The present invention relates to an ion source device for generating ions from a sample and a mass spectrometer using the ion source device.
An atmospheric pressure ionization mass spectrometer analyzes the mass of ions by introducing ions generated at atmospheric pressure into a vacuum system. Among atmospheric pressure ionization methods that are widely used are electrospray ionization (ESI) and atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI).
In ESI, a sample solution is flowed through a sample spray nozzle (i.e., capillary) to which a high voltage is applied, so as to be sprayed and form charged droplets, and then, the charged droplets repeatedly undergo evaporation and fission to generate ions. In ESI, a method is also used that includes coaxially arranging a nebulizer gas nozzle around the outer circumference of the sample spray nozzle so that finer charged droplets are sprayed with blowing of nebulizer gas. When the liquid flow rate is high, in particular, a method of spraying a large amount of heated gas (i.e., heating gas) to promote evaporation and vaporization of the droplets is also used in combination. ESI is an ionization method that can be applied to a high-molecular-weight sample with a high molecular weight, a highly polar sample with high polarity, and the like.
APCI is a method of ionizing sample molecules, which have been obtained by heating and vaporizing a sample solution, using corona discharge. In this method, electric charges move between the sample molecules and the primary ions generated by the corona discharge so that the sample molecules are ionized. APCI can be applied to even a low-molecular-weight sample with a lower molecular weight than that in ESI or a low polarity sample with lower polarity than that in ESI.
Therefore, it is necessary to selectively use the ionization methods depending on samples to be analyzed. For such reasons, if a plurality of ionization methods (i.e., ESI and APCI) that are based on different ionization principles can be implemented using a single ion source, it becomes possible to expand the range of substances to be measured.
Patent Literature 1 describes a method of switching between two ionization methods, specifically, a method of switching an ionization method from ESI to APCI or vice versa by manually switching a probe from an ESI probe to an APCI probe or vice versa.
Patent Literature 2 and Patent Literature 3 each propose a method of executing ESI and APCI using an ion source with the same configuration without switching a probe or the like. An electrostatic spray portion of ESI and a needle electrode of APCI are arranged in the same space, and ESI ionization and APCI ionization are executed concurrently.
Patent Literature 4 describes a configuration in which an atomization chamber that is movable in the axial direction of an ionization probe (i.e., needle) is provided, and an ionization method is switched by moving the atomization chamber between ESI and APCI. The needle and the atomization chamber are moved by a movement mechanism so that an end of the needle is arranged such that it protrudes forward beyond the atomization chamber in ESI and is arranged within the atomization chamber in APCI. With this method, the ionization method can be easily switched in a short time.
Patent Literature 1: U.S. Pat. No. 6,759,650 B2
Patent Literature 2: JP 4553011 B2
Patent Literature 3: U.S. Pat. No. 7,488,953 B2
Patent Literature 4: JP H08-236064 A
In Patent Literature 1, switching an ionization method takes time and involves complex operations as a probe is manually switched from an ESI ionization probe to an APCI ionization probe or vice versa. In addition, as an operation of turning on or off a heater is needed, it takes tens of minutes to stabilize the temperature by increasing or lowering the temperature.
In the examples described in Patent Literature 2 and Patent Literature 3, ESI ionization and APCI ionization are performed concurrently. Thus, it is, in principle, possible to measure ions that have been generated by either method. However, as the two types of ionization are performed concurrently, a problem occurs in that sensitivity decreases.
In Patent Literature 4, a heater of the atomization chamber should be turned on or off when an ionization method is switched. Thus, there is a problem in that a waiting time is generated. That is, as the heater is turned off in ESI and is turned on in APCI, it is predicted that at least several minutes to tens of minutes would be required to stabilize the temperature of the heater. Thus, a high throughput analysis is difficult to perform.
Herein, suppose a case where the heater of the atomization chamber is always set off or on regardless of the ionization methods in Patent Literature 4. In such a case, as a waiting time for stabilizing the temperature is not needed, the ionization method can be switched at fast speed. However, the following problems are concerned. If the heater is always off, it is predicted that an operation is performed without any problem in ESI; however, if the heater is off in APCI, there will be almost no vaporization effect in the atomization chamber. Thus, it is predicted that a significant decrease in the sensitivity occurs. Next, if the heater is always on, the atomization chamber is heated in ESI. Thus, a liquid sample undergoes bumping (i.e., boiling) and electrospray does not go well. Thus, problems occur in that sensitivity decreases, or ionization becomes unstable and ionization intensity fluctuates.
