Development of miniaturized (micro) total analysis systems (μTAS) is of increasing interest in the biomedical research community. Often referred to as ‘Laboratory-on-a-chip’ (or LOC), this technology offers new prospects for health care delivery and biomedical research. Envisioned are microsystems for massively parallel chemical analysis, drug testing, bioassay, and diagnostic devices for non-invasive, early detection of cancers and other serious health problems.
Real biological cells, such as erythrocytes, cells derived from tissue, and microbial cells express a high degree of heterogeneity in a typical population. When subjected to nonuniform electrical fields, individual cells in these populations manifest a wide range of AC electrokinetic responses and behaviors [1-3]. References indicated by numerals in square brackets are listed at the end of the disclosure and incorporated by reference herein. Furthermore, these characteristic dielectric fingerprints are quite sensitive to the sample environment. Specifically, the frequency-dependent polarization response reflected in the dielectrophoretic (DEP), electrorotation (ROT) and traveling wave dielectrophoresis (TW-DEP) spectra of viable, nonviable and/or diseased cells manifest highly distinguishable characteristics in certain regions of the frequency spectrum.
In the past, cellular DEP has been practiced primarily using closed fluidic chambers or interconnected microchannels interfaced to external fluid pumping and sample injection hardware [2, 4]. Such systems, particularly those employing microfluidic channels for cell collection and separation, usually require sample preprocessing and are often plagued by micro-channel blockage. By their very nature, closed channel microfluidic systems are very complex structures, requiring extensive on-chip valving and flow control devices. The pressure differentials required to force liquids through the narrow channels are sufficiently high (˜105 Pa) are high enough so that leakage becomes a concern. For successful commercialization in microfluidic cell analysis/sorting devices, these problems must be overcome.
An attractive alternative to the closed channel microfluidic systems is open-channel microfluidics for micro and potentially nanoscale DEP-actuated fluidic transport and subsequent particle manipulation [5, 6]. In the preferred embodiment of such open systems, droplets themselves serve as the carriers for the cells or biological molecules and the reagents needed for biochemical protocols. Because the liquid samples are sessile droplets residing on an open substrate, such systems are immune to microchannel blockage. The basic design rules for DEP droplet dispensing have been published in two papers [10, 11]. King et al. showed that particles can be transported using transient liquid DEP actuation [12] with sorting based on particle size. The present application addresses a novel approach for particle sorting that builds upon DEP actuated liquid transport.
According to an aspect of the invention, there is provided an integrated droplet-based, DEP-actuated microfluidic device with integral DEP particle processing. According to a further aspect of the invention, there is provided apparatus, comprising:
a first electrode set defining a first flow path for liquid along a first gap between electrodes of the first electrode set;
a second electrode set defining a second flow path for liquid along a second gap between electrodes of the second electrode set;
an intermediate electrode station formed by an intersection between the first electrode set and the second electrode set, the intersection incorporating an electrode configuration for supplying a voltage gradient at the intermediate electrode station; and
voltage sources connected to the first electrode set, second electrode set and the intersection for separately supplying dielectrophoresis voltage to the first electrode set, second electrode set and the intermediate electrode station.
According to another aspect of the invention, the second electrode set may comprise plural electrode stations.
According to a further aspect of the invention, there is provided apparatus, comprising:
a first dielectrophoretic actuator incorporating a first set of electrodes defining a first flow path for liquid, the first flow path extending to an intermediate electrode station;
a second dielectrophoretic actuator incorporating a second set of electrodes defining a second flow path for liquid extending from the intermediate electrode station to a plurality of electrode stations; and
the intermediate electrode station incorporating electrodes configured for establishing an electric field gradient at the intermediate electrode station that is capable of isolating particles carried by the liquid upon application of a dielectrophoretic voltage to the electrodes at the intermediate electrode station.
According to still further aspects of the invention:
The first set of electrodes and the first flow path may extend to plural intermediate stations.
The apparatus may comprise multiple dielectrophoretic actuators, each of the multiple dielectrophoretic actuators incorporating a set of electrodes defining a flow path for liquid extending from respective ones of the intermediate electrode stations to respective sets of electrode stations.
