Air filters are commonly used in forced air systems, e.g. residential heating and air-conditioning systems and room air purifiers, in order to remove dust and dirt particles and the like.
Herein is disclosed a framed air filter and method of making. The framed air filter includes air filter media and a frame with four frame portions. At least one corner of the frame is a bonded, non-integral corner at which a reinforcing plate that integrally extends from an elongate downstream flange of a first frame portion of a pair of neighboring frame portions that meet to form the non-integral, bonded corner, is affixed to an inner sidewall of a second frame portion of the pair of neighboring frame portions. These and other aspects of the invention will be apparent from the detailed description below. In no event, however, should the above summaries be construed as limitations on the claimed subject matter, which subject matter is defined solely by the attached claims, as may be amended during prosecution.
Like reference numbers in the various figures indicate like elements. Unless otherwise indicated, all figures and drawings in this document are not to scale and are chosen for the purpose of illustrating different embodiments of the invention. In particular the dimensions of the various components are depicted in illustrative terms only, and no relationship between the dimensions of the various components should be inferred from the drawings, unless so indicated.
Although terms such as “first” and “second” may be used in this disclosure, it should be understood that those terms are used in their relative sense only unless otherwise noted. As used herein as a modifier to a property, attribute or relationship, the term “generally”, unless otherwise specifically defined, means that the property, attribute or relationship would be readily recognizable by a person of ordinary skill but without requiring absolute precision or a perfect match (e.g., within +/−20% for quantifiable properties). The term “substantially” means to a high degree of approximation (e.g., within +/−10% for quantifiable properties) but again without requiring absolute precision or a perfect match. The term “essentially” means to a very high degree of approximation (e.g. within +/−4% for quantifiable properties) but again without requiring absolute precision or a perfect match. Terms such as “outer”, “outward”, “outwardmost”, “outwardly”, and the like, refer to a direction generally away from the geometric center of the air filter media. Terms such as “inner”, “inward”, “inwardmost”, “inwardly”, and the like, refer to a direction generally toward the geometric center of the air filter media.
The term “upstream” is used to denote the closed-end side of a framed air filter, corresponding to the far side of filter 1 as shown in
The term “frame portion” is used to denote a portion of an assembled frame that is mounted on a particular edge of the filter media. The term “frame piece” is used to denote a piece of material (that is typically flat as made) that can be folded to form a frame portion and can be joined to other folded frame pieces to form an assembled frame. (Exemplary frame pieces are depicted in
Shown in
For convenience in describing such generally rectangular geometry, the four major portions of frame 12 and components thereof may occasionally be referred to herein by a lettered subscript (e.g., a, b, c, or d). Not all corresponding features of the various frame portions are individually identified by number in the Figures, but will be understood to be present in many embodiments. Similarly, not all components or features will be individually subscripted to denote the particular frame portion in which they are depicted in the various Figures, but it will be understood that all such subscripts can be applied as needed. Frame 12 may thus take the form of a rectangular frame with four major elongate frame portions (12a, b, c and d as indicated in
As most easily seen in
Any such portion of frame 12 will further comprise an outer sidewall 40, which extends downstream (and in some embodiments, outward) from upstream flange 30 and is foldably connected thereto at outer junction 35 as shown in
The portion of frame 12 further comprises an inner sidewall 50, which extends outward and downstream from downstream flange 60 and is foldably connected thereto at inner junction 55. Downstream flange 60 and inner sidewall 50 define an angle of repose α with a vertex coinciding with inner junction 55. Angle of repose a will, in many embodiments, be greater than 110 degrees, e.g. so that the frame and the framed air filter can be nestable. In various embodiments, angle of repose α may be at least 115, 120, 130, or 140 degrees. In further embodiments, angle of repose a may be at most 160, 150, 145, 135, or 125 degrees. Often, all four frame portions will exhibit similar angles of repose α. For example, a nominal angle of repose α in the range of 120-130 degrees for all four frame portions may be targeted in production. In some embodiments, the angle of repose α of inner junction 55 may be within plus or minus 15, 10, or 5 degrees of the inclination angle Ω of outer junction 35, as for the exemplary design depicted in
The portion of frame 12 is configured so that outer sidewall 40 and inner sidewall 50 meet each other, and are foldably connected to each other, at sidewall junction 45 as indicated in
However, a nestable arrangement does not necessarily require that inner and outer sidewalls 50 and 40 must be positioned in the manner described above and pictured in
As mentioned above, in some embodiments such an arrangement may exhibit an angle of repose α of inner junction 55 that is at least somewhat greater than the inclination angle Ω of outer junction 35, as is evident for the exemplary arrangement depicted in
The above angles (σ, α, Ω) are considered to be “nominal” angles that are e.g. targeted in production. It will be appreciated that in actual production of framed filters, some deviation from these nominal values may occur due to normal variations in manufacturing procedures. Moreover, these angles may vary slightly along the elongate length of a frame portion, with those sections of the frame portion that are closest to the frame corners being more constrained by the rigidifying and bracing action of the frame corners, in comparison to sections of the frame portion that are far away from the frame corners. Thus, in ascertaining whether a frame portion exhibits any of the herein-discussed angles and geometric relationships, a number of measurements may be taken along the elongate extent of the frame portion (and encompassing frame sections that are near the corners, and frame sections that are far from the corners), with an average value of the angle then being calculated.
