This invention relates to diffusion optical spectroscopy and, in particular, to a handheld probe and system using the handheld probe for cross-sectional imaging of human tissue.
According to the Canadian and American cancer societies' reports, breast cancer is the most common cancer in women and it is ranked as the second cause of death, in North America. Breast cancer affects approximately one in eight North America women during their lifetime. Treatment entails a number of steps from the time of diagnoses to a consistent follow-up after the treatment stage. These steps have to be taken seriously if there is any suspicions lesion. Introducing new technology or improving one or more of the assessment parameters including: accuracy, sensitivity, specificity or positive predictive value on current techniques, may help physicians to detect breast cancer in its early stage, which is crucial in women's health. The screening methods of clinical breast exam (CBE) and X-ray mammography are questionable for their lower sensitivity. X-ray mammography is a preliminary screening methodology, it is painful and uses harmful ionizing X-ray radiation.
Ultrasound, x-ray mammography, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are commonly used for breast cancer detection where X-ray mammography is the primary screening technique for breast cancer. Although X-ray mammography is the principle modality for breast cancer screening, it is recommended for women over the age of 50, because it has low sensitivity (67.8%) for younger women or women with dense breasts. In addition, it has a potential health risk as an effect of ionizing radiations. Therefore, because of X-ray mammography's limitations, researchers have been encouraged to use different breast cancer detection modalities, such as diffuse optical tomography, impedance spectroscopy and elasto-graphy.
Over the past three decades great progress has occurred in optoelectronics components and fiber optics. In parallel with these developments, near-infrared (NIR) optical imaging, in association with optoelectronic devices and fiber optics, also have been developed very rapidly and currently NIR optical imaging approaches have been advanced for breast cancer diagnosis. This technique is known as a noninvasive and promising method for compositional and functional imaging of extremely scattering mediums, such as brain and breast.
The optical properties of the breast tissue have been widely studied. For example, it is known that the absorption of the four main constituents of breast tissue, namely water, fat, deoxyhemoglobin (Hb) and oxyhemoglobin (HbO2), is low in the wavelength spectrum from 650 nm to 1100 nm, which allows light to travel deeply into the breast tissue.
A number of handheld diffuse optical probes have been implemented and tested for breast cancer detection and screening. Almost all of the probes are designed in reflectance geometry to measure optical properties of the breast tissue underneath of the probes. Laser light sources or fiber coupled laser light sources in near infrared range are used to determine the concentration of main chromophores in the breast tissue related to sensing anomalies. However, laser and fiber-optic based illumination techniques are complex, large in size and costly.
An object of the invention is to address the above shortcomings.
The above shortcomings may be addressed by providing, in accordance with one aspect of the invention, a diffuse-optical-spectroscopy system for scanning human tissue. The system includes: (a) a handheld probe operable to emit electromagnetic radiation at one or more wavelengths corresponding to absorption associated with one or more human-tissue constituents, respectively, the handheld probe being operable to detect received electromagnetic radiation at each of the one or more wavelengths; and (b) a processor operable to produce, in response to the received electromagnetic radiation, one or more cross-sectional images of the human tissue respectively associated with the one or more wavelengths.
The handheld probe may include one or more sensors for detecting the received electromagnetic radiation, the one or more sensors being aligned along a first axis and facing in an outward direction. The handheld probe may include first and second sources for emitting the electromagnetic radiation, the first and second sources being aligned along the first axis, facing in the outward direction, and disposed on either side of the one or more sensors. The one or more wavelengths may include at least four wavelengths corresponding to absorption associated with at least four human-tissue constituents. Each of the at least four wavelengths may be in at least one of a visible region, a near-infrared region, and an infrared region of the electromagnetic spectrum. The at least four human-tissue constituents may include deoxyhemoglobin, oxyhemoglobin, water and fat. Each of the first and second sources may include first, second, third and fourth light sources operable to emit the electromagnetic radiation at first, second, third and fourth wavelengths, respectively, each of the first, second, third and fourth light sources being selected from the group consisting of a light-emitting diode, an encapsulated light-emitting diode, and a laser. The handheld probe may include a linear array detector (charge-coupled device or linear photodiode) that includes the one or more sensors. The electromagnetic radiation may be continuous wave electromagnetic radiation.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of scanning human tissue by diffuse-optical-spectroscopy. The method involves: (a) emitting electromagnetic radiation at one or more wavelengths corresponding to absorption associated with one or more human-tissue constituents, respectively, by a handheld probe placed in proximity to the human tissue; (b) detecting by the handheld probe received electromagnetic radiation at each of the one or more wavelengths; and (c) in response to the received electromagnetic radiation, producing by a processor one or more cross-sectional images of the human tissue respectively associated with the one or more wavelengths.
