Hydroelectric turbine recovery system and a method therefor

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 9765647
  • Patent Number
    9,765,647
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, November 8, 2011
    13 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 19, 2017
    7 years ago
Abstract
The present invention relates to a hydroelectric turbine recovery system, and in particular a system which significantly reduces the complexity of recovering a base mounted hydroelectric turbine from a deployment site on the seabed by providing a frame having an open mouth which can be advanced around the turbine before the frame is fully lowered into locking engagement with the base, thereby allowing the base, with the turbine thereon, to be recovered from the seabed.
Description
FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to a hydroelectric turbine recovery system, and in particular a system that significantly reduces the complexity of recovering a base mounted hydroelectric turbine from a deployment site on the seabed or the like.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Due to the environmental damage that has been inflicted on the planet as a result of the burning of fossil fuels, renewable energy has finally begun to be given significant attention, with many projects being developed around solar energy, wind energy, and tidal power. Of these alternative forms of energy, tidal power is arguably the most attractive, given that tidal flows are entirely predictable and constant, unlike wind or solar energy which are relatively intermittent and therefore less dependable.


However, harnessing tidal energy does provide its own challenges, in particular with respect to the installation, maintenance and retrieval of tidal power generators, for example hydro-electric turbines, which by the very nature of the operation of same must be located in relatively fast flowing tidal currents, and more than likely located on the seabed. In addition, in order to be economically viable these turbines must be built on a large scale. As a result the turbines and associated bases/supports are large components, and require heavy lifting and transport equipment in order to achieve both deployment and recovery thereof. The use of such heavy lifting equipment is normally a hazardous undertaking, and is rendered even more dangerous when this equipment is operated at sea under difficult and unsteady conditions.


The above processes are further complicated by an increasing shortage in the market of suitable vessels and equipment to perform such work and the extreme danger of engaging divers in high tidal flow sites.


DE102008032625 discloses a lifting device for a turbine generator unit that is adapted to lift a turbine off a seabed mounted base with the base being left fixed on the seabed. The device has an immersion component (1) comprising a transverse centering device (9) and a gripping device (10). The transverse centering device comprises movable enclosure elements that are opened outwardly while the lifting device is brought into position about the generator unit, and are then closed in order to centre the lifting device relative to a turbine generator unit (2). The turbine generator unit can then be lifted off the base, which remains in position on the seabed.


The present invention has therefore been developed with a view to simplifying the recovery of a base mounted hydroelectric turbine system, and in particular reducing the complexity and the time taken to effect recovery of the base and turbine, as a single unit, from the seabed.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

According to a first aspect of the present invention there is provided a hydroelectric turbine recovery system for recovering a base mounted hydroelectric turbine, the system comprising a frame having an opening permitting the frame to be advanced around the turbine via the opening; characterised in that the frame comprises a plurality of couplers engagable with the base.


Preferably, the base comprises corresponding couplers engagable with the plurality of couplers on the frame.


Preferably, the couplers on the frame and the couplers on the base are arranged to be brought into registration through vertical movement relative to one another.


Preferably, the frame is substantially U shaped.


Preferably, the frame comprises one or more guides to assist in aligning the frame with the base.


Preferably, the one or more guides are immovably fixed in position.


Preferably, at least one of the guides comprises a buffer positioned to engage the turbine and/or base when the frame is substantially aligned with the base in order to arrest further displacement of the fame relative to the base.


Preferably, the buffer comprising a cross member extending between a pair of opposed arms of the frame.


Preferably, the buffer is resiliently deformable in order to prevent damage to the turbine and/or base on contact therewith.


Preferably, the couplers on the frame each comprise a hydraulically actuated lifting tool and the couplers on the base each comprise a corresponding dock within which the lifting tool is reversibly lockable.


Preferably, the couplers on the frame and/or base are secured by mountings which permit limited displacement of the couplers.


Preferably, the system comprises one or more sensors operable to detect contact and correct alignment between the frame and the turbine and/or base.


