Gas turbine efficiency and regulation speed improvements using supplementary air system continuous and storage systems and methods of using the same

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 10145303
  • Patent Number
    10,145,303
  • Date Filed
    Monday, August 18, 2014
    10 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, December 4, 2018
    6 years ago
Abstract
The present invention discloses a novel apparatus and methods for augmenting the power of a gas turbine engine, improving gas turbine engine operation, and reducing the response time necessary to meet changing demands of a power plant. Improvements in power augmentation and engine operation include additional heated compressed air injection, steam injection, water recovery, exhaust tempering, fuel heating, and stored heated air injection.
Description
TECHNICAL FIELD

The invention relates generally to gas turbine engine power systems, including supplementing the generating capacity of such gas turbine engines, as well as to energy storage for use in providing additional electrical power during periods of peak electrical power demand. More specifically, a series of improvements to the supplemental generating system are identified.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Currently, marginal energy, or peak energy, is produced mainly by gas turbines, operating either in simple cycle or combined cycle configurations. As a result of load demand profile, the gas turbine base systems are cycled up during periods of high demand and cycled down, or turned off, during periods of low demand. This cycling is typically driven by the electrical grid operator under a program called “active grid control”, or AGC. Unfortunately, because industrial gas turbines, which represent the majority of the installed power generation base, were designed primarily for base load operation, a severe penalty is associated with the maintenance cost of that particular unit when they are cycled. For example, a gas turbine that is running base load might go through a normal maintenance cycle once every three years, or 24,000 hours of operation, at a cost of between two million dollars and three million dollars ($2,000,000 to $3,000,000). That same cost could be incurred in one year for a gas turbine that is forced to start up and shut down every day due to the severe penalty associated with the maintenance cost of cycling that particular gas turbine. Also, even aero-derivative engines, which are designed for quick starting capability, may still take ten (10) minutes or longer to deliver the required power when called on. This need to cycle the gas turbine fleet is a major issue, and is becoming more problematic with the increased use of intermittent renewable energy sources on the grid.


Currently the gas turbine engines used at power plants can turn down to approximately 50% of their rated capacity. They do this by closing the inlet guide vanes of the compressor, which reduces the air flow to the gas turbine and in turn reduces fuel flow, as a constant fuel air ratio is desired in the combustion process at all engine operating conditions. The goal of maintaining safe compressor operation and gas turbine exhaust emissions typically limit the level of turn down that can be practically achieved.


One way to safely lower the operating limit of the compressor in current gas turbines is by introducing warm air to the inlet of the gas turbine, typically extracted from a mid-stage bleed port on the compressor. Sometimes, this warm air is introduced into the inlet to prevent icing as well. In either case, when this is done, the work that is done to the air by the compressor is sacrificed in the process for the benefit of being able to operate the compressor safely at a lower air flow, yielding the increased turn down capability. Unfortunately, bleeding air from the compressor has a further negative impact on the efficiency of the overall gas turbine system as the work performed on the air that is bled off is lost. In general, for every 1% of air that is bled off the compressor for this turn down improvement, approximately 2% of the total power output of the gas turbine is lost. Additionally, the combustion system also presents a limit to the system.


The combustion system usually limits the amount that the system can be turned down because as less fuel is added, the flame temperature reduces, increasing the amount of carbon monoxide (“CO”) emissions produced. The relationship between flame temperature and CO emissions is exponential with reducing temperature, consequently, as the gas turbine system gets near the turn-down limit, the CO emissions spike up, so it is important to a maintain a healthy margin from this limit. This characteristic limits all gas turbine systems to approximately 50% turn down capability, or, for a 100 MW gas turbine, the minimum power turn-down that can be achieved is about 50%, or 50 MW. As the gas turbine mass flow is turned down, the compressor and turbine efficiency falls off as well, causing an increase in heat rate of the machine. Some operators are faced with this situation every day and as a result, as the load demand falls, gas turbine plants hit its lower operating limit and the gas turbines have to be turned off, which causes the power plant to incur a tremendous maintenance cost penalty.


Another characteristic of a typical gas turbine is that as the ambient temperature increases, the power output goes down proportionately due to the linear effect of the reduced density as the temperature of air increases. Power output can be down by more than 10% from nameplate power rating during hot days, which is typically when peaking gas turbines are called on most frequently to deliver power.


Another characteristic of typical gas turbines is that air that is compressed and heated in the compressor section of the gas turbine is ducted to different portions of the gas turbine's turbine section where it is used to cool various components. This air is typically called turbine cooling and leakage air (hereinafter “TCLA”) a term that is well known in the art with respect to gas turbines. Although heated from the compression process, TCLA air is still significantly cooler than the turbine temperatures, and thus is effective in cooling those components in the turbine downstream of the compressor. Typically 10% to 15% of the air that enters the inlet of the compressor bypasses the combustor and is used for this process. Thus, TCLA is a significant penalty to the performance of the gas turbine system.


Other power augmentation systems, like inlet chilling for example, provide cooler inlet conditions, resulting in increased air flow through the gas turbine compressor, and the gas turbine output increases proportionately. For example, if inlet chilling reduces the inlet conditions on a hot day such that the gas turbine compressor has 5% more air flow, the output of the gas turbine will also increase by 5%. As ambient temperatures drops, inlet chilling becomes less effective, since the air is already cold. Therefore, inlet chilling power increase is maximized on hot days, and tapers off to zero at approximately 45° F. ambient temperature days.


In power augmentation systems such as the one discussed in U.S. Pat. No. 6,305,158 to Nakhamkin (the “'158 patent”), there are three basic modes of operation defined, a normal mode, charging mode, and an air injection mode, but it is limited by the need for an electrical generator that has the capacity to deliver power “exceeding the full rated power” that the gas turbine system can deliver. The fact that this patent has been issued for more than ten (10) years and yet there are no known applications of it at a time of rapidly rising energy costs is proof that it does not address the market requirements. First of all, it is very expensive to replace and upgrade the electrical generator so it can deliver power “exceeding the full rated power” that the gas turbine system can currently deliver. Also, although the injection option as disclosed in the '158 patent provides power augmentation, it takes a significant amount of time to start and get on line to the electrical grid. This makes application of the '158 patent impractical in certain markets like spinning reserve, where the power increase must occur in a matter of seconds, and due to do the need for the large auxiliary compressor in these types of systems, that takes too long to start.


