in any way either the spirit or scope of the present invention. Two sets of web samples, SAMPLE 1 and SAMPLE 2, were evaluated. Each set of web samples was formed from dielectric fibers and non-dielectric fibers.
SAMPLE 1
SAMPLE 1 included 7 nonwoven webs each having a basis weight of 150 grams per square meter (gsm). The percent weight range of dielectric and non-dielectric fibers in each of the SAMPLE 1 nonwoven webs was varied to achieve the respective distributions of the dielectric and non-dielectric fibers reported in TABLE II. The SAMPLE 1 nonwoven webs were formed by the process described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,818,464, which is herein incorporated by reference. These nonwoven webs were generally prepared using the conditions listed in TABLE I. The dielectric fibers were formed from Himont PF015 polypropylene. The non-dielectric fibers were formed from Weyerhauser NF405 cellulose pulp.
TABLE I______________________________________Conditions Used To Prepare SAMPLE 1 WebsCode 1 Extr #1 Extr #2______________________________________PP Pump Rate (RPM) 12 12Zone 1 Temp 300.degree. F. 300.degree. F.Zone 2 Temp 370.degree. F. 370.degree. F.Zone 3 Temp 420.degree. F. 420.degree. F.Zone 4 Temp 480.degree. F. 480.degree. F.Zone 5 Temp 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Zone 6 Temp 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Extruder Melt Temp 517.degree. F. 510.degree. F.Hose Temp 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Adapter Temp 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Spin Pump Body Temp 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Die Zone 1 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Die Zone 2 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Die Zone 3 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Die Zone 4 500.degree. F. 500.degree. F.Die Tip Melt Temp 505.degree. F. 508.degree. F.Primary Air Temp -- --Extruder Pressure 300 150Spin Pump Pressure 147 139Adapter Pressure 300 300Melt Pressure 110 320Primary Air Pressure 7 7Prim Air Htr 20" line 570 --Primary Air Heater -- --Priinary Air Flow 2 470 --CET Feed rpm 7 --Line Speed fpm 213 --Die Angles 48.degree. 49.degree.Tip to Tip Distance 6 3/4" 6 3/4"Tip to Wire Distance 12 3/4" 11 1/2"Forming Height --CET Duct to Wire Dist 18 1/2"Under Wire Zone 1 0Under Wire Zone 2 -4Under Wire Zone 3 -16Under Wire Zone 4 -15Under Wire Zone 5 -3Under Wire Zone 6 -6______________________________________ Note: All Pressures are in pounds per square inch (psi)
Several of the SAMPLE 1 nonwoven webs were subjected to corona discharge. The corona discharge was produced by using a Model No. P/N 25 A--120 volt, 50/60 Hz reversible polarity power unit (Simco Corp., Hatfield, Pa.), which was connected to the EFIS, and a Model No. P16V 120 V,.25A 50/60 Hz power unit (Simco Corp., Hatfield, Pa.) which was connected to the EFRS. The EFIS was a RC-3 Charge Master charge bar (Simco. Corp.) and the EFRS was a solid, three inch diameter, aluminum roller. The corona discharge environment was 70.degree. F. and 53% relative humidity. As described in the above U.S. Pat. No. 5,401,446, two sets of EFIS/EFRS are used. The voltage applied to the first set of EFIS/EFRS was 15 KV/0.0 KV, respectively. The voltage applied to the second set of EFIS/EFRS was 25 KV/7.5 KV, respectively. The gap between the EFIS and the EFRS for each set was one inch.
The particulate filtration properties of the SAMPLE 1 nonwoven webs exposed to corona discharge (Post Corona--TABLE II) were compared to the SAMPLE 1 nonwoven webs which were not exposed to corona discharge (Pre Corona--TABLE II).
The particulate filtration test used to evaluate the particulate filtration properties of these SAMPLES is generally known as the NaCl Filter Efficiency Test (hereinafter the "NaCl Test"). The NaCl Test was conducted on an automated filter tester, CERTITEST.TM. Model# 8110, which is available from TSI Inc., St. Paul, Minn. The particulate filtration efficiency of the test fabric is reported as "% penetration". The "% penetration" is calculated by the following formula: 100.times. (downstream particles/upstream particles). The upstream particles represent the total quantity of approximately 0.1 .mu.m NaCl aerosol particles which are introduced into the tester. The downstream particles are those particles which have been introduced into the tester and which have passed through the bulk of the test fabric. Therefore, the "% penetration" value reported in TABLE II is a percentage of the total quantity of particles introduced into a controlled air flow within the tester which pass through the bulk of the test fabric. The size of the test fabric was 4.5" in diameter.
