In the field of sound reproduction and particularly in the field of headsets that provide a cup around a listener's ear with a speaker or driver in the cup to generate sound and deliver it to the listener's ear, reproducing sound in such a way that the listener perceives the sound as the same or similar as if the listener were hearing it in an open-air setting without wearing headphones can be challenging. In addition, generating or reproducing sound in a headset that gives the listener an experience of the sound coming from a particular direction (and moving relative to the listener) can also be challenging.
The left-most digit(s) of a reference number identifies the figure in which the reference number first appears, and same reference numbers indicate similar or identical items.
Sound is one of the most important senses people use in daily life, along with sight, touch, smell, and so forth. We can hear sound from different directions including sound emanating from behind and/or above us, and can often discern direction and distance to sound sources, as well as relative speed or velocity between us and those sound sources (from change in volume or intensity, change in frequency or tone such as Doppler shift, and so forth). As consumer electronics (hardware and software) become increasingly sophisticated, there is increasing demand for a natural sound experience from digital media sources of all types, including real-time electronic communications such as telephone and teleconference calls, movies, games, music, augmented reality scenarios and so forth. In this context, emitting “natural” sound from electronic and electromechanical devices includes recreating sound to provide the listener with an immersive experience, that accurately, authentically or convincingly simulates a particular acoustic environment and/or event for the listener. This can be done, for example, with the use of specialized recording methods or digital signal processing that capture or encode three-dimensional audio cues and acoustic characteristics that provide the listener with spatial information such as direction and/or location of sound sources relative to the listener, including information about an environment surrounding the sound sources and the listener (reflective, absorbent, enclosed, and so forth). One challenge in providing this kind of aural experience is that playback devices such as headphones are used, and a combined transfer function of the headphones and the listener's ear structure is different than a combined transfer function of open air and the listener's ear structure, between a sound source and the listener's inner ear.
The listening experience can be thought of as having at least three major components—a source, a transmission medium, and a listener. In a natural system the sound source can be, for example, a loudspeaker at a concert, a helicopter, a thunderstorm, a person playing a piano or a guitar, a person speaking, a rifle, a tree in the wind, and so forth. The transmission medium can for example be an open-air natural environment, a room or cave with a sound source in it, a tunnel, a forest, a mountain valley with rock faces nearby (that reflect echos, for example), and so forth. Aspects of the listener can affect the listening experience—sound can for example encounter the person (clothing, hair, face, and so forth), and may be channeled in different ways by the listener's ear structure (outer ear, inner ear, and so forth) between the listener's eardrum and the transmission medium. Bone conduction, or transmission of sound through parts of the listener's body other than the ear to the eardrum, can influence the listener's natural listening experience. Principles of diffraction, refraction, interference, reflection, and so forth can influence sound traveling between the sound source and the listener's eardrum(s), for example depending on what the transmission medium or environment is composed of, and how different elements in it are arranged. Aspects of the listener can be considered either part of the transmission medium (e.g., clothing, body structure including pinnae or outer ears, etc.) or can be considered part of the listener, but in principle are part of an overall transfer function or effect between the source and the ultimate receiver, whether the ultimate receiver is defined as the listener's brain, cochlea, eardrum, inner ear, or outer ear, or entire person.
Where sound is reproduced for a listener via headphones, the resulting system is basically an electronic signal provided to the headphones, which then generates sound in the ear piece(s) or ear cup(s) and projects it toward the listener's ear(s). The drivers in the headphones will have specific (and likely imperfect, or an imperfect compromise of) performance characteristics, and by their very proximity and creation of a closed environment around the ear, ear pieces or ear cups of the headphones also modify and/or abrogate functions of the listener's ear structure, for example the pinna. Accordingly, generating and transmitting sound from small, enclosed spaces such as within ear cups of headphones fitted over a listener's ears and against the listener's head, that provides the listener with an acoustic experience intended to replicate sound generated in an open air environment with significant directionality (e.g., sensation of a helicopter orbiting around the listener) can be challenging.
