The disclosed process relates to an improved process for manufacturing tetrahydrofuran (“THF”) from a reaction mixture comprising 1,4-butanediol (“BDO”) in the presence of an acid catalyst.
In current processes for manufacturing THF from a reaction mixture comprising BDO in the presence of an acid catalyst, for example, sulphuric acid, in a distillation reaction zone, the acid catalyst is in the reaction mixture to accomplish dehydration of the BDO and ring closure. This process necessitates the use of high grade materials to avoid corrosion of the process vessels due to the strong acidity of the hot process liquor. Further, this process generates an accumulating high concentration of an acidic black viscous tar which represents a yield loss and operational problems. Literature teaches that the same chemistry can be carried out with a solid acid catalyst (see Vaidya et al, Applied Catalysis A: General 242 (2003), 321-328). In the latter case the reaction takes place on the surface of the catalyst rendering the mixture pH neutral. However, in a continuous process, even with the use of a solid acid, catalyst, periodic costly maintenance for regeneration of catalyst with significant surface tar is required.
U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2008/0161585A1 and its European counterpart EP1939190B1 disclose use of ZrSO4 as catalyst in either a liquid or gas phase process to manufacture THF from butanediol. The publication drawing shows a reactor linked to a distillation column. THF and water are removed from the top of the distillation column while butanediol from the base of the column is recycled to the reactor.
U.S. Pat. No. 5,099,039A (“the '039 patent”) relates to a process for the production of THF from BDO wherein polybenzimidazole (“PBI”) catalyzes the conversion of BDO to THF. The PBI catalyst is in the protonated or acidic form as described in example I of the '039 patent.
Japan Patent No. 07118253A discloses only a particular catalyst as a means for effecting the conversion of BDO to THF. It does not mention tars or byproducts.
China Patent No. 101298444B discloses using a strongly acidic ion exchange resin to convert BDO to THF at an operating temperature of up to 120° C. It does not mention suspending the acidic ion exchange resin above boiling BDO in a distillation reaction zone.
Chemical Engineering Science, 56, 2001, 2171-2178, discloses conversion of BDO to THF in a batch stirred pot reactor using an ion exchange resin contained in a basket. The basket is initially suspended in the pot until the batch reactor is heated. At that point, the basket is dropped into the pot, i.e., the catalyst is in the reaction mixture in the batch stirred pot reactor. Boiling vapor is not used to effect the reaction, which is done in the liquid phase under pressure to prevent evaporation of product.
In light of current practices and the disclosures of art, a simple economical process is needed for manufacturing THF from a reaction mixture comprising BDO in the presence of an acid catalyst to avoid these issues.
The present invention provides an economical improved process for manufacturing THF from a reaction mixture comprising BDO in the presence of an acid catalyst at reaction conditions.
One aspect of the disclosed process is directed to an improved process for making tetrahydrofuran, the process comprising:
providing a reaction mixture comprising 1,4-butanediol to a first zone;
maintaining conditions of temperature and pressure in the first zone sufficient to produce a vapor-rich region comprising the reaction mixture;
providing a second zone in the vapor-rich region between the first zone and a vapor condenser, wherein the second zone comprises an acid catalyst;
maintaining conditions of temperature and pressure in the second zone sufficient to effect dehydration of 1,4-butanediol and ring closure to form a product comprising tetrahydrofuran; and
recovering the product.
One aspect of the disclosed process is directed to an improved process for making tetrahydrofuran, the process comprising:
providing a reaction mixture comprising 1,4-butanediol to a first zone;
maintaining conditions of temperature and pressure in the first zone sufficient to produce a vapor-rich region comprising the reaction mixture;
providing a second zone in the vapor-rich region between the first zone and a vapor condenser, wherein the second zone comprises an acid catalyst;
maintaining conditions of temperature and pressure in the second zone sufficient to effect dehydration of 1,4-butanediol and ring closure to form a product comprising tetrahydrofuran; and
recovering the product.
As a result of intense research, we have found that we can economically and effectively manufacture THF from a reaction mixture comprising BDO. In certain embodiments, the improved process can be in the presence of a solid catalyst in a reaction vessel comprising a distillation column reaction zone at distillation reaction conditions. The disclosed process avoids the problems associated with current practices of acid catalyzing the dehydration of BDO in a distillation reaction zone to produce product comprising THF. The improvement of the present invention allows lower cost materials of construction for reaction zone equipment with significant reduction in tar formation. Reduction in tar formation represents a significant yield improvement along with much less frequent equipment down-times and shutdowns for cleanup and maintenance.