Another drawback is that the system cannot be implemented on a combined cycle plant without significant negative impact on fuel consumption and therefore efficiency. Most of the implementations outlined in the '158 patent use a recuperator to heat the air in simple cycle operation, which mitigates the fuel consumption increase issue, however, it adds significant cost and complexity. The proposed invention outlined below addresses both the cost and performance shortfalls of the invention disclosed in the '158 patent.


Also, as outlined in a related U.S. Pat. No. 5,934,063 to Nakhamkin (the “'063 patent”), there is a valve structure that “selectively permits one of the following modes of operation: there is a gas turbine normal operation mode, a mode where air is delivered from the storage system and mixed with air in the gas turbine, and then a charging mode”. The '063 patent has also been issued for more than ten (10) years and there are also no known applications of it anywhere in the world. The reason for this is again cost and performance shortfalls, similar to those related to the '158 patent. Although this system can be applied without an efficiency penalty on a simple cycle gas turbine, simple cycle gas turbines do not run very often so they typically do not pay off the capital investment in a timeframe that makes the technology attractive to power plant operators. Likewise, if this system is applied to a combined cycle gas turbine, there is a significant heat rate penalty, and again the technology does not address the market needs. The proposed invention outlined below addresses both the cost and performance issues of the '063 patent.


SUMMARY

The current invention, which may be referred to herein as TurboPHASET™, provides several options, depending on specific plant needs, to improve the efficiency and power output of a plant at low loads, and to reduce the lower limit of power output capability of a gas turbine while at the same time increasing the upper limit of the power output of the gas turbine, thus increasing the capacity and regulation capability of a new or existing gas turbine system.


One aspect of the present invention relates to methods and systems that allow running gas turbine systems to provide additional power quickly during periods of peak demand.


Another aspect of the present invention relates to an energy storage and retrieval system for obtaining useful work from an existing source of a gas turbine power plant.


Yet another aspect of the present invention relates to methods and systems that allow gas turbine systems to be more efficiently turned down during periods of lowered demand.


One embodiment of the invention relates to a system comprising at least one existing gas turbine that comprises one first compressor, at least one electrical generator, at least one turbine connected to the generator and the compressor, a combustor, and a combustion case (which is the discharge manifold for the compressor) and further comprising a supplemental compressor which is not the same as the first compressor.


An advantage of other preferred embodiments of the present invention is the ability to increase the turn down capability of the gas turbine system during periods of lower demand and improve the efficiency and output of the gas turbine system during periods of high demand.


Another advantage of embodiments of the present invention is the ability to increase the turn down capability of the gas turbine system during periods of low demand by using a supplemental compressor driven by a fueled engine, operation of which is which is independent of the electric grid.


Another advantage of embodiments of the present invention is the ability to increase the turn down capability of the gas turbine system during periods of low demand by using a supplemental compressor driven by a fueled engine which produces heat that can be added to compressed air flowing to the combustion case, from either the supplemental compressor, an air storage system, or both, or such heat can be added to the steam cycle in a combined cycle power plant.


Another advantage of some embodiments of the present invention is the ability to increase output of the gas turbine system during periods of high demand by using a supplemental compressor which is not driven by power produced by the gas turbine system.


Another advantage of some embodiments of the present invention is the ability to increase output of the gas turbine system during periods of high demand by using a supplemental compressor which is driven by steam produced by the heat recovery steam generator of a combined cycle power plant.


Another advantage of the present invention is the ability to incorporate selective portions of the embodiments on existing gas turbines to achieve specific plant objectives.


Another advantage of an embodiment of the present invention is the ability to inject compressed air into a turbine cooling circuit without heating up the air prior to such injection, and because cool cooling air can achieve the same desired metal temperatures with use of less compressed air (as compared to heated compressed air), efficiency is improved.


Another advantage of another embodiment of the present invention is that because the incremental amount of compressed air can be added at a relatively constant rate over a wide range of ambient temperatures, the power increase achieved by the gas turbine is also relatively constant over a wide range of ambient temperatures. Additionally, since the supplemental compressed air is delivered without any significant power increase from the gas turbine's compressor, (because the compressed air is from either a separately fueled compressor or an a compressed air storage system), for every 1% of air injected (by mass flow), a 2% power increase results. This is significant because other technologies, such as inlet chillers, for supplementing power yield closer to a 1% power increase for each 1% increase of injected air, therefore, twice as much power boost is achieved with the same incremental air flow through the turbine and combustor, resulting in a physically smaller, and lower cost, power supplementing system.


One preferred embodiment of the present invention includes an intercooled compression circuit using a supplemental compressor to produce compressed air that is stored in one or more high pressure air storage tanks, wherein the intercooling process heat absorbed from the compressed air during compression is transferred to the steam cycle of a combined cycle power plant.


Optionally, when integrated with a combined cycle gas turbine plant with a steam cycle, steam from the steam cycle can be used to drive a secondary steam turbine which in turn drives a supplemental compressor. The use of high pressure air storage tanks in conjunction with firing this air directly in the gas turbine gives the gas turbine the ability to deliver much more power than could be otherwise produced, because the maximum mass flow of air that is currently delivered by the gas turbine system's compressor to the turbine is supplemented with the air from the air tanks. On existing gas turbines, this can increase the output of a gas turbine system up to the current generator limit on a hot day, which could be as much as an additional 20% power output, while at the same time increasing the turn down capability by 25-30% more than current state of the art.


On new gas turbines, the generator and turbine can be oversized to deliver this additional power at any time, thus increasing the name plate power rating of the system by 20% at a total system cost increase that is much lower than 20%, with 25-30% more turn down capability than the current state of the art.


Other advantages, features and characteristics of the present invention, as well as the methods of operation and the functions of the related elements of the structure and the combination of parts will become more apparent upon consideration of the following detailed description and appended claims with reference to the accompanying drawings, all of which form a part of this specification.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS

The present invention is described in detail below with reference to the attached drawing figures, wherein:



FIG. 1 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention having a supplemental energy system with a recuperated engine driving the supplemental compressor.



FIG. 2 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention having a supplemental energy system with a recuperated engine driving the supplemental compressor and energy storage.



FIG. 3 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention incorporating a continuous power augmentation system.



FIG. 4 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention in which an auxiliary steam turbine is drives the supplemental compressor.



