Injection molded plastic article with integral weatherable pigmented film surface

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • RE35970
  • Patent Number
    RE35,970
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, October 24, 1996
    28 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 24, 1998
    26 years ago
Abstract
Molded articles having contoured, decorative outer surfaces are disclosed. The articles comprise a molded polymer substrate and a decorative surfacing film adhered to one side of the substrate. The decorative surfacing film comprises a substantially molecularly unoriented cast polymer film formed from a weatherable polymer. The articles are particularly suited for use as automobile body panels and the like. Also disclosed is a method for making such articles, and a method for making sets of such articles for assembly into automobile bodies and the like.
Description

FIELD OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to shaped molded polymer articles generally, and particularly relates to shaped articles formed from a molded polymer substrate which have a decorative surfacing film on the outer surface thereof presenting a surface appearance of high quality comparable to a high quality automotive paint finish.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The trend in the automobile industry is towards increased use of plastic body panels in automobile construction. Use of such panels makes it possible to reduce the weight of the automobiles and also to reduce tooling costs arising from body styling changes, while providing increased styling freedom in car design. Other advantages arising from this type of construction include reduced facility costs and factory floor space requirements, and process cycle times allowing the just-in-time, low inventory manufacturing of parts at or near the automobile assembly plant. See C. Kirkland and P. Dickard, Dateline: Detroit. SAE Show News Bulletins, Plastic Technology, page 103 (April 1986).
A significant problem with plastic automobile body parts is that many of the most desirable molding polymers for such parts are not weatherable. Moreover, many such polymers do not provide a good bonding surface for paints. Even where paint bonding problems are overcome, conventional spray-painting techniques pose a significant pollution problem arising from the evaporation of noxious paint solvents, and, further, are very expensive if a high quality, multiple coat paint finish is to be obtained. Because the overall finished appearance of an automobile is among its most important selling features, these problems are serious, and a great deal of effort and expense is being devoted to their solution. See, for example, Automotive Coatings: Helping Detroit Woo Consumers, Chemical Week, page 30, (Jul. 4, 1984). One approach to this problem is to provide a film surface for the plastic part.
Various molded polymer automobile parts with film surfaces have been made in the past. For example, clear, unpigmented, nonweatherable, cast PVC films have been used to surface interior automobile parts. Another example, U.S. Pat. No. 3,679,510 to Conley and Ellison, discloses a reverse-printed, oriented, polyvinyl fluoride film (a "TED-LAR" film) bonded to a molded polymer substrate. Such weatherable, oriented films are excellent for use in making side rails and other automobile trim parts. These films are, however, difficult to uniformly internally pigment, and are generally not suitable for use in a deep draw molding procedure. In order to be useful as a surfacing film on exterior automobile parts, the film must duplicate the surface appearance of a quality automobile paint finish. The finish must have high gloss, high distinctness of image (DOI), excellent weatherability and durability under exposure to sunlight and temperature extremes, and the film must match the solid and metallic colors used in automobile paint finishes.
Accordingly, an object of the present invention is to provide a molded polymer article which has a weatherable surface.
A further object of the invention is to provide an article as described above which has a high grade decorative finish suitable for use as an automobile body part.
An additional object of the invention is to provide an article of the type described which can be deep draw molded into various three-dimensional shapes used in automobile body parts.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
These and other objects and advantages of the present invention are achieved in the embodiments illustrated herein by the provision of an article having a contoured, decorative outer surface, and which is comprised of a molded polymer substrate and a decorative surfacing film adhered to one side of the substrate and conforming to the contoured surface. The decorative surfacing film comprises a substantially molecularly unoriented cast polymer film formed from a weatherable polymer, which film has pigments, such as colored pigments or reflective flakes, uniformly distributed therein.
