The disclosure below may be subject to copyright protection. The copyright owner has no objection to the facsimile reproduction by anyone of the documents contained in this disclosure as they appear in the Patent and Trademark Office records, but otherwise reserves all applicable copyrights.
A common desire in golf club manufacturing is to produce a club head having a striking face that imparts significant spin on a hit ball. Specifically, iron-type and utility-type golf club heads generally include a striking face having a plurality of grooves, or scorelines thereon. Such scorelines assist in imparting spin to a golf ball at least by channeling water and debris and improving traction between the striking face and the golf ball. However, the ability of scorelines to increase spin on a hit golf ball is limited in part by USGA regulation governing scoreline geometry. In addition, conventional scorelines fail to account for low-scale dynamic interaction characteristics between the striking face and the golf ball.
To further improve the ability of the striking face to impart spin, conventional club heads have included low-scale surface textures in addition to, or in place of, scorelines. However, such surface textures tend not to be tailored to the specific interaction between an elastomeric-coated golf ball and a metallic striking face. Further, conventional surface texturing is subject to rapid wear and costly to produce.
Also, common striking face surface textures are generally ineffective at enabling high spin for each of a variety of golf shot types that a golfer may attempt. For example, a golf ball hit by a golfer using a conventional club head with a specified swing speed would generally have a reduced ball spin if the golfer were to attempt a shot with the club face open, i.e. a “flop shot,” as compared with a typical golf shot with the club head squarely addressed.
Certain embodiments of the present invention, in one or more aspects thereof, may advantageously comprise a golf club head that delivers improved spin production, increased player confidence, and increased playability of the golf club.
According to various embodiments, a golf club head comprises a striking face having: a plurality of scorelines including a first scoreline and a second scoreline adjacent to the first scoreline, and a plurality of auxiliary grooves each spaced from the plurality of scorelines. When the club head is in a reference position, in a first imaginary vertical plane generally perpendicular to the striking face and passing through the first and second scorelines, a first path is formed by a first intersection between the first imaginary vertical plane and the striking face. The plurality of auxiliary grooves has a first concentration no less than 0.17 measured between the first scoreline and the second scoreline. In a second imaginary vertical plane generally perpendicular to the striking face and passing through the first and second scorelines, the second imaginary vertical plane being horizontally spaced from the first imaginary plane, a second path is formed by a second intersection between the second imaginary vertical plane and the striking face, and the plurality of auxiliary grooves has a second concentration measured between the first scoreline and the second scoreline. The second concentration is different from the first concentration.
According to various embodiments, a golf club head, when oriented in a reference position, comprises a top portion, and a bottom portion opposite the top portion, a heel portion, and a toe portion opposite the heel portion, a hosel extending from the heel portion, and a striking face. The striking face has a plurality of scorelines including a first scoreline and a second scoreline adjacent to the first scoreline, and a plurality of texture elements, each spaced from the plurality of scorelines. A first and a second imaginary vertical plane, each generally perpendicular to the striking face, and each passing through the first and the second scorelines, are horizontally spaced from each other by 10 mm. A third and a fourth imaginary vertical plane, each generally perpendicular to the striking face, and each passing through the first and the second scorelines, are each located toeward of both the first and the second imaginary vertical planes, and are horizontally spaced from each other by 10 mm. A first region is delimited by the first imaginary plane and the second imaginary plane, and, in the first region, the plurality of texture elements has an average concentration, C1, measured between the first and the second scorelines. A second region is delimited by the third imaginary plane and the fourth imaginary plane, and, in the second region, the plurality of texture elements has an average concentration, C2, measured between the first and the second scorelines. A ratio, C2/C1, is no greater than 0.85.
According to various embodiments, a golf club head when oriented in a reference position relative to a ground plane comprises a heel portion and a toe portion opposite the heel portion, a hosel extending from the heel portion, and a striking face. The striking face has a striking face plane, a face center, a central region including the face center, a peripheral region outward of the central region, and a plurality of scorelines that include at least a first scoreline and a second scoreline adjacent the first scoreline. The plurality of scorelines extending into the central region and the peripheral region. The striking face also has a plurality of auxiliary grooves at least partially interspersed within the plurality of scorelines. The plurality of auxiliary grooves extends into the central region and the peripheral region. In the central region, one or more of the plurality of auxiliary grooves follows a generally horizontal path relative to the ground plane, and the plurality of auxiliary grooves have an average concentration no less than 0.17 between the first scoreline and the second scoreline. In the peripheral region, one or more of the plurality of auxiliary grooves follows a non-horizontal path relative to the ground plane.
