Formation testing instrument having extensible housing

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6655458
  • Patent Number
    6,655,458
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, November 6, 2001
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, December 2, 2003
    20 years ago
Abstract
A well logging instrument is disclosed which includes a housing operatively coupled to a well logging conveyance and movable within the wellbore. The housing has therein a formation testing system and an axial extension mechanism. The axial extension mechanism controllably extends and retracts to allow the formation testing system to perform tests and take samples in an axially fixed position in the wellbore while the housing moves through the wellbore.
Description




CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS




Not applicable.




STATEMENT REGARDING FEDERALLY SPONSORED RESEARCH OR DEVELOPMENT




Not applicable.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The invention relates generally to the field of wellbore testing and sample taking instruments. More particularly, the invention relates to designs for such instruments which reduce a possibility of the instrument and/or conveyance device becoming stuck in a wellbore.




2. Background Art




When drilling a wellbore through earth formations for the purpose of producing hydrocarbons, frequently the wellbore operator requires information concerning formation and wellbore parameters, such as fluid pressure and fluid content of the various formations penetrated by the wellbore. Such pressure and fluid content information is used for, among other purposes, determining a depth at which to set casing, determining which formations are likely to be commercially productive of hydrocarbons or whether to set casing at all.




Various instruments are known in the art for taking formation fluid pressure measurements and/or formation fluid samples. Many of these instruments are designed to be conveyed at one end of an armored electrical cable (“wireline” conveyed). Other types of instruments may be conveyed by coiled tubing, drill pipe or similar conveyances. These instruments typically include an elongated instrument housing adapted to traverse the wellbore. The instrument housing includes therein a probe adapted to be extended from the housing and placed in externally sealed engagement with the wall of the wellbore at the position of a formation to be tested. Various flowlines, pressure transducers and sample chambers are disposed in the instrument housing and are adapted to cause fluid to be withdrawn from the selected formation while pressure and fluid composition properties are measured. In some cases a sample of the formation fluid will be directed to a storage tank for ultimate removal from the wellbore and subsequent analysis at the earth's surface. Examples of such formation pressure measuring and sample testing instruments are described in U.S. Pat. No. 6,058,773 issued to Zimmerman et al. and U.S. Pat. No. 4,936,139 issued to Zimmerman et al.




One particular concern associated with substantially all formation pressure measuring and sampling instruments such as the ones described in the above references is that the instrument must be stopped in the wellbore in order to take a sample and/or make a pressure measurement. Stopping the instrument in the wellbore substantially increases the risk of the instrument and/or means of conveyance becoming stuck in the wellbore. Mechanisms for becoming stuck include debris settling out of the drilling fluid and lodging between the instrument and the wellbore wall, differential pressure between the drilling fluid in the wellbore and the formation being tested, and the conveyance becoming “keyseated” in the wall of the wellbore. So called “tractor” devices have been developed to prevent wellbore tools from sticking in the wellbore. Examples of such tractor devices include U.S. Pat. No. 5,954,131 issued to Sallwasser on Sep. 21, 1999 and U.S. Pat. No. 6,179,055 issued to Sallwasser et al. on Jan. 30, 2001, the entire contents of both are hereby incorporated by reference. These tractor devices convey a tool along a wellbore using a cam system to lock against the borehole wall.




What is needed is a device for enabling continued motion of the conveyance and a substantial portion of the instrument while the tool conducts wellbore operations, such as deploying a probe to make a formation pressure measurement and/or fluid test. One such device is described for example in U.S. Pat. No. 4,600,059 issued to Eggleston et al. The device disclosed in this reference includes a telescoping section coupled between a wireline conveyed fluid testing instrument and the armored electrical cable. When the testing instrument is deployed to test a particular earth formation, and is thus stationary, the armored electrical cable may be kept in continuous motion by repeated extension and retraction of the telescoping section. This is known in the art as “yo-yoing” the cable. Yo-yoing the cable requires the cable operator to pay very close attention to a winch control system to avoid too much upward and/or downward motion of the cable for operating the telescoping section. It is desirable to have a telescoping section for a wellbore test instrument which does not require cable yo-yoing.




