Hydrogen peroxide indicator and method

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 7481975
  • Patent Number
    7,481,975
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, July 14, 2004
    19 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, January 27, 2009
    15 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Original Assignees
  • Examiners
    • Warden; Jill
    • Chorbaji; Monzer R.
    Agents
    • Ersfeld; Dean A
Abstract
The present invention provides a hydrogen peroxide indicator that includes a substrate on which is disposed an indicator composition that includes at least one of a select group of colorants. As a result of contact with hydrogen peroxide, the colorants change color, and even become colorless, thereby providing an indication of the presence of hydrogen peroxide.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Medical instruments, particularly surgical instruments, are typically sterilized prior to use using steam or other sterilizing/disinfecting gases or liquids. A traditional sterilization process uses steam under pressure. Alternative sterilization processes use ethylene oxide or hydrogen peroxide in vapor form as the sterilant.


The use of hydrogen peroxide and other chemical vapor phase sterilization techniques typically involve operating temperatures well below those associated with steam sterilization. These “low temperature” technologies generally operate at temperatures below about 80° C., and often below about 65° C. For hydrogen peroxide sterilization, the sterilized goods are typically available for use shortly after the completion of the sterilization cycle. This is because the decomposition products (e.g., water and oxygen) are nontoxic. The potency of the hydrogen peroxide may be augmented by the presence of electrical energy in the form of an ionizing plasma field.


Sterilization indicators are used to monitor whether a sterilization process has been performed. Sterilization indicators typically include an indicator composition, carried on a substrate, that changes color during the sterilization process. Conventional indicators for hydrogen peroxide, however, often fade upon exposure to light. Thus, there is still a need for a suitable indicator that includes a color change composition for indicating the vapor phase sterilization of an article using hydrogen peroxide.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The present invention is directed to a method and indicator for detecting the presence of hydrogen peroxide in the vapor phase. The method and indicator are particularly well suited for monitoring whether a hydrogen peroxide sterilization process has been performed.


The present invention provides a hydrogen peroxide indicator that includes a substrate and an indicator composition disposed thereon, wherein the indicator composition includes at least one colorant selected from the group consisting of Malachite green oxalate, Crystal violet, Methyl violet 2B, Ethyl violet, New fuchsin, Victoria blue B, Victoria pure blue BO, Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Disperse blue 1, Brilliant blue R, Victoria blue R, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Methylene green, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Brilliant green, Spirit soluble HLK BASF, Victoria green S extra, Acid violet 17, Eriochrome black T, Eriochrome blue black B, D & C green no. 2, Spirit soluble fast RR, Spirit soluble fast red 3B, D & C red no. 22, Nitro red, Congo red, Brilliant cresyl blue ALD, Arsenazo 1, Basic red 29, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet, Methylene violet 3RAX, Mordant brown 1, Reactive black 5, Mordant brown 48, Acid brown AX987, Acid violet AX990, Basic red 15, Mordant red 19, Bromopyrogallol red, and combinations thereof.


Preferably, the colorant is selected from the group consisting of Ethyl violet, New fuchsin, Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Disperse blue 1, Brilliant blue R, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Methylene green, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Brilliant green, Spirit soluble HLK BASF, Victoria green S extra, Acid violet 17, Eriochrome black T, Eriochrome blue black B, D & C green no. 2, Spirit soluble fast RR, Spirit soluble fast red 3B, D & C red no. 22, Nitro red, Congo red, Brilliant cresyl blue ALD, Arsenazo 1, Basic red 29, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet, Methylene violet 3RAX, Mordant brown 1, Reactive black 5, Mordant brown 48, Acid brown AX987, Acid violet AX990, Mordant red 19, Bromopyrogallol red, and combinations thereof.


In a preferred embodiment the present invention provides a hydrogen peroxide indicator that includes a substrate and an indicator composition disposed thereon, wherein the indicator composition includes a binder, at least one colorant selected from the group consisting of Malachite green oxalate, Crystal violet, Methyl violet 2B, Ethyl violet, New fuchsin, Victoria blue B, Victoria pure blue BO, Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Disperse blue 1, Brilliant blue R, Victoria blue R, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Methylene green, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Brilliant green, Spirit soluble HLK BASF, Victoria green S extra, Acid violet 17, Eriochrome black T, Eriochrome blue black B, D & C green no. 2, Spirit soluble fast RR, Spirit soluble fast red 3B, D & C red no. 22, Nitro red, Congo red, Brilliant cresyl blue ALD, Arsenazo 1, Basic red 29, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet, Methylene violet 3RAX, Mordant brown 1, Reactive black 5, Mordant brown 48, Acid brown AX987, Acid violet AX990, Basic red 15, Mordant red 19, Bromopyrogallol red, and combinations thereof, and at least one colorant that does not change color upon contact with hydrogen peroxide vapor.