Preferably, the system comprises one or more imaging sensors.


According to a second aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of recovering a base mounted hydroelectric turbine from the seabed, the method comprising the steps of:


lowering a recovery frame having an opening from a deployment vessel into a position laterally adjacent the base mounted turbine;


advancing the frame around the turbine via the opening;


coupling the frame to the base; and


lifting the base and turbine off the seabed as a single unit.


Preferably, the method comprises, prior to the step of coupling the frame to the base, substantially vertically lowering the frame into engagement with the base.


Preferably, the method comprises the step of:


arresting the lateral displacement of the frame, when substantially aligned with the base, through contact with the turbine of a buffer mounted to the frame.


Preferably, the method comprises, in the step of coupling the frame to the base, inserting a plurality of couplers on the frame into a corresponding plurality of couplers on the base.


Preferably, the method comprises the step of performing the method in a running tide; and positioning the recovery frame down tide of the turbine prior to lowering the frame into position laterally adjacent the turbine.


Preferably, the method comprises the step of providing power to the recovery frame via a power cable connected between the deployment vessel and the frame; and managing the cable by positioning the cable in the water down tide of the frame.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS


FIG. 1 illustrates a perspective view of a hydroelectric turbine recovery system according to an embodiment of the present invention, being advanced towards a base mounted turbine;



FIG. 2 illustrates a side elevation of the arrangement shown in FIG. 1;



FIG. 3 illustrates the recovery system shown in FIG. 1 with a frame of the system having been brought into register with the turbine;



FIG. 4 illustrates a side elevation of the arrangement shown in FIG. 3;



FIG. 5 illustrates the recovery system shown in FIGS. 1 to 4 in which the frame has been lowered and locked onto the base in order to permit recovery thereof;



FIG. 6 illustrates a side elevation of the arrangement shown in FIG. 5;



FIG. 7 illustrates a perspective view of the recovery frame, showing one form of guide thereon; and



FIG. 8 illustrates a perspective view of the recovery frame, showing a further form of guide thereon.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Referring now to the accompanying drawings there is illustrated a hydroelectric turbine recovery system, generally indicated as 10, for use in retrieving a hydroelectric turbine T and base B, in a single operation, from a deployment site on the seabed or the like.


The recovery system 10 comprises a frame 12 that is suspended beneath a deployment vessel such as a barge (not shown) or the like and can be raised and lowered relative to the barge on a number of guidelines 14. The guidelines 14 may also carry power, whether electric, hydraulic, pneumatic or the like, from the barge to the frame 12, for reasons set out hereinafter. It is however preferred that a dedicated power line or umbilical (not shown) is provided between the deployment vessel and the frame 12. Each of the guidelines 14 is preferably wound onto a suitable winch or the like located on the barge, in order to allow the frame 12 to be raised and lowered relative to the barge. The frame 12, in the embodiment illustrated, is manufactured from tubular steel, although it will be appreciated that the materials and design of the frame 12 may vary once retaining the underlying functionality as described hereinafter.


Referring in particular to FIGS. 7 and 8 it can be seen that the frame 12 is substantially u-shaped in plan and includes a pair of arms 16 that, in the latter half thereof, taper towards one another and are connected at an apex 18. Each of the arms 16 terminate in a fixed or immovable guide 20 (only shown in FIG. 7) which curve outwardly away from a longitudinal axis L of frame 12. The free ends of the arms 16, as defined by the guides 20, define a mouth 22 of the frame 12 that permits access to a docking space 24 defined by the frame 12. This docking space 24 terminates, in the direction of the longitudinal axis L, at a third guide in the form of a cross member 26. The cross member 26 acts as a buffer which in use, and as will be described hereinafter, makes contact with the outer face of the turbine T as the frame 12 is advanced into position, in order to prevent the frame 12 from being advanced beyond its intended position. The cross member 26 is shown in full detail in FIG. 8, while in the remaining drawings is shown in reduced detail for the purposes of clarity.


