High-power piezoelectric ceramics

Abstract
The disclosed invention relates to piezoelectric rare earth doped Pb(Zr,Ti)O3—Pb(Mn,Sb)O3 compounds including (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3—(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z is ≦0.95, 0.40
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The invention relates to high power piezoelectric ceramics, more particularly, to piezoelectric ceramic compositions for use in ultrasonic motors, ultrasonic vibrators, piezoelectric actuators, and the like.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The art has explored the high-power characteristics of piezoelectric materials for use in devices such as ultrasonic motors, piezoelectric actuators and piezoelectric transformers. It is preferred in the art that the piezoelectric materials used in these types of devices have a high mechanical quality factor, low heat generation, a high piezoelectric constant, as well as high vibrational velocities (v


o


) when subjected to low AC electric fields. The art has found it difficult, however, to achieve a piezoelectric material which has both a high mechanical quality factor and a high piezoelectric constant, as well as high vibrational velocity.




It is known in the art that the v


0


in lead-zirconate-titanate (PZT) compounds which have the ABO


3


perovskite structure can be increased by introducing lower valent dopants such as Fe on the B-site, and that v


0


can be decreased by introducing higher valent dopants such as Nb on the B-site. The lower valent dopants tend to produce “hardening” effects on the base PZT type compounds by increasing the mechanical quality factor (Q


m


) while decreasing the electromechanical coupling factor (k). In contrast, higher valent substituents tend to decrease the Q


m


while increasing the (k) value.




It also is known in the art that the vibrational velocity (v


0


)of a piezoelectric material is restricted by heat generation within the piezoelectric material when subjected to an electric field (E


ac


). Heat generation under an electric field is known to be a function of vibrational velocity (v


o


). The value of v


o


is directly proportional to Q


m


and to the electromechanical coupling factor (k) under constant E


ac


. Development of a piezoelectric material with significantly higher v


o


, however, has not been successful in the art since each of Q


m


and k are increased at the expense of the other.




A need therefore exists for a piezoelectric material which has both increased Q


m


and increased k values, as well as increased vibrational velocity for high-power applications.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




This invention relates to piezoelectric compositions for manufacture of rare earth (“RE”) doped Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


compounds which have increased vibrational velocity as well as increased Q


m


and (k) values. The invention further relates to piezoelectric compounds corresponding to the formula (zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


—(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+RE


x


) where z is ≦0.95, preferably about 0.90, 0.4≦w≦0.6, preferably 0.50≦w≦0.54, more preferably about 0.52, and where RE is a rare earth cation dopant, and 0<x<5%, preferably 0<x<2%.




The RE dopants employed advantageously generate both “hardening” and “softening” effects in the doped Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


compounds. Examples of RE dopants which may be employed include Eu


+3


, Yb


+3


, Ce


3+


, Er


3+


, Tm


3+


, Ho


3+


and Dy


3+


, and mixtures thereof, preferably Eu


+3


, and Yb


+3


, most preferably Yb


+3


. The Eu and Yb dopants advantageously produce both “hardening” and “softening” effects in Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


compounds such as 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


. Doping of 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


with any of Eu and Yb produces increased Q


m


, d


31


, and k


31


relative to undoped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


. Under high E


ac


conditions, Eu and Yb doping of Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


type compounds such as 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


advantageously produces an increased v


0


relative to undoped 0.90 Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


. These doped compounds include compounds of formula (zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


−(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+RE


x


) where z is 0.90, w is 0.52, RE is Yb and x is about 0.1 to about 0.3%. Advantageously, Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


type compounds such as 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)O


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


, when doped with about 0.1 to about 2.0 wt. % Yb, preferably about 0.1% to about 0.2% Yb, produces a high-power piezoelectric material.