Use of a cast polymer film is important in obtaining uniform distribution of the pigments within the film and enables the production of a high-quality decorative surfacing film with an appearance which closely simulates the high grade automotive paint finishes used on automobile body parts. Such pigmented, cast, weatherable films are suitable for deep draw molding, as will be explained below, and do not require the use of separate pigment layers in addition to a protective weatherable outer layer.
A shaped article as described above is made by placing into a mold having a contoured, three-dimensional molding surface, a preformed decorative surfacing film of the type described above. A moldable polymer is then introduced into the mold on one side of the surfacing film. The surfacing film is then molded into a contoured three-dimensional configuration conforming to the molding surface of said mold, while molding said polymer to form a shaped article with the decorative surfacing film adhered to the outer surface thereof.
The decorative surfacing film also includes a bonding layer formed of a thermoplastic thermoformable polymer, different from the cast film. The decorative surfacing film is placed into the mold with the bonding layer oriented inwardly away from the molding surface so as to become adhered to the moldable polymer.
Also disclosed herein is a method of making a structure such as an automobile body which has a uniform decorative outer surface, which is comprised of a set of interconnected shaped articles, each article being formed from a molded polymer material (and optionally from a plurality of different moldable polymer materials), and each article having a decorative surfacing film on the outer surface thereof presenting a surface appearance of high quality comparable to a high quality automobile paint finish. Bach article in the set is preferably formed of a moldable polymer which is selected to provide the desired structural properties to the particular location in the assembled structure in which it is installed. At the same time, while the assembled structure may be formed from different structural polymer materials, it has an outer surface which is uniformly colored in accordance with a predetermined color scheme (single colored, multicolored, etc.).





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of an apparatus and procedure for making molded plastic articles of the present invention.
FIG. 2 is a cross-section of a decorative film, taken along the line 2--2 of FIG. 1.
FIG. 3 is a perspective view of an automobile formed from a set of molded plastic articles of the present invention.
FIG. 4 is an exploded view of a set of molded plastic articles of the present invention.
FIG. 5 is a cross-section of a molded plastic article taken along the line 5--5 of FIG. 4.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
Molded plastic articles of the present invention can be made by placing a preformed decorative surfacing film 10 into a mold 11, closing the mold, and injecting a moldable polymer 12 into the mold on the inner side of the film 10 (see FIG. 1). The decorative surfacing film, as shown in FIG. 2, comprises a substantially molecularly unoriented weatherable cast film 13 which has pigments uniformly distributed therein, and a bonding layer 14 formed of a different polymer adhered to the inner side of the cast film.
Molded plastic articles 20 of the present invention are useful in a variety of applications where it is desired to have a high quality paint-like appearance on a molded plastic article. Such articles are particularly suitable for use in exterior applications such as exterior building panels or as outer body panels in an automobile, as illustrated in FIG. 3. Such an automobile has a body which is comprised of a set of molded plastic articles 20, as illustrated in FIG. 4. FIG. 5 illustrates a cross section of a molded plastic article of the present invention, with the preformed decorative surfacing film 10 adhered to the molded polymer substrate 21. FIG. 5 shows that the bonding layer 14 is adhered to the molded polymer substrate 21, with the weatherable cast film on the outer surface of the article.
Cast films for practicing the present invention should be selected so they are pigmentable, thermoformable and weatherable. Such films are substantially molecularly unoriented cast films, as opposed to films which have been oriented or biaxially oriented. The films are "preformed" films, in that they are provided as self-supporting sheets of material. Such films are prepared by a number of known liquid casting methods, such as by spreading a solvent solution having a polymer dissolved therein onto a carrier with a casting die, doctor bar, or reverse roll coater, then evaporating the solvent, and then stripping the polymer film from the carrier. The reverse-roll coating method is the preferred method of malting liquid cast films for the present invention. Other liquid casting methods are also known and useful for practicing the present invention. In appropriate cases, a plastisol, organosol, or dispersion of the polymer can be cast onto the carrier instead of a solvent solution. For example, polytetrafluoroethylene, which is virtually insoluble, can be cast as a dispersion. Such liquid cast film processes, and some current uses of cast films, are discussed in Plastics Engineering, at pages 29-33 (May, 1983). Thus, for purposes of the present invention, "substantially molecularly unoriented cast films" are liquid cast films, and not melt cast films or films formed by melt extrusion.