According to various embodiments, a golf club head, when oriented in a reference position relative to a ground plane, comprises a heel portion and a toe portion opposite the heel portion, a hosel extending from the heel portion, and a striking face. The striking face has a striking face plane, a plurality of scorelines having a heelwardmost extent, a toewardmost extent, and a width, W, being the horizontal distance between the heelwardmost extent and the toewardmost extent. The plurality of scorelines includes at least a first scoreline and a second scoreline adjacent the first scoreline. A plurality of auxiliary grooves is at least partially interspersed within the plurality of scorelines. A first imaginary vertical plane, perpendicular to the striking face plane, passes through the heelwardmost extent of the plurality of scorelines. A second imaginary vertical plane, parallel to the first imaginary vertical plane, passes through the toewardmost extent of the plurality of scorelines. A third imaginary vertical plane is parallel to the first imaginary vertical plane and equidistant between the first imaginary vertical plane and the second imaginary vertical plane. A fourth imaginary vertical plane is parallel to the first imaginary vertical plane and spaced from the third imaginary vertical plane toward the heelwardmost extent by a distance, D, that is between 0.10*W and 0.45*W. A fifth imaginary vertical plane is parallel to the first imaginary vertical plane and spaced from the third imaginary vertical plane toward the toewardmost extent by the distance D. A central region is delimited by the fourth and the fifth imaginary vertical planes. A heel region is delimited by the first and the fourth imaginary vertical planes. A toe region is delimited by the second and the fifth imaginary vertical planes. In the central region, one or more of the plurality of auxiliary grooves follows a generally horizontal path relative to the ground plane and the plurality of auxiliary grooves have a concentration no less than 0.17 measured between the first scoreline and the second scoreline. Further, in at least one of the heel region and the toe region, one or more of the plurality of auxiliary grooves follows a non-horizontal path relative to the ground plane.
These and other features and advantages of the golf club head according to the invention in its various aspects, as provided by one or more of the various examples described in detail below, will become apparent after consideration of the ensuing description, the accompanying drawings, and the appended claims. The accompanying drawings are for illustrative purposes only and are not intended to limit the scope of the present invention.
The present invention, in one or more aspects thereof, is illustrated by way of example and not by way of limitation, in the figures of the accompanying drawings, where:
For purposes of illustration, these figures are not necessarily drawn to scale. In all the figures, same or similar elements are designated by the same reference numerals.
Representative examples of one or more novel and nonobvious aspects and features of the golf club head according to the present invention, disclosed below, are not intended to be limiting in any manner. Furthermore, the various aspects and features of the present invention may be used alone or in a variety of novel and nonobvious combinations and subcombinations with one another.
Iron-type and utility-type golf club heads generally include a striking face that interfaces with and strikes a golf ball. A plurality of grooves, or scorelines, is provided on the striking face to assist in imparting spin to the golf ball. A portion of the face may have an area with a different type of surface treatment that extends beyond the scoreline extents. Conventionally, the orientation of the scorelines is such that spin is maximized when the striking face squarely impacts the golf ball with respect to a target line. However, when the orientation of the striking face deviates from the target line, e.g. when a golfer attempts a “flop shot” by opening the face of the club head, spin production and playability are reduced.
The striking face is selectively textured to enhance playability. The face point of contact with the ball, as well as the orientation and location of a contact path, varies depending upon the particular golf shot being performed. If the ball is laying on the fairway and the golfer takes a “regular” swing, then the golfer strives to make contact with the ball on the lower portion of the club face, typically the lower, central portion of the club face. In such cases, the resulting ball contact path along the striking face is substantially vertical and centered on the striking face, when the club head is viewed in a reference position relative to a ground plane, as defined below. For a flop shot, the golfer opens the club face to a large degree, which would result in a different contact point location and angular orientation. Still other portions of the face may be used for other types of shots; for example, some golfers use the extreme outer toe portion of the face, with the toe pointed toward the playing surface, as the ball contact point for chip shots. The face may therefore be variably textured to enhance each of the different types of shots the golfer may perform.