Methods of monitoring a hydrogen peroxide sterilization process is also provides. These methods include exposing an article to be sterilized and the hydrogen peroxide indicators as described herein to hydrogen peroxide vapor.







DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

The present invention provides a hydrogen peroxide indicator that includes a substrate on which is disposed an indicator composition that includes at least one of a select group of colorants. As a result of contact with hydrogen peroxide, the colorants change color, and even become colorless, thereby providing an indication of the presence of hydrogen peroxide.


In particular, the present invention is directed to a system for indicating exposure to a hydrogen peroxide vapor sterilization process. The indicator composition includes at least one component that is transformed (typically, chemically transformed) in the presence of vaporous hydrogen peroxide such that the color of the composition changes. The composition may include one or more components that change color upon contact with hydrogen peroxide, as well as other components that do not change color upon contact with hydrogen peroxide. For example, the composition preferably includes a polymeric binder to aid in applying the composition to a suitable substrate.


Indicators of the present invention are very useful in indicating when an article has been exposed to hydrogen peroxide in the vapor phase. Significantly, indicators of the present invention offer one a simple, yet effective means for indicating when a particular article has been subjected to sterilization using vaporous hydrogen peroxide.


Preferably, the indicator compositions of the present invention undergo a color change when exposed to an atmosphere above an aqueous solution containing 30 weight percent (wt-%) hydrogen peroxide at 50° C. within a period of at least about one hour and/or a color change when exposed to an atmosphere containing about 6 milligrams/liter (mg/l) to about 7 mg/l hydrogen peroxide (in an empty chamber, i.e., without articles to be sterilized) at a pressure of about 8×102 Pascals (Pa) to about 13.3×102 Pa and a temperature of about 45° C. to about 50° C. for a period of at least about 50 minutes, which are typical conditions within an empty commercial hydrogen peroxide plasma sterilizer. More preferably, for use in conventional sterilizers, the indicator compositions of the present invention undergo a color change when exposed to an atmosphere containing about 6 mg/l to about 7 mg/l hydrogen peroxide (in an empty chamber) at a pressure of about 8×102 Pa to about 13.3×102 Pa and a temperature of about 45° C. to about 50° C. for a period of at least about 50 minutes. As used herein, a color change includes becoming colorless.


Preferably, the indicator compositions do not significantly fade upon exposure to room lighting, e.g., fluorescent lighting. More preferably, the indicator compositions do not significantly fade, for example, upon exposure to sunlight through a window for one week or room lighting for two months.


Suitable colorants for use in the indicator compositions of the present invention include the following: Malachite green oxalate, Crystal violet, Methyl violet 2B, Ethyl violet, New fuchsin, Victoria blue B, Victoria pure blue BO, Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Disperse blue 1, Brilliant blue R, Victoria blue R, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Methylene green, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Brilliant green, Spirit soluble HLK BASF, Victoria green S extra, Acid violet 17, Eriochrome black T, Eriochrome blue black B, D & C green no. 2, Spirit soluble fast RR, Spirit soluble fast red 3B, D & C red no. 22, Nitro red, Congo red, Brilliant cresyl blue ALD, Arsenazo 1, Basic red 29, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet, Methylene violet 3RAX, Mordant, brown 1, Reactive black 5, Mordant brown 48, Acid brown AX987, Acid violet AX990, Basic red 15, Mordant red 19, and Bromopyrogallol red. Alternative names and Color Index Numbers for these colorants are listed in Tables 1 and 2 below. Various combinations of these colorants can be used in the indicator compositions of the present invention. Such mixtures or blends would increase the options available in color changes dramatically.


A preferred group of colorants include the following: Ethyl violet, New fuchsin, Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Disperse blue 1, Brilliant blue R, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Methylene green, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Brilliant green, Spirit soluble HLK BASF, Victoria green S extra, Acid violet 17, Eriochrome black T, Eriochrome blue black B, D & C green no. 2, Spirit soluble fast RR, Spirit soluble fast red 3B, D & C red no. 22, Nitro red, Congo red, Brilliant cresyl blue ALD, Arsenazo 1, Basic red 29, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet, Methylene violet 3RAX, Mordant brown 1, Reactive black 5, Mordant brown 48, Acid brown AX987, Acid violet AX990, Mordant red 19, Bromopyrogallol red, and combinations thereof.


Another preferred group of colorants include the following: Malachite green oxalate, Methyl violet 2B, New fuchsin, Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Brilliant green, Victoria green S extra, Eriochrome blue black B, Congo red, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet, Methylene violet 3RAX, Bromopyrogallol red, and combinations thereof.


