Patent Application
20190042751
A device firmware is a set of instructions embedded in the device that facilitate controlling, monitoring, and so forth, the device and/or or components of the device. In various examples, the device firmware may be held in a non-volatile memory and may rarely, if ever, be changed during the life cycle of the device (depending on the type of device). In some devices, the firmware may be the primary enabler of device functionality. In other devices, the firmware may act as an interface between device hardware and applications installed on the device. Devices that include various types of firmware may include, for example, personal computers, printers, other peripherals, appliances, remote controls, digital watches, cellular phones, digital cameras, and so forth.
The present application may be more fully appreciated in connection with the following detailed description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
Devices, methods, and equivalents associated with firmware encryption are described. As discussed above, device firmware facilitates control, monitoring, and so forth of device functionality. In some cases, it may be desirable to activate, release, or otherwise modify a device functionality after a certain event in a life cycle of a device. By way of illustration, consider a device feature that is not ready to be activated at a release date of the device, but uses specialized firmware. Because updating firmware of the device may be difficult (e.g., if firmware is embedded in read only memory), it may be desirable to embed the specialized firmware in the device in a manner that allows later activation of the firmware. In other examples, device security may depend in part on security of the device firmware, and changing the device firmware periodically may make it more difficulty to attack the device. Instead of updating the firmware, it may be possible to embed updated security measures in the firmware that can be activated periodically over time. In some situations, it may be desirable to encrypt these modules to keep their behavior undiscoverable and/or unknown prior to their decryption. Additionally, encrypting modules may also facilitate reducing the number of persons with the ability to access the modules prior to the production and/or release of the devices into which the modules are embedded.
Consequently, device firmware may include firmware that controls base device functionality, as well as a series of encrypted firmware modules that otherwise update, modify, enhance, disable, replace, add to, and so forth, the base device functionality. The different encrypted firmware modules may be encrypted using different encryption keys. When a decryption module, also embedded in the device firmware, receives encryption keys, respective encrypted firmware modules may be decrypted and activated. This may allow updating device functionality, activating device functionality, updating device security, and so forth.
Thus, base module 110 may be firmware that controls operations of a device into which device firmware 100 is inserted. In some examples, for less sophisticated devices, the firmware may be all that is used to control operation of a device into which device firmware 100 is inserted. By way of illustration, a remote control may primarily operate based on firmware that causes specific signals to be transmitted by the remote upon certain presses of buttons on the remote. A device receiving the signals may do more work, possibly involving firmware, hardware, software, and so forth, to accomplish a task based on the signal received from the remote.
In other examples, base modules 110 may operate as an interface between applications and device functions 180. In examples where device firmware 100 is embedded in a more sophisticated device such as a personal computer or mobile device, many of the applications interfacing with base module 110 may be executing on the device in which device firmware 100 resides. In other examples, base module 110 may interface with applications external to the device in which device firmware 100 is embedded. Other examples of roles performed by base module 110 in controlling device functions 180 may also be possible.
Device firmware 100 also contains a set of encrypted modules including a first encrypted module 120 and a second encrypted module 130. Though two encrypted modules are illustrated, device firmware 100 may include numerous encrypted modules that perform a variety of functions when activated. The encrypted modules may be embedded into device firmware 100 at the same time as base module 110 with the intent that the encrypted modules be activated independent from base module 110. In various examples described herein, the encrypted modules may be configured such that they do not operate without being decrypted independently. By way of illustration, some devices employ firmware encryption techniques to hinder malicious attacks against the device. In examples described herein, the encrypted modules may operate differently than these firmware encryption techniques because they are decrypted separately than the remainder of the firmware (e.g., base module 110). This allows the decrypted modules to, for example, reside inactive in firmware until activated by being decrypted. This may, for example, facilitate device security, allow late delivery of functionality to the device, and so forth.