The electrode stations may be spaced at spaced at intervals corresponding to Rayleigh instability points.
The intermediate electrode stations may each comprise interdigitated electrodes. Other DEP electrode arrangements may be used for particle separation.
The electrode stations may comprise bumps on the electrodes.
The electrodes of any electrode set have a width between bumps, the bumps of an electrode set are formed of semi-circles having a radius; and for any electrode set, the width of the electrodes may equal the bump radius. Other geometries of bumps may be used.
The electrodes may be patterned on the surface of a substrate, either directly or on a coated surface, such as a dielectrically coated surface of a substrate.
The flow paths are open, as defined in the detailed description.
The electrodes may be coated with a dielectric material.
One of the intermediate electrode stations may be a traveling wave dielectrophoretic actuator.
The apparatus is provided with heat dissipation structures. Heat dissipation may also be obtained through a thermally conductive substrate material such as mica.
An intermediate electrode station may be provided with electrodes leading towards it from multiple droplet reservoirs, to enable mixing to take place at the intermediate electrode station.
The electrodes may be patterned on a chip provided with capillaries, and the electrodes may define flow paths that terminate at an opening into a capillary.
According to a further aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of sample separation, the method comprising the steps of:
applying dielectrophoretic forces to a liquid to cause the liquid to move along a flow path to an intermediate station;
applying dielectrophoretic forces within the liquid at the intermediate station to cause a separation of material carried by the liquid; and
applying dielectrophoretic forces to the liquid along a flow path to remove material separated at the intermediate station.
The method may be carried out using the features of the apparatus of the invention.
The method may further comprise removal of separated material from the intermediate stations to further stations along a flow path.
Further processing of the separated material may occur at the further stations. The further stations may also be configured for high electric field gradient and the separated material may be subject to a second stage separation process for example using DEP with a different frequency window from a frequency window used at the intermediate stations.
Material isolated by a DEP separation process at the further stations may be drawn by DEP along a still further flow path to an additional set of stations.
The method may be applied to the separation of particles, such as cells, carried by the liquid. The cells may contain DNA and the process may further comprise lysing of the cells and treatment of the cell contents such as DNA by PCR. Cell lysing and PCR may be carried out in droplets at the stations.
Detection of material in the populations at the intermediate stations or at the further stations may be carried out, for example using fluorescence detectors or other optical means.
The electrodes may be used to transport liquid and material carried by the liquid to an entry into a capillary electrophoresis channel, where the material may be subject to capillary electrophoresis.
Other aspects of the invention are included in the detailed description of preferred embodiments.
There will now be described preferred embodiments of the invention by way of example, with reference to the figures, in which:
a is a graph showing an exemplary DEP polarization spectrum of two different cell types (A and B);
b is a graph showing frequency response of a heterogeneous sample consisting of cell types A, B, C and D;
In this patent document, “comprising” is used in its inclusive sense and does not exclude other elements being present. Also, the indefinite article “a” before an element does not exclude another of the element being present. The word “particle” includes any substance, including an inorganic material, liquid droplet, molecule such as DNA, RNA or other subcellular components, or cell, that is capable of being affected by a dielectrophoretic field. “Open” means free from lateral constraint by solid objects except for constraint by a single supporting surface that provides lateral constraint in one direction.
In an exemplary embodiment of the invention, DEP and EWOD microfluidics serve as a controllable plumbing system, dispensing, transporting, and manipulating droplets of biological media containing cells and cellular components as well as chemicals and washing solutions needed to perform prescribed cell separation processes. Droplet manipulation steps are conducted first using fixed coplanar electrode structures and relatively higher voltages to distribute equal quantities of the sample to each of a large number of stations. Then, cell-level separation, trapping, and beneficiation operations are initiated at each station by exciting fine structure electrodes embedded in the microfluidic structure with much lower voltages. Voltage magnitudes, application intervals, and frequencies are individually programmed for each station, allowing parallel processing of large numbers of identical samples according to a prescribed set of conditions. Next, if the cells have been suitably stained or labeled to distinguish them based on some attribute (e.g., healthy versus cancerous), fluorescent intensities of the sample at each station can be interrogated to quantify numbers of cells utilizing optical microscopy. The scheme is amenable to a modular design, can be scaled readily, and is limited only by the signal generation and identification hardware. The invention provides a unique capability for parallel DEP processing of small inventories of fluids containing a cell mixture. Multiple frequency modules permit cell partitioning into two or more sub-populations.
