HID ballast with hot restart circuit

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6194843
  • Patent Number
    6,194,843
  • Date Filed
    Friday, January 29, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, February 27, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
A ballast includes a hot restart circuit for hot restart of a HID lamp. In one embodiment, the hot restart circuit includes inductively coupled first and second inductive elements coupled end to end. A first capacitor has a first terminal coupled to a point between the first and second inductive elements and a second terminal coupled to a switching element. When the switching element transitions to a conductive state, a voltage pulse is generated on the second inductive element and the corresponding pulse on the first inductive element is sufficient to achieve hot restart of the lamp. In one embodiment, the first capacitor and the second inductive provide a parallel resonant LC circuit. The resultant signal on the second inductive element increases a voltage on the first inductive element for hot restart of the lamp.
Description




CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION




Not Applicable.




STATEMENT REGARDING FEDERALLY SPONSORED RESEARCH




Not Applicable.




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to ballast circuits and more particularly to ballast circuits for energizing high intensity discharge lamps.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




High intensity discharge (HID) lamps are typically coupled to an electronic ballast which provides an alternating current (AC) signal to the lamps. To initially ignite the lamps, i.e. cold start, the ballast must apply a relatively high voltage, 2 kilovolts for example, which initiates an electric arc between the lamp terminals. After ignition of the lamp, the ballast provides operational signal levels for sustaining the electrical arc which is the source for light emitted by the lamp. To re-ignite a lamp immediately after the arc is extinguished, a hot start voltage, e.g., 10-25 kV, is required which is significantly higher than for cold start of the lamp.




The challenges of achieving hot restart of HID lamps are well known to one of ordinary skill in the art. In general, when the electric arc between the lamp terminals is extinguished the gas within the lamp de-ionizes such that a relatively high restart voltage is required to breakdown the electrical field of the hot gas and re-initiate a light generating arc. Some ballasts utilize a spark gap device to provide voltage levels sufficient to enable hot restart of the lamp. Other ballasts include complex and expensive circuitry to generate the relatively high voltage and current levels needed for hot restart of the lamp. However, such ballasts are often unreliable and may degrade the lamp operating characteristics.




It would, therefore, be desirable to provide a ballast having an efficient and elegant circuit for hot restart of a HID lamp.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention provides a ballast that includes a circuit for hot restart of a HID lamp. Although the invention is primarily shown and described in conjunction with ballasts for energizing a HID lamp, it is understood that the invention has other applications such as fluorescent lamps, as well as voltage regulators and motors.




In one embodiment, a ballast in accordance with the present invention includes a rectifier and an inverter having a hot restart circuit for providing hot restart of a HID lamp. In one particular embodiment, the inverter includes first and second switching elements coupled in a half bridge configuration. A first control circuit controls the conduction state of the first switching element and a second control circuit controls the conduction state of the second switching element. A resonant circuit including a resonant inductive element and a resonant capacitor is coupled to the switching elements and the lamp for providing an AC signal to the HID lamp.




The hot restart circuit is coupled to the lamp and to the resonant capacitor. In an exemplary embodiment, the hot restart circuit includes inductively coupled first and second inductive elements. A first capacitor is coupled to the second inductive element and a switching element is coupled to the first capacitor. In one particular embodiment, a circuit loop includes the first capacitor, the switching element and the second inductive element. When the switching element transitions to a conductive state, a voltage pulse is generated at the second inductive element. The corresponding signal on the inductively coupled first inductive element is effective to provide hot restart of the lamp.




In one embodiment, the transition of the switching element to a conductive state results in the first capacitor and the second inductive element forming a parallel resonant LC circuit. The resonant signal increases the voltage generated at the second inductive element which concomitantly generates an increased voltage signal on the first inductive element. The resonant nature of the circuit thereby increases signal levels applied to the lamp for enhancing the hot restart capability of the ballast











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The invention will be more fully understood from the following detailed description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:





FIG. 1

is a schematic block diagram of a ballast circuit in accordance with the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a circuit diagram of an exemplary implementation of the circuit of

FIG. 1

; and





FIG. 3

is a circuit diagram showing further details of the circuit of FIG.


