High efficiency induction heating and melting systems

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6690710
  • Patent Number
    6,690,710
  • Date Filed
    Monday, April 29, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, February 10, 2004
    20 years ago
  • CPC
  • US Classifications
    Field of Search
    • US
    • 373 7
    • 373 138
    • 373 139
    • 373 151
    • 373 152
    • 373 153
    • 373 155
    • 373 156
    • 373 159
    • 373 160
    • 373 161
    • 373 162
    • 373 163
    • 373 164
    • 075 1014
    • 266 44
    • 266 275
    • 266 280
    • 219 600
    • 219 635
    • 219 647
    • 219 653
    • 219 672
    • 432 248
    • 432 156
    • 034 247
    • 034 443
    • 034 444
    • 034 493
    • 034 68
    • 164 254
    • 164 256
    • 164 335
    • 164 337
  • International Classifications
    • H05B602
    • Term Extension
      92
Abstract
An induction heating and melting system uses a crucible formed from a material that has a high electrical resistivity or high magnetic permeability, and one or more inductor coils formed from a wound cable consisting of multiple individually insulated copper conductors to form an induction furnace that, along with its associated power supply, provides a compact design. The system components are air-cooled; no water-cooling is required. The crucible may alternatively be shaped as a tunnel or enclosed furnace.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to induction heating and melting systems that use magnetic induction to heat a crucible in which metal can be heated and/or, melted and held in the molten state by heat transfer from the crucible.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Induction melting systems gain popularity as the most environmentally clean and reasonably efficient method of melting metal. In the induction melting furnace


1


shown in

FIG. 1

, the electromagnetic field produced by AC current in coil


2


surrounding a crucible


3


couples with conductive materials


4


inside the crucible and induces eddy currents


5


, which in turn heat the metal. As indicated in

FIG. 1

, the arrows associated with coil


2


generally represent the direction of current flow in the coil, whereas the arrows associated with eddy currents


5


generally indicate the opposing direction of induced current flow in the conductive materials. Variable high frequency ac (typically in the range from 100 to 10,000 Hz) current is generated in a power supply or in a power converter


6


and supplied to coil


2


. The converter


6


, typically but not necessarily, consists of an AC-to-DC rectifier


7


, a DC-to-AC inverter


8


, and a set of capacitors


9


, which, together with the induction coil, form a resonance loop. Other forms of power supplies, including motors-generators, pulse-width modulated (PWM) inverters, and the like, can be used.




As shown in

FIG. 2

, the magnetic field causes load current


10


to flow on the outside cylindrical surface of the conductive material, and coil current


11


to flow on the inner surface of the coil conductor. Crucible


3


in a typical furnace is made from ceramic material and usually is not electrically conductive. The efficiency of the furnace is computed by the formula:









η
=

1

1
+



D
1


D
2


·


ρ
1


ρ
2


·


Δ
2


Δ
1









equation






(
1
)














where




η=furnace efficiency;




D


1


=coil inner diameter;




D


2


=load outer diameter;




ρ


1


=resistivity of coil winding material (copper);




ρ


2


=resistivity of load (melt);




Δ


1


=current depth of penetration in copper winding; and




Δ


2


=current depth of penetration in load (melt).




The depth of current penetration (Δ) is a function of a material's properties as determined by the formula:









Δ
=

k
·


ρ

f
·
μ








equation






(
2
)














where:




ρ=resistivity in ohm·meters;




f=frequency in Hertz;




μ=magnetic permeability (dimensionless relative value); and




Δ=depth of penetration in meters.




The constant, k=503, in equation (2) is dimensionless.




Because current does not penetrate deep into the low resistivity copper material of the coil, the typical coil efficiency is about 80 percent when the molten material is iron. Furnaces melting low resistivity materials such as aluminum (with a typical resistivity value of 2.6×10


−8


ohm·meters), magnesium or copper alloys have a lower efficiency of about 65 percent. Because of significant heating due to electrical losses, the induction coil is water-cooled. That is, the coil is made of copper tubes


12


and a water-based coolant is passed through these tubes. The presence of water represents an additional danger when melting aluminum, magnesium or their alloys. In case of crucible rupture, water may get into molten aluminum and a violent chemical reaction may take place in which the aluminum combines with oxygen in the water, releasing free hydrogen which may cause an explosion. Contact between water and magnesium may similarly result in an explosion and fire. Extreme caution is taken when aluminum or magnesium is melted in conventional water-cooled furnaces.




