Ignition apparatus having feature for shielding the HV terminal

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6724289
  • Patent Number
    6,724,289
  • Date Filed
    Friday, August 17, 2001
    23 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, April 20, 2004
    20 years ago
Abstract
An ignition apparatus includes a high voltage (HV) terminal formed of stamped sheet metal configured to be disposed in a secondary winding spool, and to which a high voltage end of the secondary winding is attached and soldered. The ignition apparatus further includes an electrically conductive cup configured to surround the high voltage terminal when the secondary winding spool is inserted in the case. The high voltage terminal has one end that comes into engagement with an inner annular surface of the cup. The cup includes an annular sidewall that extends axially up to a winding flange where a HV end of the secondary winding exits a winding bay thereby surrunding the exiting HV secondary winding wire. The cup provides for a reduced electric field concentration.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Technical Field




The present invention relates generally to an ignition apparatus for developing a spark firing voltage that is applied to one or more spark plugs of an internal combustion engine.




2. Discussion of the Background Art




Ignition coils are known for use in connection with an internal combustion engine such as an automobile engine, and which include a primary winding, a secondary winding, and a magnetic circuit. The magnetic circuit conventionally may comprise a cylindrical-shaped, central core extending along an axis, located radially inwardly of the primary and secondary windings and magnetically coupled thereto. The components are contained in a case formed of electrical insulating material, with an outer core or shield located outside of the case. One end of the secondary winding is conventionally configured to produce a relatively high voltage when a primary current through the primary winding is interrupted. In a common configuration, insulating resin or the like is introduced into the gap between the secondary winding and the case for insulating purposes. The high voltage end is coupled to a spark plug, as known, that is arranged to generate a discharge spark responsive to the high voltage. It is further known to provide relatively slender ignition coil configuration that is adapted for mounting directly above the spark plug—commonly referred to as a “pencil” coil.




One problem in the design of ignition coils, particularly pencil coils, involves a relatively high electrical field concentration at a location where the high voltage end of the secondary winding is terminated to a high voltage (HV) secondary terminal associated to a secondary winding spool. The relatively high electrical field concentration may be magnified by any burr, sharp edge, or solder icicle that may be formed on the terminal.




In addition, to connect the high voltage end of the secondary winding to the HV secondary terminal, the wire end must leave a so-called winding bay (i.e., the winding surface on the spool between upper and lower flanges). Outside the winding bay, the secondary winding wire creates a high density electric field therearound. As a consequence, the increased electrical field concentration, over time, may result in an electrical tree or dendrite forming off of the secondary winding, which may propagate through the insulating resin. After the dendrite grows far enough, for example toward ground potential (i.e., through the resin and case to the shield), the high voltage secondary winding will short to ground and the ignition coil will fail.




U.S. Pat. No. 6,208,231 issued to Oosuka et al. entitled “STICK-TYPE IGNITION COIL HAVING IMPROVED STRUCTURE AGAINST CRACK OR DIELECTRIC DISCHARGE,” discloses an ignition coil wherein a high voltage end of the secondary coil is electrically connected to a dummy coil, which is then electrically connected to a terminal plate. A high voltage connector configured for connection to a spark plug is then connected to the terminal plate. Oosuka et al. disclose the contention that since the secondary coil and the terminal plate are electrically connected through not a single connection but rather through the dummy coil, the surface area of the electrically connected portion between the secondary coil and the terminal plate is enlarged so as to avoid the concentration of electrical field. However, Oosuka et al. still disclose that the high voltage end of the dummy coil is electrically connected to the terminal plate by fusing or soldering. Additionally, the secondary winding wire as it leaves the winding bay still presents a relatively thin profile, wherein a high electric field is maintained. Accordingly, it is believed that the same problems described above continue to exist in the design of Oosuka et al.




Accordingly, there is a need for an improved ignition apparatus that minimizes or eliminates one or more of the problems as set forth above.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




An object of the present invention is to solve one or more of the problems as set forth above. An ignition apparatus according to the present invention overcomes shortcomings of conventional ignition apparatus by including an electrically conductive cup absent of sharp edges, burrs, or the like, which makes contact with a portion of a high voltage terminal. The cup also surrounds the high voltage terminal and the secondary winding wire as it exits the winding bay (i.e., it extends, in an axial direction, up to a lower winding flange). Because the cup is at the same voltage potential as the high voltage terminal, there will not be an electric field concentration in and around the area of the high voltage terminal. Additionally, since the cup extends up to the winding flange, the secondary connection wire is also surrounded, reducing the electric field in that region. The reduction in electric field concentration reduces or eliminates formation of dendrites which, as described in the Background, may over time result in ignition coil failures.




