The present invention relates generally to a filtration system that utilizes an actuated flow control valve, as a means of controlling performance of filtration of the system, for filtering a liquid. More particularly, the present application involves a filtration system that utilizes a pair of set points, one being flow rate and the other pressure differential, to achieve a high capacity filtration rate with minimum filtration system fouling.
Industries such as food and beverage, oil and gas, pulp and paper, and waste water treatment utilize filtration technology. The filtration removes solids from the medium in which the particulates are carried. The filtration process may be accomplished with a single process and filter, or multiple different types of filtration using different filtration equipment can be used with the medium in order to achieve a desired removal of particulates. One such filtration system utilizes a spinning filter, sometimes called a hydroclone, that receives feedwater with particulates therein. A spinning flow pattern is developed within the hydroclone so that heavier solids within the feedwater are moved by centrifugal force to the inside wall of the hydroclone for removal, or down into a circulation loop for removal at another time.
In a self-cleaning hydroclone filter system, medium and lighter particulates engage a self-propelled cleaning unit that spins around a filter media or screen that filters out these particulates from the feedwater. Filtered water is then removed from the hydroclone and is moved downstream to a storage tank, subsequent filtration station, or anywhere else desired. The spinning filter unit can have one or more brushes that continuously wipe off the filter media as they spin around the filter media to clean it and help prevent it from being dogged or fouled. The particulates removed by this cross-flow portion of the hydroclone are likewise moved down into the circulation loop via the flow path established within the hydroclone, or disposed of from the system.
Although capable of filtering particulates from feedwater, such filters ultimately become clogged in that particles impinge themselves within the filter media thus reducing the system's filtering capacity. The flow within the filter may push particulates against the filter media causing them to become stuck within gaps of the filter media, and unable to be swept off by the spinning brush. Over time, the system must be shut off and the filter media removed and serviced in which the fouled filter media is cleaned.
In order to reduce fouling of the filter screen and downtime of the filter system, certain techniques have been established for running the filtration process. One such process utilizes the pressure differential within the hydroclone between the area inside the filter media and the area outside of the filter media. If this pressure differential is great, solids will be pushed into the Filter media and cause clogging or fouling of the filter media. A pressure differential set point may be established that is a safe pressure differential under which clogging or fouling will be minimized. A filtrate flow control valve set at a particular flow control rate is present at the exit of the filtered medium exiting the hydroclone. Once the pressure differential set point is reached, an automated valve on the effluent line is closed and a drain valve of the hydroclone is opened to cause particulates to exit the filtration system.
Although capable of removing particulates from the hydroclone before fouling of the filter media occurs, such a process must have the pressure differential set point at a level that is lower than a point at which fouling of the filter media occurs. This is because the system cannot react instantaneously to spikes in the pressure differential which would cause fouling to occur if the set point were located at or close to the pressure differential at which fouling actually occurs. The set point is thus located at a lower level to give the system time to reduce pressure through various means including closing the effluent valve once it appears the pressure differential is rising. This process sacrifices filtration capacity to achieve a reduction in filter media fouling and thus much less medium is filtered by the system per unit time. Further, although described as avoiding filter media fouling, it is to be understood that over time the filter media will in fact become fouled with particulates and will need to be serviced. The aforementioned process helps to reduce the amount of downtime in the system, but does not eliminate the occurrences of filter screen fouling. As such, there remains room for variation and improvement within the art.
A full and enabling disclosure of the present invention, including the best mode thereof, directed to one of ordinary skill in the art, is set forth more particularly in the remainder of the specification, which makes reference to the appended Figs. in which:
Repeat use of reference characters in the present specification and drawings is intended to represent the same or analogous features or elements of the invention.
Reference will now be made in detail to embodiments of the invention, one or more examples of which are illustrated in the drawings. Each example is provided by way of explanation of the invention, and not meant as a limitation of the invention. For example, features illustrated or described as part of one embodiment can be used with another embodiment to yield still a third embodiment. It is intended that the present invention include these and other modifications and variations.