Step (b) of the method may involve detecting the received electromagnetic radiation by one or more sensors of the handheld probe when the one or more sensors are aligned along a first axis and facing in an outward direction. Step (a) of the method may involve emitting the electromagnetic radiation by first and second sources of the handheld probe when the first and second sources are aligned along the first axis, facing in the outward direction, and disposed on either side of the one or more sensors. Step (a) of the method may involve emitting the electromagnetic radiation at the one or more wavelengths that may include at least four wavelengths corresponding to absorption associated with at least four human-tissue constituents, each of the at least four wavelengths being in at least one of a visible region, a near-infrared region, and an infrared region of the electromagnetic spectrum, the at least four human-tissue constituents comprising deoxyhemoglobin, oxyhemoglobin, water and fat. Step (a) of the method may involve emitting the electromagnetic radiation by first, second, third and fourth light sources at first, second, third and fourth wavelengths, respectively when each of the first, second, third and fourth light sources are selected from the group consisting of a light-emitting diode, an encapsulated light-emitting diode, and a laser. Step (b) of the method may involve detecting the received electromagnetic radiation by at least one of a charge-coupled device and an array photodiode of the handheld probe when the at least one of a charge-coupled device and an array photodiode comprises the one or more sensors. Step (a) of the method may involve emitting continuous wave electromagnetic radiation.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, there is provided a system for scanning human tissue by diffuse-optical-spectroscopy. The system includes: (a) source means for emitting electromagnetic radiation at one or more wavelengths corresponding to absorption associated with one or more human-tissue constituents, respectively; (b) receiving means for detecting received electromagnetic radiation at each of the one or more wavelengths; and (c) processing means for producing, in response to the received electromagnetic radiation, one or more cross-sectional images of the human tissue respectively associated with the one or more wavelengths.
Diffuse optical spectroscopy (DOS) and diffuse optical Imaging (DOI) are methods for breast cancer diagnosis which are noninvasive and nonionizing techniques. The DOB-Scan probe is used to measure optical properties of breast tissue and create functional and compositional cross-sectional images of the breast. Four wavelengths light emitting diodes (LED), encapsulated in a package (eLED), are used to illuminate the breast tissue. A linear charge coupled device (CCD) measures the intensity of the scattered photons at different radial destinations from the illumination source on the surface of the breast tissue. The proposed method replaces fiber optic based illumination techniques, which increases the complexity, size and cost of a potential probe, by multi-wavelengths eLED which acts as a pencil beam source in such a scattering media like the breast tissue. In addition, the DOB-Scan probe and associated algorithm can create cross-sectional images of the breast tissue underneath of the probe by using high resolution linear CCD. The introduced technique miniaturizes the probe, while maintaining reliability and accuracy of this technique in breast imaging. Multi-wavelength light sources are used to increase the capability of the probe by creating separate images for four primary chromophores of the breast tissue including deoxyhemoglobin, oxyhemoglobin, fat and water. The average scattering coefficient of the medium and localized concentration variations in oxyhemoglobin and deoxyhemoglobin can be measured utilizing the probe. In order to evaluate the performance of DOB-Scan probe, a series of tissue-like materials (phantoms), containing of Intralipid®, Black ink, Delrin®, and Pierce™ have been used to produce the experimental results indicated below. The test results provide evidence that the DOB-Scan probe can detect any inhomogeneity inside the phantoms.
The foregoing summary is illustrative only and is not intended to be in any way limiting. Other aspects and features of the present invention will become apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art upon review of the following description of embodiments of the invention in conjunction with the accompanying figures and claims.
In drawings which illustrate by way of example only embodiments of the invention:
A system for scanning human tissue by diffuse-optical-spectroscopy includes: (a) source means for emitting electromagnetic radiation at one or more wavelengths corresponding to absorption associated with one or more human-tissue constituents, respectively; (b) receiving means for detecting received electromagnetic radiation at each of the one or more wavelengths; and (c) processing means for producing, in response to the received electromagnetic radiation, one or more cross-sectional images of the human tissue respectively associated with the one or more wavelengths.