2


.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION





FIG. 1

shows a ballast circuit


100


for energizing a high intensity discharge (HID) lamp


102


. The ballast


100


includes first and second input terminals


104




a,b


coupled to an AC energy source


106


. The ballast circuit


100


receives a relatively low frequency signal from the AC energy source


106


and provides a relatively high frequency signal to the lamp


102


for generating an electric arc across the lamp terminals thereby causing the lamp to emit visible light. As described below, the ballast


100


provides signal levels which are capable of hot restarting a HID lamp after the arc has been extinguished.




The ballast


100


includes a rectifier


108


for receiving the relatively low frequency signal from the AC energy source


106


and providing a DC signal to an inverter circuit


110


. The inverter


110


is effective to energize the lamp


102


with a high frequency signal that generates a sufficiently high voltage to initiate and sustain an electric arc between the lamp terminals T


1


,T


2


.





FIG. 2

shows an exemplary embodiment of the ballast


100


of FIG.


1


. The rectifier


108


is a full bridge rectifier formed from first, second, third, and fourth rectifying diodes DR


1


-


4


. The first and third diodes DR


1


,DR


3


are coupled end to end between first and second DC output terminals


112




a,b


of the rectifier which correspond to positive and negative rails


114


,


116


of the inverter


110


. The second and fourth diodes DR


2


,DR


4


are also coupled end to end between the output terminals


112




a,b


of the rectifier. The AC energy source


106


has a first terminal


118




a


coupled to a point between the first and third diodes DR


1


,DR


3


and a second terminal


118




b


coupled to a point between the second and fourth diodes DR


2


,DR


4


. A filter capacitor CF can be coupled between the rectifier output terminals


112




a,b


. The rectifier is effective to provide respective DC signals for energizing the positive and negative rails


114


,


116


of the inverter


110


.




The inverter


110


is shown as a resonant inverter having first and second switching elements Q


1


,Q


2


coupled in a half bridge configuration. The first-switching element Q


1


, shown here as a transistor, has a first or collector terminal


120


coupled to the positive rail


114


of the inverter, a second or base terminal


122


coupled to a first control circuit


124


for controlling the conduction state of the first switching element, and a third or emitter terminal


126


coupled to a first or collector terminal


128


of the second switching element Q


2


. The second switching element Q


2


has a second or base terminal


130


coupled to a second control circuit


132


for controlling the conduction state of the second switching element Q


2


and a third or emitter terminal


134


coupled to the negative rail


116


of the inverter.




A resonant inductive element LR has a first terminal


136


coupled to a point between the first and second switching elements Q


1


,Q


2


and a second terminal


138


coupled to a first terminal


140


of a resonant capacitor CR to which the first terminal T


1


of the lamp


102


is also coupled. A second terminal


142


of the resonant capacitor CR is coupled to a first terminal


144


of a hot restart circuit


146


. A second terminal


144




b


of the hot restart circuit


146


is connected to a point between first and second bridge capacitors CB


1


,CB


2


which are coupled end to end between the positive and negative rails


114


,


116


of the inverter.





FIG. 3

shows an exemplary circuit embodiment of the hot restart circuit


146


, as well as the first and second control circuits


124


,


132


. The first control circuit


124


includes a capacitor CQ


1


B coupled across the base and emitter terminals


122


,


126


of the first switching element Q


1


and a resistor RQ


1


B coupled in series to an inductive element LQ


1


B across the capacitor CQ


1


B. The inductive element LQ


1


B is inductively coupled to the resonant inductive element LR with a polarity indicated with conventional dot notation. The second control circuit


132


includes corresponding circuit elements CQ


2


B, RQ


2


B,LQ


2


B. As known to one of ordinary skill in the art, the inductive elements LQ


1


B,LQ


2


B are effective to alternately bias a respective switching element to conductive and non-conductive states to achieve resonant operation of the inverter and thereby provide an AC signal to the lamp


102


. In general, the first switching element Q


1


is conductive as current flows from the resonant inductive element LR to the lamp


102


and the second switching element Q


2


is conductive as current flows in the opposite direction from the lamp


102


to the resonant inductive element LR.