Examples of the reaction vessels, include, but are not limited to, a continuously stirred tank reactor, a plug flow reactor, or a trickle flow reactor. In one embodiment, the reaction vessel is a continuously stirred tank reactor. In a further embodiment, the reactor vessel is a tank with external circulation through a pump. In another embodiment, the reaction vessel is a plug flow reactor. In yet another embodiment, the reaction vessel is a trickle flow reactor with the liquid flowing down and the vapors flowing up.
The term “BDO” as used herein represents 1,4-butanediol, also known as 1,4-butylene glycol, having the formula HOCH2CH2CH2CH2OH.
The phrase “reaction mixture comprising BDO” is intended to refer to a mixture primarily containing 1,4-butanediol, but may also contain minor amounts of impurities such as, for example, 2,4-hydroxybutoxy tetrahydrofuran; 2-methyl-1,4-butanediol and 2-butene-1,4-diol. In one embodiment, the reaction mixture comprises about 40-100 wt % BDO, 0-30 wt % THF and 0-30 wt % water. In another embodiment, the reaction mixture comprises about 50-100 wt % BDO, 0-25 wt % THF and 0-25 wt % water. In yet another embodiment, the reaction mixture comprises about 60-100 wt % BDO, 0-20 wt % THF and 0-20 wt % water. In a further embodiment, the reaction mixture comprises about 70-100 wt % BDO, 0-15 wt % THF and 0-15 wt % water. In yet another embodiment, the reaction mixture comprises about 80-100 wt % BDO, 0-10 wt % THF and 0-10 wt % water.
In some embodiments, the reaction mixture comprising BDO is a liquid mixture that is used to generate the vaporized feed to the reaction zone.
The term “THF” as used herein represents tetrahydrofuran, also known as cyclotetramethylene oxide, represented by the formula C4H8O. Percentages used herein are in weight % unless otherwise indicated.
The term “yield loss” as used herein means a molecular loss of a useful reactant via its conversion to form undesired reaction by-product(s). The yield loss of a chemical reactant is due to inefficiencies in the chemical conversion process. A zero-percent yield loss means no chemical reactant has been lost to undesired chemical by-products. A 100-percent yield loss means all chemical reactant has been lost to undesired by-products. Specifically, the yield loss of BDO to the byproduct tar formation means the molecules of BDO that are associated with the undesired tar formation. A lower yield loss is desirable in any chemical reaction system.
The term “tar” as used herein represents mass accumulation of side reaction products from undesirable chemical interactions involving the product, catalyst and/or starting feed at the reaction conditions. Tar formation and build-up is associated with the loss of desired product selectivity and yield, and is also responsible for coloring of the reaction mixture. Tar formation has detrimental effects on the equipment operability and performance. Increasing levels of tar is undesirable from any reaction viewpoint.
In some embodiments, the yield loss of butanediol to tar is less than 5.0, or less than 4.0, or less than 3.0 percent by weight. In other embodiments, the yield loss of butanediol to tar is less than 2.0 percent by weight. In a further embodiment, the yield loss of butanediol to tar is less than 1.0 percent by weight.
In some embodiments, the reaction mixture is characterized by a Hunter Colorimetry index, L*/a*/b*, and the Hunter Color index, L* is from about L*=0 to about L*=100, a* is from about a*=−100 to about a*=100 and b* is from about b*=−100 to about b*=100.
In some embodiments, the tar formation is determined by the mass totaling method.
The main purpose of the first zone is to generate vapor feed for the reaction without over-heating the reaction mixture. In some embodiments, the first zone may be a liquid-vapor heat exchanger with the heat-transfer surface that adequately heats the liquid reaction mixture to its bubble-point temperature. In other embodiments, the first zone is a reboiler. The reboiler may be of any of such conventional types as, but not limited to, shell-and-tube, calendria, thermosyphon, film evaporator, jacketed and/or heating coiled kettle, forced-circulation, fuel-fired. The reboiler may be equipped with a liquid circulation pump and a draw-off point for removing the liquid to maintain the steady state. Steam is normally used as heat source, however, other heat transfer fluids as hot-oil and DowTherm™ may be used depending on the temperature range. In fuel-fired type, fuel oil or fuel gas such as natural gas or LPG may be used. The reboiler may be installed for an efficient vapor disengagement from the liquid while maintaining a good contact between the heat transfer surface and liquid.