It is desirable to have a wellbore instrument, such as a formation fluid pressure and/or sampling instrument, which enables substantially continuous motion of a well logging conveyance in order to prevent sticking and reduce the duration of wellbore operations. This combination of a wellbore instrument in a continuous motion enables economically combining wellbore options, such as a combined pressure/fluid sample test instrument with other types of well logging instruments that make measurements while moving along the wellbore. Typically, such “moving measurements” have not been combined with formation pressure and sampling instruments to operate simultaneously because the former are adapted to make measurements while moving along the wellbore, and the latter, as previously explained, must be stopped. Examples of the former include, without limitation, acoustic devices, resistivity devices and nuclear porosity and lithology measuring devices.




SUMMARY OF INVENTION




One aspect of the invention is a well logging instrument which includes a lower housing having therein a formation testing system adapted to be operated in an axially fixed position in a wellbore. The instrument also includes an upper housing adapted to be operatively coupled to a well logging conveyance. The instrument includes an axial extension mechanism operatively coupled between the lower housing and the upper housing. The extension mechanism is adapted to controllably extend and retract to lengthen and shorten the instrument, respectively.




A method for testing an earth formation according to another aspect of the invention includes moving a logging instrument axially along a wellbore by operating a logging conveyance coupled to an upper end of the instrument. A testing system adapted to test the earth formation at a fixed axial position along the wellbore is deployed, while continuing to move the conveyance along the wellbore. A length of the logging instrument between the conveyance and the testing system is increased by operating an axial extension mechanism disposed between the conveyance and the testing system, while continuing to move the conveyance along the wellbore. The earth formation is tested, the testing system is retracted; and the axial extension mechanism is then retracted. In one embodiment, tension between the instrument and the conveyance is measured, and the axial extension mechanism is extended at a rate adapted to maintain the tension substantially constant.




Other aspects and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following description and the appended claims.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

shows an example embodiment of a formation testing instrument according to one aspect of the invention.





FIG. 2

shows another embodiment of an axial extension mechanism according to one aspect of the invention.





FIG. 3

shown another embodiment of an axial extension mechanism according to one aspect of the invention.





FIGS. 4-8

show a well logging/pressure testing operation according to another aspect of the invention.





FIGS. 9-13

show a well logging/pressure testing operation according to another aspect of the invention.





FIGS. 14-19

show a well logging/pressure testing operation according to another aspect of the invention.





FIG. 20

shows an example embodiment of a cable tension measuring device used in another aspect of the invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION




An embodiment of a formation testing instrument is shown schematically in FIG.


1


. The instrument


10


in this embodiment is adapted to make formation pressure measurements and/or take fluid samples from an earth formation. Formation fluid pressure measuring/sample taking devices are a principal example, but only one example, of a type of formation testing system which is adapted to perform its testing function while in an axially fixed position within a wellbore.




The instrument


10


includes an upper housing


28


adapted to couple at its upper end to an instrument conveyance, which in this example is an armored electrical cable (not shown). Connection to the cable (not shown) can be either directly, or through other intervening well logging instruments (not shown in

FIG. 1

for clarity). The upper housing


28


is adapted to slidingly, sealingly engage a lower housing


26


.




The lower housing


26


in this embodiment includes therein the various components of a testing and sampling system


12


. The system


12


includes a probe


14


which is adapted to be extended laterally from the lower housing


26


by hydraulic cylinders


16


or the like, and may include a back up pad system


20


located circumferentially opposite the probe


14


about the lower housing


26


. The back up pad system


20


can be of any type well known in the art adapted to provide the probe


14


with adequate ability to be sealingly forced against the wall of a wellbore (not shown) in which the instrument


10


is disposed, particularly when the wellbore has a large diameter as compared with the diameter of the instrument


10


. The back up pad section


20


can be extended and retracted using hydraulic cylinders


18


or the like.




The probe


14


is in selective hydraulic communication with a pressure testing cylinder


22


having therein a pressure transducer (not shown separately) which makes measurements of the fluid pressure of the selected earth formations adjacent to the wellbore. The pressure testing cylinder


22


may be operatively controlled by a controller/telemetry unit


24


, which operates the pressure testing cylinder


22


and records, formats and/or transmits measurements made by the transducer (not shown) so fluid that pressure of the selected earth formations can be determined. Systems including the system


12


, pressure test cylinder


22


and transducer therein, controller/telemetry unit


24


and the back up pad system


20


may be any one or more of a number of types well known in the art, such as disclosed, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 6,058,773 issued to Zimmerman et al. and U.S. Pat. No. 4,936,139 issued to Zimmerman et al. The type and structure of the system


12


, pressure test cylinder


22


, controller/telemetry unit


24


and the back up pad system


20


are only provided to help explain the invention, and are not in any way intended to limit the scope of the invention.