Colored pigments are uniformly distributed in the cast film by dispersing them in a vehicle compatible with the liquid from which the film is cast, and mixing the vehicle with the same prior to casting the film. When a metallic paint finish is desired, reflective flake pigments, such as aluminum flakes of the type used to produce metallic finishes on automobiles, or mica flakes, either surface treated (e.g., pigmented) or not, of the type used in automobile finishes, are uniformly distributed in the cast film in like manner. U.V. screeners arc added as needed to improve the weatherability of the cast films. For certain automotive styling effects, the cast film 13 may be formed of multiple layers of liquid cast molecularly unoriented polymer. For example, the glossy wet look of a base coat/clear coat automotive finish is achieved by a combination of layers, with the outer or top layer being a transparent layer of high gloss and optical clarity, and with an underlying opaque layer containing colored and/or metallic pigments providing the desired color.
Polymers suitable for forming such weatherable cast films are selected to provide a pigmented film which will not significantly fade, peel, chalk, or crack, when exposed to the environment, for the intended life of the product for which the molded plastic article is made. A number of known testing procedures, in which objects are exposed to either the natural environment over an extended time or a harsh artificial environment for a short time, are used to determine the weatherability of polymers. Such weatherable polymers include fluoropolymers, acrylate polymers, urethane polymers, and blends thereof. Acrylate polymers useful for practicing the present invention are obtained from a variety of acrylic monomers, such as acrylic and methacrylic acids, and their amides, esters, salts, and corresponding nitriles. Particularly suitable monomers for such polymers are methyl methacrylate, ethyl acrylate, and acrylonitrile. The polymers may each be used in the form of homopolymers, or with various other monomers which can be copolymerized therewith. Additional illustrative examples of acrylate polymers which may be useful for the present invention are thermoplastic polyacrylates and polymethacrylates which are homopolymers and copolymers of acrylic acid ester and methacrylic acid ester, such as, for example, polyacrylic acid isobutyl ester, polymethacrylic acid methyl ester, polymethacrylic acid ethylhexyl ester, polyacrylic acid ethyl ester; copolymers of various acrylic acid esters and/or methacrylic acid esters, such as, for example, methacrylic acid methyl ester/acrylic acid cyclohexyl ester copolymers; and copolymers of acrylic acid esters and/or methacrylic acid esters with styrene and/or alpha-methylstyrene, as well as the graft polymers and copolymers and polymer mixtures composed of acrylic esters, methacrylic acid esters, styrene and butadiene. A group of transparent, weatherable blends of acrylate polymers and polyvinylidene fluoride polymers useful for practicing the present invention are disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,524,906. The disclosures of this patent, and all other patent references cited herein, are specifically intended to be incorporated herein by reference.
Fluoropolymers useful for practicing the present invention include polymers and copolymers formed from trifluoroethylene, tetrafluoroethylene, hexafluoropropylene, monochlorotrifluoroethylene and dichlorodifluoroethylene. Copolymers and terpolymers of these monomers formed from fluoroolefins such as vinylidene fluoride are also useful. Further illustrative examples of fluoropolymers useful for practicing the present invention include polyvinyl fluoride, polyvinylidene fluoride, fluorinated ethylene/propylene copolymers ("FEP" resins), ethylene/chlorotrifluoroethylene copolymers, vinylidene fluoride/hexafluoropropene copolymers, and vinylidene fluoride/perfluoro (alkyl vinyl ether) dipolymers and terpolymers with tetrafluoroethylene. Illustrative of the commercially available fluoropolymer resins useful for practicing the present invention are those sold under such trademarks as KYNAR, FORAFLON, SOLEF, LUMIFLON, and TEFLON. These resins can be formulated and formed by liquid casting into films. An illustrative weatherable polymer film for use in the present invention is an alloy of an acrylic polymer and polyvinylidene fluoride, such as "FLUOREX.RTM." (a trademark of Rexham Corporation).