Suitable colorants become colorless or change to a different color upon exposure to hydrogen peroxide vapor. Preferred are those colorants that show good contrast between the initial color and the color after exposure to hydrogen peroxide vapor. Examples include, Malachite green oxalate, Methyl violet 2B, New fuchsin, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Congo red, Eriochrome blue black B, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet 3RAX, and combinations thereof.


Another group of preferred colorants are those that become substantially colorless upon exposure to hydrogen peroxide vapors under conventional sterilization conditions (e.g., 6 mg/l to about 7 mg/l hydrogen peroxide in an empty chamber at a pressure of about 8×102 Pa to about 13.3×102 Pa and a temperature of about 45° C. to about 50° C. for a period of at least about 50 minutes) or to the more concentrated hydrogen peroxide vapors in a desiccator. Examples of such colorants include Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Victoria green S extra, Methylene violet, Bromopyrogallol red, Brilliant green, and combinations thereof.


Such colorants that become substantially colorless after exposure to hydrogen peroxide can also be used in combination with other colorants (e.g., dyes or pigments) that do not change color in the presence of hydrogen peroxide to give a chemical indicator with a suitable contrasting color change. For example, Alkali blue 6B plus a red unreactive dye such as Quinacridone red 19 show a color change from blue (initial) to pink, or a mixture of Brilliant green and Auramine O show a color change from bright green (initial) to bright yellow. In addition to Quinacridone red 19 and Auramine O, other sterilant-immune colored components may include those examples indicated in Tables 3A and 3B below.


Preferably, at least one colorant is present in the indicator composition in an amount sufficient to cause a color change when the composition is exposed to an atmosphere above an aqueous solution containing 30% hydrogen peroxide at 50° C. within a period of at least about one hour and/or an amount sufficient to cause a color change when exposed to an atmosphere containing about 6 mg/l to about 7 mg/l hydrogen peroxide (in an empty chamber) at a pressure of about 8×102 Pa to about 13.3×102 Pa and a temperature of about 45° C. to about 50° C. for a period of at least about 50 minutes. Generally, the compositions contain about 0.1 wt-% to about 5.0 wt-%, based on the total weight of the composition, of a colorant that changes color upon exposure to hydrogen peroxide.


In effect, the colorant concentration should be such as to allow a clear visual indication of a color change. If at least one colorant that does not change color upon exposure to hydrogen peroxide is used in the indicator compositions of the present invention, it is present in an amount sufficient to provide the targeted color intensity, both prior to and subsequent to exposure to hydrogen peroxide vapor. Generally, such compositions contain about 0.1 wt-% to about 5.0 wt-%, based on the total weight of the composition, of a colorant that does not change color upon exposure to hydrogen peroxide.


The indicating composition is generally formulated in the form of a dispersion or solution in water or an organic solvent (preferably, an organic solvent). The composition includes at least one colorant as described above as well as an organic binder. A wide variety of suitable binders can be used. Examples include synthetic or natural polymers or resins. Suitable binders are those that do not interfere with the function of the indicator composition. Examples include cellulose acetate butyrate, shellac, ethyl cellulose, methyl cellulose, acrylic resins, etc. A sufficient amount of binder is included in the compositions to provide adequate binding of the composition to a substrate on which it is disposed, while providing the desired rate of color change. Generally, the compositions contain about 20 wt-% to about 40 wt-% of a polymer binder, based on the total weight of the composition.


Indicator compositions of the present invention can also include other resins that do not necessarily function as a binder. For example, the compositions can include a resin that functions as a dispersing agent, such as Rhoplex I-545, a water based acrylic polymer, available from Rohm and Haas Corp., Philadelphia, Pa., that assists in dispersing the ingredients of the composition in the solvent used in application of the composition to a substrate. Indicator compositions of the present invention can also include opacifying agents such as titanium dioxide, surfactants, plasticizers, antifoam agents, and the like. For certain embodiments, a basic material such as an organic amine (e.g., triethanolamine) can be used to enhance sensitivity of the colorant to the low concentration of hydrogen peroxide in a conventional sterilizer. Typically, such additives are used in no more than about 5 wt-% based on the total weight of the indicator composition.


The compositions are typically applied to a substrate out of a solvent as discussed above. Suitable solvents include water and organic solvents such as ketones, esters, alcohols, and the like. Examples of suitable solvents include methyl ethyl ketone, n-propyl acetate, and isopropanol. The solvent is typically used in an amount of about up to about 15 wt-%, based on the total weight of the composition. The indicator composition can be applied to the substrate by a wide variety of techniques, including, for example, printing or coating by flexographic, gravure, screen, or die processes.