An object of the present invention is to improve the efficiency of an induction furnace by increasing the resistance of the load by using as the load a crucible made of a high temperature electrically conductive material or a high temperature material with high magnetic permeability. It is another object of the present invention to improve the efficiency of an induction furnace by reducing the resistance of the induction coil by using as the coil a cable wound of multiple copper conductors that are isolated from each other. It is still another object of the invention to properly select operating frequencies to yield optimum efficiency of an induction furnace.




It is a further object of the present invention to provide a high efficiency induction melting system with a furnace and power supply that do not use water-cooling and can be efficiently air-cooled.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In its broad aspects, the present invention is an induction furnace that is used for melting a metal charge. The furnace has a crucible formed substantially from a material having a high electrical resistivity or high magnetic permeability, preferably a silicon carbide or a high permeability steel. At least one induction coil surrounds the crucible. The coil consists of a cable wound of a plurality of conductors isolated one from the other. An isolation sleeve electrically and thermally insulates the crucible from the at least one induction coil. Preferably, the isolation sleeve is a composite ceramic material, such as an air-bubbled ceramic between two layers of ceramic. In alternate examples of the invention, the induction furnace is used to heat the metal charge to a temperature that may be below its melting point.




Copper is especially preferred for the conductors, because of its combination of reasonably high electrical conductivity and reasonably high melting point. A preferred form of the cable is Litz wire or litzendraht, in which the individual isolated conductors are woven together in such a way that each conductor successively takes all possible positions in the cross section of the cable, so as to minimize skin effect and high-frequency resistance, and to distribute the electrical power evenly among the conductors.




In another aspect, the present invention is an induction melting system that is used for melting a metal charge. The system has at least one power supply. The crucible that holds the metal charge is formed substantially from a material having a high electrical resistivity or high magnetic permeability, preferably a silicon carbide or a high permeability steel. At least one induction coil surrounds the crucible. The coil consists of a cable wound of a large number of copper conductors isolated one from the other. An isolation sleeve electrically and thermally insulates the crucible from the at least one induction coil. Preferably, the isolation sleeve is a composite ceramic material, such as an air-bubbled ceramic between two layers of ceramic. Preferably, the induction melting system is air-cooled from a single source of air that sequentially cools components of the power supply and the coil. The metal charge is placed in the crucible. Current is supplied from the at least one power supply to the at least one coil to heat the crucible inductively. Heat is transferred by conduction and/or radiation from the crucible to the metal charge, and melts the charge. In alternate examples of the invention, the induction furnace is used to heat the metal charge to a temperature that may be below its melting point.




These and other aspects of the invention will be apparent from the following description and the appended claims.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




For the purpose of illustrating the invention, there is shown in the drawings a form which is presently preferred; it being understood, however, that this invention is not limited to the precise arrangements and instrumentalities shown.





FIG. 1

is a diagrammatic representation of a prior art induction melting system that includes a furnace and power supply converter.





FIG. 2

is a cross sectional elevation view of a prior art induction coil of copper tubes around a crucible that has a conductive material inside of the crucible.





FIG. 3

is a cross sectional elevation view showing the distribution of current in an electrically conductive high resistance crucible used in the induction furnace of the present invention.




FIG.


4


(


a


) is a perspective view of a wound cable composed of twisted multiple copper conductors that is used in the induction furnace of the present invention.




FIG.


4


(


b


) is a cross sectional view of the wound cable shown in FIG.


4


(


a


).




FIG.


4


(


c


) is a cross sectional view of one of the insulated copper conductors that make up the wound cable.




FIG.


5


(


a


) is a cross sectional elevation view of an induction furnace of the present invention with a high electrical resistance crucible and an induction coil of the wound cable shown in FIG.


4


(


b


).




FIG.


5


(


b


) is a cross sectional detail of one embodiment of the isolation sleeve shown in FIG.


5


(


a


).




FIG.


5


(


c


) illustrates the airflow through the power supply and induction coil for the induction melting or heating systems of the present invention.





FIG. 6

is an electrical schematic of the power circuit for one embodiment of the induction melting or heating systems of the present invention.