In some embodiments, the second zone comprises a solid catalyst section that accomplishes the desired chemical conversion in the catalyst presence. In some embodiments, the second zone may comprise of a catalytic reaction section integrated with the distillative separation stages. In other embodiments, the catalytic reaction section may be external to the distillative separation stages. The catalytic reaction section affords a chemical conversion reaction in the presence of liquid and/or vapor phases. In further embodiments, the solid catalyst section is located in the vapor-rich environment of the second zone.
In some embodiments, the second zone further comprises an annular chimney reactor. In other embodiments, the second zone is externally connected with the solid catalyst section. In one embodiment, the second zone comprises the catalyst section internally.
In some embodiments, when steady state is reached in the disclosed process, the product comprises 80±20/20±20, weight/weight, THF/water.
In some embodiments, the vapor condenser accepts the overhead vapor stream from the distillative reaction vessel and condenses into a liquid product. The vapor condenser may be vapor-liquid heat exchanger with the heat-transfer surface that is adequate to cool the overhead vapors to, or sub-cool below, its dew point temperature. The vapor condenser is oriented such that the condensed liquid flows out of the unit without letting the uncondensed vapors escape. In a conventional arrangement, the vapor condenser may be equipped with a liquid seal and a condensed liquid accumulator to prevent any vapor escape. The condenser may be equipped with a condensate pump-around and a draw-off point to establish steady state while in operation. Conventional vapor-liquid condensers may be of the surface-type such as shell-and-tube, cross-flow, or contact-type such as direct contact and spray condenser.
In some embodiments, the acid catalyst section may be located external to the second zone, e.g., a distillation column (see
In some embodiments, the conditions in the second zone are such that the BDO in the reaction mixture reacts to form THF, and include a temperature of from 80 to 250° C. and pressure from 200 to 10,000 mbar absolute. Examples of such reaction conditions include a temperature of from 110 to 250° C., such as from 120 to 150° C., and pressure from 950 to 8,000 mbar absolute. Heat may be applied to the reaction zone directly to control temperature conditions therein. The contents may vaporize in the reactor upon formation of THF and water, or it may be kept in the liquid phase if the pressure is kept high enough within the above ranges.
In some embodiments, the acid catalyst can be in the forms of solid, semi-solid, and/or of gel consistency. In one embodiment, the acid catalyst is a solid catalyst. In other embodiments, the solid catalyst is a strongly acidic ion exchange resin. In other embodiments, the solid catalyst can be mineral-based supported acid catalysts, such as zeolites. In one embodiment, the solid resin catalyst can be selected from commercially available strongly acidic, cationic polymeric catalysts. Non-limiting examples of such solid acid resin catalyst include Amberlyst™ 35, Amberlyst™ 70, Puralite™ CT and combinations thereof. In some embodiments, the suitable solid acid resin catalyst has an acid equivalency of at least 1, for example from at least 1 to 10, such as from 3 to 10.
In some embodiments, the product separation and recovery may be accomplished by suitable process techniques, such as, appropriate distillation means.
A more detailed description of a representative process for THF production from BDO is shown as arrangement 11 in
According to a non-limiting embodiment shown in
The reacted effluent vapor stream 115, from the catalyst section 145, comprising unconverted BDO, THF product, water, and optionally, other byproducts along with any residual tar, is taken back to the column 161 via appropriate piping and vapor feed port. The temperature and pressure conditions across the column 161 are maintained such that the THF product along with water are distilled in the overhead via stream 120. The unconverted BDO and other high-boiling components such as tars flow down as equilibrated liquid. The tars and BDO are separated in the section 166 and tars are concentrated as stream 130. The column 161 therefore provides the necessary separation between the low-boiling THF product, higher-boiling reactant BDO and highest-boiling tars.
Stream 120 comprises of the THF product and water that are formed in the catalyst section 145. Further separation and refining for yielding purified THF is accomplished by processing stream 120 via known methods for THF purification, including but not limited to, conventional distillation, azeotropic distillation, pressure distillation, membrane separation, dehydration beds, etc.
The bottoms stream 130 essentially comprises unconverted BDO and other by-products including tars and with negligible THF. Stream 130 is taken to the reboiler and heated to provide the BDO-rich vapor feed (not shown) to the column 161.