As described above, the conventional techniques have problems in that sensitivity decreases or switching of ionization takes a long time.
The present invention provides a hybrid ion source with high sensitivity that can easily switch between a plurality of ionization methods in a short time, and a mass spectrometric device that uses the ion source.
An ion source of the present invention includes an ionization probe for spraying a sample; a heating chamber having an internal sample flow path, the heating chamber being adapted to heat and vaporize a sample that flows through the sample flow path; and a driving portion for changing a distance between an outlet end of the ionization probe and an inlet end of the heating chamber. The distance between the ionization probe and the heating chamber is changed by the driving portion to individually execute a plurality of ionization methods.
The plurality of ionization methods include ESI and APCI or include ESI and APPI.
The driving portion may drive at least one of the ionization probe or the heating chamber either linearly or by rotating it about a fixed point.
A mass spectrometric device of the present invention includes an ion source adapted to ionize a sample; a mass spectrometer having an ion inlet port into which sample ions obtained through ionization by the ion source are introduced, the mass spectrometer being adapted to analyze a mass of the ions introduced from the ion inlet port; and a control unit. The ion source includes an ionization probe for spraying a sample, a heating chamber having an internal sample flow path, the heating chamber being adapted to heat and vaporize a sample that flows through the sample flow path, and a driving portion for changing a distance between an outlet end of the ionization probe and an inlet end of the heating chamber. The driving portion is controlled by the control unit to change a position relationship of the ionization probe and/or the heating chamber with respect to the ion inlet port of the mass spectrometer, thereby individually executing a plurality of ionization methods.
The control unit is adapted to control the driving portion so that a sample ionization region of an ionization method that uses the ionization probe, or a sample ionization region of an ionization method that uses the ionization probe and the heating chamber are positioned near the ion inlet port of the mass spectrometer.
As specific examples, the plurality of ionization methods include ESI and APCI or include ESI and APPI. The control unit is adapted to, in the ESI mode, control the driving portion so that the heating chamber is not arranged between the outlet end of the ionization probe and the ion inlet port of the mass spectrometer, and to, in the APCI mode or the APPI mode, control the driving portion so that the heating chamber is arranged between the outlet end of the ionization probe and the ion inlet port of the mass spectrometer.
According to the present invention, it is possible to always maintain the temperature constant without the need to wait until the temperature of a heater becomes stable when an ionization method is switched. Thus, an ionization method can be switched at fast speed in a short time. In addition, as each ionization method can be performed under optimal conditions, a high-sensitivity analysis is possible.
Other problems, configurations, and advantageous effects will become apparent from the following description of embodiments.
Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings.
The present invention is directed to switching between two ionization methods such as ESI and APCI, and switching between the two ionization methods at fast speed by coupling or separating an ionization probe and a heating chamber to/from each other by moving them relative to each other. Although the drawings show specific embodiments in accordance with the principle of the present invention, such drawings should be used only for the understanding of the present invention, and should not be used to narrowly construe the present invention.