Consequently, device firmware 100 may contain a decryption module 140 for the purpose of decrypting the encrypted modules. Decryption module 140, upon obtaining a decryption key from a key provider 199, may decrypt an encrypted module to which the decryption key corresponds. Upon decryption of this encrypted module, the encrypted module may activate. Key provider 199 may be, for example, built into a device into which device firmware 100 is embedded. In this example, key provider 199 may be a secure application specific integrated circuit. In other examples, key provider 199 may be external to the device into which device firmware 100 is embedded. When this device is network connected, key provider 199 may be a manufacturer or other type of service provider for the device. Other key providers may include, for example, users, other devices similar to and/or connected to the device in which device firmware 100 is embedded, trusted third parties, and so forth. Whether key provider 199 is internal or external to the device may depend on, for example, security concerns, a likelihood device firmware 100 will have access to a network connection, how critical the encrypted modules will be to device functionality, and so forth. By way of illustration, for certain products, it may be undesirable to mandate that the product be periodically connected to a network. In these examples, the key provider may reside within products. For other devices, where device security is important, it may be possible to remotely provide decryption keys for encrypted modules via a network.
In some examples, decrypted modules may modify existing device functions 180. In this example first encrypted module 120 is indicated as being affecting an existing device function 180. In various examples, first encrypted module 120 may modify, upgrade, replace, deactivate, and so forth an existing device function 180 when first encrypted module 120 is decrypted and activated. By way of illustration, a printer may use a variety of print consumables. Some of the print consumables may be containers of print material (e.g., ink, toner, a 3D print material). To hinder consumption of counterfeit print containers by the printer, the printer may authenticate print containers. Thus, encrypted modules may be embedded in the firmware of the printer that use a variety of authentication techniques over time. This may cause the printer to obtain changing credentials from print containers over time, making it more difficult to manufacture counterfeit print containers that keep up with the changing credentials. Embedding the encrypted modules in the firmware of the printer may allow the printer to automatically adjust authentication techniques over time, without requiring a firmware update to be received over a network connection or installed by a user. That the encrypted modules are not received or installed after product distribution may be additionally valuable because their activation can be made non-optional. While a user could opt not to install a firmware update, firmware modules that are capable of being automatically decrypted upon receiving a decryption key may facilitate managing future behavior of a product to that controls behavior of the device without user interaction. This may include for example, disabling features no longer under contract, enhancing security, and so forth.
In other examples, decrypted modules may add additional functionality 185 to a device into which device firmware 100 is embedded. By way of illustration, a fitness wearable may be designed with a GPS functionality that is not quite ready at the release of the wearable. In this example, the firmware may be ready, but the applications that use the firmware may be finished after users have begun using the wearable. Consequently, firmware associated with the GPS functionality may be disabled by encrypting the firmware until an appropriate decryption key is received by the wearable. This may allow the GPS functionality to be added without updating the firmware after release of the wearable. Using an encrypted module instead of merely disabling the feature may allow the code to remain undiscoverable, thereby hindering undesired activation by an enterprising user. This may allow the device manufacturer to control when the additional functionality is activated and ensure they have an initial opportunity to provide the functionality to the customer.
In various examples, decryption keys may be provided by key provider 199 to decryption module 140 on a set schedule. The schedule may be defined prior to release of the device into which device firmware 100 is embedded. In some examples, the set schedule may be based on specific dates, passage of time following activation of the device into which device firmware 100 is embedded, and so forth. In other examples, the set schedule may be based on usage of the device into which device firmware 100 is embedded, consumption of components or supplies by the device, and so forth. Releasing a key based on a usage or consumption based scenario may facilitate, for example, maintaining a device into which device firmware 100 is embedded, rewarding a user of the device, and so forth. In various examples, the criteria and/or schedule for releasing decryption keys may be protected from discovery or alteration using embedded security hardware, encryption and/or signing technologies, and so forth.
In other examples, the decryption keys may be provided without a set schedule. For example, key provider 199 may provide a decryption key to decryption module 140 to decrypt second encrypted module to modify a device function 180 or activate additional functionality 185 after key provider 199 receives a payment from a user. In a similar example, a user may act as key provider 199 themselves after obtaining a key. Examples where keys are provided without a known schedule may be appropriate to encourage behavior from a user, allow trial functionality of device features, release functionality to a user on a subscription basis, and so forth.
