The subject disclosure claims priority from GB Application No.: GB 2314042.9, filed on Sep. 14, 2023, herein incorporated by reference in its entirety.
This disclosure is concerned with heat exchange and with working fluids for apparatus used in management of heat energy by storing heat, absorbing heat or transferring heat energy from one location to another.
Various forms of apparatus use a working fluid to absorb heat and transfer the heat to another location. An example is a heat exchange circuit. Another example is a solar water heating system in which solar energy heats a working fluid which in turn heats domestic hot water. A working fluid may also be used to receive and store heat energy when that energy is available and give up the heat at a later time. There are also systems where heat is taken from a working fluid and the cooled fluid is used to absorb heat at a later time. Such working fluids are often water or an aqueous solution or may be some other single-phase liquid.
This summary is provided to introduce concepts that will be further elaborated and described below in the detailed description. This summary is not intended to identify key or essential features of the claimed subject matter, nor is it intended to be used as an aid in limiting the scope of the claimed subject matter.
One aspect of the present disclosure is a method of moving heat into or out of a flowing fluid, comprising pumping the fluid through a heat transfer device which comprises a chamber for through flow of fluid and wherein a chamber wall in contact with the flowing fluid is an interface through which heat energy is transferred to or from the flowing fluid, wherein the chamber contains an array of spaced obstructions compelling the streamlines of the flowing fluid to repeatedly change direction in order to flow through gaps between the obstructions; the viscosity of the fluid, the flow rate of the fluid within the chamber and the width of the gaps between obstructions gives a Reynolds number (Re) for the flow which is in a range from 1 to 1000, possibly 1 to 100, 1 to 250 or 1 to 500; the fluid contains a solute which enables the fluid to display elastic turbulence; and the flow rate of the fluid through the chamber is such that the flowing fluid is in a state of elastic turbulence.
A system for moving heat energy may comprise a heat transfer device including a chamber for through flow of fluid wherein a chamber wall is an interface through which heat energy is transferred to or from the flowing fluid, a fluid and a pump for pumping the fluid through the chamber, wherein the chamber contains an array of spaced obstructions compelling the streamlines of flowing fluid to repeatedly change direction in order to flow through gaps between the obstructions; the fluid contains a solute which enables the fluid to display elastic turbulence; and the system is configured so that the viscosity of the fluid, the flow rate of the fluid within the chamber and the width of the gaps between obstructions gives a Reynolds number (Re) for the flow which is in a range from 1 to 1000, possibly 1 to 500, 1 to 250 or 1 to 100.
In some embodiments, the heat transfer device is part of a heat exchange system comprising a second heat transfer device at a different location, a pump and pipework connecting the pump and the heat exchange devices as a closed circuit containing the said fluid.
The obstructions may be a plurality of pillars extending across the chamber from the interface to another wall of the chamber. The pillars may be arranged so that flow through gaps between pillars in a row is compelled to change direction by pillars in an adjacent row.
In another aspect, this disclosure provides a working fluid for a heat exchange system wherein the working fluid is a multi-phase system with a continuous phase and at least one suspended disperse phase which changes between solid and liquid at temperatures where the continuous phase is liquid and wherein the continuous phase is a solution containing a solute which enables the continuous phase, and thereby the overall working fluid composition, to display elastic turbulence.
The subject disclosure is further described in the detailed description which follows, in reference to the noted plurality of drawings by way of non-limiting examples of the subject disclosure, in which like reference numerals represent similar parts throughout the several views of the drawings, and wherein:
The particulars shown herein are by way of example and for purposes of illustrative discussion of the embodiments of the subject disclosure only and are presented in the cause of providing what is believed to be the most useful and readily understood description of the principles and conceptual aspects of the subject disclosure. In this regard, no attempt is made to show structural details in more detail than is necessary for the fundamental understanding of the subject disclosure, the description taken with the drawings making apparent to those skilled in the art how the several forms of the subject disclosure may be embodied in practice. Furthermore, like reference numbers and designations in the various drawings indicate like elements.
This detailed description refers to embodiments of the present disclosure and possibilities which may be used. It should be appreciated that features or possibilities described in combination may, where it is practical to do so, be used individually. Also, features or possibilities described in any embodiment may be used in any other embodiment, in so far as it is possible to do so.