The structure of the ionization probe 1 will be described. The ionization probe 1 has a structure in which three cylindrical nozzles are coaxially overlaid. The three cylindrical nozzles include a sample spray nozzle 2 for feeding a sample 5, a nebulizer gas nozzle 3 for flowing nebulizer gas 6, and a heating gas nozzle 4 for flowing heating gas 7. A sample or gas is flowed through the inside of each nozzle. The sample 5 is a solvent such as an organic solvent (i.e., methanol or acetonitrile) or water, or a liquid sample diluted with a mixed solvent of such solvents. A liquid sample is fed by a pump, and is fed at a flow rate in the range of about several nL/min to several mL/min. The sample spray nozzle 2 is a capillary made of metal, for example, and has an inner diameter of about several μm to several hundred μm. Not only a metal capillary, but also a glass capillary can be used. The nebulizer gas 6 has the effect of nebulizing a sample solution and spraying it in the form of a liquid mist, and the sample 5 is sprayed from an outlet end 8 of the ionization probe 1 by the nebulizer gas. The heating gas 7 promotes vaporization of a sample solution and thus promotes generation of ions, thereby contributing to improving sensitivity. The flow rate of each gas is set in the range of about zero to tens of L/min. The ionization probe 1 is connected to a driving portion 33 with a support portion 34, and can thus be moved by the driving portion 33. As an example of the support portion 34 and the driving portion 33, a driving stage that is movable in a single direction can be used. The ionization probe 1 moves in the long-axis direction of the ionization probe 1 (i.e., in the vertical direction in the drawing) in the ESI mode and the APCI mode as shown in
The heating chamber 11 has a function of heating a sample for APCI and thus promoting vaporization. The outer shape of the heating chamber 11 is cylindrical, and the inside thereof has a cavity with a hole so as to pass a sprayed sample therethrough. For the heating chamber 11, a material with high thermal conductivity, such as metal or ceramic, is used. The heating chamber has a heater attached to the inside thereof, and thus can be controlled to a given temperature (e.g., hundreds of ° C.). The heating chamber 11 is connected to a driving portion 31 with a support portion 32, and thus can be moved by the driving portion 31. The heating chamber 11 also moves in the long-axis direction of the ionization probe 1 (i.e., in the vertical direction in the drawing) like the ionization probe 1. Further, a discharging electrode 12, which is supported by a support portion 13, is attached to the heating chamber 11, and the discharging electrode 12 moves in conjunction with the heating chamber 11. Accordingly, the heating chamber 11 and the discharging electrode 12 can be concurrently moved by a single driving portion. The discharging electrode 12 is connected to a high-voltage power supply 10. When a high voltage is applied to the discharging electrode 12, the discharging electrode 12 discharges electricity with an electrode at an inlet port 25 of the mass spectrometer. Thus, ionization becomes possible. The outer shape of the discharging electrode 12 may be, other than a cylindrical shape, any shape, such as a square pole, for example.
Sample ions that have been generated enter the mass spectrometer 24 from the inlet port 25, and are subjected to mass spectroscopy, so that a mass spectrum of m/z (mass-to-charge ratio) and the amount of ions is obtained.
The configurations and features of the ESI mode and the APCI mode, and a method for switching between the ionization methods will be described. The ionization method is switched when the ionization probe 1 and the heating chamber 11 are moved by the driving portions 31 and 33 and the configuration is thus changed. The driving portions 31 and 33 can move the ionization probe 1 and the heating chamber 11 via the support portions 32 and 34. For each of the driving portions and the support portions, a stage that is movable in a uniaxial direction, for example, is used. Movement of the stage may be either performed manually or automatically controlled by a computer.
Mode switching from the APCI mode to the ESI mode occurs when the heating chamber 11 has moved down to a level below the inlet port 25 of the mass spectrometer 24, and the ionization probe 1 has also moved down to a level at which the outlet end 8 of the ionization probe 1 is located around the inlet port 25. In the ESI mode, the sample 5 is heated and vaporized using the heating gas 7. Thus, the outlet end 8 of the ionization probe 1 is arranged around the inlet port 25 of the mass spectrometer 24 as shown in
In addition, in the ESI mode, the heating chamber 11 is moved to and arranged at a position where ionization of ESI is not disturbed, below and outside an ESI ionization region 21, which is located in proximity to the outlet end 8 of the ionization probe 1, so as to prevent a sample or sample ions from passing through the heating chamber 11. If bumping (i.e., boiling) of a sample solution occurs, problems occur in that electrospray becomes unstable, sensitivity decreases, and signal intensity becomes unstable. If the heating chamber 11 is placed away from the ionization probe 1, it is possible to, even when the heating chamber 11 is at a high temperature, stably spray a sample solution electrostatically without heating the sample spray nozzle 2 of the ionization probe 1 or bumping a liquid sample that comes out of the outlet end 8. A high voltage is applied to the sample spray nozzle 2 from the high-voltage power supply 9, so that a sample that has been electrostatically sprayed into the ESI ionization region 21 from the sample spray nozzle 2 at the outlet end 8 of the ionization probe 1 is ionized.
