Closed circuit desalination (CCD) in apparatus of fixed, intrinsic volume under fixed flux and variable pressure conditions [Efraty, PCP/IL2005/000670, “CONTINUOUS CLOSED CIRCUIT DESALINATION APPARATUS WITHOUT CONTAINERS”, and PCT/IL2004/000748 “APPARATUS FOR CONTINUOUS CLOSED CIRCUIT DESALINATION UNDER VARIABLE PRESSUER WITH A SINGLE CONTAINER”] claimed a new class of low energy high recovery batch desalination processes which can be made continued on a consecutive sequential basis. Under CCD conditions, the flow rates of pressurized feed (QF), permeate (QP) and recycled concentrates (QCP) remain unchanged, QF=QP and the recycled concentrate mixed with fresh pressurized feed at module inlet. Power increase on recovery during CCD proceeds by cycles of fixed time duration (T) expressed by T=Vi/QCP; wherein, QCP stands for fixed cross flow of the circulation pump and Vi for the fixed intrinsic volume of the closed circuit, with batch sequence power demand on recovery expressing the average power over the number of cycles (n) required to reach the desired batch recovery. Specific energy (SE) of a defined cycle (n) during the CCD sequence may be expressed by SEn=T*Pn/(T*QP)=Pn/QP; wherein, Pn stands for the power demand of the defined cycle (n) and QP for the fixed flow rate of permeate, with batch sequence average (av-SE) on recovery expressing the average energy over the number of cycles (n) required to reach the desired batch recovery.
Very recently, Warsinger et al [“Energy efficiency of batch and semi-batch (CCRO) reverse osmosis desalination”, Water Research 106 (2016) 272-282.] and Werber at al [“Can batch or semi-batch processes save energy in reverse-osmosis desalination?”, Desalination 402 (2017) 109-122.] described batch-RO techniques with closed circuit apparatus comprising variable-volume high pressure tanks of declined volume on recovery of the lowest projected energy demand near the theoretical limits. Implementation of the batch-RO approach according to Warsinger et al citation of a provisional application [“Batch Pressure-driven Membrane Desalination with Closed Flow Loop and Reservoir Tank”] is made possible in an apparatus comprising a pressure-vessel with membrane elements in front and a permeate bladder in the rear, a circulation pump for concentrate recycling from outlet to inlet of said pressure vessel, and a high pressure pump for pressurizing the received permeates to said permeate bladder thereby, causing a declined dosed circuit intrinsic volume as function of batch recovery
If operated under fixed flow and variable pressure conditions, the cycle duration is shortened continuously with a declined accumulation of permeates per subsequent cycle which translates to a declined weight of subsequent cycles on the av-SE and the av-TDS of permeates.
The present patent application describes the implementation of the hydraulic-arm concept for batch-RO desalination of low energy and high recovery
The invention describes a batch-RO apparatus based on hydraulic-arm (HA) principles comprising a pressure-vessel (PV) with a separation disc (SD) wherein pressurized hydraulic fluid received from a high pressure hydraulic pump (HPHP) compresses a recycled salt water solution of increased salinity through RO membranes in modules) inside a RO-skid under fixed flow and variable-pressure conditions. A mixing device (MD) inside the salt water solution section of said hydraulic-arm (HA) blends its content with the recycled concentrates received from the membranes. The mixing device may comprise an electric or electromagnetic drive. Desalination in the inventive batch-RO apparatus proceeds under constant flux, module recovery, and cross-flow with a declined intrinsic volume of recycled concentrates and identical flow rates of permeate and hydraulic fluid. The inventive batched desalination sequence is stopped when the displaced volume in said HA reaches a predefined maximum. Preparation of said apparatus for the next desalination batch desalination sequence proceeds by a two-step process with a low pressure feed pump (LPFP); the 1st step of brine replacement by feed in said RO-skid and a small section of said HA, and the 2nd step of salt water solution recharge of said HA with hydraulic fluid displacement to its hydraulic fluid reservoir (HFR).
