Patent Grant
9008951
The present invention relates to a fuel admission control unit to control a diesel engine that is provided with an EGR (an Exhaust Gas Re-circulation) system by which a part of exhaust gas is returned as EGR gas to an air intake system of the diesel engine.
The EGR (Exhaust Gas Re-circulation) method is known as a technology that is used for reducing problematic NOx (nitrogen oxide) in exhaust gas emitted from a diesel engine. On the other hand, when the EGR method is applied, the amount of a fresh air (a fresh intake air flow rate) inhaled by the engine decreases relatively which is prone to cause an O2-deprived (oxygen-deprived) atmosphere in a combustion chamber of the engine when the engine is rapidly accelerated or a fuel admission opening of the engine is rapidly increased.
In order to overcome the above-mentioned difficulty, increasing the amount of the fresh intake air by constraining EGR gas flow rate seems to be a possible countermeasure. However, since control response speed as to an EGR system is slower, controlling the EGR gas flow rate is not enough, and thus, it is required to provide a countermeasure as to a fuel injection system control which has a faster control response speed.
However, it must be taken into consideration that the fuel admission (accelerator opening) control independent of engine load control or engine speed control may hinder the engine speed stability. In other words, ensuring compatibility between the exhaust gas performance and the engine speed response performance is a technical prerequisite.
For instance, a patent reference 1 (JP1999-36962) discloses a fuel admission control method by which the amount of exhaust gas smoke of a diesel engine produced when accelerated does not exceed a target density. In the method of the reference 1, a maximum fuel mass quantity in relation to the fresh intake air flow rate and the engine rotation speed, whereby the exhaust gas smoke is not produced, is set as a map in advance, and with the determined maximum fuel mass quantity based on the detected fresh intake air flow rate and the detected engine rotation speed, production of the exhaust gas smoke is controlled.
Further, a patent reference 2 (JP1997-151761) discloses an injection annealing control in which the fuel flow rate is gradually increased with a constant increment to a constant increment, while an EGR valve opening is controlled, so that the exhaust gas smoke due to the slow response of the EGR system is not produced during the engine acceleration, and the performance of the engine acceleration is kept satisfactory. However, in the technology of the patent reference 1, a lot of man-hours are required in creating the above-mentioned map that prescribes a maximum fuel mass quantity; on the other hand, in the control technology of the patent reference 2, there is no consideration as to residual O2 (oxygen) in the EGR gas that returns back into the combustion chamber (or the intake air system of the engine) from the engine exhaust system, although the residual O2 (or the residual air that is not used in burning fuel) that has not been consumed in the former engine combustion stroke has an essential effect on the smoke yielding in the next combustion stroke.
In view of the above-stated conventional technologies and anticipated solutions thereof, the present disclosure aims at providing a fuel admission control unit to control a diesel engine, with which ensuring compatibility between the exhaust gas performance (not excessive exhaust temperature performance, lower smoke emission, lower NOx emission and so on) and the engine speed response performance is achieved by a simple control with a consideration of the residual oxygen in the EGR gas
In order to achieve the goals as mentioned, the present specification discloses
According to the invention such as the above, the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means calculates the estimation excess air ratio λs by use of the quantity of the fuel injected by the fuel injection valve into the cylinder, the intake air flow rate measured by the air flow meter, and the flow rate of the residual air (the not-consumed air) in the EGR gas that returns back into the intake air system; thus, the estimation excess air ratio λs is calculated in consideration of the residual oxygen (the oxygen which is not used for the combustion in the cylinder, and returns back into the intake air passage) that has an impact on the engine smoke emission.
Further, since the accelerator opening (the fuel admission) is controlled based on the estimation excess air ratio λs, the control can be performed so that the oxygen ratio in the cylinder air or gas can be reflected on the control. Thus, even when a hard acceleration (a rapid increase as to the accelerator opening) is performed during the EGR system operation, the smoke emission, the NOx emission, and the engine speed response deterioration due to the oxygen shortage in the combustion chamber can be restrained.
Moreover, it is preferable that the fuel admission control means of the present invention is provided with an accelerator opening controlling means by which a rate of change of the accelerator opening is limited lower than or equal to a predetermined value when the estimation excess air ratio λs computed by the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means is lower than or equal to a prescribed level.