In another aspect, the invention relates to piezoelectric devices such as ultrasonic motors, ultrasonic vibrators, and piezoelectric actuators which include a piezoelectric ceramic compound represented by formula (zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


−(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+RE


x


) where z≦0.95, preferably about 0.90, 0.4≦w≦0.6, preferably 0.50≦w≦0.54, more preferably about 0.52, RE is a rare earth cation such as Yb, Eu and Ce, and 0<x<5%, preferably 0<x<2%.




In yet another aspect, the invention relates to piezoelectric ceramic compounds represented by formula (zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


−(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+RE


x


) where z is 0.9, w is 0.52, RE is a rare earth cation selected from the group consisting of Eu, Lu, Nd and La and x is 0.1%.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




In the present invention, rare earth doped, piezoelectric compounds are produced. The compounds correspond to the formula (zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


−(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+RE


x


) where z is ≦0.95, preferably about 0.90, 0.4≦w≦0.6, preferably 0.50≦w≦0.54, more preferably about 0.52, RE is a rare earth cation dopant, and 0<x<5%, preferably 0<x<2.0%, and even more preferably x is about 0.1% to about 0.5%. These compounds are made by reaction of 98% or higher purity, preferably 99% or higher, oxides of ZrO


2


, TiO


2


, MnO, Sb


2


O


5


and a RE oxide. The RE oxide has a purity of 98% or higher. The high purity oxides employed, including the RE dopant oxides, are available from, such as, Alfa Aesar Co., Ward Hill, Mass. (USA)




The ionic radii of the RE cations of the RE oxides which may be employed are shown in Table 1:












TABLE 1











Ionic Radii














RE Cation




Ionic Radius (Angstrom)


















Ce


3+






1.034







Eu


3+






0.947







Yb


3+






.0858







Tm


3+






0.869







Er


3+






0.881







Ho


3+






0.901







Dy


3+






0.912







Nd


3+






0.995







Lu


3+






0.848







La


3+






1.061















In manufacture of the RE doped compounds, starting materials in the form of oxides, or precursors thereof such as carbonates and oxalates are employed. The amounts of the starting materials are sufficient to produce a base compound corresponding to the formula zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


−(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


, where z is ≦0.95, preferably about 0.90, 0.4≦w≦0.6, preferably 0.50≦w≦0.54, more preferably about 0.52. A RE dopant in the form of an oxide or precursor thereof is added to these starting materials in an amount sufficient to produce a doped compound corresponding to the formula (zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


−(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+RE


x


) where z is ≦0.95, preferably about 0.90, 0.4≦w≦0.6, preferably 0.50≦w≦0.54, more preferably about 0.52, RE is a rare earth cation dopant, and 0<x<5%, more preferably 0<x<2%, even more preferably x is about 0.1% to about 0.5%. The resulting blend of starting materials and dopant is mixed with a liquid such water or alcohol to form a slurry. Examples of suitable alcohols include but are not limited to C1-C4 alcohols, preferably anhydrous ethyl alcohol. The slurry is milled by ball milling or vibratory milling, preferably vibratory milling, for a time sufficient, typically about 48 hours, to achieve a uniform mixture. The mixture then is sieved to about −80 mesh to about −200 mesh, calcined, and then mixed with a liquid such as water or alcohol to form a slurry that is milled again. The resulting milled material then is dried, sieved to about −80 mesh, preferably about −200 mesh, and mixed with an organic binder to form a material. Useful organic binders include, but are not limited to, acryloid resins, and polyvinyl alcohol, preferably acryloid resins. The resulting material is isostatically cold pressed at about 3000 kg/cm


2


to about 3500 kg/cm


2


to produce a preform such as rectangular bar. The preform then is sintered to produce the final piezoelectric compound.




The invention is further illustrated below by reference to the following non-limiting examples. In the examples below, the amount of RE dopant is based on the weight of the base compound zPb(Zr


w


Ti


(1−w)


)O


3


−(1−z)Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


.