Urethane polymers useful for practicing the present invention are prepared by reacting a polyisocyanate with a compound containing at least two active hydrogen atoms, such as a polyol, a polyamine, or a polyisocyanate. Polyurethane resins for use in the present invention should be selected from resins in which the reactants have been chosen to provide weatherable, thermoformable polymers. Numerous suitable polyurethane resins useful for practicing the present invention are available. Generally, aromatic polyisocyanates tend to yellow, and aliphatic polyisocyanates are more preferred. Particularly noteworthy recent developments in this area are disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,578,426 (disclosing resins which give coatings resistant to gasoline and having high flexibility, scratch resistance and weather resistance) and U.S. Pat. No. 4,501,852 (disclosing chemical resistant, abrasion resistant, elastic and durable polyurethanes).
The molded polymer substrate should be selected to provide engineering properties (rigidity, etc.) suited to the specific end use of the particular article made. Such polymers are well known. Suitable polymers for the molded polymer substrate include, for example, polyvinyl chloride, polycarbonate, polystyrene, acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene, polyethylene, polypropylene, polyethylene terephthalateglycol, nylon, and RIM urethanes. Polyolefin homopolymers and copolymers (ionomers, etc.) are inexpensive thermoplastic resins which have excellent molding properties and are particularly preferred for practicing the present invention. Polypropylene, for example, when glass filled and foamed with a blowing agent, has performance properties suitable for structural or engineering uses. Acid copolymers of polyethylene such as "SURLYN" (a trademark of E.I. DuPont De Nemours) are similar in performance and in addition have exceptional toughness.
The bonding layer 14 of the decorative surfacing film 10 comprises a thermoplastic polymer layer applied to the inner surface of the cast polymer film 13. In a preferred embodiment, the bonding layer 14 comprises a preformed film of a thermoplastic polymer laminated to the inner surface of the cast film. Bonding of the decorative surfacing film 10 to a polyolefin molded polymer substrate can be achieved with an intermediate bonding layer or layers in accordance with known laminating procedures, and with known adhesives. For example, a decorative surfacing film formed of a cast polymer film layer which is bonded to or coated with a fusible olefin bonding layer can be placed in a mold during injection of an olefin resin. Another approach is to bond a PVC film to a cast weatherable fluoropolymer film with an acrylic adhesive and, in turn, bond the PVC film to an olefin film with a polyester isocyanate adhesive. The cast polymer film may also be laminated to an olefin film with a permanent type acrylic pressure-sensitive adhesive.
In addition to facilitating the bonding of the weatherable cast film to the molded polymer substrate, the bonding layer 14 serves several additional important functions. Since the weatherable cast film has relatively little inherent tensile strength, the bonding layer serves as a reinforcement to facilitate handling of the decorative surfacing film, placement of the film into the mold, and also ensures that it remains wrinkle free in the mold during the molding operation. During molding, as molten plastic is injected into the mold cavity and flows to fill the cavity, the bonding layer acts as a protective stabilizing layer and as an insulator to maintain the high quality outer surface appearance of the surfacing film and prevent the injected molten plastic from causing heat distortion or flow lines which would be visible on the outer surface of the molded article. Thus, the decorative surfacing film retains the gloss and distinctness of image properties which are characteristic of a high quality paint finish, such as the type of paint finish used on an automobile. For shallow contoured parts, the surfacing film may be fed directly from the source roll into the mold cavity. In producing deep-drawn, highly contoured plastic articles, it is desirable to preform the decorative surfacing film, such as by vacuum forming, prior to placement in the mold. The thermoformability properties of the thermoplastic bonding layer make it possible for the surfacing film to be vacuum thermoformed into a desired three-dimensional configuration, and insures that the thus preformed surfacing film retains its pre-formed shape during subsequent handling and placement in the mold of the injection molding machine.