The recovery system 10 additionally comprises three couplers 28 provided on and projecting vertically downward from the frame 12, one at the free end of each of the arms 16 and the remaining coupler 28 at the apex 18. The base B is provided with co-operating and correspondingly positioned couplers 30 which form an integral part of the base B, and are therefore capable of bearing the combined load of the turbine T and base B as the two are being raised from the seabed, again as will be described in detail hereinafter. The couplers 30 on the base are preferably in the form of a cylindrical sleeve into which the couplers 28 may be located and then locked in position as described below. In the embodiment illustrated the couplers 30 are defined by and formed in the legs of the base B, although it will be appreciated that the position of each of the couplers 30 may be varied depending on the overall design and/or dimensions of the base B.


In the embodiment illustrated the couplers 28 on the frame 12 each comprise a lifting tool 28 comprising a cylindrical gripping member 32 which projects vertically downwards from the arm 16 of the frame 12. The gripping member 32 comprises an array of gripping elements (not shown) covering a substantial area of the outer surface of the gripping member 32, and which may be displaced outwardly to stand proud of said surface, preferably via hydraulic actuation. In use each of the gripping members 32 is positioned internally of the respective coupler 30 provided on the base B, and the gripping elements (not shown) are then displaced outwardly in order to engage and grip the interior surface of said coupler 30. The hydraulic or other power to effect operation of the lifting tools 28 may be provided from the barge (not shown) via the guidelines 14 or secondary lines (not shown), but preferably via a dedicated power cable or umbilical (not shown). The open upper end of the couplers 30 may taper outwardly to define a funnel shaped opening via which the gripping member 32 are introduced, in order to assist in guiding the gripping members 32 into the couplers 30. It is envisaged that the lifting tools 28 and/or the couplers 30 may be secured to the frame 12 or base B via floating mountings (not shown) which will allow some play in order to reduce the accuracy required to effect registration of the lifting tools 28 with the couplers 30.


Turning then to the operation of the recovery system 10, the frame 12 is initially fastened directly to the underside of the barge, at a suitable location such as a dock or the like. The power cable or umbilical (not shown) may then be connected between the deployment vessel and the frame 12, which during the recovery operation will provide power to the lifting tools 28, in addition to any sensors on board the frame 12. The barge is then transported to the deployment site of the turbine T and base B, whether being towed by a tug (not shown) or under its own power source. The exact position of the turbine T is known, and is maintained using GPS and a marker buoy for reference or by Dynamic Positioning (DP) on the surface of the sea above the deployment site. The barge can then be accurately positioned relative to the turbine T, in order to begin recovery of both the turbine T and base B in a single operation.


On reaching the turbine T the barge is preferably positioned slightly downstream or down tide of the turbine T and base B relative to the direction of tidal flow. The frame 12 is then lowered on the guidelines 14 until the frame 12 is at the same horizontal co-ordinate as the turbine T, and as illustrated in FIGS. 1 and 2. By deploying the frame 12 during a running tide and directly down tide of the turbine T the flow of the tide will be in a direction substantially parallel with the longitudinal axis L of the frame 12. The tidal flow of water past the frame 12 will tend to maintain the correct alignment of the frame 12 relative to the turbine T and base B. In addition, the power cable or umbilical (not shown) providing power from the deployment vessel to the frame 12 will need to be managed during the recovery process, and by positioning the frame 12 down tide of the turbine T, the power cable (not shown) can simply be deposited off the back of the deployment vessel and thus into the water down tide of the frame 12. The running tide will then ensure that the power cable remains down tide of the frame 12 during the entire recovery process and will thus not pose an obstacle to the operation. By advancing the barge and frame from a down tide position, a failsafe is then built into the operation in the event of a power loss to the barge or tug, which will result in the frame 12 drifting away from the turbine T and thus avoiding the possibility of the frame 12 contacting and damaging the turbine T.