According to the above invention, when the estimation excess air ratio λs exists in a range lower than or equal to a constant value, the accelerator opening controlling means limits the rate of change of the accelerator opening so that the rate of change does not exceed a limitation level; thus, even when a hard acceleration (a rapid increase as to the accelerator opening) is performed during the EGR system operation, the smoke emission deterioration due to the oxygen shortage in the combustion chamber, the NOx emission deterioration, and the engine speed response deterioration can be restrained.
According to a preferable example of the above aspect, the accelerator opening controlling means uses a predetermined table that prescribes the relation between the estimation excess air ratio λs and the maximum rate of change of the accelerator opening.
According to the above example, the allowable maximum limit as to the rate of change of the accelerator opening can be easily adjusted by arranging the predetermined relation table that prescribes the relation between the estimation excess air ratio λs and the maximum allowable accelerator opening. Therefore, the trade-off relation between the smoke emission and the engine speed response can be easily adjusted.
According to a preferable aspect of the present invention, the fuel admission control means is provided with an accelerator opening controlling means by which the accelerator opening is controlled so that the estimation excess air ratio λs computed by the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means tracks a target excess air ratio λm that is pre-programmed or prescribed.
According to the above aspect, the control unit is provided with the accelerator opening controlling means, whereby the accelerator opening is corrected (amended in a feedback system) so that the prescribed target excess air ratio λm is followed up by the estimation excess air ratio λs which is calculated by the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means; thus, a finer control as to the rate of change of the acceleration opening is performed in the second embodiment than in the first embodiment; in this way, the estimation excess air ratio λs is accurately controlled so that the air or oxygen content in EGR gas is taken into consideration, whereby the air or oxygen content has a direct influence on the smoke emission level. As a result, the engine smoke emission can be restrained.
Moreover, in a transient state during acceleration, the EGR valve is closed for the purpose of either smoke reduction or response improvement; in closing the valve, the air or gas condition in the inlet manifold varies so that the combustion temperature and the NOx emission level increase. This difficulty can be solved by the above invention, since the estimation excess air ratio λs can be accurately controlled, the EGR valve can be moderately (not rapidly) closed, and the estimation excess air ratio λs can be controlled through a quick response of the fuel injection control (the fuel admission control). Therefore, smoke restraint together with NOx reduction can be achieved.
According to a preferable aspect of the present invention, the fuel flow rate is controlled under a condition that the rate of change of the accelerator opening exceeds a prescribed level under the quick acceleration, as well asunder a condition that the rate of change of the accelerator opening is not less than another prescribed level.
According to the above aspect, the engine can be free from the across-the-board fuel limitation (the indiscriminate limitation) during a high load operation where the excess air ratio is low.
According to a preferable aspect of the present invention, the fuel admission control unit comprises,
as a substitute of the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means, an oxygen concentration meter that detects the oxygen concentration of an intake air passage at the down stream side of the position where an EGR passage joins the intake air passage, and
the fuel flow rate under quick acceleration is controlled based on the oxygen concentration detected by the oxygen concentration meter.
According to the above aspect, the oxygen concentration in the gas including the intake air and the EGR gas is directly detected by means of the oxygen concentration meter which is installed at the inlet manifold that is an air or gas passage at the down stream side of the confluence as to the EGR passage and the intake air passage; the fuel injection control (the fuel admission control) is performed so that the detected oxygen concentration is reflected on the control; thus, the fuel injection control can be simplified in comparison with the before-described manner in which the intake gas pressure and temperature are detected so that the estimation excess air ratio λs is calculated through the predetermined formulae.
In addition, the reduction of the oxygen concentration is directly evaluated whereby the reduction causes the engine smoke emission; thus, the fuel injection control which reflects the reduction of the oxygen concentration can surely restrain the smoke emission.
As described above, the present invention can provide a fuel admission control unit to control a diesel engine, whereby the control is simple; even the residual oxygen in the EGR gas is taken into consideration; the exhaust gas performance is compatible with the engine speed response performance.
Hereafter, the present invention will be described in detail in consultation with the embodiments shown in the figures. However, the dimensions, materials, shape, the relative placement and so on of a component described in these embodiments shall not be construed as limiting the scope of the invention thereto, unless especially specific mention is made.
In the engine 1, a combustion chamber 9 is formed over the top surface of the piston 5 and within the inner surface of the cylinder 3; an intake air passage 13 is connected to the combustion chamber 9 via an intake air port that is opened and closed by an intake valve 15. Further, an exhaust gas passage 19 is connected to the combustion chamber 9 via an exhaust gas port that is opened and closed by an exhaust valve 21.