The framed filter portion depicted in
In many embodiments, all four filter frame portions (e.g., 12a-12d) will comprise the above-recited upstream and downstream flanges and inner and outer sidewalls and junctions/foldable connections therebetween. In this context, the term foldable signifies that a frame portion is formed (i.e. into a folded configuration of the general type shown in
A frame piece can thus be transformed from a flat configuration e.g. of the general type shown in
Any of several types of scoring can be used to provide a score line/fold line or a segment thereof. A first type of score line is a cut-scored line. In cut-scoring, the material (e.g. paperboard, chipboard or the like) of a frame piece is cut e.g. with a sharp blade that penetrates partially, but not completely, through the thickness of the frame piece. That is, the cutting blade penetrates into a first, contact surface of the frame piece but stops short of penetrating through to the opposing, second surface. In specific embodiments, a cut-scored line may comprise a depth of penetration of from at least 40, 45, 50, or 55, to at most 80, 75, 70, 65, or 60 percent, of the thickness of the frame piece. The remaining uncut material can act as a hinge allowing the two panels that are connected by the hinge to be foldably moved relative to each other.
A cut-scored line (when viewed in cross-section along the long axis of the score line, prior to folding) typically takes the form of a relatively narrow and high-aspect ratio cut or fissure with relatively little deformation of the material of the frame piece at locations laterally adjacent to the cut and/or on the opposing, second surface of the material. To transform a flat piece of scored material (often referred to as a “blank”) into a frame portion, adjacent panels of the blank are usually folded along a cut-scored line in a direction that causes the cut to open wider (“open” folding, as discussed later herein). This is to avoid the faces of the cut-score binding against each other and resisting the folding, as will be readily apparent to ordinary artisans.
A second type of score line is a crush-scored line. In crush-scoring, the material of a frame piece is contacted with a member that is relatively rounded/blunt and/or wide in comparison to a blade used for cut-scoring. Such a crush-scored line (when viewed in cross-section along the long axis of the score line, prior to folding) typically takes the form of a relatively wide and shallow, inwardly-deformed recess on the contact side of the frame piece, with a corresponding outwardly-deformed, rounded protrusion on the opposite side of the frame piece. (In contrast, a cut-score may be only faintly visible, or not visible at all, when viewed from the opposite side of the frame piece.) Adjacent panels are customarily folded along a crush-scored line in a direction that causes the contact-side recess to open wider, for similar reasons to those described above for cut-score lines.
A third type of scoring is perforation. As defined herein, perforating (“perfing”) is a process in which successive, spaced apart areas (that are e.g. aligned along a linear path) of frame piece material are cut e.g. with a blade that passes through the entire thickness of the frame piece to leave a through-hole. A perf-scored line thus comprises a succession of through-holes that are spaced apart along a frame piece (in many embodiments, the through-holes will be slit-like with a long axis oriented along the perf-scored line).