FIG. 5 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention in which includes an auxiliary steam turbine driving the supplemental compressor and energy storage.



FIG. 6 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention installed in conjunction with two gas turbines and a steam turbine.



FIG. 7 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention installed in conjunction with one gas turbine and a steam turbine.



FIG. 8 is a schematic drawing of an embodiment of the present invention installed in conjunction with one gas turbine.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The components of one embodiment of the present invention are shown in FIG. 1 as they are used with an existing gas turbine system 1. The existing gas turbine system 1, which compresses ambient air 2, includes a compressor 10, combustor 12, combustion case 14, turbine 16 and generator 18. A fueled engine 20 is used to drive a multistage intercooled supplemental compressor 22 which compresses ambient air 24 and discharges compressed air 26. As used herein, the term “fueled engine” means a reciprocating internal combustion engine, a gas turbine (in addition to the gas turbine in the existing gas turbine system 1, or a similar machine that converts fuel into energy through an exothermic reaction such as combustion (e.g., gasoline, diesel, natural gas, or biofuel and similar fuel). The fueled engine draws in ambient air 42 and as a result of the combustion process, produces hot exhaust gas 32. As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, as air in the supplemental compressor 22 passes from one compressor stage to the next, the air is intercooled by use of an intercooler heat exchanger 28, such as a cooling tower, to reduce the work required to compress the air at the subsequent compressor stage. As used herein, the term “intercooler heat exchanger” means a heat exchanger that receives compressed air from an upstream stage of a compressor, and cools that air before delivering it to another compression stage downstream of the upstream compressor stage. Use of the intercooler heat exchanger 28 increases the efficiency of the supplemental compressor 22, which makes it more efficient than the compressor 10 of the existing gas turbine system 1. As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, although referred to herein as an “intercooler”, the intercooler heat exchanger 28 actually includes an intercooler and an after-cooler as described in greater detail below.


This embodiment further includes a recuperator 30, which is a heat exchanger that receives the exhaust gas 32 from the fueled engine 20 and the compressed air 26 from the supplemental compressor 22. Flow of compressed air from the supplemental compressor 22 to the recuperator 30 is controlled by the recuperator flow control valve 44. Within the recuperator 30, the hot exhaust gas 32 heats the compressed air 26 and then exits the recuperator 30 as substantially cooler exhaust gas 34. At the same time in the recuperator 30, the compressed air 26 absorbs heat from the exhaust gas 32 and then exits the recuperator 30 as substantially hotter compressed air 36 than when it entered the recuperator 30. The substantially hotter compressed air 36 is then discharged from the recuperator 30 into the combustion case 14 of the gas turbine system 1 where it becomes an addition to the mass flow through the turbine 16.


The cooler exhaust gas 34 is then discharged to atmosphere. A selective catalytic reduction (“SCR”) device (not shown) of the type known in the art, can be inserted before, in the middle of, or after the recuperator 30 to achieve the most desirable condition for the SCR function. Alternately, after the SCR device, the cooler exhaust gas 34 can be injected into the exhaust gas 38 of the turbine 16 as shown in FIG. 1, and then the mixed flow exhaust 38 will either be discharged to the atmosphere (in the case for the simple cycle gas turbine) or directed to the heat recovery steam generator (“HRSG”) of a steam turbine of the type known in the art (not shown) in combined cycle power plants. If the mixed flow exhaust 38 is to be discharged into the HRSG, the means used must ensure that the exhaust gas 38 flow from the turbine 16 into the HRSG and the SCR device is not disrupted. On “F-Class” engines, such as the General Electric Frame 9FA industrial gas turbine, there are large compressor bleed lines that, for starting purposes, bypass air around the turbine section and dump air into the exhaust plenum of the turbine 16. These bleed lines are not in use when the gas turbine system 1 is loaded, and therefore are a good place to discharge the cooler exhaust gas 34 after it exits the recuperator 30, since these compressor bleed lines are already designed to minimize the impact on the HRSG and SCR device. By injecting the exhaust 32 from the fueled engine 20 into to exhaust 38 of the gas turbine system 1, the SCR of the gas turbine system 1 may be used to clean the exhaust 32, thus eliminating an expensive system on the fueled engine 20.


It turns out that gasoline, diesel, natural gas, or biofuel and similar reciprocating engines are not sensitive to back pressure, so putting the recuperator 30, on the fueled engine 20 does not cause a measurable effect on the performance of the fueled engine 20. This is significant because other heat recovery systems, such as the HRSGs used in the exhaust of a typical gas turbine power plants, create a significant power loss all of the time, independent of whether a power augmentation system is in use or not.


The power from the fueled engine 20 is used to drive the intercooled compressor 22. If the installation does include a HS G and a steam turbine, the auxiliary heat from the engine jacket, oil cooler and turbocharger on the fueled engine 20 can be transferred into the steam cycle of the steam turbine via the HSRG (typically the low pressure and temperature condensate line). Likewise, heat removed by the intercooler heat exchanger 28 from the air as it is compressed in the multistage supplemental compressor 22 can be transferred into the steam cycle in a similar manner, prior to the compressed air being cooled by the cooling tower, to lower the temperature of the compressed air to the desired temperature prior to entering the subsequent compression stage of the supplemental compressor 22. If an auxiliary gas turbine is used as the fueled engine 20 instead of a reciprocating engine, lower emission rates will be achievable, which will allow emission permitting even in the strictest environmental areas. Also, if the auxiliary gas turbine is used as the fueled engine 20, the exhaust gas from the auxiliary gas turbine can be piped directly to the exhaust bleed pipes of the existing gas turbine system 1 described above, thus avoiding the cost and maintenance of an additional SCR device.


When peaking with this system, the gas turbine system 1 will most likely be down in power output and flow (assuming that the peaking is needed in the summer when higher ambient air temperatures reduce total mass flow through the gas turbine system 1 which in turn reduces power output of the gas turbine system 1 as a whole, and the supplemental compressor 22 will just bring the air mass flow through the gas turbine system 1 back up to where the flow would have been on a cooler day (i.e. a day on which the full rated power of the gas turbine system 1 could be achieved).



