The present invention relates to frozen aerated confections, such as ice cream. In particular, it relates to frozen aerated confections that contain oils which are high in polyunsaturated fat, such as sunflower oil, and methods for producing them.
Frozen aerated confections, such as ice creams, sorbets and the like are popular foodstuffs. Typically they are aerated to an overrun of about 100%. Fat is an important constituent of such confections. Conventionally, frozen aerated confections have been prepared with fats having a high proportion of saturated fat, for example dairy fat (60-65%) or coconut oil (90%), together with emulsifiers such as mono/di-glycerides of fatty acids. Typically the emulsifiers are present at about 0.1% by weight of the confection. Emulsifiers and saturated fats are conventionally considered essential for the creation of stable foams, and hence for ice cream that can be aerated to the desired overrun, and which has good consumer properties such as texture and meltdown (see for example, “Ice Cream”, 6th Edition R. T. Marshall, H. D. Goff and R. W. Hartel, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York 2003, pages 36, 42-43 and 69 or “The Science of Ice Cream”, C. Clarke, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, 2004, pages 4648 and 62-73). Briefly, the reasons for this are as follows.
The standard manufacturing process for frozen aerated confections is described in detail in, for example, “Ice Cream”, 6th Edition, chapters 6, 7 and 9. It consists of a number of steps: (i) mixing the ingredients, (ii) pasteurisation and homogenisation, (iii) ageing, (iv) aerating and partially freezing the mix in an ice cream freezer (v) drawing the partially frozen aerated confection from the freezer and (vi) hardening. Hardening is necessary because as the ice cream mix passes through the freezer, its temperature decreases and its ice content increases. This results in an increase in the viscosity of the mix, so more power is required to rotate the dasher. This extra energy is dissipated in the mix as heat, which must be removed by the refrigerant. For this reason, the partially frozen ice cream is drawn from the freezer when it reaches about −5 or −6° C. (see for example page 190 of Ice Cream, 6th Edition or page 75 of “The Science of Ice Cream”). At this temperature the ice cream is soft and unstable, and it must then be further cooled (“hardened”) to its storage temperature (typically −18° C. or lower).
After pasteurization and homogenisation the fat exists as small droplets. Milk proteins readily adsorb to the bare surfaces of the fat droplets and stabilise the emulsion. During ageing, the emulsifiers adsorb to the surface of the fat droplets, replacing some of the milk protein. This makes the emulsion less stable because the mixed membrane of protein and emulsifiers is weaker than the membrane of protein alone. During freezing and aeration, the mix is sheared. The shear causes the fat droplets collide with each other. If emulsifiers were not added, the fat droplets would resist this coalescence, due to the strong protein membrane on the fat droplets. However, if the membrane is weakened, the fat droplets can coalesce. Thus despite their name, the function of emulsifiers in ice cream is to de-emulsify the fat. When the fat droplets are partly liquid and partly solid, they partially coalesce, i.e. they form a cluster but retain some of their individual identity. Partially coalesced fat (also known as de-stabilized or de-emulsified fat) stabilizes air bubbles. Saturated fats are conventionally used because they are mostly solid at the temperatures at which freezing and aeration take place in an ice cream freezer, and therefore they undergo partial coalescence. Liquid fat droplets on the other hand coalesce completely, which leads to an unstable air phase resulting in low overrun.
Health-conscious consumers are now looking for frozen aerated confections which have all the properties of these traditional products but which are healthier. Attempts have therefore been made to produce frozen aerated confections in which saturated fats are replaced by polyunsaturated fats. However, it has not been possible simply to replace the saturated fats in ice cream formulations with unsaturated fats (which are liquid at ambient temperatures) and obtain the desired meltdown characteristics and mouthfeel for the consumer, because unsaturated fats do not contain sufficient solid fat. The mix is difficult to aerate in the ice cream freezer and as a result, the ice cream has a very low overrun.
WO 97/30600 discloses an unaerated ice cream formulated with sunflower oil and mono/di-glycerides. Since the ice cream is unaerated, there is no need to use solid fat. JP 57/036944 describes the production of ice cream with oils that are high in polyunsaturated fatty acids, such as safflower oil and sunflower oil. It was found that an overrun of only 30% could be achieved with a standard formulation containing a conventional emulsifier. To overcome the problem of producing good ice cream with liquid fat, it was found necessary to use a specific emulsifier, namely a sucrose fatty acid ester.
