The invention relates to methods of stabilising fungal material. More specifically, the invention relates to methods of producing stabilised forms of fungal spores, mycelia, and/or sporophores by use of a biopolymer composition.
Fungal material such as spores, sporophores and mycelia are presently used in biopesticide and mycoherbicide applications for the control of pests and weeds. Fungi treatment agents have value to manufacturers and users as they provide an environmentally friendly alternative to chemical treatments.
Typical fungi used in biocontrol agent compositions include fungi from the classes: Metarhizium, Beauveria, Sclerotinia, Paecilomyces, Trichoderma, and Fusarium to name a few.
The primary existing method of production of fungi material for use in such applications is to:
In one alternative, the fungus is not allowed to sporulate and the mycelia is collected. This may include the sporophore stage, which is formed presporulation.
Assuming ideal conditions for the above process and mixing, fungi may continue to be viable from this method for time periods of up to 6 months, depending on the fungus and storage conditions.
However, there are problems with the above method broadly split between issues surrounding viability of the fungi over time and issues surrounding labour and handling.
Viability issues include the fact that:
It should be appreciated that if the viability is reduced, the commercial usefulness of the spores in products such as biopesticides may be dramatically reduced.
Labour and handling issues include the fact that:
A further problem with the existing method is that it is only marginally profitable for products manufactured on a commercial scale. As an illustration, a Beauveria biopesticide for use in pastoral agriculture is not commercially viable when the product price rises above $40/hectare however, the cost of producing the biopesticide is $30/hectare before any other costs are applied leaving little profit margin.
There are numerous references in the literature to methodologies for fungal production (see references listed at the back of this specification) and a number of patents also outline methods of production (for example, U.S. Pat. No. 4,512,103, U.S. Pat. No. 4,530,834 and U.S. Pat. No. 6,143,549). However, the focus of such publications tends to be around managing inputs such as nutrients to increase spore growth, rather than manipulating the final stages of production to capture spores and preserve them in a more efficient manner. In all cases, managing contamination remains a major issue.
It is therefore an object of the present invention to address the foregoing problems or at least to provide the public with a useful choice.
All references, including any patents or patent applications cited in this specification are hereby incorporated by reference. No admission is made that any reference constitutes prior art. The discussion of the references states what their authors assert, and the applicants reserve the right to challenge the accuracy and pertinency of the cited documents. It will be clearly understood that, although a number of prior art publications are referred to herein, this reference does not constitute an admission that any of these documents form part of the common general knowledge in the art, in New Zealand or in any other country.
It is acknowledged that the term ‘comprise’ may, under varying jurisdictions, be attributed with either an exclusive or an inclusive meaning. For the purpose of this specification, and unless otherwise noted, the term ‘comprise’ shall have an inclusive meaning—i.e. that it will be taken to mean an inclusion of not only the listed components it directly references, but also other non-specified components or elements. This rationale will also be used when the term ‘comprised’ or ‘comprising’ is used in relation to one or more steps in a method or process.
Further aspects and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from the ensuing description which is given by way of example only.
For the purposes of this specification the words ‘stable’, ‘stability’, ‘viable’ and ‘viability’ will be used interchangeably and refer to the maintenance of spore viability and cellular integrity under conditions (temperature, pH, enzyme reactions etc.) under which spore viability would normally deteriorate.
According to one aspect of the present invention there is provided a composition including:
According to a further aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of producing a stable fungal composition including the steps of:
According to a further aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of producing a stable fungal composition including the steps of:
According to a further aspect of the present invention there is provided the use of a composition including:
According to a further aspect of the present invention there is provided the use of a composition including:
The above compositions, methods and uses have been found by the inventors to result in compositions that are shelf stable at standard atmospheric conditions such as at room temperature (20° C.) for many months. This time period for stability is considerably higher than that found for most compositions which normally deteriorate or lose viability under such conditions. The methods described also have a number of other advantages which should become apparent to those skilled in the art, one of which is the fact that there is no need to separate solid substrate from the fungi and reduced dust losses as the composition of the present invention prevents dust formation.