Several factors create specific challenges for creating a natural sound experience using headphones. First, in a natural sound experience there are often both directional sound sources, and more diffuse sound elements in the sound source environment. In a case where recordings are processed for playback over loudspeakers, if those recordings are then played back over headphones the listener's audio experience is unnatural, largely on account of lost crosstalk and issues relating to localization. Lost crosstalk refers to absence of sound that reaches the listener by different paths, for example directly from the source, plus indirectly as from echoes, indirectly via conduction of a portion of the sound through bone to the listener's inner ear rather than via the listener's outer ear, sound that reaches one of the listener's ears earlier (or later) than it reaches the listener's other ear, and so forth. Second, since the headphones are on the listener's head and effectively have a small chamber created between the listener's head and the ear cups of the headphones, the open air transfer function and the transfer function of the listener's ear are altered or absent. Accordingly, the headphones need further equalization to at least partially compensate. This equalization can be very difficult. One reason that equalization is difficult is because the listener's outer ear helps the listener discern directionality, and the headphone's local sound source in the ear cup omits or distorts directional information and can also lead to coloration inaccuracies—when the listener's head moves, the headphones move with it and thus movement of the listener's head won't provide directional information (unlike the listener's aural experience in a natural system or natural sound experience). Yet another reason that equalization can be difficult is that not only the listener's outer ear, but also other parts of the listener's body can influence sound waves before they reach the listener's inner ear—for example sound traveling along the listener's clothing, face, via bone-conduction through the listener's jaw and skull, and so forth.
Another challenge with headphones is that reproducing higher frequencies of sound in a headset with sufficient power and balance can be difficult. For example, many headphones have trouble providing linear frequency response, typically above about 8 KHz. This in turn increases a difficulty of providing a realistic, three-dimensional aural experience to the listener, because it is the higher frequencies, for example 6 kHz and above, that provide directional information to the listener.
Example embodiments variously described herein address and resolve or mitigate many of these challenges, and include a physical or solid state transfer function that receives a signal, for example an equivalent of an open air signal, and changes the signal to compensate for a listener's ear function that is omitted or altered by an environment that the headset and the listener's ear structure together create.
In accordance with various embodiments described herein, an acoustic transformer can be in the form of a plate, disc, or other generally fixed element that is provided within a headphone ear cup, between a speaker or driver in the ear cup and a listener's ear when the listener is wearing the headphone. The acoustic transformer effectively acts as a physical transfer function that moderates or corrects negative effects of the headset on a normal transfer function of the listener's outer ear, in other words a transfer function that exists between a natural free-air sound source and the listener's inner ear. The acoustic transformer includes strategically located apertures or acoustic windows (for example, areas with low acoustic impedance) that direct higher frequencies toward the listener's ear canal, and direct lower frequencies toward the back of the listener's ear when the acoustic transformer is oriented with respect to the listener's ear. The acoustic transformer effectively also changes path lengths that sound from the driver would otherwise travel to meet the listener's ear, which also can enhance the listener's listening experience. The pinna of the human ear is asymmetrical, for example along both vertical and horizontal axes. One effect of this is that sounds coming from different directions to a listener's ear are captured differently, including having different path lengths along the pinna to the inner ear, and this can provide directional information regarding the sound source to the listener's brain. An example aspect of this is shown generally in
As shown in
As noted earlier, headphones provide sound to the listener's ear differently than a free-air source does, at least in part because of the near proximity of the headphone acoustic driver to the listener's ear and the enclosed space formed by the headphone cup around the listener's ear. Accordingly, the listener's listening experience with headphones can be very different from a listening experience that a free-air sound source would provide. Embodiments of the acoustic transformer described herein can provide a corrective audio transfer or transformation function between a headphone and a listener's ear that overcomes many of the acoustic changes and distortions that headphones introduce, to mimic a free-air listening experience for the listener and improve the quality of the listener's experience.