By whatever method a score line is provided, such a score line can define a fold line along which two adjacent areas (e.g. panels) of a frame piece will preferentially fold upon the application of appropriate bending force to the areas. A score line will thus be present at (and in fact will define) the junctions between various sidewalls, flanges, etc., in a frame portion that results from the folding process. The various fold lines disclosed herein may make use of any desired score line, chosen e.g. from any of the above general categories. In some embodiments, combinations of score lines of various types may be used. If multiple types of scoring are to be performed, if desired they may all be performed on the same surface of the frame piece and/or at the same time, e.g. using a rotary-scoring apparatus or a batch scoring apparatus. If desired, the outer borders of the frame piece may be cut, e.g. die-cut, in the same operation.
In some embodiments a score line may exhibit segments in which different types of scoring are used. For example, “skip-scoring” may be performed, in which a score line exhibits one or more segments that are cut-scored and one or more segments that are crush-scored. Such arrangements are discussed in detail in U.S. patent Ser. No. 11/376,537, which is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety for the purpose of describing various scoring/folding arrangements. Any of the arrangements disclosed and/or pictured in the '537 patent may be used in combination with any of the arrangements described in the present disclosure. (Various types and/or combinations of score lines may be apparent in certain Figures of the present disclosure; all such depictions are exemplary and the arrangements disclosed in the present document are not limited to use with only the particular types of score lines shown in the Figures.)
As will be evident from
A frame piece may be scored on a hidden surface, and/or on a visible surface, as desired. In many embodiments the scoring may be performed on the visible surface of the frame piece, followed by “open” folding of the frame piece to form a frame portion. As noted above, “open” folding denotes a folding operation that, along the score, causes the opposing faces of the panels to open wider (that is, to move apart from each other, rather than to impinge against each other). Open folding may be applied to a frame piece that was scored on the “visible” surfaces of the frame piece, e.g. so that these surfaces of the frame piece (e.g. surfaces that were coated, printed, etc. for aesthetic effect) are visible surfaces in the finished frame. For example, in some embodiments, fold lines/junctions 35 and 45 as depicted in
A case in which areas of a frame piece are folded the opposite way, i.e. so that, along the score, the opposing faces of the areas move toward each other (e.g. so as to narrow or close off the groove formed by the scoring), will be referred to herein as “reverse” folding. Such procedures are not commonly performed in the art for reasons noted earlier herein. However, in some instances particular panels of frame pieces may be reverse-folded. In particular, with some pinch/compression frame designs, it may not be possible for all fold lines to be open-folded; rather, at least one fold line, if it is a cut-scored or crush-scored fold line, may need to be reverse-folded. For example, inspection of
In various embodiments, inner sidewall 50 and outer sidewall 40 may be positioned at various sidewall angles σ relative to each other (when viewed in cross section as shown in
By nestable is meant that multiple framed air filters 1 (of at least substantially the same shape and size), can be stacked so that they collectively occupy less than 70% of the total height obtained by multiplying the height of each filter (along the upstream-downstream direction) by the number of filters. A stack of such nested framed filters may resemble the general arrangement depicted e.g. in FIG. 4 of U.S. patent Ser. No. 11/179,665 (noting however that the media need not necessarily be pleated and/or compressible in the manner described in the '665 patent).
It will be appreciated that framed air filters of the type depicted in
In some embodiments, the four portions (12a-d) of frame 12 may be obtained from four individual, separately made frame pieces that are assembled with/connected to each other, and folded, to form frame 12. For example, in the exemplary embodiment of
In other embodiments, one frame piece may provide two neighboring frame portions (e.g. 12a and 12b) and another frame piece may provide the two remaining neighboring frame portions (e.g. 12c and 12d). Such a frame piece may take the form of (e.g. after partial folding) an L-shaped frame piece in which the two arms of the L are integrally joined to each other by an integral, foldable connection e.g. between the outer sidewalls of the arms of the L. Such arrangements will provide a frame in which at least one corner of the frame is an integral corner (rather than a bonded corner). For example, such a frame may thus comprise two diagonally-opposing frame corners that are integral corners and two remaining diagonally-opposing frame corners that are bonded corners.