An ignition apparatus according to the present invention comprises a central core having a main axis, and primary and secondary windings outwardly of the central core. The secondary winding is wound on a secondary winding spool having a winding surface and at least one flange. The flange is provided to cooperate with the winding surface to receive the secondary winding. A high voltage end of the secondary winding is connected to a high voltage terminal located away from the winding surface. According to the invention, a cup formed of metal material engages the high voltage terminal on an inner surface thereof. The cup is configured to be contacted by a connector assembly that is itself suitable for connection to a spark plug. The cup surrounds the HV terminal, and, significantly, extends axially up to the winding flange also surrounding the secondary winding wire as it exits the winding surface. The cup being free of sharp edges and the like, as well as surrounding the secondary winding wire, reduces electrical field concentrations.




A method of making an ignition apparatus including the aforementioned conductive cup is also presented.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The present invention will now be described by way of example, with reference to the accompanying drawings.





FIG. 1

is a simplified cross-sectional view of an ignition apparatus having a conductive cup high voltage terminal arrangement according to the present invention.





FIG. 2

is a simplified cross-sectional view showing a portion of the cup of FIG.


1


.





FIG. 3

is a simplified perspective view of the apparatus of

FIG. 1

, with portions broken away, showing a connection to a HV terminal.





FIG. 4

is a simplified cross-sectional view taken substantially along lines


4





4


in

FIG. 3

showing the HV terminal contacting the conductive cup.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




Referring now to the drawings wherein like reference numerals are used to identify identical components in the various views,

FIG. 1

is a simplified, cross-section view of an ignition apparatus or coil


10


in accordance with the present invention. As is generally known, ignition apparatus


10


may be coupled to, for example, an ignition system


12


, which contains primary energization circuitry for controlling the charging and discharging of ignition apparatus


10


. Further, the relatively high voltage produced by ignition apparatus


10


is provided to a spark plug


14


for producing a spark across a spark gap thereof, which may be employed to initiate combustion in a combustion chamber of an engine. Ignition system


12


and spark plug


14


perform conventional functions well known to those of ordinary skill in the art.




Ignition apparatus


10


is adapted for installation to a conventional internal combustion engine through a spark plug well onto a high-voltage terminal of spark plug


14


, which may be retained by a threaded engagement with a spark plug opening into the above-described combustion cylinder. The engine may provide power for locomotion of a self-propelled vehicle, such as an automotive vehicle.





FIG. 1

further shows a core


16


, an optional first magnet


18


, an optional second magnet


20


, an electrical module


22


, a primary winding


24


, a first layer of encapsulant such as an epoxy potting material layer


26


, a secondary winding spool


28


, a secondary winding


30


, a second layer


32


of encapsulant such as epoxy potting material, a case


34


, a shield assembly


36


, a first electrically conductive cup


37


, a low-voltage (LV) connector body


38


, and a high-voltage (HV) connector assembly


40


. Core


16


includes a top end


42


and a bottom end


44


. Connector assembly


40


may include an inductive resistor


41


, a second conductive cup


43


, and a spring


68


.

FIG. 1

further shows a rubber buffer cup


46


, a winding surface


47


of spool


28


, annular flange portions


48


,


50


, a high voltage (HV) secondary terminal


52


, a boot


54


, and a seal member


56


.




As described in the Background, a significant failure mode for conventional pencil coils results from a high electric field intensity where the high voltage end of the secondary winding is brought out of the winding bay and routed to the HV secondary terminal. Over time, with such conventional arrangements, dendrites form, and grow through the insulating epoxy and case toward ground potential (e.g., toward the shield element). Once the insulating resin and/or case material has been compromised, the high voltage secondary winding can short to ground, thus failing the ignition coil.