TABLE II______________________________________SAMPLE 1 % Penetration-0.1 .mu.m NaCl% wt Pulp % wt Polypropylene Pre Corona Post Corona______________________________________90 10 49.3 37.180 20 55.4 38.470 30 56.3 23.760 40 53.4 13.650 50 42.7 9.7230 70 43.8 3.4320 80 35.7 2.530 100 43.5 0.4______________________________________
SAMPLE 2
SAMPLE 2 included 2 nonwoven webs having different basis weights (See TABLE III). Each of the nonwoven webs were formed from a combination of dielectric and non-dielectric fibers. The percent weight range of dielectric and non-dielectric fibers for each nonwoven web was also varied. The dielectric fibers were formed from Shell DX5E65 polypropylene. The non-dielectric fibers were formed primarily from Northern Softwood Kraft pulp.
The SAMPLE 2 nonwoven webs were formed by hydroentangling as described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,284,703 and 5,389,202, which are herein incorporated by reference.
A portion of the SAMPLE 2 nonwoven webs were subjected to corona discharge. The corona discharge was produced by using a Model No. P/N 25 A--120 volt, 50/60 Hz reversible polarity power unit (Simco Corp., Hatfield, Pa.), which was connected to the EFIS, and a Model No. P16V 120 V,.25 A 50/60 Hz power unit (Simco Corp., Hatfield, Pa.) which was connected to the EFRS. The EFIS was a RC-3 Charge Master charge bar (Simco. Corp.) and the EFRS was a solid, three inch diameter, aluminum roller. The corona discharge environment was 70.degree. F. and 53% relative humidity. As described in the above U.S. Pat. No. 5,401466, two sets of EFIS/EFRS are used. The voltage applied to the first set of EFIS/EFRS was 15 KV/0.0 KV, respectively. The voltage applied to the second set of EFIS/EFRS was 25 KV/7.5 KV, respectively. The gap between the EFIS and the EFRS for each set was one inch.
The particulate filtration properties of the SAMPLE 2 nonwoven webs which were exposed to corona discharge (Post Corona--TABLE III) were compared to the SAMPLE 2 nonwoven webs which were not exposed to corona discharge (Pre Corona--TABLE III).
The particulate filtration test used to evaluate the particulate filtration properties of these SAMPLES is generally known as the NaCl Filter Efficiency Test (hereinafter the "NaCl Test"). The NaCl Test was conducted on an automated filter tester, CERTITEST.TM. Model# 8110, which is available from TSI Inc., St. Paul, Minn. The particulate filtration efficiency of the test fabric is reported as "% penetration". The "% penetration " is calculated by the following formula: 100.times. (downstream particles/upstream particles). The upstream particles represent the total quantity of approximately 0.1 .mu.m NaCl aerosol particles which are introduced into the tester. The downstream particles are those particles which have been introduced into the tester and which have passed through the bulk of the test fabric. Therefore, the "% penetration" value reported in TABLE III is a percentage of the total quantity of particles introduced into a controlled air flow within the tester which pass through the bulk of the test fabric. The size of the test fabric was 4.5" in diameter.
TABLE III______________________________________SAMPLE 2Basis % Penetration-0.1 .mu.m NaClWt. (gsm) % Pulp % polypropylene Pre Corona Post Corona______________________________________86 gsm 80 20 76.5 60.460 gsm 77 23 86.5 69.2______________________________________
It is clear from the data contained in TABLEs II and III, that the particulate filtration efficiency of a web formed from dielectric and non-dielectric materials is significantly improved by subjecting such webs to corona discharge.
While the invention has been described in detail with respect to specific embodiments thereof, it will be appreciated that those skilled in the art, upon attaining an understanding of the foregoing, may readily conceive of alterations to, variations of and equivalents to these embodiments. Accordingly, the scope of the present invention should be assessed as that of the appended claims and any equivalents thereto.
Claims
  • 1. A conformed web comprising dielectric and non-dielectric fibers, wherein the dielectric and non-dielectric fibers in the conformed web are intermingled such that the distribution of dielectric and non-dielectric fibers in the web is generally uniform, and wherein the conformed web has been subjected to DC corona discharge.
  • 2. The web of claim 1 wherein the dielectric fibers are formed from a thermoplastic polymer.