In addition to features discussed above, firmware encryption may facilitate enhanced organizational control over information related to development of devices. During the process of manufacturing devices, many individuals may have access to device firmware including developers, manufacturers, device testers, and so forth. Each additional person with access to device firmware may pose an additional risk of leaking important information to competitors, counterfeiters, and/or other individuals with malicious intent (e.g., hackers). By way of illustration, printer manufacturers often begin seeing counterfeit supplies appear on the market within weeks of a product release, a feat that may only be achievable with aid of leaked information. Encrypting firmware may allow an organization to restrict knowledge regarding device behaviors to a limited number of individuals, thereby reducing a risk of leaking valuable corporate information. To illustrate, device behavior could be changed on launch day of a product by triggering decryption of an encrypted firmware module, thereby reducing the value certain information obtained prior to the launch day.
To further achieve the goal of reducing access to firmware and/or device functionality prior to its activation, various components of device firmware 100 and/or the device into which device firmware 100 is embedded may be generated and or installed into the device using secure manufacturing processes. These manufacturing processes may, for example, programmatically manipulate firmware modules so that modules in separate devices are made up of differing instructions that cause similar results. In other examples, release schedules, authentication materials, and so forth may be manipulated and or otherwise securely embedded into the device via its components (e.g., a secure ASIC that releases encryption keys), components of device firmware 100, and so forth.
It is appreciated that, in the following description, numerous specific details are set forth to provide a thorough understanding of the examples. However, it is appreciated that the examples may be practiced without limitation to these specific details. In other instances, methods and structures may not be described in detail to avoid unnecessarily obscuring the description of the examples. Also, the examples may be used in combination with each other.
“Module”, as used herein, includes but is not limited to instructions stored on a computer-readable medium or in execution on a machine that perform a function(s) or an action(s), and/or to cause a function or action from another module, method, and/or system. Where multiple logical modules are described, it may be possible to incorporate the multiple logical modules into one logical module. Similarly, where a single logical module is described, it may be possible to distribute that single logical module between multiple logical modules.
Device firmware 210 also includes a first encrypted module 230. The first encrypted module may be inactive until decrypted. This may, for example, hinder undesired analysis of the first encrypted module prior to its activation, prevent early use of a functionality associated with the first encrypted module, and so forth. The first encrypted module may modify a first function of device 200. As with the base function controlled by base module 220, the first function may be one of numerous device functions 250 performed by device 200. Modifying the first function may include, for example, activating the first function, replacing executable instructions associated with the first function, changing a way the first function is performed, changing a component of device 200 performing the first function, deactivating the first function, and so forth. When activating a device function 250, first encrypted module 230 may provide executable instructions to device 200 that cause device 200 to perform the first function. In various examples, decryption of first encrypted module 220 and modifications to the first function, including activation of the first function, may occur during operation of device 200. Thus, a reset or power cycle of device 200 may be unnecessary to decrypt and execute first encrypted module 230.
In some examples, the base function and the first function may be the same function. Consequently, the first encrypted module may modify the base function. In some examples, once decrypted, first encrypted module 230 may prevent further operation of base module 220, thereby causing first encrypted module 230 to replace base module 220 during operation of device 200.
Device firmware 210 also includes a decryption module 240. First decryption module 240 may decrypt first encrypted module 230 using a first encryption key. The encryption key may be received from, for example, another component of device 200, an external device via a network connection, an external device over a direct connection, a user input to device 200, and so forth. In some examples, the encryption key may be obtained from multiple sources and assembled by decryption module 240.
Device firmware 310 also includes a second encrypted module 335. Second encrypted module 335 may modify a second function of device 300. In some examples, the second function of device 300 may be one of the numerous device functions 350 performed by device 300, and may be the same function as a base function controlled by base module 320 and/or a first function affected by first encrypted module 330. Second encrypted module 335 may be inactive until decrypted by decryption module 340. Decryption module 340 may use a second encryption key to decrypt second encrypted module 335.
Device 300 also includes an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC) 360. ASIC 360 may securely store encryption keys including a first encryption key used to decrypt first encrypted module 330 and the second encryption key. The encryption keys stored in ASIC 360 may be periodically provided by ASIC 360 to decryption module 340 causing decryption module 340 to decrypt corresponding encryption modules of device firmware 310.
Though two encrypted modules are illustrated, device 300 may include numerous encrypted modules. Each encrypted module may have a corresponding decryption key that causes decryption module 340 to decrypt and activate respective encrypted modules. These encrypted modules may be installed in device 300 to reduce scenarios requiring updating firmware of device 300, but still allowing updates to the device firmware. Further, as the updates are encrypted, it may be difficult for a person attempting to maliciously affect device 300 to identify countermeasures built into encrypted modules before the encrypted modules are activated.
