The application relates to flues, particularly to flues for condensing and non-condensing boilers.
Condensing boilers require a relatively expensive stainless steel stack that is listed by UL as Category IV, based on pressure and corrosion resistance. Older boiler stacks are more typically Category I stacks which are presently unsuitable for use with condensing boilers. Particularly in urban settings where boiler stacks can be two hundred feet high, replacing a category I stack with a category IV stack can cost far more than the new condensing boiler.
A heated flue includes a flue section configured to be fluidly coupled to an exhaust outlet of a boiler. At least one heater is mechanically coupled to the flue section to heat an exhaust gas flowing within. A sensor is mechanically coupled to the flue section or disposed within the flue section. The sensor is configured to measure a parameter of the exhaust gas flowing within. A controller is operatively coupled to the at least one heater and the sensor. The controller is configured to control a temperature of the exhaust gas based on the parameter.
The heated flue is configured to allow a condensing boiler to discharge exhaust gases to a Category I stack without causing corrosive failure or a net positive pressure within the flue.
The heated flue heats the exhaust gas flowing within to about 400 degrees F.
The at least one heater can include a gas fired burner. The at least one heater can include an electric heating element.
The sensor can include a temperature sensor. The sensor can include a pressure sensor. The sensor can include a water content sensor. The sensor can include a sound sensor.
The water separator is disposed in an exhaust gas path between the boiler and the at least one heater. The water separator can include a cyclone water separator. The cyclone water separator can include an about cone shaped lower section.
The heated flue can further include an acoustic silencer. The acoustic silencer can include a swirl silencer.
A method to vent a condensing boiler into a non-condensing rated stack includes: providing a stack section which includes a water separator and a flue heater; separating a plurality of water droplets from an exhaust gas of the condensing boiler to remove the plurality of water droplets from the exhaust gas; heating the exhaust gas; and venting a dried heated exhaust gas into the non-condensing rated stack.
The step of heating can include heating the exhaust gas to about 400 degrees F.
The step of separating can include separating the plurality of water droplets from the exhaust gas of the condensing boiler to remove the plurality of water droplets by use of a cyclone vapor separator.
The step of separating can include separating the plurality of water droplets from the exhaust gas of the condensing boiler to remove the plurality of water droplets by use of a cyclone vapor separator having an about cone shaped lower section.
The method can further include between the steps of heating and venting, a step of acoustic attenuation by use of a swirl mixing silencer.
A heated flue for venting a condensing boiler into a non-condensing rated stack includes a flue section configured to be fluidly coupled to an exhaust outlet of a boiler. At least one heater is mechanically coupled to the flue section to heat an exhaust gas flowing within. A water separator is disposed at an inlet of the flue section before the at least one heater. A sensor is mechanically coupled to the flue section or disposed within the flue section. The sensor is configured to measure a parameter of the exhaust gas flowing within. A controller is operatively coupled to the at least one heater and the sensor, the controller configured to control a temperature of the exhaust gas based on the parameter.
A cyclone water separator for a boiler exhaust flue includes an input port adapted to accept an exhaust gas including water droplets from the boiler. A cyclone cylinder with a cyclone inducing flow path includes a lower about cone shaped section. An exhaust port is adapted to fluidly couple into a flue section to exhaust the exhaust gas substantially free of water droplets with a particle size over about 0.00025″. A drain drains liquid water from the cyclone cylinder.
The foregoing and other aspects, features, and advantages of the application will become more apparent from the following description and from the claims.
The features of the application can be better understood with reference to the drawings described below, and the claims. The drawings are not necessarily to scale, emphasis instead generally being placed upon illustrating the principles described herein. In the drawings, like numerals are used to indicate like parts throughout the various views.
As described hereinabove, condensing boilers require a relatively expensive stainless steel stack that is listed by UL as Category IV, based on pressure and corrosion resistance. Older boiler stacks are more typically Category I stacks which are presently unsuitable for use with condensing boilers. Particularly in urban settings where boiler stacks can be two hundred feet high, replacing a category I stack with a category IV stack can cost far more than the new condensing boiler.
Condensing boilers typically heat water for a closed loop water circulation system, such as to heat a building. The condensing boiler burns a fuel such as natural gas which produces heat, and a hot exhaust flue gas which includes carbon dioxide and water. A condensing boiler can operate with a very high efficiency of about 95% efficient when operated into Category IV condensing stack. A condensing stack, which can be several hundred feet high, is typically lined with stainless steel and is sealed as a pressurized system which can be run as a cold flue. The more efficient the condensing boiler operates, the cooler the flue. However, such a pressurized Category IV stack requires an expensive high grade stainless steel.