FIG. 2 shows the embodiment of FIG. 1 with the addition of compressed air storage. The compressed air storage system includes an air storage tank 50, a hydraulic fluid tank 52, and a pump 54 for transferring hydraulic fluid, such as water, between the hydraulic fluid tank 52 and the air storage tank 50. According to preferred embodiments, during periods when increased power delivery is needed, the air exit valve 46 opens, the air bypass valve 48 opens, the air inlet valve 56 closes, and the supplemental compressor 22 is operated, driven by the fueled engine 20. As one skilled in the art will readily appreciate, if compressed air is to be stored for later use, it will likely need to be stored at a higher pressure, thus, the supplemental compressor 22 would preferably have additional stages of compression, as compared to the supplemental compressor 22 of the embodiment shown in FIG. 1. These additional stages may be driven by the fueled engine 20 all the time, or may be capable of being driven intermittently by installing a clutch type mechanism that only engages the additional stages when the fueled engine 20 is operated to store compressed air in the air storage tank 50 (where the desired storage pressure is substantially higher to minimize the required volume of the air storage tank 50). Alternatively, the additional stages may be decoupled from the fueled engine 20 and driven by a separately fueled engine (not shown) or other means, such as an electric motor.


The compressed air 26 flowing from the supplemental compressor 22 is forced to flow to the mixer 58 as opposed to towards the intercooler heat exchanger 28 because the air inlet valve 56, which controls air flow exiting the intercooler heat exchanger 28, is closed. The compressed air 26 flowing from the outlet of the supplemental compressor 22 is mixed in the mixer 58 with the compressed air exiting the air storage tank 50 and introduced to the recuperator 30 where it absorbs heat from the exhaust gas of the fueled engine 20 before being introduced into the combustion case 14 using the process described below. As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, for thermal efficiency purposes, the recuperator 30 would ideally be a counter-flow heat exchanger, since that would allow the maximum amount of heat from the exhaust 32 to be transferred to the compressed air exiting the air storage tank 50. Alternately, if the recuperator 30 is made up of one or more cross-flow heat exchangers, it can have a first stage, which is a first cross-flow heat exchanger, followed by a second stage, which is a second cross-flow heat exchanger. In this configuration, where the exhaust 32 first enters the first stage of the recuperator, is partially cooled, then flows to the second stage of the recuperator. At the same time, the compressed air exiting the air storage tank 50 first enters the second stage of the recuperator 30, where additional heat is extracted from the partially cooled exhaust 32, thereby “pre-heating” the compressed air. The compressed air then flows to the first stage of the recuperator 30 where it is heated by exhaust 32 that has not yet been partially cooled, prior to flowing to the mixer 58 to join the air flowing from the supplemental compressor 22. In this case, the “two stage” recuperator acts more like a counter-flow heat exchanger, yielding higher thermal efficiency in the heating of the compressed air.


As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, since the air being compressed in the supplemental compressor 22 is bypassing the intercooler heat exchanger 28 due to the bypass valve 48 being open, the compressed air exiting the supplemental compressor 22 retains some of the heat of compression, and when mixed with the compressed air flowing from the air storage tank 50, will increase the temperature of the mixed air so that when the mixed air enters the recuperator 30, it is hotter than it would be if only compressed air from the air storage tank 50 was being fed into the recuperator 30. Likewise, if the air exiting the air storage tank 50 is first preheated in a “second stage” of the recuperator as described above prior to entering the mixer 58, an even hotter mixture of compressed air will result, which may be desirable under some conditions.


As the combustion turbine system 1 continues to be operated in this manner, the pressure of the compressed air in the air storage tank 50 decreases. If the pressure of the compressed air in the air storage tank 50 reaches the pressure of the air in the combustion case 14, compressed air will stop flowing from the air storage tank 50 into the gas turbine system 1. To prevent this from happening, as the pressure of the compressed air in the air storage tank 50 approaches the pressure of the air in the combustion case 14, the fluid control valve 60 remains closed, and the hydraulic pump 54 begins pumping a fluid, such as water, from the hydraulic fluid tank 52 into the air storage tank 50 at a pressure high enough to drive the compressed air therein out of the air storage tank 50, thus allowing essentially all of the compressed air in the air storage tank to be delivered to the combustion case 14.


As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, if additional compressor stages, or high pressure compressor stages, are added separate from the supplemental compressor 22 driven by the fueled engine 20, then, if desired, air from the gas turbine combustion case 14 can be bled and allowed to flow in reverse of the substantially hotter compressed air 36 as bleed air from the gas turbine combustion case 14 and take the place of air from the separately fueled engine 20 driven supplemental compressor 22. In this case, the bleed air could be cooled in the intercooler heat exchanger 28, or a cooling tower, and then delivered to the inlet of the high pressure stages of the supplemental compressor 22. This may be especially desirable if low turn down capability is desired, as the bleed air results in additional gas turbine power loss, and the drive system for the high pressure stages of the supplemental compressor 22 can driven by an electric motor, consuming electrical power generated by the gas turbine system 1, which also results in additional gas turbine power loss. As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, this is not an operating mode that would be desirable during periods when supplemental power production from the gas turbine system is desired.


According to preferred embodiments, independent of whether or not the hydraulic system is used, when the air stops flowing from the air storage tank 50, the supplemental compressor 22 can continue to run and deliver power augmentation to the gas turbine system 1. According to other preferred embodiments, such as the one shown in FIG. 1, the supplemental compressor 22 is started and run without use of an air storage tank 50. Preferably, an intercooler heat exchanger 28 is used to cool air from a low pressure stage to a high pressure stage in the supplemental compressor 22 that compresses ambient air 24 through a multistage compressor 22.


The air inlet valve 56, the air outlet valve 46, the bypass valve 48, and the supplemental flow control valve 44, are operated to obtain the desired operating conditions of the gas turbine system 1. For example, if it is desired to charge the air storage tank 50 with compressed air, the air outlet valve 46, the bypass valve 48 and the supplemental flow control valve 44 are closed, the air inlet valve 56 is opened and the fueled engine 20 is used to drive the supplemental compressor 22. As air is compressed in the supplemental compressor 22, it is cooled by the intercooler heat exchanger 28 because the bypass valve 48 is closed, forcing the compressed air to flow through the intercooler heat exchanger 28. Air exiting the supplemental compressor 22 then flows through the air inlet valve 56 and into the air storage tank 50. Likewise, if it is desired to discharge compressed air from the air storage tank 50 and into the combustion case 14 the air outlet valve 46, the bypass valve 48 and the supplemental flow control valve 44 are opened, and the air inlet valve 56 can be closed, and the fueled engine 20 can be used to drive the supplemental compressor 22.


