1. Field of the Invention
The invention generally relates to integrated methods and systems for utilizing CO2 as a feedstock for microorganisms. In particular, the invention provides methods for capturing CO2, converting it to bicarbonate, and using the bicarbonate as a carbon source for the growth of photosynthetic algae and cyanobacteria.
2. Background of the Invention
Combustion of fossil fuels such as coal, petroleum, and natural gas for energy is the major reason for the increased CO2 concentration in the atmosphere, and this has caused growing concern with respect to the effects on global climate change and ocean acidification (Iglesias-Rodriguez et al., 2008). Usually, the production of 1 kWh of electricity leads to 0.95 kg CO2 emission from coal combustion (DOE&EPA, 2000). A small 50 MW coal fired power plant produces about 1,140 metric ton (MT) CO2/day, whereas a mid-sized 500 MW plant produces 11,400 MT CO2/day (EPA, 2011).
One potential way to reduce this emission is to capture, transport, and store CO2 in geologic formations. However, compared to processes without carbon capture, the coal combustion process with carbon capture and storage has a very high cost, and can become a favored technology only if the emission price of CO2 reaches $67/MT (NETL, 2010; Plasynski et al., 2009). Also, storage of CO2 in geologic formations may create new environmental issues such as induction of earthquake activity, threat of CO2 leakage, or potential contamination of groundwater (Plasynski et al., 2009; Sminchak and Gupta, 2001).
Instead of storage in geologic formations, an ideal solution for captured CO2 would be conversion into biomass, so that CO2 can be recycled into the biotic carbon pool, or stored in soil carbon pools as organic or inorganic carbon (Lal, 2004; Lee et al., 2010; Ramanan et al., 2010). Production of biofuel from the grown biomass would reduce the usage of fossil fuels, and this would likewise contribute to a reduction in CO2 emissions (Packer, 2009; Pienkos and Darzins, 2009).
Biodiesel can be produced from a variety of traditional oil crops such as soybeans, canola, palm, corn, and jatropha. However, these crops compete with food resources, and may suffer from production limitations in the future. Microalgae culture promises a superior alternative, due to its significant advantages for high productivity, no competition with food sources, as well as generating valuable co-products (Chen et al., 2010; Chisti, 2007). However, key challenges such as the high cost of algal biomass production, harvesting, and oil extraction remain to be solved before such cultures are ready for industrial application.
The high cost of feedstock CO2 is the major obstacle for algal biomass production. All current carbon capture technologies require large amounts of extra energy to regenerate the absorbent, and this leads to a significantly decreased power plant efficiency and corresponding increased cost of electricity (COE). For example, based on the reaction of CO32−+CO2+H2O2HCO3−, the Benfield™ process of Honeywell Group's UOP Inc. developed a process that uses a high concentration of potassium carbonate to absorb CO2, and convert it into potassium bicarbonate (Plasynski et al., 2009). The bicarbonate is then converted back to carbonate by releasing CO2 using heat. This process consumes 1,381-2,549 MJ of extra thermal energy to remove 1 MT CO2 (Furukawa and Bartoo, 1997), and this parasitic energy consumption is about 36.4%-67.3% of the electricity produced.
Usually, the available land around power plants is limited, and thus CO2 has to be captured and transported to algae ponds a long distance away. However, this is limited by high costs for carbon transportation. Typically, CO2 is compressed to a pressure of 150 atm to be transported through a pipeline. This compression process consumes considerable energy and increases the transportation cost. The cost estimated by Kadam et al (1997) for 100 km-transportation is $8.48/MT CO2 for compression and drying, as well as $3.30/MT CO2 for pipeline transportation, respectively.
Using captured carbon for algae culture also faces other major challenges. For example, the captured CO2 cannot be temporarily stored during night time or winter, when algae do not grow. Also, there is a significant loss of CO2 from outgas if the algae are cultured in an open system. As a result of these problems a maximum of only 25% CO2 is typically captured by algae culture (Benemann, 2009). This is not satisfactory for a successful carbon capture process, which requires that 90% of the CO2 in flue gas be recovered (Benemann, 2009; NETL, 2010).
In summary, current technology for using CO2 from a concentrated source for algae culture is limited by the high cost of carbon capture, high cost of transportation, difficulty of CO2 temporary storage, and low efficiency. An alternative process for CO2 capture, transport, and delivery is required for an industrial scale algal biomass production system.