The system


12


of

FIG. 1

is depicted as a formation fluid pressure measuring/sample taking system with a probe and hydraulic cylinders. However, the system may be substituted with any downhole instrument capable of performing operations in the apparatus


10


. Example of such downhole instruments include devices, such as a rotary or percussion “core” sampling device, perforation tools, rock testing and sampling tools as well as others instruments usable with downhole tools.




As previously explained, the upper housing


28


and the lower housing


26


are adapted to slidingly, preferably sealingly, engage each other. An axial position of the upper housing


28


with respect to the lower housing


26


is controlled, in various embodiments of the invention, by an axial extension mechanism


38


. One end of the axial extension mechanism


38


is fixedly coupled to a selected position along the lower housing


26


, such as at lower bulkhead


38


A. The other end of the axial extension mechanism


38


is fixedly coupled to a selected position along the upper housing


28


, such as at upper bulkhead


38


B.




The embodiment of the axial extension mechanism


38


shown in

FIG. 1

may include an electric motor


30


the rotary output of which turns an extension screw, or ball screw


32


. The ball screw


32


engages a ball nut


34


fixed to the lower bulkhead


38


A or other element coupled to the lower housing


26


. The motor


30


in this embodiment is controlled by a motor controller


36


, functionality of which will be further explained. To summarize, the motor


30


may be turned to rotate the ball screw


32


to cause the lower housing


26


to slide outward from the upper housing


28


(or as may be described inversely, the upper housing


28


slides outwardly from the lower housing


26


). The outward relative sliding lengthens the instrument


10


. The motor


30


may also be turned in the opposite direction to ultimately cause the housings


26


,


28


to slide together with respect to each other, to shorten the instrument


10


.




As will be appreciated by those skilled in the art, when the pressure testing system


12


is engaged with the wall of a wellbore (not shown) to make a pressure test of an earth formation, its axial position in the wellbore (not shown) is fixed. By causing the motor


30


to operate to lengthen the instrument


10


, the cable (not shown) and any intervening logging instruments (not shown) may continue to move along the wellbore (not shown). After a pressure measurement is made, and the pressure measuring system


12


is retracted, the motor


30


may be operated to cause the instrument


10


to shorten, still while moving the cable and any intervening logging instruments.




Another possible embodiment of the axial extension mechanism


38


is shown in FIG.


2


. In this embodiment, the axial extension mechanism includes an hydraulic cylinder


40


coupled at one end to bulkhead


38


B in the upper housing


28


, and an hydraulic piston


41


coupled at one end to bulkhead


38


A in the lower housing


26


. The piston


41


/cylinder


40


combination may be any conventional type adapted to extend and retract the piston


41


from the cylinder


40


upon application of suitable hydraulic pressure. The piston


41


/cylinder


40


combination should be operatively coupled to a suitably controlled hydraulic pressure source (not shown) to extend and retract the piston


41


from the cylinder


40


to lengthen and shorten the instrument


10


as explained with respect to the previous embodiment of the axial extension mechanism


38


.




Another possible embodiment of the axial extension mechanism


38


is shown in FIG.


3


. This embodiment is a linear electric actuator including a primary winding


43


mechanically coupled to the lower housing


26


and a secondary winding


42


mechanically coupled to the upper housing


28


.




For any embodiment of the axial extension mechanism, such as the ones described above, it is understood that the positions of the various elements of any embodiment of the mechanism


38


described above within either of the upper housing


28


and lower housing


26


are only to illustrate the general principle of an instrument made according to this aspect of the invention. Accordingly, the relative positions of the various components of the axial extension mechanism shown herein are not meant to limit the invention. For example, the motor


30


and balls crew


32


of

FIG. 1

could as easily and effectively be located in an coupled to the lower housing


26


. It is also understood that having the lower housing


26


be adapted to slide within the upper housing


28


as shown in

FIGS. 1

,


2


and


3


is also meant only to illustrate the principle. The upper housing


28


could as easily be adapted to slide within the lower housing


26


while performing as intended within the scope of the invention.