As air is compressed in the supplemental compressor 22, it heats up due to the heat of compression, and it is not cooled in the intercooler heat exchanger because bypass valve 48 is open, thereby bypassing the intercooler heat exchanger. Compressed air from the air storage tank 50 then flows through the mixer 58 where it is mixed with hot air from the supplemental compressor 22 and then flows to the recuperator 30 where it absorbs heat transferred to the recuperator 30 from the exhaust gas 32 of the fueled engine 20 and then flows on to the combustion case 14. In the event that all of the airflow from the supplemental compressor 22 is not needed by the gas turbine system 1, this embodiment can be operated in a hybrid mode where the some of the air flowing from the supplemental compressor 22 flows to the mixer 58 and some of the air flow from the supplemental compressor 22 flows through the intercooler heat exchanger 28 and then through the air inlet valve 56 and into the air storage tank 50.


As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, the preheated air mixture could be introduced into the combustion turbine at other locations, depending on the desired goal. For example, the preheated air mixture could be introduced into the turbine 16 to cool components therein, thereby reducing or eliminating the need to extract bleed air from the compressor to cool these components. Of course, if this were the intended use of the preheated air mixture, the mixture's desired temperature would be lower, and the mixture ratio in the mixer 58 would need to be changed accordingly, with consideration as to how much heat, if any, is to be added to the preheated air mixture by the recuperator 30 prior to introducing the compressed air mixture into the cooling circuit(s) of the turbine 16. Note that for this intended use, the preheated air mixture could be introduced into the turbine 16 at the same temperature at which the cooling air from the compressor 10 is typically introduced into the TCLA system of the turbine 16, or at a cooler temperature to enhance overall combustion turbine efficiency (since less TCLA cooling air would be required to cool the turbine components).


It is to be understood that when the air storage tank 50 has hydraulic fluid in it prior to the beginning of a charging cycle to add compressed air to the air storage tank 50, the fluid control valve 60 is opened so that as compressed air flows into the air storage tank 50 it drives the hydraulic fluid therein out of the air storage tank 50, through the fluid control valve 60, and back into the hydraulic fluid tank 52. By controlling the pressure and temperature of the air entering the turbine system 1, the gas turbine system's turbine 16 can be operated at increased power because the mass flow of the gas turbine system 1 is effectively increased, which among other things, allows for increased fuel flow into the gas turbine's combustor 12. This increase in fuel flow is similar to the increase in fuel flow associated with cold day operation of the gas turbine system 1 where an increased mass flow through the entire gas turbine system 1 occurs because the ambient air density is greater than it is on a warmer (normal) day.


During periods of higher energy demand, the air flowing from the air storage tank 50 and supplemental compressor 22 may be introduced to the gas turbine system 1 in a manner that offsets the need to bleed cooling air from the compressor 10, thereby allowing more of the air compressed in the compressor 10 to flow through the combustor 12 and on to the turbine 16, thereby increasing the net available power of the gas turbine system 1. The output of the gas turbine 16 is very proportional to the mass flow rate through the gas turbine system 1, and the system described above, as compared to the prior art patents, delivers higher flow rate augmentation to the gas turbine 16 with the same air storage volume and the same supplemental compressor size, when the two are used simultaneously to provide compressed air, resulting in a hybrid system that costs much less than the price of prior art systems, while providing comparable levels of power augmentation.


The supplemental compressor 22 increases the pressure of the ambient air 24 through at least one stage of compression, which is then cooled in the intercooler heat exchanger 28, further compressed in a subsequent stage of the supplemental compressor 22, and then after-cooled in the intercooler heat exchanger 28 (where the compressed air exiting the last stage of the supplemental compressor 22 is then after-cooled in the same intercooler heat exchanger 28), and then the cooled, compressed, high pressure air is delivered to the air storage tank 50 via the open air inlet valve 56 and the inlet manifold 62, and is stored in the air storage tank 50.


As the pressurized air flowing through the intercooler heat exchanger 28 is cooled, the heat transferred therefrom can be used to heat water in the H SG to improve the efficiency of the steam turbine. An alternate method to cool the compressed air in the intercooler heat exchanger 28 is to use relatively cool water from the steam cycle (not shown) on a combined cycle plant. In this configuration, the water would flow into the intercooler heat exchanger 28 and pick up the heat that is extracted from the compressed air from the supplemental compressor 22, and the then warmer water would exit the intercooler heat exchanger 28 and flow back to the steam cycle. With this configuration, heat is captured during both the storage cycle described in this paragraph, and the power augmentation cycle described below.


According to preferred embodiments, the air storage tank 50 is above-ground, preferably on a barge, skid, trailer or other mobile platform and is adapted or configured to be easily installed and transported. The additional components, excluding the gas turbine system 1, should add less than 20,000 square feet, preferably less than 15,000 square feet, and most preferably less than 10,000 square feet to the overall footprint of the power plant. A continuous augmentation system of the present invention takes up 1% of the footprint of a combined cycle plant and delivers from three to five times the power per square foot as compared to the rest of the plant, thus it is very space efficient, while a continuous augmentation system of the present invention with storage system takes up 5% of the footprint of the combined cycle plant and delivers from one to two times the power per square foot of the power plant.



FIG. 3 shows another embodiment of the present invention in which an auxiliary gas turbine 64 is used to provide supplemental air flow at times when additional power output from the gas turbine system 1 is needed. The auxiliary gas turbine 64 includes a supplemental compressor section 66 and a supplemental turbine section 68. In this embodiment, the auxiliary gas turbine is designed so that substantially all of the power produced by the supplemental turbine section 68 is used to drive the supplemental compressor section 66. As used herein the term “substantially all” means that more than 90% of the power produced by the supplemental turbine section 68 is used to drive the supplemental compressor 66, because major accessories, such as the electric generator used with the gas turbine system 1, are not drawing power from the auxiliary gas turbine section 68. Manufacturers of small gas turbines, such as Solar Turbines Inc., have the capability to mix and match compressors and combustors/turbines because they build their systems with multiple bearings to support the supplemental compressor section 66 and the supplemental turbine section 68. A specialized turbine, with an oversized gas turbine compressor 66 and with a regular sized turbine/combustion system 68 is used to provide additional supplemental airflow to the gas turbine system 1, and the excess compressed air 70 output from the oversized compressor 66, which is in excess of what is needed to run the turbine/combustion system 68, flows through the combustion case flow control valve 74, when it is in the open position, and is discharged into the combustion case 14 of the gas turbine system 1 to increase the total mass flow through the turbine 16 of the gas turbine system 1, and therefore increases the total power output by the gas turbine system 1. For example, a 50 lb/sec combustor/turbine section 68 that would normally be rated for 4 MW, may actually be generating 8 MW, but the compressor is drawing 4 MW, so the net output from the generator is 4 MW. If such a turbine were coupled with a 100 lb/sec compressor on it, but only 50 lbs/sec were fed to the combustor/turbine section 68, the other 50 lb/sec could be fed to the combustion case of the gas turbine system 1. The exhaust 72 of the 50 lb/sec combustor/turbine section 68 could be injected into the exhaust 38 of the main turbine 16 similar to the manner described in the embodiment shown in FIG. 1, and jointly sent to the SCR. Optionally, the exhaust can be separately treated, if required.