It is common to install a replacement or upgraded boiler in place of an old existing boiler installation. Many of the older boilers vent their flue gas into a Category I stack. Category I stacks are not sealed and cannot be pressurized. Moreover, the materials of most category I stacks cannot survive the acidity of the water vapor content of the relatively cool exhaust gas of a modern condensing boiler. Also, a Category I stack must maintain a hot stack to achieve the needed draft of upward traveling boiler exhaust gas. Category I stacks typically require a hot flue gas on the order of 400 degrees F. to promote the flow of exhaust gas up through the stack.
One problem is that to replace a Category I stack with a new Category IV stack can cost far more than the boiler, and introduce so much additional cost into a replacement or upgrade project that even though the new boiler is so much more efficient than the old boiler, the net cost of the project with a new Category IV stack cannot realize a cost savings.
What is needed is a system and method to allow a condensing boiler to vent exhaust gas into noncondensing stack, such as a Category I stack.
More than a century ago, relatively small heaters (Bunsen or gas burner (of a simple flame type), GB 106,468 1917), reheating by rerouting exhaust through steam, or adding a small auxiliary burner (GB 11,502, 1915) were used to heat flue gas to reduce corrosion in a stack. However, such systems at the early part of the last century were not capable of modulating the heat input to maintain 400° F.±10° F. under all firing conditions or controlling the heat input to a sensor to minimize the heat losses up the flue. They had to oversize the flue burner to make sure they didn't allow condensing in the flue under start-up or high load conditions. The structures of these GB patents were not optimal and wasted much of the heat gained by the higher efficiency boiler proposed in GB 11,502, 1915. Also, some heating of the flue gas was to facilitate a discharge of an exhaust gas laden with water vapor.
Now, as described hereinbelow, it has been realized that when combined with mechanical water droplet removal, when the exhaust gas of a condensing boiler is heated to about 400° F., a condensing boiler be used with a non-condensing (e.g. Category I) stack, and the overall efficiency of the system can be increased by exploitation of the energy of latent heat from condensing exhaust gas.
A flue system can be directly attached to the exhaust port of a condensing boiler which removes water from the exhaust from the condensing boiler and heats the exhaust gas to 400° F. using electrical heating elements or a modern gas fired burner to achieve a 400° F.±10° F., a temperature control not achievable by the Bunsen burner or gas fire (gas light) technology of that early part of the last century from 1910 to 1917. Moreover, a water separator, such a cyclone water separator, removes condensed water droplets over a wide range of droplet sizes. Preventing water droplets from entering the heated flue section of the device lowers the required energy input to heat the exhaust gases up to the 400° F. target temperature. If droplets are carried in the gas flow from the boiler to heated flue section, they will absorb the latent heat of the phase change from liquid to vapor, reducing the net efficiency of the system.
The purpose of heating stack gas of the prior art was to achieve greater draft, ascendency of the exhaust gas, as well as to evaporate or further vaporize water so that water did not condense out on the inside surface of the stack, causing stack corrosion.
It was realized however, that adding heat to water droplets in the exhaust heat decreases efficiency. It takes far more heat to reach 400° F. by heating exhaust gas with water droplets. Therefore, according to the application, water droplets are first removed, such as by a water separator, before the exhaust gas is heated in the flue.
By use of the new system and method according the Application, it is now possible to operate a condensing boiler into a non-condensing stack without corrosion, with positive updraft, and an increased net efficiency of the boiler system. That is, while still slightly more efficient to operate the same condensing boiler into a pressurized Category IV stack, by use of the new system and method of the Application, operation into a Category I stack is now possible (with water droplet removal combined with exhaust gas heating), and only slightly less efficient than operating into a far more expensive Category IV stack (approximately 2.7% efficiency loss)
Electric heating elements 103 of electric heaters 101 raise the temperature of the exhaust gas to about 400° F.+/−10° F. A controller 121 regulates the electrical power 141 to electric heaters 101 by any suitable power control method. Suitable power control methods include, for example, on/off operation, proportional control, pulse width modulation, duty cycle control, etc. Controller 121 includes any suitable processor to perform a control loop function, such as, for example, a negative feedback control loop to maintain the temperature of a temperature sensor 123 at about 400° F. Controller 121 can control each or all of the electric heaters via any suitable control line 125, where there is a control input at each electric heater. Or, controller 121 can directly control the electrical power to each or all of the electric heaters by controlling and/or regulating the electrical power delivered to the electric heaters 101 (e.g. a solid state (e.g. one or more SCR) electrical power control in the controller 121. In some cases where controller 121 directly controls the electrical power to each one of the electric heaters separately, or to all in common, the separate control line or control lines 125 can be omitted.