With reference to the Figures, a handheld diffuse optical breast scanning probe, an exemplary prototype of which is variously referred to herein as the probe and/or the DOB-Scan probe 10, is operable for functional and compositional cross-sectional imaging of breast tissue 12 (
The DOB-Scan probe 10 is used to create two-dimensional cross-sectional images of breast tissue 12 in-vivo. In the probe, an array detector (e.g. CCD 18) is used to create cross-sectional images of breast tissue 12. The breast tissue 12 is illuminated with two eLEDs 16 which in an exemplary embodiment are located 60 mm away from each other (15 mm away from either side of the CCD 18) and are used to have symmetrical light illumination sources.
An exemplary embodiment of the DOB-Scan probe 10 for functional and compositional cross-sectional imaging of the breast tissue 12 employs multi-wavelength diffuse optical spectroscopy technique with four wavelengths encapsulated in an eLED 16 light source in the near infrared spectrum range. The device and associated system hardware provide four two-dimensional images of the breast tissue's function and composition. Each eLED 16 contains four wavelengths (e.g. 690 nm, 750 nm, 800 nm and 850 nm), which are illuminated into the breast tissue 12 once a time and the linear CCD 18 collects scattered light on the skin of the breast tissue 12. Then, the system processes the data and transfers them to a host computer 20 for further analysis and image reconstruction. From the collected data at one or more (e.g. four) different wavelengths, the system is able to create one or more cross-sectional optical absorption images for concentration of one or more different chromophores in the breast tissue such as Hb and HbO2 which are markers for cancerous tissue. Also, the prototypical probe and method accurately create cross-sectional optical absorption images such that there is no need to use laser diodes or fiber coupled laser diodes as an illumination source, although such illumination sources may be employed in variations of embodiments of the present invention. Real time data acquisition system components add functional imaging advantages to the probe. In the exemplary prototypical embodiment, the image reconstruction for each wavelength is performed at the rate of 24 Hz which is sufficient for functional imaging of biological activity.
A photograph of the DOB-Scan probe 10 prototype with its system hardware housed within the DOB-Scan probe 10 is shown in
Eight near infrared light sources are used to illuminate the breast tissue 12 through two eLEDs 16. A Schematic diagram of the instrument is shown in
Two eLEDs 16 (e.g. from Marubeni America Corporation L690/750/800/850) are used in the probe 10, which are located 15 mm away from each end-side of the detector (e.g. CCD 18) as shown in
The light detector plays an important role in the instrument. In order to have high resolution images, it should have large number of light sensors with small size and patches. The light sources are located at two ends of the detector and the illuminated photons are travelling in different path lengths to reach to the photodetectors. The photodetectors which are located close to the active light source will be exposed to a higher light intensity and the ones that are placed far from active light source, will receive lower light intensity. Therefore, the photodetectors must have a large dynamic range to allow measurement for both small and large source-photodetector separations. The photodetector circuit of the prototype is specially designed to address these challenges. The light detector (ILX511, SONY™) used for the probe 10 is a linear charge coupled device 18, which has a fixed capacitor associated with each photodetector (pixel). The photodetector chip of the prototype has 2086 pixels in total which is called one frame. 32 pixels at the beginning of the frame and 6 pixels at the end of the frame are dummy pixels. Therefore, the photodetector of the prototype has 2048 effective pixels with 14 μm pixel pitch; consequently the effective imaging area of the prototype is 28.672 mm (2048×14 μm).
NIR photons migration in biological tissue and optical properties of the breast tissue are compatible with diffusion optical spectroscopy. Four main absorbers in the breast tissue in NIR range (650 nm to 1100 nm) are deoxyhemoglobin (Hb), oxyhemoglobin (HbO2), water and fat. The optical properties of the breast tissue are widely studied and published in academic journal articles. These studies demonstrate that absorption of water and fat are low in NIR range, which allows photons to travel deeply into the breast tissue.