JP 57/068742 discloses ice cream made from safflower oil. It was found that an overrun of at most 45% could be achieved when a glycerol fatty acid ester emulsifier was used. To produce ice cream having an overrun of more than 60% it was found necessary to add a significant amount of a non-dairy protein, such as soy protein. However, such additives can detract from the natural, dairy and healthy perception of the product by consumers and also add cost. There is a need therefore to provide frozen aerated confections containing high levels of polyunsaturated fats which have good processing and consumer properties (such as aeration, texture and meltdown), but which do not suffer from these disadvantages.
Unless defined otherwise, all technical and scientific terms used herein have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art (e.g. in frozen food manufacture). Definitions and descriptions of various terms and techniques used in frozen confectionery manufacture are found in “Ice Cream”, 6th Edition. With the exception of percentages cited in relation to the overrun, all percentages, unless otherwise stated, refer to the approximate percentage by weight of the total composition.
Frozen Aerated Confection
The term “frozen aerated confection” as used in this specification means a sweet-tasting fabricated foodstuff intended for consumption in the frozen state (i.e. under conditions wherein the temperature of the foodstuff is less than 0° C., and preferably under conditions wherein the foodstuff comprises a significant amount of ice). Frozen aerated confections are made by freezing a pasteurised mix of ingredients. Overrun is typically produced by intentionally incorporating gas into the product, such as by mechanical agitation. The gas can be any food-grade gas such as air, nitrogen or carbon dioxide. Typical examples of frozen aerated confections include ice creams.
Fat
Fats are largely made up of triglycerides (approximately 98%), together with minor amounts of other components such as phospholipids and diglycerides. Triglycerides are esters of glycerol with three fatty acids. Fatty acids which have no carbon-carbon double bonds are said to be saturated (herein abbreviated as SAFA), whereas fatty acids that contain one or more carbon-carbon double bonds are said to be monounsaturated (abbreviated as MUFA) and polyunsaturated (PUFA) respectively. Fats that are liquid at ambient temperatures are often referred to as oils. In this specification the term “fat” includes such oils. The SAFA, MUFA and PUFA contents of fats and oils are given in “The Lipid Handbook”, Second Edition, Authors Frank D Gunstone, John L Harwood, Fred B Padley, Published by Chapman & Hall 1994.
Oil bodies (also known as oleosomes, lipid bodies or spheresomes) are discrete subcellular structures found in the seeds of oilseed crops in which the oil is naturally encapsulated by a monolayer of phospholipids in which proteins (known as oleosins) are embedded. As used herein, the term fat refers to fats and oils extracted from such sources, and therefore does not include oil bodies.
Milk Proteins
Sources of milk protein include milk, concentrated milk, milk powders (such as skimmed milk powder), caseins, caseinates (such as sodium and/or calcium caseinates) whey, whey powders and whey protein concentratesasolates. Sources of milk protein generally also comprise other materials. For example, skimmed milk powder typically comprises 37% milk protein, 55% lactose and 8% milk minerals.
Sweetener
Sweetener means a mono-, di- or oligo-saccharide containing from three to ten monosaccharide units joined in glycosidic linkage, or a corn syrup, or a sugar alcohol, or a mixture thereof. Sweeteners include sucrose, fructose, lactose (for example from the source of milk protein), dextrose, invert sugar, corn syrup and sorbitol.
Free Sugars
The term “free sugars” is defined as in “Diet, nutrition and the prevention of chronic diseases”—Report of a Joint WHO/FAO Expert Consultation, WHO Technical Report Series 916, WHO, Geneva, 2003. Thus free sugars are all mono and disaccharides added by the manufacturer, cook or consumer plus sugar naturally present and sourced from honey, syrups and juices. Free sugars do not include sugars naturally present and sourced from fruit or milk.
