Geothermal heat pump cleaning control system and method

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6604577
  • Patent Number
    6,604,577
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, December 5, 2000
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, August 12, 2003
    20 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Examiners
    • Ciric; Ljiljana
    Agents
    • Young & Basile, P.C.
Abstract
An apparatus for removing deposits from a heat transfer wall of a heat exchanger. The apparatus includes a cleaning cycle control system that operates through the control system of the heat pump and eliminates the need for periodic acid cleaning of heat exchanger. The cleaning cycle control system engages a heating cycle of the heat pump to at least partially freeze the fluid adjacent to the heat transfer wall and then engages the cooling cycle of the heat pump to thaw the fluid adjacent to the heat transfer wall. The thermal expansion and contraction of the deposits on the heat transfer wall and the flow of fluids through the heat exchanger flush deposits from the heat transfer wall of the heat exchanger.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to an apparatus and method for cleaning the interior of a heat exchanger by controlling the flow of separate fluids flowing through separate fluid conduits of the heat exchanger.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




One of the known methods of cleaning a heat pump is an acid cleaning process. One gallon of muriatic acid is mixed with three gallons of water to create a 25% muriatic acid solution in a five gallon plastic bucket. The water inlet and outlet hoses are disconnected from the heat pump. An acid pump is positioned within the five gallon plastic bucket with an outlet hose connected to the outlet of the heat pump, while another hose is connected to the inlet of the heat pump for discharging the 25% muriatic acid solution back into the five gallon plastic bucket while being recirculated by the acid pump. The pump is selected with components to tolerate a 25% muriatic acid solution. The 25% muriatic acid solution is circulated through the heat pump in through the outlet port and out through the inlet port for 20-30 minutes. The heat pump is then flushed with pure water. The water inlet and outlet hoses are then reconnected to the heat pump. This process requires extreme caution when handling muriatic acid. The operator is required to wear eye protection and protective gloves, and it is recommended to only be performed by a trained technician.




Ground water heat pump installations can require cleaning on a regular basis due to poor quality ground water. Water treatment normally is not an option due to the large amounts of water used with ground water heat pump installations as opposed to a closed loop system. The normal course of cleaning is to require acid cleaning of the water coil or heat recovery unit. If scaling of the coil is suspected, the coil can be cleaned with a solution of phosphoric acid (food grade acid).




The instructions typically indicate that the manufacturer's directions for mixing, use, etc. should be followed. The acid solution can be introduced into the heat pump coil through a hose bib. The isolation valves are closed to prevent contamination of the rest of the system by the acid. The acid is pumped from a bucket into the hose bib and returned to the bucket through the other hose bib. The standard instructions typically indicate that the manufacturer's directions for the product used should be consulted to determine how long the solution is to be circulated, but is usually circulated for a period of several hours.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention provides an apparatus for removing deposits that accumulate on an interior surface of a heat exchanger. The apparatus removes deposits by controlling the flow of the separate fluids that concurrently pass through the heat exchanger. The heat exchanger includes a heat transfer wall that separates the flow of the two fluids. The flows of the respective fluids are controlled by control means. The cleaning cycle control system, through the control means, engages a heating cycle so that a first fluid draws heat from the second fluid through the heat transfer wall. The second fluid begins to freeze along the heat transfer wall. The deposits located on the heat transfer wall, on the side of the second fluid, also begin to freeze. After the freezing process has progressed for a period of time, the cleaning cycle control system, through the control means, reverses the flow of the first fluid so that heat is directed toward the second fluid. Frozen deposits positioned on the wall begin to thaw. The thawing process causes the deposits to separate from the heat transfer wall. The flow of the second fluid carries the deposits away from the heat exchanger. The present invention can also include a solenoid water valve positioned within the second fluid conduit. When the cooling cycle is actuated to thaw the frozen deposits, the solenoid valve is reactivated. The present invention also provides means for disengaging a freeze switch or pressure switch to allow the heat transfer wall to at least partially freeze. Disengaging the switch allows the cleaning cycle control system, through the control means, to operate without interruption by the switch. The present invention also provides means for automatically engaging the cleaning cycle control system, through the control means, after the heat exchanger has operated for a predetermined period of time.