The bonding layer 14 may be from about 0.25 to about 250 thousandths of an inch thick, and most desirably a minimum thickness of 2 mils to ensure good thermoformability and other properties as noted above.
Preferably, the tear strength of the cast film is less than the bond strength of the cast film to the molded polymer substrate. This will prevent tears from forming in the cast film, running across the surface of the molded article, and quickly destroying the article. Instead, the weatherable cast polymer film surface will flake off in small particles when disrupted by nicks and scratches from stones and other flying particles, as routinely confronts automobile surfaces.
The cast weatherable film is preferably between 0.5 and 300 thousandths of an inch thick, and most preferably from about one to about two thousandths of an inch thick. Similar molded parts can be achieved with injected ABS and styrene by laminating the surface film to a corresponding substrate layer of ABS or styrene.
The present invention is carried out on conventional molding equipment in accordance with known techniques. Particularly suitable injection-molding equipment and techniques are disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,397,806 and 4,307, 057 to Hettinga. The decorative film may be heated and vacuum formed in a separate forming mold prior to being placed in the injection mold, or may be shaped by heat and pressure in the injection mold.
The present invention is particularly suitable for making deep draw molded articles. Deep draw articles, and deep draw molding procedures, are those in which the depth of the molded article is relatively large in relation to the length and width of the two-dimensional decorative surfacing film from which the article is made. More particularly, the depth of the article should be such that substantial stretching and elongation of the decorative surfacing film occurs at least in regions of the decorative surfacing film. Such substantial stretching and elongation occur when the decorative surfacing film is subjected to elongation of about 25% or more at least in regions thereof. The cast film is preferably formed from a polymer selected so that the decorative surfacing film will maintain a paint-like appearance, and will not stress whiten, when stretched and elongated.
With the surfacing film of the present invention, it is possible to produce a structure formed from a set of assembled parts, wherein each part has a uniform decorative outer surface formed by a decorative surfacing film. For example, a set of molded plastic automobile parts can be produced and assembled as shown in FIGS. 3 and 4. This method comprises the steps of first placing into a mold a preformed decorative surfacing film of the type described above, then introducing a moldable polymer into the mold as described above, and then molding the surfacing film and the polymer, as also described above. These three steps (placing the surfacing film into the mold; introducing polymer into the mold; molding the surfacing film and the polymer) are then repeated for each article in the set, so that each article in the set has the same weatherable cast pigmented polymer film on the outer surface thereof. As stated above, the articles in the set may or may not all be formed of the same moldable material. Therefore, for the making of each article, the decorative surfacing film has a bonding layer of a material which has been preselected to adhere to the particular moldable polymer from which that particular article is made. While molding polymers may thus advantageously differ from article to article, and bonding layers may accordingly differ from article to article, every article in the set has the same cast pigmented film on the outer surface thereof. As a result, when the set of molded articles is assembled into the aforesaid structure, the need for spray-painting the structure to otherwise provide it with a uniform decorative outer surface is eliminated.
The present invention is explained further in the following nonlimiting examples.
EXAMPLE 1
A weatherable cast film formed from an alloy of an acrylic polymer and polyvinylidene fluoride (e.g., "FLUOREX"), is formed with internal pigments, including reflective metallic flakes. The film is laminated to a polyvinylchloride (PVC) film with an acrylic adhesive. The multilayered film is then placed in a mold, the mold closed, and PVC injected into the mold behind the polyvinylchloride bonding layer. The PVC molding polymer and the weatherable film/PVC film laminate are then molded for a time and temperature sufficient to form a shaped article, with the weatherable film bonded to the outer surface thereof by the PVC bonding layer.