The invention provides integrated methods and systems for capturing CO2 and converting captured CO2 to bicarbonate, transporting bicarbonate e.g. into an alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria culture system, where the bicarbonate serves as a carbon source for the microorganisms, and recycling medium from the culture system, which contains a high concentration of dissolved CO2) by recapturing the CO2 and converting it to bicarbonate, which is then used in the alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria culture system, and so on. The CO2 is thus recycled indefinitely. If the original source of the CO2 is the culture system, then the method is truly a closed loop method. However, the initial input of CO2 (or subsequent inputs) may be from other sources (e.g. industrial sources), in which case the method is partially closed, but may continue as a closed loop system. Also, the bicarbonate (which may be in either solid or solution form) may serve as the sole source of carbon for the microorganisms, or, alternatively, other carbon sources may also be used.
Systems for carrying out the method are also provided. The systems include apparatuses or means for i) capturing and ii) converting the CO2, a suitable culture system, and integrated means for transporting the CO2 and bicarbonate from one system component to another. The methods and systems are advantageous in part because the transport of bicarbonate (either as a solid or in solution) is less costly and less dangerous than the transport of CO2 gas.
Upon analysis of these CO2 transportation related problems, it can be deduced that these problems exist because captured carbon is handled as a compressed CO2, rather than water solution at normal atmospheric pressure. Fortunately, inorganic carbon (Ci) not only exists as CO2 gas, but also as carbonate or bicarbonate salts. The solubility of certain carbonate salts in water is very high. For example, the solubility of sodium bicarbonate at 25° C. is 103 g/L or 10.3% (w/v). If the captured carbon is converted into a bicarbonate/carbonate aqueous solution, it can easily be transported in a water pipeline at normal pressure.
Zhou and Richard (2005) estimated the cost for a 100 km horizontal transport of water to be $0.05-$0.06/m3 by canal and $ 0.104-$0.125/m3 by water tunnel (2005). It can be predicted that a bicarbonate solution will have a much lower transportation cost than the corresponding compressed CO2. Also, the transportation cost of a water solution can be linearly reduced if the transport distance is shortened, whereas compression is obligatory for any distance of CO2 gas transportation.
For an algae culture process, the bicarbonate water solution can be stored during winter or night time, and supplied to the algae culture system in summer or day time. For example, the daily emission of 1,140 tons of CO2 from a small 50 MW power plant can be stored as a 22,800 m3 sodium bicarbonate solution. It may be noted that delivery of this bicarbonate solution to an algae culture system does not require a gas sparging system. Also, algae culture at high pH would prevent invading and undesirable species from contaminating the designated culture systems.
There are actually many methods of CO2 capture that convert CO2 into bicarbonate, and all these methods can be used as a method in this integrated system. If the bicarbonate is produced as solids, it can be stored and/or transported as solids, which will save significant cost for compression of CO2. If bicarbonate is produced as water solution, it can be stored and/or transported with water pipeline, or open water channel, as indicated in
Either CO2 or HCO3−, once imported into the cell, accumulates mainly as HCO3−. Lipid membranes are about 1000-fold more permeable to CO2 than HCO3− and severe leakage occurs if a rapid equilibration between CO2 and HCO3− occurs in the cytosol. Thus, HCO3− is normally held at steady-state, where its concentration can reach 20-40 mM, despite the extracellular CO2 concentration of 15 μM in fresh water and 2 mM in seawater (Price et al., 2008).
According to the equilibrium H++HCO3−CO2+H2O, H+ is consumed in the conversion of HCO3− to CO2, and the CO2 is ultimately fixed by Rubisco in photosynthesis. Thus, steady-state usage of HCO3− as the original carbon source for photosynthesis leaves OH− in the cell, and this has to be neutralized by H− uptake from the extracellular environment. The reduction of H+ in the culture medium unavoidably leads to an increased pH, which subsequently changes the equilibrium between different Ci species. The pKa of HCO3− in fresh water at 25° C. and 1 atm is 10.33; thus the acid/base pair bicarbonate/carbonate can act as a strong buffer around this pH. The increased pH will ultimately result in higher ratio of CO32− to HCO3−. From this viewpoint, the algae culture process actually regenerates carbonate by means of solar energy.