EXAMPLE 1




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Yb


3+


)




35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure), 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure) are employed as starting materials. These starting materials are milled with 0.06 grams Yb


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powder is ground, and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder)of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a material. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)0


3


+0.1% Yb


3+


)




EXAMPLE 2




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.2% Yb


3+


)




The procedure of example 1 is performed except that 0.0899 grams Yb


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) is used. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.2% Yb


3+


)




EXAMPLE 3




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.3% Yb


3+


)




The procedure of example 1 is performed except that 0.18 grams Yb


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) is used. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0 52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.3% Yb


3+


)




EXAMPLE 4




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.5% Yb


3+


)




The procedure of example 1 is performed except that 0.3 grams Yb


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) is used. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.5% Yb


3+


)




EXAMPLE 5




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Eu


3+


)




35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure),and 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure). These starting materials are milled with 0.0536 grams Eu


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is sieved to −200 mesh and calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled. The resulting doped compound corresponds is a solid solution that to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Eu


3+


).




EXAMPLE 6




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.3% Eu


3+


)




The procedure of example 5 is performed except that 0.161 grams Eu


2


O


3


(99.9%) is used. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.3% Eu


3+


).




EXAMPLE 7




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.5% Eu


3+


)




The procedure of example 5 is performed except that 0.267 grams Eu


2


O


3


(99.9%) is used. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3




+0.5% Eu




3+


).




EXAMPLE 8




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Ce


3+


)




35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO (99% pure), 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure). These starting materials are milled with 0.05 grams CeO


2


(99.9% pure) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is sieved to −200 mesh and calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Ce


3+


).




EXAMPLE 9




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.3% Ce


3+


)




The procedure of example 7 is performed except that 0.15 grams CeO


2


is used. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.3% Ce


3+


).




EXAMPLE 10




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.5% Ce


3+


)




The procedure of example 7 is performed except that 0.25 grams CeO


2


is used. The resulting doped compound is a solid solution that corresponds to the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.5% Ce


3+


).




EXAMPLE 11




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% La


3+


)




35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure),and 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure) are employed as starting materials. These starting materials are milled with 0.0496 grams La


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is sieved to −200 mesh and calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled. The resulting doped compound corresponds to a solid solution of the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% La


3+


).




EXAMPLE 12




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Nd


3+


)




5.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure),and 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure) are employed as starting materials. These starting materials are milled with 0.0512 grams Nd


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is sieved to −200 mesh and calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled. The resulting doped compound corresponds to a solid solution of the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Nd


3+


).




EXAMPLE 13




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Lu


3+


)




35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure), and 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure) are employed as starting materials. These starting materials are milled with 0.0606 grams Lu


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is sieved to −200 mesh and calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled. The resulting doped compound corresponds to a solid solution of the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Lu


3+


)




EXAMPLE 14




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Er


3+


)




35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure), and 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure) are employed as starting materials. These starting materials are milled with 0.0582 grams Er


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is sieved to −200 mesh and calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled. The resulting doped compound corresponds to a solid solution of the formula (0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)0


3


+0.1% Er


3+


)




In another aspect of the invention, mixtures of dopants are used. This aspect of the invention is illustrated by the following non-limiting example.




EXAMPLE 15




(0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


+0.1% Yb


3+


and 0.1% Eu


3+)






A mixture of 35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure), 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure). These starting materials are milled with 0.0449 g Yb


2


O


3


(99.9% pure) and 0.0402 g Eu


2


O


3


(99.9%) in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is sieved to −200 mesh and calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting material is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1210° C., maintained at 1210° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled.