As described hereinabove, exhaust gas exiting the boiler and entering the electric heated flue 100 includes water droplets over a range of droplet sizes. Cyclone water separator 151 removes most or substantially all of the water droplets. Electric heaters 101 then raise the temperature of the relatively cool and now dry exhaust gas entering the heated flue 171 to 400° F., at which point, the now relatively dry and heated flue gas is suitable to be vented into a category I stack. Note that considerable electrical energy savings is achieved by removing the water droplets prior to heating the flue gas. This improvement over the prior art, allows the flue gas to be heated to 400° F. with considerably less energy than would have been required in the prior art, where those systems had to heat the exhaust gas plus the water in the exhaust gas.
Gas burner 102 raises the temperature of the exhaust gas to about 400° F.+/−10° F. Gas burner 102 can be, for example, a mesh type burner. The fire side 112 of gas burner 102 is shown inside of the flue 171 in
Where a gas fired burner heats the flue gas in a relatively short length of flue, there can be undesirable sounds including sounds related to burner and flue resonances. A sound silencer can be added to the heated flue section to reduce or substantially eliminate some sounds including resonance related gas burner induced noise.
As described hereinabove, exhaust gas exiting the boiler and entering the gas burner heated flue 100 includes water droplets over a range of droplet sizes. Cyclone water separator 151 removes most or substantially all of the water droplets. Gas burner 102 then raises the temperature of the relatively cool exhaust gas entering the heated flue 171 to 400° F., at which point, the now relatively dry and heated flue gas is suitable to be vented into a category I stack. Note that considerable fuel energy savings is achieved by removing the water droplets prior to heating the flue gas. This improvement over the prior art, allows the flue gas to be heated to 400° F. with considerably less energy than would have been required in the prior art, where those systems had to heat the exhaust gas plus the water in the exhaust gas.
In place of, or in addition to temperature sensor 123, there can also be a pressure sensor (not shown in
There can also be a moisture or relative humidity sensor. The relative humidity of the flue gases measured after the water droplet separator indicates the effectiveness of the separator. Measured after heating and before exiting to the Category I flue indicates the amount of vapor condensed and separated within the boiler and separator, and that is inversely proportional to the net efficiency of the boiler.
There can also be a sound sensor. The sound sensor can be used to detect thermal acoustic resonance and to make changes in the air/fuel mixture to reduce the sound level.
Without the water separator, far more energy would be required to heat the flue gas including the water (about another 5.5%), for an overall lower system efficiency of about 84.8%.
An optional flue gas return (FGR) tube is also shown in
Also, shown in
Cyclone water separator—Exemplary modeling, more specifically with an AERCO BMK2000 boiler was performed. It was realized that cyclone water separator with a lower cone shape, rather than a cylindrical lower section more efficiently removes water droplets over a wide range of droplet size.
Controller—Any suitable processor based device can be used as the controller. Suitable processors include, for example, microcomputers, programmed or programmable logic devices, processors, microprocessors, etc. The controller function can also be provided by any suitable computer. Typically, one or more controllers can report performance data, including at least one of temperature, pressure, etc. to one or more computers by any suitable wired or wireless method including, for example, industrial current loops, serial protocols, Bluetooth, WIFI, ethernet, etc. While less common, the controller can also be an analog controller, such as for example, including an analog control and/or analog feedback loop to control the flue heater.
In summary, and with respect to exemplary
Processor firmware and/or software, including for the controller described hereinabove, design applications and computer modeling, including computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis can be provided on a computer readable non-transitory storage medium. A computer readable non-transitory storage medium as non-transitory data storage includes any data stored on any suitable media in a non-fleeting manner Such data storage includes any suitable computer readable non-transitory storage medium, including, but not limited to hard drives, non-volatile RAM, SSD devices, CDs, DVDs, etc.
It will be appreciated that variants of the above-disclosed and other features and functions, or alternatives thereof, may be combined into many other different systems or applications. Various presently unforeseen or unanticipated alternatives, modifications, variations, or improvements therein may be subsequently made by those skilled in the art which are also intended to be encompassed by the following claims.
This application claims priority to and the benefit of co-pending U.S. provisional patent application Ser. No. 63/057,435, HEATED FLUE SYSTEM AND METHOD TO VENT A CONDENSING BOILER INTO A NONCONDENSING STACK, filed Jul. 28, 2020, which application is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63057435 | Jul 2020 | US |