It is to be understood that the ranges mentioned herein include all ranges located within the prescribed range. As such, all ranges mentioned herein include all sub-ranges included in the mentioned ranges. For instance, a range from 100-200 also includes ranges from 110-450, 170-190, and 153-462. Further, all limits mentioned herein include all other limits included in the mentioned limits. For instance, a limit of up to 7 also includes a limit of up to 5, up to 3, and up to 4.5.
The present invention provides for a filtration system 10 that may be used to separate substances from one another. For example, the filtration system 10 may be used to separate water from contaminants in a fluid that may be hydraulic fracturing flow back fluid. However, the filtration system 10 may be used in a variety of applications as a way to remove particulates from a medium. The system 10 employs an actuated flow control valve 12 that can open and close automatically in order to regulate a pressure differential present in a filter 14 of the system 10. The filtration system 10 may be arranged to regulate the pressure differential so that it does not exceed a particular set point. Still further, the filtration system 10 may also include a second set point that is the flow rate of the medium through the filter 14. The filtration system 10 may be set up so that both of these two set points are not exceeded. The actuated flow control valve 12 may allow the filtration system 10 to operate so that capacity of the filtration system 10 is increased resulting in a larger amount of filtered medium 34 to be produced and to minimize fouling of the filter media 18 that occurs through the impingement of particulates onto the filter media 18 within the filter 14.
The filtration system 10 includes a circulation loop 44 into which the medium from the medium source 30 is inserted. The circulation loop 44 has a circulation pump 26 that drives fluid through the circulation loop 44. The circulation pump 26 is in communication with the control panel 24 that obtains data from the circulation pump 26 and that in turn can control the operation of the circulation pump 26. Medium from the medium source 30 is inserted into the circulation loop 44 at a location 56 just before the circulation pump 26. Medium exiting the filter 14 merges with the medium supplied by the medium source 30 at location 56 and this combined stream is then subsequently supplied to the circulation pump 26. Inserting the medium from the medium source 30 at location 56 upstream of the circulation pump 26 may eliminate the arrangement in which medium is forced into the filtration system 10 by a pump.
Medium exiting the circulation pump 26 is introduced back into the filter 14 and medium within the filter 14 is subsequently pulled from the filter 14 back to location 56. The circulation loop 44 is thus driven by the circulation pump 26 and includes medium that has particulates within. These particulates are however kept out of the medium that is filtered by the filter 14 and that makes up the filtered medium 34. The particulates are in effect trapped within the circulation loop 44 as the filtration system 10 operates. The circulation loop 44 functions to clean the filter media 18 and to circulate suspended particulates in the medium.
The filter 14 is a component of the filtration system 10 that functions to remove particulates within the medium that is introduced into the filter 14. The filter 14 may be constructed in a variety of manners in accordance with different exemplary embodiments of the filtration system 10. In accordance with certain exemplary embodiments, the filter 14 is a TEQUATIC™ PLUS filter provided by The Dow Chemical Company having offices located at 2030 Dow Center, Midland, Mich., 48674, USA. This type of filter is sometimes referred to as a hydroclone filter. However, it is to be understood that the use of a hydroclone filter is only exemplary, and that other types of filters may be used as the filter 14. Further, although described as having a single filter 14, multiple numbers of filters 14 could be used in other exemplary embodiments. Medium entering the filter 14 via the circulation loop 44 is forced against a self-propelled filter unit and spins the self-propelled filter unit via the force of the medium flow. The self-propelled filter unit has one or more brushes that likewise spin. The brushes are arranged around filter media 18 of the filter 14 and function to clean the surfaces of the filter media 18 as they spin around the filter media 18. This brushing action sweeps off particulates that would otherwise accumulate on the filter media 18 and impede flow through the filter media and reduce filtering capacity.