A microfluidic device of the type disclosed here is particularly suited to use as a laboratory on a chip device by combining and integrating two critical elements: (i) liquid dielectrophoretic actuation for the microfluidic subsystem and (ii) particulate dielectrophoresis to separate particles such as cells based on their frequency-dependent, dielectric spectra.
In
Parallel strip portions of electrodes A and D extend away from parent station P to an intermediate station I formed of enlargements of the electrodes A, B, C and D arranged in quadrants. Parallel strip portions of electrodes A and B extend away from reservoir R to a series of stations S, each formed of enlargements of the corresponding electrodes A and B. Multiple intermediate stations can be added above station I as shown in
When a voltage is applied momentarily between electrodes A and D and between electrodes B and C, an electric field is established in the gap between the electrodes A and D and in the gap between electrodes B and C. This electric field draws a finger or rivulet of liquid from the parent droplet along the flow path established by the electrodes A and D towards the station I according to known principles of dielectrophoresis. The liquid is drawn to areas of high field gradient. If additional intermediate stations In are formed beyond station I, the liquid will flow through to these stations as well, provided sufficient voltage is applied. The liquid projects out very rapidly from the parent station P along the electrode flow path and rapidly covers the intermediate station I to form an intermediate reservoir of sample liquid. With electrodes A and D having a width in their strip portions of 60 microns, and being spaced by a gap of 60 microns, with water as the liquid and a voltage in the order of 240 volts RMS at 100 kHz, the station I fills in about ˜102 milliseconds. As soon as the actuation voltage is removed, the rivulet connecting the large droplet at P to the intermediate station I drains rapidly, leaving an isolated sub-microliter volume droplet at station I. This process occurs in ˜10 milliseconds. In the second stage of operation, voltage is applied between electrodes C and D and between electrodes A and B. In response, a liquid finger forms and moves to the right from the intermediate station I along the flow path established by the electrodes A and B to fill the stations S. Only a few of the stations S (sometimes called bumps) are shown, but the array can consist of as many as twenty or more and they need not be in a straight line. Subsequent removal of voltage results in the formation of one sessile droplet atop each of these stations S. Formation of droplets on the stations S takes less than ˜10 milliseconds for electrodes A, B, where the strip width of the electrodes A, B between stations S is 30 microns, water is used for the liquid and a voltage of 130 volts RMS at 100 kHz is used.
When water is used as the carrier liquid, the electrodes need to be coated with a dielectric to avoid ionization of the water. In addition, if a dielectric liquid is used as a carrier liquid, the electrodes should still be coated with dielectric for use in analyzing particles that might be ionized by the electrodes. In some situations, where for example only dielectric liquids are to be separated or analyzed, without particles, the electrodes need not be covered by dielectric.