FIG. 7

is a perspective view of an induction tunnel heating system of the present invention for heating a workpiece.





FIG. 8

is a perspective view of another induction tunnel heating system of the present invention for heating a workpiece.





FIG. 9

is a perspective view of an enclosed induction heating system of the present invention for heating a workpiece.





FIG. 10

is a perspective view of another enclosed induction heating system of the present invention for heating a workpiece.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




The efficiency of an induction furnace as expressed by equation (1) and equation (2) can be improved if the resistance of the load can be increased. The load resistance in furnaces melting highly conductive metals such as aluminum, magnesium or copper alloys, may be increased by coupling the electromagnetic field to the crucible instead of to the metal itself. The ceramic crucible may be replaced by a high temperature, electrically conductive material with high resistivity factor. Silicon carbide (SiC) is one of the materials that has these properties, namely a resistivity generally in the range of 10 to 10


4


ohm·meters. Silicon carbide compositions with resistivity in the approximate range of 3,000 to 4,000 ohm·meters are particularly applicable to the present invention. Alternatively, the crucible may be made from steel. For example, there are high permeability ferromagnetic steels with relative permeabilities in the range of 5,000. In this case, rather than relying on high resistivity, the high permeability will result in low depth of current penetration.

FIG. 3

shows the distribution of current


28


in the crucible


27


that will produce the effect of high total resistance. The best effect is achieved when the wall thickness of the crucible is about 1.3 to 1.5 times larger than the depth of current penetration into the crucible. In this case, the shunting effect of highly conductive molten metal


29


is minimized.




An additional improvement in the efficiency of an induction furnace can be achieved by reducing the resistance of the coil. High conductivity copper is widely used as the material for a coil winding. However, because of the high conductivity (low resistivity) of the copper, the current is concentrated in a thin layer of coil current


11


on the surface of the coil facing the load, as shown in FIG.


2


. The depth of current penetration is given by equation (2). Because the layer is so thin, especially at elevated frequencies, the effective coil resistance may be considerably higher than would be expected from the resistivity of copper and the total cross-sectional area of the copper coil. That will significantly affect the efficiency of the furnace. Instead of using a solid tubular conductor, one embodiment of the present invention uses a cable


17


wound of a large number of copper conductors isolated one from another, as shown in FIGS.


4


(


a


),


4


(


b


) and


4


(


c


). One of the insulated copper conductors


14


is shown in FIG.


4


(


c


) with the insulation


16


that isolates the copper conductor


15


from surrounding conductors. The cable


17


is of the sort known in the electronic industry as Litz wire or litzendraht. It assures equal current distribution through the copper cross section when the diameter of each individual copper wire strand is significantly smaller than the depth of current penetration Δ


1


as given by equation (2). For the present application, a suitable but not limiting number of strands is approximately between 1,000 and 2,000. Other variations in the configuration of the Litz wire will perform satisfactory without deviating from the present invention.




The proper selection of operating frequencies yields optimum efficiency of an induction furnace. The criteria for frequency selection are based on depth of current penetration in the high resistance crucible and copper coil. The two criteria are:




Δ


1


>>d


1


; and




Δ


2


≈1.2·d


2






where:




d


1


=diameter of a strand of Litz wire; and




d


2


=wall thickness of the crucible.




For example, when the copper strand diameter is d


1


=0.01 inch and the silicon carbide wall is d


2


=2.0 inches, the optimal frequency is 3,000 Hz. With this selection, the relative electrical losses in the coil may be reduced to about 2.2%, which is more than 15 times better than a standard induction furnace.




Acceptable, but not limiting, parameters for a furnace in accordance with the present invention is selecting d


1


in the range of 0.2 to 2.0 meters, d


2


in the range of 0.15 to 1.8 meters, and frequency in the range of 1,000 to 5,000 Hertz.




Such an increase in efficiency or reduction in coil losses, and thus reduction in heating of the coil, eliminates the need for a water-based cooling system. Instead, a reasonable airflow through the induction coil is sufficient to remove the heat generated by the coil. The furnace crucible should be well insulated from the coil to minimize thermal losses and heating of the copper winding due to thermal conduction.




Referring now to the drawings, wherein like numerals indicate like elements, there is shown in FIG.