Obviously, the pressure from the 100 lb/sec compressor 66 has to be sufficient to drive the compressed air output therefrom into the combustion case 14. Fortunately, many of the smaller gas turbine engines are based on derivatives of aircraft engines and have much higher pressure ratios than the large industrial gas turbines used at most power plants. As shown in FIG. 3, this embodiment of the present invention does not include the recuperator 30, the intercooled compressor 22, or the intercooler heat exchanger 28 shown in FIGS. 1 and 2. Of course, the embodiment shown in FIG. 3 does not provide the efficiency improvement of the intercooled embodiments shown in FIGS. 1 and 2, however the initial cost of the embodiment shown in FIG. 3 is substantially less, which may make it an attractive option to operators of power plants that typically provide power in times of peak demand, and that therefore are not run much and are less sensitive to fuel efficiency. When the auxiliary gas turbine 64 is not running, the combustion case flow control valve 74 is closed.


The embodiment shown in FIG. 4 shows another way to incorporate a supplemental compressor 22 into the gas turbine system 1. In some situations, the gas turbine augmentation of the present invention with (i) the additional mass flow to the HRSG, and/or (ii) the additional heat from the intercooler heat exchanger 28 and fueled engine 20 (as compared to a gas turbine system 1 that does not incorporate the present invention), may be too much for the steam turbine and/or the steam turbine generator to handle if all of the additional heat flows to the steam turbine generator (especially if the power plant has duct burners to replace the missing exhaust energy on hot days). In this case, the additional steam generated as a result of adding the heat of compression generated by the supplemental compressor 22 can be extracted from the steam cycle HRSG. As it happens, when compressed air augmentation is added to the gas turbine system 1, the heat energy extracted from the intercooler heat exchanger 28 generates about the same amount of energy that it takes to drive the supplemental compressor 22. In other words, if you had a steam turbine that generated 100 MW normally and 108 MW when the supplemental compressor 22 was injecting compressed air into the gas turbine system 1, the extra 8 MW is approximately equal to the power requirement to drive the intercooled supplemental compressor 22. Therefore, if some of the steam is extracted from the steam cycle of the power plant, and the steam turbine is kept at 100 MW, a small auxiliary steam turbine 76 can be used to drive the intercooled supplemental compressor 22, and there would be no additional source of emissions at the power plant.


In FIG. 4, an auxiliary steam turbine 76 drives the intercooled supplemental compressor 22 and the steam 78 that is used to drive the steam engine 76, which comes from the HRSG (not shown) of the power plant, is the extra steam produced from the heat, being added to the HRSG, which was extracted by the intercooler heat exchanger 22 during compression of air in the supplemental compressor 22. The exhaust 80 of the steam engine 76 is returned to the HRSG where it is used to produce more steam. This embodiment of the present invention results in a significant efficiency improvement because the compression process of the supplemental compressor 22 is much more efficient than the compressor 10 of the gas turbine system 1. In this situation, the power augmentation level will, of course, be reduced as the steam turbine will not be putting out additional MW, however there will be no other source of emissions/fuel burn.



FIG. 5 shows the embodiment of FIG. 4 with the addition of compressed air storage. This implementation of compressed air energy storage is similar to that described with respect to FIG. 2, as is the operation thereof. As those skilled in the art will readily appreciate, the power augmentation level of the embodiment shown in FIG. 5 is less than the embodiment shown in FIG. 2, since the steam turbine will not be putting out additional MW, however there will be no other source of emissions/fuel burn.



FIGS. 6-8 show various implementations of the embodiment shown in FIG. 1, referred to as the “TurboPHASE system”. TurboPHASE, which is a supplemental power system for gas turbine systems, is a modular, packaged “turbocharger” that can be added to most, if not all, gas turbines, and can add up to 20% more output to existing simple cycle and combined cycle plants, while improving efficiency (i.e. “heat rate”) by up to 7%. The TurboPHASE system is compatible with all types of inlet chilling or fogging systems, and when properly implemented, will leave emissions rates (e.g. ppm of NOx, CO, etc.) unchanged, while the specific emissions rates should improve as the result of improvement in heat rate. Since only clean air, at the appropriate temperature, is injected into the turbine, the TurboPHASE system has no negative effect on gas turbine maintenance requirements. Due to the factory-assembled & tested modules that make up the TurboPHASE system, installation at an existing power plant is quick, requiring only a few days of the gas turbine system being down for outage to complete connections and to perform commissioning.



FIG. 6 shows an implementation of the embodiment of the present invention shown in FIG. 1 in conjunction with two 135 MW General Electric Frame 9E industrial gas turbines 82, 84 in a combined cycle configuration with a 135 MW steam turbine 86 (“ST”). The results of this implementation are shown below in Table 1.