The raw data acquired from the linear CCD 18 (2048 pixels, pixels pitch: 14 μm), two light sources and four NIR wavelengths are one frame which obtained from surface of the breast tissue. Therefore, total numbers of measurement points for one frame scan are 16384 (2048×2×4). The propagation of the light in a highly scattering medium like the breast tissue 12 can be precisely modeled utilising the diffusion equation. As illustrated in
In particular, in a highly scattering medium such as breast tissue 12, the radiative transfer equation can be simplified by the diffusion equation as follows:
∇D(r)∇Φd(r)−μacmΦd(r)=−S(r) (1)
where Φd represents the intensity at the detector located r mm away from the illumination source(S(r)). cm and μa are the photons velocity in the medium and absorption coefficient, respectively. D represents diffusion coefficient.
Within the NIR spectrum range (650 nm to 1100 nm), the photons' migration in the biological tissue is in the scattering region and diffusion equation can be used to describe photons propagation. The following expression (2) presents analytical solution for the diffusion equation in a homogeneous media while the illumination source and detector setting in reflectance geometry.
Where the parameters are defined as follows:
The diffusion equation is effective while r is greater than 10×(μa+μs′)−1 and μa<<μs′;
There are several studies demonstrating that there is not remarkable changes on the total attenuation coefficient (μt′) of normal and cancerous breast tissue. Because, μa of the breast tissue is much smaller than μs′, so fluctuation in μa will not have remarkable variation on μt′. These studies demonstrate that μa and μs′ of the breast tissue are in the range of 0.002 mm−1 to 0.012 mm−1 and 0.6 mm−1 to 1.5 mm−1, respectively, at the NIR spectrum range. It has also been shown that variation on μt′ does not have notable results on the back scattered photons at the photodetector position.
Oxy-hemoglobin (HbO2), deoxy-hemoglobin (Hb), water (H2O), and fat are the four primary chromophores in the breast tissue which contribute to the attenuation at wavelength λ and concentration of HbO2 and Hb vary by the time. The direct-approach-method equation (3) can be used to create cross-sectional images for the four chromophores concentration and concentration variations in Hb (ΔcHb) and HbO2 (ΔcHbO2) shown in the cross-sectional images.
Where εnλ is the molar absorption extinction coefficient for the chromophore type n (n should be Hb, HbO2, H2O and Fat) at illuminated wavelength of λ (690 nm, 750 nm, 800 nm, 850 nm) and Cn is the total concentration of the chromophore in the photons path lengths. While the exemplary wavelengths of 690, 750, 800 and 850 nm are mentioned herein in association with the chromophores of Hb, HbO2, H2O and Fat, it is understood that each of the wavelengths may vary in any range that is suitably associated with a corresponding chromophore or other human-tissue constituent or type.
In the wider source-detector separation, back scattered light travels through deeper and longer paths in the tissue. Concentrations of Hb and HbO2 vary by the heartbeat. Concentration distribution of four absorbers can be calculated by solving equation (3) for different light paths to reconstruct images for the absorbers and visualize the variation of them in the breast tissue.
The obtained raw data from the exemplary prototype having 2048 pixels, 2 sources and 4 wavelengths are measurement points collected from surface of the tissue. A reconstruction algorithm is useful for converting the surface measured light intensity into two-dimensional cross-sectional images of the chromophores. In the first step, the absorption coefficient (μa) of each light paths are calculated by utilizing equation (2) while the tissue is illuminated by each wavelength. In order to reduce effect of the noise on the measurements, we reduced the number of measurement points to 128 points (P1 to P128) by averaging 16 pixels. It can be assumed that the origin of the coordinate is located on the center of light source #1 as showed in
Table 1 presents a brief specification of the exemplary DOB-Scan probe in prototype form.
