This application relates to structures and methods for use in protective equipment, including but not limited to helmets for use in recreational activities.
Designers of protective equipment are often faced with many conflicting requirements and challenges. For example, helmets for sporting use are expected to be lightweight, able to withstand and absorb significant impacts of different types and directions, capable of providing air flow to the wearer’s head in use, as well as a comfortable and conformable fit that can accommodate variations in the size or shape of a user’s head within each specific helmet size. Considerations of style, and the limitations of existing molding techniques in Expanded Polystyrene (EPS) molding, are also relevant.
To easily identify the discussion of any particular element or act, the most significant digit or digits in a reference number refer to the figure number in which that element is first introduced.
Honeycomb (hexagonal) sandwich panels are commonly used for lightweight mechanical structures. In such panels, hexagonal interior walls are enclosed by parallel sheets to form a plate-like assembly. Honeycomb sandwich panels are used where a high ratio of strength to mass is needed, and are typically available in paper, aluminum, fiberglass and advanced composite materials.
The desirable properties of sandwich panels extend to products produced by additive manufacturing. For example, total weight and specific strength are key concerns for the manufacture of custom 3D-printed sport safety helmets. For some products, holes through the structure are necessary, such as in a bicycle helmet where user comfort depends on adequate airflow. Unfortunately, any holes in a sandwich panel greatly reduces its mechanical properties by allowing crumpling in-plane.
For an additive manufactured helmet there are other problems with removing all or part of the outer panels: knife-like walls oriented perpendicular to the inside that may pose a safety risk, difficulty in some additive manufacturing processes to print walls consistently when there is no peripheral support, and a tendency to propagate cracks where inner and outer walls meet at ninety degrees. Simply making holes in the outer surfaces that are smaller than the hexagons defined by the walls of a honeycomb structure retain many of these mechanical problems.
In some examples, provided is a personal protective item such as a helmet. The personal protective item includes a hexagonal structure comprising a plurality of hexagonal tubes, each hexagon tube having a first end and a second end and being formed by a plurality of walls, the first and second ends being defined by edges of the plurality of walls, and a cylindrical end cap on at least some of the edges of the plurality of walls. At least some of the hexagonal tubes may be open adjacent to the end caps for ventilation. The end caps may be circular cylinders or circular tubes, or may be elliptical in shape.
The personal protective item may further include an end wall coupled to at least some of the edges of the walls to close the ends of at least some of the hexagonal tubes, the edges of the walls of the hexagonal tubes adjacent to the end wall not having cylindrical end caps.
In some examples, the personal protective item may also include supporting columns along the hexagonal tubes where the walls of adjacent hexagonal tubes meet. The supporting columns may taper from the first end to the second end. A side of at least one supporting column may be flat to enhance 3D printability. A diameter of the supporting columns may also vary across the personal protective item.
The personal protective item may be assembled from at least a first part and a second part, the first part having a spline defined thereon and the second part having a groove defined therein for receiving the spline.
The personal protective item may be assembled from at least a first part and a second part and an extrinsic spline, the first part having groove defined therein for receiving the spline and the second part having a groove defined therein for receiving the spline.
In some examples, the personal protective item includes a pad for providing user comfort, the pad including a plate that is deflectable relative to a substrate of the personal protective time, the pad being coupled to the substrate by one or more constant force springs. The pad may include a number of posts mounted to the plate, the posts being received by post holes defined in the substrate.
In some examples, a personal protective item such as a helmet includes an inner wall having a first aperture defined therein, an outer wall having a second aperture defined therein, a honeycomb structure located between the inner wall and the outer wall, the honeycomb structure including a plurality of hexagonal tubes having first ends and second ends, the first and second ends of a first group of the hexagonal tubes being exposed through the first aperture and the second aperture, and end caps located on the first and second ends of the first group of hexagonal tubes. The first and second ends of a second group of hexagonal tubes are coupled to the inner wall and the outer wall respectively without having end caps.
The hexagonal tubes may comprise tube walls, and the personal protective item may further include supporting columns along the hexagonal tubes where the tube walls of adjacent hexagonal tubes meet. The supporting columns may taper along the length of the hexagonal tubes, and a diameter of the supporting columns may vary across the personal protective item.
The personal protective item may be assembled from at least a first part and a second part, the first part having a spline defined thereon and the second part having a groove defined therein for receiving the spline.
The personal may further include a pad for providing user comfort, the pad includes a plate that is deflectable relative to a substrate of the personal protective time, the pad being coupled to the substrate by one or more constant force springs.