The hot restart circuit


146


includes first and second hot restart inductive elements LHR


1


,LHR


2


,which are inductively coupled to each other. The respective polarities of the inductive elements LHR


1


,LHR


2


correspond to conventional dot notation as shown. The first and second hot restart inductive elements LHR


1


,LHR


2


are coupled end to end between the resonant capacitor CR and the second terminal T


2


of the lamp


102


. A hot restart capacitor CHR has a first terminal


148


coupled to a point between the first and second hot restart inductors LHR


1


,LHR


2


and a second terminal


150


coupled to a first terminal


152


of a threshold switching element SW


1


, shown here as a silicon-controlled rectifier (SCR). It is understood, however, that other types of switching elements known to one of ordinary skill in the art can be used. The threshold switching element SW


1


has a second terminal


154


coupled to a diac DD


1


and a third terminal


156


coupled to the


144


B of the second hot restart inductive element LHR


2


. A current limiting resistor R


1


is coupled across the second and third terminals


154


,


156


of the threshold switching element SW


1


.




The hot restart circuit


146


further includes an inductive bias element LB which is inductively coupled to the resonant inductive element LR (and/or LQ


2


B) with a polarity as shown with conventional dot notation. A first terminal


158


of the bias element LB is coupled to the first terminal


152


of the threshold switching element SW


1


via a second resistor R


2


and a first diode D


1


, and a second terminal


160


is coupled to the third terminal


156


of the switching element SW


1


. A second diode D


2


, a third resistor R


3


, and a fourth resistor R


4


complete a circuit loop which includes the second resistor R


2


. and the bias element LB. A diac capacitor CDD


1


is coupled in parallel with the fourth resistor R


4


between the diac DD


1


and the second terminal


160


of the bias element LB.




The hot restart circuit


146


provides a voltage to the lamp


102


that is sufficient to re-ignite the lamp after the arc has been extinguished, i.e., hot restart. As the signal levels in the inverter increase due to the resonant nature of the circuit, the signal at the bias element LB, which is inductively coupled to the resonant inductive element LR, increases. The second diode D


2


rectifies the bias element LB signal so as to charge the diac capacitor CDD


1


. The signal present on the bias element LB is also rectified by the first diode so as to generate a voltage on the hot restart capacitor CHR.




When the voltage present on the diac capacitor CDD


1


is sufficient to cause the diac DD


1


to become conductive, the threshold switching element SW


1


transitions to a conductive state. As the threshold switching element SW


1


becomes conductive, a voltage pulse derived from energy stored in the circuit elements, e.g., CHR,LHR


2


, is generated on the second hot restart inductor LHR


2


which induces a corresponding pulse on the first hot restart inductive element LHR


1


. The resultant signal on the first hot restart inductive element LHR


1


is applied to the lamp


102


for hot restart of the lamp.




In an exemplary embodiment, the circuit can include a resonant feature to enhance the properties of the signal or pulse applied to the lamp. While the threshold switching element SW


1


is conductive, the hot restart capacitor CHR and the second hot restart inductive element are arranged in parallel inductive-capacitive (LC) resonant circuit. As known to one or ordinary skill in the art, a parallel resonant LC circuit appears to the circuit as an open circuit at a characteristic resonant frequency, i.e., a notch filter. It is understood that the resonant frequency of the parallel LC circuit can vary. In an exemplary embodiment, the characteristic resonant frequency is about 100 kiloHertz. And while current at or near the resonant frequency does not flow through the parallel LC circuit, significant amounts of current flow between the hot restart capacitor CHR and the second hot restart inductive element LHR


2


due to the phase difference between the current flowing through the inductive and capacitive elements.




The flow of current through the second hot restart inductive element LHR


2


induces a corresponding voltage in the first hot restart inductive element LHR


1


. In an exemplary embodiment, the turns ratio of the first hot restart inductive element LHR


1


to the second hot restart inductive element HLR


2


is about


30


. It is understood by one of ordinary skill in the art that the turns ratio can vary widely to achieve a desired voltage level at the inductors. Thus, for a turn ratio of about thirty, a voltage of about 500 volts on the second hot restart inductive element LHR


2


generates a voltage of about 15,000 volts on the first hot restart inductive element LHR


1


. This voltage is applied to the lamp


102


for achieving hot restart of the HID lamp, i.e., re-igniting an arc between the lamp terminals T


1


,T


2


.




It will be appreciated that values for the circuit components can vary. One of ordinary skill in the art can readily modify exemplary component values. Accordingly, the exemplary component values provided in the table below demonstrate but one particular circuit embodiment.

















Component




Value

























CR




0.0047




μF






CHR




0.001




μF






CDD1




0.1




μF






R1




10











R2




100




Ω






R3




100




Ω






R4




1











LR




1




mH






LHR1




100




T






LHR2




3000




T






DD1




10




V threshold














One of ordinary skill in the art will appreciate further features and advantages of the invention based on the above-described embodiments. Accordingly, the invention is not to be limited by what has been particularly shown and described, except as indicated by the appended claims. All publications and references cited herein are expressly incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.