For the purposes of further description, reference will be made to fungal spores. This should not be seen as limiting as it should be appreciated that other reproductive cellular material may also be collected and maintained viable by the present invention including, but not limited to, conidia, mycelia, sporophores and the like.
In the inventor's experience, the viability of the stabilised fungal material remains consistent when stored at 20° C. for at least 7 months.
The inventors have also noted a considerable advantage form the present invention being reduced amounts of dust being formed. Besides the health and handling issues that reduced dust formation addresses, losses in fungal material from the composition are also reduced. This is because the dust formed is primarily fungal conidia. By lowering these losses, the composition when used will have a greater efficacy than would be the case of the conidia had been removed as dust. More specifically, the rate of conidial loss is reduced from approximately 40% to approximately 5% compared to traditional methods where no biopolymer composition is used to encapsulate the fungal material and substrate.
Preferably, the fungi may be selected from fungi of the division of hyphomycetes characterised by their production of naked spores or conidia. However, it should be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the invention may be applied to any fungi that reproduces asexually.
More preferably, the fungi genus are selected from the group consisting of: Beauveria; Phytophthora; Celletotrichum; Metarhizum; Sclerotinia; Paecilomyces; Trichoderma; Fusarium; and combinations thereof. Most preferably, the fungi may be of the species of Beauveria bassiana. Genus and species described are provided by way of example only and other genera that may have useful properties and require stabilisation may also be encompassed within the invention as described. Specific embodiments envisaged by the inventors include selection of fungi that control weed and pest growth for use in agricultural applications.
Preferably, the pests controlled by the fungi include: soil-dwelling scarabs, beetles and weevil adults and larvae; caterpillars, cicadas, wasps, ants and termites.
Preferably, the weeds controlled by the fungi include: herbaceous pasture weeds; herbaceous crop weeds; herbaceous weeds of fine turf and amenity areas; woody weeds of pastures and natural areas; wilding trees.
Preferably, the herbaceous pasture weeds are giant buttercup, Californian thistle and ragwort.
Preferably, the herbaceous crop weeds are nightshades in pea crops.
Preferably, the herbaceous weeds of fine turf and amenity areas are dandelion, cat's ear, hawkbit, and hawksbeard.
Preferably, the woody weeds of pastures and natural areas are gorse and broom.
Preferably, the wilding trees are willows and poplars.
Preferably, the biopolymer composition includes: water and at least one gum. More preferably the biopolymer composition also includes a surfactant.
Preferably, the water is distilled and substantially sterile.
Preferably, the gum is a polysaccharide gum. More preferably, the gum is selected from the group consisting of: xanthan gum, acacia gum, guar gum, gellan gum, locust bean gum and combinations thereof.
Preferably, surfactants are selected form the group consisting of: t-Octylphenoxypolyethoxyethanol (Triton X-100™); Polyoxyethylenesorbitan (Tween 80™), and combinations thereof. In one embodiment, the surfactant is in dilute concentrations ranging from 0.01% wt to 0.1% wt. More preferably the concentration is approximately 0.05% wt. It should be appreciated that the amount of surfactant used may vary dependent on the fungal material and other aspects such as the solid substrate chosen or even distilled water used.
Preferably, the solid substrate includes any substantially solid material that may be formed into grains or granules and that provides the fungal inoculum with growth nutrients. More preferably, solid substrates may be selected from the group consisting of: rice grains, cereal grains, starch compounds, sands, gravels, zeolite, pumice, and combinations thereof.
Preferably, where rice grains are used as the solid substrate, they may either be in dried or in wet states. Further, rice grains may be either whole, broken, crushed or a combination of whole, broken and/or crushed states.
Preferably, where cereal grains are used as the solid substrate, they may be selected from the group of grain types consisting of: wheat, barley, millet, maize, and combinations thereof.
Preferably, where starch grains are used as the solid substrate, the starch is tapioca starch.