A frame portion will be formed via the folding of foldably-connected, elongate panels of at least a part (or the entirety) of a frame piece. An exemplary frame piece 13a from which can be formed a frame portion of the general type shown in
Frame piece 13a of
Panels 30 and 40 are joined to each other by a score/fold line that, when the panels are folded along the score line, will provide outer junction 35. Panels 50 and 60 are similarly joined to each other by a score/fold line that, when the panels are folded along the score line, will provide inner junction 55. Panels 40 and 50 that will form the outer and inner sidewalls, are joined by a score/fold line that, when the panels are folded along the score line, will form sidewall junction 45. Exemplary frame piece 13b as shown in
As noted, in some embodiments one or more corners 11 of frame 12 may be an integral corner in which at least some part of the respective frame portions are integrally connected to each other. For instance, a type of integral corner that is commonly used in the art comprises a pair of neighboring frame portions in which the outer sidewalls of the two frame portions are integrally connected to each other.
However, one or more corners 11 of frame 12 will be a bonded corner. In various embodiments, two or three such corners may be bonded corners; in some embodiments, all four corners may be bonded corners. By definition, a bonded corner is a non-integral corner in which no part of the two frame pieces that meet to form the corner, are integral with each other as made. Rather, some part or parts of the first frame piece/portion are bonded (affixed) to some part or parts of the second frame piece/portion in the process of forming the frame. As discussed in detail herein, one such part that is bonded in this manner may be a reinforcing plate of one of the frame portions.
Two frame pieces can be brought together, folded to form neighboring frame portions, and assembled to each other to form a corner, e.g. in the following general manner. As an example, the formation of corner 11a-b (as shown in the upper right of
Such a corner can be held in the desired configuration in any desired manner. Typically, at least some portions of the first frame portion and the second frame portion are affixed to each other to achieve this. In some embodiments, this may be done via mechanical fastening, e.g. by the use of staples or similar fasteners. However, in many convenient embodiments, this may be performed by adhesive bonding. Thus in some embodiments, a layer of adhesive of any suitable type may be disposed on at least a portion of, for example, the hidden surfaces of one or more frame pieces. In some embodiments, such an adhesive may be coated over the entirety of the hidden surface of a frame piece. However, it may be more efficient to provide adhesive only at the locations at which it is needed for bonding.
At a bonded corner, at least one part of a frame portion will be affixed to a neighboring frame portion at the corner formed by the two portions. In some embodiments, one such affixable part will be a reinforcing plate. Exemplary reinforcing plates 101 are depicted in
The use of a reinforcing plate of this general type can advantageously enhance the mechanical stability of the thus-formed corner. In particular, the use of reinforcing plates at one, two, three, or all four corners of a frame, can significantly increase the resistance of the framed filter to out-of-plane twisting. While in some embodiments the mechanical strength of the frame may be further enhanced by the use of optional reinforcing tabs as described elsewhere herein, it is emphasized that the use of one or more reinforcing plates is not predicated on being used in combination with reinforcing tabs.
As seen in
Thus in some embodiments, an inner junction 55 between the elongate inner sidewall 50a and the elongate downstream flange 60a of a second, neighboring frame portion 12a may exhibit an angle of repose α of e.g. from 110 degrees to 160 degrees. The fold line 106 between reinforcing plate 101 and the end of elongate downstream flange 60b of the first frame portion (from which the reinforcing plate integrally, foldably extends) may exhibit a reinforcing plate angle that is at least generally congruent with (e.g., is within plus or minus 10, 5, or 2 degrees of) the angle of repose α of the inner junction 55 of the second, neighboring frame portion. This can allow plate 101, as folded along fold line 106, to extend upward and outward along the inner surface of corner-proximate bonding area 121 of inner sidewall 50a of the neighboring frame portion 12a while remaining closely abutted against this inner surface of area 121, as is evident from
Thus in the assembled filter frame, substantially or essentially all of the area of reinforcing plate 101 of first frame portion 12b may closely abut, e.g. reside upon, the inward surface of corner-proximate bonding area 121 of inner sidewall 50a of the neighboring frame portion, as is evident from
A reinforcing plate 101 may comprise any desired shape and/or size. In some embodiments, a corner-facing side-edge 102 of reinforcing plate 101 (as identified in
Similarly, opposing side-edge 103 of reinforcing plate 101 may be essentially straight and aligned with fold lines 35, 45 and 55; however, in some embodiments it may be at an off-angle relative to these fold lines. Also, it does not necessarily need to be straight. Similarly, downstream edge 104 of reinforcing plate 101 may be straight and/or may closely approach junction 45a of second sidewall portion 12a, but this need not necessarily be the case.