Claims
  • 1. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:an inverter circuit having two switching elements for providing an AC drive signal to the lamp; a resonant inductive element coupled between said switching elements and the lamp; and a hot restart circuit coupled to the lamp when the lamp is connected in circuit for applying a voltage to the lamp that is sufficient to achieve hot restart of the lamp, the hot restart circuit including: a first inductor coupled to the lamp; a second inductor inductively coupled to the first inductor, said second inductor having first and second ends, said first end being directly connected to the lamp and said second end being connected to an end of the first inductor at a junction; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor at said junction; and a first switching element coupled to the first capacitor, said first switching element, said first capacitor, and said second inductor selectively forming a circuit loop such that a transition of the first switching element to a first state generates a voltage pulse on the second inductor which induces a corresponding voltage pulse on the first inductor for hot restart of the lamp.
  • 2. The ballast circuit according to claim 1, wherein a resonance between the first capacitor and the second inductor increases the voltage applied to the first lamp.
  • 3. The ballast circuit according to claim 2, wherein the resonance is a parallel LC resonance between the first capacitor and the second inductor.
  • 4. The ballast circuit according to claim 1, wherein the first switching element has first, second and third terminals, the first terminal being coupled to the first capacitor and the third terminal being coupled to the second inductor.
  • 5. The ballast circuit according to claim 1, wherein a first circuit loop includes the second inductor, the first capacitor and the first switching element.
  • 6. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:an inverter circuit having two switching elements for providing an AC drive signal to the lamp; a resonant inductive element coupled between said switching elements and the lamp; a hot restart circuit coupled to the lamp when the lamp is connected in circuit for applying a voltage to the lamp that is sufficient to achieve hot restart of the lamp, the hot circuit including: a first inductor coupled to the lamp; a second inductor coupled to the first inductor the first and second inductors being inductively coupled; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor; a first switching element having first, second and third terminals said first switching element being coupled to the first capacitor such that a transition of the first switching element to a first state generates a voltage pulse on the second inductor which induces a corresponding voltage pulse on the first inductor for hot restart of the lamp; and a diac coupled to the second terminal of the first switching element; wherein a first circuit loop includes the second inductor, the first capacitor and the first switching element.
  • 7. The ballast circuit according to claim 6, further including a diac capacitor coupled to the diac which biases the diac to a conductive state when a voltage on the diac capacitor is greater than a predetermined level.
  • 8. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp,a hot restart circuit coupled to the lamp when the lamp is connected in circuit for applying a voltage to the lamp that is sufficient to achieve hot restart of the lamp, the hot restart circuit including: a first inductor coupled to the lamp; a second inductor coupled to the first inductor, the first and second inductors being inductively coupled; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor; a first switching element coupled to the first capacitor, such that a transition of the first switching element to a first state generates a voltage pulse on the second inductor which induces a corresponding signal pulse on the first inductor for hot restart of the lamp, a diac coupled to the second terminal of the first switching element, a diac capacitor coupled to the diac which biases the diac to a conductive state when a voltage on the diac capacitor is greater than a predetermined level, and an inductive bias element and a diac diode coupled to the diac capacitor for rectifying a signal on the bias element and charging the diac capacitor, wherein a first circuit loop includes the second inductor, the first capacitor and the first switching element.
  • 9. The ballast circuit according to claim 8, wherein the bias element is inductively coupled to a resonant inductive element which forms a portion of a resonant circuit for providing an AC signal to the lamp.
  • 10. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:an inverter circuit having two switching elements for providing an AC drive signal to the lamp; a resonant inductive element coupled between said switching elements and the lamp; a hot restart circuit coupled to the lamp when the lamp is connected in circuit for applying a voltage to the lamp that is sufficient to achieve hot restart of the lamp, the hot restart circuit including: a first inductor coupled to the lamp; a second inductor coupled to the first inductor the first and second inductors being inductively coupled; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor; a first switching element coupled to the first capacitor such that a transition of the first switching element to a first state generates a voltage pulse on the second inductor which induces a corresponding voltage pulse on the first inductor for hot restart of the lamp; an inductive bias element inductively coupled to said resonant inductive element and coupled to the first capacitor, and a first diode coupled to the first capacitor for rectifying a signal on the bias element and charging the first capacitor.