Although it appears promising, the potential for such a culture system depends on availability of strains of algae that can grow in a high concentration bicarbonate environment. To grow in this environment, the eukaryotic algae or cyanobacteria must overcome the high pH and high ion strength. Fortunately, the same challenges exist naturally in many soda lakes. Zavarzin et al have summarized the parameters of some soda lakes, and showed that their pH ranges from 8.4 to 10.8, and the CO32− concentration from 0.3 to 90.2 g/L (1.5 M) (Fleming and Prufert-Bebout, 2010; Gerasimenko and Mikhodyuk, 2009; Oberholster et al., 2009; Zavarzin et al., 1999).
Even in this extreme environment, blooms of cyanobacteria can occur, and their biomass productivity can reach 10 g C/m2/day (Zavarzin et al., 1999). If the carbon content in the produced algal biomass is 50%, the dry biomass productivity would be about 20 g/m2/day, which is at the same level as an artificial open pond algae culture system designed for biofuel production (Sheehan et al., 1998). Our unpublished research on alkaliphilic cyanobacteria culture within the pH range 9.5 to 10.5 resulted in a biomass productivity of 0.1 g/L/day, which is very similar to the growth rate of other common microalgae reported to be 0.117 g/L/day (Chisti, 2007). Further efforts on culture condition optimization promise to improve this productivity.
These halophilic and alkaliphilic cyanobacteria strains can be isolated and used in the integrated culture system proposed in
Water solution with high concentration of bicarbonate is fatal for most of microbes, but some photosynthetic cyanobacteria and microalgae are able to grow in it (Mikhodyuk et al., 2008). Culture the algae or cyanobacteria that utilize bicarbonate as the carbon source for their photosynthesis and are tolerant to high concentration of bicarbonate is the key for this algae culture process.
There are some alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria existed in nature (Pikuta et al., 2007), which can be used in this system. More preferably are the alkaliphilic algae strains that are tolerant to high salt concentration (for example, high sodium concentration). Still more preferably are the alkaliphilic algae strains that are tolerant to high concentration of bicarbonate (for example, sodium bicarbonate). Most preferably are the algae strains that can grow in saturated sodium bicarbonate or sodium carbonate solution.
The algae or cyanobacteria strains isolated from soda lakes are ideal for this process, since soda lakes usually have high pH, high salt concentration, and high bicarbonate or carbonate concentration. Extremely alkaliphilic and halophilic algae can be isolated from this environment. These strains can be from, but not limited to, cyanobacteria such as Synechocystis sp., Cyanothece sp., Microcoleus sp., Euhalothece sp., Spirulina sp., as well as eukaryotic microalgae Chlorella and Dunaliella. Also, other algae strains with similar characters but isolated from other environment also can be used in this culture system.
The algae culture system that can be used in this system include, but not limited to, open pond system, closed photo-bioreactor system, and any other known or new designed algae culture system.
The pH in this algae culture system is from neutral (pH=7.0) to very alkaline (pH>11.0), as long as the culture algae or cyanobacteria can survive and grow. With consumption of bicarbonate in the algae culture process, the pH increases gradually.
Besides carbon capture, a major purpose of this algae culture system is to produce algal products. Microalgae are found to be a good producer for many chemicals, and it has been used as source of food and a variety of other bioproducts. These products includes, but not limited to, algae oil for biofuel, algae oil for nutraceuticals (such as omega-3 fatty acids), pigments (such as carotenoids), alginate, fertilizer, and any other bioproducts that can be produced from algae. Products produced by or from the microorganisms cultured as described herein are encompassed by the invention. Further, the methods of the invention may further comprise a step of obtaining such products from the cultured organisms, e.g. by harvesting and extricating a product, or by using harvested organisms directly in a product (e.g. fertilizer), or by extracting a product from the medium in which the organisms are grown, etc.
It is notable that high concentration of bicarbonate can produce a high density of algae biomass. It was calculated and listed in table 2. As indicated, if only 0.1 mol/L of bicarbonate is consumed, it can produce 2.4 g/L algal biomass. If more bicarbonate is consumed, the algae biomass yield can be higher. However, the algae culture is usually limited by light source, and a single culture process may produce limited algae biomass density, and leave a significant concentration of bicarbonate, which can be used for another cycle of algae culture. Thus, repeat culture may be used in this algae culture process. In this situation, the cultured algal biomass is separated and harvested, and the water is discharged into another algae culture system for another round of algae culture.