On a part way of the exhaust gas passage 19, an EGR (Exhaust Gas Re-circulation) passage 23 is branched so as to merge with the intake air passage 13 at the down stream side of an intake air throttle valve 29. On the EGR passage 23, an EGR cooler 25 that cools the EGR gas stream in the EGR passage 23 is provided, and, at the downstream side of the EGR cooler 25, an EGR valve 27 is also provided for regulating the flow rate of the EGR gas.
The opening of the intake air throttle valve 29 is controlled so as to regulate the flow rate of the intake air inhaled into the combustion chamber 9. In the case of diesel engines, the opening of the intake air throttle valve 29 is operated in the direction that closes the intake air throttle valve 29 when an EGR control is performed, but usually, the throttle valve 29 is kept in its fully opened condition, and excess air ratio is controlled by the fuel flow rate.
A fuel injection valve 31 is installed in each cylinder of the engine 1 for injecting fuel pressurized by a fuel injection pump (not shown) into the combustion chamber 9, and the fuel amount per shot and the injection timing are controlled by a control unit (a fuel admission control means) 33. The control unit 33 also controls the fuel injection timing so that the fuel is injected at a predetermined point of time; in general, the injection timing can be variably controlled.
An air flow meter 35 that measures the flow rate of the fresh intake air which is inhaled into the combustion chamber 9 is fitted on a part way of the intake air passage 13, upstream to the air throttle valve 29; from the air flow meter 35, signals as to the flow-rate of the fresh air are inputted into the control unit 33. Similarly, an EGR gas flow meter 37 that measures the (volume) flow rate of the EGR gas which streams into the intake air passage 13 from the EGR gas passage 23 is fitted on a part way of the EGR gas passage 23, upstream to the EGR valve 27; from the EGR gas flow meter 37, the signals as to the flow-rate of the EGR gas are inputted into the control unit 33.
Further, the engine is provided with an inlet manifold pressure sensor 39 that detects pressure in an inlet manifold of the engine, and an inlet manifold temperature sensor 41 that detects temperature in the inlet manifold; from the sensors 39 and 41, pressure signals and temperature signals are inputted into the control unit 33.
Further, signals from an engine speed sensor 43 which detects engine speed, and an accelerator sensor 45 which detects the stepping amount on the accelerator or the operation amount of accelerator-wheels, etc. are inputted to the control unit 33.
Hereinafter, the control unit 33 is explained. The control unit 33 according to the first embodiment comprises an estimation excess air ratio λs computing means 47 that is an arithmetic section to compute an estimation excess air ratio λ in the cylinder 3 from the quantity of the fuel injected by the fuel injection valve 31 into the cylinder 3, the intake air flow rate measured by the air flow meter 35, and the flow rate of the residual oxygen in the EGR gas that flows back to the intake air passage 13.
Further, the control unit 33 comprises an estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 that is an arithmetic section to evaluate whether the estimation excess air ratio λs which is computed by the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means 47 is smaller than or equal to a threshold value or not, and when the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 evaluates that the estimation excess air ratio λs is lower than or equal to the threshold value, an accelerator opening controlling means 50 provided in the control unit 33 limits the rate of change of the accelerator opening below a predetermined value.
In connection with a flow chart in
After an accelerator opening limitation process is started at Step S1, an accelerator-opening signal is read into the unit 33 at Step S2. The accelerator-opening signal changes on an hour-by-hour basis, as depicted in
In Step S4, the rate of change of the accelerator opening is calculated based on the accelerator-opening signals that have been read in at Step S2. The rate of change of the accelerator opening corresponds to the slope (the gradient) of the accelerator-opening curve (line) as depicted in
In Step S5, based on the threshold values H1 and H2, the control unit 33 determines whether the accelerator opening is to be limited or not. More specifically, when the rate of change of the accelerator opening is greater than or equal to the value H1, the control unit 33 determines that the limitation is to be effective, on the other hand, when the rate of change of the accelerator opening becomes lower than or equal to the value H2, then the control unit 33 determines that the limitation is to be ineffective; accordingly, an effective flag or an ineffective flag is set. In
In this way, only when the rate of change of the accelerator opening is greater than or equal to an constant value, the accelerator opening limitation is performed. Therefore, the engine can be free from the across-the-board fuel limitation (the indiscriminate limitation) even during a high load operation where the excess air ratio is low.