The present invention provides a method for cleaning a heat transfer wall in a heat exchanger. A heating cycle is engaged to draw heat from a fluid in the heat exchanger. The heat is drawn from the fluid through a heat transfer wall. Fluid immediately adjacent to the heat transfer wall and deposits on the heat transfer wall at least partially freeze. The heating cycle is reversed and heat is absorbed by the fluid so that the fluid and deposits adjacent to the heat transfer wall thaw and separate from the heat transfer wall. The present invention also provides the step of shutting off the flow of fluid through the heat exchanger while the freezing process is proceeding. Also, the present invention provides the step of disengaging a freeze switch operably associated with the heat exchanger to prevent the heating cycle from shutting down before a predetermined period of time has transpired. In addition, the present invention also provides the step of automatically engaging the cleaning process for the heat exchanger after the heat exchanger has operated for a predetermined period of time.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The description herein makes reference to the accompanying drawings wherein like reference numerals refer to like parts throughout the several views, and wherein:





FIG. 1

is a schematic diagram of a heat pump according to the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a simplified flow diagram illustrating steps performed during a cleaning process according to the present invention;





FIG. 3

is a circuit diagram for an electronic control according to the present invention;





FIG. 4

is a circuit diagram for an electronic control according to the present invention with an automatic initiating means;





FIG. 5

is a graph showing the performance of a heat pump without a cleaning apparatus according to the present invention; and





FIG. 6

is a graph showing the performance of a heat pump using a cleaning method according to the present invention.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




The present invention provides a cleaning cycle control system


10


for a heat pump


12


. As is shown in

FIG. 1

, the heat pump


12


includes a heat exchanger


14


, a first fluid conduit


16


and a second fluid conduit


18


. The first fluid conduit


16


and second fluid conduit


18


pass adjacent to one another through the heat exchanger


14


and are separated by a heat transfer wall


20


.




The first fluid conduit


16


creates a path for a first fluid


22


. In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the first fluid conduit


16


is a reversible closed loop system and the first fluid


22


passes through the heat exchanger


14


, a reversing valve


24


, a compressor


26


, a second heat exchanger


28


, and an expansion valve


30


. However, the present invention can include any configuration of heat pump known to those skilled in the art.




The first fluid


22


can be a refrigerant. Examples of suitable refrigerants include freon, ammonia, water, air, methylene chloride, methyl chloride, sulphur dioxide, propane, ethane, ethyl chloride, and carbon dioxide. In addition, any other refrigerant known to those skilled in the art can be used in the present invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention disclosed herein. The flow of the first fluid


22


through the first fluid conduit


16


is controlled by the reversing valve


24


. The compressor


26


compresses the first fluid


22


and forces the first fluid


22


towards the reversing valve


24


. The reversing valve


24


then directs the first fluid


22


towards either the heat exchanger


14


or the second heat exchanger


28


. The direction of the flow establishes whether the heat pump


12


is operating in a heating cycle or a cooling cycle. If the heat pump


12


is operating in a heating cycle mode, the first fluid


22


is directed by the reversing valve


24


towards the second heat exchanger


28


. The first fluid


22


releases heat at the second heat exchanger


28


and absorbs heat at the heat exchanger


14


. In a cooling cycle, the process is reversed. The compressor


26


directs the first fluid


22


to the reversing valve


24


and the reversing valve


24


directs the first fluid


22


towards the heat exchanger


14


. The first fluid


22


releases heat at the heat exchanger


14


and absorbs heat at the second heat exchanger


28


.




The second fluid conduit


18


creates a path for a second fluid


32


. The second fluid conduit


18


can include a pump


34


. In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the second fluid conduit is an open loop system. However, the present invention can include the second fluid conduit being a closed loop system. The second fluid


32


is used as a “heat sink” in one mode of operation. As used herein, the term “heat sink” refers to a part of a system at a lower temperature than the surroundings and used to dissipate heat from the system. For example, heat is being drawn from the second fluid


32


during a heating cycle of the heat pump


12


, and heat is being directed toward the second fluid


32


during a cooling cycle of the heat pump


12


. Examples of a suitable heat sink fluids include air, water, and coolant, and mixtures thereof. In a geothermal heat pump, water is used as the second fluid


32


. The pump


34


draws ground water from underground and forces the water through the heat exchanger


14


. The second fluid


32


can contain contaminants such as soluble minerals and other particles in suspension or various levels of concentration. These contaminants can settle on the interior surfaces of the second fluid conduit


18


, including the surface of the heat transfer wall


20


. The accumulation of deposits on the heat transfer wall


20


reduces the efficiency of the heat pump


12


. As a result, it is desirable to periodically clean the second fluid conduit


18


to remove these deposits and increase efficiency of the heat transfer process.