At this point the barge, with the frame 12 suspended therebeneath, is advanced towards the turbine T and base B, preferably in a direction substantially parallel with the longitudinal axis L of the frame 12, and with the mouth 22 leading. The frame 12 may be advanced by advancing the tug to which the barge is tied, or as an alternative the tug may be correctly positioned and then winch the barge and frame upstream. It is preferable that the frame 12 is provided with a number of sensors (not shown) for monitoring the position/condition of the frame 12 during the recovery operation. These sensors may be in the form of one or more cameras or imaging sonar, in order to provide visual feedback during the operation, even when the water is not clear, has high turbidity, or during night time operations.


The frame 12 will thus slowly approach the turbine T, and if there is any misalignment between the two the pair of guides 20, which are only illustrated in FIG. 7, will serve to gently correct the position of the frame 12 such that the turbine T passes through the mouth 22 and into the docking space 24 defined within the frame 12. The horizontal displacement of the frame 12 around the turbine T continues until the cross member 26 contacts the face of the turbine T, thereby arresting the further horizontal displacement of the frame 12. The cross member 26 is positioned such that when it contacts the outer face of the turbine T each of the lifting tools 28 will be positioned directly above the respective coupler 30 on the base B, as illustrated in FIGS. 3 and 4. The frame 12 may also be provided with additional sensors to indicate contact with the turbine T, such as load cells (not shown) which can monitor for contact. Once these sensors indicate contact between the frame 12 and the turbine T, the frame 12 can be halted. It is preferable, at this stage, to advance the barge slightly up tide in order to place some tension in the guidelines 14 in order to hold the frame 12 securely against the turbine T. Due to turbulence and/or fluctuations in the velocity of the tidal flow, an increase in the velocity may temporarily displace the frame 12 down tide of the turbine T, and once the increased tidal flow reduces the frame 12 will then swing back towards and contact the turbine T. This swinging of the frame 12 may therefore result in damage to the turbine T or the frame 12. By placing tension in the guidelines 14 the frame 12 will be held securely against the turbine T even during such tidal fluctuations.


At this point the barge is halted and maintained in position directly above the turbine T and base B. The guidelines 14 are then used to slowly lower the frame 12 in the vertical direction, whereby each of the lifting tools will be inserted into the respective coupler 30 on the base B, as illustrated in FIGS. 5 and 6. Once the frame 12 has been fully lowered into position the guidelines 14 will begin to go slack, at which point the winches lowering the frame 12 are stopped. The lifting tools 28 are then actuated, whereby the gripping elements (not shown) are projected outwardly in order to grip the cylindrical inner surface of the couplers 30, thereby locking the lifting tools 28 to the couplers 30.


It is envisaged that the vertical orientation of the couplers 28, 30 could be altered, for example being in a horizontal orientation. With such an arrangement it would then only be necessary to advance the frame 12 horizontally into engagement with the base 12, although a greater degree of accuracy in the initial horizontal positioning of the frame 12 would be required. It should also be appreciated that the lifting tools 28 and corresponding couplers 30 could be substituted with any other suitable means of connecting and securing the frame 12 to the base B, for example using hooks, collets, or other forms of mechanical fasteners. It is also to be understood that while the system 10 of the embodiment illustrated is designed to recover a triangular base B, and is thus comprises of three lifting tools 28, the system 10 may be reconfigured to recovery alternative styles of base, for example a rectangular base or the like, and may therefore comprise more or less that the three lifting tools 28 of the embodiment illustrated.


The frame 12 is now securely locked to the base B, and on which the turbine T is itself fixed. The winches can now be reversed in order to haul up the guidelines 14, thereby lifting the turbine T and base B as a single unit, off the seabed. It may be necessary to lift each leg of the base B individually in order to help break any settling effects at the legs. This can be achieved by individually raising each guideline 14 until the respective leg breaks free of the seabed, at which point that leg can then be lowered back down and the next leg then raised. Once all of the legs have been freed from the seabed the frame 12 is preferably raised fully against the underside of the barge, which is designed to allow the turbine T to pass upwardly through an opening therein. At this point the frame 12 is safely secured to the barge, which can then transport the base B and turbine T ashore.