COMPARISON EXAMPLE




Undoped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3






35.30 grams Pb


3


O


4


(99% pure), 8.915 grams ZrO


2


(99% pure), 5.248 grams TiO


2


(99.5% pure), 0.363 grams MnO(99% pure) and 1.642 grams Sb


2


O


5


(99.99% pure) are wet milled in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in a SWECO vibratory mill for 48 hrs. The resulting mixture is calcined at 800° C. for 4.5 hrs. The calcined powders are ground and wet milled again in anhydrous ethyl alcohol in the SWECO mill for 48 hours. The resulting milled powder then is dried, sieved to −200 mesh and mixed with 3 wt. % (based on the weight of the milled powder) of acryloid resin from Rohm and Hass Co. to form a mixture. The resulting mixture is cold isostatic pressed at 3000 kg/cm


2


for 10 minutes to produce a preform in the shape of a rectangular bar. The preform then is heated in flowing air at 0.5° C./min to 300° C. and held at 300° C. for 4 hr. The preform then is heated at 2.5° C./min from 300° C. to 550° C., and held at 550° C. for 4 hrs. The preform then is cooled to room temperature. The preform then is heated at 5° C./min to 1230° C., maintained at 1230° C. for 2 hrs, and furnace cooled.




Property Measurement




The sintered samples produced in examples 1-9, as well as in the comparison example, are cut into rectangular plates of dimensions 42 mm×7 mm×1 mm. Gold electrodes are sputtered onto the top and bottom surfaces of the plates. The plates then are poled at 2.5 kV/mm for 15 min at 130° C. in silicon oil. Electrical measurements are performed at 36 hrs after poling. Curie Temperature (T


c


) is determined by measuring dielectric response as function of temperature and frequency. The measurements are made while cooling at a rate of 2° C./min by using a HP 4275 A LCR meter.




The piezoelectric properties are determined by impedance spectra under a low-level constant-voltage using a HP4194 impedance analyzer according to IEEE standard on Piezoelectricity (American National Standard, STD 176/1987). By measuring resonance and antiresonance frequencies and other parameters, piezoelectric properties such as d


31


and k


31


are calculated by known techniques according to this standard.




The piezoelectric properties also are determined by impedance spectra under various vibration velocities using a constant current method using laser Doppler vibrometer (LDV) models OFV-3001 and OFV-511 from Polytec PI Corp. This constant current method is described by Uchino et al. in the Journal of Electroceramics 2:1, 33-40, 1998. As described therein, this method entails measuring admittance (Y) as a function of frequency to obtain an admittance curve under a constant current. This constant current method of measurement achieves a completely symmetrical impedance peak at high vibrational driving condition. The v


o


is read directly read from the laser Doppler vibrometer.




X-ray diffraction patterns of 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


doped with 0.1, 0.3, 0.5 wt. % Eu, and with 0.1, 0.3, 0.5 wt. % Yb have a single phase perovskite structure. The piezoelectric properties of doped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)O


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


, as well as of undoped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


, are shown in table 2.












TABLE 2











Piezoelectric properties of doped






0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


-0.10Pb(Mn





Sb





)O


3



























Elastic






Amount & type




Density







|d


31


|





Compliance






of dopant wt. %




(10


3


kg/m


3


)




Q


m






K




k


31






(pC/N)




Tc




(10


−12


(m


2


/N))









Undoped




7.38




1150




660




0.19




44




290




8.8






0.1 Eu




8.40









608




0.24




50




262




8.1






0.3 Eu




8.08




1210




578




0.23




48




265




8.7






0.5 Eu




8.02




1340




565




0.24




51




263




8.8






0.1 Yb




8.20




1250




610




0.23




50




255




8.5






0.2 Yb




8.35




1386




509




0.28




57









9.0






0.3 Yb




7.85




1350




490




0.27




53




250




8.8






0.5 Yb




7.70




1330




550




0.26




53




248




9.2






0.1 La




7.62




1484




653




0.22




53









9.8






0.1 Nd




7.93




1437




624




0.22




52









9.6






0.1 Lu




8.17




1608




566




0.25




53









8.8






0.1 Er




8.20




1293




490




0.28




56





8.8














As shown in Table 2, K decreased with increasing amounts of Eu and Yb dopants. Table 2 also shows that the Q


m


of Eu doped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


increased from 1150 to 1340 as the amount of Eu dopant increased from 0% to 0.5%. As the amount of Eu dopant increased from 0 to 0.3 wt. %, k