As noted above, a reinforcing plate 101 integrally extends from an end of downstream flange 60 of first frame portion 12b and is integrally, foldably connected to the end of downstream flange 60 of first frame portion 12b by a fold line 106. As defined herein, a reinforcing plate will not integrally extend from (nor be connected to by a fold line) any other flange or sidewall of the first frame piece/portion besides the downstream flange 60. Specifically, a reinforcing plate will not have any portion that extends from the elongate inner sidewall 50b of the first frame portion 12b. Rather, the elongate inner sidewall 50b of the first frame portion 12b will terminate at a terminal end 51 that is positioned at the corner of the frame (as indicated in
A reinforcing plate 101 of a bonded corner as disclosed herein is also distinguished from, for example, a folded flange or flap of the general type disclosed e.g. in U.S. Pat. No. 9,962,640. A folded flap of the general type disclosed in the '640 patent is typically present at an integral corner that results from manipulating the segments of an L-shaped frame piece to provide two frame portions joined at the integral corner. The folded flap results from folding end areas of two segments of frame material together (so that the resulting flap comprises two layers of frame material rather than one) at the corner in order to deal with excess frame material that converges at the integral corner. In other words, such an approach basically involves forming a “dart” in the frame pieces so that an integral corner can be more easily formed. In contrast, the presently-disclosed reinforcing plate comprises a single layer of frame material rather than two layers. Furthermore, a reinforcing plate is at a bonded corner and does not serve the purpose of dealing with excess material at an integral corner.
In some embodiments in which fold line 106 is achieved by cut-scoring, arranging a reinforcing plate 101 in the manner described above may require that plate 101 be “reverse-folded” (relative to downstream flange 60 from which it extends) along fold line 106. This may not cause unacceptable consequences, because in many embodiments reinforcing plate 101 does not necessarily need to be rotated through a very large folding angle in order to reside in inward, substantially coplanar relation with a corner-proximate bonding area 121 of inner sidewall 50a of second frame portion 12a. Rather, plate 101 need only be folded along fold line 106 through a folding angle (e.g. in the range of 40-60 degrees) that will allow it to match the angle of repose α of the inner sidewall 50a of the second frame portion. However, in some embodiments, fold line 106 may be scored by e.g. perforation or crush-scoring rather than by cut-scoring.
In some embodiments, two, three or all four corners of frame 12 may comprise reinforcing plates of the general type described above. The above descriptions will thus apply in similar manner to any such corners. The frame pieces from which such a frame is made can be configured in any suitable manner. For example, in some embodiments each of the four frame pieces may comprise a reinforcing plate at one end and no reinforcing plate at the other end. However, in some embodiments, it may be convenient to use a pair of opposing frame pieces that each have reinforcing plates at both ends (e.g. as in frame piece 13b of
In some embodiments, a part of a frame piece/portion that is bonded to a neighboring frame piece may be an optional reinforcing tab. Such a tab may be used e.g. in addition to an above-described reinforcing plate. Exemplary reinforcing tabs 47 as they may appear on a frame piece (before being folded/assembled into a frame) are shown in
Such an arrangement is shown in exemplary manner in
The fold line 48 may be angled (as evident in
The presence of such a reinforcing tab may further enhance the mechanical strength of a frame corner and/or it may minimize the ability of air to leak through the frame corner. In some embodiments, all four corners of frame 12 may be a tabbed corner of this general type. The frame pieces from which such a frame is made can be configured in any suitable manner. For example, in some embodiments each of the four frame pieces may comprise a tab at one end and no tab at the other end. However, in some embodiments, it may be convenient to use a pair of opposing frame pieces that each have tabs at both ends (e.g. as in frame piece 13b of
In some embodiments, frame pieces may be provided in identical pairs that are in opposing relation to each other. For example, a frame may comprise two opposing frame pieces of the general type shown in
The arrangements disclosed herein can allow the use of frame pieces that are relatively simple in design and are amenable to straightforward scoring, folding, and assembling, in comparison to various complex frame arrangements that are known in the art. This is exemplified by frame piece 13a as depicted in
Similarly, in at least some embodiments a frame piece 13b as depicted in
The elongate length of frame pieces (along a left-right direction of
Frame pieces 13a and/or 13b may be made of any suitable material, e.g. paperboard, plastic, and so on, into which may be imparted score/fold lines as described herein. In particular embodiments, frame pieces may be made of paperboard of thickness in the range of 20-30 thousandths of an inch. In specific embodiments, frame pieces may be made of single-layer paperboard rather than corrugated paperboard. However, in some embodiments any suitable material (e.g. multilayer paperboard) may be used. As noted, paperboard that is used in frame pieces is often coated (e.g. with clay or some other white pigment) for aesthetic purposes, across the entirety of the visible surface of the paperboard, e.g. in the production facility where the paperboard is made. The paperboard is typically printed with indicia, decorative designs, or the like; however, this is typically not done at the paperboard mill but rather at a converter where the paperboard is also die cut, scored, and so on. Often, the paperboard is printed (on the aesthetic side, which will become the visible surface of the assembled frame) and is then overcoated with a protective clear coat or lacquer.