It will thus be appreciated that by using an open sided frame having a mouth 22 to accept the turbine T, and the provision of the guides 20 and cross member 26, the frame 12 can be positioned and secured to the base B with relative ease and without the requirement for divers or other personnel to be on the seabed during the operation. As a result the turbine T and base B can be recovered as a single unit, avoiding the need to separate the two while on the seabed. This also ensures that once transported ashore, the turbine T is still fixed to the base B, and so the turbine T can remain fully supported by the base B on land, where an inspection and/or suitable repairs can then be made. This avoids the requirement for transferring the turbine T to a separate support, which would be a difficult and time consuming operation, and increases the risk of damage to the turbine T.

Claims
  • 1. A hydroelectric turbine recovery system for recovering a hydroelectric turbine mounted on a base, the system comprising: a hydroelectric turbine mounted on a base; anda frame having an opening permitting the frame to be advanced around the hydroelectric turbine via the opening, and having a plurality of couplers engagable with the base, wherein the frame is configured to be raised and lowered via guidelines and wherein the hydroelectric turbine and the base are separate and detached from the frame and guidelines prior to the couplers engaging with the base.
  • 2. A recovery system according to claim 1, further comprising corresponding couplers on the base engagable with the plurality of couplers on the frame.
  • 3. A recovery system according to claim 2 in which the couplers on the frame and the couplers on the base are arranged to be brought into registration through vertical movement relative to one another.
  • 4. A recovery system according to claim 1 in which the frame is substantially U shaped.
  • 5. A recovery system according to claim 1 in which the frame comprises one or more guides to assist in aligning the frame with the base.
  • 6. A recovery system according to claim 5 in which the one or more guides are immovably fixed in position.
  • 7. A recovery system according to claim 5 in which at least one of the guides comprises a buffer positioned to engage the turbine and/or base when the frame is substantially aligned with the base in order to arrest further displacement of the fame relative to the base.
  • 8. A recovery system according to claim 7 in which the buffer comprising a cross member extending between a pair of opposed arms of the frame.
  • 9. A recovery system according to claim 7 in which the buffer is resiliently deformable whereby damage to the turbine and/or base on contact therewith is inhibited.
  • 10. A recovery system according to claim 2 in which the couplers on the frame each comprise a hydraulically actuated lifting tool and the couplers on the base each comprise a corresponding dock within which the lifting tool is reversibly lockable.
  • 11. A recovery system according to claim 1 comprising one or more sensors operable to detect contact and correct alignment between the frame and the turbine and/or base.