Emulsifiers
Emulsifiers are described in “Ice Cream”, 6th Edition, pages 85-86. The term “emulsifier” as used herein includes mono- and di-glycerides of saturated or unsaturated fatty acids (e.g. monoglyceryl palmitate—MGP), polyoxyethylene derivatives of hexahydric alcohols (usually sorbitol), glycols, glycol esters, polyglycerol esters, sorbitan esters, stearoyl lactylate, acetic acid esters, lactic acid esters, citric acid esters, acetylated monoglyceride, diacetyl tartaric acid esters, polyoxyethylene sorbitan esters (such as polysorbate 80), sucrose esters, lecithin, egg, egg yolk and surface active proteins and protein derivatives (other than milk protein), for example soy protein and whipping agents derived from soy protein. The term also includes mixtures of any the above. However, the term “emulsifier” as used herein does not include milk proteins. As pointed out above, fats and oils may include small amounts of substances such as mono or diglycerides or phospholipids. The term “emulsifier” does not include such molecules when they are naturally present in the fat in small quantities.
Overrun
The overrun of ice cream (and other frozen aerated confections) is defined by
Overrun is measured at atmospheric pressure.
Measuring Overrun
The density of the unaerated mix is determined by weighing a standard overrun cup containing mix at approximately 4° C., subtracting the mass of the cup and dividing by the known volume of the cup (density=mass/volume). A minimum of three repeat measurements is taken. The density of the (aerated) ice cream is determined by repeating the procedure using the same overrun cup with freshly drawn ice cream (at typically −5° C. to −6° C.). Again a minimum of three repeat measurements is taken. With a knowledge of the density of both unaerated mix and aerated ice cream, the overrun can be calculated using the equation given above.
Meltdown
Resistance to meltdown and to serum leakage is determined by measuring the rate at which ice cream melts in a constant temperature environment, as follows. Stainless steel wire mesh grids having a size of 25×25 cm, with 3 mm holes, 1 mm thick wire are placed on a 60° funnel with a bore size of 2 cm suspended over a collecting vessel (of large enough volume to collect the entire sample tested). The collecting vessel is placed on a balance for weighing the material collected in the vessel. The balances are connected to a data logging system to record the mass collected. The apparatus consisting of grid, funnel, vessel and balance, is contained in a cabinet set at a constant temperature of 20° C. The cabinet is capable of holding up to 12 of these sets of apparatus simultaneously.
Ice cream samples in the form of rectangular blocks measuring 14.5×9×3.8 cm are equilibrated in a freezer at −25° C., and then weighed on a zeroed balance with the grid (one of the largest flat faces of the sample is in contact with the grid). The samples are then arranged randomly over the available positions in the meltdown cabinet. Once all samples are in place on the funnels, the data logging system records the amount of collected material every minute. From the mass of the sample collected over this period, the percentage mass loss of the samples is calculated using the following formula.
wherein:
The meltdown initiation time is defined as the time that elapses before 4% of the initial weight of the sample has dropped into the collecting vessel. At least three samples are measured per product, and the mean of these is recorded.
Contrary to conventional wisdom, we have found that palatable and stable aerated frozen confections that contain significant amounts of polyunsaturated fat can be prepared when the confection is substantially free from emulsifier, provided that the temperature at which the frozen aerated confection is drawn from the ice cream freezer is below −4.0° C. Accordingly, in a first aspect the present invention provides a frozen aerated confection comprising water; a fat component in an amount of 2 to 12% by weight of the frozen aerated confection wherein at least 35% by weight of the fatty acids in the fat component are polyunsaturated; less than 0.04% emulsifier by weight of the frozen confection; milk protein; and sweetener; characterised in that the frozen aerated confection has an overrun of from 60 to 200%.
Preferably the frozen aerated confection comprises less than 0.02%, more preferably less than 0.01% total emulsifier by weight of the frozen confection. Most preferably, the frozen aerated confection contains no emulsifier. Emulsifiers in such compositions can result in ice cream with poor aeration and texture, and can also detract from the natural, dairy image of the product.
The higher the amount of polyunsaturated fatty acids, the greater the health benefit. Thus it is preferable that the fat comprises at least 40% polyunsaturated fatty acids by weight of the fat, more preferably at least 45% or 50% and optimally at least 60%.