A vortex flow pattern is established within the filter 14 and heavier solids within the medium being filtered are pushed outwards by centrifugal forces and tend to fall downwards within the filter by gravity. Lighter solids are generally removed by the cross-flow filtration as previously indicated and go either into the circulation loop 44 or can join the heavier solids towards the bottom of the filter 14. Particulates 32 made up of the heavier solids, and that may also include the lighter solids, flow out of the bottom of the filter 14 and past an outlet valve 48. In the embodiment illustrated, the outlet valve 48 is a ball valve 48 that is actuated by a motor 50. These components are in communication with the control panel 24. The filtration system 10 may open the ball valve 48 that in turn causes the particulates 32 to flow out of the filter 14, through the ball valve 48, and then into a collection chamber, another filtration sub-system, or anywhere else desired. The particulates 32 are sometimes referred to as concentrate 32 and represent medium into which a larger amount of particulates are present than the medium that is known as effluent 34 or filtered medium 34 that contains fewer or no particulates therein.
The filtration system 10 also includes a pressure differential sensor 16 that measures the pressure difference between two locations 20, 22 associated with the filter 14. Location 20 is a point within the filter 14 located outside of the filter media 18 such that the medium at location 20 is not filtered. Location 22 is a point inside the filter media 18 and is the pressure of medium that has been filtered by the filter media 18. Within the filter 14, medium is forced through the filter media 18 and then subsequently out of the filter 14 to the filtered medium 34. In order to move medium through the filter media 18 and out of the filter 14, there must be a pressure differential between locations 22 and 20 so that pressure is higher at location 20 than at location 22 to in turn cause the medium to flow through the filter media 18 and out of the filter 14.
The pressure differential sensor 16 may sense the pressure at locations 20 and 22 and can convert these readings to a pressure differential, or can submit this information to the control panel 24 that in turn receives data from the pressure differential sensor 16 and does the conversion to arrive at a pressure differential. Regardless of what component performs the calculation, the filtration system 10 will be provided with a pressure differential within the filter 14 that can be used in a control process of the filtration system 10. Although described as acquiring a pressure differential within the filter 14 for control of the filtration system 10, it is to be understood that the pressure differential sensor 16 can be arranged to measure the pressure differential at other portions in the system to achieve control in other exemplary embodiments. For example, the pressure differential sensor 16 may measure pressure differences in the circulation loop 44, the filtered medium 34 exit line out of the filter 14, or between the location 56 and the medium source 30 in other embodiments.
The filtration system 10 may also include a flow meter 38 that measures flow rate of the filtered medium 34 exiting the filter 14. A flow meter transmitter 40 can be incorporated into the flow meter 38 or otherwise associated with the flow meter 38 in order to relay flow rate information of the filtered medium 34 to the control panel 24.
An actuated flow control valve 12 may be located downstream of the flow meter 38 such that the flow meter 38 is located between the filtered medium 34 exit of the filter 14 and the actuated flow control valve 12. The flow control valve 12 may include a motor 42 that functions to open and close the flow control valve 12. Information from the actuated flow control valve 12 and motor 42 can be sent to the control panel 24, and the control panel 24 can be used to automatically control the functioning of the motor 42 and the actuated flow control valve 12. The actuated flow control valve 12 can be opened and closed through a range of degrees so that a desired flow capacity can be established through the actuated flow control valve 12. In effect, the actuated flow control valve 12 is not an open/closed only valve, but can be opened through a range of degrees so that it is fully closed, minimally opened, opened halfway, opened almost all the way, fully opened, etc. The actuated flow control valve 12 can be opened 10%, 20%, 30%, 60%, 80%, or up to 100% in accordance with various exemplary embodiments. Although any type of actuated flow control valve can be used, the filtration system 10 may include an actuated flow control valve 12 that may be a HAYWARD® actuated flow control valve model number EPM3-120 sold by Hayward Industries whose offices are located at 620 Division Street, Elizabeth, N.J., 07201, USA.
Filtered medium 34 flowing past the actuated flow control valve 12 may be moved into a storage container, to a subsequent downstream filtering subsystem, or may be used as a clean source of fluid if the filtration system 10 is the only or is the final stage of a filtering process. The filtered medium 34 is sometimes referred to as effluent and may contain some particulates although not as much as before being introduced into the circulation loop 44. In some embodiments of the filtration system 10, there is no open only/closed only valve located in the line between the outlet of the filter 14 for the filtered medium 34 and the exit of the filtered medium 34 from the filtration system 10.