In the APCI mode, the heating chamber 11 is used while being heated to a high temperature so as to promote vaporization of a sample. Thus, the heating chamber 11 is also desirably heated and maintained at a high temperature in the ESI mode. This is because if the temperature settings are changed each time the ionization mode is switched, it takes a long time until the temperature becomes stable. That is, a waiting time of about several minutes for stabilizing the temperature is generated each time the ionization mode is switched. Consequently, the measurement stops and the measurement throughput decreases.
It is also possible to heat the ESI ionization region 21 using the heating chamber 11 at a high temperature during ESI. Due to radiant heat from the heating chamber 11, a heating region at a temperature higher than the room temperature is generated around the heating chamber 11. In particular, as a heating region 27 on the ionization probe side allows efficient vaporization of a sprayed sample, it is expected that ionization in the ionization region 21 is promoted. Adjustment of the temperature of the ionization region 21 is possible by changing the position of the heating chamber 11, that is, by placing the heating chamber 11 closer to or farther from the ionization region 21.
A method for setting the temperature of the heating chamber 11 constant (not changing the temperature) regardless of the ionization modes has been described above. As another method, it is also possible to lower the temperature of the heating chamber down to a level, which does not require much time to change the temperature, in the ESI mode. For example, it is possible to use a method of setting the temperature of the heating chamber at 600° C. in the APCI mode and lowering the temperature to 400° C. in the ESI mode. Consequently, it becomes possible to suppress power consumption of the heater of the heating chamber, and thus prevent unwanted propagation of heat to a sample or the periphery in the ESI mode.
Next, the configuration and the feature of the APCI mode will be described. Mode switching from the ESI mode to the APCI mode occurs when the ionization probe 1 has moved upward in the drawing and the heating chamber 11 has also moved upward in the drawing. In the APCI mode, as shown in
A liquid sample is sprayed from the outlet end 8 of the ionization probe 1, and passes through a sample flow path 17 from the inlet end 15 of the heating chamber, and then moves toward an APCI ionization region 22 from the outlet end 35 of the heating chamber. The heating chamber 11 is maintained at a high temperature of hundreds of ° C. by a ceramic heater or the like that is attached to the heating chamber. Thus, heating and vaporization occur in the heating region 23 and the sample flow path 17 at a high-temperature state. The sample that has been vaporized and turned into gas is ionized in the APCI ionization region 22 by ions that are generated by corona discharge between the discharging electrode 12 and the electrode at the inlet port of the mass spectrometer 24. The thus ionized sample ions enter the mass spectrometer 24 from the inlet port 25 as in ESI, and are subjected to a mass analysis.
During APCI, a high voltage is desirably not applied to the sample spray nozzle 2 from the high-voltage power supply 9. This is because if a high voltage is applied, APCI ionization may be disturbed, which can result in a decrease in the amount of ions. Even if no voltage is applied, a sample is sprayed by the nebulizer gas 6.
In the APCI mode, the heating chamber 11 approaches closest to the ionization probe 1.
As another desired configuration, it is also possible to use a configuration in which a substance with low thermal conductivity is interposed between the ionization probe 1 and the heating chamber 11 so that the two components are physically contacted and bound together. When the two components are bound together, it is possible to match the position relationship of the ionization probe 1 and the heating chamber 11 with respect to each other with high reproducibility.
If a structure in which the ionization probe 1 (in particular, the heating gas nozzle 4) is allowed to be heated to a high temperature is used, it is possible to place the ionization probe 1 and the heating chamber 11 into direct contact with each other. That is, if a structure is used in which heat of the heating gas nozzle 4 is not transmitted to the sample spray nozzle 2 in the ionization probe 1, and a sample solution is thus not boiled, that is, if a structure is used in which the sample spray nozzle 2 is maintained at a temperature of about less than or equal to 50° C. even if the heating gas nozzle 4 is at a high temperature, it is possible to place the ionization probe 1 and the heating chamber 11 into direct contact with each other.
The method of the ion source in this embodiment has the following features and advantages.
First of all, as the ionization probe and the heating chamber are configured to be movable separately, it is possible to perform ionization with an optimal configuration in each of the ESI ionization mode and the APCI ionization mode, and thus realize high-sensitivity measurement.