Conductive cup


37


is made so as to not have sharp edges, burrs, or the like. The cup is in electrical contact with the high voltage terminal, and is therefore at the same electrical potential or voltage. Significantly, the cup has annular sidewalls that extend axially up to the lower winding flange


50


. Accordingly, the aforementioned electric field concentration is reduced relative to the prior art.





FIG. 2

shows a portion of

FIG. 1

containing cup


37


in greater detail. The HV terminal


52


may be of the conventional stamped sheet metal type (e.g., 1008 steel) that is associated with secondary spool


28


, and to which a high voltage end of secondary winding


30


is terminated.




Cup


37


, generally, is configured in size and shape to be pressed or molded onto a lower axial portion of spool


28


. Cup


37


is manufactured in such a way so as to not have any sharp edges, burrs, or the like. These manufacturing approaches include but are not limited to machining and stamping, coupled with, for example, a vibratory finishing.




Cup


37


has a longitudinal axis associated therewith and is generally annular in shape. Cup


37


further includes a base


58


, and a first, generally annular side wall


59


extending therefrom in a first axial direction to a folded over (hemmed) edge


60


that defines an opening leading to an interior of the cup. The interior is configured to receive a lower longitudinal end of secondary winding spool


28


. The lower end of spool


28


is configured to receive the high voltage terminal


52


. The interior is defined, in-part, by an inner, generally annular surface of sidewall


59


. The axial extent of sidewall


59


is such that it extends all the way up to flange


50


when cup


37


is placed on spool


28


(so that base


58


engages spool


28


).




Cup


37


further includes a second annular side wall


61


extending from base


58


in a second axial direction opposite the first axial direction. In the illustrated embodiment, cup


37


includes an annular aperture


62


having a stop surface


63


. Aperture


62


is configured in size and shape to receive an end of resistor


41


in a press fit (interference fit).




Significantly, however, cup


37


is formed out of stamped sheet metal, which is subjected to a drawing and forming operation to arrive at the result shown in

FIGS. 1-4

. Fold


60


exhibits a relatively large radii, so as to maintain a reduced electric field (i.e., eliminate sharp edges). In addition, since sidewall


59


extends up to flange


50


, the cup surrounds the secondary winding


30


as it exits winding surface


47


. Cup


37


may be formed out of aluminum, brass, or other suitable electrically conductive material.





FIG. 3

is a perspective of ignition apparatus


10


, with portions broken away. Secondary winding


30


exits the winding bay through an axially extending passage


65


. In the illustrated embodiment, terminal


52


comprises a wire that is square shaped in cross-sectional. Terminal


52


is inserted in a bore


53


formed in spool


28


. A high voltage end of winding


30


, designated


30




HV


, is terminated on end


52




1


of terminal


52


, for example, via multiple turns, accompanied by a conventional soldering process.




With reference to

FIG. 4

, when secondary spool


28


is inserted and pressed longitudinally downwardly into case


34


, terminal


52


will go down into an interior portion of cup


37


. A first end


52




1


, is bent over after the high voltage end


30




HV


is terminated thereto. The second end


52




2


is also bent over; however, the shape and dimensions of spool


28


and cup


37


are selected so that end


52




2


engages cup


37


when cup


37


is placed over the bottom of spool


28


. The shape of spool


28


and dimensions are further selected so that end


52




1


does not touch cup


37


. Terminal end


52




2


and cup


37


will be in positive electrical contact. Because cup


37


is at substantially the same voltage potential as high voltage terminal


52


, and cup


37


surrounds terminal


52


, there will be a substantially reduced or eliminated electric field concentration at terminal


52


. Moreover, since cup


37


has sidewalls


59


that extend axially up to flange


50


(best shown in FIGS.


2


-


3


), the wire exiting the secondary winding bay is also surrounded. This has the advantage of reducing the concentrated electric field surrounding the thin wire.