The substrate on which the indicator composition is disposed can be any of a wide variety. Typically, suitable substrates include polymeric materials, which may be pigmented or colorless, such as polyester, polyethylene, or polystyrene films, paper, and the like. Preferably, it is a Melinex™ polyester film from E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company, Wilmington, Del. The substrate may be in the form of a strip of material (e.g., a strip of material having the dimensions 2 cms by 13 cm). Optionally, the composition can be coated as a stripe over the length of the substrate strip. The substrate may also have an adhesive on the surface opposite that on which the indicator composition is disposed. In this way, the indicator may be used as a tape or label for attachment to the article to be sterilized


The vapor sterilization procedure used is conventional, and is disclosed in, for example U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,756,882, 4,643,876, 4,956,145, and 5,445,792, for example. Preferably, it is a plasma-based sterilization system.


In general, the article to be sterilized is placed in a sterilization chamber, and a dose of hydrogen peroxide, which generally comes pre-measured, is delivered to the chamber. Vapor is generated and allowed to fill the container for an appropriate length of time after which the sterilization is complete. The equipment and the entire procedure is generally controlled electronically. When sterilizing medical instruments, one cycle is often sufficient. The medical instruments are often packaged, with the entire package being placed into the sterilizing compartment. The package allows the hydrogen peroxide to penetrate and effect sterilization of the instruments, while subsequently protecting the instruments from contamination in air. The temperatures used in the process of the present invention are all generally less than 65° C.


The invention will be illustrated in greater detail by the following specific examples. It is understood that these examples are given by way of illustration and are not meant to limit the disclosure or the claims to follow. All percentages in the examples, and elsewhere in the specification, are by weight unless otherwise specified.


EXAMPLES
Example 1
Preparation of Indicator Compositions

Indicator compositions were prepared by mixing 70 grams of a shellac binder solution containing 60% weight percent of shellac in isopropanol (commercially available as 5 pound refined shellac in 99 percent isopropanol form Mantrose, Bradshaw and Zinsser Group, Westport, Conn.), 17.5 grams of dispersing resin (commercially available as Rhoplex I-545 from Rohm & Haas Corp., Philadelphia, Pa.), in 15 grams of isopropanol, with approximately 0.1 gram or a sufficient amount of colorant (0.1 wt-% to 5 wt-%) to give a good color of the colorants listed in Table 1. The indicator compositions were mixed in glass jars containing marbles. The glass jars were rolled for three hours on a roller mill.


Coating of Indicator Compositions

An indicator composition was coated on a plastic backing (commercially available as “3M Printable Polyester Film Label Stock” from Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Co., St. Paul, Minn.) using a number 16 Meyer bar (commercially available from R. D. Specialties, Webster, N.Y.). The coated ink was dried at 50° C. in an oven (commercially available as “Despatch Style V 29” from Despatch Oven Co., Minneapolis, Minn.) for 2 minutes. The coated film was cut using scissors to obtain indicators of approximately 2 cm by 13 cm.


Test Methods

One indicator composition was placed on an instrument tray lid and exposed to a full cycle of a hydrogen peroxide plasma sterilization procedure at 45-55° C. in a STERRAD™ 100SI GMP Sterilizer, obtained from Advanced Sterilization Products Co., Irvine, Calif. During the sterilization procedure a vacuum was drawn in the sterilization chamber for 5-6 minutes until the pressure was reduced to 40.0 Pa. A 1.8 ml aliquot of an aqueous solution of 58-60 percent hydrogen peroxide was then injected into the empty sterilization chamber over a period of about 6 minutes, yielding an empty chamber concentration of 6-7 mg/liter hydrogen peroxide. Hydrogen peroxide vapor was allowed to diffuse throughout the chamber for 44 minutes at 8×102 to 13.3×102 Pa. A vacuum was then drawn, reducing the pressure to 66.7 Pa and removing all detectable hydrogen peroxide vapor from the chamber. A plasma phase was then generated in the chamber by emitting an RF power source at 400 watts and 13.56 MHz for about 15-16 minutes at 66.7 Pa, after which the chamber was vented for 3-4 minutes until atmospheric pressure was reached in the chamber. After exposure to the sterilization procedure the indicators were removed from the tray lid and examined for color change. The results for each indicator composition are described in Table 1.


Some of the colorants were either the same color as they were initially or only slightly lighter, so another set of indicators were exposed to a higher concentration of hydrogen peroxide to determine if changing concentration would effect the results. A set of indicators were taped to a roll of film which was placed in a vented desiccator containing 80 ml of 30 weight percent (wt-%) hydrogen peroxide. The desiccator was placed in an oven (commercially available as “Despatch Style V 29” from Despatch Oven Co.) at 50° C. for one hour. The indicators were removed from the desiccator and examined for color change. The results for each indicator composition are also described in Table 1.