At steady state, the fresh feed stream 101 flow rate is roughly matched with the net distilled liquid take-off (not shown) from the overhead, which may be the entire stream 120 or a portion of stream 120. In the case of stream 120 portion taken as overhead product, the remaining portion may be fed back to the column 161 as reflux to balance the column hydraulics. Several purge points may be selected at appropriate locations to control and prevent the byproducts from building up in the process.
In
At steady state, the fresh column feed 215 rate is roughly matched with the net overhead product draw (not shown). The overhead product draw may be the entire stream 220 or a portion thereof. The bottoms BDO-rich stream 230 is taken to the reboiler where the boilup heat is provided and the BDO-rich vapors (not shown) are fed back to the column 261.
The internal catalyst section 245 may be one or multiple sections, arranged to fit inside the column internals via proper bracketing and supporting. These sections may be packed with proper voidages to provide acceptable pressure drop across the column. The catalyst section may be a suitable catalytic structured packing type, rolled, corrugated sheet sections, reticulated foam type or wash-coated catalytic substrates such as honeycomb or monolithic structures.
In arrangements 11 and 21, adequate temperature and pressure measurement points may be provided to obtain the desired reaction and distillative environment. Conventionally, the bottoms reboiler will be equipped with over-temperature controls and liquid level controls to minimize over-heating and drying of the heated surface. The overhead condenser will be equipped with proper coolant feed controls and liquid level controls for efficient vapor condensing. The catalyst section may operate either adiabatically, isothermally or with controlled temperature profile via the available means.
The following Examples demonstrate the present invention and its capability for use. The invention is capable of other and different embodiments, and its several details are capable of modifications in various apparent respects, without departing from the scope and spirit of the present invention. Accordingly, the Examples are to be regarded as illustrative in nature and not as restrictive. All percentages are by weight unless otherwise indicated.
Hunter Colorimetry Method—
In the examples, color measurements are determined as described in Hunter Lab Applications Note, Vol. 8, No. 9, 2008, 1-3, and the association of color with tar formation is made with a Hunter Lab color measurement instrument. The reaction mixture in the process is characterized by a Hunter Color index, L*/a*/b*, wherein, the Hunter Color index, L* is from about L*=0 to about L*=100, a* is from about a*=−100 to about a*=100 and b* is from about b*=−100 to about b*=100. A convenient key to these color measurements is that higher L* and lower b* values indicate lower tar content. As an illustration, an L* value of “0” indicates totally opaque/black coloration due to excessive tar; and an L* value of 100 indicates completely clear of the tar formation.
Mass Totaling Method—
In the following examples, a quantitative determination of tar formation is made by analyzing the reaction liquid mixture at steady-state conditions, measuring composition of known components in the reaction mixture, and by mass subtraction of the combined weight percentages of the known components from 100%.
As used in the Examples, the term “BDO” refers to 1,4-Butanediol (1,4-BDO; Chemical Abstracts Registry Number CAS No. 110-63-4). Table 1 (1,4-BDO by INVISTA S.à.r.l.) gives a typical composition of the BDO used.
The concentrated H2SO4 used has a typical composition of 98% by weight.
The Amberlyst™ 35 used is obtained from Dow Chemicals. The Amberlyst™ 35 W resin form is washed with demineralized water and dried in an oven overnight at 90° C.
In this example, 1.25 grams of H2SO4 is added to 98.75 grams of BDO, i.e., a 1.25% H2SO4 in BDO solution, and charged to the reaction flask 373. Heat is applied via isomantle 371. When the reaction mixture began to boil (˜130° C.) and THF/water collection commenced in the distillate receiver 379, additional BDO is added continuously via stream 305 to maintain liquid level in the reaction flask 373. The steady state flow rate of BDO achieved is about 3.5 mL/minute with the bulk, reaction liquid temperature reaching about 143° C. This produces about 3.5 mL/minute of an 80:20, wt/wt mixture of THF and water distilled overhead via stream 315, and eventually, the condensed liquid stream 320.
The experiment is continued for over 60 hours during which time tar formation is visually observed in the reaction flask 373 as severe discoloration, i.e., the bulk reaction mixture 310 turns black and opaque after 6 hours. The liquid phase samples of 310 taken from the reaction flask 373 has a steady state composition of 75% BDO, 3% THF and 5% water, giving about 15% tar by the mass totaling method. The color of 310 by Hunter Colorimetry method is determined to be steady state L*/a*/b* values of 25/17/40 following a ten-fold dilution of the samples in BDO.