The United States Golf Association (USGA) publishes and maintains the Rules of Golf, which govern golf in the United States. Appendix II to the USGA Rules provides several limitations for golf clubs. For example, currently, the width of a groove cannot exceed 0.035 inch, the depth of a groove cannot exceed 0.020 inch, and the surface roughness within the area where impact is intended must not exceed that of decorative sand-blasting or of fine milling. The Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews, which is the governing authority for the rules of golf outside the United States, currently provides similar limitations to golf club design.
Certain embodiments of the present invention, in one or more aspects thereof, may advantageously comprise a golf club head that delivers improved spin production, increased player confidence, and increased playability of the golf club by way of incorporating a plurality of auxiliary grooves and/or texture elements into the striking face of the golf club head.
In one or more embodiments, and as depicted by way of example in
Referring to
The golf club head 100 also has a striking face 111 for striking a golf ball. The striking face 111 has a plurality of scorelines 113 and a plurality of auxiliary grooves 115 interspersed between the scorelines 113 and, in some embodiments, alternatively or additionally located outside of the region generally occupied by the scorelines 113. The plurality of scorelines 113 is provided on the striking face 111 to assist in imparting spin to a golf ball that contacts the striking face 111. The scorelines may be machined, e.g. by milling, optionally by spin-milling, or may be forged, stamped, rolled, pressed, or cast. In one or more embodiments, the plurality of auxiliary grooves 115 is a different type of surface treatment that extends between the scoreline extents. In some embodiments, the auxiliary grooves 115 vary in concentration and/or orientation between the scorelines 113 when traversing the striking face 111 from the toe portion 101 to the heel portion 103, and, additionally or alternatively, when traversing the striking face 111 the top portion 105 to the bottom portion 107. The striking face generally lies in an imaginary striking face plane 112 (see
Conventionally, the orientation of the scorelines 113 is such that spin is maximized when the striking face 111 squarely impacts the golf ball with respect to the reference position, or, in other words, the target line, during a “regular” shot. However, when the orientation of the striking face of a conventional golf club head that does not have any auxiliary grooves deviates from the reference position, spin production and playability are reduced.
The golf club head 100, as shown in
In some embodiments, as shown for example in
In one or more embodiments, the striking face 111 is polished, a nickel layer is applied, the striking face 111 is sandblasted, a second nickel layer is applied, and then the auxiliary grooves 115 are generated. This combination of processing steps and materials produces an aesthetically-pleasing contrast between auxiliary groove 115 coloring and the striking face 111. In some embodiments, the final nickel-coating process results in a dark, or black finish, further enhancing contrast. Further, such contrasts increase visibility of the auxiliary grooves and, in some embodiments, enhance a golfer's ability to align the club head with a golf ball.
Alternative or additional finishing processes may be applied to the striking face 111 of the club head 100, preferably prior to production of the auxiliary grooves 115. For example, the auxiliary grooves 115 may be superimposed on a striking face 111 that is micro-milled, media-blasted, chemically-etched, stamped, forged, laser-peened, unpolished, has other metal layers, rusted, not sandblasted, etc. Further embodiments may incorporate micro-surface texturing in combination with a substrate that is cast, milled, machined, forged, case-hardened, plated, media-blasted, anodized, etc. Any variation in materials, formation, surface texturing, layup, etc. may have an aesthetic effect that creates an appealing contrast with the auxiliary grooves 115, creates a moiré pattern that aids in alignment, creates a larger-scale roughness profile, aids in water/debris channeling, and may alter the performance and/or degree of feedback a player receives during a golf shot.