The control panel 24 may have user input and output mechanisms, displays, and ports. The control panel 24 may include a microprocessor or other computer that can be programmed to control the operation of the filtration system 10. Although shown in communication with various components, it is to be understood that the control panel 24 may be in communication with any or all of the components of the filtration system 10 in accordance with other exemplary embodiments. The filtration system 10 can be controlled automatically by the control panel 24, or user input may be received so that the filtration system 10 is manually controlled.
The actuated flow control valve 12 can be initially closed when the system 10 is at rest. This closure will prevent filtered medium 34 from exiting the system 10 and will in effect prevent filtration of the medium 34 in the filter 14. At start up, the circulation pump 26 can be started and medium will assume circulation flow through the circulation loop 44 when the system 10 is pressurized. The ball valve 48 may be closed to prevent particulates 32 from leaving the filter 14 and the system 10 because there is no filtration being done at start up. The control panel 24 may include an automatic program that slowly opens the actuated flow control valve 12 from a closed position to an open position. The opening may be done in a slow manner to ensure that strain is not imparted onto the components of the filtration system 10. A controlled opening of the actuated flow control valve 12 will in turn cause medium to flow from the medium source 30 because the only place the medium from the medium source 30 can go into the system 10 is via replacement of filtered medium 34 that is sent out of the system 10.
After start up, medium from the medium source 30 will enter the circulation loop 44 at location 56 and medium will be filtered by the filter 14 and filtered medium 34 will exit the system 10 through the actuated flow control valve 12.
The first set point 60 is selected so that particulates will not be likely to impinge upon and foul the filter media 18, which can include a filter screen. The velocity of flow of the medium onto the filter media 18 will be limited at this pressure differential so that particulates do not jamb into and otherwise clog the filter media 18, but yet sufficient velocity is present to allow a significant amount of flow through the filter media 18 so that the filtration system 10 has a large capacity of filtration. At point in time 57 the system 10 will continue to monitor the pressure differential and will make automatic adjustments of the actuated flow control valve 12 to open it a bit, or close it a bit, as is needed in order to maintain the pressure differential at the first set point 60 of 0.85. When maintaining the first set point 60, the filtration of the medium may still occur and a purge of the filter 14 may not occur when maintaining the first set point 60.
After filtering for a certain amount of time, the filtration system 10 may enter a purge stage in which the particulates that have built up within the filter 14 and that are pushed through the circulation loop 44 are removed. This purge is done for preventative maintenance in the system 10 to clear particulates from the filter 14. At time 58 the actuated flow control valve 12 may be closed and the ball valve 48 can be opened. This will cause a dumping of particulates out of the filter 14 and through the ball valve 48 to the particulates 32 tank or other location. As shown in
The plot shown in
The filtration system 10 may include a safety shut off mechanism as can be illustrated with reference to
After start up, the filtration system 10 operates as previously described in that the actuated flow control valve 12 opens and closes to maintain the pressure differential at the first set point of 0.85. If the medium source 30 begins providing medium that has large particulates or large amounts of particulates, the filter 14 may become clogged with these larger amounts of particulates thus reducing flow through the filter media 18 and subsequently reducing the amount of filtered medium 34 produced. The actuated flow control valve 12 may not be capable of regulating the pressure differential at this point in time which is designated as time 62. The pressure differential may begin to rise past the first set point 60 to the safety shut off pressure differential 66 that is shown at time 64. In some embodiments, once the safety shut off pressure differential 66 is reached, the filtration system 10 shuts down all operation in order to prevent damage to the system 10 or to prevent fouling of the filter media 18. In this regard, the actuated flow control valve 12 may be closed or the motor 42 stopped, the circulation pump 26 may be stopped, and/or the optional influent pump 36 may be stopped. In some embodiments, the filtration system 10 may monitor the pressure differential to determine if the safety shut off pressure differential 66 is reached for a specific amount of time, such as 0.3 seconds. Stopping of the system 10 may be implemented once the safety shut off pressure differential 66 has been reached for this particular amount of time.