Method 400 includes receiving a first decryption key at 410. The decryption key may be received in the firmware of a device. The decryption key may be associated with a first encrypted module. The first encrypted module may be embedded in the firmware of the device. The first encrypted module may modify a function of the device. Modifying a function of a device may include, for example, activating the function, disabling the function, changing how the function operates, and so forth.
Method 400 also includes decrypting the first encrypted module at 420. The first encrypted module may be decrypted using the first decryption key. Method 400 also includes controlling execution of the first encrypted module at 430. Execution of the first encrypted module may occur after completing decryption of the first encrypted module. Consequently, method 400 may illustrate how a device may activate an encrypted module embedded within the device. This may allow the device to, for example, securely update itself without an external source providing an updated firmware image.
Method 500 also includes receiving a second decryption key at 540. The second decryption key may be associated with a second encrypted module. The second encrypted module may be embedded in the firmware of the device.
Method 500 also includes decrypting the second encrypted module using the second encryption key at 550. The second encrypted module may be decrypted using the second decryption key. Method 500 also includes controlling execution of the second encrypted module at 560. The second encrypted module may be executed upon completing decryption of the second encrypted module.
Method 600 also includes embedding a decryption module in the firmware of the device at 620. The decryption module may receive decryption keys associated with encrypted modules. The decryption module may use the decryption keys to decrypt corresponding encrypted modules. The decryption module may also control execution of the decrypted modules. In some examples, upon decryption of a member of the series of encrypted modules, a previous member of the series of encrypted modules may be deactivated. In other examples, decrypted modules may remain functional over the remaining life cycle of the device.
Method 600 also includes controlling delivery of the decryption keys to the decryption module at 630. In some examples, controlling delivery of the decryption keys may be achieved by embedding a secure delivery vector into the device. Consequently, the secure delivery vector may provide the decryption keys to the decryption module in association with the set schedule. In other examples, delivery of the decryption keys may occur by providing the keys to the device over a network, providing the keys to a user who inputs the keys into the device, and so forth.
In various examples, components embedded into the device during their respective actions may be embedded during manufacturing of the device using a secure process. The secure process may facilitate updating and/or modifying the components between their design and when the components are embedded into the device in a manner that facilitates reducing access to specific release details of the components. By way of illustration, during design, a placeholder release date may be used that is modified prior to manufacturing of the device by an administrator based on a confidential planned release schedule for the feature. In other examples, embedding components into the device using a secure process may facilitate modifying authentication materials, and so forth.
The instructions may also be presented to device 700 as data 750 and/or process 760 that are temporarily stored in memory 720 and then executed by processor 710. The processor 710 may be a variety of processors including dual microprocessor and other multi-processor architectures. Memory 720 may include non-volatile memory (e.g., read only memory) and/or volatile memory (e.g., random access memory). Memory 720 may also be, for example, a magnetic disk drive, a solid state disk drive, a floppy disk drive, a tape drive, a flash memory card, an optical disk, and so on. Thus, memory 720 may store process 760 and/or data 750. Device 700 may also be associated with other devices including other computers, devices, peripherals, and so forth in numerous configurations (not shown).
It is appreciated that the previous description of the disclosed examples is provided to enable any person skilled in the art to make or use the present disclosure. Various modifications to these examples will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art, and the generic principles defined herein may be applied to other examples without departing from the spirit or scope of the disclosure. Thus, the present disclosure is not intended to be limited to the examples shown herein but is to be accorded the widest scope consistent with the principles and novel features disclosed herein.
The subject matter of this application is related to that of copending patent application Ser. No. ______ filed concurrently herewith by M. Nelson et al. for PRINTER FIRMWARE ENCRYPTION (Atty. Docket No. 84460072) and assigned to a common assignee. The disclosure of application Ser. No. ______ is incorporated herein by reference. The matter of this application is related to that of copending patent application Ser. No. ______ filed concurrently herewith by M. Nelson et al. for PRINTER AUTHENTICATION (Atty. Docket No. 84460076) and assigned to a common assignee. The disclosure of application Ser. No. ______ is incorporated herein by reference.
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/US2016/034631 | 5/27/2016 | WO | 00 |