The invention thus provides a method for CO2 capture and algae culture, and systems in which the method can be implemented. The method comprises the following steps or processes:
1) a CO2 capture process that converts CO2 into bicarbonate; 2) transport of the produced bicarbonate to one or more algae culture system as a water solution or as solid bicarbonate salts; 3) culture of alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria in the algae culture system with the transported bicarbonate as the one of carbon sources to produce algal or cyanobacteria bioproducts, and 4) transport of the used (leftover) water from algae culture process for CO2 capture. In some embodiments, the bicarbonate is present as a salt, e.g. a sodium salt. However, other salts (e.g. potassium, ammonium, etc.) may also be used. Thus, in various embodiments, the bicarbonate solution or salt may be, for example sodium bicarbonate or potassium bicarbonate or ammonium bicarbonate, or even a mixture of these.
The CO2 capture process is generally a method that produced bicarbonate as one of its product. These methods include, but are not limited to, using a salt of carbonate as an absorbent, or using carbonic anhydrase as a catalyst, or using ammonia and sodium chloride as feedstock to produce bicarbonate, for example, Solvay process and Hou's process (Plasynski et al., 2009).
Sources of CO2 which is captured include, but are not limited to, thermal power plant (e.g. coal-, natural gas, or oil-fired plants), fermentation processes, anaerobic digestion processes, ammonia plants, air, exhaust, and any other CO2 sources.
If the bicarbonate is stored as a liquid solution, transportation methods include, but are not limited to, closed pipelines, or open pipelines, tank trucks, tanks transported by rail, or any other transport methods suitable for liquid. In this embodiment, the bicarbonate solution that is transported has a concentration of at least 0.01 mol/L, for example, a range of about 0.01 mol/L to a fully saturated sodium bicarbonate solution. In some embodiments, a preferred concentration is in the range of about 0.3 mol/L up to saturation, i.e. up to a saturated solution of sodium bicarbonate. Those of skill in the art will recognize that saturation is the point at which a solution of a substance can dissolve no more of that substance and additional amounts of it will appear as a precipitate. This point of maximum concentration, the saturation point, may depend on the temperature of the liquid such that if the substance is dissolved to the point of saturation in hot solvent, a change in conditions (e.g. cooling) may result in a supersaturated solution. In some embodiments, the bicarbonate is solid bicarbonate salt. In this embodiment, transportation methods include, but are not limited to, truck, railway, belt, or any other transport methods for solids.
The culture system that utilizes the bicarbonate as a carbon source may be any phototrophic microorganism or group of microorganisms that can utilize bicarbonate as a carbon source. In some embodiments, the phototrophic microorganism are alkaliphilic algae and/or cyanobacteria. Exemplary alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria include, but are not limited to, cyanobacteria such as Synechocystis sp., Cyanothece sp., Microcoleus sp., Euhalothece sp., Spirulina sp., eukaryotic microalgae Chlorella and Dunaliella. The microorganisms may be isolated from natural sources, or, alternatively, may be genetically engineered using recombinant techniques, e.g. to increase their tolerance of bicarbonate and/or alkalinity. In some embodiments, the alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria include all phototrophic microorganisms that are capable of growing in (i.e. that tolerate) culture medium with a concentration of least about 0.01 mol/L bicarbonate. In some embodiments, the alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria include phototrophic microorganisms that grow in culture medium with a concentration range from about 0.01 mol/L bicarbonate up to a saturated solution of bicarbonate. For example, the concentration range may be from at least about 0.3 mol/L bicarbonate up to a saturated solution of bicarbonate.
pH of the culture of alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria is generally in a pH range of from about 8.0 to about 12, for example, from about 9.0 to about 11. The alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria culture may or may not have a pH control mechanism in the algae culture system, and may or may not have a CO2 bubbling system.
In some embodiments of the invention, the culture of alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria may utilize bicarbonate as the solely carbon source. However, culture systems which include other carbon sources are also encompassed, i.e. bicarbonate may be one of a plurality of carbon sources.
Exemplary culture systems include but are not limited to: open pond systems, closed photo-bioreactor systems, etc. Any suitable culture system may be used in the practice of the invention. In some embodiments, the culture of alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria is conducted in batch culture, or in semi-continuous culture, or in continuous culture. Bicarbonate enriched solution (e.g. water) may be used, for example, in one or in multiple steps or batches of the procedure. For example, the culture of alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria may use bicarbonate enriched water in more than one batch (i.e. repeat culture) with the same water, e.g. until the pH has increased to a range that algae species cannot survive in.