Stopping of the system 10 is shown at time 64 in which the pressure differential drops back to zero. The filtration system 10 may then again be started and run to the first set point 60 until a purge of particulates 32 is desired. Again, this purge may simply be preventative maintenance. In some arrangements of the filtration system 10, when the system 10 shuts down due to the safety shut off pressure differential 66 being reached the ball valve 48 opens and the particulates 32 are removed from the filter 14 while the pumps 26 and 36 are stopped and when the actuated flow control valve 12 is stopped.
Although described as going over the first set point 60 at time 62 and reaching the safety shut off pressure differential 66 at time 64, it may be the case that the filtration system 10 functions to reduce the pressure differential before reaching the safety shut off pressure differential 66 and stopping. In this regard, once the pressure differential moves into the area between the first set point 60 and the safety shut off pressure differential 66, the actuated flow control valve 12 can close to cause the pressure differential to drop down to the first set point 60. If the first set point 60 is maintained, then the filtration system 10 may continue to function without having to be stopped even though the pressure differential moved above the first set point 60. As such, the first set point 60 may be at a pressure differential that is desired to be maintained, but the system does not stop if the pressure differential exceeds the first set point 60.
There may be a minimum set point established in certain embodiments. This may come into play at times in which the first set point 60 is exceeded, but the safety shut off pressure differential 66 is not reached or not reached for the sufficient amount of time as discussed. As the actuated flow control valve 12 closes to bring the pressure differential down to the level of the first set point 60, the flow rate may be significantly decreased due to this adjustment. If the flow rate reaches the minimum set point (for example 20 gpm), or reaches the minimum set point for a set amount of time, the system 10 will then conduct a purge in which the actuated flow control valve 12 closes and particulates 32 are flushed from the filter 14 through the outlet valve 48. The system 10 will not stop once the minimum set point is reached, but instead the purge will occur.
In other embodiments the filtration system 10 may have both the first set point 60 and a second set point 74. The filtration system 10 may operate so that after start up, the filtration system 10 encounters either the first set point 60 or the second set point 74. Once one of the set points 60 or 74 is encountered, the filtration system 10 maintains the functioning of the filtration so that the first encountered set point 60 or 74 is maintained. The first set point 60 may be a pressure differential as measured by the pressure differential sensor 16 and as previously discussed. The second set point 74 may be a flow rate of the filtered medium 34 as measured by the flow meter 38 which represents the amount of filtered medium 34 that is flowing out of the filter 14. This second set point 74 may be 40 gpm, 60, gpm, 70 gpm, 80 gpm, or up to 200 gpm in accordance with various exemplary embodiments. It is to be understood that the actual flow rates immediately called out are only exemplary and that the second set point 74 could be any flow rate in accordance with various exemplary embodiments. The system 10 may be operated so that filtration of the medium still occurs when the second set point 74 is maintained and so that a purge of the filter 14 does not occur when the second set point 74 is exceeded or maintained.
When the system 10 has both the first and second set points 60 and 74, it may also have the minimum set point so that if the minimum set point is reached or if the flow rate goes below the minimum set point a purge occurs. The system 10 may not shut down if the minimum set point is reached. The minimum set point may be a flow rate that is lower than the flow rate of the second set point 74.
The opening and closing of the actuated flow control valve 12 may be used to regulate the filtration system 10 so that the filtration system 10 operates at either the first set point 60 or the second set point 74. With reference to
At time 70 the pressure differential in the system 10 begins to rise so that it reaches the first set point 60 of 085. The actuated flow control valve 12 will then make adjustments in order to maintain the pressure differential at the first set point 60 of 0.85, and to maintain the flow rate at the second set point 74 of 80 gpm. In some cases, at time 70 the flow rate may drop below 80 gpm at which time the actuated flow control valve 12 will continue to open until reaching the first set point 60 of 0.85. The system 10 will then maintain the pressure differential at the first set point 60 of 0.85, and the flow rate may be less than 80 gpm so that the second set point 74 is not reached when the system 10 is running between times 70 and 72. As such, the system 10 may be set up so that it runs at the first set point 60 for some amount of time but the second set point 74 is not reached, and may be set up to run for a length of time in which the second set point 74 is reached but not the first set point 60.