In the example shown in
After formation of droplets on the stations I, particulate DEP is used to separate and fractionate particles such as cells or cell components suspended in the liquid samples that have been manipulated and dispensed by the DEP microfluidic subsystem. The foundation of particle manipulation of cells suspended in liquids is the frequency dependence of the force as revealed in
Fine electrode structures are embedded into the electrodes at the stations I (
DEP-based separation or fractionation is not limited to binary sorting of two different cell types, but can be extended to more complex populations. For example, consider a cell sample containing a mixture of four different cell types A, B, C and D, which have distinct differences in their polarization spectra. The DEP separation strategies discussed above can be employed successfully to isolate individual cell types at properly selected frequencies. The bar graph in
The process steps carried out by the apparatus of
For example, the liquid placed at the station P in
The device shown in
In stage 1 shown in
In stage 2 shown in
In stage 3 shown in
As revealed in
A feature of this cell-sorting architecture is the ability to incorporate travelling wave dielectrophoresis (TW-DEP) into the structures. Refer to
The DEP liquid actuation and droplet forming structures need not be restricted to a linear arrangement, but may assume other more compact, higher density structures. An example of one such radial electrode arrangement is shown in
The frequency dependence of the liquid profile in DEP liquid actuation was explained by Jones et al [6]. The critical frequency (fc) of the liquid profile can be estimated from an RC circuit model found in that citation. fc is dependent on the capacitive coupling of the planar electrodes to the sample of known conductivity and may be written as:
where, Gw and Cw are the resistance and capacitance in the sample medium, and Cd is the capacitance of the dielectric layer covering the electrodes. At frequencies less than fc, the voltage drop occurs primarily across the dielectric layer and hence no significant DEP force can act on the droplet to shape its profile. Operation at a frequency greater than fc results in a strong non-uniform E field inside the liquid to effect particulate DEP. On the other hand, at frequencies significantly exceeding fc, a significant fraction of the applied voltage (Va) appears along the droplet. In this limit, the electric field in the liquid helps to shape the profile. The voltage developed across the droplet may be approximated as
From this equation, we note that the voltage drop across the droplet increases with increasing dielectric layer capacitance (Cd). When materials of high dielectric constant such as strontium titanate, barium strontium titanate, and others, are used to coat the electrodes, the high dielectric constant of the dielectric layer increases the DEP actuation force acting on the liquid, but at the same time, could partially screen the electric field used for cell separation. This trade-off needs to be taken into account in design of an embodiment of the invention.
The innovation resulting from the integration of DEP fluid actuation with cellular DEP provides a new class of fluidic Microsystems, which find numerous applications in biological, biotechnology and clinical laboratories that rely or benefit from rapid, reliable and non-invasive DEP fractionation and fingerprinting of cells in suspension. The proposed open-channel platform technology is especially well suited to life science applications that demand real-time monitoring of cell population(s) grown in culture media. For example, the quantification of cell viability is an important parameter for the description of the status of cell cultures and is a basis for numerous cytotoxicity studies. In a clinical setting, the technology is attractive since it requires minimal sample for analysis compared to traditional laboratory techniques employing bench-top instrumentation and has good potential of it being practically applied to the early stage detection of various types of cancers in the human body. Cancer cells originating from different tissues may metastasize into peripheral blood while growing. The proposed invention may be used in a tool for the monitoring of the progression of leukemia therapy, through monitoring the proportion of such cancers in a minute blood sample. Such screening capability can furthermore be exploited to screen for HIV, hepatitis viruses, or other blood borne pathogens in potential donors.
Devices made in accordance with the invention may be integrated with other conventional microfluidic components such on chip PCR, and capillary electrophoresis. Such integrated systems may be used to perform genetic (DNA) analysis on a chip of a certain type or groups of cells to enable genetic profiling of high risk individuals or certain population groups on a routine basis. This type of premptive genetic screening capability will greatly benefit society by enabling efficient and cost effective delivery of diagnosis and therapy.
A device according to the invention may be built as a portable, automated hand held device that can monitor and detect the presence environmental pathogens in air and water supply targeted for human consumption. Applications for the device and method of the invention include: sample manipulation and division for closed microchannel LOC devices, and cell fractionation on the surface of capillary electrophoresis (CE) chips to eliminate contamination of samples due to intermediate handling stage. For example, as shown in
Care must be taken with the selection of dielectric coatings with high dielectric constant and good dielectric strength. To avoid negative effects of high voltage, which include ionization of particles and also the skipping of stations by the rivulet, it is preferred to operate at as low voltages as will provide adequate liquid actuation. Thin dielectrics of relatively high dielectric constant are thus preferred for electrode coatings. A material such as strontium titanate may be made 1 micron thick and it is believed based on theoretical calculations will function as a suitable dielectric at low DEP voltages of around 20 Vpp. Also, surface treatments should be used to reduce wetting hysteresis. SU-8™, Teflon™ and Paralyne™ may be used. Although designed for open channel use, nonetheless, a device according to the invention requires packaging technology to reduce possible sample contamination and evaporation. A cover made for example from PDMS (polydimethylsiloxane) may be used. Heat dissipation should also be maximized to deal with Joule heating effects, especially in aqueous biological media containing significant ions. Heat dissipation may be achieved through supporting the electrodes on a metal base with an insulator between the electrodes and the metal base. The metal base, for example made of aluminum, assists in achieving heat dissipation. Heat dissipation may also be achieved through coating the surface of the device with transformer oil or other relatively viscous oil, when aqueous media is used as the motive liquid. The water rivulet extends through the oil, underneath it, and the oil assists in heat dissipation from the liquid rivulet. The low-high voltage switches should preferably be housed on-chip. Care should also be taken to avoid bio-fouling problems.