31


increased by 17%, and the absolute value of d


31


increased from 44 pC/N to 51 pC/N. The Curie Temperature (T


c


)decreased from 290° C. to 263° C. at 0.5 wt. % Eu. In addition, upon Eu doping, the elastic constant decreased, and then increased to 8.8×10


−12


m


2


/N at 0.5 wt. % Eu.




As also shown in Table 2, the Q


m


of Yb doped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


increased from 1150 to 1350 as the amount of Yb dopant increased from 0% to 0.3%; k


31


increased by 39% at 0.3 wt. % Yb, and the absolute value of d


31


increased from 44 to 53 pC/N at 0.3 wt. % upon Yb dopant. The Curie Temperature decreased from 290° C. to 250° C. at 0.3 wt. % Yb, and the elastic constant decreased, and then increased to 9.2×10


−12


m


2


/N at 0.5 wt. % Yb.




The increased values of Q


m


, together with the decreased values of K, show that Eu and Yb dopants generate “hardening” effects in Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


compounds such as 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


. In addition, the increased values of k


31


together with the increased absolute values of d


31


show the “softening” effects generated by use of Eu and Yb dopants on Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


compounds such as 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


.




The results in Table 2 show that Eu


3+


and Yb


3+


dopants generate a combination of “hardening” and “softening” doping effects on Pb(Zr,Ti)O


3


—Pb(Mn,Sb)O


3


compounds such as 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


.




As is known in the art, for a rectangular sample driven by an electric field under the d


31


mode, where both longitudinal ends of the sample are mechanically free, v


o


is proportional to the product k


31


Q


m


. In order to have a maximum v


o


, both Q


m


and k


31


should be maximized. However, simultaneous achievement of maximum values of Q


m


and k


31


is contrary to conventional prior art concepts of “hardening” and “softening” piezoelectric characteristics. Advantageously, however, the present invention produces such a combination of “hard” and “soft” piezoelectric characteristics.




Table 3 shows vibrational velocity (v


o


) as a function of electric field (E


ac


, rms) and dopant on 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


.