After a specific amount of time running at the first set point 60, the system at time 72 may conduct a purge of the particulates 32 as previously discussed. The flow rate and pressure differential will drop to zero at time 72, and then subsequently the system 10 may be restarted to again filter the medium. The system 10 may at start-up be arranged to slowly open the actuated flow control valve 12 from a fully closed position until the system 10 reaches either the first set point 60 or the second set point 74, whichever one comes first. The opening of the actuated flow control valve 12 may stop at that point and then may close, open, or remain at the same place in order to maintain the system 10 at the first encountered set point 60 or 74. The actuated flow control valve 12 may thus control the pressure differential in the system 10 and the flow rate in the system 10. The actuated flow control valve 12 can be automatically controlled by the microprocessor or computer contained with the control panel 24. The actuated flow control valve 12 may in some embodiments be provided so that it is not manually adjustable. Further, the actuated flow control valve 12 may be provided so that it is not an open or closed only valve, but one that is capable of being open, closed, and various degrees in between so that it can be partially opened and partially closed.
The filtration system 10 may be set up so that a minimum flow rate can be established. The flow rate can be measured by the flow meter 38, and the pressure differential measured between locations 20 and 22 can be monitored and adjusted via the operation of the actuated flow control valve 12. If the flow as measured by the flow meter 38 is reduced to or below a minimum, predetermined rate, then the system 10 will initiate a purge function to remove collected solids from the circulation loop 44 as previously discussed. The minimum, predetermined rate may be less than the second set point 74.
The filtration system 10 can be provided as a skid mounted system in which the various components 14, 16, 38, 12, 44 and 48 are mounted onto a skid or other frame. The medium source 30, the filtered medium outlet 34, and the particulates 32 may not be located on the skid or frame, but may be hooked up to lines on the skid or frame in order to supply and remove fluids and particulates to and from the filtration system 10 that is on the skid or frame. Another arrangement of the filtration system 10 is shown with reference to
As shown in
The flow meter 38 is shown in communication with the control panel 24, and a flow meter transmitter 40 is absent. The flow meter 38 may include the flow meter transmitter 40, or the flow meter transmitter 40 could be a separate component in other exemplary embodiments that functions to transmit flow data from the flow meter 38 to the control panel 24. The arrangement of the concentrate 32 line leaving the filter 14 is somewhat different in the
The arrangements and components disclosed in the embodiment of the filtration system 10 shown in
As such, the system 10 may be run so that the first and second set points 60 and 74 are maintained in that they are not exceeded or met. This maintaining is made by the automatic adjustment of the actuated flow control valve 12 by the control panel 24 upon obtaining data on the system 10. This maintaining may occur while filtration of the medium takes place such that filtered medium 34 is still being produced while the maintaining of the first and second set points 60 and 74 takes place. This maintaining may be arranged so that a purge of the system 10 does not take place, but rather filtering of the medium occurs while the first and second set points 60, 74 are maintained. The system 10 will in effect monitor both the first and second set points 60 and 74 and make automatic adjustments (that is no human being has to open or close a valve or otherwise adjust a valve) so that the set points 60, 74 are not exceeded.
The control panel 24 may be a computer, a microprocessor, or a combination of various components that function to obtain data from the system 10 and process this data and in turn instruct various components of the system 10 to start up, shut down, or modify their operational state. The control panel 24 can send a first signal to a component of the system 10, for example the actuated flow control valve 12, to cause the component to adjust its operation in order to maintain the first set point 60 from being exceeded. The control panel 24 can send a second signal to a component of the system 10, for example the actuated flow control valve 12, to cause the component to adjust its operation to maintain the second set point 74 from being exceeded.