Using the equipment arrangement and procedures described above and in
The original equipment arrangement described in Example 1 and shown in
Referring to
A stationary bed 145, containing solid acidic resin catalyst pellets, is mounted in an external reactor 141. A liquid stream 105 is drawn from the column via tray 169 to reactor 141, while reactor effluent consisting of vapor and optionally liquid is returned to column 161 via line 115. There are more than one theoretical separation stages between the reactor effluent return line 115 and overhead condenser and more than one theoretical stages between the liquid draw-off stream 105 and bottoms reboiler.
A fresh reaction feed comprising BDO is introduced via stream 101 to replenish the converted BDO in the system. The fresh feed stream 101 is mixed with the liquid side-draw stream 105 from the liquid collection section 169 of the column 161, and the combined stream 110 is fed to the catalyst section 145. A provision is made to monitor and control the temperature of the combined feed stream 110 at the inlet of the reactor 141.
The catalyst reaction zone 145 conditions are maintained such that the reaction of BDO to THF proceeds with high conversion and desired product selectivity. As the reaction continues the by-product water and THF product are driven out of the reaction zone as vapor. The vapor mixture (i.e., stream 120) is condensed in the overhead condenser and recovered as 80120:20120% THF:water distillate mixture. The THF-rich liquid distillate is drawn out of the system and processed downstream.
Fresh BDO is charged via stream 101 at a steady feed rate to replenish the converted feed. At steady state, the overhead product mass flow rate is roughly matched with the fresh BDO addition. The column base continues to boil BDO which provides the reactant feed to the reaction zone 145.
The undesired tar byproduct is concentrated and removed in the column base where the maximum temperature is observed. The bottom liquid stream 130 composition comprises mainly BDO with trace amounts of THF, water and a few % by weight tars.
Referring to
A stationary bed, containing solid acidic resin catalyst pellets, is mounted in the mid-section 245 of the column. The catalyst bed is held in place by similar arrangements as catalytic structured packings (such as Katapak-S) that are typically used in reactive distillation. There are more than one theoretical separation stages between the catalyst bed and overhead condenser and more than one theoretical stage between the catalyst bed and bottoms reboiler. The feed entry point can be above, middle or below the catalyst bed location. In this example, the liquid-feed enters above the catalyst bed via stream 215. The catalyst reaction zone 245 conditions are maintained such that the reaction of BDO to THF proceeds with high conversion and desired product selectivity. As the reaction continues the by-product water and THF product are driven out of the reaction zone as vapor. The vapor mixture (i.e., stream 220) is condensed in the overhead condenser and recovered as 80±20:20±20% THF:water distillate mixture. The THF-rich liquid distillate is drawn out of the system and processed downstream.
Fresh BDO is charged via stream 215 at a steady feed rate to replenish the converted feed. At steady state, the overhead product mass flow rate is roughly matched with the fresh BDO addition through stream 215. The column base continues to boil BDO which provides the reactant vapor feed to the reaction zone 245.
The undesired tar byproduct is concentrated and removed in the column base where the maximum temperature is observed. The bottom liquid stream 230 composition comprises mainly BDO with trace amounts of THF, water and a few % by weight tars.
All patents, patent applications, test procedures, priority documents, articles, publications, manuals, and other documents cited herein are fully incorporated by reference to the extent such disclosure is not inconsistent with this invention and for all jurisdictions in which such incorporation is permitted.
When numerical lower limits and numerical upper limits are listed herein, ranges from any lower limit to any upper limit are contemplated.
While the illustrative embodiments of the invention have been described with particularity, it will be understood that various other modifications will be apparent to and may be readily made by those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. Accordingly, it is not intended that the scope of the claims hereof be limited to the examples and descriptions set forth herein but rather that the claims be construed as encompassing all the features of patentable novelty which reside in the present invention, including all features which would be treated as equivalents thereof by those skilled in the art to which the invention pertains.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. provisional application No. 61/875,828, filed Sep. 10, 2013, the disclosures of which are incorporated herein by reference in their entireties.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2014/054842 | 9/9/2014 | WO | 00 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61875828 | Sep 2013 | US |