The auxiliary grooves 115, in one or more embodiments, are textured troughs generated by a high temperature laser that locally softens the surface of the striking face, creating a trough and generally roughened area surrounding the trough, otherwise known as “laser milling.” In some embodiments, such laser milling heat treats the striking face 111 in the region to which it is applied, which results in a more durable surface, and tighter tolerances than mechanical milling/machining. Alternatively, or in addition to the laser milling, the auxiliary grooves 115 may be generated by way of chemical etching, media blasting, milling, micro-milling, cross-milling, stamping, etc.
Laser milling is relatively non-invasive. In other words, it is too shallow to negatively affect the structural integrity of striking face 111. As such, there is no need to thicken the striking face. Further, the laser milling manner generating the auxiliary grooves 115 generally avoids creation of stress concentrations, and is clean and precise. This precision results in minimal waste and cleanup when compared to other processes, such as machine-milling Thus, laser milling is cost-effective. Further, laser milling may be applied without interference with the structure of the scorelines 113 and, in some cases, does not require any significant after-polishing, thereby further effecting a high spin surface at a low cost with little machine wear.
The auxiliary grooves 115 change the color of the affected area of the striking face 111 creating appealing contrast. This contrast increases visibility of scorelines 113, and increases the ability of the golfer to properly align the golf club head 100 with a golf ball, thereby improving a player's perception of the golf club head 100 and increasing the player's confidence in his or her ability to make a successful golf shot.
Referring to
Referring again to
As illustrated in
As shown in
Referring to
A first path 150 is formed along the striking face 111 by an intersection of the cross-section A-A′ and the striking face 111, and between the lowermost point 118 of the first scoreline 114 and the uppermost point 120 of the second scoreline 116. A distance λ1 of the first path 150 is illustrated between the lowermost point 118 of the first scoreline 114 and the uppermost point 120 of the second scoreline 116. Preferably, the distance between each pair of adjacent scorelines, in the cross-section A-A′, is substantially uniform. However, in alternative embodiments, the distance separating each pair of adjacent scorelines varies. A distance ω1 is a width of a first of the auxiliary grooves 115. Preferably, a width of each auxiliary groove in the cross-section A-A′ is substantially uniform. However, in alternative embodiments, such widths vary. A distance ω2 is a width of the second scoreline 116. Preferably, the width of each scoreline in cross-section A-A′ is substantially uniform. However, in alternative embodiments, such widths vary.
A distance d1 is a depth of one of the auxiliary grooves 115. Preferably, a depth of each of the auxiliary grooves shown in the cross-section A-A′ is substantially uniform, i.e. within the range of typical tolerances associated with the material removal process used in its formation. However, in alternative embodiments, such depths vary. A distance d2 is a depth of the second scoreline 116. Preferably, a depth of each scoreline shown in the cross-section A-A′ is uniform. However, in alternative embodiments, such depths vary.
As used herein, the term “concentration” refers to the concentration of auxiliary grooves over a specified length in a specified vertical cross-section, and is determined as a ratio of the total sum of widths of all auxiliary grooves that traverse a specified segment of a specified vertical cross-section to the overall length of the specified segment of the specified vertical cross-section.
In the central region 119, e.g. in the cross-section A-A′, the concentration of the plurality of auxiliary grooves 115 along the first path 150, in one or more embodiments, is no less than 0.12. However, in recognition of the specific interaction between an elastomeric-type golf ball and a metallic striking face, the concentration of the plurality of auxiliary grooves 115 along the first path 150 is more preferably between 0.17 and 0.25. However, in alternative embodiments, specifically where it is intended to provide a striking face having selectable spin characteristics dependent on the location of contact with a golf ball, the concentration may be less than 0.17 in areas intended to have reduced spin.
To further produce desired spin results, the average depth of the auxiliary grooves 115 in one embodiment is no greater than 15 microns. In another embodiment, the average depth of the auxiliary grooves 115 is no greater than 12 microns. In a further embodiment, the average depth of the auxiliary grooves 115 is between 6 microns and 12 microns.
Also, the average width of the auxiliary grooves 115 in some embodiments is no greater than 1.0 mm. In another embodiment, the width of the auxiliary grooves 115 is no greater than 0.5 mm. In still another embodiment, the average width of the auxiliary grooves is no greater than 0.25 mm. In another embodiment, the average width of the auxiliary grooves 115 is no greater than 0.20 mm. In a further embodiment, the average width of the auxiliary grooves 115 is between 0.12 mm and 0.18 mm.