Preferably, during step (b) of the method, the inoculum and substrate mixture are enclosed within a sealed environment. Preferably, the sealed environment is a plastic bag.
Preferably, step (b) is complete when the desired levels of spores, sporophores, and/or mycelia have been reached. In the inventors' experience, this time period is approximately 1 to 4 weeks although, it should be appreciated that this time period may vary depending on various factors including the type of fungi, solid substrate used and environmental conditions such as temperature.
In one embodiment, the solid substrate and grown fungi from step (b) is dried before step (c) is completed. Drying is preferably completed in air for a time period of approximately 2 to 24 hours at a temperature of approximately 25° C.
Preferably, during step (c) of the method, the solid substrate and grown fungal material is fully encapsulated by coating the biopolymer composition over the substrate and fungal material. Preferably coating is completed by gentle mixing although it is envisaged that no particularly special handling will be required unlike existing methods which require very gentle handling to minimise dust release and ensure spore viability.
It should be appreciated from the above description that there is provided methods to produce compositions that maintain fungal reproductive material such as spores in a viable state for extended periods of time when stored in conditions that would normally be associated with rapid deterioration.
The compositions produced also have the advantage of superior flow and reduced dust formation over existing formulations. This is particularly beneficial for ease of handling and to avoid safety issues surrounding dust inhalation by people handling the fungal product. This also assists to ensure that the composition when used has maximum viability and efficacy.
A further advantage of the above methods is that processing steps may be avoided therefore reducing labour and processing complexity and cost. It should be appreciated that the reduced cost processes described above are advantageous to produce a more commercially viable product.
Further aspects of the present invention will become apparent from the following description which is given by way of example only and with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:
The invention is now described with reference to a series of experiments completed to determine the effectiveness of various methods at producing and maintaining viable fungal material.
Two different types of formulation were prepared, either as a spore coated granule (Trial 1) or as encapsulation of the spores (Trial 2). Drying requirements and broken versus whole substrates were also tested (Trials 3 and 4) as well as spore viability (Trial 5). Additional trials (Trials 6 to 11) were included to:
The formulations of Trials 1 to 4 were stored in gas transferable bags (GT bags) and shelf life was monitored at 20° C. under standard atmospheric conditions (i.e. atmospheric pressure, non-extreme humidity etc).
A fluorescence stain test was also completed to verify cell viability (Trial 5).
Zeolite is a porous clay material with absorbent properties. In this trial the potential for using zeolite as a carrier for Beauveria spores is investigated to assist with stabilisation and application of the fungal material in the field.
Sterile zeolite granules (approximately 2-4 mm diameter) were coated with Beauveria bassiana spores, as described below.
The formulation was prepared by:
The formulation was then stored at 20° C. and viability tested by enumerating samples at monthly intervals using plate counting tests to determine the number of viable cells.
A photograph of the zeolite granule end product is shown in
The number of viable colony forming units or cfus (should be equivalent to spores theoretically) immediately after preparation of the formulation was 7.2×108 cfus per gram of granules. This comprised approximately 80% of the theoretical number of spores applied, indicating little loss of viability during processing. The number of viable cfus on the granules continued to remain stable over the following 7-month trial period tested as shown in
It is the inventors understanding that the variation in spore count noted between sampling times suggests heterogeneity variation between the samples rather than changes in viable spore count.
Further observations noted were that coating Beauveria spores onto zeolite granules results in a product that flows well and is easy to handle with little dust formation. However, a disadvantage noted with this method is that the processing costs of spore extraction are higher than that desired.
A direct encapsulation method was tested to determine if it is possible to remove the need for harvesting or separation of spores from rice grains.
Rice grains with spores grown using existing methods were dried and encapsulated using a biopolymer gel.
The biopolymer gel was prepared by mixing 2 grams of xanthan gum (Grindsted@Xanthan Easy Rhodiogel Easy™) in 48 ml of sterile distilled water to give 4% gel strength.