The present disclosure uses the phenomenon of elastic turbulence. It is of course well known that Newtonian fluids such as water can undergo either laminar flow or turbulent flow. Such turbulent flow may be referred to as inertial turbulence. Conditions for laminar and turbulent flow are often expressed by Reynolds number which is a ratio of inertial to viscous forces within a fluid. Reynolds number has no dimensions because it is a ratio. At Reynolds number above about 2000 there is inertial turbulent flow. At Reynolds number below about 1500 a Newtonian fluid is in a state of laminar flow.
Elastic turbulence is a different physical phenomenon discovered at the end of the twentieth century. It has been observed at low flow speeds where Reynolds number is low and a Newtonian fluid would be in a state of laminar flow. Elastic turbulence has sometimes been referred to using the older and more general term “elastic instability”.
A number of documents have mentioned possible use of elastic turbulence in microfluidics, where dimensions of flow paths and rates of flow are so small that apparatus has a volume below 10 ml and Reynolds number is vanishingly small, far below one. In contrast with that, the present disclosure uses elastic turbulence in equipment where dimensions of the apparatus and rates of flow are large enough that Reynolds number is one or more but less than one thousand. When Reynolds number is in this range, the flow of a Newtonian fluid such as pure water is laminar. As already mentioned, a heat exchange device in accordance with this disclosure has a chamber for the through flow of a fluid which displays elastic turbulence as it flows through the chamber. The fluid volume within this chamber may be at least 50 ml (possibly in experimental apparatus) and may be more, such as at least one liter or at least fifty liters in larger scale equipment.
The formula which may be used to determine Reynolds number for flow through a chamber containing obstructions so as to compel the flow stream lines to bend is:
If the flow rate is measured as volume in unit time, the formula above becomes
Elastic turbulence occurs in solutions containing a solute which has a flexible structure. One category of material able to undergo elastic deformation and enable a solution to display elastic turbulence is a polymer containing long flexible linear chains. The number of monomer units in the polymer may be at least 5000 and may be considerably more such as at least 25,000. The monomer units may be present in linear chains of at least 1000 monomer units which may each be connected one to the next by a single covalent bond, so that one monomer unit can rotate relative to adjoining monomer units. Individual linear chains may be longer and a polymer may contain a linear chain of at least 5000 or even at least 10,000 monomer units. The mean molecular weight of the polymer may be 10° Daltons or more. The concentration of such long chain/high molecular weight polymer included in a solution for enabling elastic turbulence to occur may be under 5% by weight, for instance in a range from 0.05% or 0.1% up to 1% or 2% by weight.
A long chain polymer which enables elastic turbulence to occur may be a polymer of a single monomer or may be a copolymer of more than one monomer, for instance a block
S copolymer which is linear. A polymer may include side chains attached to a long chain of monomer units which are connected together by single covalent bonds. A polymer may include some chain branching, for instance at branch points where three or more chains, each of at least 1000 monomer units and possibly at least 2000 or 5000 monomer units, are connected together.
The flexibility of the polymer chains enables the polymer molecules to become entangled. The flexibility of polymer chains can be described by means of a mathematical model. The freely jointed chain model is commonly used and the flexibility of a particular polymer can be indicated by parameters of an equivalent freely jointed chain (itself a mathematical model). A description of this approach is provided by Chapter 2 of “Polymer Physics” by Rubinstein and Colby, 2003, Oxford University Press. An equivalent freely jointed chain has the same mean-square end-to-end distance and the same maximum end-to-end distance as the actual polymer but is considered to consist of so-called Kuhn monomers which are freely rotatable relative to each other. These model monomers have a length, termed the Kuhn length, and a molar mass.
Polymers which enable elastic turbulence to occur may contain at least one flexible polymer chain with length and composition represented by at least 1000 Kuhn monomers having a Kuhn length not more than 100 Angstroms (10 nm) and possibly not more than 50 Angstroms, If a polymer is a single, unbranched chain, its length and composition may be represented by at least 5,000 Kuhn monomers having a Kuhn length not more than 100 Angstroms and possibly considerably more, such as at least 20,000 Kuhn monomers of such Kuhn length.