TABLE 1







Indicator Compositions



















Color Change





Color

Color Change
When in


Run


Index
Initial
when in
Desiccator


No.
Colorant
Colorant Class
No.
Color
Sterilizer
(30% H2O2)
















1

1Malachite green

Methane
4200
Blue/green
Pale green
Pale green



oxalate (Basic



green 4)


2

1Crystal violet

Methane
42555
Very Dark
Slightly Lighter
Lighter



(Gentian violet


Blue



or Hexamethyl-



pararosaniline



chloride


3

1Methyl violet

Methane
42535
Fuchsia
Lighter
Light lavender



2B (Basic violet



1)


4

1Ethyl violet

Methane
42600
Blue
No Change
Lighter



(Basic violet 4)


5

1New fuchsin

Anthraquinone
42520
Purple
Slightly lighter
Light pink



(Basic violet 2 or



Magenta III)


6

1Victoria blue B

Methane
44045
Royal blue
Lighter
Lighter



(Basic blue 26)


7

1Victoria pure

Methane
42595
Blue
Slightly Lighter
Lighter



blue BO (Basic



blue 7)


8

1Toluidine blue

Thiazine
52040
Pale blue
No Change
Colorless



O (BasicbBlue



17 or Tolonium



chloride)


9

1Luxol brilliant

Methane
None
Blue/green
Pale green
Almost



green BL




Colorless



(Solvent green



11)


10

1Disperse blue 1

Anthraquinone
46500
Royal Blue
More gray
Dark gray blue



(Solvent blue 18



or Celliton blue



extra)


11

1Brilliant blue R

Methane
42660
Blue
No Change
Lighter



(Acid blue 83 or



Coomassie



brilliant blue R)


12

1Victoria blue R

Methane
44040
Royal blue
Slightly Lighter
Lighter



(Basic blue 11)


13

1Quinea green B

Methane
42085
Green
Pale green
Very pale



(Acid green 3)




green


14

1Thionin

Thiazine
52000
Blue
No Change
Light gray



(Lauth's violet)


15

1Meldolas blue

Oxazine
51175
Dark lilac
Slightly Lighter
Pale beige


16

1Methylene

Thiazine
52020
Light blue
None
Very Pale blue



green


17

1Lissamine green

Methane
44090
Blue (teal)
Slightly Lighter
Pale blue



B (Acid Green



50 or Wool



Green S)


18

2Alkali blue 6B

Methane
42765
Blue
Light grey blue
Light blue



(Acid Blue 119)


19

1Brilliant Green

Methane
42040
Green
Pale green
Colorless



(Basic Green 1)






1Commercially available from Sigma-Aldrich Fine Chemicals, St. Louis, MO.




2Commercially available from ICN Biomedicals, Costa Mesa, CA.







Colorants that showed good contrast between the initial color and the color after exposure to hydrogen peroxide vapor are Malachite green oxalate, Methyl violet 2B, New fuchsin, Quinea green B, Thionin, Meldolas blue, Lissamine green B, and Alkali blue 6B.


Another set of preferred colorants for chemical indicators become colorless after exposure in the STERRAD™ Sterilizer or to the more concentrated hydrogen peroxide in a desiccator. Examples of these colorants include Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, and Brilliant green.


Example 2
Preparation of Indicator Compositions for Screening

A cellulose acetate butyrate binder was prepared by dissolving 15 grams of the cellulose acetate butyrate grade 553-0.4 resin (commercially available from Eastman Chemical Company, Kingsport, Tenn.) in 100 milliliters of methyl ethyl ketone. Indicator compositions were prepared by dissolving a sufficient amount (approximately 0.1 gram or more 0.1 wt-% to 5 wt-% of the colorants listed in Table 2 to give a good color in 15 milliliters of the binder.


The resulting indicator composition was coated as described for Example 1. Each indicator composition was exposed to a full cycle of a hydrogen peroxide plasma sterilization procedure in a STERRAD™ 100SI GMP Sterilizer as described in Example 1. The results for each indicator composition are described in Table 2.


As in Example 1 some of the colorants were either the same color as they were initially or only slightly lighter, so another set of indicators were exposed to a higher concentration of hydrogen peroxide to determine if changing concentration would effect the results. The results for each indicator composition are also described in Table 2.