The biopolymer gel was then added to the dried rice grains at a rate of 2% (20 grams gel per kg of rice grains) in the bowl of a mixer operating at a low speed. To ensure efficient mixing, the grains were intermittently melded together with a clean plastic spatula for uniform distribution of the gel. The grains coated with the gel and spores were then air-dried on a clean plastic tray at approximately 25° C. for 2 hours.
The product obtained is shown in
The initial count of viable cfus on rice was measured at 8.0×108 cfu/g. Shelf life of the formulation was then tested by measuring the plate count of samples stored at 20° C. taken at monthly intervals. The results on the shelf data obtained (shown in
An advantage of the above method is that, by incorporating the biopolymer directly onto the grain coating, this method avoids the potential handling problems and associated costs (labour and reduced spore count) of a spore separation step.
Biopolymer at 4 to 10% gel strength was encapsulated onto rice at a rate of 2 to 10% that was either undried or dried after spore production. These options were tested to investigate the possibility of eliminating the drying step after spore production.
For both rice samples (dried and undried), 5 grams of xanthan gum (Rhodigel Easy™) was mixed with 45 ml of sterile distilled water containing approximately 0.05% wt Tween 80™ surfactant. The rice grains, both dried (24 hours drying on a clean plastic tray at 25° C.) and undried (taken directly from the production bags), were coated at a rate of 2% gel/grain. The formulations were packed in gas transferable bags and the shelf life was monitored at monthly intervals at 20° C. by measuring plate counts.
The initial viable number of colony forming units (cfus) for undried and dried rice samples were 8.4×108 cfu/g and 5.6×108 cfu/g, respectively. The results (shown in
The results indicate that it does not matter whether rice was dried or undried at the end of the production process. It is the inventors understanding that the biopolymer in effect dehydrates the grain spore mix. Using biopolymer on undried rice is advantageous as this eliminates a further processing step, saving energy and labour costs as well as simplifying the process.
Spore production was investigated on broken rice grains to determine if grain shape had an effect on viability.
The method of preparation was the same as that of Trial 2 (see above) except that broken rice grains were used rather than whole grains as described in Trial 2.
The end product is shown in
The initial count of viable cfus on the broken rice product was 6.3×108 cfu/g. Shelf life of the formulation stored at 20° C. was tested at monthly intervals and is shown in
The broken rice production and formulation system appears to have a number of advantages over the previously described systems. In addition to reducing dust and improving survival, greater homogeneity is achieved on the broken rice grains as indicated by the consistent viability results. Homogeneity is desirable to deliver the required number of spores to the soil.
Spore viability in the formulations was confirmed by fluorescence microscopy following staining with STYO/PI dyes (Molecular Probes Ltd). As shown in
Shelf life data (cfu/g) for Beauveria bassiana formulations stored at 20° C. were as shown in Table 1 below.
An additional trial was completed using four strains of fungi grown on rice and coated with biopolymer. The strains tested were, Beauveria caledonica, Metarhizium anisopliae var anisopliae, and Metarhizium anisopliae. Short term shelf life studies were completed at 20° C. to determine that the method works for other fungi strains. The results found were as shown in Table 2:
Metarhizium
anisopliae var
anisopliae:
Metarhizium
anisopliae:
Beauveria
caledonica
The above results show that the viability is maintained over time for various strains of fungi and that from these results it should be obvious that other fungi strains would also give similar results. It should also be noted that the inventors found that dust levels from the different strains of fungi were also maintained at lower levels than that expected when no biopolymer treatment is undertaken.
The above trials were completed using xanthan gum as the biopolymer. It should be appreciated that other polysaccharides may also be used and the following trial is conducted to show use of an alternative polysaccharide.
In this trial the survival of fungal conidia in a gellan biopolymer coating after storage at 20° C. for 7 days was tested. The results are shown below in Table 3.
Metarhizium anisopliae var
anisopliae: Biopolymer coated
Beauveria bassiana: Biopolymer
The results show that the method may be completed as expected using alternative biopolymers such as gellan.