5


(


a


) an embodiment of a high-efficiency induction melting system


33


in accordance with the present invention. The induction melting system


33


includes a high electrical resistance or high magnetic permeance crucible


30


containing metal charge


31


. The high resistance or high permeance is achieved by using a crucible made from a high resistivity material (ρ>2500 μΩ·cm) like silicon carbide or from a high permeability steel (μ>20), respectively. The selection of crucible material depends on the properties of the metals to be melted. For aluminum or copper alloys, silicon carbide is a better crucible material, while for magnesium or magnesium alloys, steel may be a better choice for the crucible material. The crucible


30


is heated by the magnetic field generated by current in the coil


32


, which is made with Litz wire. The hot crucible is insulated from the coil electrically and thermally by an isolation sleeve


34


. The isolation sleeve is constructed from a high strength composite ceramic material containing one or more inner layers


35


and outer layers


36


filled with air-bubbled ceramic


37


with good thermal insulation properties. The honeycomb structure of the isolation sleeve provides necessary strength and thermal isolation. The electrically insulating nature of the isolation sleeve, together with its low magnetic permeability, ensures that no appreciable inductive heating takes place in the isolation sleeve itself. That concentrates the heating in the crucible


30


, inside the thermal insulation of the isolation sleeve


34


, which both improves the efficiency of the induction melting system


33


and reduces heating of the coil


32


.




One embodiment of the invention includes a power converter


39


that converts a three-phase standard line voltage such as 220, 280 or 600 volts into a single phase voltage with a frequency in the range of 1,000 to 3,000 Hz. The power converter may include power semiconductor diodes


41


, silicon controlled rectifiers (SCR)


40


, capacitors


42


, inductors


43


and


46


, and control electronics. The schematic diagram of one implementation of the power converter is shown in FIG.


6


. In

FIG. 6

, diodes


41


in the rectifier bridge are optionally provided in dual-diode modules. Inductor


43


serves as a chock, and inductors


46


are di/dt reactors. SCRs


40


and associated anti-parallel diodes


41


are suitably connected to heat sinks. All of the semiconductor components of the power converter are air-cooled via heat exchangers


44


, such as heat sinks. Other inverter circuits and/or electromechanical systems can be used.




In one embodiment of the invention, the power converter


39


is mounted adjacent to the induction coil


32


. As shown in FIG.


5


(


a


) and FIG.


5


(


c


), an airflow


47


(as illustrated by arrows from an external blower


45


) is fed to the power converter where the cold air first cools the semiconductors' heat exchangers


44


, and then the capacitors, inductors and other passive components. The converter cabinet is positively pressurized to prevent dust and other particulate from entering the electronics compartments. The airflow exits through a slot


48


in the back wall of the power supply


39


and enters and flows through the coil chamber


38


to remove heat from the coil. In FIG.


5


(


c


), for clarity in illustrating the airflow


47


through the induction melting system, the induction melting system


33


is outlined in phantom.




In an alternative embodiment as shown in

FIG. 7

, a high-efficiency induction heating system


33




a


in accordance with the present invention, is in the form of a tunnel furnace through which multiple discrete workpieces, or a continuous workpiece


90


, such as a metal strip, wire or other object to be heated, can be run through the furnace by a mechanical conveying system (not shown in the drawing) in the direction indicated by the arrows. In this embodiment, the furnace tunnel crucible


30




a,


is surrounded by isolation sleeve


34




a.


Coil


32




a


is coiled around the exterior of isolation sleeve


34




a


and connected to a suitable power supply converter (not shown in FIG.


7


). Crucible


30




a,


isolation sleeve


34




a,


coil


32




a


and the power supply converter are similar to crucible


30


, isolation sleeve


34


, coil


32


, and power converter


39


disclosed in other examples of the invention. Ac current supplied from the power converter to the coil that comprises a cable wound of a plurality of conductors isolated from each other will generate a magnetic field that inductively heats the crucible. Heat generated in the crucible will conduct into the tunnel of the furnace and heat workpieces within the tunnel.





FIG. 8

illustrates an alternative embodiment of a high-efficiency induction heating system


33




b


of the present invention wherein the tunnel furnace utilizes a conveyor means


91


to move workpieces


94




a


and


94




b


through the crucible of the tunnel furnace. Not shown in

FIG. 8

within the enclosure of the tunnel furnace is crucible


30




a,


isolation sleeve


34




a


and coil


32




a,


which are generally arranged as illustrated in FIG.