A method of performing wellbore operations according to the invention is illustrated in

FIGS. 4 through 8

. Specifically,

FIGS. 4 through 8

show a method of taking pressure measurements and/or fluid samples.

FIGS. 4 through 8

also show how the overall length of the instrument


10


extends and retracts over time.




In

FIG. 4

, an instrument


10


according to the invention is coupled to a well logging cable


50


. The instrument


10


has an upper housing


28


coupled to the cable


50


through an intervening logging instrument


51


adapted to make one or more types of petrophysical measurements while the intervening instrument


51


is moved along the wellbore


52


. The instrument


10


also has a lower housing


26


coupled to the upper housing


28


as previously described. Other embodiments of a method according to the invention may exclude the intervening logging instrument


51


.

FIG. 4

shows the instrument


10


at initial time to with the axial extension mechanism fully retracted. The test system


12


is deployed in an earth formation which is intended to be tested, and the various components of the test system


12


which are adapted to contact the wellbore


52


are placed in contact therewith.





FIG. 5

shows the tool as it has advanced up the wellbore at a time t


1


. The logging cable


50


continues to be withdrawn from the wellbore


52


, in some embodiments, at substantially the same rate as prior to deployment of the test system


12


. As the cable


50


continues to be withdrawn, the axial extension mechanism


38


is operated to enable the upper housing (


28


in

FIG. 1

) to continue to move at the same rate as the cable


50


. The lower housing (


26


in

FIG. 1

) remains axially fixed within the wellbore


52


.





FIG. 6

show the tool at time t


3


. The lower housing


26


of the instrument


10


is stopped with the system


12


deployed to perform wellbore operations. Upper housing


28


continues to advance uphole thereby increasing the overall instrument


10


length as shown in

FIG. 6

as the pressure test system


12


is operated to make at least one fluid pressure test from the surrounding earth formation.





FIG. 7

shows the instrument


10


at time t


4


. In

FIG. 7

, the pressure test is completed, and the pressure test system is retracted to enable resumed upward motion of the lower housing


26


having the pressure test system


12


therein. The lower housing


26


of the instrument


10


is released from the wellbore and begins to retract into the upper housing and the overall length of the tool


10


begins to decrease. The lower housing is retracted by operating the axial extension mechanism


38


to shorten the instrument length as discussed previously.





FIG. 8

shows the instrument


10


at time t


4


. In

FIG. 8

, the lower housing


26


is fully retracted and the overall instrument length is returned to its original, retracted length at t


1


. The tool may then be moved into another position within the wellbore to take additional tests, or be withdrawn from the borehole.




Referring now to

FIG. 9

, the instrument


10


is shown in combination with an extender


100


. The extender


100


has an upper portion


28




a


coupled to the lower housing


26


of instrument


10


, and a lower portion


26




a.


The upper portion


28




a


and the lower portion


26




a


having an axial extension mechanism


38




a


adapted to axially extend and retract upper portion


28




a


and lower portion


26




a


as previously described with respect to axial extension mechanism


38


of

FIGS. 1 through 3

. The lower portion


26




a


of the extender


100


may optionally be provided with additional instruments to perform tests.




A method of performing wellbore operations using the instruments


10


with the extender


100


is illustrated in

FIGS. 9 through 13

.

FIGS. 9 through 13

show the instrument


10


advance up the wellbore as previously described with respect to

FIGS. 4 through 8

. At time t


0


, the instrument


10


is in the fully retracted position and the extender


100


is in the fully extended position. As shown in FIG.


10


and at time t


1


, the upper housing


28


of the instrument


10


and the lower portion


26




a


of the extender


100


have begun to move uphole. At time t


2


of

FIG. 11

, the instrument


10


is in the fully extended position, and the extender


100


is in the fully retracted position.

FIG. 12

shows the instrument


10


at time t


3


with the sampling probe


14


having completed its test. The instrument


10


begins to retract while the extender


100


begins to extend. At time t


4


shown in

FIG. 13

, the instrument


10


has fully retracted and the extender


100


has fully extended. The cycle may then begin again at another position in the wellbore.





FIGS. 9 through 13

depict the instrument


10


extending while the extender


100


retracts and the extender


100


extending as the instrument


10


retracts. This depiction of the instrument


10


operating at alternate intervals with the extender is one example of an operation with multiple extension mechanisms. The instrument and extender may be timed to operate simultaneously, out of sync, or at any desired interval.




Another embodiment of the present invention is depicted in FIG.