  • 12. A recovery system according to claim 1 comprising one or more imaging sensors.
  • 13. A method of recovering a base mounted hydroelectric turbine from the seabed, the method comprising the steps of: lowering a recovery frame having an opening from a deployment vessel into a position laterally adjacent the base;advancing the frame around the turbine via the opening;coupling the frame to the base via engaging couplers within the frame to the base; andlifting the base, the turbine and the frame off the seabed as a single unit;wherein the frame is configured to be raised and lowered via guidelines and wherein the hydroelectric turbine and the base are separate and detached from the frame and guidelines prior to the couplers engaging with the base.
  • 14. A method according to claim 13 comprising, prior to the step of coupling the frame to the base, substantially vertically lowering the frame into engagement with the base.
  • 15. A method according to claim 13 comprising the step of: arresting the lateral displacement of the frame, when substantially aligned with the base, through contact with the turbine of a buffer mounted to the frame.
  • 16. A method according to claim 13 comprising, in the step of coupling the frame to the base, inserting the couplers on the frame into a corresponding plurality of couplers on the base.
  • 17. A method according to claim 13 comprising the step of performing the method in a running tide; and positioning the recovery frame down tide of the turbine prior to lowering the frame into position laterally adjacent the turbine.
  • 18. A method according to claim 13 comprising the step of providing power to the recovery frame via a power cable connected between the deployment vessel and the frame; and managing the cable by positioning the cable in the water down tide of the frame.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
10190576 Nov 2010 EP regional
PCT Information
Filing Document Filing Date Country Kind 371c Date
PCT/EP2011/069623 11/8/2011 WO 00 8/27/2013
Publishing Document Publishing Date Country Kind
WO2012/062739 5/18/2012 WO A
US Referenced Citations (150)
Number Name Date Kind
228467 Maclay Jun 1880 A
928536 Pino Jul 1909 A
1710103 Nelson Apr 1929 A
2054142 Sharp Sep 1936 A
2470797 Thomas May 1949 A
2501696 Souczek Mar 1950 A
2563279 Rushing Aug 1951 A
2658453 Walters Nov 1953 A
2782321 Fischer Feb 1957 A
2792505 Baudry May 1957 A
2874547 Fiore Feb 1959 A
3078680 Wapsala Feb 1963 A
3209156 Struble, Jr. Sep 1965 A
3292023 Korber Dec 1966 A
3342444 Nelson Sep 1967 A
3355998 Roemisch Dec 1967 A
3384787 Schwartz May 1968 A
3422275 Braikevitch et al. Jan 1969 A
3433024 Diamond et al. Mar 1969 A
3477236 Burrus Nov 1969 A
3487805 Satterthwaite et al. Jan 1970 A
3603386 Talley, Jr. Sep 1971 A
3708251 Pierro Jan 1973 A
3986787 Mouton, Jr. et al. Oct 1976 A
3987638 Burkhardt et al. Oct 1976 A
4095918 Mouton et al. Jun 1978 A
4163904 Skendrovic Aug 1979 A
4219303 Mouton, Jr. et al. Aug 1980 A
4274009 Parker, Sr. Jun 1981 A
4367413 Nair Jan 1983 A
4421990 Heuss et al. Dec 1983 A
4427897 Migliori Jan 1984 A
4496845 Ensign et al. Jan 1985 A
4523878 Richart et al. Jun 1985 A
4541367 Lindberg Sep 1985 A
4541755 Castel Sep 1985 A