In Step S6, the estimation excess air ratio λs is calculated by the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means 47 by the use of the following formulae (1) and (2):
whereby,
The intake air mass flow rate Ga in the formula (1) is calculated by use of a detected signal from the air flow meter 35; the EGR gas mass flow rate Gegr is calculated through numerical computations based on the EGR gas flow rate detected by the EGR gas flow meter 37 or a measurement as to the pressure drop of the EGR gas through the EGR cooler 25. Hereby, it is noted that the unit as to the pressure drop measurement is not shown in the attached drawings.
The air mass flow rate Gegra in the EGR gas flow rate is estimated by use of the calculation result obtained in the former step as to the former data samplings, using the formula (2). Here, the calculation result means a result of the estimation excess air ratio λs.
In Step S7, the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 makes a judgment as to whether or not the calculated estimation excess air ratio λs is smaller than or equal to a threshold value K as to the estimation excess air ratio. In a case where the estimation excess air ratio λs is smaller than or equal to the threshold value K, Step 8 is carried out in which the to-be-limited maximum rate of change of the accelerator opening is calculated in response to the estimation excess air ratio λs. It is hereby noted that the mentioned threshold value K is a variable corresponding to the estimation excess air ratio λs rather than a constant value; thus, the to-be-limited maximum rate of change of the accelerator opening calculated in step S8 is predetermined as a function of the estimation excess air ratio λs or a function of the variable K. In the next step S9, the to-be-limited maximum rate of change of the accelerator opening calculated in the step S8 is limited within a limit value (function) P as shown in
The limiting process of the maximum rate of change of the accelerator opening in the steps S9 and S10 is carried out by the accelerator opening controlling means 50 of the control unit 33.
As shown in
In addition, the threshold variable K as to the estimation excess air ratio λs and the limit value (function) P as to the maximum rate of change of the accelerator opening are predetermined in a form of a table that can be depicted in a figure such as
As depicted in the table function of
As described above, the mentioned threshold value K as to the estimation excess air ratio is a variable corresponding to the estimation excess air ratio λs and the variable is related to a limit value P as to the rate of change of the accelerator opening; thus, the limit value P is easily adjusted in relation to the threshold value K as to the estimation excess air ratio by adjusting the table. Therefore, the trade-off relation between the smoke emission and the engine speed response can be easily adjusted.
Since the smoke emission level of the engine can be controlled by only one parameter, namely, the estimation excess air ratio λs, the control logic becomes more simplified and the control adjustment can be simplified in comparison with the case where a plurality of control parameters are introduced.
As described above, according to the first embodiment, the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means 47 calculates the estimation excess air ratio λs in the cylinder 3 by use of the following quantities: the quantity of the fuel injected into the cylinder 3, the intake air flow rate fed into the cylinder 3 through the intake air passage 13, and the flow rate of the residual air in the EGR gas returned into the intake air passage 13; thus, the estimation excess air ratio λs is calculated in consideration of the residual oxygen (the oxygen which is not used for the combustion in the cylinder, and returns back into the intake air passage) that has an impact on the engine smoke emission.
Further, since the accelerator opening (the fuel admission) is controlled based on the estimation excess air ratio λs, the control can be performed so that the oxygen ratio in the cylinder air or gas can be reflected on the control. Moreover, when the estimation excess air ratio λs exists in a range smaller than or equal to a constant value, the accelerator opening controlling means 50 limits the rate of change of the accelerator opening so that the rate of change does not exceed a limitation level; thus, even when a hard acceleration (a rapid increase as to the accelerator opening) is performed during the EGR system operation, the smoke emission, the NOx emission, and the engine speed response deterioration due to the oxygen shortage in the combustion chamber 9 can be restrained.
The dotted line R in
In addition,
Next, in consultation with
In the first embodiment, the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 makes a judgment as to whether or not the calculated estimation excess air ratio λs is reduced, and the accelerator opening controlling means 50 performs a control limitation in relation to the rate of change of the accelerator opening; on the other hand, in the second embodiment the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 is replaced with a target excess air ratio λm calculating means 52, and the accelerator opening controlling means 50 is replaced with an accelerator opening controlling means 54. In other words, the control unit 33 of the first embodiment comprises the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 and the accelerator opening controlling means 50, while the control unit 51 of the second embodiment comprises the target excess air ratio λm calculating means 52 and the accelerator opening controlling means 54 as shown in
In
In the accelerator opening controlling means 54 (in
In consultation with the flowchart of
Firstly, at Step S21, a corrective action as to the accelerator opening starts; in Step S22, a signal as to the accelerator opening is read from the accelerator sensor 45; in Step S23, an engine speed signal and an accelerator opening signal are read by the target excess air ratio λm calculating means 52; and in Step S24, a target excess air ratio λm is calculated by means of the map of the target excess air ratio λm.