EXAMPLE 2
The procedure of Example 1 is repeated with polyethylene terephthalate-glycol (PETG) as the bonding substrate and with PETG as the molding polymer to form additional molded articles.
EXAMPLE 3
The same procedure is carried out as described in Example 1 above, except that the cast film is bonded to a PETG bonding film, and RIM urethane is used as the molding resin.
EXAMPLE 4
The same procedure is carried out as described in Example 1 above, except that the cast film is bonded to an acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) bonding film, and ABS is used as the injection-molding polymer.
EXAMPLE 5
A weatherable cast film formed from an alloy of an acrylic polymer and polyvinylidene fluoride is bonded to a PVC film with an acrylic adhesive, and the PVC film is bonded to a polypropylene film bonding layer with a polyester isocyanate adhesive. An article is made according to the procedures set forth in Example 1, with polypropylene as the molding polymer. Other articles can be made with other olefins as bonding layers, and with thermoplastic olefins, known as "TPO polymers," as molding polymers.
EXAMPLE 6
A weatherable cast film formed from a fluoropolymer, an acrylate polymer, a urethane polymer, or a blend thereof, is bonded, with an acrylate adhesive, to an ABS, PVC, or nylon film to form a decorative surfacing film. Articles are made with such decorative surfacing films according to the procedures set forth in Example 1. with nylon molding polymers.
In the drawings and specification, there has been disclosed typical preferred embodiments of the invention. Although specific terms are employed, they are used in a generic and descriptive sense only and not for purposes of limitation, the scope of the invention being set forth in the following claims.
Claims
  • 1. A decorative surfacing film for in-mold surfacing of a molded plastic article to impart a high quality surface appearance comparable to that of a high quality automotive paint finish, comprising a preformed molecularly unoriented liquid-cast weatherable fluoropolymer film, a bonding layer comprising a preformed film of a melt produced thermoplastic thermoformable olefin polymer different from said cast polymer film, and an adhesive layer adhering said bonding layer to said liquid-cast weatherable fluoropolymer film, said bonding layer having a thickness of at least 2 mils and sufficient to render the preformed decorative surfacing film shape sustaining when thermoformed, said cast polymer film having pigments therein for providing an appearance and color to the molded plastic article comparable to a high quality automotive paint finish.
  • 2. A decorative surfacing film as claimed in claim 1, wherein said liquid cast weatherable fluoropolymer film comprises an alloy of a polyvinylidene fluoride polymer and an acrylic polymer.
  • 3. A decorative surfacing film as claimed in claim 1, wherein said bonding layer is formed of an acrylonitrilebutadiene-styrene polymer.
  • 4. A decorative surfacing film as claimed in claim 1, wherein said bonding layer is formed of a polyolefin.
  • 5. A decorative surfacing film as claimed in claim 4, wherein said bonding layer comprises a chlorinated polyolefin.
  • 6. A decorative surfacing film as claimed in claim 1, wherein said molecularly unoriented cast polymer film has reflective pigments uniformly distributed therein.
  • 7. A decorative surfacing film as claimed in claim 1, wherein said decorative surfacing film has regions thereof which have been subjected to an elongation of about 25% or more.
  • 8. A decorative surfacing film for in-mold surfacing of a molded plastic article to impart a high quality surface appearance comparable to that of a high quality automotive paint finish, comprising a preformed substantially molecularly unoriented cast weatherable polymer film comprising an alloy of polyvinylidene fluoride and an acrylic polymer, a thermoformable bonding layer formed of a melt produced thermoplastic thermoformable polymer different from said cast polymer film, and an adhesive layer between said thermoformable bonding layer and said cast polymer film, said bonding layer having a thickness of at least 0.25 mils and sufficient to render the preformed decorative surfacing film shape sustaining when thermoformed, said cast polymer film having pigments therein for providing the molded plastic article the appearance of a high-quality automobile body paint finish.