Preferably the fat comprises at least 80% more preferably at least 90%, and even more preferably at least 95% by weight of the fat of a vegetable oil selected from the group consisting of sunflower oil, safflower oil, linseed oil, soybean oil, walnut oil, corn oil, grape seed oil, sesame oil, wheat germ oil, cottonseed oil and mixtures thereof. Particularly preferred is sunflower oil owing to its clean flavour, high poly-unsaturated fat content and wide availability.
Preferably the fat component comprises at least 4% fat by weight of the confection, more preferably at least 6%. Preferably the fat component comprises at most 10% fat by weight of the confection, more preferably at most 9%.
Preferably the overrun is at least 70%, more preferably at least 80%. It is preferable that the overrun does not exceed 150%, however, otherwise the confection does not exhibit the cold mouth-feel conventionally associated with frozen confections. More preferably the overrun is less than 130%.
In order to aid in aeration during manufacture of the frozen confection it is preferable that the confection comprises milk protein in an amount of at least 1% by weight of the frozen confection, more preferably greater than 2%. In order to prevent the confection from exhibiting a chalky mouth-feel, however, it is also preferable that the protein content is less than 8%, more preferably less than 6% by weight of the frozen confection. Milk proteins provide good flavour, heat stability and surface activity.
Preferably the frozen aerated confection contains substantially no protein other than milk proteins, for example less than 0.5% by weight of proteins other than milk protein.
In order to provide the customary sweetness associated with frozen aerated confections and to avoid the confection being unduly hard, it is preferable that the frozen aerated confection comprises sweeteners in an amount of at least 10% by weight of the frozen confection, more preferably at least 15%, most preferably at least 17%. To avoid the frozen aerated confection being too sweet, the amount of sweeteners should be at most 35%, preferably at most 30%, most preferably at most 25% by weight of the confection.
A preferred sweetener is lactose, especially when added as part of the milk solids. This is because lactose has a relatively low molecular weight (and therefore provides excellent freezing point depression) but is neither overly sweet nor counted among the unhealthy free sugars (when added as part of the milk solids). Thus it is preferable that lactose is present in an amount of at least 3% by weight of the frozen confection, preferably at least 4%. In order to avoid crystallisation of the lactose, however, it is also preferred that the lactose is present in an amount of less than 9%, preferably less than 8% by weight of the frozen confection.
In order to increase the appeal of the frozen aerated confection to health conscious consumers, it is preferable that the amount of free sugars is less than 17% by weight of the frozen aerated confection, preferably less than 15%.
The frozen aerated confections may include optional ingredients e.g. stabilisers, such as alginates, gum arabic, gum ghatti, gum karaya, gum tragacanth, locust bean gum, carrageenans, xanthan gum, guar gum, gelatine, agar, sodium carboxymethylcellulose, microcrystalline cellulose, methyl and methylethyl celluloses, hydroxypropyl and hydroxypropylmethyl celluloses, low and high methoxyl pectins and mixtures thereof.
The frozen aerated confections may also include colours and flavours. We have found that frozen aerated confections according to the invention have a good taste even though they contain no milk fat provided that flavours are added.
Preferably the frozen aerated confection has a meltdown initiation time of greater than 40 minutes, more preferably greater than 50 minutes, even more preferably greater than 60 minutes, most preferably greater than 70 minutes when measured at 20° C. in the test described above. We have found that ice creams made from fats rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids have increased meltdown initiation times when they are drawn from the ice cream freezer at low temperatures.
In a second aspect the present invention provides a process for manufacturing a frozen aerated confection comprising the steps of:
Preferably the frozen aerated confection is drawn from the ice cream freezer at a temperature of below −5.0° C., more preferably below −6.0° C., −6.5° C. −7.0° C. or −7.5° C., most preferably below −8.0° C. It has been found that the lower the temperature at which the frozen aerated confection is drawn from the freezer, the slower the meltdown of the hardened frozen aerated confection.
Preferably the process further comprises hardening the frozen aerated confection after step (d). Typically the hardening temperature is in the range −17 to −40° C., preferably −20 to −35° C.
In a third aspect the present invention provides a product obtained by the methods of the invention. Also provided is a product obtainable by the methods of the invention.
The present invention will be further described in the following examples which are illustrative only and non-limiting, and by reference to the figures which show meltdown results for ice creams according to the invention.
Ice cream mixes were prepared from five different ice cream formulations labelled 1-5 in Table 1. These differ in their sugars, total solids, milk proteins and fat contents. None of the formulations contains any emulsifier.