The operation of the heat pump


12


in a heating cycle or a cooling cycle is determined by the direction of the flow of the first fluid


22


. Also, the reversing valve


24


controls the direction of the flow of the first fluid


22


. The heat pump


12


can include control means


36


for controlling the operation of the reversing valve


24


and, in turn, the operation of the heat pump


12


for selectively operating a heating cycle or a cooling cycle in response to the control system. The heat pump


12


can also include other elements that can also be controlled by the control means


36


. For example, the heat pump


12


can include one or more low pressure switches


38




a


and


38




b.


The low pressure switches


38




a


and


38




b


can be positioned adjacent to the compressor


26


to monitor the pressure of the first fluid


22


as the first fluid


22


enters or exits the compressor


26


.




The heat pump


12


can also include a freeze switch


40


. The freeze switch


40


is operably positioned adjacent to the heat exchanger


14


or within the heat exchanger


14


. The freeze switch


40


can determine if the heat exchanger


14


is freezing. During the heating cycle, heat is drawn from the second fluid


32


and into the first fluid


22


. Continuous operation of the heating cycle can cause a layer of ice to form on the heat transfer wall


20


. When a cooling cycle is engaged, heat is drawn from the first fluid


22


and into the second fluid


32


to melt any ice that has formed on the heat transfer wall


20


.




The present invention includes a cleaning cycle control system


10


. The cleaning cycle control system


10


is operable through the control means


36


. As used herein, the term “operable through” means that the cleaning cycle control system


10


uses the existing control means


36


of the heat pump


12


, and the existing first and second fluids


22


and


32


, respectively, to clean the heat transfer wall


20


. Prior known cleaning systems typically required the use of an additional pump and different fluids. For example, the prior known cleaning system required an acid pump and circulation of acidic fluid. The present invention, on the other hand, is operable through the existing components of the heat pump


12


on a regular or periodic basis without the need for additional equipment to be attached to the fluid conduits, or the introduction of acidic fluids. The cleaning cycle control system


10


includes electronic controls that are connectable to existing controls of commonly used commercial or residential heat pumps. The cleaning cycle control system


10


can be a software-based control system or a hardware based control system.




In either case, the process steps according to the present invention are shown in the simplified flow diagram of FIG.


2


. The cleaning cycle control system


10


of the present invention can include an initiating means for cleaning the heat pump


12


automatically. The control starts at step


42


. Step


44


monitors the time that the heat exchanger


14


operates. After a first predetermined period of time has passed, the cleaning cycle control system


10


will continue to the next step


46


. If the first predetermined time period has not passed, the cleaning cycle control system


10


continues to monitor the period of time that the heat exchanger


14


has been in operation since the last cleaning cycle process. The preferred time period between cleaning depends on several factors including the size of the heat exchanger


14


and the relative amount of contaminants in the second fluid


32


. The cleaning cycle control system


10


can clean the heat transfer wall


20


of the heat exchanger


14


every 500 hours of operation, every 2,000 hours of operation, or on any desired time interval. If desired, the cleaning cycle control system


10


can be activated more frequently than every 500 hours of operation. The cleaning cycle control system


10


of the present invention can be operated without an automatic cleaning cycle step


44


. In step


46


, the cleaning cycle control system


10


bypasses the low pressure switches


38




a


and


38




b.


If the heat pump


12


does not include low pressure switches


38




a


and


38




b,


step


46


is eliminated or skipped. Step


46


also bypasses the freeze switch


40


. As with the low pressure switches


38




a


and


38




b,


if the heat pump


12


does not include a freeze switch


40


, than step


46


is eliminated or skipped. Step


48


deactivates solenoid valve


33


and/or pump


34


in communication with the second fluid conduit


18


to stagnate the second fluid in the heat exchanger


14


. The overall efficiency of the cleaning process is improved when the flow of second fluid is deactivated during the first part of the cleaning process.