Elastic turbulence has been observed with several different long chain polymers in solution. One such polymer is polyacrylamide, which may be hydrolyzed or partially hydrolyzed. Experimental evidence for elastic turbulence in a solution of high molecular weight polyacrylamide was given by Groisman and Steinberg in “Elastic Turbulence in a polymer solution flow” Nature, Vol 45 p53 (2000). Other instances of long chain polymers reported to give rise to elastic turbulence include polyisobutylene of molecular weight 4 to 6 Megadaltons dissolved in an organic solvent (Dris and Shaqfeh, J. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech. Vol 80 pages 1 to 58 (1998)), polystyrene of molecular weight 18 Megadaltons in an organic solvent (Magda and Larson, J. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech. Vol 30 pages 1-19 (1988)) and polyethylene oxide of molecular weight 4 MegaDaltons in an aqueous solution (Davoodi et al, J. Fluid Mech, Vol 857, pages 823-850 (2018)). Kuhn lengths for polystyrene and polyethylene oxide given by Rubinstein and Colby, as 15 to 25 Angstroms (Fetters, Lohse and Colby, Chain Dimensions and Entanglement Spacings. In Physical Properties of Polymers Handbook; Mark, J. E., Ed.; Springer: New York, 2007; pages 447-454).
When using a long chain linear polymer to enable elastic turbulence to occur, it is desirable to include a biocide to protect the polymer from biodegradation.
Long chain partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide linear polymers with a molecular weight of more than 1 MegaDalton are available from SNF Floerger, whose headquarters are in Andrézieux, France.
Elastic turbulence has also been observed with solutions containing a surfactant which forms worm-like micelles in solution. There is extensive scientific literature concerning surfactants which form worm-like micelles, their properties and applications. One review is Yang “Viscoelastic wormlike micelles and their applications” Current Opinion in Colloid & Interface Science vol 7 pages 276-281 (2002). Discussions of properties include Raghavan and Kaler “Highly Viscoelastic Wormlike Micellar Solutions Formed by Cationic Surfactants with Long Unsaturated Tails” Langmuir vol 17, pages 300-306 (2001) and Beaumont et al “Turbulent flows in highly elastic wormlike micelles” Soft Matter vol 9 page 735 (2013). An example, using cetyl trimethyl bromide as the surfactant, is mentioned by Favolin et al in Physical Review Letters Vol 104 178303 (2010).
When a solution contains a substance able to cause elastic turbulence, the phenomenon of elastic turbulence occurs if the solution is flowing at a sufficient flow velocity (which may be a low velocity) and the path of flow causes the streamlines of the flow to curve. Consequently, one known possibility for a flow path which induces elastic turbulence is a serpentine channel. Another possibility is described below with reference to the drawings. A detailed discussion of elastic turbulence is provided by Steinberg in Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, vol 53, pages 27-58 (2021).
The ability of a fluid composition to display elastic turbulence can be demonstrated with laboratory apparatus, as mentioned below. A flow rate through a heat exchange device which is sufficient for a selected fluid composition to display elastic turbulence can be found by experiment, as is also shown below.
In the present disclosure, the elastic turbulence mixes the working fluid as it flows over a solid interface through which heat is transferred into or out of the working fluid. As a consequence of the elastic turbulence, the rate of heat transfer is increased because the heat transfer to or from the interface is not restricted to the conduction of heat through the working fluid.
As an example embodiment of this disclosure, the drawings show a heat transfer system for transferring heat energy from a heat source to a volume of water. The device 10 at the left of
The device 10 has a cuboidal casing defining a chamber through which the working fluid is pumped. The casing face 20 which is exposed to the heat of the sun is the interface between the working fluid inside the casing and the source of heat. This is made of a thermally conductive material, such as copper or aluminum. The opposite surface 22 has heat insulation 24 against it to reduce heat loss.
Inside the casing of the device 10 is an array of pillars 30 formed by bars which extend from the casing face 20 across the internal chamber to the opposite face 24.
The heat exchange device 12, which is immersed in water to be heated, has a cuboidal casing 40 which is the interface through which heat energy leaves the working fluid. Fins 42 projecting from the casing 40 assist the conduction of heat from the casing 40 to the surrounding water.
The interior of the device 12 is similar to the interior of the device 10. The casing 40 defines a chamber for the through flow of working fluid. Bars which extend across the interior chamber from one side face to the other provide an array of pillars 30 obstructing flow just as described for the device 10.
The working fluid circulated through the heat exchange devices 10 and 12 may be an aqueous solution of a long chain partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide linear polymer with a molecular weight of more than 1 MegaDalton and possibly more than 3, or 5 or 10 MegaDaltons, Its concentration may be no more than 5% by weight and may possibly be no more than 1% by weight. Such polymers are available from SNF Floerger, whose headquarters are in Andrézieux, France. The working fluid also contains a small concentration of a biocide to prevent biological degradation of this polymer.