Raftilose P95 is 95% oligofructose in powder form supplied by Orafti. The corn syrups were supplied by Cerestar. 63DE is a glucose-fructose syrup (C*Sweet F 017Y4) containing 22% water, 55% mono and disaccharides and 23% other solids. 38DE is a spray-dried glucose syrup (C*Dry GL 01934) containing 5% water, 36.5% mono and disaccharides and 58.5% other solids. 28DE is a spray-dried glucose syrup (C*Dry GL01924) containing 4% water, 14% mono and disaccharides and 82% other solids.
Mixes were prepared as follows. Water at 80° C. was added into a tank equipped with a turbo mixer. The dry sugars were mixed with the stabilisers and added to the tank followed by the skimmed milk powder, liquid sugars, oil and flavours. The mix was blended for about 10 minutes at 60-70° C. The mix was then homogenised at 150 bar and pasteurised at 82° C. for 25 seconds in a plate heat exchanger. The mix was then cooled to 4° C. in the plate heat exchanger and aged overnight in an ageing tank at 4° C., with gentle stirring.
Mixes 1-5 were aerated (target overrun 100%) and frozen in an ice cream freezer (Crepaco WO4 scraped surface heat exchanger) fitted with a series 15 open dasher. The resulting ice creams were labelled examples 1-5. Mix 2 was also aerated and frozen using a series 80 closed dasher and the resulting ice cream was labelled example 6. Partially frozen ice cream was drawn from the freezer into 500 ml cardboard boxes. The draw temperature is controlled by the load on the motor which rotates the dasher. The motor load is coupled with the refrigerating power, so that they are increased together. Thus higher motor load allows the rotating dasher to churn more viscous partially frozen ice cream, so that the ice cream can be drawn from the freezer at a lower temperature. The actual draw temperature depends on the ice cream formulation. Motor loads of 30%, 60% and 85% were used, corresponding to draw temperatures in the range −4.4 to −8.3° C. These are summarised in Table 2. Finally, the ice cream was hardened by blast freezing at −35° C. for 3 hours and stored at −25° C. prior to testing.
The mixes all processed very well through the ice cream freezer, both when the open dasher and the closed dasher were used. The ice cream flow was generally smooth and continuous with few air pockets. The overrun was measured on leaving the freezer using an overrun cup as described above. All of the ice creams achieved the target overrun of 100% (±5%). All of the ice creams were acceptable when eaten. They had a smooth texture and creamy flavour, and melted quite rapidly in the mouth. These examples show that palatable and stable aerated frozen confections can be prepared that contain significant amounts of polyunsaturated fat provided that the frozen aerated confection is drawn from the freezer below −4.0° C. and that emulsifier is not used.
Meltdown tests as described above were performed on each sample. The meltdown data are plotted in
Table 3 shows the draw temperature and meltdown initiation time for each sample. It is apparent from this data that ice creams made with a fat high in PUFA have longer meltdown initiation times when they have been drawn from the freezer at lower temperatures. The lowest draw temperature (−8.3° C. for formulation 1) had the longest meltdown initiation time (90 minutes).
Ice creams produced with low draw temperatures were also preferred by an informal taste panel. In summary, these results show that ice creams made with a fat high in PUFA and no emulsifier have improved meltdown properties and texture when they are drawn from the ice cream freezer at relatively low temperatures. The lower the draw temperature, the slower the meltdown.
The various features of the embodiments of the present invention referred to in individual sections above apply, as appropriate, to other sections mutatis mutandis. Consequently features specified in one section may be combined with features specified in other sections as appropriate.
All publications mentioned in the above specification are herein incorporated by reference. Various modifications and variations of the described methods and products of the invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art without departing from the scope of the invention. Although the invention has been described in connection with specific preferred embodiments, it should be understood that the invention as claimed should not be unduly limited to such specific embodiments. Indeed, various modifications of the described modes for carrying out the invention which are apparent to those skilled in the relevant fields are intended to be within the scope of the following claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
EP05252447 | Apr 2005 | EP | regional |
EP05252453 | Apr 2005 | EP | regional |
EP05252425 | Apr 2005 | EP | regional |