7


. Optionally a power supply or converter, similar to power converter


39


, may be included in the enclosure of the tunnel furnace. The supply may, for example, be located in bottom section


93


of the enclosure. For this option, a forced airflow can be drawn into the bottom of the enclosure to first cool components of the power converter, and then directed upwards around the coil to cool the coil. The heated air exits the enclosure through openings


95


in its top.




In another alternative embodiment as shown in

FIG. 9

, a high-efficiency induction heating system


33




c


in accordance with the present invention, is in the form of an enclosed furnace in which one more discrete workpieces


94


can be heated. The crucible


30




a,


isolation sleeve


34




a


and coil


32




a


are similar to crucible


30


, isolation sleeve


34


and coil


32


disclosed in other examples of the invention. Furnace first end structure


92


is attached to crucible


30




a


to form the first closed end of the furnace's closed heating chamber. Furnace second end structure


98


is removably attached to the opposing end of crucible


30




a.


The first and second end structures


92


and


98


are composed of a thermal insulating material, such as but not limited to, the disclosed material for the isolation sleeve. Suitable support means


96


, such as a grating composed of a non-electrically conductive and high temperature withstand material, can be provided inside the heating chamber to support the workpieces. After insertion of the workpieces into the heating chamber, removably attached second end structure


98


is attached to the opposing end of crucible


30




a


to close the heating chamber. Ac current is supplied from a suitable source to coil


32




a.


The current generates a magnetic field in the coil that comprises a cable wound of a plurality of conductors isolated from each other that inductively heats crucible


30




a.


The heat generated in the crucible conducts into the enclosed heating chamber to heat workpiece


94


within the chamber.





FIG. 10

illustrates another arrangement of a high-efficiency induction heating system


33




d


of the present invention using a furnace with an enclosed heating chamber. Not shown in

FIG. 10

with the enclosure of the furnace is crucible


30




a,


isolation sleeve


34




a,


furnace first end structure


92


and coil


32




a,


which are generally arranged as illustrated in FIG.


9


. In the arrangement shown in

FIG. 10

, furnace second end structure


98




a


comprises a circular component that is attached by a hinged element to the enclosure. Optionally a power supply or converter, similar to power converter


39


, may be optionally included in the enclosure of the furnace. The supply may, for example, be located in bottom section


93




a


of the enclosure. For this option, a forced airflow can be drawn into the bottom of the enclosure to first cool components of the power converter, and then directed upwards around the coil to cool the coil. The heat exits the enclosure through openings


95




a


in its top.