The circulating pump 16 propels the working fluid at a flow rate such that flow entering at the device 10 at its inlet 26 is laminar and flow entering the device 12 is also laminar. This flow rate is such that as the working fluid flows through the arrays of pillars within the devices 10 and 12 it is in a state of elastic turbulence. In the device 10 this has the effect of transferring heat energy from the casing surface 20 to the working fluid more rapidly than would be transmitted by conduction under conditions of laminar flow without elastic turbulence. Similarly, in the device 12, elastic turbulence increases the rate of transfer of heat from the working fluid to the casing 40 of the device 12, from which the heat energy passes on to the water surrounding the device 12.
The ability of a solution to display elastic turbulence can be shown experimentally. In a cone and plate rheometer cell, the onset of elastic instability with application of increasing shear is observed as an apparent increase in viscosity at a particular shear rate associated with an abrupt increase in the noise in the measured torque signal. This has been described by D. O. Olagunju, “Instabilities and bifurcations of von Karman similarity solutions in swirling viscoelastic flow”, Z angew Math Phys, 46 (1995) 224-238 and also by E. Tran, A. Clarke, “The relaxation time of entangled HPAM solutions in flow”, Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics, 311 (2023) 104954.).
A minimum flow rate required to cause elastic turbulence in a heat exchange device and the rate of heat transfer to or from the circulating working fluid can both be determined experimentally. Apparatus for this is shown in
When liquid from the tank 62 is pumped through the device 10 there will be a pressure drop between the inlet pressure sensor 64 and the outlet pressure sensor 65. When the flow rate through the device 10 is very low, the flow will be laminar, without any elastic turbulence. The minimum flow rate to cause elastic turbulence in the device 10 can be found by progressively increasing the pump speed to increase the flow rate and plotting the pressure drop against flow rate or plotting the pump speed, which is indicative of pressure drop, against flow rate. This plot will show a change in slope on reaching the flow rate at which elastic turbulence begins.
This is illustrated by the following description of experimental work with apparatus as shown in
A calculation of Reynolds number, at a flow rate giving elastic turbulence was as follows:
The flat faces 32 of the pillars had a width “a” of 4 mm and the height of the pillars was 7 mm. The spacing “b” between the faces 32 of adjacent pillars was 2 mm and so the gaps between adjacent edges 34 was √8=2.83 mm. A full line of pillars transverse to the overall direction of flow contained 12 pillars with 11 gaps between edges 34, d so the cross section available for flow was:
The apparatus of
Measurements were made with the Flopaam 3630 polyacrylamide solution in the flow circuit and also with water in this circuit. Measurements were made at a number of pump speeds. At each pump speed the electrical power to the resistors 72 was increased in steps and the temperature difference between the thermocouples 66, 67 was recorded. For each pump speed, this temperature difference was plotted against the electrical power supplied to the resistors 72. These plots were all linear and the slope of the line was a rate of heating the fluid flowing through the device 10. It was observed that when the flow rate was sufficient to cause elastic turbulence, the rate of heating was considerably increased. Without elastic turbulence the transfer of heat into the flowing fluid was solely conductive. When elastic turbulence was present, the transfer of heat included movement, brought about by the elastic turbulence, of heated fluid away from the surface 20 and into the body of the flowing fluid. In short, when there was elastic turbulence, the heat transfer was convective as well as conductive.
Calculations to show this quantitatively used the Nusselt number which is a dimensionless number indicating ratio of convective heat transfer to conductive heat transfer. The formula for a mean Nusselt number relating to heat transfer between a fluid and a flat, solid surface is:
This ratio was calculated for each pump speed and the calculated ratios are shown in
In some embodiments of this disclosure, the working fluid is an emulsion or suspension where the disperse phase is able to melt and to freeze at temperatures where the continuous phase is liquid. Emulsions and suspensions are used extensively in a wide range of commercial products over a wide range of industries. Emulsions are liquid-in-liquid systems with small drops of one liquid (the dispersed phase) distributed within another liquid (the continuous phase). The two liquids may be (and usually are) immiscible. The dispersed phase may be stabilized against coalescence by a surfactant in the composition or possibly by solid particles (smaller than the emulsion droplets) at the interface between the dispersed and continuous phases. An emulsion stabilized with solid particles is sometimes termed a Pickering emulsion. Suspensions have small particles of solid suspended within a continuous liquid phase.