A MATLAB® (MATLAB R2012b, MathWoks®) based software interface gives the user complete controls of the hardware in addition to allowing them to collect, store, analyze data and create images, including color-mapped images, on the host computer. The software interface communicates with the DOB-Scan probe 10 via USB2.0 (or other serial communications technology) virtual comport and contains a graphical user interface (GUI) 34, as shown in
Experimental Results
To verify performance of the exemplary prototype of the designed DOB-Scan probe 10, a study based upon tissue equivalent material was conducted. In this study, we used an incomplete (truncated) cylindrical shaped (8 cm diameter and 28 cm length) acetal resin rod 14 (Delrin®) and Intralipid® to mimic background breast tissue 12 due to similarity in optical properties to the breast fat. (μs′=2.3 mm−1 and μa=0.002 mm−1). Also, optical properties of these two materials are well-documented and known. In order to mimic cancerous lesions, a 5 mm hole 36 is placed on the side wall of the cylinder 14; located 15 mm below the incomplete side of the Acetal resin rod 14, as shown in
In the first experiment, we used phantom #1 14 in which the hole 36 was filled with tumor-like liquid phantom. The liquid-phantom is a solution consisting of 1 L water, 50 mL Intralipid® and 1.5 mL India black ink. In this case, we put the probe 10 in three different locations on the phantom 14 in which the middle line of the probe 10 (middle of the CCD 18) is aligned: a) along the center of the hole 36, b) 7 mm to the left of the hole 36 center, and c) 7 mm to the right of the hole 36 center, as shown in
In the second experiment, we evaluated performance of the probe 10 to accurately create a separate image for different absorbers such as Hb and HbO2. Therefore, we used protein assay reagent (PAR) to form inhomogeneity inside the phantom which has similar optical properties to HbO2 in the NIR spectrum range. We used a solution of 1.5 mL Pierce™ 660 nm PAR (Thermo Scientific™ Inc.) mixed with 10 μL Pre-diluted protein assay standards: Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA), with 1000 μg/mL in 0.9% saline and 0.05% sodium azide to make a PAR. The absorption coefficient of RBSA at 690 nm wavelength is 0.17 mm−1 which is much higher than its absorption coefficient at 750 nm, 800 nm and 850 nm (0.015 mm−1).
Since, absorption coefficient of the RBSA is much higher than surrounded material the probe 10 can capture this difference.
In order to evaluate the probe's effectiveness in monitoring the effect of therapy on the size of a tumor, we have done one more experiment in which the absorption coefficient of a cancerous-mimicking phantom 14 is gradually increased by adding India black ink to a reference solution of water and Intralipid® (50 ml/l). In this experiment, India black ink was added in 0.125 ml/l increments from 0.125 ml/l to 0.75 ml/l, however, the scattering coefficient of the medium was not affected by increasing the ink concentration.
Four images are reconstructed for each step. Therefore 24 images are created, in total. As mentioned before, we just present one image 48 (690 nm) for each step, because India black ink has a flat absorption spectrum in the NIR range, which is shown in
The reddish areas 40 and the non-reddish areas 42 in images 48 of
The performance of an exemplary prototype of the probe 10 was evaluated by testing it on breast tissue-like phantom 14. The test results of the exemplary probe being used on breast tissue-like phantom show that the probe 10 can create functional images and chromophores composition images of the phantom 14.
Initial Clinical Study
Extended data collected for cancerous tissue further demonstrates the probe's performance in its prototypical form. A technique to identify malignant breast tumors using contralateral healthy body tissue as a control is used to produce preliminary results for ten cases presented below.
A clinical study was performed on ten patients who have been diagnosed with breast cancer. Before any measurements are taken, subjects' height, weight, age and gender were recorded. Details of subjects' breast cancer (for example, type of cancer, date of diagnosis, etc.) were also recorded. The subjects were asked to lie down on their back and then we placed the probe on the location of the breast that had cancer. The skin to which the probe is located is cleaned with alcohol prep pads. The same procedure has been done on the contralateral side of the breast. The test procedure takes approximately twenty minutes. We obtained preliminary data with DOB-Scan probe while that is located on the breast where diagnosed to have malignant tissue and its contralateral location on the healthy breast. Data gathered with cross sectional diffuse optical imaging modality processed and analysed to explore performance of the exemplary probes to detect and characterize malignant tissue in the breast, in-vivo.
The reconstructed preliminary images show that the DOB-San probe can distinguish the cancerous region from the surrounding healthy tissue. The cancerous region is observable in the images (red area) due to a higher level of absorption caused by higher levels of vascularization. The red area on the images reflexes location of anomaly tissue in the breast.
For each patient, two locations are scanned over cancerous lesion with the control as a contralateral healthy breast tissue. Four cross-sectional images are reconstructed for four NIR sources on each location. The test results below show that absorption coefficient of cancerous lesions are significantly higher than normal surrounding tissue. The main objective of this study was to validate the usability of developed DOB-Scan imaging set up to create cross-sectional images of the breast tissue and detect anomalies inside inhomogeneous breast tissue, based upon optical properties of the anomaly to the surrounding material.
Table 2 represents brief clinical reports for the patients who enrolled in the further clinical study.