TABLE 1







(7.0% additional Flow added to 2 × 1 9E combined cycle on a 59F day (+71 lbs/sec per GT))










Existing plant
With TurboPHASE ™





Compressor Pressure ratio
12.7
13.6


Compressor discharge temperature
673F
760F


Compressor discharge pressure
185 psi
197 psi


Turbine Firing temperature
2035 F
2035F


Turbine exhaust temperature
1000 F
981F (−19F)


9E GT Output (MW each)
135 MW (base load each)
+23 MW (+17% output)


Increased flow
N/A
+20.7


Increase PR turbine output (delta)
N/A
+5.6


Increase PR compressor load (delta)
N/A
−3.3


ST output (MW)
135 MW (base load)
+16 MW (+12%)


Increased flow
N/A
+9.4


Cooler Exhaust temp
N/A
−2.9


Jacket heat and IC heat put into S
N/A
+9.5


9E Plant Output SC (MW)
135 MW (base load)
158 MW




(+23 MW or + 17%)


9E Plant Output CC (MW)
405 MW (base load)
467 WM




(+62 MW or +15%)


Base load Fuel Burn per GT
1397 MMBTU/hr
1514 MMBTU/hr


Fuelburn of aux engine delivering
N/A
96 MMBTU/hr (740 Gal/


71 lbs/sec

hr ~ 15,000HP)


Total additional fuel burn of GT
N/A
11 MMBTU/hr (+1%)


Increase flow
N/A
98 MMBTU/hr (+7%)


Increased PR/higher CDT/mixed temp
N/A
−77 MMBTU/hr


Total Plant Fuel Burn CC
2974 MMBTU/hr
3028 MMBTU/hr


Heat rate SC
10350 BTU/kWh
5582 BTU/kWh




(−767 BTU/kWh or −7%)


Heat rate CC
6900 BTU/kWh
6483 BTU/kWh




(−416 BTU/kWh or −6%)









As is clear from Table 1, the implementation increased power output from each of the gas turbines by 23 MW, and increased power output from the steam turbine by 6 MW, for a total of 52 MW (2×23 MW+6 MW=52 MW). The TurboPHASE system increases air flow to the gas turbines by 7%, is operable at any ambient temperature, and yields a 4% heat rate improvement. In doing so, the pressure ratio (“PR”) at the gas turbine outlet of each gas turbine increased by 5.6, while the PR of the compressor load exhibited a 3.3 decrease. The total fuel consumption rate for the combined cycle (“CC”) plant increased by 54 MMBTU/hr while the heat rate for the CC plant decreased by 416 BTU kWh. For informational purposes, Table 1 also shows that if the implementation had been on a simple cycle (“SC”) plant, the increased power output from each of the gas turbines by would have totaled 46 MW, while the heat rate would have decreased by 767 BTU/kWh. As an option, the intercooler heat exchanger can be eliminated and the supplemental compressor heat and engine heat added to the steam turbine cycle, which increases ST output from +6 MW to +16 MW (62 MW total) and improves heat rate by 6%.



FIG. 7 shows an implementation of the embodiment shown in FIG. 1 on a CC plant comprising one General Electric Frame 9FA industrial gas turbine 82 and one 138 MW steam turbine. In this implementation, power output by the 9FA industrial gas turbine 82 is increased by 42 MW from 260 MW, and power output by the steam turbine 88 is increased by 8 MW, for a total power output increase of 50 MW, along with a heat rate improvement of 0.25%. As an option, the intercooler heat exchanger 28 can be eliminated and the heat of compression of the supplemental compressor 22 and the heat from the exhaust 32 of the fueled engine can be added to the H SG in the steam cycle, which increases ST output from +8 MW to +14 MW (56 MW total) and improves heat rate to 1.8%.



FIG. 8 shows an implementation of the embodiment shown in FIG. 1 on a SC plant comprising one General Electric Frame 9B (or 9E) industrial gas turbine 90. In this implementation, power output by the 9B is increased by 23 MW from 135 MW, along with a heat rate improvement of 7%.


Implementation of the embodiments of the present invention preferably provide the following benefits: (i) Installation is quick and simple, with no major electric tie-in required; (ii) No change in gas turbine firing temperature, so gas turbine maintenance costs are unchanged; (iii) It uses existing ports on gas turbine system's combustion case to inject air; (iv) High efficiency, recuperated and internal combustion engine-driven inter-cooled supplemental compressor improves both SC and CC heat rates; (v) It is compatible with water injection, fogging, inlet chilling, steam injection, and duct burners; (vi) Air is injected into gas turbine combustion case at compatible temperatures and pressures; (vii) The internal combustion, reciprocating, fueled engine can burn natural gas, low BTU biofuel or diesel (also available with small steam turbine driver and small gas turbine driver for the fueled engine.); and (viii) Energy storage option also available: approximately 2 times the price and 2 times the efficiency improvement.


While the particular systems, components, methods, and devices described herein and described in detail are fully capable of attaining the above-described objects and advantages of the invention, it is to be understood that these are the presently preferred embodiments of the invention and are thus representative of the subject matter which is broadly contemplated by the present invention, that the scope of the present invention fully encompasses other embodiments which may become obvious to those skilled in the art, and that the scope of the present invention is accordingly to be limited by nothing other than the appended claims, in which reference to an element in the singular means “one or more” and not “one and only one”, unless otherwise recited in the claim. It will be appreciated that modifications and variations of the invention are covered by the above teachings and within the purview of the appended claims without departing from the spirit and intended scope of the invention.