If melting and freezing of the disperse phase of an emulsion take place within a temperature range where the continuous phase is liquid, the disperse phase may freeze and remain as a suspension of solid particles in the continuous phase. Because the continuous phase remains liquid, this suspension remains mobile, capable of flow and pumpable. Such a two-phase liquid is termed a phase change material emulsion (PCME). If a PCME is used as a working fluid for heat exchange or heat storage, with temperatures such that the disperse phase undergoes melting or freezing, the heat-carrying capacity of the fluid includes the latent heat of fusion of the dispersed phase (or the latent heats of the disperse phases if two or more are present and change between solid and liquid) because this latent heat is supplied to cause melting and is given out on freezing.
As an illustration of this, if a unit mass of water with specific heat capacity cpwater is heated from temperature T1 to temperature T2 the enthalpy change is:
If unit mass of an emulsion containing proportion ϕ of an oil is heated over the same temperature range, and the melting point of the oil is between T1 and T2, the enthalpy change is:
The use of a PCME as working fluid and the use of a working fluid displaying elastic turbulence can work in co-operation with each other. Using a PCME may reduce the volume and/or the flow rate of working fluid required to carry heat without directly altering the rate at which heat is transferred into or out of the working fluid. Indeed, use of a PCME may even reduce the rate at which heat is transferred from or to the working fluid, because the PCME may have lower overall thermal conductivity than its continuous phase. Use of elastic turbulence improves heat transfer at the interface through which heat is carried into or out of the working fluid. and so can reduce the size required for this interface or reduce the required flow rate over this interface and in consequence reduce the required pumping power. Thus the use of a PCME as working fluid jointly with elastic turbulence at the point of heat transfer to or from the working fluid can reduce the size and/or power demand of equipment to transfer heat by means of a flowing working fluid,
The continuous phase used for the PCME may be an aqueous solution. However, it could be a non-aqueous liquid such as an organic solvent or a low viscosity polydimethyl siloxane, commonly referred to as low viscosity silicone oil.
The disperse phase or phases of the PCME should not be agglomerated by interaction with the polymer which enables elastic turbulence. A disperse phase may therefore be an organic compound without heteroatoms, such as a paraffinic hydrocarbon, or may be an organic compound in which the only heteroatoms are oxygen atoms in ester or ether groups. It is also possible that a disperse phase is a fluorocarbon.
A number of factors may destabilize emulsions. In particular, so called ‘creaming’ is a problem encountered when the disperse and continuous phases are of different densities. It refers to the migration of emulsion droplets to the top of the emulsion, resulting in the eventual separation of phases. Emulsions additionally suffer from coalescence, where droplets merge to form larger droplets unless kinetically arrested using surfactants. A polymer which enables elastic turbulence may also stabilize against creaming. A further possibility is to incorporate a second polymer which will not by itself enable elastic turbulence to occur but will slightly enhance viscosity and thereby stabilize the PCME against creaming. More specifically a second polymer may be weakly associative so that a weak or critical gel is formed (i.e. giving the fluid solid-like properties) under quiescent conditions. As soon as flow starts the weak structure is broken and the emulsion flows easily.
The amount of a second polymer included to stabilize the emulsion may be under 5% by weight, and may be in a range from 0.05% or 0.1% up to 1% or 2% by weight,
The following experimental work shows a PCME which displays elastic turbulence. The continuous phase was an oil-in-water emulsion containing the following materials:
The polyacrylamide was Flopaam 3630 as mentioned above, with molecular weight 18-20 MegaDaltons. The disperse phase was hexadecane.
Preparation of the emulsion began with preparation of three compositions as follows:
The xanthan solution and the HPAM solution were combined in a 1:1 by weight proportion. The combined solution exhibited elastic turbulence which was detected as a rheological flow instability observed with a cone and plate rheometer as mentioned above.
The PCME was then made by mixing the combined solution and the hexadecane emulsion. PCME's containing 0.6 vol %, 1.5 vol % and 3 vol % of the initial hexadecane emulsion were observed to be stable to creaming and each exhibited elastic turbulence when tested using a cone and plate rheometer as above. The onset of elastic turbulence on increasing shear rate was again seen at about 150s−1.