Step


48


also engages the heating cycle of the heat pump


12


for a second predetermined period of time. During the heating cycle of the heat pump


12


, heat is extracted from the second fluid


32


and absorbed by the first fluid


22


. During the heating cycle, the second fluid


32


adjacent to the heat transfer wall


20


will lose heat and eventually begin to freeze if sufficient heat is removed. The deposits on the heat transfer wall


20


also begin to freeze. It is commonly believed that the freeze switch is required to prevent freezing of the second fluid


32


that can damage the heat exchanger


14


. According to the present invention, controlled freezing of the second fluid


32


is desirable. By at least partially freezing the second fluid


32


and the deposits on the heat transfer wall


20


, in combination with the thermal expansion and contraction that take place, it is believed that the deposits are caused to dislodge from the heat transfer wall


20


. The freezing process is continued for a second predetermined period of time. Preferably, the second predetermined period of time lasts from about five minutes to about eight minutes inclusive. However, the second predetermined period of time can be shortened or lengthened depending on the size of the heat exchanger


14


. The second predetermined period of time is selected to be sufficiently short to prevent any permanent damage the heat exchanger


14


.




Step


52


activates the flow of the second fluid after the second predetermined period of time has elapsed. Step


52


also engages the cooling cycle of the heat pump


12


. During the cooling cycle of the heat pump


12


, heat is drawn from the first fluid


22


and absorbed by the second fluid


32


. The second fluid


32


and the deposits on the heat transfer wall


20


begin thawing during the cooling cycle. Activating the flow of second fluid produces a flushing action within the heat exchanger


14


. The flow of the second fluid


32


and the thawing process produced by the cooling cycle results in deposits breaking away from the heat transfer wall


20


. Step


52


engages the cooling cycle for a third predetermined period of time. The third predetermined period of time typically can be three to four minutes and is measured by step


54


. However, the cooling cycle can be as long or short as is desired provided that sufficient heat is supplied to the heat transfer wall to completely thaw and remove any frozen material before resuming normal operations. The operation of the cooling cycle poses no threat of damaging the heat exchanger


14


. Step


56


reactivates the freeze switch


40


. If the heat pump


12


does not include a freeze switch


40


than program step


56


can be eliminated or skipped. Step


56


also reactivates the low pressure switches


38




a


and


38




b.


If the heat pump


12


does not include low pressure switches


38




a


and


38




b,


step


58


can be eliminated or skipped. After step


56


, the cleaning cycle control system


10


returns back to normal operation until the cleaning cycle is run again.




The cleaning cycle control system


10


of the present invention can include a hardware electronic control circuit as shown in

FIGS. 3 and 4

.

FIG. 3

shows a circuit diagram of a hardware cleaning cycle control system


10


. The cleaning cycle control system


10


, according to the present invention, can include an activating switch


60


, an adjustable time delay relay


62


capable of timing up to 10 minute intervals and an adjustable time delay relay


64


capable of timing up to 6 minute intervals. The circuit is wired as shown in

FIG. 3

with suitable relay contacts R


1


, R


2


, R


3


, R


4


, R


5


, R


6


, R


7


, R


8


. This circuit connects to a microprocessor


66


for receiving the signals and controlling the compressor, reversing valve, and flow valve.

FIG. 3

depicts a manually initiated cleaning cycle system. In

FIG. 4

, the cleaning cycle controller


10


of the present invention is shown with automatic initiation means for the cleaning cycle. The automatic initiation means can include an adjustable timer


67


. The adjustable timer


67


of a hardware version of the cleaning cycle control system


10


functions to include step


44


of cleaning cycle control system


10


depicted in FIG.


2


. The adjustable time delay relay


67


preferably is capable of timing up to 2000 hours of compressor operation between automatic cleaning cycles. The timer can be overridden by manual activation of a cleaning cycle with switch


60




a.







FIG. 5

is a graph showing the performance of a heat pump


12


in temperature (° F.) versus time without a cleaning cycle control system


10


. Graph line


68


illustrates the water temperature of the second fluid


32


as the second fluid


32


enters the heat exchanger


14


. Graph line


70


illustrates the temperature of the second fluid


32


as the second fluid


32


exits the heat exchanger


14


. As the graph demonstrates, less heat is withdrawn from the second fluid


32


as time passes. This reduction in heat withdrawn from the second fluid


32


is caused by the accumulation of deposits on the heat transfer wall


20


. The deposits interfere with the passage of heat between the first fluid


22


and the second fluid


32


.