As noted, the frame pieces can be affixed to each other in any suitable manner. In many embodiments, adhesive bonding may be preferred. Any adhesive may be used, relying on any delivery system. In some embodiments a water-based adhesive composition may be used. In other embodiments a 100% solids composition, e.g. a hot-melt adhesive composition, may be used. Any such adhesive(s) may be applied e.g. to a wide area and/or in elongate, e.g. narrow, lines or beads of the general type mentioned elsewhere herein. Any such adhesive may be of any suitable composition, based e.g. on ethylene-vinyl acetate polymers and/or copolymers, styrenic block copolymers, acrylic and acrylate polymers, polyolefins, polyamides, polyesters, and so on. Such an adhesive may be used e.g. at any location at which an area of a first frame portion is closely abutted against an area of a second frame portion. In particular, such a location may be the area of overlap between a reinforcing plate 101 of a first frame portion and a corner-proximate bonding area 121 of an elongate inner sidewall of a second frame portion. Other potentially suitable bonding locations include e.g. areas of overlap between inner sidewalls of neighboring frame portions, between outer sidewalls of neighboring frame portions, and between an inner sidewall of a frame portion and an outer sidewall of a neighboring frame portion and vice versa. Other potentially suitable bonding locations include e.g. areas of overlap between upstream flanges of neighboring frame portions, between downstream flanges of neighboring frame portions, and between a downstream flange of a frame portion and an upstream flange of a neighboring frame portion and vice versa.
It is emphasized that all of the locations described above may be suitable for the placing of an adhesive; any such adhesive need not be placed in every one of these locations. Also, while the discussions above have primarily concerned bonding in order to attach neighboring frame portions to each other at corners of the frame, bonding may also be performed within an individual frame piece. For example, the upstream and downstream flanges of each frame piece may be adhesively bonded to each other along some or all of the elongate length of the frame piece, e.g. in order to further enhance the rigidity of the frame piece and the frame as a whole. In some locations, a border section 7 of filter media 5 may be present in such a location and may also be bonded in this manner.
Any suitable air filter media 5 may be used in filter 1. Air filter media 5 is typically sheet-like, with a length and width that are greater than the thickness of the air filter media and with an overall planar configuration (even if pleated). Although
In some embodiments, filter media 5 (whether pleated or in substantially flat state or otherwise), may include one or more layers comprising e.g. a porous media, a nonwoven scrim, and/or a set of reinforcing members such as e.g. filaments, a netting, a wire mesh, or any such structure(s), which may be provided along with the filter media (e.g., bonded thereto) and which may be made of any suitable material. If the filter media is pleated, such members may help stabilize the pleated structure. An exemplary reinforcing member 9 is visible in
The arrangements disclosed herein may be implemented in any suitable manner. In some embodiments some or all such processes (e.g. folding of frame pieces to form frame portions, mounting of frame portions on edges of filter media, affixing ends of frame portions to ends of neighboring frame portions, affixing the filter media to the frame, and so on) may be performed manually. In some embodiments, some of all of such processes may be performed e.g. by robotic machinery. In some embodiments robotic machinery may perform any or all of the following operations: deposit elongate adhesive beads on hidden surfaces of selected panels of frame pieces (e.g., panels that will form upstream and downstream flanges of the finished frame); fold frame pieces into frame portions; mount frame portions onto the edges of filter media; bring together the ends of frame portions to form corners; and, hold the thus-formed frame in position for a sufficient time for the adhesive to harden.