A “frequency” of the plurality of auxiliary grooves, as used herein, refers to a number of all auxiliary grooves that traverse a specified path of a specified vertical cross-section of a striking face of a club head. Over the first path 150, in the cross-section A-A′, a frequency of the auxiliary grooves 115 is preferably no less than 0.90 grooves/mm. More preferably, and in recognition of the specific dynamic interaction between an elastomeric-type golf ball and a metallic striking face, such frequency is no less than 1.00 grooves/mm. More preferably, such frequency is no less than 1.10 grooves/mm. In a further embodiment, such frequency is no more than 1.70 grooves/mm. As discussed below, increasing or decreasing auxiliary groove frequency outside of this range has a deleterious effect on desired ball spin. The frequency of the auxiliary grooves 115 may be constant or variable between any two adjacent scorelines of the plurality of scorelines 113 over the striking face 111 and in a single cross-section, e.g. cross-section A-A′, or variable between multiple cross-sections spaced apart laterally. In other words, a first frequency between the same or different pair of scorelines 113 may be the same or different from a second frequency between the same or different pair of scorelines 113, depending on the location of a cross-section that is taken of the golf club head 100. Generally, however, a change in frequency would have an advantageous effect on the spin production in the case of alternative striking face 111 orientations.
With respect to the number of auxiliary grooves 115 between any two of the plurality of scorelines 113, in one embodiment, the number of auxiliary grooves 115 is no greater than five auxiliary grooves 115. In another embodiment, the number of auxiliary grooves 115 is no greater than four auxiliary grooves 115. In a further embodiment, the number of auxiliary grooves 115 is no less than three auxiliary grooves 115.
The following tables 1-1 and 1-2 illustrate collected performance data relating the frequency, concentration, and orientation of auxiliary grooves 115 to spin production using robot testing. Table 1-1 illustrates collected performance data comparing the auxiliary groove frequency and concentration of a golf club head 100, in a specified cross-section of a central region 119 of the striking face 111, the location of which being constant for each test club head, to the spin rate of the golf ball after impact.
Referring to
In one or more embodiments, the concentration, frequency, and/or number of auxiliary grooves 115 that occur between the first and second scorelines 114, 116 along the first path 150 (i.e. in the cross-section A-A′) and the second path 123 (i.e. in the cross-section B-B′) are different from one another. This variation in concentration causes the spin production to be different depending on the orientation of the golf club head 100 when impacting a golf ball, as discussed above. Specifically, a concentration of the auxiliary grooves that traverse the cross-section B-B′ is preferably less than the concentration of auxiliary grooves traversing the cross-section A-A′ in between the same first scoreline 114 and second scoreline 116. Specifically, such concentration is no greater than 0.18. More preferably, such concentration is between 0.05 and 0.18. Even more preferably, such concentration is between 0.12 and 0.16, most preferably substantially equal to 0.15.
Similarly, a frequency of all auxiliary grooves 115 traversing the second path 123 of the cross-section B-B′ is less than the frequency of all auxiliary grooves 115 traversing the first path in the cross-section A-A′. Specifically, such frequency is preferably no greater than 1.30 grooves/mm. More preferably, such frequency is between 0.50 grooves/mm and 1.15 grooves/mm. Even more preferably, such frequency is between 0.85 grooves/mm and 1.05 grooves/mm, most preferably between 0.95 grooves/mm and 1.05 grooves/mm. Similarly, the simple number of auxiliary grooves that traverse the second path in the cross-section B-B′ is less than the number that traverse the first path of cross-section A-A′, and in some embodiments less than four.
Table 1-2 includes performance data of a first golf club head having a striking face with a plurality of scorelines but absent any auxiliary grooves, and a second golf club head identical to the first golf club head, but with auxiliary grooves following the pattern shown in
Accordingly, to determine the average concentration of the plurality of auxiliary grooves 115 between the first scoreline 114 and the second scoreline 116, and between the third imaginary vertical plane 134 and the fourth imaginary vertical plane 136 (see
An exemplary concentration measurement is taken at l5 and in the cross-section C-C′.