The foregoing embodiments do not limit the scope of the disclosed invention. The scope of the disclosed invention is covered in the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. An induction furnace for heating a workpiece, comprising:a crucible forming a tunnel through which the workpiece travels, the crucible formed substantially from the group of materials consisting of silicon carbides, high resistivity steels and high permeability steels; an at least one induction coil comprising a cable wound of a plurality of conductors isolated from each other, the at least one induction coil surrounding the crucible; and an electrically and thermally insulating isolation sleeve of low magnetic permeance separating the crucible from the at least one induction coil.
  • 2. The induction furnace of claim 1 wherein the isolation sleeve comprises a composite ceramic material.
  • 3. The induction furnace of claim 2 wherein the composite ceramic material comprises an air-bubbled ceramic disposed between an at least one inner and an at least one outer layer of ceramic.
  • 4. The induction furnace of claim 1 further comprising a power supply for providing ac power of a selected frequency to the at least one induction coil wherein the depth of penetration into the crucible of a magnetic field generated by a current of the selected frequency in the at least one induction coil is in the range of from half the thickness to the thickness of the crucible.
  • 5. The induction furnace of claim 4 wherein the power supply is mounted adjacent to the at least one induction coil.
  • 6. The induction furnace of claim 5 wherein an air flow sequentially cools the components of the power supply and the at least one induction coil.
  • 7. The induction furnace of claim 1 further comprising a conveyance means for conveying the workpiece through the tunnel of the crucible.
  • 8. An induction furnace for heating a workpiece, comprising:a substantially enclosed tunnel shaped crucible having a selectably closeable opening whereby the workpiece can be inserted or removed from the crucible, the crucible formed substantially from the group of materials consisting of silicon carbides, high resistivity steels and high permeability steels; an at least one induction coil comprising a cable wound of a plurality of conductors isolated from each other, the at least one induction coil surrounding the crucible; and an electrically and thermally insulating isolation sleeve of low magnetic permeance separating the crucible from the at least one induction coil.
  • 9. The induction furnace of claim 8 wherein the isolation sleeve comprises a composite ceramic material.
  • 10. The induction furnace of claim 9 wherein the composite ceramic material comprises an air-bubbled ceramic disposed between an at least one inner and an at least one outer layer of ceramic.
  • 11. The induction furnace of claim 8 further comprising a conveyance means for moving the workpiece into and out of the crucible.
  • 12. The induction furnace of claim 8 further comprising a power supply for providing ac power of a selected frequency to the at least one induction coil wherein the depth of penetration into the crucible of a magnetic field generated by a current of the selected frequency in the at least one induction coil is in the range of from half the thickness to the thickness of the crucible.
  • 13. The induction furnace of claim 12 wherein the power supply is mounted adjacent to the at least one induction coil.
  • 14. The induction furnace of claim 13 wherein an air flow sequentially cools the components of the power supply and the at least one induction coil.
  • 15. A process for heating a metal workpiece comprising the steps of:feeding the metal workpiece through a tunnel formed from a crucible, the crucible substantially comprising a material of high electrical resistivity or high magnetic permeability; inductively heating the crucible by supplying a current to an at least one induction coil consisting of a cable wound of multiple conductors isolated from each other, the at least one induction coil surrounding the crucible and being electrically and thermally isolated from the crucible by an isolation sleeve; and adjusting the frequency of the current so that the depth of penetration into the crucible of the magnetic field generated by the current in the at least one induction coil is in the range of from half the thickness to the thickness of the crucible, whereby the metal is heated by the conduction of heat from the crucible to the metal.
  • 16. The process of claim 15 wherein the crucible is formed substantially from a silicon carbide or a high permeability steel.
  • 17. The process of claim 15 further comprising the steps of:providing an ac power supply adjacent to the at least one induction coil to provide the current to the at least one induction coil; and supplying an air flow sequentially through the power supply and the at least one induction coil to cool the components in the power supply and the at least one induction coil.
  • 18. A process for heating a metal comprising the steps of:placing the metal in a tunnel shaped crucible formed substantially from a material of high electrical resistivity or high magnetic permeability; inductively heating the crucible by supplying a current to an at least one induction coil consisting of a cable wound of multiple conductors isolated from each other, the at least one induction coil surrounding the crucible and being electrically and thermally isolated from the crucible by an isolation sleeve; and adjusting the frequency of the current so that the depth of penetration into the crucible of the magnetic field generated by the current in the at least one induction coil is in the range of from half the thickness to the thickness of the crucible, whereby the metal is heated by the conduction of heat from the crucible to the metal.
  • 19. The method of claim 18 wherein the crucible is formed substantially from a silicon carbide or a high permeability steel.
  • 20. The process of claim 18 further comprising the steps of:providing an ac power supply adjacent to the at least one induction coil to provide the current to the at least one induction coil; and supplying an air flow sequentially through the power supply and the at least one induction coil to cool the components in the power supply and the at least one induction coil.
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. application Ser. No. 09/550,305, filed Apr. 14, 2000, now U.S. Pat. No. 6,393,044, the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety, and which claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/165,304, filed Nov. 12, 1999.

US Referenced Citations (9)
Number Name Date Kind
1842272 Knerr Jan 1932 A
4618964 Larsson et al. Oct 1986 A
5416795 Kaniuk et al. May 1995 A
5469461 Andrea Nov 1995 A
5495495 Cullan Feb 1996 A
5768799 Delaunay et al. Jun 1998 A
5997802 Holcombe et al. Dec 1999 A
6393044 Fishman et al. May 2002 B1
6523598 Shaffer Feb 2003 B2
Foreign Referenced Citations (1)
Number Date Country
0744 222 Nov 1996 FR
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/165304 Nov 1999 US
Continuation in Parts (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 09/550305 Apr 2000 US
Child 10/135271 US