The system is a breakthrough in parallel processing of small (sub-microliter) volume samples because it avoids the complex pumping and valving units of other, closed-channel microfluidic devices. The proposed system offers a simple, robust, and flexible architecture for sensitive, massively parallel diagnosis of cell disease, for example, early-stage cancerous “fingerprints”. The invention realizes high-speed liquid actuation [actuation speed ˜15 cm/sec.] on a truly open channel system and the formation of uniformly spaced equal volume droplets.
There will now be described factors influencing liquid actuation, formation of droplets at specific regions, capillary instability, volume and size of the droplets formed and the factors impacting the formation of uniform sized droplets.
On breaking the electric field applied to draw a rivulet along a flow path defined by a gap between electrodes, the rivulet disintegrates into uniform droplets influenced by the Rayleigh's instability criteria. The Rayleigh's theory predicts that the most unstable wavelength for a liquid rivulet to be 9.016×radius of the liquid rivulet. Formation of Nano-liter droplets from parent micro-liter droplets by this phenomenon was reported by one of the authors [6,9]. Further, to enhance the formation of uniformly sized droplets and to increase capillary instability, semicircular bumps were placed along the length of the electrode at locations that are integer multiples of Rayleigh's unstable wavelength.
Bumps at locations other than Rayleigh's instability point results in a non-uniform rivulet breakup. However, bumps located with a uniform λ* spacing [where λ*=9.016R, the Rayleigh's unstable wavelength] resulting in the equal break-up of the rivulet into uniform sized pico-litre droplets on each bump. The ratio of bump radius to the rivulet radius has been found to be 1:1.
Depending on the application, particle DEP implementation in surface microfluidics may require suitable coating material to either promote or deter adhesion of bioparticles to the microfluidic surface. For example, mammalian cells in general are reported to have a high sticking coefficient, which normally hinders the movement of cells under negative DEP force. This may be particularly important for hydrophilic substrates, which are more prone to the adhesion of cells than hydrophobic substrates. Hydrophobic coatings such as Teflon, PDMS, Silicon-on-glass can be successfully used to provide the necessary hydrophobicity. Also, silicon-dioxide (SiO2, K=3.9) and silicon nitride (Si3N4, K=7.5) with a dielectric strength of 107 V/cm each are known to be effective dielectric materials. DEP with Si3N4 and SiO2 as dielectric coating is also known prevent cell adhesion to the surface. In addition, materials such as Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA), Poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA), and monolayer dispersion of proteins can be used to prevent cell sticktion to the surface. Furthermore, it is preferable that the coating be readily applied and removed in order to enable reusability of the liquid/particle processing facilitated by DEP. In case of samples containing DNA, we may alternatively apply coating to promote adhesion of specific types of DNA strands on to surfaces above particle DEP electrodes. Here adhesion of selective DNA fragment is enhanced in the vicinity of high field regions created by positive DEP force. This capability may be useful in the analysis of DNA transported in droplets.
Immaterial modifications may be made to the embodiments described without departing from the invention.
This application claims the benefit under 35 USC 119(e) of provisional application No. 60/669,697 filed Apr. 8, 2005.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60669697 | Apr 2005 | US |