FIG. 6

is a graph showing the performance of a heat pump


12


in temperature (° F.) versus time including a cleaning cycle control system


10


. Graph line


72


illustrates the temperature of the second fluid


32


as the second fluid


32


enters the heat exchanger


14


. Graph line


74


illustrates the temperature of the second fluid


32


as the second fluid


32


exits the heat exchanger


14


. As the graph demonstrates, the amount of heat withdrawn from the second fluid


32


remains constant over


5


months of operation. The graph of

FIG. 6

illustrates a preferred performance for the heat exchanger


14


.




The preferred form of heat pump


12


, according to the present invention, is a geothermal heat pump. However, the present invention can include any form of heat exchanger known in the art having control means


36


for controlling the flow of the first fluid


22


through a first fluid conduit


16


and controlling the flow of a second fluid


32


through a second fluid conduit


18


, each of the first and second fluids passing through a heat exchanger


14


and separated by a heat transfer wall


20


.




While the invention has been described in connection with what is presently considered to be the most practical and preferred embodiment, it is to be understood that the invention is not to be limited to the disclosed embodiments but, on the contrary, is intended to cover various modifications and equivalent arrangements included within the spirit and scope of the appended claims, which scope is to be accorded the broadest interpretation so as to encompass all such modifications and equivalent structures as is permitted under the law.