  • 11. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:a hot restart circuit coupled to the lamp when the lamp is connected in circuit for applying a voltage to the lamp that is sufficient to achieve hot restart of the lamp, the hot restart circuit including: a first inductor coupled to the lamp; a second inductor coupled to the first inductor the first and second inductors being inductively coupled; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor; a first diode and an inductive bias element coupled to the first capacitor for rectifying a signal on the bias element and charging the first capacitor, the bias element being inductively coupled to a resonant inductive element which forms a portion of a resonant circuit for providing an AC signal to the lamp, and a first switching element coupled to the first capacitor such that a transition of the first switching element to a first state generates a voltage pulse on the second inductor which induces a corresponding signal pulse on the first inductor for hot restart of the lamp.
  • 12. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprisinga hot restart circuit coupled to the lamp when the lamp is connected in circuit for applying a voltage to the lamp that is sufficient to achieve hot restart of the lamp, the hot restart circuit including: a first inductor having first and second ends, said first end being coupled to the lamp; a second inductor inductively coupled to the first inductor, said second inductor having first and second ends, the first end of the second inductor being connected at a junction to the second end of the first inductor and the second end of the second inductor being directly connected to the lamp; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor; and a first switching element coupled to the first capacitor, such that a transition of the first switching element to a first state generates a voltage pulse on the second inductor which induces a corresponding voltage pulse on the first inductor for hot restart of the lamp.
  • 13. The ballast circuit according to claim 12, further including a resonant capacitor which forms a portion of a resonant circuit for providing an AC signal to the lamp, wherein the resonant capacitor is coupled to the first inductive element.
  • 14. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:a first inductor having first and second ends, said first end being coupled to the lamp; a second inductor inductively coupled to the first inductor, said second inductors having first and second ends, the first end of the second inductor being coupled to the second end of the first inductor; a resonant capacitor which forms a portion of a resonant circuit for providing an AC signal to the lamp, the resonant capacitor being coupled to the first inductive element; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor; and a first switching element coupled to the first capacitor such that a transition of the first switching element to a first state generates a voltage pulse on the second inductor which induces a corresponding voltage pulse on the first inductor for hot restart of the lamp, wherein a first circuit loop includes the resonant capacitor the first and second inductors and the lamp.
  • 15. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:a rectifier circuit for receiving a AC input signal and outputting a DC output signal; an inverter circuit coupled to the rectifier circuit for receiving the DC output signal and providing an AC drive signal to the lamp, the inverter circuit including a resonant circuit having a resonant inductive element and a resonant capacitive element; and a hot restart circuit including inductively coupled first and second hot restart inductive elements coupled so as to form a series circuit path, the first hot restart inductive element being coupled to the resonant capacitive element; a hot restart capacitor having a first terminal coupled to a point between the first and second hot restart inductive elements and a second terminal; and a threshold switching element having first, second and third terminals, the first terminal being coupled to the second terminal of the hot restart capacitor, and the third terminal being coupled to the second hot restart inductive element such that the hot restart capacitor, the threshold switching element and the second hot restart inductive element form a first circuit loop, said threshold switching element having an inductive bias element inductively coupled to said resonant inductive element.
  • 16. The ballast circuit according to claim 15, wherein the hot restart circuit further includes a diac coupled to the second terminal of the threshold switching element.