CROSS REFERENCES TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a division of Ser. No. 08/267,568, filed Jun. 28, 1994, now U.S. Pat. No. 5,514,427; which is a division of application Ser. No. 07/955,317, filed Oct. 1, 1992, now U.S. Pat. No. 5,342,666; which is a continuation of now abandoned application Ser. No. 07/410,662 filed Sep. 21, 1989; which in turn is a continuation-in-part of now abandoned application Ser. No. 06/924,295 filed Oct. 28, 1986.Iadd.; and is also a continuation of Ser. No. 07/241,856, filed Sep. 8, 1988, now U.S. Pat. No. 4,931,324, which in turn is a continuation in part of Ser. No. 06/924,299, filed Oct. 28, 1986, now U.S. Pat. No. 4,810,540.Iaddend..

US Referenced Citations (69)
Number Name Date Kind
3122598 Berger Feb 1964
3257266 Sapper Jun 1966
3338617 Lockwood Aug 1967
3459834 Schmitt Aug 1969
3524906 Schmitt et al. Aug 1970
3551232 Thompson Dec 1970
3579485 Folzen Logen et al. May 1971
3616192 Sinclair Oct 1971
3654062 Loew Apr 1972
3655840 Krug Apr 1972
3679506 Burgess et al. Jul 1972
3679510 Conley et al. Jul 1972
3880690 Fuchs et al. Apr 1975
3914482 Sana et al. Oct 1975
3949139 Dunning et al. Apr 1976
4086118 Dewey Apr 1978
4141927 White et al. Feb 1979
4201820 Johnson May 1980
4211590 Steward et al. Jul 1980
4263077 Rampelberg Apr 1981
4303697 Baseden Dec 1981
4314004 Stoneberg Feb 1982
4317860 Strassel Mar 1982
4349592 Nussbaum Sep 1982
4364886 Strassel Dec 1982
4368224 Jackson Jan 1983
4369157 Conner Jan 1983
4396672 Adesko Aug 1983
4396680 Chang Aug 1983
4403003 Beckhouse Sep 1983
4415519 Strassel Nov 1983
4446179 Waugh May 1984
4451522 de Vroom May 1984
4451597 Victorius May 1984
4482586 Smith et al. Nov 1984
4486478 Madonia et al. Dec 1984
4507342 Kielbania, Jr. Mar 1985
4515649 Nussbaum et al. May 1985
4548857 Galante Oct 1985
4560956 Duncan Dec 1985
4574103 Stamper Mar 1986
4623413 Questel et al. Nov 1986
4652470 Das et al. Mar 1987
4654239 Sancovsky Mar 1987
4656098 Yonekura et al. Apr 1987
4678690 Palmer et al. Jul 1987
4681811 Simpson et al. Jul 1987
4699814 Ambrose et al. Oct 1987
4719132 Porter Jan 1988
4734312 Sugiyama Mar 1988
4769100 Short et al. Sep 1988
4810540 Ellison et al. Mar 1989
4818589 Johnson et al. Apr 1989
4824506 Hoerner et al. Apr 1989
4828637 Mentzer et al. May 1989
4832991 Hayward et al. May 1989
4872270 Fronheiser et al. Oct 1989
4902557 Rohrbacher Feb 1990
4913760 Benson et al. Apr 1990
4913970 Hayward et al. Apr 1990
4918800 Reafler et al. Apr 1990
4931324 Ellison et al. Jun 1990
4959189 Rohrbacher et al. Sep 1990
5009821 Weaver Apr 1991
5026448 Reafler et al. Jun 1991
5030514 Hartman Jul 1991
5055346 Rohrbacher Oct 1991
5215826 Shimanski et al. Jun 1993
5342666 Ellison et al. Aug 1994
Foreign Referenced Citations (17)
Number Date Country
929984 Jul 1973 CAX
230364 Jul 1987 EPX
251546 Jan 1988 EPX
285071 Oct 1988 EPX
374551 Jun 1990 EPX
2085615 Dec 1971 FRX
3441906 May 1986 DEX
56140064 Mar 1983 JPX
59-135231 Aug 1984 JPX
59-227447 Dec 1984 JPX
1232971 May 1971 GBX
2079182 Jan 1982 GBX
2084513 Apr 1982 GBX
WO 8807416 Oct 1988 WOX
WO 8904350 May 1989 WOX
WO 8904257 May 1989 WOX
WO 8904218 May 1989 WOX
Non-Patent Literature Citations (22)
Entry
B. Johnson, Development of an Automotive "Paint Film" Concept, SAE Technical Paper Series, International Congress and Exposition, Detroit, Michigan, Feb. 27-Mar. 3, 1989.