Used (spent, leftover, residual, etc.) liquid or medium (usually water) from the algae culture system e.g. after the microorganisms have been harvested or otherwise removed from the culture, is also recycled into the system. This spent medium has a pH of between about 8.0 to about 12.0, for example, a pH between about 9.0 to about 11.0, and contains large amounts of carbonate (and also may contain various dissolved salts, minerals, and organic molecular byproducts of microorganism growth, etc.) The carbonate-rich spent medium may be reprocessed to recapture the carbonate, either in solid form, or in a liquid (e.g. water) with a very high carbonate concentration, including and up to saturation, as described above. Transportation of the used water to a suitable processing facility may be carriod our using any suitable approach, for example, a closed pipeline, an open pipeline, or any other transport methods suitable for liquid.
Those of skill in the art will recognize that many products may be produced as the result of the culture of alkaliphilic algae or cyanobacteria produced as described herein. One or more algal products may be produced from a single culture, these products including, but not limited to, algae oil for biofuel, algae oil for nutraceuticals (such as omega-3 fatty acids), pigments (such as carotenoids), alginate, fertilizer, and any other byproducts that can be produced from algae. The invention also encompasses products made by algae or cyanobacteria using the methods and systems of the invention.
The foregoing Examples are provided to illustrate various exemplary embodiments of the invention, but should not be construed so as to limit the invention in any way.
Dunaliella primolecta (UTEX LB 1000) is cultured with artificial seawater medium (UTEX) with reduced concentration of calcium (5% of original concentration) and magnesium (10% of original concentration).
The cells were cultured in the 24-well plate, 2 mL for each well. The culture room temperature was controlled at 20° C. Different concentrations of sodium bicarbonate were used as the inorganic carbon source, and no CO2 gas is delivered into the culture. The optical distribution was tested with 750 nm wavelength light for each sample.
Dunaliella primolecta grows to its maximum growth at 3rd day of culture (
The cells were culture in 250-mL scale photobioreactors, and artificial seawater medium with reduced concentration of calcium (5% of original concentration) and magnesium (10% of original concentration). The culture room temperature was controlled at 20° C. 0.3M sodium bicarbonate was used as the inorganic carbon source in the stirred cultures without bubbling. Two other cultures conducted as comparisons. One group used the same medium, and sparged with 2% (v/v) CO2 in air. The other group used same medium without bicarbonate, and sparged with 2% (v/v) CO2 in air.
The stirred culture without CO2 sparging had same productivity as the culture with the two CO2 sparging controls, with or without bicarbonate as the extra carbon source (
Euhalothece ZM001 is cultured with a 1.0 M sodium bicarbonate concentration, and its compositions are:
The cells were cultured in photobioreactors with agitation, but not aeration. The light path for the photobioreactor was about 0.5 cm, and the photobioreactors were place under the light with intensity of 100 μmol/m2/s. the culture temperature was 35° C.
The initial pH was adjusted to 9.5 with sodium hydroxide. With inoculation concentration of 1.2 g/L, the final biomass concentration in this culture was 4.8 g/L, and the daily productivity was 0.72 g/L/day (
These examples show that sufficient carbon source can be delivered to the algae culture system as bicarbonate, instead of CO2 gas. The productivity of algae biomass with bicarbonate as inorganic carbon source obtained is at the same level as the culture with CO2 gas as inorganic carbon source. Culture of Euhalothece sp. used medium contains 1.0 M sodium bicarbonate. This concentration was proved to be effective when carbonate is used as absorbent for CO2 capture (Plasynski et al., 2009). The productivity of biomass can reach 0.72 g/L/day, and this indicates captured carbon can be utilized efficiently and be converted into algae biomass.
While the invention has been described in terms of its preferred embodiments, those skilled in the art will recognize that the invention can be practiced with modification within the spirit and scope of the appended claims. Accordingly, the present invention should not be limited to the embodiments as described above, but should further include all modifications and equivalents thereof within the spirit and scope of the description provided herein.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/US11/64127 | 12/9/2011 | WO | 00 | 8/19/2013 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61421449 | Dec 2010 | US |