In addition, proximity as well as orientation of the acoustic transformer to an outer surface of the driver's acoustic drive surface (also referred to as a driving surface of the driver), for example a speaker cone or diaphragm, can be adjusted or selected to effectively increase power or intensity of the higher frequency sound generated by the driver, thus improving linearity of the driver's response in higher frequencies that provide both a balanced and pleasing aural experience for the listener as well as a realistic three-dimensional (x, y, z) aural experience, for example a realistic perception that a sound source is moving relative to the listener, such as a helicopter flying past or circling overhead. Generally, the impact is realized across the entire audio spectrum, for example within a natural human hearing range. The natural human hearing range can be considered to range from 20 Hz to 20 kHz, although individuals may have hearing ranges that extend beyond one or both of these upper and lower limits. In addition, in some circumstances it can be advantageous to extend capabilities of example embodiments beyond the 20 Hz lower limit and/or the 20 kHz upper limit, for example to fractional or integer multiples of 20 kHz as an upper limit of generated sound, due to harmonics and other phenomena that can affect sound experienced by the listener within the listener's hearing range. When measured, the improvement or audio effect enhancement can be broad, and can for example be noted from 1 kHz (or lower) to at least 12 kHz. This type of experience can be especially valued by video gamers who rely on aural as well as visual information to perform effectively, and by listeners seeking an immersive virtual experience that includes audio or audiovisual stimuli, for example for improved situational awareness and so forth. Accordingly, a proximity or distance between the acoustic transformer and the outer surface of the driver's acoustic cone or drive surface/driving surface can be selected to be narrow enough or close enough to enhance power of frequencies between about 4 kHz and 16 kHz, or between about 8 kHz and 14 kHz, or to have effect within narrower ranges or to extend above or below these ranges. Generally, the acoustic transformer can be applied to improve headphone performance within audible ranges and optionally above audible ranges, for example 1 kHz and up to 16 kHz, up to 20 kHz, or for example to 30 kHz or 40 kHz or higher. The distance between the acoustic transformer and the driver's drive surface when the driver is at rest or quiescent, can be selected based on a maximum deflection of the driver's acoustic drive surface from a resting or quiescent position, plus a clearance distance that is a distance between the drive surface and the acoustic transformer when the drive surface is at the maximum deflection towards the acoustic transformer. This clearance distance can be termed a dynamic clearance distance. For example, if a maximum deflection of the drive surface toward the acoustic transformer is 0.6 millimeters and a desired dynamic clearance distance is 1 millimeter, then the distance between the acoustic transformer and the driver's acoustic drive surface (e.g., a drive cone) at rest or in a quiescent state would be 1.6 millimeters, and in operation the drive surface would come no nearer than 1 millimeter to the acoustic transformer. The distance between the acoustic transformer and the driver's acoustic drive surface (e.g., a driving surface of a drive cone) at rest or in a quiescent state, can be termed a quiescent clearance distance. The maximum deflection of the drive surface or driving surface can be an absolute physical maximum that the driver can achieve but not exceed, or can be a maximum deflection distance that will occur within a given operating envelope, for example where an input signal range or input signal amplitude provided to the acoustic driver is bounded or is specified to be within particular bounds. In example embodiments the desired or specified clearance distance can be as small as 0.5 millimeters, as large as 1 centimeter, or any enumerated value between 0.5 millimeters and 10 millimeters. Example clearance distance ranges can be, for example, 0.5-1.5 millimeters, 1.0-2.0 millimeters, 1.0-3.0 millimeters, or any subset between 0.5 millimeters and 10 millimeters.
In some embodiments, apertures in the acoustic transformer can be located based on observed or determined performance anomalies of the driver, to damp or attenuate erroneous sound that can result from design or construction flaws or accepted variations in engineering tolerances. Such flaws or variations can include, for example, a driver's drive cone that is placed slightly off-center from the driver's drive coil; asymmetric mass distribution across the drive cone, resulting perhaps from excess adhesive on one side of the cone, variations in drive cone material thicknesses or densities, oil-canning of a dust cap over a center of the voice coil or drive coil, and so forth. These kinds of variations can produce local resonances or distortions, which can be masked or attenuated by strategically locating apertures in, and solid surfaces of, the acoustic transformer relative to these anomalous areas of the drive cone.
As proximity or distance becomes closer between a driving surface of the drive cone and a solid surface, lower frequency sound from the drive cone is damped and higher frequency sound is channeled or enhanced in magnitude, and motion of the driving surface is restricted or damped. For example, at locations of the driver's driving surface where low frequency sound is greater than desired, the acoustic transformer can be arranged to have a closer proximity to damp lower frequency sound and movement of the driving surface that generates the lower frequency sound. Areas of the driver's driving surface that produce more high frequency sound than is desired can have a corresponding opposite surface of the acoustic transformer arranged at a further proximity so as not to channel or enhance this higher frequency sound, or even an aperture to let the sound (and higher frequency sound channeled from elsewhere on the driver's driving surface) through toward the listener's ear. Areas of the driver's driving surface that produce less high frequency sound energy than is desired can have a corresponding opposite surface (rather than an aperture) of the acoustic transformer that is closer so as to enhance this higher frequency sound. An area of the driver's driving surface that produces a generally desirable level of high frequency sound energy can have an apertures in the acoustic transformer that is located opposite to let that sound energy through the aperture toward the listener's ear, or can have a surface of the acoustic transformer that is neither so close as to accentuate, nor so distant as to attenuate, but instead channels, the high frequency sound energy laterally or diagonally to an aperture in the acoustic transformer that is not opposite, but is instead further away from, the originating area of the drive or driving surface that produces the generally desirable level of high frequency sound energy. The aperture can have angled walls and/or extending features to help collect and/or transmit such channeled sound energy. Channeled sound energy that travels from the driver's driving surface along a surface of the acoustic transformer to one or more apertures or aperture areas in the acoustic transformer can not only be provided to locations of the listener's ear via the apertures, but the additional path length provided by this travelling (as opposed to a direct path from the acoustic driver to the listener's ear if the acoustic transformer were not present) can also provide an improvement or increased sense of realism to the listener's aural experience with the headphones, for example via phase differences resulting from the increased path length(s).