Affidavits of Victor H. Rampelberg and Dennis Northrop and accompanying exhibits.
Final Decision by the Board of Patent Appeals and Interference dated Dec. 2, 1994.
Opinion of Judge Sofocleous staying the '680 Interference until the outcome of the '324 Civil Action, served Mar. 6, 1997.
Memorandum in Support of Avery's Motion for Summary Judgment Based on the Failure of Rexam to Disclose the Best Mode Concerning its Polymer Formulation, dated Aug. 8, 1997, served Aug. 8, 1997.
Rexam's Opposition to Avery's Motion for Summary Judgment �Filed Under Seal!, filed Sep. 8, 1997.
Avery's Reply Brief in Support of its Motion for Summary Judgment based on the Failure of Rexam to Disclose the Best Mode Concerning its Polymer Formulation, dated Sep. 16, 1997, served Sep. 17, 1997.
Chemical Week, Jul. 4, 1984, p. 30, Automotive Coatings: Helping Detroit Woo Consumers.
Research Disclosure, Jul. 1984, No. 243, Disclosure 24303, "A Method for Obtaining Prepainted Parts Using a Painted Carrier Film", Publisher: Kenneth Mason Publications, Ltd.
Modern Plastics, Oct. 1984, pp. 22-24.
J.P. McCarthy, "Polypropylene", Modern Plastics Encyclopedia, 1984-1985, p. 80.
T.M. Ellison et al., "In-Mold Decorating and Finishing Plastic Parts with Dry Paint Film", In Tune with the Newest Decorating Technologies, Retac Proceedings, Oct. 1993, pp. 13-21.
Rexham Decorative Products Brochure, Brilliant Performance, "The Fluorex.TM. film finish by Rexham. Tough enough to outweather paint and PVC on exterior automobile parts", 1987.
Eastman Chemicals Publication, Chlorinated Polyolefin CP 343-1(100%), Publication No. GN-355, Nov. 1983.
"Fluoropolymer Gives Ford Flair", British Plastics and Rubber, Oct. 1983
Japan Economic Journal, Oct. 18, 1986, p. 1 "Auto parts makers to move production to N. America".
Machine Design, Oct. 25, 1984, vol. 56, p. 56, ISSN: 0024-9114, "Automakers continued to say yes to plastics".
Automotive Industries, Sep., 1984, vol. 164, p. 72, ISSN: 0273-656X, "Future looks bright for European plastics".
Ward's Auto World, Sep. 1983, vol. 19, p. 31, ISSN: 0043-0315, "Honda's CRX sports plastics innovation".
Dialog Trademarkscan database printout for the trademark Fluorex, U.S. Registration No. 1,554,682, registration date Sep. 5, 1989.
"A Method for Obtaining Prepainted Parts Using a Painted Carrier Film", Research Disclosure Jul. 1984, p. 304 (disclosed anonymously).
Ricklin, S., "Solvent-Cast Films", Plastics Engineering, May 1983, pp. 29-33.
Divisions (2)
Number Date Country
Parent 267568 Jun 1994
Parent 955317 Oct 1992
Continuations (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 410662 Sep 1989
Continuation in Parts (2)
Number Date Country
Parent 924295 Oct 1986
Parent 924299 Oct 1986
Reissues (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 438092 May 1992