4613762 Soderholm Sep 1986 A
4720640 Anderson Jan 1988 A
4740711 Sato et al. Apr 1988 A
4744697 Coppens May 1988 A
4744698 Dallimer et al. May 1988 A
4810135 Davenport et al. Mar 1989 A
4867605 Myers et al. Sep 1989 A
4868408 Hesh Sep 1989 A
4868970 Schultz et al. Sep 1989 A
4990810 Newhouse Feb 1991 A
5495221 Post Feb 1996 A
5592816 Williams Jan 1997 A
5606791 Fougere et al. Mar 1997 A
5609441 Khachaturian Mar 1997 A
5656880 Clark Aug 1997 A
5662434 Khachaturian Sep 1997 A
5715590 Fougere et al. Feb 1998 A
5800093 Khachaturian Sep 1998 A
5998905 Fougere et al. Dec 1999 A
6039506 Khachaturian Mar 2000 A
6109863 Milliken Aug 2000 A
6113314 Campbell Sep 2000 A
6166472 Pinkerton Dec 2000 A
6168373 Vauthier Jan 2001 B1
6232681 Johnston et al. May 2001 B1
6242840 Denk et al. Jun 2001 B1
6293734 Thomas et al. Sep 2001 B1
6300689 Smalser Oct 2001 B1
6309179 Holden Oct 2001 B1
6367399 Khachaturian Apr 2002 B1
6406251 Vauthier Jun 2002 B1
6409466 Lamont Jun 2002 B1
6445099 Roseman Sep 2002 B1
6476709 Wuidart et al. Nov 2002 B1
6612781 Jackson Sep 2003 B1
6648589 Williams Nov 2003 B2
RE38336 Williams Dec 2003 E
6729840 Williams May 2004 B2
6756695 Hibbs et al. Jun 2004 B2
6770987 Sogard et al. Aug 2004 B1
6777851 Maslov Aug 2004 B2
6806586 Wobben Oct 2004 B2
6840713 Schia et al. Jan 2005 B1
6843191 Makotinsky Jan 2005 B1
6857821 Steenhuis et al. Feb 2005 B2
6957947 Williams Oct 2005 B2
7190087 Williams Mar 2007 B2
D543495 Williams May 2007 S
7223137 Sosnowski May 2007 B1
7275891 Owen et al. Oct 2007 B2
7352078 Gehring Apr 2008 B2
7378750 Williams May 2008 B2
7425772 Novo Vidal Sep 2008 B2
7471009 Davis et al. Dec 2008 B2
7527006 Khachaturian May 2009 B2
7611307 Owen et al. Nov 2009 B2
7845296 Khachaturian Dec 2010 B1
7874788 Stothers et al. Jan 2011 B2
7976245 Finnigan Jul 2011 B2
8022581 Stiesdal Sep 2011 B2
8308422 Williams Nov 2012 B2
8310077 Pearce Nov 2012 B2
8350400 Rosefsky Jan 2013 B2
8466595 Spooner Jun 2013 B2
20020034437 Williams Mar 2002 A1
20020062644 Rosefsky May 2002 A1
20020088222 Vauthier Jul 2002 A1
20030044272 Addie et al. Mar 2003 A1
20030137149 Northrup et al. Jul 2003 A1
20030155829 McMullen et al. Aug 2003 A1
20030168864 Heronemus et al. Sep 2003 A1
20030193198 Wobben Oct 2003 A1
20030218338 O'Sullivan et al. Nov 2003 A1
20040021386 Swett Feb 2004 A1
20040021437 Maslov et al. Feb 2004 A1
20040201299 Naritomi et al. Oct 2004 A1
20040227500 O'Meara Nov 2004 A1
20040232792 Erfourth Nov 2004 A1
20040262926 Hansen Dec 2004 A1
20050005592 Fielder Jan 2005 A1
20050031442 Williams Feb 2005 A1
20060261597 Gehring Nov 2006 A1
20070018459 Williams Jan 2007 A1
20070063448 Kowalczyk Mar 2007 A1
20070164626 Taniguchi et al. Jul 2007 A1
20070231072 Jennings et al. Oct 2007 A1
20070241566 Kuehnle Oct 2007 A1
20070262668 Brisson et al. Nov 2007 A1
20070291426 Kasunich et al. Dec 2007 A1
20080012538 Stewart et al. Jan 2008 A1
20090162144 Ayre Jun 2009 A1
20090278357 Williams Nov 2009 A1
20100068037 Ives Mar 2010 A1
20100133838 Borgen Jun 2010 A1
20100148513 Susman Jun 2010 A1
20100172698 Ives et al. Jul 2010 A1
20100201129 Holstein et al. Aug 2010 A1
20100232885 Ives et al. Sep 2010 A1
20100295388 Ives et al. Nov 2010 A1