As shown in the second view 1504 of
It will be recognized that how the listener chooses to wear headphones equipped with acoustic transformers can affect how the transformers align with the listener's ears. Generally the acoustic transformers can be oriented within headphone ear cups so that when the headphones are worn in accordance with their intended design purpose, for example with a headband extending between the headphone ear cups over the top of the listener's head, the acoustic transformers are generally aligned with a vertical axis of the listener's head or are generally aligned with the listener's ear centerline (or both). For example, in some embodiments the acoustic transformers can be aligned with the headband of the headphones, with the set of smaller apertures toward the front of the headband and the larger aperture toward the rear of the headband. In some embodiments that feature headphones equipped with acoustic transformers such as those variously described herein, the acoustic transformers are mounted in such a way that the listener can rotate or re-orient them within the headphone ear cups, and/or can rotate or re-orient the ear cups with respect to a headband or other support structure of the headphones, so that the acoustic transformers are advantageously aligned with the listener's ears when the listener is wearing the headphones in a particular or preferred position or fashion. Thus in some embodiments the listener can customize orientation of the acoustic transformer to match his or her preference.
Example embodiments of acoustic transformers described herein, for example including those shown in
In other example embodiments, one or more of the apertures or aperture locations can be substituted with areas that have some physical barrier, such as a lesser thickness of material of the acoustic transformer or a different material or a membrane such as Mylar™, that is flexible and/or has other properties that provide a different acoustic impedance than surrounding portions of the acoustic transformer. Such locations can effectively act as acoustic apertures to pass more sound energy than other portions of the acoustic transformer. In addition, the materials and thicknesses at those acoustic apertures can be tuned to pass certain sound frequencies or frequency bands or ranges, and/or to enhance or reduce desired path delays. Exemplary materials can include, for example, cloth, cotton, plastic, metal, wood, or any other substance in any appropriate configuration (layered, felted, forming a matrix, forming one or more membranes, and so forth).
An example embodiment is shown in
As shown in
It will be understood that aperture features of example acoustic transformers can exhibit a variety of features, including not limited to thickened portions of acoustic transformer material, extensions, apertures that are variously angled and/or have differing contours and surface area as they extend from one side of an acoustic transformer to another, ribbed or flanged supports or splines, chamfered or otherwise contoured edges, regular edge variations such as indentations or recesses with different geometric shapes or contours, as well as irregular edge variations, and so forth. Raised areas or extensions fully or partly surrounding an aperture can have cylindrical, conical, trapezoidal or other shapes, with different flaring or radii. In addition, as earlier discussed, example acoustic transformers can have surfaces contoured to provide differing distances between surface locations of the acoustic transformer and the driver's drive surface to tailor frequency response or enhancement as well as compensate for driver performance anomalies.
Distances between the acoustic transformer sections and the respective drivers shown in
As demonstrated by acoustic transformers shown in
In some acoustic transformer embodiments, all of the smaller apertures in an acoustic transformer have the same shape, and/or have a same area. In other embodiments, at least some of the smaller apertures have both different area and different shape from each other. In some embodiments, an area of each of one or more of the smaller apertures can be within a range (inclusive) of 5% to 10% of the area of a largest aperture or aperture area of the acoustic transformer, or can be within a range (inclusive) of 10% to 15% of the area of the largest aperture or aperture area, or can be within a range (inclusive) of 15% to 20% of the area of the largest aperture or aperture area, or can be within a range (inclusive) of 20% to 25% of the area of the largest aperture or aperture area, or can be within a range (inclusive) of 25% to 30% of the area of the largest aperture or aperture area of the acoustic transformer. Thus, for example, an acoustic transformer could have four smaller apertures each with an area that is 25% of an area of the largest aperture; or one with an area of 10% of the area of the largest aperture or aperture area, the second and third with an area of 20%, and the fourth with an area of 30%; or the first with an area of 5%, and the second, third and fourth each with areas of 10%; or all four each with an area of 30%; or a first with 7%, a second with 13%, and the third and fourth with 17%; and so forth.