  • 17. A ballast circuit for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:a rectifier circuit for receiving an AC input signal and outputting a DC output signal; an inverter circuit coupled to the rectifier circuit for receiving the DC output signal and providing an AC drive signal to the lamp, the inverter circuit including a resonant circuit having a resonant inductive element and a resonant capacitive element; and a hot restart circuit including inductively coupled first and second hot restart inductive elements coupled so as to form a series circuit path, the first hot restart inductive element being coupled to the resonant capacitive element; a hot restart capacitor having a first terminal coupled to a point between the first and second hot restart inductive elements and a second terminal; a threshold switching element having first, second and third terminals the first terminal being coupled to the second terminal of the hot restart capacitor, and the third terminal being coupled to the second hot restart inductive element such that the hot restart capacitor, the threshold switching element and the second hot restart inductive element form a first circuit loop; a diac coupled to the second terminal of the threshold switching element; and an inductive bias element which is inductively coupled to the resonant inductive element.
  • 18. The ballast circuit according to claim 17, wherein the hot restart circuit further includes a diac capacitor and a diac diode, such that a second circuit loop includes the bias element, the diac diode and the diac capacitor.
  • 19. The ballast circuit according to claim 18, wherein a signal through the resonant inductive element induces a corresponding signal in the bias element which is rectified by the diac diode so as to charge the diac capacitor, such that the diac transitions to a conductive state when a voltage on the diac capacitor increases above a first predetermined threshold.
  • 20. The ballast circuit according to claim 17, wherein the hot restart circuit further includes a hot restart diode coupled to the hot restart capacitor such that a third circuit loop includes the bias element, the hot restart diode and the threshold switching element.
  • 21. The ballast circuit according to claim 20, wherein a signal through the resonant inductive element induces a corresponding signal on the bias element which is rectified by the hot restart diode so as to charge the hot restart capacitor.
  • 22. The ballast circuit according to claim 15, wherein a transition of the threshold switching element to a conductive state generates a parallel LC resonance between the hot restart capacitor and the second hot restart inductive element, which induces a corresponding voltage in the first hot restart inductive element for hot restart of the lamp.
  • 23. A ballast for energizing a HID lamp, comprising:an inverter circuit having two switching elements for providing an AC drive signal to the lamp; a resonant inductive element coupled between said switching elements and the lamp; first and second inductively coupled inductors, said second inductor being directly connected to the lamp at an end thereof; a first capacitor coupled to the second inductor; and a switching element coupled to the first capacitor such that a first circuit loop includes the switching element, the first capacitor and the second inductor, wherein a transition of the switching element to a conductive state generates a parallel LC resonance between the first capacitor and the second indicator which induces a corresponding voltage at the first inductive element for hot restart of the lamp.
US Referenced Citations (51)
Number Name Date Kind
3732460 Wattenbach May 1973
3989976 Tabor Nov 1976
4103209 Elms Jul 1978
4107579 Bodine, Jr. et al. Aug 1978
4204141 Nuver May 1980
4287454 Feuersanger et al. Sep 1981
4331905 Owen May 1982
4339692 Lasecki et al. Jul 1982
4350935 Spira et al. Sep 1982
4356433 Linden Oct 1982
4373146 Bonazoli et al. Feb 1983
4378514 Collins Mar 1983
4414493 Henrich Nov 1983
4437043 Pitel Mar 1984
4455510 Lesko Jun 1984
4503364 Engel Mar 1985
4745341 Herres May 1988
4763044 Nuckolls et al. Aug 1988
4810936 Nuckolls et al. Mar 1989
4890041 Nuckolls et al. Dec 1989
4904903 Pacholok Feb 1990
4958107 Mattas et al. Sep 1990
4959593 Joanino Sep 1990
5003231 Perper Mar 1991
5023521 Sridharan Jun 1991
5036256 Garrison et al. Jul 1991
5047694 Nuckolls et al. Sep 1991
5051665 Garrison et al. Sep 1991
5084801 El-Hamamsy et al. Jan 1992
5118994 Byszewski et al. Jun 1992
5134345 El-Hamamsy et al. Jul 1992
5138231 Iida et al. Aug 1992
5225742 Beasley Jul 1993
5321338 Nuckolls et al. Jun 1994
5339005 Byszewski et al. Aug 1994
5387849 Sridharan Feb 1995
5391966 Garrison Feb 1995
5424617 Garbowicz et al. Jun 1995
5428268 Melis et al. Jun 1995
5444334 Speaker et al. Aug 1995
5449980 Kiefer et al. Sep 1995
5569984 Holtslag Oct 1996
5572093 Kiefer Nov 1996
5594308 Nuckolls et al. Jan 1997
5606222 Cottaar et al. Feb 1997
5623187 Caldeira et al. Apr 1997
5677602 Paul et al. Oct 1997
5684367 Moskowitz et al. Nov 1997
5723951 Byszewski et al. Mar 1998
5925986 Moisin Jul 1999
5962981 Okude et al. Oct 1999
Foreign Referenced Citations (5)
Number Date Country
39 23 699 A1 Mar 1990 DE
40 15 400 A1 Nov 1991 DE
0 337 021 A1 Oct 1989 EP
0 411 617 A2 Feb 1991 EP
2 319 677 May 1998 GB
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
International Search Report Mailed May 25, 2000.