14


. The instrument


200


is provided with a slotted housing


130


having an upper end


140


and a lower end


150


. An axial mechanism


180


having an upper portion


32




a


and a lower portion


32




b


is disposed within the housing. A mechanical stop


160


is disposed between the upper portion


32




a


and the lower portion


32




b.






An axially movable testing systems


12




a


is positioned on upper portion


32




a,


and an axially movable testing system


12




b


is positioned on lower portion


32




b.


Each testing system is provided with a probe


14


and opposing back up pad section


18


extendable through slots (not shown) in the housing


130


. The testing systems


12




a


and


12




b


are axially movable along their respective portion of the axial mechanism


180


.




A method of performing wellbore operations using the instrument


200


in accordance with the invention is illustrated in

FIGS. 14 through 19

. The instrument


200


is shown progressing uphole in the wellbore


52


from time t


0


of

FIG. 15

to time t


5


of FIG.


20


. As shown in

FIGS. 14 through 16

at times t


0


through t


2


, the testing system


12




a


extends through the slot (not shown) in the housing and engages the wellbore


52


to perform a testing function. Testing system


12




a


advances toward mechanical stop


160


along the upper portion


32




a


of the axial mechanism


180


, and the testing system


12




b


advances toward mechanical stop


160


along the lower portion


32




b


of the axial mechanism


180


.




Referring now to

FIG. 17

at time t


3


, testing system


12




a


retracts back into the housing, and testing system


12




b


extends through the slotted housing to perform a test. As the instrument


200


continues uphole as shown in

FIG. 18

at time t


4


, instrument


12




b


advances towards the lower end


150


of the instrument, and testing system


12




a


advances toward the upper end


140


of the instrument


200


. As shown in

FIGS. 14 through 19

, testing systems


12




a


and


12




b


test at alternate intervals, but could be timed at alternate, simultaneous or random intervals to perform a variety of tests.




It is understood that reference to a well logging cable as explained with respect to

FIGS. 4-19

are merely examples of a well logging conveyance which may be used in various embodiments of an instrument and method according to the invention. Coiled tubing and drill pipe logging conveyances may also be used in other embodiments.




Another aspect of the invention can be better understood by referring to FIG.


20


.

FIG. 20

shows a typical cable head


53


which is used to make electrical and mechanical connection between the logging cable


50


and the instrument (


10


in FIGS.


4


-


9


). This embodiment of the cable head


53


includes therein a sensor


54


having an output related to the amount of tension between the logging cable


50


and the cable head


53


. As will be appreciated by those skilled in the art, the instrument upper housing (


28


in

FIG. 1

) synchronously moves with the cable even when the lower housing (


26


in

FIG. 1

) is axially fixed in the wellbore, as explained with respect to

FIGS. 4-9

. If the cable motion matches the rate at which the axial extension mechanism (


38


in

FIGS. 4-9

) increases the instrument length, the tension between the cable head


53


and the cable should remain substantially constant. In this embodiment of the invention, the sensor


54


is operatively coupled to the motor controller (


36


in FIG.


1


), and the controller is adapted so that the rate of extension of the axial extension mechanism


38


may be substantially matched to the rate of motion of the logging cable


50


. If the cable


50


moves faster than the extension mechanism


38


lengthens, it would be expected that the tension indicated by the sensor


54


will increase, and vice versa.




While the invention has been described with respect to a limited number of embodiments, those skilled in the art, having benefit of this disclosure, will appreciate that other embodiments can be devised which do not depart from the scope of the invention as disclosed herein. Accordingly, the scope of the invention should be limited only by the attached claims.