A sample portion of this PCME formulation was examined by differential scanning calorimetry. The results are shown by
As an example, a heat exchange circuit as in
Further demonstrations of elastic turbulence, both when caused by viscoelastic surfactant and when caused by high molecular weight polymer, were carried out using a flow guide 100 as shown by
The apparatus shown by
Beams from a red LED light 125R and a green LED light 125G were directed along paths, respectively shown as a solid line and as a broken line, towards a video camera 126. The chamber 108 containing flow guide 100 was positioned between linear polarizing filters 128R, 129R set with their polarization directions at right angles (i,e, crossed) and between linear polarizing filters 128G, 129G which were also set with their polarization directions at right angles to each other. Consequently, no light could reach the video camera 126 unless birefringence in the chamber 108 altered the angle of polarization of light passing through the chamber. The filters 128R and 128G were set with their polarization directions at right angles to each other, so that the planes of polarization of the red and green light entering the chamber were at right angles to each other. Dichroic mirrors 130 which pass the red beam and reflect the green beam were used to merge the red and green beams, then to separate them after they have passed through chamber 104, and subsequently to reunite them before they arrive at the camera 126.
Other parts of the apparatus were mirrors 138, lenses 132, red and green bandpass filters 134G and 134R and dichroic mirrors 136 which were set with a 90° difference in rotation with respect to the red beam path in order to cancel rotation of polarization induced due to Fresnel refraction. Such dichroic mirrors were not needed for the green beam because its polarization was such that no rotation of polarization was induced.
Wormlike micelles formed by viscoelastic surfactants are birefringent. Consequently, when these molecules became aligned by liquid flow within the chamber 108 and were illuminated with polarized red and green light, they changed the plane of polarization of the light thereby allowing some of this light to pass through the filters 129R and 129G to the camera, although this did not occur if the alignment of the micelles coincided with the plane of polarization of the light. Providing two light beams with different planes of polarization as they entered the chamber 104 addressed this issue: any micelles aligned with the red polarization would not be aligned with the green polarization and vice versa. Hence the apparatus was sensitive to polarization alignment in any direction.
When there was flow of a liquid containing wormlike micelles through the chamber, these micelles became aligned through extensional flow as the liquid flowed around the pillars 102 of the flow guide 100, and the birefringence from the aligned micelles could be seen as red or green color in pictures or video recorded by the camera 126.
A first experiment was carried out using a solution similar to one mentioned by Moss and Rothstein in the paper above. This solution contained 100 mM (approx. 4 wt %) of the viscoelastic cationic surfactant cetylpyridinium chloride and 50 mM (approx. 0.8 wt %) of sodium salicylate dissolved in a brine of 100 mM (approx. 0.6 wt %) NaCl in distilled water.
The viscoelastic solution was pumped through the chamber 108 at a low flow rate of 5 ml per minute. The camera 126 recorded video at twenty frames per second for a period of 5 seconds and the recording showed that the pattern of flow around the pillars 102 of the flow guide 100 remained constant. Four pictures from that video recording, at half second intervals, are shown in grayscale as the top row in
Similar experiments were carried out with solutions containing partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide of average molecular weight 18 MDa (HPAM) to enable the display of elastic turbulence and containing xanthan as an additional thickening agent, and with comparative solutions containing only xanthan (which was too rigid to cause elastic turbulence, as mentioned above). These polymers do not form micelles but do cause birefringence when aligned. Again elastic turbulence was not observed at a flow rate of 5 ml/min but was observed at faster flow rates.
Flow rates and observations are given in the following table which also repeats the comments from the above experiment with viscoelastic surfactant.
It is apparent from these comments that the solution containing HPAM and xanthan displayed elastic turbulence at 15 ml·sec and above, but solutions containing xanthan without HPAM did not display elastic turbulence even at 30 ml/min.
The various embodiments of this disclosure which have been set out above are intended to assist understanding of this disclosure, but not to limit in any way the scope of this disclosure as defined by the following claims. It should be appreciated that any features or possibilities described in combination may, where it is practical to do so, be used individually. Also, features or possibilities mentioned in the following claims or described in any embodiment may be used in any other embodiment, in so far as it is practical to do so and in particular where two or more of the following claims are dependent on the same preceding claim, the reader should understand that the present disclosure includes any possible combination of any two or more or all of those dependent claims with each other and with that preceding claim.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
GB2314042.9 | Sep 2023 | GB | national |