TABLE 3











Vo as function of (E


ac


, rms) and






dopant in 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


-0.10Pb(Mn





Sb





)O


3





























Dopant/






















Eac/Vo




v


o




1






E


ac




2






v


o




1






E


ac




2






v


o




1






E


ac




2






v


o




1






E


ac




2






v


o




1






E


ac




2






v


o




1






E


ac




2






v


o




1






E


ac




2






v


o




1






E


ac




2
































Undoped




0.04




0.7




0.2




2.2




0.38




3.6




0.38




4.1




0.57




5.2




0.58




6.0




0.60




7.0




0.62




10.0






0.1% Yb




0.2




0.7




0.58




2.2




0.71




3.6




0.78




4.1




0.92




5.2




0.96




6.0




1.0




7.0




1.00




10.0






0.2% Yb




0.07




3.4




0.06




6.84







































20.0




0.92









1.00




10.0






0.3% Yb




0.18




0.7




0.60




2.2




0.66




3.6




0.78




4.1




0.84




5.2




0.92




6.0




0.84




7.0




0.90




10.0






0.5% Yb




0.18




0.7




0.57




2.2




0.61




3.6




0.68




4.1




0.69




5.2




0.70




6.0




0.68




7.0




0.82




10.0






0.3% Eu




0.42




1.8




0.58




3.0




0.61




3.6




078




4.6




0.78




6.0




0.90




8.3




0.94




9.6
















0.5% Eu




0.30




1.8




0.44




3.0




0.54




3.6




0.60




4.6




0.64




6.0




0.78




8.3




0.79




9.6
















0.1% La




0.31




0.93




0.51




1.6




0.62




2.1




0.66




3.2




0.74




4.1




0.78




5.3




0.84




6.8
















0.1% Nd




0.2




0.66




0.51




1.9




0.66




2.9




0.73




3.4




0.81




3.8




0.90




5.0


























0.1% Lu




0.21




0.66




0.30




0.91




0.55




1.8




0.64




2.4




0.68




3.3




0.75




4.1




0.81




5.3




0.85




8.3






0.1% Er




0.19




0.66




0.38




1.5




0.49




2.3




0.55




3.1




0.61




4.0




0.83




5.0

































1


(m/s, rms)












2


(kV/m, rms)













As shown in Table 3, at E


ac


=10.0 kV/m (rms), v


o


is 1.0 m/s (rms) for 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


doped with 0.1 wt. % Yb to 0.2 wt. % Yb. As the amount of Yb dopant increased, v


0


decreased slightly but remained significantly higher than that of the undoped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


that has a v


o


of 0.60 m/s rms) at E


ac


=7 kV/m (rms).). In addition, by introducing Eu dopant, the v


0


of 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


also increased. The v


0


of 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


doped with 0.3 wt. % Eu is 0.94 m/s at E=9.6 kV/m (rms value).




Another important property of high power piezoelectric materials is heat generation (ΔT). A high-power piezoelectric material desirably has a high v


0


and low ΔT. Achievement of high v


0


and low ΔT, however, has been a problem in the art because ΔT is proportional to v


0




2


.




Table 4 shows v


0


as a function of ΔT. Heat generation is measured by a thermocouple placed at the nodal point of the vibrating sample.












TABLE 4











(Vo, rms) and T(° C.) as function of dopant in






0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


-0.10Pb(Mn





Sb





)O


3



























Dopant




Vo


1






T




Vo


1






T




Vo


1






T




Vo


1






T




Vo


1






T




Vo


1






T




Vo


1






T




























Undoped




0.2




2.0




0.38




4.8




0.57




8.0




0.62




20




0.65




25


























0.1% Yb




0.2




0.5




0.38




2.0




0.57




4.0




0.65




5.0




0.77




8.0




0.93




0.9




1.0




20






0.2% Yb




0.7




0.3




0.86




19




1.0




40.














































0.3% Yb




0.52




2.0




0.6




2.2




0.65




2.5




0.77




4.5




0.82




6.0




0.90




10




0.92




20






0.5% Yb




0.2




0.5




0.38




1




0.6




3.0




0.77




9.0




0.82




10




0.86




12




0.88




20






0.3% Eu




0.32




0.5




0.54




1.5




0.61




2.0




0.76




5




0.9




20


























0.5% Eu




0.32




2




0.43




6




0.52




7.5




0.62




12




0.73




18


























0.1% Ce
































































0.74




20






0.3% Ce
































































0.79




20






0.5% Ce
































































0.63




20






0.1% La




0.30




1.5




0.50




5




0.62




7.5




0.66




12




0.74




19.5




0.78




23
















0.1% Nd




0.20




1




0.51




5




0.66




9




0.73




14




0.81




16




0.9




20
















0.1% Lu




0.21




0.5




0.55




3.5




0.64




6




0.68




8




0.81




16.5




0.84




21.5
















0.1% Er




0.19




0.5




0.38




2.5




0.49




5




0.55




7.5




0.61




10




0.83




23
























Table 4 shows that the maximum vibrational velocity, v


0


(ΔT=20° C.) is 0.62 m/s for undoped 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


. The 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


compound doped with 0.3 wt. % Eu produces a v


0


(ΔT=20° C.) of 0.9 m/s. Doping of 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)0


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)O


3


with 0.1 wt. % Yb produces a v


0


(ΔT=20° C.) of 1.0 m/s. In addition, doping of 0.90Pb(Zr


0.52


Ti


0.48


)O


3


−0.10Pb(Mn


1/3


Sb


2/3


)0


3


with 0.2 wt. % Yb produces a v


0


(ΔT=40° C.) of 1.0 m/s.