  • 3. The web of claim 1 wherein the dielectric fibers are formed from a polymer selected from the group consisting of polyesters, polyolefins, nylon and copolymers thereof.
  • 4. The web of claim 1 wherein the dielectric fibers are formed from polypropylene.
  • 5. The web of claim 1 wherein the non-dielectric fibers are formed from a material selected from the group consisting of cellulose, glass, wool and protein polymers.
  • 6. The web of claim 1 wherein the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web ranges from between 5% to 95% weight of the web.
  • 7. The web of claim 1 wherein the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web ranges from between 10% to 90% weight of the web.
  • 8. The web of claim 1 wherein the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web ranges from between 20% to 80% weight of the web.
  • 9. The web of claim 1, wherein the dielectric fibers comprise polypropylene, and the non-dielectric fibers comprise cellulose.
  • 10. A woven web comprising dielectric fibers and non-dielectric fibers, wherein the dielectric and non-dielectric fibers in the web are intermingled such that the distribution of dielectric and non-dielectric fibers in the web is generally uniform; the percent weight of the non-dielectric fibers ranges from at least 5% to 95% weight of the web, and wherein the woven web has been subjected to DC corona discharge.
  • 11. The web of claim 10 wherein the dielectric fibers are formed from a polymer selected from the group consisting of polyesters, polyolefins, nylon and copolymers thereof.
  • 12. The web of claim 10 wherein the non-dielectric fibers are formed from a material selected from the group consisting of cellulose, glass, wool and protein polymers.
  • 13. The web of claim 10 wherein the dielectric fibers are formed from polypropylene.
  • 14. The web of claim 10, wherein the dielectric fibers comprise polypropylene, and the non-dielectric fibers comprise cellulose.
  • 15. The web of claim 10, wherein the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web ranges from between 10% to 90% weight of the web.
  • 16. The web of claim 15, wherein the percent weight of dielectric fibers present the web ranges from between 20% to 80% weight of the web.
  • 17. A web comprising dielectric and non-dielectric fibers, wherein the dielectric and non-dielectric fibers are intermingled to form a single layer, the web being formed by a process comprising:
  • conforming dielectric and no-dielectric fibers into a single nonwoven layer; and
  • subjecting single nonwoven layer DC corona discharge.
  • 18. The web of claim 12, wherein the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web ranges from between 10% to 90% weight of the web.
  • 19. The web of claim 18, wherein the percent weight of dielectric fibers present in the web ranges from between 20% to 80% weight of the web.
  • 20. The web of claim 17, wherein the dielectric fibers comprise polypropylene, and the non-dielectric fibers comprise cellulose.
Parent Case Info

This is a continuation of application No. 80/450,043 filed May 25,1995, now abandoned.

US Referenced Citations (132)
Number Name Date Kind
RE32171 van Turnhout Jun 1986
668791 Blake et al. Feb 1901
813063 Sutton et al. Feb 1906
859998 Wentworth Jul 1907
924032 Blake et al. Jun 1909
1222305 Kraus Apr 1917
1297159 Hedberg Mar 1919
1355477 Howell Oct 1920
2106865 Bantz et al. Feb 1938
2217444 Hill Oct 1940
2328577 Oglesby Sep 1943
2378067 Cook, Jr. Mar 1945
2398792 Johnson Apr 1946
3012668 Fraas Dec 1961
3338992 Kinney Aug 1967
3341007 Mayer et al. Sep 1967
3341394 Kinney Sep 1967
3380584 Fulwyler Apr 1968
3402814 Morel et al. Sep 1968