Secondly, in Step S25, the estimation excess air ratio λs is calculated by the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means 47. The calculation is performed by use of the formulae (1) and (2), in the same manner as in the first embodiment. From the estimation excess air ratio λs, the target excess air ratio λm is subtracted at an adder-subtracter 56 in
In procedure B, namely, in Steps S28 to S30, whether the rate of change of the accelerator opening is greater than or equal to a predetermined threshold value or not is estimated, as is the case in the steps S3 to S5 in the first embodiment. Then, the steps as to corrective process (such as Step S32 and/or S33) follow. In Step S31, if the rate of change of the accelerator opening is greater than or equal to the predetermined threshold value, and the fuel input limitation (the accelerator opening limitation) is regarded as effective, then Step S31 is followed by Step S32 in which the output of the process A (the step S27) is set as an accelerator opening correction value; namely, the output Mi from the minimum value selector 60 in
On the other hand, in Step S31, if the fuel input limitation (the accelerator opening limitation) is regarded as non-effective, then the Step S31 is followed by Step S33 in which the accelerator opening itself is set as an accelerator opening correction value; namely, the signal itself as to the accelerator opening Ac in
In Step S34 that follows the Step S32 or S33, the signal inputted into the saturation element 62 through which the input signal is saturated; namely, in the element 62, the input signal is converted into a signal so that the output signal does not step across the bounds even when the input signal increases or decreases beyond certain limits. Thus, the output signal as an accelerator opening correction value falls within a range of 0% to 100%. Further, in Step S35, the corrected signal as to the accelerator opening is memorized to be used for a control (command) signal. Thus, a chain of steps in the flowchart (
According to the second embodiment as described above, since the accelerator opening (the fuel admission) is controlled based on the estimation excess air ratio λs, the control with which the oxygen ratio in the cylinder air or gas is accurately reflected on the control can be performed, as is the case in the first embodiment.
Further, the control unit is provided with the accelerator opening controlling means 54 whereby the accelerator opening is corrected so that the prescribed target excess air ratio λm is followed up by the estimation excess air ratio λs which is calculated by the estimation excess air ratio λs computing means 47; thus, a finer control as to the rate of change of the acceleration opening is performed in the second embodiment than in the first embodiment; in this way, the estimation excess air ratio λs is accurately controlled so that the air or oxygen content in EGR gas is taken into consideration, whereby the air or oxygen content has a direct influence on the smoke emission level. As a result, the engine smoke emission can be restrained.
In a transient state during acceleration, the EGR valve 27 is closed for the purpose of either smoke reduction or response improvement. However, by closing the valve 27, the air or gas condition in the inlet manifold varies causing the combustion temperature and the NOx emission level increase rapidly. This difficulty can be solved by the second embodiment, since the estimation excess air ratio λs can be accurately controlled, the EGR valve can be moderately (not rapidly) closed, and the estimation excess air ratio λs can be controlled through a quick response of the fuel injection control (the fuel admission control). Therefore, smoke restraint together with NOx reduction can be achieved.
In consultation with
In the first embodiment, the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 makes a judgment as to whether the calculated estimation excess air ratio λs is reduced or not, and the accelerator opening controlling means 50 performs a control limitation in relation to the rate of change of the accelerator opening; on the other hand, in the third embodiment the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 is replaced with an oxygen concentration evaluating means 73, and the accelerator opening controlling means 50 is replaced with an accelerator opening controlling means 75. In other words, the control unit 33 of the first embodiment comprises the estimation excess air ratio λs evaluating means 49 and the accelerator opening controlling means 50, while the control unit 71 of the third embodiment comprises the oxygen concentration evaluating means 73 and the accelerator opening controlling means 75 as shown in
As shown
According to the third embodiment, the oxygen concentration in the gas including the intake air and the EGR gas is directly detected by means of the oxygen concentration meter 77. The fuel injection control (the fuel admission control) in which the detected oxygen concentration is accurately reflected on the control is performed. Accordingly, the fuel injection control can be simplified in comparison with the before-described manner in which the intake gas pressure and temperature are detected so that the estimation excess air ratio λs is calculated through the predetermined formulae.