Claims
  • 1. A piezoelectric compound consisting essentially of (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z≦0.95, 0.40≦w ≦0.60, and where RE is a rare earth cation selected from the group consisting of Eu, Yb, Ce, La, Er, Nd, Lu, Tm, Ho and Dy and 0<x<5.0%.
  • 2. The piezoelectric compound of claim 1 where z is 0.9, 0.5<w<0.54 and 0<x<2.0%.
  • 3. The piezoelectric compound of claim 2 where w is about 0.52.
  • 4. A piezoelectric compound consisting essentially of (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z is about 0.90, w is about 0.52, RE is Yb and x is 0.1 to 0.5%.
  • 5. The piezoelectric compound of claim 4 wherein x is 0.1 to 0.3%.
  • 6. A piezoelectric compound consisting essentially of (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z is about 0.90, w is about 0.52, wherein RE is Eu and x is about 0.1 to 2%.
  • 7. The piezoelectric compound of claim 6 wherein x is about 0.1% to about 0.5%.
  • 8. A composition consisting essentially of Pb3O4, ZrO2, TiO2, MnO, and Sb2O5 and a rare earth dopant oxide in amounts sufficient to produce a piezoelectric compound corresponding to the formula (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z≦0.95, 0.50<w<0.54, RE is a rare earth cation dopant selected from the group consisting of Yb, Eu, La, Nd, Er, Lu and Ce, and 0<x<5.0%.
  • 9. A composition consisting essentially of Pb3O4, ZrO2, TiO2, MnO, and Sb2O5 and a rare earth dopant oxide in amounts sufficient to produce a piezoelectric compound corresponding to the formula (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z is about 0.90, w is 0.52, and RE is a rare earth cation dopant selected from the group consisting of Yb and Eu, and 0≦x≦0.5%.
  • 10. The composition of claim 9 wherein 0<x<2%.
  • 11. A piezoelectric device consisting essentially of a piezoelectric ceramic compound represented by formula (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z≦0.95, w is about 0.52, RE is a rare earth cation selected from the group consisting of Yb, Eu, La, Nd, Er, Lu and Ce, and 0≦x≦5.0%.
  • 12. The composition of claim 11 wherein 0<x<2%.
  • 13. The piezoelectric device of claim 12 where z is about 0.90.
  • 14. The piezoelectric device of claim 13 where w is about 0.52, RE is Yb and x is 0.1 to 0.5%.
  • 15. The piezoelectric device of claim 14 where x is about 0.1% to about 0.3%.
  • 16. The piezoelectric device of claim 13 where w is 0.52, RE is Eu and x is about 0.1 to about 0.5%.
  • 17. The piezoelectric device of claim 16 where x is about 0.1 to about 0.3%.
  • 18. A piezoelectric ceramic compound consisting essentially of (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+(Ybx+Eux)) where z is 0.9, w is 0.52, and x is 0.1%.
  • 19. A piezoelectric ceramic compound consisting essentially of (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z is 0.9, w is 0.52, RE is a rare earth cation selected from the group consisting of Er, Lu, Nd and La and x is 0.1%.
  • 20. The piezoelectric ceramic compound of claim 19 wherein RE is Er.
  • 21. The piezoelectric ceramic compound of claim 19 wherein RE is Lu.
  • 22. The piezoelectric ceramic compound of claim 19 wherein RE is Nd.
  • 23. The piezoelectric ceramic compound of claim 19 wherein RE is La.
  • 24. A composition consisting essentially of Pb3O4, ZrO2, TiO2, MnO, and Sb2O3 and a rare earth dopant oxide in amounts sufficient to produce a piezoelectric compound corresponding to the formula (zPb(ZrwTi(1−w))O3−(1−z)Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3+REx) where z is about 0.90, w is about 0.52, and RE is a rare earth cation dopant selected from the group consisting of Yb and Eu, and 0≦x≦0.2%.
Parent Case Info

This application in a continuation in part of International Patent Application PCT/US01/47950, filed Dec. 13, 2001, which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 60/255,579, filed Dec. 14, 2000.