Prototype compression frames were made of the general type illustrated in the Figures herein. The frames were nominal 20″×25″×1″ and were made of kraft single-layer paperboard of a type commonly used to make compression frames for air filters. The Working Example frames comprised a reinforcing plate that extended from a downstream flange of one frame portion onto an inner sidewall of a neighboring frame portion (very similar to plate 101 as shown in
Comparative Examples of two types were made. The first type of Comparative Example was conventional compression frames in which various areas of the flanges and sidewalls were adhesively bonded to each other in the usual manner. Reinforcing tabs were also present and were bonded in similar manner as in the Working Example frames. The overall design, shape, size, etc. of these frames was the same as for the Working Example frames. This first type of Comparative Example was thus generally equivalent to the Working Examples except that no reinforcing plates were present.
The second type of Comparative Example was similar to the first type of Comparative Example, except that each corner of the frame included a stabilizing flap that extended from an inner sidewall of one frame portion onto an inner sidewall of a neighboring frame portion and was adhesively bonded thereto. These stabilizing flaps were present at all four corners of the frame. Reinforcing tabs were also present and were bonded in similar manner as in the Working Example frames. The overall design, shape, size, etc. of these frames was the same as for the Working Example frames. This second type of Comparative Example was thus generally equivalent to the Working Examples excepting that stabilizing flaps were used rather than the herein-disclosed reinforcing plates.
Thus in these Examples, evaluations were performed of Working Example compression frames in which the frame corners were braced by reinforcing plates that extended from downstream flanges to inner sidewalls of neighboring frame portions, in comparison to conventional compression frames (with no added corner-bracing) and in comparison to compression frames in which the frame corners were braced by stabilizing flaps that extended from inner sidewalls to inner sidewalls of neighboring frame portions.
Samples of the various framed air filters were mounted into a fixture and subjected to out-of-plane twisting forces; results were reported as Minimum Torque in inch-pounds. Multiple samples were evaluated and results averaged. The Comparative Example first type samples (conventional compression frames) exhibited an average Minimum Torque of approximately 12.7 inch-pounds. The Comparative Example second type samples (with stabilizing flaps) exhibited a slightly higher Minimum Torque, of approximately 13.2 inch-pounds. The Working Example samples exhibited a Minimum Torque of approximately 14.3 inch-pounds.
These results indicated that bracing frame corners by way of reinforcing plates as disclosed herein can provide resistance to out-of-plane twisting that is noticeably higher than that of conventional compression frames. Furthermore, bracing frame corners by reinforcing plates as disclosed herein is found to provide noticeably higher resistance to out-of-plane twisting than bracing frame corners by stabilizing flaps that extend between inner sidewalls of neighboring frame portions.
Working Example frames and framed air filters were also generated at a large-scale manufacturing facility using production equipment (although the frames and filters were produced on a limited-number, pilot scale). The frames and filters, as made, were very similar to those in the above-described Working Examples and exhibited similar behavior.
It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the specific exemplary embodiments, elements, structures, features, details, arrangements, configurations, etc., that are disclosed herein can be modified and/or combined in numerous ways. It is emphasized that any embodiment disclosed herein may be used in combination with any other embodiment or embodiments disclosed herein, as long as the embodiments are compatible. While a limited number of exemplary combinations are presented herein, it is emphasized that all such combinations are envisioned.
Numerous variations and combinations are contemplated as being within the bounds of the conceived invention, not merely those representative designs that were chosen to serve as exemplary illustrations. Thus, the scope of the present invention is not limited to the specific illustrative structures described herein, but rather extends at least to the structures described by the language of the claims, and the equivalents of those structures. Any of the elements that are positively recited in this specification as alternatives may be explicitly included in the claims or excluded from the claims, in any combination as desired. Any of the elements or combinations of elements that are recited in this specification in open-ended language (e.g., comprise and derivatives thereof), are considered to additionally be recited in closed-ended language (e.g., consist and derivatives thereof) and in partially closed-ended language (e.g., consist essentially, and derivatives thereof). To the extent that there is any conflict or discrepancy between this specification and the disclosure in any document that is incorporated by reference herein but to which no priority is claimed, this specification as written will control.
This application claims priority from U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 63/429,690, filed 2 Dec. 2022, the disclosure of which is incorporated by reference in its/their entirety herein.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63429690 | Dec 2022 | US |