Second, as the ionization probe and the heating chamber are provided in a separable configuration, the temperature of the heating chamber can be always maintained high. Consequently, as the temperature needed not be switched, it is not necessary to take time to switch the temperature. Thus, it is possible to switch the ionization mode at fast speed (in less than or equal to 10 seconds), and thus perform a high-throughput analysis. In the ESI mode, it is possible to prevent the sample spray nozzle 2 of the ionization probe from reaching a high temperature by placing the heating chamber 11 at a high temperature away from the ionization probe 1, and thus prevent bumping (or boiling) of a sample solution. Thus, stable measurement is also possible in the ESI mode.
Third, as the inner diameter of the sample flow path 17 in the heating chamber 11 can be reduced regardless of the size of the ionization probe, high vaporization efficiency can be realized in APCI. This is because the heating chamber moves in a direction away from the ionization probe unlike in Patent Literature 4 and thus the inner diameter of the flow path in the heating chamber can be designed in any configuration such that it is smaller than the outer diameter of the ionization probe, specifically, smaller than the outer diameter of the heating gas nozzle of the ionization probe (though it is impossible in Patent Literature 4). The vaporization efficiency of a sample is expected to improve more as the inner diameter of the heating chamber is smaller. This is because when the inner diameter is smaller, it becomes easier to transmit heat in the heating chamber to a sample solution that passes through the narrow flow path. Thus, vaporization easily occurs.
An exemplary sequence of switching an analysis and an ionization method will be described with reference to
The ionization modes include the ESI mode and the APCI mode as shown in
As shown in
If the inlet end 15 of the heating chamber 11 has a funnel shape like a funnel portion 14 shown in
As the mass spectrometer, an ion trap mass spectrometer such as a three-dimensional ion trap mass spectrometer or a linear ion trap mass spectrometer; a quadrupole mass spectrometer (Q Filter); a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer; time of flight mass spectrometer (TOF/MS); Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer (FTICR); an orbitrap mass spectrometer); a magnetic sector mass spectrometer; or the like is used. Besides, other known mass spectrometers may also be used.
As described above, according to this embodiment, the ionization mode is switched by the movement of the ionization probe 1 and the heating chamber 11. In the APCI mode, the ionization probe and the heating chamber are placed in proximity to or in contact with (i.e., bound to) each other, while in the ESI mode, the ionization probe and the heating chamber are placed away from each other. Such a method can provide an optimal configuration for each ionization method and thus can perform highly efficient ionization. Thus, a high-sensitivity analysis is realized. Further, as the temperature of the heating chamber can be maintained high, it is not necessary to take time to switch the temperature. Thus, the ionization method can be switched at fast speed.
Next, the second example of the first embodiment will be described. In this embodiment, the heating chamber is not in the shape of a funnel but in the shape of a cylinder with a single inner diameter or a cylinder with two or more different inner diameters. Points other than that are the same as those in the first example of the first embodiment.
The third example of the first embodiment will be described. This embodiment is characterized in that the inner diameter of the outlet end 35 of the heating chamber 11 is further reduced so that the vaporization efficiency of a sample further improves in APCI. Points other than that are the same as those in the first example of the first embodiment.
The fourth example of the first embodiment will be described. In this embodiment, a method of flowing heating gas 16 to the ESI ionization region 21 using the heating chamber 11 in ESI will be described. The other configurations and methods are the same as those in the first example.
In addition, as shown in
The second embodiment is an embodiment in which the moving direction of the heating chamber differs. In this embodiment, the movement direction of the heating chamber is not a linear movement along a single, straight line, but a rotational movement about a fixed point. The method for moving the ionization probe is the same as that in the first embodiment.
The heating chamber 11 is connected to the driving portion 31 with a support portion 42, and moves by rotating about a fixed point 41. In the ESI mode, the heating chamber 11 is moved away from the ionization probe 1, and is placed at a position opposite (in front of) the mass spectrometer 24 (
Meanwhile, in the APCI mode, the heating chamber 11 is rotated about the fixed point 41 by 90 degrees by the driving portion 31, and moves such that the heating chamber 11 comes into proximity to or contact with the ionization probe 1 as shown in
In this embodiment, the heating chamber 11 is not located along an extension of the sample spray nozzle 2 in the ESI mode. Thus, as a sprayed sample does not easily stick to the heating chamber 11, there is an advantage in that the heating chamber 11 does not become dirty with the sprayed sample. Therefore, as dirt (contamination) of the ion source and detection of contaminants (i.e., carry over) can be prevented, measurement with higher precision is expected to be achieved.