In addition, where indentations and/or extensions are provided along part or all of an edge of a larger aperture formed or within an acoustic transformer, the indentations or recesses and extensions can be provided with different shapes—regular polygonal shapes such as squares, or triangles/sawteeth, or semicircular “teeth” with flat segments between them, thus forming a regular texture, and the ratios of protrusion to recess of the indentations and/or extensions or textured contours can vary (even, greater length of recess, or greater length of protrusion). Additionally or alternatively, irregular or randomized edge textures can also be provided, for example a sandpaper-type texture, and can be three-dimensional (having texture along a long axis or direction of the acoustic transformer as well as along a thickness or depth of the acoustic transformer).
In particular,
Alternatively in an example embodiment, instead of providing an acoustic transformer with apertures 2018 and 2008 and also the aperture cover 2102, the aperture cover 2102 can be omitted and the acoustic transformer can instead be provided with the central aperture 2012 and an aperture corresponding to the aperture 2108 (instead of the apertures 2018, 2008). In this embodiment there would be a left ear version and a right ear version of the acoustic transformer, with placement of the large aperture 2004, and the smaller apertures 2006, 2010, 2014, 2016 swapped about an axis formed by the aperture 2012 and the aperture corresponding to the aperture 2108 so that the large aperture 2004 in each headphone ear cup will be located opposite a rear portion of the listener's pinna when the headphones are arranged on the listener's head. In this embodiment the central aperture 2012 and the aperture corresponding to the aperture 2108 can also be angled, consistent with angles of the apertures 2108, 2106 as shown for example in
Angled apertures such as the apertures 2106, 2108 shown in
Different drivers can come in different sizes and configurations, and acoustic transformers can be provided to match them according to principles and illustrations described herein. Example acoustic transformers can be larger than, smaller than, or coextensive with, drive surfaces of the drivers. For example, different embodiments acoustic transformers can extend beyond or stay within outer circumferences of the driver surfaces, and can be configured to match acoustic characteristics and anomalies of particular drivers, or models of drivers, or types of drivers. For example, in a situation where an active drive surface of a driver exceeds dimensions of a listener's ear in one or more dimensions or directions, in accordance with example embodiments an acoustic transformer can be sized to match dimensions of the active drive surface, with apertures or aperture regions strategically aligned with the listener's ear, for example as earlier described. Alternatively, an acoustic transformer can be sized to primarily interact with portions of the active drive surface that are directly opposite the listener's ear. Optionally, elements of the acoustic transformer that extend beyond boundaries of a listener's ear can be blocked or damped by adjacent or corresponding elements of an acoustic transformer, for example by absence of apertures or aperture regions, and optionally with sound-absorbing or deflecting material provided at those adjacent or corresponding elements of the acoustic transformer. In addition, drivers can have a total perimeter, or a perimeter of an active or sound-generating surface as presented toward a listener's ear or in an intended direction of sound propagation, that is round. Alternatively, one or both of these perimeters can have different polygonal or rounded shapes such as hexagonal, polygonal, round, elliptical, oval, egg-shaped, polygon with some straight edges and some curved edges, or any other appropriate shape, and acoustic transformers as described herein in can also be shaped to match or be compatible with one or both of the total perimeter or the active surface perimeter of the driver.
Those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that acoustic transformers as described herein can be made of different materials and/or composites of materials, including but limited to plastics, metals, glass, ceramic, wood, or other material or composite of suitable materials having appropriate characteristics, for example rigidity, consistency and/or acoustic opaqueness.