Other technical features may be readily apparent to one skilled in the art from the following figures, descriptions, and claims.
Ventilation holes 106 are provided in the walls 102. The holes 106 correspond to the walls of the honeycomb structure, allowing air flow to the user’s head from the outside. The holes 106 thus form a honeycomb pattern corresponding to the interior honeycomb structure. The openings of the holes at the interior and exterior walls are reinforced by cylindrical or tubular end caps 104 formed at the upper and lower ends of the hexagons formed by the interior honeycomb structure. The transition from the walls of the honeycomb structure to the end caps 104 may be filleted to discourage crack propagation between the honeycomb structure and the end caps 104.
The reinforcement to the otherwise exposed hexagonal edges of the interior honeycomb structure provided by the end caps 104 improves printability and structural integrity without greatly hindering airflow from the exterior of the helmet shell to the user’s head. The end caps 104 may have a circular, elliptical or some other cross-sectional shape.
In some examples, Fused Deposition Modelling (FDM) is used to make the helmet shell 100. Circular or elliptical shapes are advantageous to FDM because imprecision of starting and stopping filament precisely (retraction) does not weaken the end cap. Circular or elliptical end caps are tougher than planar endcaps and present rounded edges to the exterior surface instead of sharp edges. In some examples, the helmet shell 100 comprises a number of pieces that are made separately using additive manufacturing, which are then assembled into the final helmet shell 100, for example as discussed below with reference to
As can be seen, the aperture defined by an edge 204 of the exterior wall 202 does not follow the end caps 104 as for the interior wall 102. This is typically done for aesthetic or other design purposes. The end caps 104 may, but typically do not continue underneath the exterior wall 202, since reinforcement of the interior honeycomb structure in that area is then provided by the exterior wall 202.
Also shown in
In
Providing columns 604 at the intersections of walls 602 in a honeycomb structure 600 can improve the specific energy absorption of a sandwich panel including the honeycomb structure 600, or of the honeycomb structure 600 itself. Such integrated reinforcements are harder to produce by traditional sandwich panel construction, but are well suited to additive manufacturing. Such reinforcement is aesthetically and structurally well suited for combination with end caps 104 parallel to the head surface, and may be sized to be visually hidden by the end caps 104.
In the case of frustoconical columns 604, the diameter of a column adjacent to the inner surface of the helmet shell 100 and the diameter of the column 604 adjacent to the outer surface of the helmet shell 100 can be varied from one column to another column around the helmet shell 100, or for different sections of the helmet shell 100, to optimize desired energy absorption and density. The end caps 104 may also be of variable diameter or not present everywhere. The diameters of end caps 104 at an exterior surface of the helmet shell 100 may but need not match the diameter of end caps 104 at the interior surface of the helmet shell 100. As before, the transition between end caps 104 and columns 604 may be filleted to reduce crack propagation.
In some examples of a bicycle helmet using a carbon-fiber reinforced polymer, the end caps 502 parallel to the scalp of a user and near the skin, and end caps 104 at the exterior surface of the helmet shell 100, have outer diameters of 3 mm and 4 mm respectively. This geometry is interpolated to form columns 604 perpendicular to the head where three or more walls come together. The surfaces may be constructed to smoothly vary between the diameters.
In an FDM printer, material must be extruded on top of already extruded material to have something to which to attach. Having no material below the nozzle (called “overhang”) leads to gross defects with material being placed away from where it is intended. Some of the posts 708 have a flattened side 706 to enable FDM printing with less overhang. A cylinder having a nearly horizontal axis can create such a situation, where the bottom of the cylinder is too much “printing on air”. As shown in the image, the posts 708 have been adjusted to be flatter in ways that reduce overhangs. Such adjustments permit easier manufacture of the device using additive manufacturing. The alternative is to print extra material that has to be manually removed later, which adds cost and complexity.
While the flattened sides 706, which are nearly horizontal during 3D printing, is at risk for print defects, this is less so than a round column would be. That is because, for the flattened side 706, the filament is extruded along a shorter path between stable endpoints, whereas the extrusion for a cylinder has to follow a relatively long elliptical cross-section far away from support.
In
Pads are most comfortable when they provide a consistent and controlled pressure. When sports equipment has a poor fit, the pressure may be too small (or zero) such that the equipment is not held in place correctly. Alternately, pressure that is too high is uncomfortable or painful. Foam pads generally transmit more force as they get squeezed into a smaller volume. However, this limits the comfortable range of motion. While a conventional pad allows choosing a density to increase or decrease pressure, this cannot guarantee comfort as the ideal density will still differ with fit, and pressure may not be evenly distributed across the pad.