Claims
  • 1. A well logging instrument, comprising:a lower housing having therein a wellbore testing system adapted to be operated in an axially fixed position in a wellbore; an upper housing adapted to be operatively coupled to a well logging conveyance; and an axial extension mechanism operatively coupled between the lower housing and the upper housing, the extension mechanism adapted to controllably extend and retract so as to controllably lengthen and shorten the instrument, respectively.
  • 2. The instrument as defined in claim 1 wherein the axial extension mechanism comprises a motor having a ball screw operatively coupled thereto, and a ball nut operatively coupled to the ball screw.
  • 3. The instrument as defined in claim 1 wherein the axial extension mechanism comprises an hydraulic cylinder and piston combination.
  • 4. The instrument as defined in claim 1 wherein the axial extension mechanism comprises an electric linear actuator.
  • 5. The instrument as defined in claim 1 further comprising a controller operatively coupled to the axial extension mechanism and a sensor having an output related to a tension on the well logging conveyance, the controller adapted to operate the extension mechanism so as to maintain a substantially constant tension on the well logging conveyance.
  • 6. The instrument as defined in claim 1 wherein the conveyance comprises a well logging cable.
  • 7. The instrument as defined in claim 1 wherein the testing system is selected from the group of a formation pressure testing system, a formation sampling system, a rock indentation system and a perforating system.
  • 8. The instrument as defined in claim 1 further comprising a well logging device coupled between the conveyance and the upper housing, the well logging device adapted to make measurements while moving along the wellbore.
  • 9. The instrument as defined in claim 1 further comprising an extender.
  • 10. The instrument as defined in claim 9 wherein the extender comprises an upper portion, a lower portion, and a second axial extension mechanism operatively coupled therebetween, the upper portion coupled to the lower housing; the extension mechanism adapted to controllably extend and retract so as to controllably lengthen and shorten the extender, respectively.
  • 11. The instrument as defined in claim 10 having therein a second wellbore testing system.
  • 12. A well logging instrument, comprising:a housing disposable in a wellbore, the housing having axial slots therethrough; an axial mechanism positioned within the housing; and a wellbore testing system movably positionable along the axial mechanism, the testing system adapted to extend through the slots of the housing and perform wellbore tests as the housing advances through the wellbore.
  • 13. A method for testing an earth formation, comprising:(a) moving a logging instrument axially along a wellbore by operating a logging conveyance coupled to an upper end of the instrument; (b) deploying a testing system adapted to test formation parameters at a fixed axial position along the wellbore; (c) extending a length of the logging instrument by operating an axial extension mechanism disposed between the conveyance and the testing system; (d) testing the formation; (c) retracting the testing system; and (f) retracting the axial extension mechanism, wherein the deploying, extending the length, testing the formation and retracting the testing system and extension mechanism are performed while continuing to move the conveyance along the wellbore.
  • 14. The method as defined in claim 13 wherein the extending comprises operating a motor and ball screw.
  • 15. The method as defined in claim 13 wherein the extending comprises operating an hydraulic cylinder and piston.
  • 16. The method as defined in claim 13 wherein the extending comprises operating an electric linear actuator.
  • 17. The method as defined in claim 13 further comprising measuring a tension between the conveyance and the instrument, and controlling a rate of the extending to maintain the tension substantially constant.
  • 18. The method as defined in claim 13 further comprising making a measurement of at least one formation property from an instrument adapted to move synchronously with the conveyance, the making the measurement continuing while extending the length of the logging instrument.
  • 19. The method as defined in claim 13 wherein the moving the conveyance comprises withdrawing a well logging cable from the wellbore.
  • 20. The method as defined in claim 13 wherein the step of moving a logging instrument comprises moving a wellbore tool comprising multiple logging instruments axially coupled together axially along a wellbore by operating a logging conveyance coupled to an upper end of the tool, and wherein steps (b)-(f) are performed for each instrument.
  • 21. The method as defined in claim 20 wherein the multiple instruments perform steps (b)-(f) alternately with adjacent instruments.
  • 22. The method as defined in claim 20 wherein the multiple instruments perform steps (b), (d) and (c) simultaneously.
US Referenced Citations (18)
Number Name Date Kind
4228350 Paap et al. Oct 1980 A
4252195 Fredd Feb 1981 A
4349072 Escaron et al. Sep 1982 A
4432143 Moriarty et al. Feb 1984 A
4600059 Eggleston et al. Jul 1986 A
4624313 Coshow Nov 1986 A
4697638 Knight Oct 1987 A
4860580 Du Rocher Aug 1989 A
4914826 Nold Apr 1990 A
4936139 Zimmerman et al. Jun 1990 A
5168765 Broussard Dec 1992 A
5217075 Wittrisch Jun 1993 A
5574263 Roesner Nov 1996 A
5753813 Hagiwara May 1998 A
5808191 Alexy et al. Sep 1998 A
5954131 Sallwasser Sep 1999 A
6058773 Zimmerman et al. May 2000 A
6179055 Sallwasser et al. Jan 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (1)
Number Date Country
0 346 229 Dec 1989 EP