None.
Prior art in nitrogen removal from natural gas includes several references to cryogenic separation. With adequate feed pressure, the single column process can perform the separation using no external energy other than power for a liquid pump which is used to pump liquid methane to the desired product pressure. Single and dual pressure columns are common practice in cryogenic applications such as nitrogen rejection from a natural gas stream.
U.S. Pat. No. 4,878,932 describes a single column process wherein the cooled feed is pre-separated in a phase separator into vapor and liquid portions, the vapor is condensed and at least partly employed as reflux for the column. This single column process scheme tends to have good recovery when the N2 content in the feed stream is high, typically more than 20%. However, when the N2 content decreases, the methane recovery tends to fall sharply.
For natural gas streams having a relatively low N2 content, dual distillation columns operated at different pressures typically are used to maintain high recovery. U.S. Pat. No. 4,415,345 describes one example of a double column system. Generally speaking, in dual distillation columns the high pressure column provides a methane enriched stream which is sent to the low pressure column for further enrichment. Liquid methane product is then pumped to the desired product pressure. More particularly, the double column system is operated such that condenser duty to the first column provides the reboiler duty of the second column whereas in the single column process, heat integration is carried out by using reboiler duty to condense the feed to the distillation column. In either of the single or double column schemes, the only significant external energy that is required is in the form of a liquid pump. For feed gas pressures of 80 bar or higher and methane product pressures of up to 35 bar, no additional cooling or compression is typically required. The Joule-Thomson effect between the feed gas and product streams is sufficient to satisfy plant refrigeration requirement.
A typical example of a dual column system is shown in
Membranes have been used in hybrid application such that the feed is first sent to the membrane, the product of which is then sent to a distillation column for separation. There is also prior art available on use of membrane-distillation hybrid system for natural gas applications, such as U.S. Pat. No. 5,647,227.
While the above approaches provide sufficient solutions for purifying many types of N2-containing natural gas, they often suffer from one or more disadvantages. For cryogenic separation units, variation in the feed N2 content can pose problem to the operation of a cryogenic separation unit. This is because while single column distillation systems work well for high N2 content natural gas, recoveries can fall sharply as the N2 content is decreased. In such cases, a second column may be necessary. This adds to the capital cost.
Thus, it is the object of the current invention to provide a scheme which can provide sufficient methane recovery for feeds having variable N2 contents and requires minimal energy input.
There is provided a method of purifying a gas mixture having a majority of methane and a minority of nitrogen. It includes the following steps. The gas mixture is cooled. The cooled gas mixture is fed to a gas separation membrane to provide a permeate stream further enriched in methane and a residue stream further enriched in nitrogen. The residue stream is cooled to form a cooled residue stream. The pressure of the cooled residue stream is reduced to provide a nitrogen-enriched vapor and a methane-rich liquid. The nitrogen-enriched vapor is condensed. The condensed nitrogen-enriched vapor and the methane-rich liquid are fed to a distillation column. The gaseous nitrogen withdrawn from a top of the distillation column is warmed to provide a gaseous nitrogen product stream. The liquid methane withdrawn from a bottom of the distillation column is pressurized. The pressurized liquid methane is vaporized to provide a stream of vaporized methane. The stream of vaporized methane is warmed. The permeate stream and the stream of warmed vaporized methane are combined to provide a gaseous methane product stream.
The method may include one or more of the following aspects.
There is also provided a system for purifying a gas mixture having a majority of methane and a minority of nitrogen, comprising, a source of a gas mixture; a first heat exchanger; a gas separation membrane; a distillation column; and a second heat exchanger. The source of a gas mixture comprises a majority of methane and a minority of nitrogen. The first heat exchanger is adapted to cool a stream of said gas mixture. The gas separation membrane has a feed inlet, a permeate gas outlet, and a residue gas outlet, said feed inlet being in fluid communication with said source via said first heat exchanger. The distillation column has a top and a bottom, a plurality of inlets, a gaseous nitrogen outlet disposed at said column top, and a liquid methane outlet disposed at said column bottom, said plurality of column inlets being in fluid communication with said residue gas outlet. The second heat exchanger is adapted to cool a stream of residue gas from said residue gas outlet, warm a stream of gaseous nitrogen withdrawn from said column top, and vaporize a stream of liquid methane withdrawn from said column bottom. Said first heat exchanger is further adapted to: further warm the stream of gaseous nitrogen warmed at said second heat exchanger; warm a stream of gaseous methane produced by vaporization at said second heat exchanger; and warm a stream of permeate gas from said permeate gas outlet.
The system may include one or more of the following aspects:
For a further understanding of the nature and objects of the present invention, reference should be made to the following detailed description, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which like elements are given the same or analogous reference numbers and wherein:
As best illustrated in
The cooled feed gas stream 206 is directed to membrane separation unit 208 that includes one or more membrane selectively permeable to methane over N2. Methane, being the fast gas, permeates through the one or more membranes and the result permeate stream 210 is directed back across heat exchanger 205 thereby warming it to yield warmed permeate stream 298. Depending upon the N2 content in stream 206, a significant portion of the methane may be separated out in the permeate. For example, at 15% N2 content, as much as 65% of the feed is permeated through the membrane. The operating temperature of the gas separation unit is maintained at or below −20° C. Preferably, it is maintained at a temperature of about −60 to about −90° C. Typically, the permeate stream 210 contains from about 90 to about 95 mol % methane. A back pressure control valve on the permeate side of the membrane separation unit 208 may be used to control the pressure of the permeate stream 210 (which should be slightly higher than the product pressure). This valve is throttled to adjust the permeate flux and its composition.