One possible approach is to use a viscoelastic material (“memory foam”) so that pressure points even out over time. A potential problem with memory foam is its reduced ability to sustain constant pressure over time.
Instead of a foam, pressure may be spread using a relatively stiffer panel that distributes load over the entire pad surface. The stiffness may be chosen to allow some curvature (e.g., across the forehead), while still distributing force at small scales. Deflection of the pad is arranged to provide a flat force-displacement curve, as described in more detail below with reference to
The pad 800 shown in
Each post 804 includes a conical base 808 for stability, which mates with a conical upper edge 1104 of a post holes 1102 in the helmet substrate as shown in
The spring 806 comprises primary walls 814 that are aligned with the boundary of the pad 800 to permit movement of the plate 802 relative to the helmet substrate, as well as a secondary wall 816 that prevents inversion of the primary walls 814 where the primary walls 814 meet the substrate. In one example the components of the pad can be 3D printed simultaneously and bonded thermally by proximity.
To obtain a force-displacement curve that is flat instead of stiffening with displacement, the primary walls 814 comprise an angled first wall 820 and an angled second wall 822 that meet at a waist 818, where buckling occurs when pressure is applied to the pad 800. In contrast to a traditional pad, the material properties only affect stiffness at the point (the waist 818) where buckling occurs. The buckling mechanism described in this example is an inward bend in the pad primary walls 814, but other arrangements are possible.
The material used for construction of the pad 800 can be quite stiff relative to traditional foam, but foam, wicking fabric or aesthetic material may also be laser, knife or die-cut and adhered to the surface of the plate 802 opposite to the posts 804. A preferred material for the pad is polyether thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) of shore 95A durometer which allows a smooth yet flexible surface and no additional material necessary.
Because the spring 806 has a flatter force-displacement curve than foam, the range of displacement can be larger than a traditional pad, without discomfort. The recess for the pad in the substrate and the depth of the holes for receiving the mounting posts can also be designed to accommodate the entire retracted pad 800 all the way to the adjacent surface of the substrate.
The secondary wall 816 prevents the primary walls 814 from turning inside-out (inversion) when the pad 800 is deeply depressed. Another solution would be to thicken the perimeter of the first wall 820 in the area that comes in contact with the recess in the substrate. Such thickening prevents undue expansion of the first wall 820 without affecting the apparent stiffness, because the compliance of the primary walls 814 is primarily at the waist 818.
An ordinary foam pad creates a linear relationship between displacement and force, as seen by the linear spring response line 904. The stiffness of the foam/spring can be arranged to match the slope of the line to available or preferred displacements. However, regardless of the stiffness, there is a narrow range of displacements within the acceptable range of force, as can be seen. In comparison, a near constant-force spring is able to maintain a comparable force as displacement increases, allowing a larger range of displacements to be acceptable to the wearer than can be achieved by a linear response.
As can be seen from
Also defined in the substrate is a recess 1106 that matches the overall shape of the pad 800. In some cases, the floor of the recess 1106 does not correspond to the entire shape of the pad 800 as shown, which permits the pad 800 to overlap with other functional equipment areas, such as the strap support 1108 seen in the figure.
The apparatus shown in
The posts 1304 include four-way conical split snap features 1308 that permit insertion of a post 1304 into, but not retraction of, a post 1304 from a post hole 1402, to hold the pad 1300 in place. Arches 1310 are defined in the post walls and holes 1312 are provided in the plate 1302, for example under the posts 1304, to reduce overall weight. An upper surface 1314 of the split snap feature 1308 may have an angled outer portion to permit insertion of the posts 1304 into the post holes 1402, and a flat upper portion to engage a spring 1502.
As before, the surface of the plate 1302 on the other side from the posts 1304 may have a material bonded thereto to enhance comfort, for example in the case of prolonged skin contact.
The post holes 1402 are deep enough to allow each post 1304 to fully extend into its post hole 1402 on top of a compressed spring 1502 when the pad 1300 is under pressure. Post hole upper edges 1406 are conical to facilitate post insertion of a the posts 1304 and also for engagement with the post conical bases 1306 when the pad 1300 is fully depressed, to provide additional lateral support to the pad 1300 when fully depressed. The undersides of the split snap features 1308 engage corresponding surfaces in the post holes 1402 to prevent withdrawal of the posts 1304 from the post holes 1402.