TABLE 2







Indicator Compositions



















Color Change





Color

Color Change
when in


Run

Colorant
Index
Initial
When in
Desiccator


No.
Colorant
Class
No.
Color
Sterilizer
(30% H2O2)





20
Spirit soluble HLK BASF


Green
No Change
Slightly Lighter


21
Victoria green S extra


Dark green
Almost Colorless
Very Pale green


22

1Acid violet 17

Methane
42650
Purple
No Change
Lighter


23

1Eriochrome black T

Monazo
14645
D Brown
Slightly Lighter
None


24

1Eriochrome blue black B

Monazo
14640
Dark lilac
Lighter
Very Pale beige


25
D & C green no. 2


Green/blue
Pale green
Pale green


26
Spirit soluble fast RR


Purple
Slightly Lighter
No Change


27
Spirit soluble fast red 3B


Fuchsia
Slightly Lighter
Lighter


28
D & C red no. 22


Pink
No Change
Slightly Lighter


29

1Nitro red

Monazo
None
Lilac
Lighter
Lighter


30

1Congo red

Diazo
22120
Light red
Darker
Blue orange


31

1Brilliant cresyl blue ALD

Oxazine

Light blue
No Change
Lighter


32

1Arsenazo 1

Monazo
None
Very pale
No Change
Lighter






pink


33

1Basic red 29

Monazo
11460
Dark bold
No Change
Lighter






pink


34

1Bismarck brown R

Diazo
21010
Brown/gold
No Change
Significantly








Lighter


35
Methylene violet


Light purple
Darker
Colorless


36

1Methylene violet 3RAX

Diazine
50206
Fuchsia
No Change
Light pink


37

1Mordant brown 1

Diazo
20110
Brown
Lighter
None


38

1Reactive black 5

Diazo
20505
Very pale lilac
No Change
Light gray blue


39

1Mordant brown 48

Monoazo
11300
Red/brown
Slightly Lighter
Significantly








Lighter


40

2Acid brown AX987



Lilac
Light blue
Light blue


41

2Acid violet AX990


41001
Dark lavender
Blue
Blue


42

2Basic red 15



Red/pink
Lighter
Pale pink


43
Mordant red 19


Beige
Lighter
Lighter


44

1Bromopyrogallol red

Methane
None
Lilac
Pale beige
Colorless






1Commercially available from Sigma-Aldrich Fine Chemicals, St. Louis, MO.




2Commercially available from Spectra, Kearny, NJ.




3Commercially available from ICN Biomedicals, Costa Mesa, CA.







Colorants that showed good contrast between the initial color and the color after exposure to hydrogen peroxide vapor are Eriochrome blue black B, Congo red, Bismarck brown R, and Methylene violet 3RAX.


Another set of preferred colorants for chemical indicators become colorless after exposure in the STERRAD™ Sterilizer or to the more concentrated hydrogen peroxide in a desiccator. Examples of these colorants include Victoria green S extra, Methylene violet, and Bromopyrogallol red.


Comparative Examples

The colorants listed in Table 3A were used to make chemical indicators as described in Example 1. While the colorants listed in Table 3B were used to make chemical indicators as described in Example 2. Each indicator composition was exposed to a full cycle of a hydrogen peroxide plasma sterilization procedure in a STERRAD™ 100SI GMP Sterilizer as described in Example 1. The results for each indicator composition are described in Table 3A or 3B.


As in Example 1, some of the colorants were either the same color as they were initially or only slightly lighter. Thus, another set of indicators were exposed to a higher concentration of hydrogen peroxide to determine if changing concentration would effect the results. The results for each indicator composition are also described in Table 3A or 3B.









TABLE 3A







Colorants for Indicator Compositions
















Color


Color Change


Run

Colorant
Index
Initial
Color Change
in Desiccator


No.
Colorant
Class
No.
Color
in Sterilizer
(30% H2O2)





1

1Brilliant blue G (Acid Blue 90 or

Methane
42655
Blue
No Change
No Change



Coomassie Brilliant Blue G 250)


2

1Acid black 24

Diazo
26370
Grey
No Change
No Change


3

2Patent blue violet

Methane

Blue
No Change
No Change


4

1Disperse red 13 (Celliton Scarlet B)

Monoazo
11115
Purple
No Change
No Change


5

1Sudan black B

Diazo
26150
Blue/Black
No Change
No Change


6

1Janus green B

Monoazo
11050
Blue
No Change
No Change


7

1Acridine orange base (Solvent

Acridine
46005
Orange
No Change
No Change



Orange 15)


8

1Fast green FCF (Food Green 3)

Methane
42053
Blue (teal)
No Change
No Change


9

1Patent blue VF (Acid Blue 1)

Methane
42045
Dark blue

No Change






1Commercially available from Sigma-Aldrich Fine Chemicals, St. Louis, MO.




2Commercially available from ICN Biomedicals, Costa Mesa, CA.