The average concentration of the plurality of auxiliary grooves 115 measured between the first scoreline 114 and the second scorelines 116, and between the third imaginary vertical plane 134 and the fourth imaginary vertical plane 136 (see
Preferably, C1 is no less than 0.15. More preferably, C1 is between 0.18 and 0.25, most preferably equal to about 0.20. Preferably, C2 is no greater than 0.20. More preferably, C2 is between 0.12 and 0.18, and most preferably equal to about 0.15. Preferably, C1 and C2 are related in that C1 is greater than C2. More specifically, C1 is preferably greater than C2 by at least 0.25, more preferably at least 0.35. Alternatively, or in addition, a ratio of the concentrations C2/C1 is no greater than 0.85. In another embodiment, the ratio of concentrations C2/C1 is no greater than 0.80. In still a further embodiment, the ratio C2/C1 is between 0.70 and 0.80. Alternatively, or in addition, the face center 117 of the striking face 111 is located within the region delimited by the first scoreline 114, the second scoreline 116, the first imaginary vertical plane 130, and the second imaginary vertical plane 132.
In
The auxiliary grooves 115 define a first transition location 146 at which an auxiliary groove pattern transitions, e.g. from horizontal, spaced apart grooves to spaced apart grooves, proximate the heel portion 103 of the club head 100, inclined relative to the ground plane. At a second transition location 148, the auxiliary groove pattern again transitions from horizontal spaced apart grooves to spaced apart grooves, proximate the toe portion 101 of the club head 100, inclined relative to the ground plane. In some embodiments, either, or both, of the transition locations 146 and 148 lie at the intersection of the striking face plane 112 and a vertical plane perpendicular to the striking face plane 112. In alternative embodiments, either, or both, of the transition locations 146 and 148 lies along a linear path that is oblique relative to the direction of elongation of the scorelines 113. In alternative embodiments, either, or both, of the transition locations 146 and 148 follow a generally curvilinear path along the striking face plane 112.
An eighth imaginary vertical plane 144 is perpendicular to the striking face plane 112 and coplanar with the transition location 146. A ninth imaginary vertical plane 145 is perpendicular to the striking face plane 112 and coplanar with the transition location 148.
A width W of the plurality of scorelines 113 denotes the lateral distance between the heelwardmost extent 152 and the toewardmost extent 154 of the plurality of scorelines 113. The width W is preferably within the range of 35 mm to 65 mm, more preferably between 45 mm and 55 mm, and most preferably equal to about 50 mm. The fifth imaginary vertical plane 138 and the eighth imaginary vertical plane 144 are spaced apart by a distance L5. The distance L5 is preferably between 12 mm and 18 mm, more preferably equal to about 15 mm. The seventh imaginary vertical plane 142 and the eighth imaginary vertical plane 144 are spaced apart by a distance L3. The distance L3 is preferably between 6 mm and 14 mm, more preferably equal to about 10 mm. The seventh imaginary vertical plane 142 and the ninth imaginary vertical plane 145 are spaced apart by a distance L2. The distance L2 is preferably between 6 mm and 14 mm, more preferably equal to about 10 mm. The sixth imaginary vertical plane 140 and the ninth imaginary vertical plane 145 are spaced apart by a distance L4. The distance L4 is preferably between 12 mm and 18 mm, more preferably equal to about 15 mm.
In various embodiments, the seventh imaginary plane 142 is equidistant between the fifth imaginary plane 138 and the sixth imaginary plane 140. That is, L5+L3=L4+L2. Additionally, or alternatively, the eighth and ninth imaginary planes 144 and 145 are spaced from the seventh imaginary plane 142 by a distance D. In some embodiments, the distance D is preferably between 0.10*W and 0.45*W.
In various embodiments, a central region is delimited by the eighth imaginary vertical plane 144 and the ninth imaginary vertical plane 145, a heel region is delimited by the fifth imaginary vertical plane 138 and the eighth imaginary vertical plane 144, and a toe region is delimited by the sixth imaginary vertical plane 140 and the ninth imaginary vertical plane 145. In some embodiments, at least one of the auxiliary grooves 115 follows a generally horizontal path, relative to the ground plane within the central region.