Moreover, as the reduction of the oxygen concentration, which is the cause of the engine smoke emission, is directly evaluated and then controlled, the fuel injection control which reflects the reduction of the oxygen concentration can surely restrain the smoke emission.
In the above explanation from the first to third embodiment, the control command signal is directed to the accelerator opening; however, as a matter of course, the command signal may be any other command signal directed to the fuel injection amount (e.g., in some cases of fuel injection valves, the fuel admission index may be the injection time duration).
According to the present invention, a four-stroke cycle engine with an EGR control unit, in which the engine starting performance such as a quick starting performance is enhanced by being able to avoid a significant descent of speed as to the engine speed during a steady speed operation, can be provided.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2008-122732 | May 2008 | JP | national |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/JP2009/058235 | 4/21/2009 | WO | 00 | 4/14/2010 |
| Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| WO2009/136562 | 11/12/2009 | WO | A |
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4185604 | Nagaishi et al. | Jan 1980 | A |
| 5553575 | Beck et al. | Sep 1996 | A |
| 5704340 | Togai | Jan 1998 | A |
| 5918582 | Itoyama et al. | Jul 1999 | A |
| 5938975 | Ennis et al. | Aug 1999 | A |
| 5988138 | Kadota | Nov 1999 | A |
| 6012431 | Itoyama et al. | Jan 2000 | A |
| 6016788 | Kibe et al. | Jan 2000 | A |
| 6032656 | Itoyama et al. | Mar 2000 | A |
| 6095127 | Kolmanovsky et al. | Aug 2000 | A |
| 6170469 | Itoyama et al. | Jan 2001 | B1 |
| 6230697 | Itoyama et al. | May 2001 | B1 |
| 7270118 | Yamaoka et al. | Sep 2007 | B2 |
| 7383118 | Imai et al. | Jun 2008 | B2 |
| 8104457 | Ide et al. | Jan 2012 | B2 |
| 20050022512 | Shirakawa | Feb 2005 | A1 |
| 20080202118 | Ide et al. | Aug 2008 | A1 |
| 20100211295 | Ide et al. | Aug 2010 | A1 |
| 20100282222 | Ide et al. | Nov 2010 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 1187862 | Jul 1998 | CN |
| 1245480 | Feb 2000 | CN |
| 102 08 424 | Oct 2002 | DE |
| 0 924 417 | Jun 1999 | EP |
| 1 024 275 | Aug 2000 | EP |
| 1 577 524 | Sep 2005 | EP |
| 1 643 103 | Apr 2006 | EP |
| 1 862 657 | Dec 2007 | EP |
| 60-90950 | May 1985 | JP |
| 9-126060 | May 1997 | JP |
| 9-151761 | Jun 1997 | JP |
| 09-195825 | Jul 1997 | JP |
| 11-36962 | Feb 1999 | JP |
| 3341665 | Jul 1999 | JP |
| 2001-159356 | Jun 2001 | JP |
| 2005-48742 | Feb 2005 | JP |
| 2 027 050 | Jan 1995 | RU |
| 2 239 078 | Sep 2002 | RU |
| 45 468 | May 2005 | RU |
| 2 243 395 | Apr 2007 | RU |
| Entry |
|---|
| International Search Report issued Jul. 28, 2009 in International (PCT) Application No. PCT/JP2009/058235. |
| Japanese Decision to Grant a Patent dated Mar. 30, 2012 in corresponding Japanese Patent Application No. 2008-122732 with English translation. |
| Korean Notice of Allowance dated Jul. 2, 2012 in corresponding Korean Patent Application No. 2010-7007772 with English translation. |
| European Decision to Grant a European Patent dated Aug. 2, 2012 in corresponding European Patent Application No. 09742686.0. |
| Supplementary European Search Report dated Feb. 4, 2011 in corresponding European Patent Application No. 09742686.0. |
| International Preliminary Report on Patentability and Written Opinion of International Searching Authority issued Dec. 23, 2010 in International (PCT) Application No. PCT/JP2009/058235. |
| Russian Office Action having a date of Apr. 28, 2011 in corresponding Russian Patent Application No. 2010114261/07 with English translation. |
| Partial European Search Report issued Jul. 14, 2014 in corresponding European Patent Application No. 11186662.0. |
| Extended European Search Report issued Nov. 18, 2014 in corresponding European Patent Application No. 11186662.0. |
| Chinese Notice of Allowance issued Oct. 13, 2014 in corresponding Chinese Patent Application No. 200980100675.0 with English translation. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20100211295 A1 | Aug 2010 | US |