Claims
  • 1. A method of providing a source of heated compressed air to a gas turbine, comprising: operating a fueled engine to produce hot exhaust gases and mechanical work to drive a supplemental compressor, where the supplemental compressor produces a supply of compressed air;storing a first portion of the supply of compressed air in an air storage tank after the first portion of the supply of compressed air has been cooled by an intercooler, and routing a second portion of the supply of compressed air to a mixer, the second portion of the supply of compressed air bypassing the air storage tank and the intercooler;selectively mixing at the mixer the first portion of the supply of compressed air with the second portion of the supply of compressed air to form mixed air;heating the mixed air with heat from the hot exhaust gases of the fueled engine;wherein: the supplemental compressor draws in air separately from the fueled engine, where air drawn in by the fueled engine is ambient air; andthe supplemental compressor and the fueled engine are mechanically coupled to each other.
  • 2. The method of claim 1, further comprising returning a part of the supply of compressed air to the supplemental compressor for additional compression.
  • 3. The method of claim 1 further comprising directing the mixed air and hot exhaust gases through a recuperator.
  • 4. The method of claim 3 further comprising the step of directing the mixed air from the recuperator to an external source.
  • 5. The method of claim 1, wherein the fueled engine is a reciprocating engine.
  • 6. A system for heating compressed air for a gas turbine comprising: a fueled engine producing hot exhaust and mechanical power;a supplemental compressor mechanically coupled to the fueled engine;a recuperator in fluid communication with the supplemental compressor and the fueled engine;an air storage tank and an intercooler, each in selective fluid communication with the supplemental compressor; anda mixer upstream of the recuperator fluidly coupled to each of the air storage tank and the supplemental compressor, the mixer being configured to mix air compressed by the supplemental compressor, cooled by the intercooler, and stored in the air storage tank with air compressed by the supplemental compressor and bypassing the air storage tank and the intercooler;wherein:the recuperator receives the mixed air and hot exhaust from the fueled engine and uses the hot exhaust to raise the temperature of the mixed air passing through the recuperator;the supplemental compressor draws in air separately from the fueled engine; andair drawn in by the fueled engine is ambient air.
  • 7. The system of claim 6, wherein the fueled engine operates on natural gas.
  • 8. The system of claim 7, wherein the supplemental compressor is a multi-stage axial compressor.
  • 9. The system of claim 6 further comprising a flow control valve positioned between the supplemental compressor and the recuperator for regulating the mixed air to the recuperator.
  • 10. The method of claim 6, wherein the fueled engine is a reciprocating engine.
  • 11. A method of providing a heated compressed air supply to a gas turbine comprising: providing a fueled engine coupled to a supplemental compressor;operating the fueled engine to produce a hot exhaust gas and mechanical output to power the supplemental compressor, where the supplemental compressor produces a compressed air supply;storing a first portion of the compressed air supply in an air storage tank after the first portion of the compressed air supply has been cooled by an intercooler, and routing a second portion of the compressed air supply to a mixer, the second portion of the compressed air supply bypassing the air storage tank and the intercooler;selectively mixing at the mixer the first portion of the compressed air supply with the second portion of the compressed air supply to form mixed air;heating the mixed air with heat from the hot exhaust gas of the fueled engine; and,directing the heated mixed air to an output location;wherein: the supplemental compressor draws in air separately from the fueled engine, where air drawn in by the fueled engine is ambient air; andthe supplemental compressor and the fueled engine are mechanically coupled to each other.
  • 12. The method of claim 11, wherein the output location is a compressor discharge plenum of a gas turbine engine.
  • 13. The method of claim 11, wherein the fueled engine is a reciprocating internal combustion engine.
  • 14. The method of claim 11, wherein the heating of the mixed air occurs in a recuperator.
  • 15. The method of claim 14, wherein the hot exhaust gases are at a lower temperature at an exit of the recuperator than at an entry to the recuperator.
  • 16. The method of claim 11, wherein the fueled engine is a reciprocating engine.
  • 17. A method of providing a source of heated compressed air to a gas turbine, comprising: operating a fueled engine to produce hot exhaust gases and mechanical work to drive a supplemental compressor, where the supplemental compressor produces a supply of compressed air;providing a pathway, the pathway comprising a mixer and a recuperator; the recuperator adapted to heat a fluid using hot exhaust gases from the fueled engine;storing a first portion of the supply of compressed air in an air storage tank after the first portion of the supply of compressed air has been cooled in an intercooler;routing a second portion of the supply of compressed air through the pathway such that it bypasses the air storage tank and the intercooler, and heats up in the recuperator;routing a mixture of the first portion and the second portion to an output; wherein, the supplemental compressor draws in air separately from the fueled engine, where air drawn in by the fueled engine is ambient air.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/350,469, which claims priority from PCT/US2013/034748, filed on Mar. 31, 2013, which claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 61/686,222 filed on Apr. 2, 2012.

US Referenced Citations (45)
Number Name Date Kind
3712065 Hurst Jan 1973 A
3765170 Nakamura Oct 1973 A
3831373 Flynt Aug 1974 A
3866058 Lenssen Feb 1975 A
3893300 Connell Jul 1975 A
4150547 Hobson Apr 1979 A
4158145 Kartsounes Jun 1979 A
4353348 Black Oct 1982 A
4686822 Frutschi Aug 1987 A
4765142 Nakhamkin Aug 1988 A
5491969 Cohn Feb 1996 A
5537822 Shnaid Jul 1996 A
5778675 Nakhamkin Jul 1998 A
5934063 Nakhamkin Aug 1999 A
6212871 Rakhmailov Apr 2001 B1
6244037 Nakhamkin et al. Jun 2001 B1
6305158 Nakhamkin et al. Oct 2001 B1
6481212 Priestley Nov 2002 B2
6499303 Polukort et al. Dec 2002 B1
7147050 Kang et al. Dec 2006 B2
7614237 Nakhamkin Nov 2009 B2
7954330 Althaus Jun 2011 B2
8011189 Nakhamkin Sep 2011 B2
8458658 Faus et al. Jun 2013 B2
20010000091 Nakhamkin et al. Apr 2001 A1
20050087330 Kang et al. Apr 2005 A1
20050178114 Althaus Aug 2005 A1
20060213183 Althaus Sep 2006 A1
20080000233 Althaus Jan 2008 A1
20090200805 Kim et al. Aug 2009 A1
20090313990 Mustafa Dec 2009 A1
20110005228 Yoshinari et al. Jan 2011 A1
20110181050 Dinu Jul 2011 A1
20130125525 Hein et al. May 2013 A1
20140250902 Kraft Sep 2014 A1
20140321967 Zhang et al. Oct 2014 A1
20140366547 Kraft Dec 2014 A1
20150184593 Kraft Jul 2015 A1
20150233296 Kraft Aug 2015 A1
20150240713 Kraft Aug 2015 A1
20150240719 Kraft Aug 2015 A1
20160130982 Kraft May 2016 A1
20160131030 Kraft May 2016 A1
20160131031 Kraft May 2016 A1
20160169105 Kraft Jun 2016 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (2)
Number Date Country
776269 Jun 1957 GB
WO 2013151909 Oct 2013 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (5)
Entry
Richard Dennis, The Gas Turbine Handbook, 2006, DOE.
International Search Report with Written Opinion dated Jun. 28, 2013 in Application No. PCT/US2013/034748, 16 pages.
International Preliminary Report on Patentability dated Oct. 7, 2014 in Application No. PCT/US2013/034748, 9 pages.
Notice of Allowance dated Mar. 1, 2017, for U.S. Appl. No. 14/250,469.
Notice of Allowance dated Mar. 1, 2017, for U.S. Appl. No. 14/350,469.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20140352318 A1 Dec 2014 US
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
61686222 Apr 2012 US
Continuations (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 14350469 US
Child 14462000 US