Referring to
Each of the ten cases are described below.
Case 1: There was two cancerous lesions in the left breast and the probe 10 located on the one located at 10 o'clock of the left breast.
Case 2: There was two cancerous lesions in the left breast and the probe 10 located on the one located at 4 o'clock of the left breast.
Case 3: There was a cancerous lesions in the left breast at 1 o'clock.
Case 4: There was a cancerous lesions in the right breast at 9 o'clock. This patient had large breasts with a cancerous lesion positioned near to the chest wall. In these cases, the probe 10 captures the cancerous lesion with difficulty due to the depth of the tumor in the breast (
Case 5: There was a cancerous lesions in the left breast at 2 o'clock. Reconstructed images for the left breast of patient #5 (
Case 6: There was a cancerous lesions in the right breast at 1 o'clock.
Case 7: There was a cancerous lesions in the right breast between 10 and 11 o'clock.
Case 8: Data collection failed due to technical problem. Thus, images corresponding to this case are not provided in association with the present invention.
Case 9: There was a cancerous lesions in the left breast at 1 o'clock.
Case 10: There was a cancerous lesions in the left breast at 5 o'clock.
As shown, the DOB-Scan probe 10 can be used to capture cross-sectional images of the female breast's interior using NIR light sources associated with a linear CCD. The reconstructed preliminary images show that DOB-San probe can identify the cancerous region from the surrounding healthy tissue. The cancerous region is observed in the images due to the higher level of absorption caused by higher levels of vascularization in the cancerous region.
Thus, there is provided a diffuse-optical-spectroscopy system for scanning human tissue. The system includes: (a) a handheld probe operable to emit electromagnetic radiation at one or more wavelengths corresponding to absorption associated with one or more human-tissue constituents, respectively, the handheld probe being operable to detect received electromagnetic radiation at each of the one or more wavelengths; and (b) a processor operable to produce, in response to the received electromagnetic radiation, one or more cross-sectional images of the human tissue respectively associated with the one or more wavelengths.
While embodiments of the invention have been described and illustrated, such embodiments should be considered illustrative of the invention only. The invention may include variants not described or illustrated herein in detail. Thus, the embodiments described and illustrated herein should not be considered to limit the invention as construed in accordance with the accompanying claims.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/CA2018/050052 | 1/17/2018 | WO |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2018/132908 | 7/26/2018 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6665557 | Alfano | Dec 2003 | B1 |
20060111622 | Merritt et al. | May 2006 | A1 |
20060122475 | Balberg | Jun 2006 | A1 |
20130256534 | Micheels | Oct 2013 | A1 |
20140243681 | Hielscher | Aug 2014 | A1 |
20170195589 | Kovacovsky | Jul 2017 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2417917 | Feb 2002 | CA |
WO0212854 | Feb 2002 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Erickson-Bhatt, Sarah J., et al. “Noninvasive surface imaging of breast cancer in humans using a hand-held optical imager.” Biomedical physics & engineering express 1.4 (2015): 045001. (Year: 2015). |
Erickson-Bhatt et al., “Noninvasive Surface Imaging of Breast Cancer in Humans using a Hand-held Optical Imager”, Biomedical Physics & Engineering Express, vol. 1, No. 4, Oct. 2015, pp. 045001 [See Supplementary European Search Report]. |
Erickson et al., “Hand-held based near-infrared optical imaging devices: A review”, Medical Engineering & Physics, Butterworth-Heinemann, vol. 31, No. 5, Jun. 2009, pp. 495-509 [See Supplementary European Search Report]. |
Xu el al., “A Prospective Pilot Clinical Trial Evaluating the utility of a Dynamic Near-infrared Imaging Device for Characterizing Suspicious Breast Lesions”, Breast Cancer Research, Current Medicine Group Ltd.. vol. 9, No. 6, Dec. 2007, p. R88 [See Supplementary European Search Report]. |
Supplementary European Search Report issued in European Patent Application No. 18 74 1716 dated Sep. 25, 2020. |
Shokoufi et al., “Development of a Handheld Diffuse Optical Breast Cancer Assessment Probe”, Journal of Innovative Optical Health Sciences, vol. 9, No. 2, Oct. 30, 2015, pp. 1650007-1 to 1650007-10 See International Search. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190328233 A1 | Oct 2019 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62447752 | Jan 2017 | US |