It is to be understood that certain equipment as described herein, such as the ball valve 48, may include or be substituted for other types of valves that can serve a similar purpose. The ball valve 48 may be substituted for, or may include, a butterfly valve, a gate valve, or any other type of valve capable of allowing and preventing flow therethrough. Also, the other valves described herein, such as the butterfly valves 52 and 54 may include or be substituted with other valves that can perform similar functions such as a ball valve or gate valve. Similarly, the pressure differential sensor 16 can refer to a single unit designed to sense pressure between two points and return a value, or to two individual pressure sensing units that can return their values to a different piece of equipment such as a programmable logic controller where the difference in pressure between the two units is calculated.
While the present invention has been described in connection with certain preferred embodiments, it is to be understood that the subject matter encompassed by way of the present invention is not to be limited to those specific embodiments. On the contrary, it is intended for the subject matter of the invention to include all alternatives, modifications and equivalents as can be included within the spirit and scope of the following claims.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4282105 | Crowe | Aug 1981 | A |
4929363 | Barzuza | May 1990 | A |
5006248 | Anderson | Apr 1991 | A |
5028568 | Anderson | Jul 1991 | A |
5035784 | Anderson | Jul 1991 | A |
5059346 | Spanbel | Oct 1991 | A |
5096475 | Anderson | Mar 1992 | A |
5104539 | Anderson | Apr 1992 | A |
5128064 | Spanbel | Jul 1992 | A |
5137607 | Anderson | Aug 1992 | A |
5169576 | Anderson | Dec 1992 | A |
5187953 | Mount | Feb 1993 | A |
5194200 | Anderson | Mar 1993 | A |
5208121 | Yahnke | May 1993 | A |
5208190 | Anderson | May 1993 | A |
5215943 | Anderson | Jun 1993 | A |
5227342 | Anderson | Jul 1993 | A |
5268101 | Anderson | Dec 1993 | A |
5269926 | Webster | Dec 1993 | A |
5308454 | Anderson | May 1994 | A |
5342431 | Anderson | Aug 1994 | A |
5342709 | Yahnke | Aug 1994 | A |
5439624 | Anderson | Aug 1995 | A |
5484536 | Yamaguchi et al. | Jan 1996 | A |
5487774 | Peterson | Jan 1996 | A |
5552351 | Anderson | Sep 1996 | A |
5610109 | Anderson | Mar 1997 | A |
5639412 | Anderson | Jun 1997 | A |
5712037 | Anderson | Jan 1998 | A |
5963417 | Anderson | Oct 1999 | A |
6251294 | Davis | Jun 2001 | B1 |
6285816 | Anderson | Sep 2001 | B1 |
7540995 | Hatch | Jun 2009 | B2 |
7632416 | Levitt | Dec 2009 | B2 |
7896169 | Levitt | Mar 2011 | B2 |
8116067 | Anderson | Feb 2012 | B2 |
8216445 | Anderson | Jul 2012 | B2 |
20030095894 | Umezawa et al. | May 2003 | A1 |
20040191633 | Johnson | Sep 2004 | A1 |
20070039900 | Levitt | Feb 2007 | A1 |
20070045168 | Levitt | Mar 2007 | A1 |
20070102359 | Lombardi et al. | May 2007 | A1 |
20090050572 | McGuire et al. | Feb 2009 | A1 |
20090314711 | Barry | Dec 2009 | A1 |
20100015429 | Anderson | Jan 2010 | A1 |
20100237013 | Burke et al. | Sep 2010 | A1 |
20110120959 | Levitt | May 2011 | A1 |
20110180423 | Barry | Jul 2011 | A1 |
20110257788 | Wiemers et al. | Oct 2011 | A1 |
20120145609 | Caffell | Jun 2012 | A1 |
20130248450 | Kenley et al. | Sep 2013 | A1 |
20140048470 | Lalli | Feb 2014 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
WO1983001969 | Jun 1983 | WO |
Entry |
---|
International Searching Authority; International Search Report and Written Opinion of the International Searching Authority; International Application No. PCT/US16/42226; Patent Cooperation Treaty; pp. 1-9; publisher United States International Searching Authority; Published Alexandria, Virginia, US; copyright and mailing date Oct. 4, 2016; copy enclosed (9 pages). |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20170021368 A1 | Jan 2017 | US |