According to some embodiments, an apparatus for batch closed circuit desalination of a salt water solution feed by reverse osmosis (RO) comprises hydraulic power means (HP), hydraulic-arm (HA) means, RO means, and feed recharge means (FR), whereby the HP comprise a line of hydraulic fluid (HF) with pressurizing means for the delivery of pressurized HF from a hydraulic fluid reservoir (HFR) to the HA, thereby providing hydraulic power to the apparatus, a non-pressurized HF line for non-pressurized HF return from the HA to the HFR, and an actuated valve and check valve means, whereby either pressurized HF is supplied to the HA or alternatively retrieved from the HA to the HFR;
the HA comprise a single pressure vessel (PV) with a separation disc (SD) inside between the HF and the feed, or several PVs connected in parallel, wherein HF is supplied/retrieved from a first end of the HA, whereas the feed and concentrates of the feed created inside the HA during RO desalination are supplied/retrieved from a second end of the HA, while the second end of the HA further comprises a mixing device (MD) means to enable effective blending of the concentrates inside the HD;
the FR comprising a feed line with a low pressure supply means connected to the concentrates recycling line, a brine removal line extension from the concentrates recycling line, actuated valve and check-valve means on the above referred lines (i.e., the concentrates recycling line, and the brine removal line) to enable one of three discrete operations at a time of the concentrate recycling during RO, or the brine removal without RO, or the feed recharge of the HA without RO further associated with the HF release to the HFR;
online monitoring means of pressure on the inlet (Pin) and outlet (Pout) lines of the RO-skid, of flow or volume on the recycling line down stream of the circulation means (FVCP), and of flow or volume on the pressurized HF line to the HA(FVH); and
a computerized control board means, whereby the entire operation of the apparatus is managed automatically on the basis of the online monitored data in conjunction with selected set-points flow rates and volumes.
In some embodiments, the pressurizing means comprise a high pressure hydraulic pump (HPHP) with a variable frequency drive (vfd) means capable of a fixed flow and variable pressure operation with an aid of a flow or volume means located upstream or downstream (FVH) of the high pressure hydraulic pump.
In some embodiments, the circulation means comprise a circulation pump (CP) of low pressure difference boosting with a variable frequency drive (vfd) means capable of a fixed flow operation with an aid of a flow or volume, means located upstream or downstream (FVCP) of the circulation pump.
In some embodiments, the mixing device (MD) means comprise an electric or electromagnetically driven mixer with a variable frequency drive (vfd) means capable of vigorous mixing of the recycled concentrates inside the HA at the beginning of a desalination sequence with a progressively declined mixing rate towards the end of the sequence.
In some embodiments, the low pressure supply means comprise a low pressure feed pump (LPFP) of high flow delivery rate to enable the brine removal and feed recharge steps between RO sequences completed over a brief time duration.
In some embodiments, the computerized control board means automatically actuate the apparatus by the following steps:
In some embodiments, the hydraulic fluid is any hydraulic fluid including permeates received during the operation of the apparatus.
In some embodiments, the salt water solution feed is any aqueous solution containing salts.
The inventive batch-RO apparatus of the preferred embodiment and its components and actuation modes are described in
The HA in the inventive apparatus is divided by the SD into two sections, one of hydraulic fluid and the other of salt water solutions of changing salinity. Batch desalination sequence in the inventive apparatus of the preferred embodiment in
Blending of the recycled concentrates off said RO-skid with the declined volume of concentrates inside said HA is achieved by means of a mixing device with vfd means (MD-vdf) with maximum mixing speed applied at the beginning of a desalination sequence when said HA is fully charged with feed, and the mixing speed is steadily declined as function of the decreased volume of concentrates inside said HA.
Monitored volume (FVH) supplied to said HA is equivalent to the HF volume withdrawn from the HFR and to the permeate volume produced in said RO skid. Permeate produced by said RO-skid may also serve as hydraulic fluid (HF). The volume of HF stored in the HFR is only little greater than the maximum displaced volume from said HA.
The desalination sequence in the preferred embodiment of the inventive batch-RO apparatus with emphasis on active/passive components, position and configuration of valve means, and flow direction in lines are revealed at the beginning of a desalination sequence illustrated in
Desalination in the inventive batch-RO apparatus of the preferred embodiment described hereinabove stops when the monitored HF volume transferred from HFR to HA reach a predefined volumetric set-point (VHF) and such a signal triggers a configuration shift from
The inventive batch-RO apparatus may comprise more than one HA inline and/or RO-skid made of N module, each of n membrane elements, and such a design with two HA is illustrated in
Desalination in the inventive batch-RO apparatus under fixed flow and variable pressure conditions proceeds with a linear decline of the intrinsic closed circuit volume and with linear permeate production on the sequential time scale as well as on the recovery scale. The specific energy and permeates quality at a given recovery level during this batch-RO desalination process under said conditions correspond to the average (ay-SE and av-TDS) of the preceding steps on the recovery scale. By analogy with said batch-RO desalination process in the inventive apparatus, the related semi-batch CCD process also takes place under fixed flow and variable pressured conditions but in a fixed intrinsic closed circuit volume with recycled concentrates continuously blended with pressurized feed supplies, and such a process proceeds with fixed duration cycles of same permeate production with av-SE and av-TDS of permeates correspond to the average of the preceding cycles and expressed exponentially on the recovery scale. Unlike CCD which proceeds by fixed cycles, each of the same inlet and outlet module concentrations under the same applied pressure, the batch-RO process proceeds with continuously changing inlet and outlet module concentrations and applied pressure of no discrete cycles and their accumulation effects. The av-SE of a perfect batch-RO process is found parallel to the least minimum energy under infinitesimal flux conditions with added energy expressing the effects of flux and efficiency of hydraulic pressurizing means.