TABLE 3B







Colorants for Indicator Compositions



















Color





Color

Color
Change in


Run


Index
Initial
Change in
Desiccator


No.
Colorant
Colorant Class
No.
Color
Sterilizer
(30% H2O2)





10

1Acid red 97

Diazo
22890
Red/orange
No Change
No Change


11

1Sulforhodamine B

Xanthene
45100
Dark pink
No Change
No Change


12
Xylenol orange sodium salt


Light pink
No Change
No Change


13
Azure B


Pale blue
No Change
No Change


14
Spirit soluble fast yellow G


Yellow
No Change
No Change


15

3Keystone soap fluoro green



Blue/green
No Change
No Change


16

3Calco oil blue N


None
Blue
No Change
No Change


17

3Oil blue A



Light blue
No Change
No Change


18

3Calco oil green



Green
No Change
No Change


19

3D & C red no. 33

Monoazo
17200
Pink
No Change
No Change


20

3D & C green no. 5

Anthraquinone
61570
Pale blue
No Change
No Change


21
Bordeaux R


Light pink
No Change
No Change


22

1Xylenol cyanole FF

Methane
42135
Blue
No Change
No Change


23
Crystal scarlet


Light pink
No Change
No Change


24
Basic blue 41


Dark blue
No Change
No Change


25

1Evans blue

Diazo
23860
Blue
No Change
No Change


26

1Chicago sky blue 6B

Diazo
24410
Blue
No Change
No Change


27

1Acid blue 113

Diazo
26360
Blue
No Change
No Change


28

1Acid blue 120

Diazo
26400
Grey/blue
No Change


29
Acid red 88


Dark pink
No Change
No Change


30
Acid red 151


Red/pink
No Change
No Change


31

1Acid violet 5

Monoazo
18125
Dark
No Change
No Change






lavender


32

1Disperse red 1

Monoazo
11110
Red/orange
No Change
No Change


33
Direct red 81


Pale pink
No Change
No Change


34

1Disperse red 19

Monoazo
11130
Dark
No Change
No Change






orange


35

1Sudan red 7B

Diazo
26050
Dark pink
No Change
No Change


36

2Basic red 73



Light red
No Change
No Change


37

3Acid green AX986



Lime green
No Change
No Change






1Commercially available from Sigma-Aldrich Fine Chemicals, St. Louis, MO.




2Commercially available from Spectra, Kearny, NJ.




3Commercially available from ICN Biomedicals, Costa Mesa, CA.







Example 4

A preferred composition was prepared as described in Example 1 using the components and the amounts given in Table 4. The resulting indicator composition was coated as described for Example 1. Each indicator composition was exposed to a full cycle of a hydrogen peroxide plasma sterilization procedure in a STERRAD™ 100SI GMP Sterilizer as described in Example 1.












TABLE 4








Weight



Indicator Composition
Percent









Shellac Binder
70.2



Rhoplex I-545 Water based Acrylic Polymer Resin
23.0



Alkali Blue 6B
00.6



Quinacridone red 19 available as Sunfast Red 19
00.3



Triethanolamine
02.0



Isopropanol
03.9










Colorants that become colorless after exposure in the STERRAD™ Sterilizer or to the more concentrated hydrogen peroxide in a desiccator can be used in combination with dyes or pigments which are stable to hydrogen peroxide to give a chemical indicator with a suitable contrasting color change. For example, Alkali blue 6B plus a red unreactive dye such as Quinacridone red 19 (commercially available as Sunfast Red 19 from Sun Chemical Corporation, Cincinnati, Ohio) showed a color change from blue (initial) to pink after exposure in the STERRAD™ Sterilizer. Another example was made by combining Brilliant green and Auramine O (commercially available from Sigma Aldrich Fine Chemicals, St. Louis, Mo.) which showed a color change from bright green (initial) to bright yellow after exposure in the STERRAD™ Sterilizer.


The complete disclosures of the patents, patent documents, and publications cited herein are incorporated by reference in their entirety as if each were individually incorporated. Various modifications and alterations to this invention will become apparent to those skilled in the art without departing from the scope and spirit of this invention. It should be understood that this invention is not intended to be unduly limited by the illustrative embodiments and examples set forth herein and that such examples and embodiments are presented by way of example only with the scope of the invention intended to be limited only by the claims set forth herein as follows.