3502763 Hartmann Mar 1970
3542615 Dobo et al. Nov 1970
3581886 Singewald et al. Jun 1971
3692618 Dorschner et al. Sep 1972
3802817 Matsuki et al. Apr 1974
3821021 McMillin Jun 1974
3849241 Butin et al. Nov 1974
3909009 Cvetko et al. Sep 1975
4011067 Carey, Jr. Mar 1977
4103062 Aberson et al. Jul 1978
4140607 Kreiseimeier et al. Feb 1979
4178157 van Turnhout et al. Dec 1979
4215682 Kubik et al. Aug 1980
4273635 Beraud et al. Jun 1981
4298440 Hood Nov 1981
4305797 Knoll et al. Dec 1981
4307143 Meitner Dec 1981
4308223 Stern Dec 1981
4340563 Appel et al. Jul 1982
4353799 Leonard Oct 1982
4357234 Inculet et al. Nov 1982
4363723 Knoll et al. Dec 1982
4374727 Takahashi et al. Feb 1983
4375718 Wadsworth et al. Mar 1983
4443515 Atlas Apr 1984
4455195 Kinsley Jun 1984
4455237 Kinsley Jun 1984
4507539 Sando et al. Mar 1985
4514289 Inculet Apr 1985
4547420 Krueger et al. Oct 1985
4555811 Shimalla Dec 1985
4588537 Klaase et al. May 1986
4592815 Nakao Jun 1986
4618524 Groitzsch et al. Oct 1986
4622259 McAmish et al. Nov 1986
4652282 Ohmori et al. Mar 1987
4652322 Lim Mar 1987
4657804 Mays et al. Apr 1987
4663220 Wisneski et al. May 1987
4670913 Morell et al. Jun 1987
4677017 DeAntonis et al. Jun 1987
4689241 Richart et al. Aug 1987
4699823 Kellenberger et al. Oct 1987
4707398 Boggs Nov 1987
4720415 VanderWielen et al. Jan 1988
4729371 Krueger et al. Mar 1988
4738772 Giesfeldt Apr 1988
4749348 Klaase et al. Jun 1988
4761326 Barnes et al. Aug 1988
4795668 Krueger et al. Jan 1989
4797201 Kuppers et al. Jan 1989
4818464 Lau Apr 1989
4863785 Berman et al. Sep 1989
4863983 Johnson et al. Sep 1989
4874399 Reed et al. Oct 1989
4874659 Ando et al. Oct 1989
4886527 Fottinger et al. Dec 1989
4917942 Winters Apr 1990
4920168 Nohr et al. Apr 1990
4948515 Okumura et al. Aug 1990
4948639 Brooker et al. Aug 1990
4960820 Hwo Oct 1990
4965122 Morman Oct 1990
4983677 Johnson et al. Jan 1991
5021501 Ohmori et al. Jun 1991
5035941 Blackburn Jul 1991
5051159 Togashi et al. Sep 1991
5057710 Nishiura et al. Oct 1991
5062158 Oka et al. Nov 1991
5110620 Tani et al. May 1992
5118942 Hamade Jun 1992
5149335 Kellenberger et al. Sep 1992
5165979 Watkins et al. Nov 1992
5169706 Collier, IV et al. Dec 1992
5173356 Eaton et al. Dec 1992
5178932 Perkins et al. Jan 1993
5183701 Jacobs et al. Feb 1993
5188885 Timmons et al. Feb 1993
5204174 Daponte et al. Apr 1993
5206061 Ando et al. Apr 1993
5213881 Timmons et al. May 1993
5213882 Sassa et al. May 1993
5226992 Morman Jul 1993
5230727 Pound et al. Jul 1993
5232770 Joseph Aug 1993
5238733 Joseph et al. Aug 1993
5244482 Hassenboehler, Jr. Sep 1993
5247072 Ning et al. Sep 1993
5256176 Matsuura et al. Oct 1993
5257982 Cohen et al. Nov 1993
5264276 McGregor et al. Nov 1993
5284703 Everhart et al. Feb 1994
5286326 Greve Feb 1994
5308674 Zafiroglu May 1994
5336545 Morman Aug 1994
5350620 Sundet et al. Sep 1994
5389202 Everhart et al. Feb 1995
5397413 Trimble et al. Mar 1995
5401446 Tsai et al. Mar 1995
5407581 Onodera et al. Apr 1995
5409766 Yuasa et al. Apr 1995
5411576 Jones et al. May 1995
5436066 Chen Jul 1995
5441550 Hassenboehler, Jr. Aug 1995
5443606 Hassenboehler, Jr. Aug 1995
5455108 Quincy et al. Oct 1995
5456972 Roth et al. Oct 1995
5472481 Jones et al Dec 1995
5486411 Hassenboehler, Jr. et al. Jan 1996
5491022 Smith Feb 1996
5493117 Tamaki et al. Feb 1996
5496507 Angadjivand et al. Mar 1996
5503745 Ogata et al. Apr 1996
Foreign Referenced Citations (8)
Number Date Country
1 188 452 Jun 1985 CAX
0 334 829 Sep 1989 EPX
0 337 662 Oct 1989 EPX
0 375 234 Jun 1990 EPX
0 391 725 Oct 1990 EPX
0 444 671 Sep 1991 EPX
0 462 574 Dec 1991 EPX
0 478 011 Apr 1992 EPX
Continuations (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 450043 May 1995