Assessments of the long term stability of biopolymer coated rice with Beauveria bassiana were tested and found to be highly reproducible. Results found were as shown in
A variety of additional solid substrates were tested for use with conidial spores.
Beauveria sp and Metarhizium sp have been successfully grown on wheat and barley both by the applicant.
Formulation with Biopolymer/Zeolite Granules
Spores were extracted from the rice to produce a high density spore powder. The spore powder was incorporated into a biopolymer and successfully coated onto zeolite granules.
Further trials were completed to verify that the stabilized fungal material does indeed work as expected to control weeds and pests.
Biopolymer stabilised materials were used in field in trials to control the pests Clover Root Weevil and Fullers Rose Weevil.
Two field trials were established to examine effects of Beauveria bassiana isolate on larval populations of the clover root weevil, Sitona lepidus. One trial compared the biopolymer-coated rice and spores formulation against an emulsion and clay-based granular formulation. Measurements of persistence by soil plating (colony forming units) showed that the new formulation established at reasonable numbers in all trials suggesting stable establishment of Beauveria bassiana at around 103-104 conidia/g soil, which it should be appreciated is sufficient for larval infection to occur.
Paddock-scale trials were established in a second trial, where Beauveria bassiana was applied as a rice and biopolymer formulation, targeting CRW larvae in the clover root feeding zone. The biopolymer rice formulation was very easy to handle and apply using commercial farm equipment. There was minimal dust when transferring the product from bags to the seed drill, making handling easy and comfortable for the operator. The product was also extremely stable, with no change in spore loading and viability over 6 weeks (trial finished at week 6). From field sampling B. bassiana was recovered from all experimental sites up to 12 weeks post-treatment. Soil loadings appeared to stabilise at around 2×104 CFU/g, and infected cadavers were collected from the treated plots proving effective use.
The establishment of Beauveria bassiana applied as a granular formulation was assessed in three kiwifruit orchards. Granules were applied at a rate of 70 g/m2.
After three months, B. bassiana was isolated at rates up to 103 CFU/g soil from treated plots, significantly higher than CFU numbers isolated from untreated plots. The results indicated good potential for the granular formulation of Beauveria bassiana to persist in kiwifruit orchard soils.
As noted above, a key advantage of the present invention is that the method produces a product that is easy to handle with minimal dust. A trial was completed to show the degree of dust formation.
Biopolymer coated rice prevents dust formation due to displacement of conidia when handling. This is clearly demonstrated in
Formulations of coated and uncoated rice grains with Metarhizium anisopliae conidia were fed into a Duncan seed drill through the seed box and collected into plastic bags. The samples were then weighed and spores washed off the rice in 0.01% Triton-X 100. Haemocytometer counts were used to analyse the number of conidia per gram of rice both before and after the rice was passed through the seed drill. The results found were that the rate of conidial loss is reduced using the invention method from 40% loss to 5% loss. This is understood to be the result of both use of a biopolymer as well as optionally not having to separate fungal material from solid substrate. More examples of the results are shown below in Table 4.
M. flavoviride strain IMI - formulated
M. flavoviride strain IMI - non formulated
M. anisopliae strain - formulated
M. anisopliae strain - non formulated
It should be appreciated that the above trials show that the present invention provides methods to produce compositions that maintain fungal reproductive material such as spores in a viable state for extended periods of time when stored in conditions that would normally be associated with rapid deterioration. The compositions produced also have the advantage of superior flow and reduced dust characteristics over existing formulations. This is particularly beneficial for ease of handling and to avoid safety problems. A further advantage of the above methods is that processing steps may be avoided therefore reducing labour and processing complexity and cost.
Aspects of the present invention have been described by way of example only and it should be appreciated that modifications and additions may be made thereto without departing from the scope thereof as defined in the appended claims.
Samson P R and Milner R J, (1999). Metarhizium-based pesticides for Queensland canegrubs. Proc 7th Aust Conf Grassland Inv Ecol: 92-98.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
539962 | May 2005 | NZ | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/NZ06/00107 | 5/11/2006 | WO | 00 | 6/5/2008 |