A lower region 1404 of each post hole 1402 is sufficiently wide so as to fully accommodate the split snap feature 1308 and a spring 1502, which may expand radially when compressed.
Any type of spring may be used within the post holes 1402, but preferably constant force springs are used.
The spring force provided by the springs 1502 is primarily as a result of buckling occurring at the outer edges 1516 and waists 1518 between adjacent spring walls, such as spring wall 1508, 1510 and 1512. The springs 1502 may be any shape, but the octagonal radial accordion design illustrated in
The spring 806 in
Any mechanism capable of plateauing force may be substituted, including but not limited to: cantilever springs, volute springs, leaf springs, torsion springs, wave springs, gas springs, main springs, or dilatant or auxetic foams and lattices.
The helmet shell 100 of
Additive manufacturing processes are typically limited to a “build volume,” for example, by the range of motion of the printer’s mechanism. There are also process-specific limitations to parts that include requiring the part to have a flat surface to make contact with a “print bed,” disallowing certain angles, limitations on the number of concurrent materials used in a part, and disallowing enclosed regions that prevent raw material from being removed.
It is common to work around these limitations by splitting parts into multiple pieces that undergo later assembly. These pieces can be combined in many ways, such as sewing, screwing, welding, solvent welding, snapping, etc. It is desired to have a robust technique that requires little skill, time and equipment for assembly.
As disclosed herein, parts may be joined with “dovetail” joints, or may require external parts, for example “biscuit” or “butterfly” joints. The word “spline” is used herein to describe any such mating part as used in specific 3d-printed processes.
Assembling rigid pieces into a composite structure requires that they slide relative to one another along some path with a cross-section invariant to rotation and translation along the path. In woodworking for practical reasons this is typically a straight line. The straight line is a special case of a circular arc, which is a special case of a most general helical path. As helical curves are the most general family of shapes, the word “helical” here may be understood to apply to straight or circular paths without loss of generality.
Splines may be partially printed directly into one part (intrinsic), or created as a separate component that holds larger pieces together (extrinsic). In the latter case, it can be useful to print the spline using the same production process. Each part may incorporate any number and type of splines for joining to neighboring parts.
Additive manufacturing makes joinery shapes possible that would not be possible in traditional processes such as lathing or injection molding. The ideal path may be optimized by software in a manner appropriate to the domain, rather than set rigidly in a Computer Aided Design (CAD) tool. For example, a 3d-printed helmet may conform to users’ heads for best possible comfort and safety. Segments of the unique helmet may be combined using helical joints defined by software while still respecting printing process constraints and mechanical performance requirements. The helical path may be placed optimally based on the contour of each customer’s head.
The construction of an optimal helical path is domain specific. However, a practical special case is constructing a circular path that follows a planar print bed in order to mate two parts formed from a reference design by an arbitrary coordinate space transformation. Three points define a unique circle, so when tolerances permit, a circular path can be constructed by observing the transform at three predefined points, from which a circular and planar path can be recovered suitable for joining. The strength of this technique is that the coordinate transform need not be linear and is bounded only by the need to keep the print beds planar.
Fused Deposition Modelling of a 3D-printed helmet is used as an example. The helmet is divided into individually printed sections, which are assembled by sliding together intrinsic splines or inserting extrinsic splines. Splines may be constructed by any convenient process, not necessarily 3d-printing. Parts may be solid, filled with a pattern, or have thin walls. The material may be different for the spline and the connecting parts. Once installed splines may be held in place in many ways including being welded, solvent welded, glued, shimmed, or friction fit.
In this regard,
The second part 1604 is printed on a print bed facing the reader. Second part 1604 also has a groove 1610 constrained by the print bed into which an extrinsic spline (not shown) will be inserted for attaching another part (also not shown).
The perspective view in the middle shows a chamfer 1704 on the insertion end of the spline 1702 for easier insertion into corresponding grooves in the two parts that are to be assembled.
The perspective view on the right side shows a surface 1706 that is angled to match an exterior contour of the parts to be joined, to provide a smooth finish and to conceal the hole formed by the grooves of the joined parts.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Pat. Application Serial No. 63/251,164 filed Oct. 1, 2021 and U.S. Provisional Pat. Application Serial No. 63/324,972 filed Mar. 29, 2022, the discloses of which are incorporated herein as if explicitly set forth.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63251164 | Oct 2021 | US | |
63324972 | Mar 2022 | US |