Claims
  • 1. An apparatus for removing deposits from a heat exchanger having at least one heat transfer wall disposed between a first fluid conduit, and a second fluid conduit for transporting a heat sink liquid, the apparatus comprising:control means for controlling fluid flow through the first and second fluid conduits in order to selectively operate in one of a heating cycle, and a cooling cycle; and a cleaning control system connectible to the control means for defining a cleaning cycle, each cleaning cycle actuated through operation of the control means, the cleaning cycle periodically removing deposits from at least one side of the at least one heat transfer wall extending between the first and second fluid conduits through the heat exchanger by at least partially freezing and then thawing the heat sink liquid located adjacent to the at least one heat transfer wall.
  • 2. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the cleaning cycle flushes deposits from the second conduit with at least partially frozen liquid.
  • 3. The apparatus of claim 2, wherein the cleaning cycle reduces fluid flow through the second conduit during at least part of the cleaning cycle to partially freeze the stationary fluid, and increases fluid flow through the second conduit during at least another part of the cleaning cycle after a predetermined time period of freezing.
  • 4. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the cleaning cycle disengages a freeze switch of the heat exchanger.
  • 5. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the cleaning cycle is automatically initiated after the heat exchanger has operated for a predetermined time period.
  • 6. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the first fluid conduit further comprises:a closed loop conduit for circulating a refrigerant in either direction to create desired phase changes of the refrigerant between gas and liquid stages for transferring heat.
  • 7. The apparatus of claim 6, wherein the refrigerant is selected from the group consisting of freon, ammonia, water, air, methylene chloride, methyl chloride, sulphur dioxide, propane, ethane, ethyl chloride and carbon dioxide.
  • 8. The apparatus of claim 6 further comprising:means for compressing a first fluid flowing through the first fluid conduit; and means for expanding the first fluid.
  • 9. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the second fluid conduit comprises:an open loop conduit for circulating the heat sink liquid between a fluid inlet and a fluid outlet.
  • 10. The apparatus of claim 9, wherein the heat sink liquid is selected from the group consisting of water, coolant and mixtures thereof.
  • 11. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the cleaning cycle removes heat from the second fluid conduit to at least partially freeze liquid adjacent the at least one heat transfer wall of the second fluid conduit of the heat exchanger.
  • 12. The apparatus of claim 1 further comprising:timer means for tracking time periods for each of a series of deposit removal steps to be performed.
  • 13. A method for removing deposits from a heat exchanger having at least one heat transfer wall disposed between a first fluid conduit and a second fluid conduit for transporting a heat sink liquid, the method comprising the steps of:controlling fluid flow through the first and second fluid conduits in order to selectively operate in one of a heating cycle, and a cooling cycle with control means; and periodically removing deposits from at least one side of the at least one heat transfer wall extending between the first and second fluid conduits through the heat exchanger by at least partially freezing and then thawing the heat sink liquid located adjacent to the at least one heat transfer wall with a cleaning control system connectible with the control means for defining a cleaning cycle.
  • 14. The method of claim 13 further comprising the step of:disengaging a freeze switch of the heat exchanger.
  • 15. The method of claim 13 further comprising the step of:automatically actuating the cleaning cycle after the heat exchanger has operated for a predetermined time period.
  • 16. The method of claim 13 further comprising the steps of:removing heat from the second fluid conduit to at least partially freeze liquid adjacent the at least one heat transfer wall of the second fluid conduit through the heat exchanger.
  • 17. The method of claim 13 further comprising the step of:reducing fluid flow through the second fluid conduit while actuating the heating cycle; and increasing fluid flow through the second fluid conduit while actuating the cooling cycle.
  • 18. The method of claim 13, wherein the controlling step further comprises the step of:circulating refrigerant through a closed loop of the first conduit.
  • 19. The method of claim 13, wherein the controlling step further comprises the step of:circulating the heat sink liquid through an open loop of the second conduit.
  • 20. An apparatus for removing deposits from a heat exchanger having at least one heat transfer wall disposed between a first fluid conduit, and a second fluid conduit for transporting a heat sink liquid, the apparatus comprising:means for controlling fluid flow through the first and second fluid conduits for selectively operating in one of a heating cycle and a cooling cycle; and means for periodically removing deposits from at least one side of the at least one heat transfer wall extending between the first and second fluid conduits through the heat exchanger by at least partially freezing and then thawing the heat sink liquid located adjacent to the at least one heat transfer wall with a cleaning control system connectible to the controlling means for defining a cleaning cycle.
  • 21. A cleaning cycle control system for a heat pump having a heat exchanger with at least one heat transfer wall including first and second surfaces on opposite sides of the wall, the wall disposed between a refrigerant fluid conduit for selectively conveying refrigerant fluid in either flow direction across the first surface of the wall and a heat sink liquid conduit for selectively conveying heat sink liquid in a flow direction across the second surface of the wall, the heat pump selectively operable in a heating cycle, where the refrigerant fluid flows in a first direction across the first surface while the heat sink liquid flows across the second surface, and a cooling cycle, where the refrigerant fluid flows in a second direction across the first surface while the heat sink liquid flows across the second surface, the cleaning cycle control system comprising:a controller for initiating a cleaning cycle, where the refrigerant fluid initially flows across the first surface in the first direction while heat sink liquid flow is substantially reduced to initiate freezing of the heat sink liquid adjacent to the second surface for a first period of time, after the first period of time expires, the refrigerant fluid is then reversed to flow across the first surface in the second direction while the heat sink liquid flow is reestablished to initiate thawing of the heat sink liquid frozen adjacent to the second surface for a second period of time, wherein the freezing and thawing of the heat sink liquid adjacent the second surface of the wall loosens and dislodges accumulated deposits formed on the second surface thereby automatically cleaning the second surface to increase operational efficiency of the heat exchanger.
US Referenced Citations (33)
Number Name Date Kind
2954680 Ruff Oct 1960 A
3319704 Nasse May 1967 A
3918268 Nussbaum Nov 1975 A
3968833 Strindehag et al. Jul 1976 A
4091636 Margen May 1978 A
4143702 Barr, Jr. Mar 1979 A
4176708 Joffe Dec 1979 A
4217218 Bauer Aug 1980 A
4257239 Partin et al. Mar 1981 A
4336692 Ecker et al. Jun 1982 A
4407137 Hayes, Jr. Oct 1983 A
4468930 Johnson Sep 1984 A
4538418 Lawrence et al. Sep 1985 A
4577677 Ezzell Mar 1986 A
4593748 Kramb Jun 1986 A
4882908 White Nov 1989 A
4911229 McElroy Mar 1990 A
4928498 Gossler May 1990 A
4951473 Levine et al. Aug 1990 A
4993483 Harris Feb 1991 A
5021096 Abadi Jun 1991 A
5137081 Klaren Aug 1992 A
5190095 Fujimoto et al. Mar 1993 A
5214935 Brunskill Jun 1993 A
5388419 Kaye Feb 1995 A
5515689 Atterbury May 1996 A
5634515 Lambert Jun 1997 A
5642964 DeMasters Jul 1997 A
5706888 Ambs et al. Jan 1998 A
5727395 Guo et al. Mar 1998 A
5758514 Genung et al. Jun 1998 A
5885364 Hieatt et al. Mar 1999 A
5895763 Edstrand et al. Apr 1999 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (1)
Number Date Country
208 208 Mar 1984 DE
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
Luscombe, R.H., “Methods of Defrosting Commercial Refrigerating Equipment”, Penn Electric Switch Co., R.S.E.S. Dallas Educational Conference, Jan. 26-28, 1951, pp 1-6.