20110018274 Ives et al. Jan 2011 A1
20110088253 Ives et al. Apr 2011 A1
20110110770 Spooner et al. May 2011 A1
20110155682 Grassow Jun 2011 A1
20110291419 Dunne et al. Dec 2011 A1
20110293399 Dunne et al. Dec 2011 A1
20110298216 Ives et al. Dec 2011 A1
20110304148 Dunne et al. Dec 2011 A1
20110305518 Pearce et al. Dec 2011 A1
20120027522 Ives et al. Feb 2012 A1
20120175877 Ives et al. Jul 2012 A1
20120187680 Spooner et al. Jul 2012 A1
20120235412 Dunne et al. Sep 2012 A1
20120280506 Ives et al. Nov 2012 A1
20140102189 Dunne et al. Apr 2014 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (103)
Number Date Country
2388513 Aug 2000 CA
2352673 Jan 2003 CA
260699 Apr 1947 CH
146935 Aug 1983 CH
3116740 Nov 1982 DE
3638129 May 1988 DE
3718954 Dec 1988 DE
19948198 Apr 2001 DE
10101405 Jul 2002 DE
20308901 Sep 2003 DE
10244038 Apr 2004 DE
102007016380 Oct 2008 DE
102008032625 Aug 2009 DE
102008020965 Oct 2009 DE
1318299 Dec 2003 EP
1564455 Jan 2005 EP
1691377 Feb 2006 EP
1876350 Jan 2008 EP
1878912 Jan 2008 EP
1878913 Jan 2008 EP
1879280 Jan 2008 EP
1878911 Sep 2008 EP
1980670 Oct 2008 EP
1992741 Nov 2008 EP
1885047 Dec 2008 EP
2088311 Aug 2009 EP
2110910 Oct 2009 EP
2112370 Oct 2009 EP
1980746 Jun 2010 EP
2199199 Jun 2010 EP
2199598 Jun 2010 EP
2199599 Jun 2010 EP
2199601 Jun 2010 EP
2199602 Jun 2010 EP
2199603 Jun 2010 EP
2200170 Jun 2010 EP
2071709 Sep 2010 EP
2209175 Sep 2010 EP
2241749 Oct 2010 EP
2302204 Mar 2011 EP
2302755 Mar 2011 EP
2302766 Mar 2011 EP
2823177 Oct 2002 FR
2880389 Jan 2005 FR
2859495 Mar 2005 FR
204505 Oct 1923 GB
924347 Apr 1963 GB
980575 Jan 1965 GB
1131352 Oct 1968 GB
1413835 Nov 1975 GB
2316461 Feb 1998 GB
2344843 Jun 2000 GB
2408294 May 2005 GB
2431628 May 2007 GB
2434413 Jul 2007 GB
2447514 Sep 2008 GB
2471257 Dec 2010 GB
WO 2009127415 Oct 2009 IE
59203881 Nov 1984 JP
63055370 Mar 1988 JP
01043908 Feb 1989 JP
2000341818 Dec 2000 JP
2005069025 Mar 2005 JP
2005248822 Sep 2005 JP
2006094645 Apr 2006 JP
2007255614 Oct 2007 JP
2007291882 Nov 2007 JP
WO9844372 Oct 1998 WO
WO9852819 Nov 1998 WO
WO9966623 Dec 1999 WO
WO0077393 Dec 2000 WO
WO 0134973 May 2001 WO
WO0134977 May 2001 WO
WO02099950 Dec 2002 WO
WO03014561 Feb 2003 WO
WO03025385 Mar 2003 WO
WO03046375 Jun 2003 WO
WO2004015264 Feb 2004 WO
WO2004027257 Apr 2004 WO
WO2004107549 Dec 2004 WO
WO2004113717 Dec 2004 WO
WO2005045243 May 2005 WO
WO2005061887 Jul 2005 WO
WO2005078233 Aug 2005 WO
WO2005080789 Sep 2005 WO
WO2005116443 Dec 2005 WO
WO2006029496 Mar 2006 WO
WO2007043894 Apr 2007 WO
WO2007055585 May 2007 WO
WO2007083105 Jul 2007 WO
WO2007086814 Aug 2007 WO
WO2007125349 Nov 2007 WO
WO2008004877 Jan 2008 WO
WO2008006614 Jan 2008 WO
WO2008050149 May 2008 WO
WO2008081187 Jul 2008 WO
2008110811 Sep 2008 WO
WO2008127114 Oct 2008 WO
WO2009016409 Feb 2009 WO
WO2010118766 Oct 2010 WO
WO2011039249 Apr 2011 WO
WO2011039255 Apr 2011 WO
WO2011039267 Jul 2011 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (2)
Entry
Megson, T.H.G. Structural and Stress Analysis. Elsevier. p. 101-113. 1996.
International Search Report completed Feb. 15, 2012, from corresponding International Application No. PCT/EP2011/069623.
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20130343869 A1 Dec 2013 US