Dynamic cone or coil drivers have been described and shown herein with respect to example embodiments. Example embodiments of an acoustic transformer consistent with those described and shown herein can also be implemented in conjunction with different kinds or types of sound generators or transductors with same or similar beneficial effects in headphone performance, and that can have different shapes. For example, planar magnetic drivers, electrostatic speakers, drivers or speakers with piezoelectric elements, and ribbon speakers or drivers. Sound generators or transductors can have drive surfaces that have circular, rectangular, or other-shaped boundaries, and in example embodiments, acoustic transformers can have corresponding shapes or boundaries or effective surfaces that match or correspond to those of the sound generators or transductors to which they are paired.
Although the subject matter has been described in language specific to structural features and/or method or process acts, it is to be understood that the subject matter defined in the claims is not limited to the specific features or acts described above. Embodiments, methods and features described herein are disclosed as examples that can variously implement the claims.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4211898 | Atoji | Jul 1980 | A |
4718517 | Carlson | Jan 1988 | A |
4922542 | Sapiejewski | May 1990 | A |
4924502 | Allen | May 1990 | A |
5033086 | Fidi | Jul 1991 | A |
5729605 | Babisuthi et al. | Mar 1998 | A |
5844998 | Nageno | Dec 1998 | A |
RE37398 | Nageno | Oct 2001 | E |
6320970 | Czerwinski | Nov 2001 | B1 |
6438227 | Kretsch | Aug 2002 | B1 |
6611603 | Norris et al. | Aug 2003 | B1 |
6817440 | Kim | Nov 2004 | B1 |
6934401 | Grell et al. | Aug 2005 | B2 |
7162051 | Grell et al. | Jan 2007 | B2 |
7165647 | Lee | Jan 2007 | B2 |
7167567 | Sibbald et al. | Jan 2007 | B1 |
7316290 | Hutt et al. | Jan 2008 | B2 |
7340071 | Huang | Mar 2008 | B2 |
7510049 | Kling | Mar 2009 | B2 |
8000486 | Hildebrandt | Aug 2011 | B2 |
8045718 | Faure et al. | Oct 2011 | B2 |
8447058 | Sung et al. | May 2013 | B1 |
8718312 | Lin | May 2014 | B2 |
8989419 | Graber et al. | Mar 2015 | B2 |
9258664 | Kraemer | Feb 2016 | B2 |
9426555 | Yamamoto | Aug 2016 | B2 |
9591406 | Huang | Mar 2017 | B1 |
9743174 | Oclee-Brown et al. | Aug 2017 | B2 |
9794682 | Honda et al. | Oct 2017 | B2 |
9848271 | Lyren et al. | Dec 2017 | B2 |
9854352 | Huang | Dec 2017 | B2 |
9866963 | Kraemer | Jan 2018 | B2 |
9918177 | Horbach | Mar 2018 | B2 |
9918178 | Norris et al. | Mar 2018 | B2 |
9936281 | Tamura et al. | Apr 2018 | B2 |
20050238189 | Tsai | Oct 2005 | A1 |
20120033842 | Donarski | Feb 2012 | A1 |
20130142376 | Lin | Jun 2013 | A1 |
20130188801 | Ambrose | Jul 2013 | A1 |
20150172805 | Oishi et al. | Jun 2015 | A1 |
20150208160 | Chu | Jul 2015 | A1 |
20150249878 | Wen | Sep 2015 | A1 |
20180310090 | Wen et al. | Oct 2018 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2004091252 | Oct 2004 | WO |
Entry |
---|
“Head-Related Transfer Function”, Wikipedia, Nov. 17, 2017, https://web.archive.org/web/20171216035821/https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head-related_transfer_function. |
“Natural Sound Rendering for Headphones: Integration of Signal Processing Techniques”, Sunder et al., IEEE Signal Processing Magazine Special Issue on Sound Processing Techniques for Assisted Listening, vol. 32, No. 2, pp. 100-113, Mar. 2015. |
Sean Olive et al., “Perception & Measurement of Headphone Sound Quality: Is There a Preferred Target Response?”, Harman International Industries Incorporated, Oct. 16, 2017, pp. 1-65. |
George L. Augspurger, “The Acoustical Lens”, Electronics World, Dec. 1962. |
Sean Olive et al., “Perception & Measurement of Headphone Sound Quality: Is There a Preferred Target Response?”, Harman International Industries Incorporated, Oct. 16, 2017, pp. 66-132. |
International Application No. PCT/US2019/060138, International Search Report and Written Opinion dated Jan. 22, 2020, 15 pages. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20200154189 A1 | May 2020 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62758448 | Nov 2018 | US |