Batch-RO desalination in the inventive apparatus could not be made continuous on a consecutive sequential basis in light of the need for brine removal and feed recharge of the HA which requires the stopping of desalination at the end of each batch sequence. Despite of this limitation, permeate productivity in said batch-RO apparatus could remain relatively high pending the choice of a fast LPFP which could shortens the duration of the steps in the process without desalination.
The illustrated Example described hereinafter reveals that the batch-RO inventive apparatus enables highest recovery with the lowest energy consumption amongst all known RO techniques available today, including the next best technique that of CCD, and in additions provides good quality permeates. Permeates' volume production per sequence in the inventive batch-RO apparatus is confined by the volume displacement of its HA and the use of conventional 16″ diameter PV as HA does opens the door for small scale (up to 10 m3/h, 240 m3/day) applications. A noteworthy application in this context relates to the desalination of treated domestic and/or industrial effluents with exceptionally high recovery (≥95%) and low energy to a near zero liquid discharge (ZLD) level with maximum water savings for reuse.
It will be understood to the skilled in the art that the inventive batch-RO apparatus of the preferred embodiment and its modes of actuation enable low energy high recovery desalination of salt water solutions according to
It will be understood to the skilled in the art that means associated with pressurizing feed, boosting feed pressure, concentrates recycling, hydraulic-arms, conducing lines, flow manipulation by valves, and online monitoring devices of pressure, flow/volume, pH, temperature, and electric-conductivity of salts water solution and permeates are comprised of ordinary commercial components such as a pressure pump, a circulation pump (CP), a valve device, and, pressure vessels (e.g., 8″, 16″ and larger diameters), or several such components that are applied simultaneously in parallel or in line as appropriate. It is further understood that the referred monitoring means and their transmitted signals to a computerized control board are essential for the actuation and control of specific components within said inventive apparatus.
It will be obvious to the skill in the art that the design of the inventive apparatus is not confined by the number of modules and/or element-number per module and/or the type of modules and elements in each said RO skid, nor by the number of hydraulic-arms and therefore, said inventive apparatus may also apply to large scale desalination plants pending the availability of large enough hydraulic-arms capable to withstand the maximum pressure needs for a specific desalination application.
While the invention has been described hereinabove in respect to particular embodiments, it will be obvious to those versed in the art that changes and modifications may be made without departing from this invention in its broader aspects, therefore, the appended claims are to encompass within their scope all such changes and modifications that fall within the true spirit of the invention.
The example illustrates the application of the inventive apparatus for high recovery (˜95%) low energy (˜0.42 kWh/m3) desalination of treated effluents with salinity equivalent to that of 3,000 ppm (0.3%) NaCl solution. The performance illustration is of an inventive apparatus comprising a single-module RO-skid of 3 elements (ME3, E=ESPA2−MAX) and 54 liter intrinsic volume; two hydraulic-arms (16″ diameter PV, 430 cm long each) of 1.075 liter effective displacement volume; HPHP-vfd of 1.84 m3/h and 90% eff.; CP-vfd of 5.51 m3/h and 75% eff.; LPFP of 20 m3/h and 75% eff.; and MD-vfd of 70%. The above selected flow rate set-point imply the followings; fixed flow variable pressure desalination with 15 lmh flux; 25% module recovery; 9% average element flow; 1.156 average concentration polarization; 0.47 bar module pressure difference (Δp); and a 35 minute batch desalination sequence of 1.075 liter produced permeates. Brine replacement with feed (˜15 sec.) and feed recharge of hydraulic-arms with feed (194 sec.) through LPFP (20 m3/h) take together ˜3.5 minute and this means an overall sequence time of 38.5 minute during which desalination is experienced 90.9% of the time and functions not engaged with the desalination experienced during the rest of the time (9.1%). Accordingly, the effective permeate production of said apparatus amounts to 1.672 m3/h or 40.14 m3/day.
The simulated performance of said batch-RO inventive apparatus of the above cited design features and operational set-points under fixed flow and variable pressure condition as compared with that of a semi-batch CCD system of the same RO-skid [3 elements (ME3, E=ESPA2−MAX) and 54 liter intrinsic volume] under the same operational conditions, are displayed
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
251499 | Apr 2017 | IL | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/IL2018/050365 | 3/29/2018 | WO | 00 |