As to additional advantages, solder tips and sharp edges that are present at the point where the secondary winding is terminated (e.g., end


52




1


), and which arise due to conventional manufacturing processes can now be tolerated. In addition, the design of an ignition apparatus according to the invention will also be robust as to the bend position of terminal


52




1


, so that the position of terminal


52




1


will now not have to be as controlled. In conventional arrangements, if high voltage terminal end


52




1


were not bent over far enough, the radially outermost portions thereof would be closer to case


34


, and would result in a higher electric field. As to cost advantages, an ignition apparatus according to the invention is less expensive to manufacture since certain manufacturing equipment can be eliminated, such as (i) that required to eliminate sharp solder points, (ii) that needed to measure the HV terminal bend position. Finally, in an internal combustion engine environment, the reduced electric field will result in lower ignition apparatus failures, and accordingly a lower warranty return rate. These improvements result by the substantial reduction or elimination of case punch-through failures (i.e., dendrite growth through insulating resin material, through case material, to ground potential, namely, the outer core or shield). The reduced electric field concentration will also extend the service life of the ignition apparatus.




Referring again to

FIG. 1

, further details concerning ignition apparatus


10


will now be set forth configured to enable one to practice the present invention. It should be understood that portions of the following are exemplary only and not limiting in nature. Many other configurations are known to those of ordinary skill in the art and are consistent with the teachings of the present invention. Central core


16


may be elongated, having a main, longitudinal axis “A” associated therewith. Core


16


includes an upper, first end


42


, and a lower, second end


44


. Core


16


may be a conventional core known to those of ordinary skill in the art. As illustrated, core


16


, in the preferred embodiment, takes a generally cylindrical shape (which is a generally circular shape in radial cross-section), and may comprise compression molded insulated iron particles or laminated steel plates, both as known.




Magnets


18


and


20


may be optionally included in ignition apparatus


10


as part of the magnetic circuit, and provide a magnetic bias for improved performance. The construction of magnets such as magnets


18


and


20


, as well as their use and effect on performance, is well understood by those of ordinary skill in the art. It should be understood that magnets


18


and


20


are optional in ignition apparatus


10


, and may be omitted, albeit with a reduced level of performance, which may be acceptable, depending on performance requirements.




A rubber buffer cup


46


may be included.




Module


22


may be configured to perform a switching function, such as connecting and disconnecting an end of primary winding to ground.




Primary winding


24


may be wound directly onto core


16


in a manner known in the art. Primary winding


24


includes first and second ends and is configured to carry a primary current I


P


for charging apparatus


10


upon control of ignition system


12


of module


22


. Winding


24


may be implemented using known approaches and conventional materials. Although not shown, primary winding


24


may be wound on a primary winding spool (not shown) in certain circumstances (e.g., when steel laminations are used). In addition, winding


24


may be wound on an electrically insulating layer that is itself disposed directly on core


16


.




Layers


26


and


32


comprise an encapsulant suitable for providing electrical insulation within ignition apparatus


10


. In a preferred embodiment, the encapsulant comprises epoxy potting material. The epoxy potting material introduced in layers


26


, and


32


may be introduced into annular potting channels defined (i) between primary winding


24


and secondary winding spool


28


, and, (ii) between secondary winding


30


and case


34


. The potting channels are filled with potting material, in the illustrated embodiment, up to approximately the level designated “L” in FIG.


1


. In one embodiment, layer


26


may be between about 0.1 mm and 1.0 mm thick. Of course, a variety of other thicknesses are possible depending on flow characteristics and insulating characteristics of the encapsulant and the design of the coil


10


. The potting material also provides protection from environmental factors which may be encountered during the service life of ignition apparatus


10


. There is a number of suitable epoxy potting materials well known to those of ordinary skill in the art.




Secondary winding spool


28


is configured to receive and retain secondary winding


30


. In addition to the features described above, spool


28


is further characterized as follows. Spool


28


is disposed adjacent to and radially outwardly of the central components comprising core


16


, primary winding


24


, and epoxy potting layer


26


, and, preferably, is in coaxial relationship therewith. Spool


28


may comprise any one of a number of conventional spool configurations known to those of ordinary skill in the art. In the illustrated embodiment, spool


28


is configured to receive one continuous secondary winding (e.g., progressive winding) on an outer winding surface thereof, between upper and lower flanges


48


and


50


(“winding bay”), as is known. However, it should be understood that other configurations may be employed, such as, for example only, a configuration adapted for use with a segmented winding strategy (e.g., a spool of the type having a plurality of axially spaced ribs forming a plurality of channels therebetween for accepting windings) as known.