A first imaginary vertical plane 219 is illustrated as passing through a central region of the striking face 211. A second imaginary vertical plane 221 is illustrated as passing through a toeward region of the striking face 211. A third imaginary vertical plane 223 is illustrated as passing through a heelward region of the striking face 211. The texture elements 215 are generally horizontal in the central region. The texture elements 215 deviate from a horizontal orientation in each of the heelward and toeward regions, e.g. are inclined relative to a ground plane, in the striking face plane. Preferably, the texture elements 215 are configured such that they include frequency values, concentration values, and average concentration values that are similar to those values discussed with regard to the embodiment of
Those skilled in the art will appreciate that while the present invention has been described in association with presently preferred aspects thereof, numerous changes, modifications and substitutions of equivalents may be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope of this invention which is intended to be unlimited by the foregoing except as may appear in the following appended claims.
This application is a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 14/857,386, filed Sep. 17, 2015, which is a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 14/175,763, filed Feb. 7, 2014 (now U.S. Pat. No. 9,162,116 B2 issued Oct. 20, 2015), which is a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 13/215,917, filed Aug. 23, 2011 (now U.S. Pat. No. 8,684,861 B2 issued Apr. 1, 2014). The prior application, including the specification, drawings and abstract are incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5451056 | Manning | Sep 1995 | A |
5800285 | Thorne et al. | Sep 1998 | A |
6198066 | Thorne | Mar 2001 | B1 |
6475099 | Sumitomo et al. | Nov 2002 | B1 |
6710287 | Lu | Mar 2004 | B2 |
6713717 | Takeda | Mar 2004 | B2 |
6719644 | Beach | Apr 2004 | B2 |
7278928 | Newman et al. | Oct 2007 | B2 |
7445561 | Newman et al. | Nov 2008 | B2 |
7491131 | Vinton | Feb 2009 | B2 |
7520045 | Lo | Apr 2009 | B2 |
7594863 | Ban | Sep 2009 | B2 |
8506420 | Hocknell et al. | Aug 2013 | B2 |
8684861 | Carlyle et al. | Apr 2014 | B2 |
9162116 | Carlyle et al. | Oct 2015 | B2 |
20020091014 | Aldrich | Jul 2002 | A1 |
20050113186 | Newman et al. | May 2005 | A1 |
20070167249 | Voges et al. | Jul 2007 | A1 |
20070173346 | Chiang et al. | Jul 2007 | A1 |
20080051212 | Voges | Feb 2008 | A1 |
20080125241 | Tateno et al. | May 2008 | A1 |
20080125242 | Ban | May 2008 | A1 |
20080207349 | Gilbert et al. | Aug 2008 | A1 |
20080307631 | Lin et al. | Dec 2008 | A1 |
20090176597 | Yamagishi et al. | Jul 2009 | A1 |
20090313806 | Gilbert | Dec 2009 | A1 |
20090318243 | Golden et al. | Dec 2009 | A1 |
20100029401 | Nakamura | Feb 2010 | A1 |
20100261545 | Ban | Oct 2010 | A1 |
20100285898 | Gilbert et al. | Nov 2010 | A1 |
20110269567 | Ban et al. | Nov 2011 | A1 |
20120264537 | Breier et al. | Oct 2012 | A1 |
Entry |
---|
Cleveland Golf CG15 Black Pearl wedge, Oct. 13, 2009, http://www.clevelandgolf.com/US_cg15-black-pearl_CG15BP_viewProd_wedges.html (obtained Aug. 22, 2011). |
Nike VR Pro Wedge, Oct. 19, 2010, http://www.nike.com/nikeos/p/nikegolf/en_US/products/details?sku=GW0320 (obtained Aug. 22, 2011). |
Apr. 22, 2016 Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 14/857,386. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20170087424 A1 | Mar 2017 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 14857386 | Sep 2015 | US |
Child | 15371879 | US | |
Parent | 14175763 | Feb 2014 | US |
Child | 14857386 | US | |
Parent | 13215917 | Aug 2011 | US |
Child | 14175763 | US |