In the cooled feed gas stream 206, the N2, being the slow gas, tends to not permeate through the one or more membranes and thus accumulates in the residue stream 211. Residue stream 211 is cooled to a temperature of about −110° C. at heat exchanger 214. The cooled residue stream 209 is then flashed at valve 220 and directed to phase separator 224 where it is separated into a N2-enriched vapor stream 228 and a methane-enriched liquid stream 242. The vapor stream 228 is condensed at condenser-reboiler 282 and condensed vapor 249 is optionally cooled at optional heat exchanger 261 and directed in stream 275 as reflux to distillation column 281. The liquid stream 242 is optionally subcooled at optional heat exchanger 261 and also directed in stream 272 to column 281.
Column 281 produces a gaseous N2-rich stream 269 and a liquid methane-rich stream 278. Typically, stream 269 includes about 5 mol % methane. Typically, stream 278 includes at least about 95 mol % methane and preferably more than 97 mol % methane. Stream 269 is warmed at heat exchangers 261 (optionally), 214, 205 to yield gaseous N2 product stream 296, typically at a pressure of about 3 to 5 bar.
Liquid methane-rich stream 276 is directed to condenser-reboiler 282 utilizing heat from stream 228 to provide a stream of vaporized or partially vaporized methane 284 to column 281. A liquid methane-rich stream 290 is sent to liquid pump 293.
The stream of liquid methane pumped by pump 293 is optionally directed via stream 265 to optional heat exchanger 261 where it is warmed, but is in any case directed via stream 215 to heat exchanger 214 where it is vaporized and then directed via stream 212 where it is warmed to provide gaseous methane stream 294. Gaseous methane stream 294 is combined with warmed permeate stream 296 at a methane product conduit to provide methane product stream 295. Typically, stream 295 contains less than 6 mol % N2 and greater than 94 mol % methane. If desired, a turbo expander may be utiized to transfer power from expansion of the N2 product stream 296 to compression of the methane product stream 295. Whether or not the turbo expander is utilized, the methane product stream 295 typically has a pressure of about 36 bar with a feed gas 201 pressure of about 77 bar.
The patent and non-patent literature in the field of gas separation is replete with details on how to construct or where to procure the membrane separation unit 208, so their details need not be duplicated herein. The membrane or membranes in membrane separation unit 208 may be configured in any way known in the field of gas separation, including a sheet, tube, hollow fiber, etc. Preferably, the membrane is a spiral flat sheet membrane or hollow fiber membrane. Generally speaking, the requisite methane/nitrogen membrane selectivity will depend upon the N2 content of the cooled feed gas stream 206. At a temperature of −67° C., a selectivity of 7 was sufficient for feed gas stream 206 contents of 15-25% N2. The selectivity may be modified by changing the temperature of the cooled feed gas stream 206. If a higher selectivity is desired, the temperature should be lowered. The membrane is made of a polymeric material such that, when operated at a temperature of no greater than −20° C., the membrane has a selectivity to methane over N2 of at least 5, preferably of at least 7. Because the feed gas stream 201 is cooled via heat exchange with streams 294, 296, and 298 at heat exchanger 205, when it enters the gas separation unit 208 via stream 206, it is already at a temperature where the desired selectivity is realized. In other words, greater selectivity is achieved than that realized at relatively warmer temperatures. Suitable polymeric materials include Parel [poly(propylene oxide allyl glycidyl ether)] and silicone rubber [poly(dimethyl siloxane)]. Preferably, it is silicone rubber.
The configurations of the heat exchangers 205, 214, 261 may be any of the known configurations in the field of gas separation, including the shell and tube-type or the brazed type. The brazed exchanger in particular is the preferred choice for this type of process since it can provide an economical configuration for multi streams exchangers.
The patent and non-patent literature in the field of gas separation is replete with details on how to construct or where to procure the Joule-Thomson valve 220, phase separator 224, column 281, condenser-reboiler 282, and pump 293, and as such, they need not be duplicated herein.
Practice of the process yields several advantages.
The hybrid scheme of the invention can treat varying N2 contents in the feed gas stream with relatively high methane recovery (>97%). The membrane acts as a regulator to optimize the nitrogen content of the feed for distillation by performing a partial separation of the N2 and methane upstream of distillation. This represents a significant advantage over either a cryogenic-only solution which operates efficiently over a narrow range of feed nitrogen or a membrane-only solution which might not achieve the separation with acceptable recovery.
The hybrid scheme of the invention also lowers capital costs of a system separating N2 from methane. In comparison to the single or double column systems of
The hybrid scheme of the invention also results in lower operating costs because the energy requirements, in comparison to the conventional systems, are relatively low. Expansion of compressed gas provides cryogenic temperatures for the distillation column. Thus, external energy for cooling is unnecessary. Cross-exchange of heat of the N2 product and methane product components with the membrane feed provides the desirable low operating temperature in the membrane, again removing the need for external energy for cooling. Indeed, this process can achieve the separation with no external energy other than the small amount needed for pumping the liquid methane. On the other hand, those skilled in the art will recognize that operating costs are relatively greater for systems utilizing a compressor for compression of gaseous methane, because under most conditions compressing a gas is much more energy-intensive than pumping a liquid.
Preferred processes and apparatus for practicing the present invention have been described. It will be understood and readily apparent to the skilled artisan that many changes and modifications may be made to the above-described embodiments without departing from the spirit and the scope of the present invention. The foregoing is illustrative only and that other embodiments of the integrated processes and apparatus may be employed without departing from the true scope of the invention defined in the following claims.