Claims
  • 1. A hydrogen peroxide sterilization indicator comprising a substrate and an indicator composition disposed thereon, wherein the indicator composition comprises:at least one first colorant selected from the group consisting of Ethyl violet, New fuchsin, Victoria blue B, Victoria pure blue BO, Toluidine blue O, Luxol brilliant green BL, Disperse blue 1, Brilliant blue R, Victoria blue R, Quinea green B, Meldolas blue, Lissamine green B, Alkali blue 6B, Brilliant green, Spirit soluble HLK BASF, Victoria green S extra, Acid violet 17, Eriochrome black T, Eriochrome blue black B, D & C green no. 2, Spirit soluble fast RR, Spirit soluble fast red 3B, D & C red no. 22, Nitro red, Congo red, Brilliant cresyl blue ALD, Arsenazo 1, Basic red 29, Bismarck brown R, Methylene violet, Methylene violet 3RAX, Mordant brown 1, Reactive black 5, Mordant brown 48, Acid brown AX987, Acid violet AX990, Basic red 15, Mordant red 19, Bromopyrogallol red, and combinations thereof; andat least one second colorant that does not change color upon contact with hydrogen peroxide vapor, wherein the second colorant that does not change color upon contact with hydrogen peroxide vapor is selected from the group consisting off Quinacridone red 19, Auramine O, Brilliant blue G, Acid black 24, Patent blue violet, Disperse red 13, Sudan black B, Janus green B, Acridine orange base, Fast green FCF, Patent blue VF, Acid red 97, Sulforhodamine B, Xylenol orange sodium salt, Azure B, Spirit soluble fast yellow G, Keystone soap fluoro green, Calco oil blue N, Oil blue A, Calco oil green, D & C red no. 33, D & C green no. 5, Bordeaux R, Xylenol cyanole FF, Crystal scarlet, Basic blue 41, Evans blue, Chicago sky blue 6B, Acid blue 113, Acid blue 120, Acid red 88, Acid red 151, Acid violet 5, Disperse red 1, Direct red 81, Disperse red 19, Sudan red 7B, Basic red 73, Acid green AX986, and combinations thereof;and further wherein the composition changes color in the presence of hydrogen peroxide, and wherein the indicator composition comprises Alkali blue 6B as the at least one first colorant and Quinacridone red 19 as the at least one second colorant.
  • 2. The hydrogen peroxide sterilization indicator of claim 1, wherein the substrate is a polyester film.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This is a continuation of patent application Ser. No. 09/453,726, filed on Dec. 2, 1999, which is now allowed, hereby incorporated herein by reference.

US Referenced Citations (37)
Number Name Date Kind
4046577 Muzyczko et al. Sep 1977 A
4155895 Rohowetz et al. May 1979 A
4298569 Read Nov 1981 A
4362645 Hof et al. Dec 1982 A
4643876 Jacobs et al. Feb 1987 A
4756758 Lent et al. Jul 1988 A
4756882 Jacobs et al. Jul 1988 A
4863627 Davies et al. Sep 1989 A
4892706 Kralovic et al. Jan 1990 A
4956145 Cummings et al. Sep 1990 A
5053339 Patel Oct 1991 A
5087659 Fujisawa Feb 1992 A
5139957 Grack Aug 1992 A
5352282 Miller Oct 1994 A
5378430 Nieves et al. Jan 1995 A
5445792 Rickloff et al. Aug 1995 A
5482684 Martens et al. Jan 1996 A
5518927 Malchesky et al. May 1996 A
5620656 Wensky et al. Apr 1997 A
5942438 Antonoplos et al. Aug 1999 A
5955025 Barrett Sep 1999 A
5990199 Bealing et al. Nov 1999 A
6063631 Ignacio May 2000 A
D433511 Nieves Nov 2000 S
D438980 Hehenberger Mar 2001 S
D439344 Hehenberger Mar 2001 S
6218189 Antonoplos et al. Apr 2001 B1
6238623 Amhof et al. May 2001 B1
6267242 Nagata et al. Jul 2001 B1
6287518 Ignacio et al. Sep 2001 B1
6346417 Ignacio et al. Feb 2002 B1
6352837 Witcher et al. Mar 2002 B1
6410338 Lippold et al. Jun 2002 B1
6440744 Ignacio et al. Aug 2002 B1
6488890 Kircokf Dec 2002 B1
6551555 Antonoplos et al. Apr 2003 B2
20020151084 Lippold et al. Oct 2002 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (17)
Number Date Country
273 775 Jul 1988 DE
273776 Nov 1989 DE
0 914 833 Dec 1999 EP
1052507 Nov 2000 EP
1 465 671 Dec 2005 EP
49-046440 Dec 1974 JP
11-178904 Jul 1999 JP
WO 9222806 Dec 1992 WO
WO 9633242 Oct 1996 WO
WO 9846279 Oct 1998 WO
WO 9846994 Oct 1998 WO
WO 9852621 Nov 1998 WO
WO 9858683 Dec 1998 WO
WO 0050634 Aug 2000 WO
WO 0061200 Oct 2000 WO
WO 0073783 Dec 2000 WO
WO 0140792 Jun 2001 WO
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20040265170 A1 Dec 2004 US
Continuations (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 09453726 Dec 1999 US
Child 10890612 US