The depth of the secondary winding in the illustrated embodiment may decrease from the top of spool


28


(i.e., near the upper end


42


of core


16


), to the other end of spool


28


(i.e., near the lower end


44


) by way of a progressive gradual flare of the spool body. The result of the flare or taper is to increase the radial distance (i.e., taken with respect to axis “A”) between primary winding


24


and secondary winding


30


, progressively, from the top to the bottom. As is known in the art, the voltage gradient in the axial direction, which increases toward the spark plug end (i.e., high voltage end) of the secondary winding, may require increased dielectric insulation between the secondary and primary windings, and, may be provided for by way of the progressively increased separation between the secondary and primary windings.




Spool


28


is formed generally of electrical insulating material having properties suitable for use in a relatively high temperature environment. For example, spool


28


may comprise plastic material such as PPO/PS (e.g., NORYL available from General Electric) or polybutylene terephthalate (PBT) thermoplastic polyester. It should be understood that there are a variety of alternative materials that may be used for spool


28


known to those of ordinary skill in the ignition art, the foregoing being exemplary only and not limiting in nature.




Features


48


and


50


may be further configured so as to engage an inner surface of case


34


to locate, align, and center the spool


28


in the cavity of case


34


and providing upper and lower defining features for a winding surface therebetween.




As described above, spool


28


has associated therewith an electrically conductive (i.e., metal) high-voltage (HV) terminal


52


disposed therein configured to engage cup


37


, which cup is in turn electrically connected to the HV connector assembly


40


. The body of spool


28


at a lower end thereof is configured so as to be press-fit into the interior of cup


37


(i.e., the spool gate portion).





FIG. 1

also shows secondary winding


30


in cross-section. Secondary winding


30


, as described above, is wound on spool


28


, and includes a low voltage end and a high voltage end


30




HV


. The low voltage end may be connected to ground by way of a ground connection through LV connector body


38


in a manner known to those of ordinary skill in the art. The high voltage end


30




HV


is connected to HV terminal


52


as shown in FIG.


3


. Winding


30


may be implemented using conventional approaches and material known to those of ordinary skill in the art.




Case


34


includes an inner, generally enlarged cylindrical surface, an outer surface, a first annular shoulder, a flange, an upper through-bore, and a lower through bore.




The inner surface of case


34


is configured in size to receive and retain spool


28


which contains the core


16


and primary winding


24


. The inner surface of case


34


may be slightly spaced from spool


28


, particularly the annular features


48


,


50


thereof (as shown), or may engage the features


48


,


50


.




Lower through-bore


64


(best shown in

FIG. 2

) is defined by an inner surface thereof configured in size and shape (i.e., generally cylindrical) to accommodate an outer surface of cup


37


at a lowermost portion thereof as described above. When the lowermost body portion of spool


28


is inserted in the lower bore containing cup


37


, a portion of HV terminal


52




2


engages an inner surface of cup


37


(also via a press fit) as best shown in FIG.


4


.




Case


34


is formed of electrical insulating material, and may comprise conventional materials known to those of ordinary skill in the art (e.g., the PBT thermoplastic polyester material referred to above).




Shield


36


is generally annular in shape and is disposed radially outwardly of case


34


, and, preferably, engages an outer surface of case


34


. The shield


36


preferably comprises electrically conductive material, and, more preferably metal, such as silicon steel or other adequate magnetic material. Shield


36


provides not only a protective barrier for ignition apparatus


10


generally, but, further, provides a magnetic path for the magnetic circuit portion of ignition apparatus


10


. Shield


36


may be grounded by way of an internal grounding strap, finger or the like (not shown) well know to those of ordinary skill in the art. Shield


36


may comprise multiple, individual sheets


36


, as shown.




Low voltage connector body


38


via module


22


is configured to, among other things, electrically connect the first and second ends of primary winding


24


to an energization source, such as, the energization circuitry (e.g., power source) included in ignition system


12


. Connector body


38


is generally formed of electrical insulating material, but also includes a plurality of electrically conductive output terminals


66


(e.g., pins for ground, primary winding leads, etc.). Terminals


66


are coupled electrically, internally through connector body


38


to module


22


and other portions of apparatus


10


, in a manner known to those of ordinary skill in the art.