FEDERALLY SPONSORED RESEARCH

This work was supported by the Office of Naval Research through Contact No.: N00014-99-J-0754.

US Referenced Citations (4)
Number Name Date Kind
3645974 Ichinose et al. Feb 1972 A
5607614 Kawano et al. Mar 1997 A
5759433 Sasaki et al. Jun 1998 A
6123867 Takahishi et al. Sep 2000 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (2)
Number Date Country
11-349379 Dec 1999 JP
WO 0249122 Jun 2002 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (17)
Entry
Chen et al, Mn-Modified Pb(Mg1/3Nb2/3)O3-PbTiO3 Ceramics: Improved Mechanical Quality Factors for High-Power Transducer Applications, JPN. J. Appl. Phys., pp. 4843-4852, Aug. 2000.
Hagimura et al, Impurity Doping Effect on Electric Filed Induced Strains in (Pb, Ba)(Zr, Ti)O3, Proc. Int'l Symp. Appl. Ferroelectrics (1991), pp. 185-188.
Imry et al, Random-field Instability of the Ordered State of Continuous Symmetry, Physical review Letters, vol. 35, No. 21, ppp. 1399-1401 (1975).
Kuwata et al., Phase transitions in the Pb(Zn1/3Nb2/3)O3-PbTiO3 system, Ferroelectrics, 1981, vol. 37, pp. 579-582.
Park et al, Ultrahigh Strain and Piezoelectric behavior in Relaxor Based Ferroelectric Single Crystals, J. Appl. Phys., Aug. 15, 1997.
Tan et al, Ferroelectric Behaviors Dominated by Mobile and Randomly Quenched Impurities in Modified Lead Zirconate Titanate Ceramics, Philosophical Magazine B, 1997, vo. 76, pp. 59-74.
Takahashi et al, JPN. J. Appl. Phys., vol. 32 (1993), pp. 2422-2425.
Takahashi et al, Electro-mechanical Properties of PbZrO3-PbTiO3-Pb(Mn1/3Sb2/3)O3 Ceramics under Vibration-level Change, Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. vol. 360 1995, pp. 305-310.
Takahashi et al, JPN. J. Appl. Phys., vol. 31 (1993), pp. 3055-3057.
Uchino et al, Drive Voltage Dependence of Electromechanical Resonance in PLZT Piezoelectric Ceramics, Jap. J. Appl. Phys., pp. 47-49, 1989.
Uchino: Piezoelectric actuators and Ultrasonic Motors, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Norwell, MA (1996), pp. 167-172.
Uchino, Ferroelectric Devices, marcel deker, NY (2000), pp. 64-66.
Uchino et al, High Power Characterization of Piezoelectric Materials 2:1, J. Electroceramics, 1998, pp. 33-40.
Viehland, Symmetry-adaptive Ferroelectric Mesostates in Oriented Pb(BI1//3BII2/3)O3-PbTiO3 crystals, J. Appl. Physics, Oct. 15, 2000.
Viehland et al, Random-Field model of Ferroelectric domain dynamics and polarization reversal, J. Appl. Physics, Dec. 1, 2000, pp. 6696-6707.
Jaffe et al, Piezoelectric Ceramics, pp. 100-106 (1971).
Wu et al, Effect of Rare earth oxide on the properties of piezoelectric ceramics, Ferroelectrics, 1982, vol. 41, pp. 157-162.
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/255579 Dec 2000 US
Continuation in Parts (1)
Number Date Country
Parent PCT/US01/47950 Dec 2001 US
Child 10/124619 US