The third embodiment will be described. In this embodiment, the overall length of the heating chamber (i.e., length in the vertical direction in the drawing) is reduced to eliminate the need to move the ionization probe 1 when switching the mode and thus allow switching of the ionization method only by the movement of the heating chamber 11.
As shown in
As a feature of this embodiment, the ionization probe 1 may be fixed without being moved as the heating chamber 11 in the vertical direction is short. Consequently, as the heating chamber 11 has only to be moved when ionization is switched, there is an advantage in that only one driving portion is necessary.
As the second feature, as the heating chamber 11 in the vertical direction is short, the pipe is arranged in a serpentine manner to secure the distance of the heating region. If the heating chamber 11 has a straight cylindrical pipe structure as in the aforementioned embodiments, the distance of the heating region cannot be secured. Thus, it is necessary to form a structure with which the heating distance and time can be secured. As an example, the sample flow path in the heating chamber 11 is arranged in a serpentine manner to secure the time and distance for heating sample gas.
The fourth embodiment will be described. In this embodiment, a method for moving the heating chamber differs. When the mode is switched from the APCI mode to the ESI mode, a method for moving the heating chamber that is different than the aforementioned methods is used. Specifically, in this embodiment, the heating chamber is divided into two parts, and the two parts move in opposite directions to each other.
In this embodiment, a region around the ESI ionization region 21 may also be heated by the two parts 11a and 11b of the heating chamber in the ESI mode. Either the heating method that uses radiant heat from the heating chamber or the method that uses heating gas described in Embodiment 1 can be used. Accordingly, vaporization of ions is promoted, and sensitivity is thus expected to improve.
In the APCI mode, the two separate parts 11a and 11b of the heating chamber are combined together to form a heating chamber. The configuration in the APCI mode is the same as that in
As the ionization method, APPI (atmospheric pressure photoionization) may also be used instead of APCI. APPI can be implemented by arranging a vacuum ultraviolet lamp instead of a discharging electrode. Besides, any ionization methods that can convert gas into ions can be used instead of APCI.
Besides, any ionization methods that need heating and vaporization of a sample can be used instead of APCI or APPI.
In the ESI mode, it is also possible to use an ionization method that is similar to ESI. For example, SSI (sonic spray ionization) can be used.
It should be noted that the present invention is not limited to the aforementioned embodiments, and includes a variety of variations. For example, although the aforementioned embodiments have been described in detail to clearly illustrate the present invention, the present invention need not include all of the configurations described in the embodiments. It is possible to replace a part of a configuration of an embodiment with a configuration of another embodiment. In addition, it is also possible to add, to a configuration of an embodiment, a configuration of another embodiment. Further, it is also possible to, for a part of a configuration of each embodiment, add/remove/substitute a configuration of another embodiment.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2013-184177 | Sep 2013 | JP | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/JP2014/068272 | 7/9/2014 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2015/033663 | 3/12/2015 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
6759650 | Covey | Jul 2004 | B2 |
7488953 | Fischer | Feb 2009 | B2 |
20060169887 | Yamaguchi | Aug 2006 | A1 |
20090236518 | Kobayashi | Sep 2009 | A1 |
20090250608 | Mordehai | Oct 2009 | A1 |
20120104248 | Hardman | May 2012 | A1 |
20140131570 | Yoshioka | May 2014 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
8-236064 | Sep 1996 | JP |
08236064 | Sep 1996 | JP |
2004-139962 | May 2004 | JP |
2004139962 | May 2004 | JP |
GB 2394830 | May 2004 | JP |
2004185886 | Jul 2004 | JP |
GB 2394830 | Aug 2005 | JP |
4553011 | Sep 2010 | JP |
Entry |
---|
International Search Report (PCT/ISA/210) issued in PCT application No. PCT/JP2014/068272 dated Aug. 5, 2014 with English translation (Two (2) pages). |
Japanese-language Written Opinion (PCT/ISA/237) issued in PCT application No. PCT/JP2014/068272 dated Aug. 5, 2014 (Three (3) pages). |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20160196965 A1 | Jul 2016 | US |