HV connector assembly


40


is provided for establishing an electrical connection to spark plug


14


. Assembly


40


may include an inductive resistor


41


, a second conductive cup


43


and a spring contact


68


or the like. Resistor


41


may be provided to combat electromagnetic interference (EMI). Second cup


43


provides for a transition spring


68


. Cup


43


includes an annular projection


70


configured allow spring


68


to be coupled thereto. Contact spring


68


is in turn configured to engage in a high-voltage connector terminal of spark plug


14


. This arrangement for coupling the high voltage developed by secondary winding


30


to plug


14


is exemplary only; a number of alternative connector arrangements, particularly spring-biased arrangements, are known in the art.




An ignition apparatus in accordance with the present in invention includes a conductive cup used in establishing a high voltage connection between the secondary winding/HV terminal and the spark plug (perhaps via additional components such as resistor


41


, cup


43


and via spring


68


) which significantly reduces the electric field intensity in the area of the connection. Particularly, the cup


37


has a sidewall that extends axially up to the flange. This extension surrounds the HV end portion of secondary winding


30


as it leaves the winding bay, which is operative to reduce the electric field concentration. The reduction in the electric field intensity substantially minimizes or eliminates a significant failure mode for pencil ignition coils, namely, the grounding out of the secondary winding through an arcing via a dendrite formed in the insulating material (e.g., to a ground such as the outer core or shield). This reduction of the occurrence of this failure mode leads to lower warranty returns, as well as increasing the product's expected service life.



Claims
  • 1. An ignition apparatus comprising:a central core having a main axis; a primary winding; a spool having a winding surface and a flange; a terminal; a secondary winding wound on said surface and having a high-voltage end thereof connected to said terminal; and a cup formed of metal material engaging said terminal and configured to be contacted by a connector assembly for connection to a spark plug, wherein said cup defines a first cup having a base and a generally annular side wall, said side wall extending from said base to said spool flange in a generally axial direction relative to said main axis, said side wall having an interior surface facing said spool and terminal, said interior surface of said first cup engaging said terminal; said connector assembly including a second conductive cup, a resistive element between said first cup and said second cup, and a spring coupled to said second cup.
  • 2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said resistive element comprises a ceramic resistor, said spring being configured to be connected to the spark plug.
  • 3. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said flange extends radially outwardly relative to said winding surface, said flange including an axially extending passage configured to allow said high voltage end of said secondary winding to pass therethrough to said terminal.
  • 4. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said sidewall is a first side wall and said axial direction is a first axial direction, said cup having a second annular side wall extending from said base in a second axial direction opposite said first axial direction, said second annular side wall terminating in a closed end of said cup.
  • 5. The apparatus of claim 4 wherein said first annular wall has a first diameter associated therewith and said second annular side wall has a second diameter associated therewith smaller than said first diameter.
  • 6. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said up comprises one of aluminum, brass material, and steel.
  • 7. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said cup is configured to surround said terminal and said high voltage end of said secondary winding.
  • 8. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said cup is formed of stamped sheet metal, a fold region defined at an end of said first annular wall.
  • 9. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said terminal is configured to present a resilient arrangement for engaging an inner surface of said cup.
  • 10. An ignition coil comprising:a central core formed of magnetically permeable material having a main axis; a primary winding disposed radially outwardly of said core; a secondary winding spool having a winding surface and a flange; a high-voltage terminal; a secondary winding wound on said surface and having a high-voltage end thereof connected to said high-voltage terminal; a case formed of electrical insulating material disposed outwardly of said core, said spool and said primary and secondary windings; an outer core formed of magnetically permeable material located radially outwardly of said case; and a cup formed of metal contacting said high-voltage terminal configured to be contacted by a connector assembly for connection to a spark plug, wherein said cup has a base and a generally annular side wall extending radially along said main axis around said terminal and extending axially to said flange thereby providing an interior surface to engage said terminal.
  • 11. The apparatus of claim 10 wherein said flange includes at least one axially extending passage for allowing said high-voltage end of said secondary winding to pass therethrough for connection to said terminal.
US Referenced Citations (4)
Number Name Date Kind
5714922 Suzuki et al. Feb 1998 A
6023215 Sakamaki et al. Feb 2000 A
6094121 Sakamaki et al. Jul 2000 A
6208231 Oosuka et al. Mar 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (1)
Number Date Country
0837481 Apr 1998 EP